₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,277 members, 8,522,133 topics. Date: Friday, 20 November 2026 at 04:07 PM

Toggle theme

PastorAIO's Posts

Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 (of 287 pages)

Christianity Etc › Re: I Am Done With Intituitionalized Christianity, Would Stop Attending "church" by PastorAIO: 11:26am On Jun 12, 2009
1anonymous:
Hi everyone, 

Pls check out www.lds.org and learn about the restored gospel of Jesus Christ.
Aren't these people supposed to be racist.

Confused. Racist but they believe that the american indians are the lost tribe of Israel and when jesus left his disciples at the end of the gospels he flew to america to preach to the Aztecs and mayans before then flying up to heaven.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Holy Spirit, My Senior Partner - Understanding The Holy Spirit & His Gifts by PastorAIO: 11:22am On Jun 12, 2009
What happened to the Vicar of Christ on Earth.
Christianity Etc › Re: Do you know the Greatest Problem In the life of Man/Woman: Pls, comment by PastorAIO: 11:21am On Jun 12, 2009
The biggest issue in life is knowing what is the right thing to do and then doing it.

[size=17pt]Do the right thing[/size]
Christianity Etc › Re: Why I Am Not An Atheist by PastorAIO: 10:20am On Jun 12, 2009
Would we say Lucretius was a Naturalist?
Christianity Etc › Re: Why I Am Not An Atheist by PastorAIO: 9:50am On Jun 12, 2009
huxley2:
How do you know that what you have observe does not obey a law(s) currently unknown to us?

Are we aware of ALL the possible FIELDS that envelops the universe of space-time?  Could these particle be influencing each other along such unknown fields?
Huxley, I have no doubt that there are loads of laws of the universe currently unknown to us.  That is not the issue.  The question is if these Laws can be considered Natural Laws or not.  

According to our definition of Nature if the phenomenon does not seem to rely on traversing space and time then it is NOT operating according to a Natural law.

If however you reject our definition of Nature and leave Nature open ended so that we can keep shifting the goalposts in order to fit in any phenomena that we might encounter then we need to be ready for one possibility.

That we will discover a spiritual reality and even God and find that it is ALL very NATURAL.  Spirits will be Natural to and there'll still be no such thing as the supernatural.


As regards your other issue.  I thought that physics recognised 4 forces of the universe.  Namely, gravity, electromagnetism, weak, and strong nuclear forces.  

These have their fields via which they pass influence onto other bodies.  

Higg's field is an attempt to study the qualities of the Vacuum (empty space).  I could be wrong but I don't think that there is any difference between communicating via the Higg's field and communicating across empty space.  
If two bodies separated in space communicate instantaneously then the communication couldn't have occurred across space.  Perhaps if we entertained the idea of a hyperspace, that is an extradimensional reality.  But that is exactly what you want to avoid Huxley because that opens up a whole can of worms that play into the hands of the supernaturalists.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Ego by PastorAIO: 9:02am On Jun 12, 2009
OLAADEGBU:
What you guys are practising is what is called satanic meditation, which is passive. Satans aim is to blank out your minds by making you to clear your minds of all thoughts. This directly opens a door for demonic influence and entrance all in the name of "self realisation" and the attainment of a "higher consciousness." Self realisation is the process where a person learns to control his spirit, while higher consciousness is achieved when a person begins to communicate with various demonic spirits which they call "guide" or "counsellor." This is what you get when you dabble into idolatory.

The Infinite Creator God forbids the worship of other gods and graven images. It is a grievous sin to engage in any form of mental or internal idolatory. We are not to give anyone or anything in heaven or in earth that inward affection, worship, veneration or dependence that is due only to the true God. God also frowns at any form of external idolatory such as when pictures or images of people are being observed as possessing divine powers and are adored either at churches or places of pagan worship because they become idols.

As I said earlier, it is only the true worshippers that will worship God in the Spirit and in Truth. God has not permitted us to use or control our spirit man. God does this at His own will as we receive Jesus as our personal Saviour and Lord at the new birth. The devil and his agents deceive you into thinking that you can use your spirits to do what you want to do when in reality it is the demonic spirits that are using you to perpetrate their diabolical atrocities. There is the spirit world that comprise of God and His angels that are in God's service and there are Satan and his demons and agents that are in Satan's service.

Satan's goal is to teach humans to regain the conscious control of their spiritual bodies which he terms as the "higher Self", "god force" or "the third or fourth dimension." The human spirit is also referred to by these New Agers as "spiritual energy" or "vibrations." So all this visualisation and imagination are the stepping stones to eternal damnation. God wants us to depend on Him and to avoid the overwhelming temptations to sin and the constant awareness of Satan and his kingdom. Do you now see how the devil has deceived a lot of people into idol worshipping?
Did you get all this information in a trance or a seance or something spooky like that. Because I know for sure you did not get it from the bible.

Or maybe it's your imagination. You should write fiction. You'll do well.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Ego by PastorAIO: 6:34pm On Jun 11, 2009
Guys, I would like to suggest that you are prepared for the fact that often these things come in waves. You might get a period of heightened spiritual awareness but it will ebb for a while before it comes again. I just felt to share that so that you don't feel disappointed or feel that you're doing something wrong if it ebbs.

Also the ego is a very subtle beast. It can even masquerade as the true self that has kllled the ego. That one is quite a neat trick.
Christianity Etc › Re: I Am Done With Intituitionalized Christianity, Would Stop Attending "church" by PastorAIO: 2:51pm On Jun 11, 2009
anyway, there are enough threads on tithes. Let's not let this thread degenerate into a tithe thread.
Christianity Etc › Re: I Am Done With Intituitionalized Christianity, Would Stop Attending "church" by PastorAIO: 2:33pm On Jun 11, 2009
beewhyfocs:
From your writings, its obvious you are not seeking for advice but looking for people to rubber stamp your decision or better still, join you in it. I pray that God would open your eyes of understanding in Jesus name, so you dont be the-know it-all person to whom others opinnion does not count as long it differs from yours.

Why did you say all those churces could make one not attend church?
I love the way the tone changes from one of caring advice to chiding disapproval simply because kunle doesn't agree with one.
Christianity Etc › Re: Why I Am Not An Atheist by PastorAIO: 2:27pm On Jun 11, 2009
huxley2:
Pastor, is a lump of rock space or is it time? Where does it fit in your conceptualisation of nature? In fact, where do you fit OBJECTS in your conceptualisation of nature?
Huxley, for someone that can be quite astute and intelligent at times, there are also times when you can be quite obtuse.

I thought that we had already discussed about whether Nature referred to Stuff or to Processes.

anyway sha, no, a lump of rock is not space or time. It exists in space and time. It has position and is extended in space and also exists over a span of time.

How do I fit objects into my conceptualisation of nature? For a start objects that are masses give off gravitational force. This gravitational force field is a projection into space. So Objects will have natural effects on other objects.

I hope all this is not like your forgetting the meaning of existentialism.
Christianity Etc › Re: Why I Am Not An Atheist by PastorAIO: 1:31pm On Jun 11, 2009
Hi Wirinet. Thanks for the compliments.

I guess some of the confusion can come from the fact that this conversation has taken place over two threads. The other one is 'What is Supernatural?'. There I made it clear that I just believe that what is is. There are various Laws of being. However if we want to categorise those laws into different types, ie Natural and Supernatural, then we need proper rigorous definitions for those terms.

Failure to define Nature makes our use of the word nonsensical at best. We should just say that there are laws of being and we keep discovering more about them every day. If we say that there are two types of laws, natural and supernatural and that infact the only ones that exist are the natural ones, however we have no idea what we mean by Natural laws as opposed to supernatural laws, then I'm out of the conversation because I don't want anyone to mistake me for an idiot.

In a bid to offer a definition of Nature (Not THE definition in absolute terms but A definition, an Arbitrary definition) I suggested that we should call natural things such things that depended on Spacetime and on information travelling across space time. Therefore if we saw phenomena that did not require anything travelling across SpaceTime as specified in our definition of Nature then that phenomena must be Supernatural.
Also it is not required that we know all the laws of the universe before we make the distinction between Nature and Supernature. All we need is the definition of Nature then we can check the law to see if it tallies with our definition.
Christianity Etc › Re: Why Do Many Nigerians ´´Born Again´´ Get Backslided When They Travel Abroad by PastorAIO: 12:59pm On Jun 11, 2009
REAL TRUTH:
at Poster: How many people are actually born again in Nigeria including pastors? U re the one calling them born again in Nigeria because they appear the way you want them appeared and ultimately you gave them the approval as being born again,,,Most christians in Nigeria re just simply religious people,,they do whta the sect or church they belong to ask them to do and that makes them born again,,
  If the number of pastors we have in Nigeria re actually bron again,,,the whole world would have been transformed by gospel of our Lord Jesus Christ,after all it took just 12 Disciples and Jesus to spread the Gospel in their days, a lot of people re suffering from identity problem and therefore they don't have what we call self willed or self determination to define their personality and persons,,,
qft


How many can actually tell you what it means to be born again, even. You'll get soundbites like when you accept christ as your personal saviour then you're born again. And you learn to string a load of nonsense syllables together really fast then you are spirit filled.

It used to be funny, but now it's so utterly pathetic.
Christianity Etc › Re: Why Do Many Nigerians ´´Born Again´´ Get Backslided When They Travel Abroad by PastorAIO: 12:16pm On Jun 11, 2009
Because their born againism is a social phenomenon totally dependent on their context. Once the context changes the bornagainism changes too.

Mass hysteria is a local phenomenon.
Christianity Etc › Re: Why I Am Not An Atheist by PastorAIO: 12:01pm On Jun 11, 2009
huxley2:
OK, it is obvious that we are just crossing over each other.  But I think it would help tremendously if we go back to basic and try and answer some really simple questions, some of which you have been avoiding:

1)  Give examples of things that do NOT operate in space-time.  ( I wonder if you included matter/energy in your definition of space.  If you don't, can you justified your definition of space?)

2) Give examples of things that are constantly flouting the laws of nature.


To address one point from above - you said Nature is NOT an objects.

3)  What is a lump of rock, according to your definition of Nature?.
Yes we are truly crossing wires because your 'really simple questions' is in no way going back to basics. However I'll answer them (as a leisurely diversion from the main issue).

1) For me, Spacetime is the field in which natural events occur. These events are separated from each other by various degrees of space and time. For instance London is separated from Lagos by about 6,000 miles of space. Dawn is separated from dusk by about 12 hours of time. I do not include matter and energy in my most basic definition of Spacetime although I believe that matter and energy can influence spacetime, they are not aspects of Spacetime.

Like I said before, if I have a precognitive vision of tomorrow's news then that would flout the Natural Law that says that influence/impressions have to travel across space and across time in a futureward direction.

2) Question 1 is pretty much the same as question 2 so I'll deal with them together. Afterall to transcend the limitations of spacetime is to flout Nature (as defined as occurring within spacetime).
The very idea behind Sympathetic Magic requires that such Nature be transcended. If I have a Doll named Huxley and I get a nail and drive it into my Huxley's arm, a certain other Huxley in Manchester ought not to be aware of that. If however at the very moment I drove the nail into my doll's arm Huxley2 felt a sharp pain in his arm then somehow my act has been transmitted across space to have an effect on your arm. also the effect of my act could be instantaneous which means that there has been no time for any influence from my act to have travelled all the way to manchester across spacetime to you. According to our definition of Nature what happened happened through supernatural means.

Now you can dismiss this all as voodoo rubbish so I'll provide another example from the annals of scientific enquiry. I'm sure that you've heard of the EPR experiment. Imagine two particles travelling many miles apart. What would you say if we altered one of them and observed an immediate change in the other many miles away? How did the other know that an alteration was taking place in it's partner? How did the information travel all those miles faster than the speed of light (a physical impossibility). The experiment and it's implications are better explained in these quotes:
Another view of the EPR concept is to conceive of a pair of two particles traveling in opposite directions, and required by the Pauli Exclusion Principle to have opposite spins. (The Pauli Exclusion Principle may be considered to be absolutely essential to any viable theory of quantum mechanics, and in fact was the key link in which Einstein, et al hoped to disprove the quantum theory. It just didn’t work out too well -- the EPR Experiment has become a major supporting milestone for Quantum Physics. Bummer.)

Meanwhile, back at the ranch, When the spin of one particle is unilaterally changed, an astounding experimental result is that the second particle’s spin “immediately” flips of its own accord (and thus maintains the validity of the Pauli Exclusion Principle). Furthermore, the means by which the information of the first spin flip is transferred to the second particle (so that it too can flip) is information which is required to travel faster than the speed of light. While the information transfer may not be simultaneous (limits on the experimental apparatus prohibits any proof of simultaneity), it nevertheless -- within the time frame of the Planck constant or speeds in excess of the speed of light -- must connects the two particles in some fundamental manner.
The Einstein-Poldalsky-Rosen Experiment (the EPR Experiment) has been described by several authors.

Herbert [1] describes the situation of two quantum particles which are once together flying apart and being measured at two distant locations. There exists a connection between the particles such that the fact of an observation of particle A is relayed to the distant particle B, it such a manner that the communication, “does not diminish with distance, cannot be shielded, and travels faster than light.” The fact of the two particles once being together is sufficient to mingle the particles’ phases (which the author refers to as “quantum phase entanglement”). This results in the effect being “non-local” (whereas all ordinary light-speed-limited forces are referred to as “local”).
http://www.halexandria.org/dward148.htm

In physics, the principle of locality states that an object is influenced directly only by its immediate surroundings. Quantum mechanics predicts through Bell's inequality the direct violation of this principle[1]. Experiments have shown that quantum mechanically entangled particles violate this principle: they have been shown to influence each other when physically separated by 18 km, thus the principle of locality is false
Einstein's View

[edit]EPR Paradox
Albert Einstein felt that there was something fundamentally incorrect with quantum mechanics since it predicted violations of locality. In a famous paper he and his co-authors articulated the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen Paradox. Thirty years later John Stewart Bell responded with a paper which stated (paraphrased) that no physical theory of local hidden variables can ever reproduce all of the predictions of quantum mechanics (Bell's theorem).
[edit]Philosophical View
Einstein assumed that principle of locality was necessary, and there could be no violations of it. He said[18]:
“ The following idea characterises the relative independence of objects far apart in space A and B: external influence on A has no direct influence on B; this is known as the Principle of Local Action, which is used consistently only in field theory. If this axiom were to be completely abolished, the idea of the existence of quasienclosed systems, and thereby the postulation of laws which can be checked empirically in the accepted sense, would become impossible.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_locality

3) a lump of rock is an object that exhibits Natural properties and possibly also Supernatural properties.
Christianity Etc › Re: Why I Am Not An Atheist by PastorAIO: 8:56am On Jun 11, 2009
I can't believe that we are still on different pages.

huxley2:
Ah, you are now try to play semantics now, aren't.   "Definitions" encapsulate our way of understanding the world and reality.  "Defintions" do not instantiate reality.  So by making the object contingent on its semantic definition is wrong.  You approach would suggest that an entity only comes into existence after it has been defined.  This is clearly absurd.
I'm not trying to play semantics.  I'm  not making any object contingent on its semantic definition.  I'm making a CONCEPT contingent on it's semantic definition.  There is a vast different.

Nature is not an object.  Nature is a concept of one way the world works that is contrasted with the super-natural.  In order to know what you are talking about when you say Nature we need to have it defined well.  Do you get that?

I don't know if it was on this thread or the other one about 'what is supernatural' that I said that even the word Everything makes a distinction from somethings, or Nothing. 

So Existence is defined against another concept called Non-existence.

From the definition of Universe I know that the statement "The Earth is The Universe" is wrong. Can you tell me Why?

huxley2:
I used Newton here for illustration.  In fact, Newton was a mystic, so in that frame of mind, if he were alive today, for the first few hours or days of his ressurection, it is likely that he would consider our modern technology as mystical (or supernatural) products.  Obviously, as he catches up with modern science, he will soon learn that these are the products of naturalistic science.
No Huxley, being a mystic does not mean that you called everything that you don't understand supernatural.   I wonder if my points are going totally over your head. 

Once you have a definition, then what determines how you classify events rests on whether or not they fit the definition.  It is an arbitrary definition but the one we are working with at the moment.  Nature relies on Space and Time and it's influences traversing space and time.  Armed with this definition there is not way that Newton would think that modern technology were supernatural. 


huxley2:
Anyhow, the substantive point was this - IF something flouts currently known laws of nature, how can we know that there is no other laws of nature that it obeys?  This is the questions you keep avoiding and I keep asking.  Please, if you respond to nothing else, attempt just this one.
First I want to make sure that you are aware that we are using a working definition of Nature at the moment.  We can know that it is not obeying another natural law because it does not require space or time to operate.  Since all natural laws require space and time to operate it is easy to check if a phenomenon seems reliant on space time.  IF not then it cannot be a Natural phenomenon.
Christianity Etc › Re: Why I Am Not An Atheist by PastorAIO: 8:03pm On Jun 10, 2009
huxley2:
So far, I agree. That ties in with the definition of nature I gave earlier, according to which nature is matter, energy, time, space, events, experience.
I glad you said the above first because it shows that you haven't yet quite got what I'm getting at, so I know more explanation is necessary. What I said doesn't tie in with what you said earlier, neither can it for a number of reasons.

First the word definition. Definition, by definition ( cool) puts a limit around something. De - Fine. -Fine is the end, the limit, the boundary. In-finite. Is without boundary, without limit. So when you define something, you give it boundaries. Not only do we know what it it but also we know what it is not. We know that beyond certain boundaries what we find is no longer a part of the de-fined thing.

A definition does cannot include everything that exists. Your definition of Nature is not a definition at all.

Secondly, having pointed that out I tried to help out with a possible definition of Nature. Nature occupies space and time and Natural influences traverse Space and Time (in a futureward direction). This is the definition that we are working with at the moment and any reference to any other definition will only confuse issues because with differing definition what I'm calling nature might not be what you are calling nature.


huxley2:
Agree also. To flout the laws of Nature would be non-natural. But here-in lies the problems. Do we have knowledge of the full sample space of the laws of nature.
With a definition of Nature you do not need to have full knowledge of all the laws of nature. Once you have defined Nature when you discover a Law you can then determine whether it is a natural law or some other kind of law.

For example, We all know there is a Biological definition of a genus called Canine. We know that dogs are canines. However you don't need to know absolutely every example of a canine in the world before you recognise one. Once I know what a canine is If I run into a wolf for my first time I will know that it fits the definition of a canine. If I run into a Bear for the first time which looks remarkably different from a dog, upon closer study I'll realise that it too is a canine. It fits the definition. If however I ran into a duck for the first time, on close examination I'll correctly conclude that it isn't a canine. (or is it Canus).

Once you have the definition of Nature you don't need to know every natural thing that can possibly happen. When you come across something you can assess against your definition whether or not it is Natural.


huxley2:
For instance, if you were to ressurrect Isaac Newton today in the mindset of a 16/17th century man, in the first few hours or days of in this "new" world, he would probably consider all our modern technologies as flouting the laws of nature. Newton was unaware of quantum physics, of electronics, of electrons, of genetics, of strong/weak nuclear force, etc, etc. In the eyes of 16/17th century man, the modern world is non-natural.

If your glass instantly dematerialises and rematerialises at a different location, how are we to know if it is not obeying some yet-to-be-discovered natural law?
Funny that you should use Newton as an example. I don't think Newton would be that phased and I know he certainly won't think our modern technologies were supernatural. Newton was a lot deeper that many people imagine. Principia Mathematica was only the tip of the iceberg.
Now, if Newton were to use our definition he might be amazed at the wonderful things of nature but he would not think any of our technologies were supernatural. They all employ forces and effects that traverse space and time.

If newton were however, using our definition, to see a glass dematerialise and rematerialise elsewhere he would call it non natural. If by definition, in nature bodies have to travel through space then such vanishing and reappearing elsewhere could be occurring according to some Law of the Universe but it wouldn't be a Natural Law. A spiritual or divine Law perhaps but not a Natural law.


huxley2:
Further, of the main natural laws that we currently know, how often do these get flouted?

1) Have you ever seen the law of gravity flouted?

2) Have you ever seen a half-duck half-crocodile creature?

3) Have you ever seen contravension of the law of conservation of energy?
Laws of Nature are flouted all the time and it has been evidenced.

I personally haven't seen gravity flouted, or ducrodile or conservation of energy flouted.
Christianity Etc › Re: I Am Done With Intituitionalized Christianity, Would Stop Attending "church" by PastorAIO: 2:14pm On Jun 10, 2009
origina9ja:
so is that AN EXCUSE TO STOP "FELLOWSHIPPING" GOING TO CHURCH undecided
Where 2 or more are gathered in my name, I'll be there.

fellowship can happen anywhere were 2 likeminded people (ie 2 fellows) get together for a common cause.
Christianity Etc › Re: Why I Am Not An Atheist by PastorAIO: 8:59am On Jun 10, 2009
Okay let me try again. Under a natural regime (according to my definition of Natural) in order for influence to pass from one body to another it will have to do so across space. In order for the influence of the Sun's gravity to pass to earth it does so across space.
In order for light from the Sun to brighten up your day the light has to travel across space from the Sun to the earth. This trajectory of influence across space fits in with Nature's requirements.

If however a glass of water on my table were to disappear and instantaneously reappear on a shelf without seeming to travel across space then that would flout the laws of Nature. It would be non natural.

Not only do bodies and their influence have to travel through Space in a natural regime, but also they have to travel through time. They must travel through time in a futurewards direction. Influence cannot pass from the present into the past. Only from the present into the future.

(By influence I mean something that Flows from one thing to another.
Main Entry:
1in·flu·ence
Pronunciation:
\ˈin-ˌflü-ən(t)s, especially Southern in-ˈ\
Function:
noun
Etymology:
Middle English, from Old French, from Medieval Latin influentia, from Latin influent-, influens, present participle of influere to flow in, from in- + fluere to flow — more at fluid
Date:
14th century
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/influence

What I'm saying is that in nature all influence passes through space and also through time in a futureward direction. If we have any indication of influence passing otherwise then we have an instance of the non-natural.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Virgin As Coredemptrix by PastorAIO(op): 8:14am On Jun 10, 2009
[quote author=~Lady~ link=topic=281629.msg4004630#msg4004630 date=1244613380]
I don't mind people having an opposition to the Church
, it will always be there, it was there even before the birth of the Church. What I cannot stand is when people cannot formulate a credible logical explanation for their stance. So I urge you to please be different and formulate a credible logical explanation for your stance against the Church.

Is the New Testament the only part of the Bible?[/quote]I get what is biting you catholic people. You've got a persecution complex. I'm not attacking anyone or in opposition to anyone, church or otherwise.

I guess you've been bashed around so much by the pentecostals on this forum and the outside world that you imagine any attempt to discuss catholic doctrine to be an attack.

Me, I just found an interesting article that I thought was worth discussing. I realise now that anything of the sort will be impossible with you guys. I've been here before when I quoted a historical event from the early church councils and some catholics started foaming and cussing me. It was just an historical fact.

Anyway sha, yes I had read the article before posting it and I do know what a redemptrix is. I shouldn't have said equal to jesus as redeemer perhaps, but the basic point remains the same.

In any case, I have no more desire to discuss this subject with anyone, especially not a nairaland catholic.
Christianity Etc › Re: Why I Am Not An Atheist by PastorAIO: 1:15am On Jun 10, 2009
I have offered a definition of Natural that says that influence passes from one event or object in a futureward direction across space. 

Perception is nothing more than an impression made by an event upon the senses.

The impression cannot precede the event in a Natural world.

ie.  I cannot perceive something before it occurs.  I cannot see rosy-fingerred dawn before the sun is about to rise. 

If I do see it (ie receive an impression of the dawn on my senses) accurately prior to the sun actually rising then it could not have occurred by natural means.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Virgin As Coredemptrix by PastorAIO(op): 1:04am On Jun 10, 2009
In fact, the Church's magisterium (te[b]aching authority) has grown ever more convinced of the soundness of this insight of the Fathers and Doctors over the centuries and has come to see the Protoevangelium as a revelation of the indissoluble bond between Jesus and Mary in the work of our salvation[/b]. The Second Vatican Council's Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy, Sacrosanctum Concilium, provides explicit corroboration of such an association by stating that Mary "i[b]s inseparably linked to her Son's saving work[/b]" (indissolubili nexu cum Filii sui opere salutari coniungitur) (#103) (5). This follows logically from a principle of capital importance enunciated by Blessed Pope Pius IX in his Apostolic Constitution Ineffabilis Deus of 8 December 1854, namely that "God, by one and the same decree, had established the origin of Mary and the Incarnation of Divine Wisdom" (6).
http://www.fifthmariandogma.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=349:the-proposed-marian-dogma-the-qwhatq-and-the-qwhyq&catid=133:front-page


The concept of Co-redemptrix refers to an indirect or unequal but important participation by the Blessed Virgin Mary in redemption. She gave free consent to give life to the redeemer, to share his life, to suffer with him under the cross and to sacrifice him for the sake of the redemption of humankind.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Co-Redemptrix
Christianity Etc › Re: The Virgin As Coredemptrix by PastorAIO(op): 6:14pm On Jun 09, 2009
Sorry, I was under the impression that a redemptrix was one that redeemed and a co-redemptrix was one that redeemed with another.  Am I wrong?
Christianity Etc › Re: Why I Am Not An Atheist by PastorAIO: 6:09pm On Jun 09, 2009
huxley2:
Yes, we have seen this before and it is pretty damn difficult to refute, although it is generally agreed that it is an absurd  proposition.  Can think of all the absurdities related with it now.
It's impossible to refute and no, it isn't absurd. It might be counter intuitive, but it isn't absurd.

The point I'm making is that defining something as 'everything', such as when you say Nature is Everything that exist, is the Grandaddy of all absurdities. The very essence of words, language, semantics is that words are distinguishing things. There is no word in any language in the world that does not distinguish something from other things.

The word 'green' doesn't just tell you that something it green, it also tells you that the something is not black, or blue, or orange. the word 'up' distinguishes one direction from another 'down'. Nature (being a word in a language) should also be a distinguishing thing. It can't mean everything. Even the word Everything distinguishes everything from somethings, or Nothing. Words specify. Therefore words must have definitions. Arguing around a word without an idea of the notion that it defines is the great ancestor of absurdities.
Pick a definition so we know what you are talking about. Then we can discuss. But a discussion based around a bias against the word supernatural whatever it might mean is madness. I get a feeling that some atheists just don't like the sound of the word. And they love the sound of Nature, regardless of what it might mean. They don't care what it means.

May I suggest rather than the word supernatural to use the word Art.

Is there Art in the world or is everything Natural? What is the relationship between Art and Nature?
Christianity Etc › Re: Why I Am Not An Atheist by PastorAIO: 5:38pm On Jun 09, 2009
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=279631.msg4000243#msg4000243 date=1244553517]That's interesting. What do you have in mind?[/quote]That is another topic entirely. I don't think I can go into this now. Maybe some other time on some other thread.
Christianity Etc › Re: Why I Am Not An Atheist by PastorAIO: 5:30pm On Jun 09, 2009
huxley2:
Is this definition restricted to entities capable of perception?  Like I said ealier, was there a natural world 10 billions years ago?   How would you answer that in the light  (pun intended smiley  ) of your definition?
Perception is nothing more than an impression made upon the brain by something else.  that something else, for example a meteor, can make other impressions.  To stick with the example of a meteor an impression can be made on the earth in the form of a crater. 

The laws of natures say that the crater is formed subsequent to the impact of the meteor, never before. 

Similarly according to the laws of nature an impression can not be formed on the mind prior to the event that causes the impression. 

Whether or not there were minds then (another interesting idea but miles divorced from the trend of this thread now) the fact of nature is that impressions were being made by objects upon each other.  The laws of nature tell us that marks of water erosion upon landscape cannot have been formed prior to water being present on that landscape. 
So it seems that whether or not there is a mind to perceive events those events are still believed to interact according to the laws of nature. 

When I say prescience or precognition is a sign of supernatural I don't mean that as something special to minds and cognitive faculties. What is supernatural is the fact that the impressions from the future can travel across time in an nonnatural direction and make an impression on my mind. It is the travelling of the impression that is non natural not the perception itself.
Christianity Etc › Re: Why I Am Not An Atheist by PastorAIO: 2:12pm On Jun 09, 2009
ps, I believe the world is made up of 4 elements.
Christianity Etc › Re: Why I Am Not An Atheist by PastorAIO: 2:11pm On Jun 09, 2009
wirinet:
@ Pastor,

To me the supernatural is what is not understood under our present stage of scientific development. At one time and with all cultures, thunder and lightening was a supernatural event, Leprosy and other bacteria and viral infections were demonic attacks, madness and other mental conditions was a spiritual attack, so was movements of the planets and comets, volcanoes,   earthquakes, etc. If a witch can be verified to fly on a broomstick, then we will need to examine the process which propels the broom and replicate the system. that is the way an atheist like me reason, it will  not be enough for me to accept the notion that the propulsion system of the broom is too mysterious to understand so it must be the work of God, Satan, Angels, Demon or Santa Claus.
To make my point, let me turn things around.  I say that there is no such thing as the Natural, only supernatural.  Everything is supernatural.  thundder, lightning, leprosy, boiling a cup of water, everything.  A supernatural agent is making everything happen as it happens.  Nature is a fallacy.
Christianity Etc › Re: Why I Am Not An Atheist by PastorAIO: 1:23pm On Jun 09, 2009
It is not the state of mind that is supernatural, but rather the manner of perception. Natural vision sees events via light waves that travel across space and time. Any sort of visual perception of reality that doesn't depend on lightwaves travelling across space/time would, according to my definition of Natural, be considered non-natural.


Something can either be considered natural via aspects of nature that we are as yet unfamiliar with or it can be supernatural. Yes. But there is a school of thought that says that the easiest explanation is the best and most elegant.

According to a definition of nature that says influence has to traverse space and time (in a futureward direction), precognitive visions has to be supernatural.

Or can you think of how a future event can naturally make an impression on a mind without destroying the definition of nature.
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is The Supernatural? by PastorAIO: 12:50pm On Jun 09, 2009
huxley2:
Thank you and welcome to the club. You are an existentialist, OR better still a naturalist.
I'm sure you know why I find your familiarity with the term existentialist so mind boggling. That said, I don't believe I'm an existentialist or even a naturalist.

And Frankly, I wouldn't dream of joining a club that would have me.

Like a true african I only want what is out of reach.
Christianity Etc › Re: Why I Am Not An Atheist by PastorAIO: 12:45pm On Jun 09, 2009
huxley2:
In principle, maybe, but in practice NO. How would you know that there is no heat source in the vicinity. To know this, you will require full knowledge of the enitre sample space of heat sources. And you will also need to define what vicinity is. Is 5 light-years considered vicinity? Is 1000 LY, is 100000000 LY vicinity. Remember that heat source from pulsar, millions of LY away can still reach us here.

And there may be yet other undiscover forms of heat. Remember before radioactivity was discover, nobody could adequately explain why the core of the earth was so hot. When radioactivity was discover, it all became "natural".

So your definition for the supernatural amounts to the following:

Anything that cannot yet be adequately explained using naturalistic scientific means is supernatural.

Do you agree?
No I don't agree! Not in the least!! There are rules and laws in Nature. IF my pot of water suddenly got to boiling in 2 minutes that means there's got to be an appreciably intense source of heat in the vicinity. A star in a remote galaxy is not going to boil my water.

I have offered a definition of Natural that said that influence had to pass from one body to another via the medium of Space and Time. That is just one working definition that I am working with.
If I imagine a vision of my sister winning the lottery and dancing for joy which prove to be true despite the fact that there is no way that light waves could have travelled from where she is across space to my field of vision then that would be a supernatural event.
If I see an event that will happen tomorrow despite the fact that lightwaves from that event cannot travel across time backwards then that is a supernatural event.

If Science then discovers that it is possible for influence to travel across another medium other than space and time, like say some extradimensional reality, a hyper space, that will not make it natural. That would mean that science has found a way to explore the non-natural.
Things don't change willy nilly when you have proper definitions and you know what you are talking about.

Proper definitions do not rely on the as yet unknown.
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is The Supernatural? by PastorAIO: 12:10pm On Jun 09, 2009
huxley2:
At least, I have tried with my defintion. What is yours? How do you define natural and supernatural?
I do not really make a distinction between natural and supernatural. What is just is, as far as I'm concerned.

I however recognise that we have different ways of organising our experience of existence. And one of those ways is to organise experience as events connected in a spacio-temporal network. The functioning within that spacio-temporal backdrop is what some would call Nature.
Christianity Etc › Re: Why I Am Not An Atheist by PastorAIO: 11:58am On Jun 09, 2009
huxley2:
Like I said in the other thread, nature, in the commonsense view, is the stuff and processes that interact with stuff.  Stuff is matter, energy, time, experience, events(or process), and experience (or consciousness).  So far,, this is what WE know is nature, and using our senses we have consistently manipulated, interacted, harness, poked, this stuff of nature.

Now,, using the same sense, we have not being able to consistently and reliable to demonstrate that there is nonstuff outside this know field of stuff.  If we had been able to, then you would have two options;

1)  Bring that into the field of stuff

2)  Declare it non-stuff (or supernatural)

Now, that is my attempt at defining the natural.  Can I have you attempt of the natural and the supernatural to see if there is some common ground?
Sorry I didn't see the last bit, that's why I didn't address it.  

First we need to make a distinction between natural and naturalism.  Naturalism is the ideology that says that everything that exists is Natural and all processes are Natural processes.  This is an -ism.

I can't think of any definition of Natural that fulfills all the needs of naturalism.  ie that includes all phenomena.

However I would say that in Nature all agents of change are bodies that exist in Spacetime and extend their influence via the medium of space and time onto other bodies.  Influence can only travel in a futureward direction in time but can extend in all directions in space.  
In this instance my pot of water is getting hot because there is a stove beneath it which is giving off energy in the form of heat that is travelling across the space between the stove and the pot to heat up the pot.  

If my pot of water got hot without a source of heat in the nearby vicinity (space or time) then something non natural has happened.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 (of 287 pages)