PastorAIO's Posts
Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 254 (of 287 pages)
huxley2:It is true that I am fair, . . . tall and handsome too, however I will leave you both to iron this out for yourselves as it leads away from my main bone of contention and I'd rather gnaw at that bone. I need a definition of natural stuff. Otherwise how would you recognise the non natural when you saw it. |
What qualities would 'non-stuff' have to distinguish it from stuff? You're gonna have to do a lot better man. you're just throwing words about without presenting a rigorous system. I'll help you out a bit again. Would you say that stuff (natural stuff) would have to occupy space and time? Ie would it have to be extended in Space and exist for a span of time? Yes or no? I just wanna help you define Nature. |
huxley2:What you're trying to do is define Nature as everything that exists. You might as well just come out and say it: Nature is everything that exists so by definition there is not Supernatural. When you say Nature is composed of Experience. Well absolutely everything we are aware of is an experience. How do we experience supernatural? You need a more rigorous definition of your terms. Something that was actually descriptive would help. Secondly, are you talking about stuff or are you talking about the Processes that Stuff undergoes. Saying that Nature is composed of matter blah and blah suggest that Nature is a body not the processes that a body undergoes. |
OK, let me give you an idea. Can you say natural or supernatural to each of the following according to what is commonly and standardly accepted ?You see Huxley, it seems that you are quite confused. Pretty much everything that you've mentioned above it stuff. When you talk about naturalism or supernaturalism are you talking about stuff or are you talking about PROCESSES. Stuff is stuff. It can undergo natural processes or it can undergo supernatural processes. WAter is water. If it runs down hill you might say that is natural. If it runs uphill you might say that is un natural or supernatural. For example, Crop circles exist. That's a fact. The How they came to exist is what might rely on naturalistic or supernatural explanation. That is why it is important to know what you are talking about when you talk about naturalism. Are you referring to substances or processes? The terms are usually used to refer to processes and Causality. So you have natural causes and you have supernatural causes. Is this what you mean when you talk about natural? Is so then you will still have to define what makes a process natural as opposed to supernatural? Perhaps by saying for example that Natural causes occur prior to an event in time. That way we know that an event that occurs tomorrow cannot influence what happens today, if it did that would be supernatural. That's just an hint. |
But wait a moment. . . why is it that it's only very few atheists that are in this thread, hmmmm? Apart from Tùdor, huxley2, William_C. . where are the 'typical atheists' on NL?It is quite possible that they are put off by the excessive lengths of some of the posts. |
An issue that has never been settled by various factions is what exactly the significance of the communion is. Is it just done as a remembrance of Christ? Is it done to wash away sins? Drink, this is my blood, poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins. Is it done to nourish the spirit? When Jesus says 'do this as often as you eat it . . ' Does he mean that every meal we eat is a eucharist and should be blessed and eaten as such? |
In most systems of inference a certain level of Rigor is applicable. How necessary is such rigor to determining Truth? When rigor is relaxed to the point that one can apparently jump from any one notion to another in a seemingly arbitrary manner, then on what do we base our trust in the line of inference. This OP is inspired by parts of the letters of Paul pointed out to me by Pilgrim. 'Twisting scripture' is a familiar refrain; but I don't think that would be the case here. There's nothing wrong in someone taking a verse to make a general principle - it all depends what they mean, but not necessarily twisting scripture. A few examples might be helpful:I know that the Jews (the Rabbis/pharisees) had techniques of exegesis that they adhered to. The rigor might be less than that used in mathematics but it still had rigor. there were still rules they adhered to. When Paul 'twists' scripture, is there a rigorous limit he doesn't exceed or is he just joining issues anyhow that pleases him? I wonder. |
[b]Is Mary the 'Coredemptrix' of humanity?This movement to equate her to Jesus as redeemer is gathering strength in the Catholic folds. Any opinions? http://pewforum.org/news/display.php?NewsID=18162 |
jagunlabi:Maybe the Ego can. |
Mowire:It is laughable to hear such a distinction being made. Especially from the very same fellow that has just denounced Ifa based on the the involvement of babalawos in Oro ceremonies. If an 'evil' babalawo means that Ifa is 'evil' then shouldn't evil christians mean that christianity is evil too. You have to judge everybody on their own terms. Jesus said: By their fruits ye shall know them. Mowire:Likewise you need to quote the Ifa verses that promote human sacrifice. Or any teachings of Orunmila that allow human sacrifice. Those who " brought us this Christianity that we embrace so eagerly" as you called them were more of businessmen than missionaries. There were really only very few christian missionaries (my opinion?).This is just another one of those holier than thou stances that many christians take against each other. Keep judging yourself as to who is a true christian o! Afterall Jesus said Judge that you may be judged, abi? |
chukwudi44:I think this matter deserves a thread of it's own. |
huxley2:Answer: When we know what exactly is Natural as opposed to supernatural. |
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=279631.msg3993624#msg3993624 date=1244454549]3. we may allow any atheist to choose what best describes his/her worldview 7. naturalism alone does not satisfactorily explain the realities of our knon world 8. naturalism is also a belief-system that holds dogmatic assertions[/quote]How true is that? I haven't come across any definition of naturalism that captures every phenomenon known in the real world. I've seen naturalists define and redefine their positions in an attempt to include everything but they fail so consistently it is almost a law of nature that no definition of naturalism includes all known phenomena. It's this desperate attempt to find a definition that captures all known phenomena that leads me to the conclusion that naturalism is a reaction based on a bias against the idea of the supernatural rather than an objective position. |
Mr Olabowale sir. You still dey. E don reach 3 days. Plus one day. How have you been? |
huxley2:What are the traits that matter, time, energy and experience/consciousness share that makes them Natural. Is it that you can see, touch, smell, hear and taste them. Can you perceive consciousness with senses or advance instruments? Imagine that human senses evolved in a different way. Say, in the same way a bat's evolved. Would colour exist as a part of our natural world? If our senses were like bat's then we wouldn't see anything but we would be living in a totally different world composed of high frequency sounds that paint a picture of how the world is shaped. We would be able to maneuver around these high frequency sounds and hunt and sustain ourselves. But it would be a totally different world. If this were the case would colour be a natural phenomenon according the definition that what is natural is only what can be perceived by the senses. |
This is intimately tied to the subject of Causality. What is a causal relationship? Is there a difference between natural causes and supernatural causes? |
This is a very excellent line of enquiry. What is the Supernatural? intimately bound to this is obviously the question what is the natural. Without a clear definition of what natural is how can we say what is super-natural, super meaning 'over' or above. To know what is above the natural it is necessary to first know what the natural is. Note, even if we do not know every natural phenomenon that exists we can still say what features it will have to have in order to be considered a natural event. To answer you questions for the moment I would say 1) As we know natural events (whatever those are) via our faculties of perception tuned to the natural, if there is a supernatural world then we must have faculties capable of perceiving it. 2) That depends entirely on what you consider to be natural and what you would consider to be supernatural. 3) Again would depend on what definitions you were using for these terms. 4) When you have a proper definition of the natural and you witness an event that is not yet understood yet exhibits the features associated with natural phenomena then you can say that it is a natural event. If it has features associated with supernatural events then it is supernatural. One definition of Naturalism says that every event has a cause that is based on the material world. All causal agents are material. But that has difficulties. What is Matter? etc. Perhaps if you gave us a definition of Nature and Natural cause then implicit in that definition will be the definition of Supernaturalism. |
Even no bible school training required. I wish I was in 9ja, I for apply for the job. I go carry hidden camera and microphone. There's got to be a great documentary in this somewhere. What's wrong with all those 9ja journalists. They're useless. |
Yep God is one-sided. It is evidence throughout creation. Everything displays asymmetry. Why are humans either left handed or righthanded. Why can't we use both hands equally? Why is there more matter than anti-matter? Actually without this particular asymmetry the universe wouldn't exist. There is asymmetry in quantum physics too. The face is asymetric too. one side is not the mirror image of the other. Yes the creator is definately one-sided. |
What if someone has an allergy to nuts and dies right there in the church after the communion? |
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=113108.msg3970554#msg3970554 date=1244034807]@Pastor AIO, Thank you for your concerns. As I've repeatedly stated, my arguments are not borne out of narrow experiences where one uses only one case to plaster a conclusion across board. In which case, my opinions would not be inclined to make the RCCG the standard case for ALL tithe preachers around the world. Please bear in mind that I've also repeatedly demonstrated that people err on both sides of the debate; and as such, would it be quite "in order" to blast ALL anti-tithers with the same slurs as they hastily do to their tithing brethren? Have anti-tithers not said worse things than tithers several times, most of which I've identified already in several threads? This was why I said earlier: 'our experiences on this subject are varied - which is the more reason why anti-tithers cannot condemn everyone who is inclined to tithing' I wonder if by quoting that line earlier you were of the opinion that EVERYONE who is inclined to tithing must by default be condemned by anti-tithers? I hope not; but if otherwise, why so?[/quote]I think that it is wrong to take a particular instance of anything and then apply it broadly to anyone and anything vaguely associated. I don't think that anyone, much less everyone, who tithes is being attacked. But rather the PREACHING OF TITHING is what has been attacked as far as I can tell. It is of course naturally for humans to associate themselves so strongly with a doctrine whereby any attack on that doctrine becomes a personal attack on themselves. The subject of the thread suggests that pastors are not telling their congregation the truth about tithes and in fact are lying to them. That is a far cry from accusing the people who actually tithe, many of whom do so under the false notions fed to them by mendacious pastors. That has parallels to punishing a rape victim for falling victim to the crime. [quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=113108.msg3970559#msg3970559 date=1244034874]I think they meant verse 16, not verse 15. Yet, if we going on to verse 17, we find again that the same principle in the OT is what is preached in the NT: Deut. 16:17 - 'Every man shall give as he is able, according to the blessing of the LORD thy God which he hath given thee' 2 Cor. 8:12 - 'For if there be first a willing mind, it is accepted according to that a man hath, and not according to that he hath not.' Now, my opinion: offering, tithe and 'sowing'. I don't think the few lines quoted above could be used to draw any final conclusions to condemn the RCCG. For one, those few lines are not expatiated enough on those terms to draw a condemnation of 'extortion'; and we know that the apostles in the NT drew from the OT to exhort NT giving. The second highlighted part of the quote is a cogent statement, I believe, that is unnecessary to argue against. If one does not 'sow' (in context of giving), how does he/she reap? The NT argues that a man only reaps what he has sown; and the measure in which someone sows is the measure in which they shall reap, NO? The end of that quote exhorts to "be a good giver", and that could also be a healthy reminder that tessellates with 2 Cor. 9:7.[/quote]When I take a closer look at the passage in question what I see is God giving the people an injunction to come and eat 3 meals three times a year in his presence. These meals are namely, the Feast of Unleaven bread, The feast of Weeks, and The feast of Booths. When they come to these feast they must not come empty handed no matter how small the food they bring is. When some then takes a verse from this passage and tells their congregation that God is saying never come to church empty handed I am inclined to believe they are twisting the scripture. What do you think? |
huxley2:Huxley, the sheer fact that you are quoting this scripture to advise christians is enough to have the entire passage cast out of the bible completely. How Dare You?!! |
Krayola:Not only is it pointless but it has been done to death on Nairaland. We have a whole army of Nebuchadnezzars already doing that. A valid point that He has raised though is the fact that Ifa might be being fiddled to fit in with a certain agenda. But hey, wait a minute, is this not true of absolutely anything. The minute anyone opens their mouth to say anything it is most likely they have an agenda or at least an effect that they are trying to achieve. That might or might not be obvious from what they are saying. For this reason it is very important to be very critical and astute when listening to what anyone has to say. Check out this new thread by Huxley: https://www.nairaland.com/nigeria/topic-279466.0.html I have no doubt that their are strong reasons why our parents turned away from traditional religions to embrace christianity and islam, but I don't think those reasons have much to do with Truth. Colonialism, inferiority complex, opportunism as they were faced with the 'brave new world' presented by arabs and europeans, and many other reasons, would be closer to why they converted. I'm not into promoting any religious form over another but I have an interest in all religious forms. I'm especially interested in the religious views of African societies. You are right that every religion has it's nonsense and Ifa/orisha religions are not exceptions. They are a tool to dominate people, prop up social systems, Kings, chiefs etc. Yet there are awos that are not involved in social politics and chieftaincy titles and all that. They just practice their awo in their personal lives, and leave others to vie for the Oluwo, Ojugbona, Aseda, Akoda and other titles. To address the OP, I don't believe that religion should be a matter of identity. Rather, as Jagunlabi put it in his thread on Ego, I believe that religion should result in the dissolution of all false identities. And on the topic of human sacrifice Jehovah accepts human sacrifice well well. Ask Huxley to acquaint you on the topic. |
It is very interesting and I relate to a lot of what he says. Apart, maybe, from when he brings evolutionary theory in to explain the ego. I understand him to be saying that the ego evolved because there must have been an advantage in it, but now we are evolving back into an egoless state. I could have got him wrong, but that is what I understood. When I think about that some more though, it seems like a valid argument. I agree that immersing your mind in emptiness is the way to dissolve the ego. Have you heard of the Secret Of The Golden Flower? The entire Cosmos, all the myriad worlds, all of nature, all our lives, all emerge from and recede back into an unspeakably vast sea of conscious energy. This is Wuji– “the void.” From this void all things derive and back to it they all return. It represents an emptiness that is, nonetheless, mysteriously steeped full of hidden potential. Our minds can be likened to this primordial void, or are actually revealed to be part of it, when we learn to calm down and let our thoughts settle out until there is nothing but a kind of serene spaciousness. This is a state of mind pregnant with potential, just like the “emptiness” of Wuji. So long as our minds are cluttered with nervous, hyperactive thinking there is little opportunity for the birth of spontaneous insight. The world swirls around us. People come and go. Thoughts come and go. Hopes and fears come and go. We need to learn how to remain centered in this calmly open state of mind no matter what distracting concerns may confront us. When we center ourselves, by moderating mental activity, we make room for insights to instinctively arise out of this open, empty state of mind.http://www.wokendreams.com/GoldenFlower/GoldenFlower2.html |
This is funny. I recall going to a church that used ribena as the substitute for wine. That was a long long time ago. Imagine a world with less international trade so we couldn't import wine (grapes) and wheat. After all grapes and wheat can't grow everywhere in the world. What would/should christians in those places do? How would they practice holy communion? |
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=113108.msg3968749#msg3968749 date=1244013080] True, our experiences on this subject are varied - which is the more reason why anti-tithers cannot condemn everyone who is inclined to tithing. I could as well state the same observation about anti-tithing churches the last couple of months which constantly make the false assertion that those who are tithing are going to hell or cutting themselves off from the grace of Christ - all for what? For simply giving a certain percentage of their income as tithes?[/quote]It has been your constant claim that your experience of the preaching of tithes is different from what most of the 'anti-tithers' are talking about. While I find it difficult to imagine that you haven't really encountered the preaching of tithes as a means of extortion (endemic enough to warrant a crusade against) I guess it is not impossible. Perhaps if I acquainted you with a few of these teachings you could give me your opinion as to whether that chuch is preaching the gospel or merely practicing extortion. Please check this out: Offering: Any time you are coming to the house of God you must have it at the back of your mind not to come empty handed Duet 16:15. The offering you give is the seed sown which will bring harvest at the unexpected time. Some people when they are given an offering envelop they just put it on the chair such one can never harvest anything from God, so be a good giver.This is taken from here: http://www.rccgvictoryarea.org/keys.htm The RcCG is the biggest church in nigeria and I believe they say it is the fastest growing church in the world. I don't think it is far fetched to claim that their practices are representative of how christianity is practiced in nigeria. My question to you, Pilgrim1, is: Would you say that these teachings of RCCG are rooted in Christian doctrine or are they merely manipulating doctrine to extort funds from the gullible? I'd like your opinion on this statement too: Pastor Adeboye, sharing the revelation during the meeting, which he hosted, stated that it was revealed to him that the global economic meltdown would subsist for seven years. |
Very interesting! So not only do our concepts of God separate us from God , but also our concepts of Self separate us from our real self. All conceptualising and perception, all cognitive processes, it seems, are just interpretations of reality and are thus not the truth in and of themselves. I like what Eckhart Tolle says about the ego being destined to dissolved. I only watched the first clip so I don't know if he went deeper into this statement in the other clips, but I'm curious to know how he teaches the dissolution of the ego. (not curious enough to watch more, apparently lol!). |
Krayola:Abeg don't bother yourself with the guy. How do you want to discuss with someone who lacks the most basic comprehension skills? I don't know how he understood what I had to say about Awolowo and the forging of a yoruba identity to refer to his nonsense about elders and orisha in history. Perhaps his conceit is so extreme that he believes everything is referring to him and his posts. Moving swiftly on . . . You wanted to know the meaning of Ogbe. Ifa makes a lot of word play with different phonetic sounds and so a word can be made to mean many different things. Ogbe can therefore mean salvation, and it can mean to support, or to carry. So the statement Eji ni m'ogbe, mi o gbe enikan can be translated as I save in couples and not individuals. It can also mean I support couples not individuals. The Second Olodu is called Oyeku Meji. This is where Oyeku is on the right side and oyeku is on the left side too. While Ogbe rules over the daytime OYeku rules over the night. Oyeku is associated with water, rain, death and movement/change. A lot of references are made to Olokun (diety of the sea). The syllable ye- in yoruba suggests to shift, to budge, to change. Iku is death which is itself a major transition. Like I said above about word play Oyeku verses can mention things like the Sun's rays (oye in yoruba). For instance: Iwo o ye, Emi o ye you don't budge, I don't budge Oye sese nlaa bo l'oke, won se b'ojumo ni nmo Aurora has only just begun to rip through the heaven, but they thought day had fully broken. (reference to the brightness of early dawn, as bright as sunrise) A difa fun Eji Oye Thus was divined for Eji Oye Ti o t'oju orun la w'aye bi obereke. who from the face of heaven tears through to earth like cotton buds. Nje owo lo ba nwu mi o, mo wi Is it money I desire, I'll mention it Eji Oye: Ifa ni o ye ire t'emi fun mi Eji Oye, Ifa says shift my fortune to me Aya lo ba nwu mi o, Mo wi Is it a wife I desire, I mention it Eji Oye: Ifa ni o ye ire t'emi fun mi Eji Oye, Ifa says shift my fortune to me Gbogbo ire to ba nwu mi o, Mo wi Every fortune I desire, I'll mention it Eji Oye: Ifa ni o ye ire t'emi fun mi Eji Oye, Ifa says shift my fortune to me Another word play that Ifa makes great use of is with the word La. Ola is wealth. Ela is salvation. La a is to split or to open up. So when your road is blocked then ifa can promise to La ona. Open the road. When for instance a verse says Owu la, the cotton bud splits open, it also means that the cotton was saved, and it also means that the cotton became wealthy and all the meanings apply in a verse. |
Lol! Nairaland has got to be the sweetest website in all the 3 w's. Please correct me if I am wrong but I believe that the real meaning of seed (igbin in my mother's language) is something small that you put in the ground and a few weeks later a plant will sprout. The term can be extended to animals too where the germ/seed is called spermatozoa and ovum. Apart from this which is the REAL meaning of seed the word can also be used metaphorically. It can be used as metaphor for something small that is sacrificed (or operated on in some way) to yield something greater like a tiny seed yield a great big tree. I understand the sowing of the word as such a metaphor whereby someone hears a little something/idea and then as a consequence in his mind it blooms into a great concept. Here again something that can multiply or grow or get bigger is referred to as a seed. So is money a seed. Yes, but not in the sense that any biblical passage I know mentions seed. Money is a seed because if you invest it wisely in the stock market then it will sprout and bloom and grow. But as with all seeds the birds will eat some, some will fall on rocky soil, some will be strangled by weeds etc. But it is also said that each seed brings forth fruit according to it's kind. From this I would surmise that if I want to reap money then I have to sow money, yet if I want to reap righteousness then the seed to sow is righteousness (as a man soweth . . . innit? ) , if I want to reap trouble then I need to sow trouble. However I'm yet to understand this sowing money in order to reap righteousness. May he that multiplies all seeds of every variety plant, animal or metaphorical please multiply the fruit of the righteousness seeds that we have sown o! Amen. |
Does the fact that the ego is created by the mind make it any less you? |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 254 (of 287 pages)
