PastorAIO's Posts
Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 (of 287 pages)
KingEbukaNaija:These are all still acts. What is a judge without anything to judge. What is a protector without anything to protect. What is an avenger without anything to avenge. All your descriptions of God are based on the assumption that there are something else to which he bears these relations and attributes. Therefore before he created anything there can be nothing for him to be 'judge, father, protector, avenger' to. Therefore you cannot give him any meaningful description or attributes. To all intents and purposes you cannot say he exists. |
KingEbukaNaija:It doesn't matter what he is called. I presumed that The magician existed before he even began performing any acts of magic. Can we argue that God only came into being when he started to create the universe? ie. He is defined by his creative act, but not only that but His whole existence depends on his being a creator. |
KingEbukaNaija:I don't believe you can say that is the atheist's position, more like the Materialist's position. For instance, Buddhists and Jains are Atheist but they believe that 'nature' and all phenomena (including deities) are products of consciousness. But that is by the by. What I really want to get to is… How are you certain that nature can't produce consciousness (1), Intelligence (2), and Emotions (3)? I'm not disputing your belief, I just want to know how you arrived at it with such certainty. |
KingEbukaNaija:magic without a Magician? How about a Magician without Magic? Even though I'm avoiding contributing much here because I don't see anyone defining what they mean by intelligence, or consciousness, or emotions……. I would like to ask, If 'intelligence, consciousness, emotions' (whatever they may actually be) are attributes of God and God has always existed, then can we say that Intelligence, Consciousness, and emotions have always existed? |
Scholar8200:You're giving me work. No wahala. Here you go. I said: I said I found wikipedia TRUSTWORTHY precisely because it will alert you when it is not on solid authoritative ground.And you will show me where I quoted wikipedia where wikipedia didn't make reference to an authoritative source.And you said this: you said authoritative but you quickly want to change it to trustworthy! Not very honest!This is only one, and a very glaring one at that, so it will do. I never said wiki was authoritative but it made reference to authoritative sources and I found it trustworthy cos where it had no authoritative back up it openly admits it (unlike some people I know). You then want to call me dishonest when you are the one motivated by dishonesty from the very start. You denigrated Wikipedia then you ended up trying to rely on wikipedia to make your point because you felt you could twist it to your own ends. Alas, you won't get away with that, not with me. |
Scholar8200:I'll repeat. You made a claim will all certainty. I asked you to back it up with sources. You then told me that you had to go and search for your sources to back up what you had already stated with absolute certainty. That was when I suspected that you were a jiving kinda guy. To date you still haven't produced any evidence to back up your certain claims. Indicate the authoritative source referenced by Wiki!Are you joking!!? Oh, maybe this is just another attempt to twist from you. I asked you, "Can you show me, with evidence, where I quoted Wikipedia and what I quoted was false? " and instead of a straight answer you twist past the question and demand that I show you the authoritative source that was referenced in Wiki. Quite pathetic but I'll indulge you none the less. That was the opening lead of the wiki page, which is a summary of all that came after. This is the passage I quoted: The Waldensians (also known variously as Waldenses (/wɔːlˈdɛnsiːz, wɒl-/), Vallenses, Valdesi or Vaudois) are a Christian movement and religious cultural group which appeared first in Lyon and spread to the Cottian Alps in the late 1170s. Today, the Waldensian movement is centered on Piedmont in northern Italy, while small communities are also found in southern Italy, Argentina, Germany, the United States, and Uruguay. These are the points it raised: 1)Waldensians are a religious and cultural group. Do you really need a reference for this before you believe? I hope not. 2) They appeared first in Lyon in 1170s. So it is mentioned in the summary. Now when you read further you will see in the main body of the page where it is discussed in more detail and there the sources are given. The Main source is the Chronicles of Laon, which is a medieval book on heresies. ref [6]. http://uo-medievalchristianity.weebly.com/blog/chronicle-of-laon-and-chronicle-of-trier This link gives a summary of it. Heresy became a major issue during the 12th and 13th century due to the rise of many new forms of Christianity. One such heresy comes from Peter Waldo, told in Chronicle of Laon, who first began his Christian life after hearing a story about St. Alexis from an entertainer and from this story came his desire to seek out the knowledge of Christianity from schools. This new profound faith drove Peter to give all his property to his wife and start allocating money to the poor, his daughters, and returned money to the people he wronged. Peter then started to preach living a poorer life style to his followers, but in 1178 Pope Alexander III held a council that condemned the actions of Peter in the matters of preaching and forbade Peter to preach unless he had permission from bishops. This is what happens when you dont painstakingly read through responses and secondary sources and links attached!You took the words right out of my mouth. Too bad!Yeah too bad. |
Joshthefirst:Well, it would be advisable. Don't you think so? |
joseph1013:India was colonised too but they still kept their Hinduism. What was the difference? |
OLAADEGBU:Bingo!!! |
Muafrika2:What is righteousness? |
Kay17:Even then I feel that he erred. The stuff about meekness and 'resist not evil' was written in the bible in the first century CE. However if you look at christian history what you find is that christians are only 'meek' in the face of a greater power like the authority of imperial Rome. When it comes to dealing with others who are weaker than them like other christians less organised all the meekness flies out of the window. They castigate, they hound, they hurl polemics at each other. In fact I can guess that nearly half of christian literature is polemical in nature. Then what happens when they rise in power up to the imperial level. The lack of meekness is exhibited even more. They destroy pagan temples and drive non-christians out of the cities (hence they are called pagans cos they could only thrive in the countryside). The Orthodoxers attack the Arians after Rome fell, and vice versa. Polemics polemics polemics shaaaaaaa!! Even between Orthodoxers, they fought to split into east and west. Then They fought crusades. Then they fought Galileo and Copernicus and then the Reformation etc etc etc. Where I would be more inclined to agree with Nietzsche was if he said that Slave morality was invented by the Master Race and then foisted onto the slave population in order to make them subservient. That would make much more sense to me. Then again, one cannot rule out the possibility that there is actually a spiritual advantage in meekness and the whole notion of 'resist not evil', and humility. This is actually my belief. I'm not sure what you're referring to when you mention his arguments about existence of God outside of a religious context being useless and hopeless. |
Joshthefirst:You can accept anything that you want to accept. I was just surprised that Daily Mail was a scientific journal. |
KingEbukaNaija:I didn't realise that the Daily Mail was a scientific journal. |
A simple matter of 'what is nature?' but we had to take the digressionary path into going round and round talking nonsense with ill defined terms. How deflating!! |
plaetton: Chaos is when There are too many competing and interacting variables to discern a predictable pattern or outcome.But the laws of nature are not flouted. So there is actually Order. The problem is that you cannot discern the order. So Order and Chaos are states of the mind when observing phenomena, they are not inherent in phenomena. What you see as chaos, someone else with another perspective may see a perfect order. |
Kay17:It seems that Nietzsche sees morality as a means to justify one's condition or way of behaviour. While I agree that people have many different ways of justifying things that they were going to do anyway, or conditions that they are in, I think his categorisations are too simplistic. I've met many people, and I'm sure you have too, that once they realise that they've been the victims of a joke they immediately go out to look for another naive person to lure into the same joke so that they won't be the only victims. Too many people when they have been victims only go on to feel justified in victimising other people. It's as if their victimhood is the green light they need to wreak terror on others. (Israeli Zionists might be an example in point). In fact i've come to the conclusion from my years of experience with humans that it is those individuals that go around feeling sorry for themselves, feeling that life has been too tough for them, that are the most likely to be callous selfish hateful individuals. You can already see the selfishness in the way that they always talk about how other people were victimising them and how unfortunate their lot has been as if they are the only people on this planet that are suffering. Anybody that can look around this world and conclude that he/she is the one that is the worst victim of life has all that it takes to be a nasty Terrorist. If one takes a closer look at the 'Slave' societies that Nietzsche is talking about what you will likely find is that it too is stratified. The More oppression the Master race perpetrate on the Slave races, the more oppression the upper echelons of the Slave races will perpetrate on the lower echelons. It follows that being a victim does not lead you to have a Slave morality endorsing weakness like Nietzsche proposed but rather it makes you more likely to embrace oppression yourself. Nietzsche was trying to have a dig at christianity but I believe that he failed woefully in his thinking here cos he let his distaste for christianity cloud his judgment. |
@Plaetton, What exactly do you mean by Chaos? Do you mean lack of Laws? I ask because when a snowflake is formed the laws of nature are not flouted, the laws remain consistent in forming the snowflake. Or perhaps you mean Randomness when you say Chaos? However even in the rolling of dice, a supposedly random event, we find that there are structures. There are certain sums that are more likely to come up more often than not. Hence Statistics. Why would you give preeminence to Chaos (however you define it) over Order? Surely Chaos can emerge out of Order just as easily as Order can emerge out of Chaos. To what extent are Chaos and Order just categories in our perceptual abilities? In other words, how are you sure that Chaos and Order is out there in the world, rather than in your mind? Perhaps you inability to make sense of a phenomena is what makes it Chaotic to you and when you eventually come to make sense of it you perceive it to have Order. Are Order and Chaos just markers of your ability to grasp a phenomenon? |
GooseBaba:It is indeed curious that we readily accept that Man, presumably a part of nature, is intelligent yet we refuse to consider that there could be intelligence anywhere else in Nature. |
MrAnony1:Again Intelligence is a ill defined term that is often used without much deep thought into what is being said. The above question presumes that Nature is an entity of which we may say it is intelligent or not. That's my first gripe. Second gripe, There are actually two distinct things that are given the name intelligence. 1) The ability to perceive distinctions, and the ability to derive (or perceive) generalisations. 2) Intelligence is also used to refer to an entity that has Intention/s. I'd like to throw my tuppence into the pool of definitions. I would say that Intelligence was an awareness and perception of the environment that is overshadowed by a purpose, whereby the information from the environment is evaluated and employed according to how it can help achieve the purpose.https://www.nairaland.com/294887/what-intellect-ona-kan-o#4191856 So it follows that when I see the question 'Is Nature Intelligent?', I can also interpret that to mean, 'Are Natural Processes Teleological?'. To which I would answer with a resounding 'Yes'. |
Very Good question. Almost the kind of thread that I would open myself, only that it would be ignored if I opened it. My take on the issue is: A) Nature is one of those words that people like to bandy about without giving much thought to what they actually mean. So therefore you'll find in used in many diverse contexts with many diverse meanings implied. B) To properly have a discussion about Nature we will first have to define what we mean by it and study the different ways we have been using it to see what it is we are really saying when we use it. Anyway, I have a question to ask. I keep hearing people appeal to nature as an explanation for complexities that they find in the operation and function of non-manmade things. So my question is:A) One early mix up I've noticed in discussions of Nature is the presumption that Nature is an entity. Sometimes it is spoken of as if it is the sum of all material existence. It is sometimes even almost anthropomorphised. This approach runs into trouble when Natural is contrasted with Artificial. One person says that the fumes coming out of a car are not natural but artificial therefore bad (notice that natural is usually considered good while artificial is considered bad). Another person refutes this by saying that everything in the fumes occurs naturally in nature and is derived from nature. Carbon monoxide is a natural gas, so therefore car fumes are also natural therefore good. A funny example of this problem I encounter in my University days was of a girl that refused to take paracetamol for a headache because pills were not natural. But this same girl could smoke the hell out of indos. The claim of course being that Igbo is a herb that occurs naturally. Someone then pointed out the fact that there are far more terrible poisons and toxins occurring naturally in nature than man could ever create in a lab, and many of them infinitely more toxic than man's artificial efforts. The tendency to see Nature as an entity or a certain type of object is flaw (even before we go on to whether Naturally automatically means good). B) Then there is one other way to define nature, which I much prefer. I see nature as a type of process. So an event may arise due to a natural process, or it may arise due to a non natural process. All around us we are surrounded by processes. The passage of day into night and back into day is a 24 hour process. The course of how we spend our day is another process. I would say that Nature is the processes that would hold sway over events if Intelligence (human intelligence first and foremost) is not brought to act upon events. Natural actually comes from Natus in latin which means to give birth to.. In nature events naturally give birth to subsequent events. But that flow can be impinged upon. In other words: Intelligence is capable of making Art. I contrast Art with Nature. Art is what is created by human ingenuity. Also called Artifice. From Latin: artifice Origin late Middle English (in the sense ‘workmanship’): from Old French, from Latin artificium, based on ars, art- ‘art’ + facere ‘make’. So the product of human artfulness is Artifice which gives us the Artificial. There are some big implications here. 1, that human beings are at least in part NOT a part of nature but can impinge their wills upon nature as if from outside. 2, Where do we draw that distinction of the part of Man that is natural and the part that is capable of Artifice? This would imply that many is a supernatural (above natural) being but where do we distinguish the supernatural from the natural. A bit like a christological debate, are we Fully Natural or Fully Supernatural, or our we 2 'natures' in one, or are we a perfect blend of two natures as One nature? etc etc until you get headache. 3, It would imply that this world is not deterministic but probably Teleological too. MrAnony1: |
Scholar8200:It was a rhetorical statement. We were discussing their claims to go back to Jesus and instead of refuting that you instead tell me that Paul and John make reference to them. Since you avoided tackling the claim head on I suggested that you must believe it. The Bible is enough evidence Who the Rock was and is and will ever be!Your claims for what bible is referring to is so obviously your own subjective interpretation. So because Christ is called the Rock of Ages any mention of any other rock anywhere else in the bible must be a reference to Christ? And as the holy spirit descended like a dove, any dove we see now must be the holy spirit, abi? Search for, "The Black African Jews" by Dr Fatai Olasupo (featured in The Guardian of Monday February 29).I've already told you I don't have time. Distill the most pertinent points from his argument and post them here for me to read. Depending on the date in question! If Waldo started the people of the valley movement then common sense is that they should be known for a French and not Latin Bible!Mister, There were many versions of a latin bible that translated from the greek and hebrew long before Jerome translated the Vulgate. The Catholic church used and mentioned many of these. There are even some parts of the Catholic liturgy that still use passages from old latin translations. eg. 'Gloria in Excelsis', you won't find this phrase in the Vulgate but you will find it in the older latin translations. Unless you can prove that Waldensians existed and they are the creators of at least one of this old latin versions of the bible then there is no reason to not believe that these were all written by catholics. Waldo later translated a latin bible into his regional dialect. Now talking of regional dialects, South of France is just across the border from North of Italy. These alpine peoples have their own dialects and they are closer to each other than they are to their respective countries. So your trying to make it seem that because waldo is french he will have nothing to do with the Northern Italians will not work on me. That link takes you not to NL but to a page from a book which I dont think can be copied and pasted! So you spew out criticism without reading responses!!!But you can read! And you can type! It is not too hard to type out a relevant paragraph. I didn't 'spew' out any criticism of the book. I would have to read the book before i can 'spew' any criticism of it. However i have criticised your pseudo-scholarship because it is laid bare of us to see here. You say this but ignore links posted!!! How am I sure you read that piece from Wikisource?Again, I cannot go and read a whole book because you want to dribble me. type out the relevant passage that you want to use to buttress your point. I see, RCC was omniscient! Consider this again:Who are these Catholic authors and what is their source of information? You can yourself a scholar nah! and you even started off belittling wikipedia. But you're doing the very thing that you were belittling before. You're quoting wikipedia hook line and sinker without investigating it's statements. This is part of what we call the twisting. Now you'll notice little numbers have certain statements in wikipedia. This is where they reference their sources. Were this Catholic authors quoting from later waldensians or are they referring to references of Waldensians made at the times of antiquity? |
Scholar8200:Not all claims to antiquity are False! Nobody is arguing with you there. However that has no bearing on my point that it is a common thing to make a claim to antiquity in order to lend yourself legitimacy. Just because 0.001% of such claims may be true does not mean that we have to swallow every such claim hook line and sinker. We have to investigate and seek firm proofs. Do we have any firm evidence in any of the claims you've made? The answer is a resounding NO! The Gnostics claim that their teachings hark back to Christ. The fact that 1John or Colossians alludes to them (according to you) does not support or discredit that claim. Letters of John and Colossians were written long after Jesus was gone. (I don't know what you mean by Voltaire and unwilling Catholics sources. what did these people say that resounded with such honesty and incontrovertible authority.) I see you want to run away from disputing the Catholic claim to antiquity. Make whatever unjustified remark you want to about them but just be prepared to have the same rigorous analysis of their claim applied to your claims too. Now you've dismissed them without even an argument, but you want others to bring proofs and arguments before they dismiss yours. I didn't know that 'high international demand' was what gave a 'scholarly article' credence. In that case Crack Cocaine too must be a good thing because it is highly demanded. Anyway sha…. bring the article and we'll compare it's claims vis a vis that of the Catholic church and that of the Waldensians and see which can best withstand rigorous analysis. Did you read that google books link?Nope Did you notice that amplified portion that confirms that they were extant but little known at those times?You will have to quote the relevant part of the book that applies to our discuss and I'll read that but there is no way that I'm going to go and read a whole book just for the purpose of this discussion. I am curious as to how their existence was confirmed in this book though. I'd love to see the proof. it is up to them or you to prove this tooActually the burden of proof is on the person making the claims. |
Scholar8200:I was well on my way to my conclusion when you said you had to go and search for the evidence to back what you already made a certain claim of. My conclusions are becoming more entrenched as I see you trying to twist my words. Interesting claims those! Now, referring to wikipedia, who said this?I hope you know the difference between being an Authority and making Reference to an Authoritative Source. I said Wikipedia makes references to Authoritative sources. Can you show me, with evidence, where I quoted Wikipedia and what I quoted was false? This has to be the 3rd or 4th time I'm asking you this. you said authoritative but you quickly want to change it to trustworthy! Not very honest!I haven't changed anything. You're the one resorting to dishonesty. i knew you soon start to dance the twist. Wikipedia has the transparency to notify you when it's facts are disputed. That adds to it's trustworthiness.This is what I said. Amazing! You speak from both sides of the mouth!You are speaking of yourself here. After you searched high and low for evidence to back up your prejudices, you didn't find any so you came back to Wikipedia which you had dismissed earlier, but being twisted man, you tried to put it on me that you were quoting wikipedia because I like wikipedia. I can't not even follow your reasoning in the rest of your response. You're twisting so much that you're no longer even coherent. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=im9XuJJXylw |
Scholar8200:So you believe that they are recipients of secret teaching from Jesus. That's good to know. That of the catholic church, as regards pope starting from Peter, has feet of clay which even the epistles refute! This will do for another thread.wow, so you will just dismiss that one without backing up with evidence. Yet Waldensians came directly from the apostles and were limited to one location in europe. and nothing was heard of them till the 12th century. And there is a scholarly piece in high international demand that affirms this claim as true. (i will give you a reference when I settle)I want to see this scholarly piece o! Until you can demonstrate it let's leave things unconcluded. Not all claims to antiquity are false, but it is a common thing to try to associate with an authority from antiquity in order to get validity. It is safer to be cautious, dubious even, until solid evidence is provided. Did you read that google books link?Nope! You'll have to quote out the relevant part from me. Nairaland is a peripheral thing for me in my life, I don't have time to be reading a whole book just to participate in a thread. Did you notice that amplified portion that confirms that they were extant but little known at those times?Proof! That's all we ask for. We know for a fact that Catholic Church did not leave a stone unturned when it came to sniffing out what they considered to be heresies. Look at the Cathars. How could they have escaped notice? Surely the Church would have noticed that there was a corner of Europe that seemed to not be sending money etc. it is up to them or you to prove this too!You're asking to prove a negative. The question is how come there is no mention of them and you want us to prove that there is no mention of them. What about Christ's great commission? Did these christians not preach? We know that the Cathars preached and history is full of the details of their beliefs and things they preached. Why not the Waldensians? but after the 12th century they started preaching. |
There are two strongly contested opinions respecting the antiquity and derivation of this Church in the Wilderness. It is maintained on one side, that she has preserved her apostolic descent, intact and separate, from the earliest age of Christianity to the present time, without any mixture with other churches, and in total exemption from the errors which have clouded the faith of her Christian sisters. On this side we have the opinion of many eminent writers on prophecy, who point out the Vaudois church as the Western Witness; and also the unwilling testimony of several Roman Catholic authors, who record the tradition that the "heresy," as they term it, [size=14pt]"existed in these valleys from all antiquity[/size]."[1] The Vaudois themselves maintained, in all their appeals made at various times to their sovereigns, that the religion they followed had been preserved from father to son, and from generation to generation, "from all time, and from time immemorial."[2] Most of their historians support the same opinion. "The Vaudois of the Alps," writes one of the latest, "are, according to our belief, the primitive Christians,This is a common thing. Too common in fact that it is to be expected. Of course they never have documentation to prove their claims to antiquity. Other groups that make fantastic claims to antiquity include: Freemasonry Every one at all acquainted with the claims of Freemasonry knows that it professes to have existed in the days of Solomon; and it is claimed that Solomon himself was a Freemason, and that John the Baptist and John the Evangelist were Freemasons. Indeed, the writers frequently trace it back as coeval with the creation itself. Masons have claimed for their institution an antiquity antecedent to human government; and from this they have argued that they have a right to execute the penalties of their oaths, because Masonry is older than government. Now an examination will show that this claim is utterly false. Their own highest authorities now pronounce it to be false; and still these claims are kept up, and their oaths and ceremonies, and the whole structure of the institution profess the greatest antiquity.http://www.gospeltruth.net/1869Freemasonry/freem_chap13.htm The Alchemists, They claimed that their art goes all the way back to Adam The Gnostics, They made claims to have the true knowledge of Jesus' teachings going all the way back to Jesus himself. And of course The Catholic church itself which also claims the apostolic tradition. A Claim that you would be ever ready to deny them while you support another claim which has less evidence. Igbo people, today in nigeria there are many Igbo people who claim to be descended from Lost Jews. Claims of antiquity lend authority to movements especially new movements. Wikipedia references Samuel Moreland book written in the 17th century based on hearsay and also J. Wiley's History of the Waldenses written in the 19th century. What these books fail to address is why there is no record of the Catholic church oppressing these Waldensian guy prior to the 12th century. It is only in the 12th century the persecutions began. However we know that the catholic church was very vigilant in seeking out heresies and oppressing them. They attacked the Gnostics and the oppression is well documented. They oppressed the Arians too. Church history talks about their attacking one heresy after another. But nothing about attacking Waldensians. not until 12th century. Why? What do modern historians have to say about Waldensians and about their histories written by people like Moreland and Wylie? The origin of the Waldenses has been a matter of great dispute. They themselves allege, and their critics admit they have long held that allegation, that the group of believers has persisted in the remote valleys of the Maritime Alps since the days of Constantine. Misinterpretation of the dates of their documents by early writers has not strengthened their allegation; and it seems that their authentic records may not go back beyond the thirteenth century.Light in the Dark Ages, Edman The problem with their claims is that dates have been altered and lies inserted here and there. To the argument for the high antiquity of the sect from their writings which are preserved in manuscripts, the general reply is that these works belong to the 15th century, or later, and are affected by that Hussite influence to which reference is made above. The most plausible of these arguments has been derived from the metrical work {in the Romance language), entitled The Noble Lesson (Nobla Leyczon), the opening l1nes of which (in the first printed edition) give the date of 1100 years since Christ, and also the name "Vaudes" whence it has been inferred that the sect existed under that name, nearly a century before Waldo. But an inspection of the manuscripts in the Cambridge University Library has proved the true reading to be 1400 years ("mil et 4 cent ans" instead of "mile cent ans"http://www.hwalibrary.com/cgi-bin/get/hwa.cgi?action=get_acthesis&InfoID=1394478159 and heirs of the primitive Church, preserved in these valleys secure from the alterations introduced successively by the Roman Catholics into the evangelical faith."[3] Beza pronounces them to be "the seed of the pure Christian Church, - being those who have been appointed by the wontlerful providence of God, whom none of the storms by which the world has been shaken, nor persecution, have been able to prevail on to yield a voluntary submission to Roman tyranny and idolatry." An English historian observes, "With the dawn of history we discover some simple Christians in the valleys of the Alps, where they still exist under the ancient name of the Vaudois, who by the light of the New Testament saw the extraordinary contrast between the purity of primitive times and the vices of the gorgeous hierarchy which surrounded them."[4] The late Rev. Dr. Gilly, than whom no one could have a better right to speak on the subject, in his Preface to the former Edition of the present work, observes: "Whether the Protestant inhabitants of the valleys on each side of the Alps, between the great mountain ranges of Mount Cenis and Mount Viso, can be proved by documentary evidence to derive their Christianity from primitive times or not, this is certain, that from very remote periods there has been a Christianity in this region, different from that of Rome, in the dark, mediæval, and modern ages; and this has been handed down to the present era by a succession of martyrs and confessors, and of other faithful men. The faith and discipline of these Alpine Christians may, at times, have been more or less true to the gospel rule; but their creed and church government have always contained articles opposed to the pretensions and errors of Rome, as far as we can judge from documents that can be traced up to the fourth century at least. If, therefore, we find truth and evangelical holiness among the Waldenses of Piedmont, when other professors of the gospel in different ages and places went wrong, in the fourth century for example, and again in the ninth and eleventh, in the twelfth and thirteenth, and in the sixteenth century - if we can take epochs at random, and still find vestiges of the pure gospel at the foot of the Cottian Alps, long before the Reformation - we may conclude that the gospel was transmitted, and preserved among them, from primitive times. It is surely more probable that the "men of the valleys," shepherds and husbandmen, should retain the truth, as it was first delivered to them, than that they should be able to discover it amidst the darkness of the twelfth century, when all Christendom was departing farther and farther from the light, under the false teaching of subtle schoolmen, and ambitious and licentious hierarchs. We will now say a few words on the opinions of the other party on this contested point, who, whilst bearing an equally favourable testimony to the purity and fidelity of the Vaudois Church, assign her a more recent origin, maintaining that she received both her faith and her appellation from the merchant Reformer of Lyons, Peter Waldo, of whom we shall speak hereafter. They, too, quote from the Roman Catholic writers. Allian de l'Ile, or de Lille, who lived at the end of the twelfth century, speaks of the Vaudois as "wolves in sheep's clothing, called Valdenses, from the name of their leader, Valdus." Pierre de Vaus-Cernay, an author known at the beginning of the thirteenth century, styles them, "the heretics called Valdenses, after the name of one Valdus of Lyons." And a few of the more modern historians take the same side, considering it a sufficient honour for the Vaudois Church "to be descended from a simple layman of Lyons, whose piety, moderation, and courage may serve us for a perpetual example, and to have brought out the truths of the Gospel three ages before the Reformation, as well as to have preserved it since that time amid sufferings and privation."[6] And high praise it un doubtedly is; but we must not therefore omit to state the objections raised against this view of the subject, even by those who equally esteem the intrepid Reformer of Lyons. Again we refer to our opponents - for instance, to the bull of Pope Urban II., which sets forth that the Vaudois had been "infected with heresy from the year 1096," long before the birth of Peter Waldo. We may also again quote the assertion of Pierre de Vaus-Cernay, who in his laudatory history of Simon de Montfort, observes, that "this great Defender of the Faith especially signalized himself in his extermination |
Scholar8200:This man, you don't know that I've been trained in the sniffing out of wuruwuru with none less than Olaadegbu himself. Do you think you can twist more than him.? Okay let's go… I said I found wikipedia TRUSTWORTHY precisely because it will alert you when it is not on solid authoritative ground. That doesn't mean that I take wikipedia to be an authority. Transparency does not equal authoritative. I'm sure you're not actually that stupid. You're just trying to twist. Try harder. I asked you if the part of the wiki page I quoted was wrong, and if so what is your proof of that. I'll repeat my request. Here is the quote: The Waldensians (also known variously as Waldenses (/wɔːlˈdɛnsiːz, wɒl-/), Vallenses, Valdesi or Vaudois) are a Christian movement and religious cultural group which appeared first in Lyon and spread to the Cottian Alps in the late 1170s. Today, the Waldensian movement is centered on Piedmont in northern Italy, while small communities are also found in southern Italy, Argentina, Germany, the United States, and Uruguay.If you have any proof that this is inaccurate, please supply it like a true Scholar not a nut-job. Once again I'll say that Wikipedia's transparency makes it more trustworthy than your references thus far. That does not make wikipedia an authority. The Waldenses (from France started under Peter Waldo) merged with the Valdenses/People of the Valley (in Italy). The former started under Peter Waldo in the 12th century, but not the latter, though history reports a merger of both, it appears they still maintained their identities.What is your basis for saying this? Again, do you have historical proof or documentation? What is the difference between Waldo and Vaudois? Do they not all mean 'from the valley'? There are certain words that you'll find throughout europe due to their origin in Latin. These include Valley, Vaudois, Valdo, Waldo, Valdez Vaux. Peter Waldo simply means Peter from the valley. Vaudois means People from the valley. So you'll have a hard time to try to cook up a difference between them in the hope of fooling me. This partial merger explains the dichotomous opinion recorded by Wikisource (I chose this since you respect their records):Hahahahah! How silly!! So the only source you could find for your rubbish was wikipedia. Okay, two things. First I want to explain why I'm extra cautious with everything you say and then I want to explain wikipedia to you a little bit. 1) I asked you for evidence for what you were saying a while back and this was your response: Scholar8200:YOU ARE STILL SEARCHING KE!!! You are still searching. followed but an excuse to say providing evidence is not possible or 'impracticable' to use your term. So obviously you arrived at your conclusion without any evidence. You're now trying to go seeking for evidence, you're 'still searching'. Or maybe you've quit searching now and just opted to use wikipedia. (only because you know I respect their records abi )2)Okay, wikipedia now. It seems you do not understand how wikipedia works. Any nut-job can write anything on wikipedia, but other interested parties will flag a claim that has no evidence or is just plain nutty. Also wikipages need to be well written. That is where the 'prefatory plead' comes in. I asked a simple question which you failed to answer. What is factually inaccurate about the part of the wikipage that I quoted? Let's look at the 'prefatory plead'. This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. This article may be in need of reorganization to comply with Wikipedia's layout guidelines. (February 2016) The lead section of this article may need to be rewritten. (February 2016) If a section needs to be rewritten that doesn't mean it is factually inaccurate. It could just be badly written. Wiki explain what it is they want from their lead sections very clearly: The lead is the first part of the article that most people will read. For many, it may be the only section that they read. A good lead section cultivates the reader's interest in reading more of the article, but not by teasing the reader or hinting at content that follows. Instead, the lead should be written in a clear, accessible style with a neutral point of view.https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Manual_of_Style/Lead_section Having said that that doesn't mean that the only problems that the page will face are problems of style and organisation. Like I said before it is a constant battle to keep nutjobs from contributing to a page. Check this out from the Discussion page of the article: Should I bother posting the source or are the Catholics/French still going to pretend the names: "Waldenses"/"Waldesians"/ "valdesi" and so forth are from so-called: 'Peter Waldo' rather the VALLEY PEOPLE? — Preceding unsigned comment added by 5.69.58.27 (talk) 00:31, 6 October 2015 (UTC)I'm sure you can immediately recognise this kind of nut job first by the refusal to be bothered to post a source, and secondly by the Catholic baiting that they all seem to have in common. As the Editor points out these people are relentless and they have to be constantly vigilant. I'll address the rest of what you said in a subsequent post. |
Richirich713:The only thing that is less is the number of Uncaused things. it is just as much of an assumption to say there is only one as to say there are two, or three or a thousand. |
Scholar8200:Wikipedia has the transparency to notify you when it's facts are disputed. That adds to it's trustworthiness. What is not factual inside the part that I quoted? I'll repeat it: The Waldensians (also known variously as Waldenses (/wɔːlˈdɛnsiːz, wɒl-/), Vallenses, Valdesi or Vaudois) are a Christian movement and religious cultural group which appeared first in Lyon and spread to the Cottian Alps in the late 1170s. Today, the Waldensian movement is centered on Piedmont in northern Italy, while small communities are also found in southern Italy, Argentina, Germany, the United States, and Uruguay.I've looked on a Waldensian website (yes, this organisation still exists and unless you want to say you're a member and now it's history more than it's other members …) and this is what they have to say: Historyhttp://www.waldensian.org/3-history/ These are not some people lost in the mists of history. They still exist. They claim to have started in the 12th century. Just like Wikipedia says. I wonder, Are you a Waldensian? Do you know something about waldensians and their history that current members don't know. |
Is it possible for there to be more than one uncaused thing? And would it be possible for 2 or more uncaused things to do a collaboration on a project such as creating a universe? Richirich713: |
Scholar8200:you will show me where I quoted wikipedia where wikipedia didn't make reference to an authoritative source. Tertullian will make reference to the trinity because the concept of the trinity was already being discussed in christianity in his time. At the council of Nicea it is also referenced, without mentioning 1John 5:7. There were many theological concept discussed in christianity in that era that had no biblical source. For instance the divinity or christ, the humanity of christ, the relationship between the divinity and humanity of christ etc etc etc. Do you have any documents references the Vaudois in the 2nd century? |
Scholar8200:That is not evidence of anything. What you will do is show a document making reference to Vaudois in the 2nd century A.D. If you can't do this then get ready to be dismissed as a pseudo-scholar nut job. |
PastorAIO: The Waldensians (also known variously as Waldenses (/wɔːlˈdɛnsiːz, wɒl-/), Vallenses, Valdesi or Vaudois) are a Christian movement and religious cultural group which appeared first in Lyon and spread to the Cottian Alps in the late 1170s. Today, the Waldensian movement is centered on Piedmont in northern Italy, while small communities are also found in southern Italy, Argentina, Germany, the United States, and Uruguay. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waldensians Personally I didn't know that the bible was written in the 12th century. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 (of 287 pages)
. Magic is an action performed

, thus bring1ng the date of the poem down to the fifteenth century.16
)