PastorAIO's Posts
Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 (of 287 pages)
Chrisbenogor:Follow Banom. |
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=285732.msg4054383#msg4054383 date=1245398956]Lol, @ttalks, you understand pilgrim.1 so well I'm now scared of you! Thank goodness you didn't report me as you threatened earlier. I'm still a good gal and will remain so to you for some time to come.[/quote]Good morning Miss Pilgrim. I look forward to a day of juicy debate. I don't want to pressure you but I'm keen to hear what you're going to say next on the thread about the Origin of Roman Catholicism. That one is you and Lady. But please take your time, don't feel pressured, whenever you're ready . . . how about right now. I'm waiting!only joking! but I'm keen to see how that develops. |
The Feast day of St. John is probably my favourite day of the whole year. I'm looking forward to it. Apart from Xmas which celebrates the birth of Christ it is the only other day which marks the birth rather than the death of a saint. St. John the Baptist |
segyemaro:When you imbibe spirits you become spirit filled. |
I like the term Pente-rascals. |
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=281645.msg4043417#msg4043417 date=1245248993]You're absolutely correct (or, should I say that I agree with you - leaving room for others who might not share the same view). I'm quite familiar with Pardes, but the problem most Christians have with Biblical exegesis is to take just one out of the four (such as Peshat) and rest all their thoughts thereto, seeing nothing else. Although Peshat has its benefit in Biblical exegesis, it does not stand alone as exclusive from other methods - to hold on to Peshat alone tends to eisegesis (the opposite of exegesis). True - and that is why using only one out of the four hermeneutical devices is unhealthy. All four (Peshat, Remez, Derash and Sod) are intended to work together in hermeneutics and Biblical exgesis. Unfortunately, it happens that many people tend to apply only one of them and will never see beyond that one approach. I understand why you may feel that way - perhaps you might have been approaching the verse from only Peshat and did not consider other approaches as a collective whole. Applying the Pardes as a 'wholeness' would make the point clear that the verse as used by the RCCG pastor may not be problematic. _____________ addendum: In the case of the RCCG pastors use of that verse (Deut. 16:16), one wonders about Paul's use of the OT verses in both 1 Corinthians 9 and 1 Timothy 5. Certainly, anyone who would have problems with the apostle's hermeneutics would only be approaching his epistles from Peshat while ignoring the others - Peshat, Remez, Derash and Sod.[/quote]This is how I understand Derash. Please correct me if I am wrong. It looks at metaphors, similitudes or allegories. In other words the structure of relationships. For example, I have a father. I can say that the relationship between me and my father is equivalent to the relationship between you and your father. In other words there are certain things that are true about my relationship with my father that is also true about your relationship with your father. Let's call it the Father-Child relationship. The ability to extract (or abstract) certain essential features of a relationship and apply it wherever that relationship is found is a key aspect of human intelligence. It's the ability to mark a difference between the Special and the General. A wide variety of Special (or specific) cases can be found to actually be the same in General ( or generically). For example, the relationship between these numbers: 3, 4, and 5. The interact in a certain way and what can be said to be true of their relationship can be applied to other sets of number. In fact it is considered to be the same as those other sets of numbers. For instance, 5, 12, and 13. Or 7, 24 and 25. These three sets of numbers are bound by the same relationship to each other. As a consequence what can be said of one can also be said of the others. In fact what can be said of all of them can be put in abstract form. Namely that they are related to each other in this manner: [size=15pt]a² + b² = c²[/size] The square of one plus the square of another is equal to the square of the third. This is known as pythagoras' theorem. Any set of three numbers that are thus interrelated will have the properties of that relationship. And that relationship is an object in itself that can be studied and it's properties can be discovered. Easier still would be to say 3/4 (three quarters) or the relationship between 3 and 4, is the same as 15/20 or the relationship between 15 and 20. That relationship, which is what we are studying, acts in the same way no matter what the specific numbers in it are. So to come to my point, A metaphor is actually about a relationship. The relationship of the elements within a story. That insight of that relationship is then applied to another circumstance that bears the same internal relationships. When an Oxen is milling the corn and is allow to freely graze on it that dynamic can be applied to any labourer that is hard at work and might need to panu (snack) to keep his strength up. The correlations are obvious here. Where I just do not see the correlation is where one is told not to come to church empty handed (without money) because when Deuteronomy tells the Jews to come to 3 feasts they shouldn't come empty handed (without food). Where are the correlants? Is the church sermon the feast? What are they eating there? If it is the pastor's rhetoric that is being shared by the people then everybody should come with a piece of rhetoric of their own so that everybody can share. That would be more fitting. I personally would take that deuteronomy verse and extrapolated from it the lesson that I should never turn up to a dinner I've been invited to empty handed. Always bring a bottle of wine or something. |
What was the relationship of kung fu to buddhism in the Shaoline monasteries? |
huxley2:I've been trying to get at what you mean to say in spite of the obvious typo, but I can't. Help. huxley2:You need do no more than take my word for it to believe it is true. I might not be an authority on much in life, but I believe that I am the world's foremost authority on the contents of my belief system. That is what I believe and apart from telling you what I believe I don't know any other way to justify to you that it is truly what I believe. |
KunleOshob:What if you were a miller and you left your oxen to thresh the wheat and you left them unmuzzled. Then you came back and found that the oxen had eaten all the wheat. Even as they were threshing it they were gobbling it up. Wouldn't you muzzle them up straight away. I think the idea is for the oxen not to go hungry where they are labouring. Not to gorge themselves with private jets and fleets of cars. And definately the Oxen cannot be allowed to get more out of the deal than the Miller himself. |
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=281645.msg4036639#msg4036639 date=1245159080]Even so, let me leave you a sample of one I have in my notebook on my desk (emphasis mine): [list] But in any case, between the original command set down in Deuteronomy, which presumably was given originally out of concern for the proper care of oxen, and the application of the OT text and in 1 Corinthians 9, the text had passed through the grid of Jewish exegesis27 to yield finally the analogy that Paul employs here. The argument works a fortiori, by applying the reasoning of the Torah concerning provision for working oxen to the situation of those laboring in the gospel ministry. In both Pauline texts, Paul followed or adapted the Jewish interpretation of the text and applied it to material support for those engaged in ministry. [list]27 This commandment had been a well of deeper meaning for rabbinical scholars (see StrB 3.382-99). It was used as a particular illustration of the “lesser to greater” logic that urged that God’s concern for animals implied far greater concern for the people (b. B. Mes. 88b; b. Git. 62a; 1 Cor 9:9; e.g., Philo, On the Virtues 145; see additional refs. in Knoch, 40). Pharisaic interpretation apparently deduced from this text a broader principle: oxen stand for all species of labor including that of humans (D. I. Brewer, “1 Corinthians 9:9-11: A Literal Interpretation of ‘Do Not Muzzle the Ox,’” NTS 38 [1992]: 554-65), and Paul may have drawn on this halakic rule instead of engaging in creative midrash himself.[/list] source: The letters to Timothy and Titus By Philip H. Towner, p. 365[/list][/quote]What is obvious is that there is next to nothing to be found in the letters of Paul that is not derived from the Pharisaic traditions. Sure, by his own admission he was raised and educated as a pharisee however in his later stage I do not see anywhere where he has departed from pharisee ideology. The pharisees had 4 ways of interpreting biblical text. These were called the Pardes. The Pardes typology describes four different approaches to Biblical exegesis in rabbinic Judaism (or - simpler - interpretation of text in Torah study). The term, sometimes also spelled PaRDeS, is an acronym formed from the name initials of these four approaches, which are:Peshat is what most christians do when they read their bible. Yet there is so much of christianity that is derived via Remez and derash. These were actually a system of inference with rules and they were developed via a dialectic between groups of pharisees. An interpretation does not get accepted simply after one individual gets a notion and decides it's an insight into truth. I'm thinking of the RCCG pastor that says do not come to church empty handed and derives that teaching from the bible. I'm yet to be convinced that his line of inference is a valid one. |
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=281645.msg4038901#msg4038901 date=1245178524]Indeed, a humorous case to consider. But there's an answer: let the nigerian civil service explain their labour within the grid of Jewish exegesis, and viola! the 'oxen' will find a way! [/quote][quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=281645.msg4036639#msg4036639 date=1245159080]Pharisaic interpretation apparently deduced from this text a broader principle: oxen stand for all species of labor including that of humans (D. I. Brewer, “1 Corinthians 9:9-11: A Literal Interpretation of ‘Do Not Muzzle the Ox,’” NTS 38 [1992]: 554-65), and Paul may have drawn on this halakic rule instead of engaging in creative midrash himself.[/list][/quote]Not difficult at all. The grid of jewish exegesis clearly states that Oxen stand for ALL species of labor. If our officials are labouring somewhere then according to biblical understanding they have every right to chop from the same place where they labour. |
Thank you o, PIlgrim and KUnleoshb. Phew! I'll come back with more comments when I'm more settled but one quick thought, that is a bit of an aside but humorous to consider, is this: Can the passage about Oxen be applied to officials of the nigerian civil service? [quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=281645.msg4036639#msg4036639 date=1245159080]Nonethless, it is obvious that many Jews applied both to oxen and human affairs/transactions. Even so, let me leave you a sample of one I have in my notebook on my desk (emphasis mine): [list] But in any case, between the original command set down in Deuteronomy, which presumably was given originally out of concern for the proper care of oxen, and the application of the OT text and in 1 Corinthians 9, the text had passed through the grid of Jewish exegesis27 to yield finally the analogy that Paul employs here. The argument works a fortiori, by applying the reasoning of the Torah concerning provision for working oxen to the situation of those laboring in the gospel ministry. In both Pauline texts, Paul followed or adapted the Jewish interpretation of the text and applied it to material support for those engaged in ministry.[/quote]Since nigerian officials are threshing in their workplace is it not right that they too be left unmuzzled. People complain about corruption but shouldn't they be allowed to graze where they toil? |
[quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=280962.msg4036032#msg4036032 date=1245151680]Even thousands of years ago, people did not. In modern times there are the ignorant and those who are not. It was so in antiquity as well. People tend to think civiliztions get 'smarter' as they progress or something, that 'progress' is as linear as time, when it is no such thing. Every epoch had its scientific breakthroughs and its geniuses, and none is 'greater' or 'better' than the other. Egyptians built pyramids that took centuries for modern scientists to unravel; I think they just did so recently. Thinkers like Aristotle and Plato are still unmatched in modern times for clarity and genius, and all modern science is built on the foundations earlier epochs laid down. You know the difference between scientific puzzles and the supernatural. Most people, down history, have had little trouble telling the difference.[/quote]Absolutely correct about people thinking that progress is linear. That is a false paradigm at the basis of most modern thought that is shared by both some scientists and some religionists. I didn't think that way the pyramids were built has been unravelled yet. I thought that was still a mystery. Can you give us any links to look it up? People have jumped down my throat on this forum for going on about the eternal vs the temporal so I won't go there but I'll only say that it has a lot to do with the supernatural. Nature being closely related to Time. |
Nobody is yet helping me with this my line of enquiry. Is the bible to be taken literally or not. If not, then how is it to be interpreted. For example, was it known by all Jews that the commandment not to 'muzzle the ox while it treadeth' was not referring to oxen at all. Is the meaning of any text singular or can numerous various meanings be extrapolated from a text? |
jagunlabi:99%. Is that the exact statistic? |
tpiah:It's a possible interpretation. It would be kind of you to make yourself clear. |
tpiah:are you suggesting that it is okay to worship a construct as long as it is not a physical one made with the hands? |
I prefer miles Davis. Kind of Blue |
What is Justice? Is it something than can be achieved. What conditions are necessary for something to be just. When can we say that Justice has been served? Connected to this - What is Merit? |
tpiah:. . . and a pagan is literally someone who lives in the countryside. What we would call, in nigeria a Bush man. Ara oko in yoruba. That is was then used to refer to non christians is an extension of it's meaning. By reading the OP you will be able to gather that the meaning of idol is being extended to mean any human construct. Basically an Idol worshipper is someone who worships something that he has constructed. This would include conceptual constructs. |
I meant to say that there are Other intelligent species on earth. They don't necessarily have to be extra terrestrial. |
I'm more inclined to believe that there are other intelligent species on earth than in extraterrestrial aliens. |
But are ufo necessarily space craft with aliens abducting people. I thought they are just phenomena in the sky that are unexplained. |
tboyjnr:Na the name of hin Dog be that! |
ogajim:Obviously circumstances has a lot to do with profession of faith. I wonder what in this world is not a function of circumstance. For example a rich man who is happily married will profess great love for his wife. If one day he loses his money and suddenly finds he is constantly arguing with his wife would we say that when he professed love that he wasn't actually in love because true love survives all circumstances. |
ifele:I like this. Could you tell us more. I know the Jewish had lots of feast that they celebrated. Why the Passover and not any of the others? What does the statement 'do this as often as you drink it' mean. That we should bless every meal that we eat? |
In making a distinction between inward and outward are you not falling into the trap of circumscribing God too? You are basically saying that God cannot be found outwards of the self. But what is outward that is not the self? |
[quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=280962.msg4029889#msg4029889 date=1245061299]Mechanical baby pacifier? Lol. I meant to say metaphysical baby pacifier. We're using a 100% of our brain? Really? It isn't just Barry Gordon's opinion? Thank you for that. What do you think about UFOs though? Maybe I'm taking this in another direction, but what are they? And why, lol, are they a uniquely European and American phenomenon? You'd think they'd show up everywhere, instead of places where belief in them is prevalent.[/quote]maybe they do but they are called something different or they are understood differently. |
And after you've done that I would like you to please prove my pharmacology. |
wirinet:This is a great insight. Although I think that there is a similar process going on with whether or not we accept scientific ideas. Many scientific ideas have been resisted by scientists simply because they contradicted what the scientist believes. A famous case is Einstein's rejection of the finding of Quantum Mechanics. Even here there is a trauma to be experience when what one once believed to be scientifically true is proved unsound. What we believe about the world and the way it works, our world view, cosmology, etc seems to be intimately bound with our sense of well being. In other words we all need structure. And it is this exactly that makes existentialism and nihilism such an unsatisfactory position to be in. There is an inbuilt inertia in every belief system or cosmology. People will ignore facts that contradict their cosmology until those facts become big enough to shatter the cosmology and the believer's sense of well being along with it. For the world to make sense it requires a lot of approximating and ignoring of details. I remember when I discovered this about myself. I was talking to someone and I couldn't quite understand what they were saying. In my head I was trying to MAKE sense of what they were saying. Then suddenly I had a realisation. I was literally MAKING sense of the guys words. It was a creative process. And often the sense we MAKE out of someone's words are quite different from the sense the person intended. As regards Wirinet's words about how we are converted, especially in AFrica, I totally agree. I know especially how it took place amongst the yoruba. It was mainly in Egbaland. Abeokuta was full of returned slaves from sierra leone and also they had the CMS schools. The british were already in Lagos and the Egba people were enjoying being the middle men between the british and the indigenes for trade. Converted christians were given more regard by the British so it made sense if you wanted to better your status to become christian. Chinua Achebe also discusses how this happened in Igboland and the way they were taught to despise their traditional religions. I disagree with this statement though: When a child is born, he has no beliefs or belief system, he is basically an atheist.Atheism is a worldview and babies cannot be born Atheist. To be an atheist you must first have a concept of God before you can disbelieve in his existence. I also do not believe that one needs to have a concept of God in order to be close to God. If anything it puts a wedge between a man and God. |
But what would you say is so essentially wrong with Idol worship. |
Today all the various factions of christianity claim that the others don't understand the bible and are missing key points. Yet most derive their doctrines from the bible. So is there a proper way to read and understand the bible or are we free to just extrapolation ideas as we wish from the text? Is a literal reading of the bible of any value in understanding christianity? |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 (of 287 pages)
But on a more serious note if we are to apply morals[which is central to christianity] and other christian teachings it would conflict with the central theme of the christian message. This again shows how easily the bible can be twisted to justify personal biases and opinions.
or the direct meaning[1].