Pazienza's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Pazienza's Profile › Pazienza's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 (of 453 pages)
No Bini or Edo man would be able to understand Igbanke language written or spoken. But any Igbo man who has good grasp of variety of Igbo dialects spoken in Anambra, Imo, Enugu, Abia and Ebonyi, like myself, should understand 95percent of written Igbanke, because its virtually Igbo with predilection for "ri" in place of "di" just as seen in Owerri dialect, and always replacing "a" with "e" as seen in Nkanu( Enugu dialects), eg eka for hand, instead of aka" as is obtainable in standard academic Igbo(Igbo Izugbe). Having said this. Understanding spoken Igbanke is a big challenge for any Igbo man, because the people intonation is something you are never prepared for. Its like hearing Izzi or Ikwo for first-time, there is,no way you would understand that. But if you stay with them a bit, and listen closely, you start finding out its same words you know but spoken with bizzare intonation and even altered sentence structure at times. |
Animals in Igbanke language 1: Mbekù.... Tortoise 2: Ele....Deer 3: Anù....Meat 4: Ewù....Goat 5: Anù Ewù....Goat Meat 6: Ngwugù....pepper Soup 7: Agwó....Snake 8: Eletù....Rabbit 9: Aturùn....Sheep 10: Ebùlù....Ram 11: Ñkpīn....He Goat 12: Odegbe....She Goat 13: Egi....Snail 14: Ize.... Cray Fish 15: Azùn Ndùn.... Fresh Fish 16: Azùn: Fish |
Igbanke sentences. 1. I did not hear. A nun nim 2. I told you. Men gwa i. 3. I didn't say so. E ku nim rira 4. I told you to go. N si i jen men. 5. You called me. Yu kpom. 6. You were there. I ri ebe ehu 7. You said that I ate it. I si ni men ri e. 8. She called him. Ya kpo a 9. He is a good person. O wu ezi ihian 10. She told me to go. O sim jen men 11. It is not true. E le ezi oku 12. He came to school. O bia ulo ekukwo 13. I did not eat food. E ri nim nnin 14. I go to work. M jen orun 15. She stop. O wuzo 16. Come. Bia 17. My mother. Nnem 18. Give me yam. Ye m gi 19. You ate my food. Yu ri nnin m 20. Agree Kweri 21. Who is here Onye ri eben 22. I am going. N lako alako 23. Amend. Donzi 24. Arise. Lihi oto 25. Assist Ye eka/Y'eka 26. Father Nedi 27. Mother. Nne 28. Children. Nmu 29. Elderly man. Diokpa 30. Welcome. A lua 31. Beat. Gbu 32. Become. Henrin/Honrin 33. Begin. Bidon 34. Bend. Hie/ hiemen 35. Bite. Ta (erun) 36. Blow fire. Fu okun 37. Break. Kpagi/Tikpo 38. Bring. Wehe 39. Build house. Tun ulo 40. Burn fire. Dun okun/ren okun 41. Choose. Hanrin 42. Catch. Nwun don/ kwondon 43. What do you think. Ke iro / kiro 44. Not as you think. E le ki ro 45. I did it. Meh me 46. Man. Okenye 47. Outside. Obodo/I wea esi 48. Motorcycle. Ono di ali gbo oso 49. Radio. E kpeti ta lo Ku 50. Spirit. Nmo 51. Spoil. Wiwi 52. Steal. Zu/zuru 53. Mad. Era 54. Swear. Kwun/cun 55. Curse. Iyi 56. Sweep. Za 57. Sweep out. Zapu 58. Take. Weri 59. Teach. Kuzi 60. Teacher. Onye nkuzi 61. Mold. E pete 62. Tear. Dowa/tika 63. Good. Orika-nma/mma 64. Rich. Odafi/ogaranyia 65. Trouble. Eku ray ku 66. King. Obi/Eze 67. Age mate. Otum 68. I forgot. Azom 69. Tell. Gwa 70. High/up. Elu. 71. Sit down Nodi ali. 72. Stand. li hii/ wuzo 73. Look here. le ebeni 74. Cook. shime 75. Don't fight. alu le ogwun 76. Share it. ke a 77. Bury. lii 78. Play. Egu 79. Dance for me. Tenim egu 80. Church. Okah 81. Market. Afia 82. Knife. Ebe ke 83. Cutlass. Opia 84. Shoe. Akpu uku 85. Plate. Afere 86. I'm coming. N'la la 87. Don't beat him. Egbu le ilii 88. Remember. yhan han 89. Run. Kpa osuo 90. It's big. O hii ogbe 91. Money. Egho 92. My friend. O whum 93. Road. Ozor 94. Farm. Ugbo/Ofia 95. Sleep. Ran hin 96. Person. Ihian 97. Thing. Ihien 98. Give it to me. Ye mhe/wea ye mhe 99. Do it well. Meme ohun ma 100. Leaders. Ndi okiki 101. Door . Ekwe |
Igbanke is not Igbo . They only become Igbo when Ika accept they are Igbo wholly. Which hasn't happened yet. Igbanke are Ika, their language is Ika, but you know that fission reactions can be endless, because what's good for the goose is also good for the gander. Just as Ika rejected Igbo tag, many Igbanke people are rejecting Ika tag today. They are now claiming that Igbanke is now a distinct language and ethnic group from Ika. Now, Igbanke like all Igboid groups in SS might be claiming to have migrated from Bini, but the language is clearly an Igbo dialect . An Igbanke person who came to Onitsha for the first time will be able to fully understand Igbo people there without an interpreter, but no Igbanke man can ever understand Bini, Esan or any Edoid language without learning it from beginning like any non Edo person. Makes you wonder how a supposedly Bini descendants who still live with Edos cannot understand Edo language, but speak an Igboid language and understand Igbo language spoken in far away Anambra. If I say now that Bini oral stories of Igboids in SS(Rivers, Delta, Igbanke) are distorted and fabricated stories handed down from one generation to another, they say I am a trouble shooting Igbo man. But then agaIn, history I always maintain is a science, science conform to logic and rationality. When a history is incongruous with rationality, it becomes obvious that a distortion happened somewhere. I belong to Igbanke forums, and each time they bring up this Bini story and I hit them with jaw breaking questions, they resort to insults and personal attacks. Only few of them agree with me that something is wrong with their oral history, and many of them are Igbankes that have spent considerable amount of time in the SE or currently lives in the SE. I suspect living here and seeing similarities between Igbo and their faraway Igbanke got those ones into deep retrospective thinking. |
gregyboy:Yeah. Ozanogogo are Edoid speakers, they should be in Edo state and not in Agbor. Ika should give up Ozanogogo in exchange for Igbanke to be returned to Ika. Its the right thing to do. Give and take. |
Foncu:Sorry, but I don't have those info. |
Animals in Igbanke language 1: Mbekù.... Tortoise 2: Ele....Deer 3: Anù....Meat 4: Ewù....Goat 5: Anù Ewù....Goat Meat 6: Ngwugù....pepper Soup 7: Agwó....Snake 8: Eletù....Rabbit 9: Aturùn....Sheep 10: Ebùlù....Ram 11: Ñkpīn....He Goat 12: Odegbe....She Goat 13: Egi....Snail 14: Ize.... Cray Fish 15: Azùn Ndùn.... Fresh Fish 16: Azùn: Fish |
Igbanke sentences. 1. I did not hear. A nun nim 2. I told you. Men gwa i. 3. I didn't say so. E ku nim rira 4. I told you to go. N si i jen men. 5. You called me. Yu kpom. 6. You were there. I ri ebe ehu 7. You said that I ate it. I si ni men ri e. 8. She called him. Ya kpo a 9. He is a good person. O wu ezi ihian 10. She told me to go. O sim jen men 11. It is not true. E le ezi oku 12. He came to school. O bia ulo ekukwo 13. I did not eat food. E ri nim nnin 14. I go to work. M jen orun 15. She stop. O wuzo 16. Come. Bia 17. My mother. Nnem 18. Give me yam. Ye m gi 19. You ate my food. Yu ri nnin m 20. Agree Kweri 21. Who is here Onye ri eben 22. I am going. N lako alako 23. Amend. Donzi 24. Arise. Lihi oto 25. Assist Ye eka/Y'eka 26. Father Nedi 27. Mother. Nne 28. Children. Nmu 29. Elderly man. Diokpa 30. Welcome. A lua 31. Beat. Gbu 32. Become. Henrin/Honrin 33. Begin. Bidon 34. Bend. Hie/ hiemen 35. Bite. Ta (erun) 36. Blow fire. Fu okun 37. Break. Kpagi/Tikpo 38. Bring. Wehe 39. Build house. Tun ulo 40. Burn fire. Dun okun/ren okun 41. Choose. Hanrin 42. Catch. Nwun don/ kwondon 43. What do you think. Ke iro / kiro 44. Not as you think. E le ki ro 45. I did it. Meh me 46. Man. Okenye 47. Outside. Obodo/I wea esi 48. Motorcycle. Ono di ali gbo oso 49. Radio. E kpeti ta lo Ku 50. Spirit. Nmo 51. Spoil. Wiwi 52. Steal. Zu/zuru 53. Mad. Era 54. Swear. Kwun/cun 55. Curse. Iyi 56. Sweep. Za 57. Sweep out. Zapu 58. Take. Weri 59. Teach. Kuzi 60. Teacher. Onye nkuzi 61. Mold. E pete 62. Tear. Dowa/tika 63. Good. Orika-nma/mma 64. Rich. Odafi/ogaranyia 65. Trouble. Eku ray ku 66. King. Obi/Eze 67. Age mate. Otum 68. I forgot. Azom 69. Tell. Gwa 70. High/up. Elu. 71. Sit down Nodi ali. 72. Stand. li hii/ wuzo 73. Look here. le ebeni 74. Cook. shime 75. Don't fight. alu le ogwun 76. Share it. ke a 77. Bury. lii 78. Play. Egu 79. Dance for me. Tenim egu 80. Church. Okah 81. Market. Afia 82. Knife. Ebe ke 83. Cutlass. Opia 84. Shoe. Akpu uku 85. Plate. Afere 86. I'm coming. N'la la 87. Don't beat him. Egbu le ilii 88. Remember. yhan han 89. Run. Kpa osuo 90. It's big. O hii ogbe 91. Money. Egho 92. My friend. O whum 93. Road. Ozor 94. Farm. Ugbo/Ofia 95. Sleep. Ran hin 96. Person. Ihian 97. Thing. Ihien 98. Give it to me. Ye mhe/wea ye mhe 99. Do it well. Meme ohun ma 100. Leaders. Ndi okiki 101. Door . Ekwe |
Foncu:I'm sorry, but I don't reply emails from people on nairaland. I don't seek to make contact with anyone here nor have them contact me. |
valirex:Any Igbanke person that speaks Bini learnt it on his own. No Igbanke man can speak or understand Bini without learning it. They speak Ika language, though like Ika broke off from Igbo, Igbanke people are currently breaking off Ika, many are now claiming that Igbanke is an independent language and ethnic group of it's own free from Ika. Igbanke like many Igboid groups in SS have a history of migration from Bini. |
gregyboy:Igbanke share land boundary with Mbiri in Ika part of Delta. So yes! They can easily be added to Delta. In exchange, Delta(Anioma) would have to give up Ozanogogo to Edo state. |
Dedetwo:I am beginning to think so too. |
nijabazaar:I posted no website link. And to be sure. I retyped the whole text here and posted manually. Still got banned by spambot. |
For some reasons, I am being frustrated not to complete the aim of this thread. I copied a post and posted here, and was banned by spambot. After serving 24hrs ban and despite my plea for the powers that be here to look into it fell on deaf ears. I took the pain to manually type the document rather than copy and paste, and was still banned by spambot. My Igboid moniker is on ban too. This one was just freed and I get the feeling that if I try to post any other article here, it would be banned again. I am beginning to suspect deliberate manipulations here. |
Can someone help me. I can't seem to escape spambot. My Igboid handle just got banned too as I tried to post same info I got banned by spam bot yesterday with it. Lalasticlacla, Bigfrancis12, Seun. Can you guys help me out.? |
Part 6 |
Part 5 |
Now, as established by by all available census in the era and reiterated by Willink commission, the minorities of Eastern region constituted 1/3 of the region population and this was always reflected in the region appointments. The Igbos were accused by latter day historical distortions emanating from non Igbo parts of Nigeria of marginalizing the minorities. We would attempt to separate facts from fictions by taking a look at the Eastern region ministerial appointment in this era and see if the minorities representation were up to 1/3 of the appointments and if they got important positions. |
Disclaimer : The aim of this series is not to win any minorities to Biafra or promote any form of Union between the Minorities in SS and Ndiigbo. The OP is "pathologically" Igbophillic, an Igbo nationalist at the very core, who wish and yearn for an Igbo only country between SE and willing and non Igbophobic Igbos in SS. It is OP ultimate belief that a heterogeneous Biafra consisting of myriads of ethnicities with conflicting interests in SS will fail, like Nigeria did. The sole aim of this thread is to expose the lies of the past 50yrs against Ndiigbo in relation to our dealings with the minorities of the defunct Eastern region, and hopefully to convince my fellow Igbos, why we are better of without any form of Union, be it in modern Nigeria or outside Nigeria , with the minorities. I want to take my people (Ndiigbo) back through time, to cross examine our parents dealings with the minorities, lessons we can learn from them, changes we can make, how much our political environment has changed, reason why we must change our approach to issues and in dealings with the minorities and indeed non Igbos in Nigeria, and how we can move on from the ashes of dead Eastern region that died 50yrs ago. If you are not an Igbo, you are welcome on board too. Feel free to quote and debate with me. This is a cross examination series, it wouldn't be worth it without debates, reactions, and emotions. This will be the first part of a hopefully five part in total. Thank you. Credit : most of the documents used for these series were sourced from Chibuzo Ihuoma (Dede Chibu) collections. Ironically, he is from Etche (an Igboid group) in modern Rivers state, a people who today don't even accept their Igbo identity. |
YorubaHero12 Bro I think our main problem is context. That the Eastern minorities are not part of Biafra is not my argument. The argument is that the minorities indigenous lands included in Biafra host most of the resources and they are very important to Biafra having the ability to stand alone in the first place. I showed you the Biafran Sun newspaper to show you that Ojukwu relied so much on the crude oil and the sea access most of which are domiciled in the minorities land of that BiafraDuring this period in history. Hope you know that Ikwerre, Ogba, Ekpeye, Oyigbo, Ndoni, virtually all the most productive part of modern Rivers in terms of crude oil were still bona-fide members of Igbo Union and were not counted as minorities by the colonial government or Eastern region? I am yet to get your point, because you are obviously making no point. This thread is about some southern minorities telling the Igbos to stop disrespecting them and we can link it to the issue of Kanu wanting to annex them into another Biafra. Some Igbos always say its borne out of true brotherhood and that the minorities tribe are nobody (sometimes using demeaning words like not intelligent enough to qualify them). I just showed you their importance and why they always come up anytime Kanu is trying to talk about Biafra. Imagine all those crude oil and seas are in the Igbo core states, do you think Kanu will give a damn about them?I don't know what you are talking about. The minorities region were quickly captured during the war, yet the OAU(Owerri, Aba Umuahia) part of Biafra held on for longer time. We were going to take Biafra without the minorities if it were offered at the end. Minorities were part and parcel of Biafra from its beginning. Okoko Ndem, Rex Rawson, Effiong, Akpan, etc. It was always going to be hard for Ojukwu to just drop them overnight to prove to oil hungry Yorubas and North that he wasn't after their oil. I don't even understand how we can be having this argument. Ojukwu had the opportunity to use Niger delta oil wells to negotiate for weapons and support with USSR but declined, because unlike those in Lagos who saw the place as a spoil to hunt in pack with anyone willing to assist them and share the spoils later. Ojukwu saw it as part of Biafra that must be protected from hawks. As of Kanu adding Niger delta for crude oil and sea access. I don't know as I'm not Kanu, but I know he is claiming Igalaland too, and they are no where near the sea or have oil, likewise Igbanke in Edo. Also there are lot of instances where the Igbos committed atrocities against the minorities during the Biafran war. Some men of the Ikun clan in Biase Local government in Cross River were suspected of collaborating with the Nigerian soldiers, and the Biafrans arrested, looted, raped, and committed other atrocities in Ikun land.The war was virtually Britain vs Biafra. I wouldn't take words coming from Britain papers serious. They would say and write anything to demonize Biafra. Biafra army had many minorities as part of it. How could they kill minorities? Even in Igbo land, saboteurs and their families were usually targeted. Ifeajuna family were almost wiped off in Onitsha, their house were burnt and they were persecuted, in fact it got to a point that almost all Onitsha persons were seen as Sabos by everyone in Biafra. This was the state of things in Igboland. All over the world, traitors were never treated with kid gloves in war period, because many are usually in pains. What ever happened to traitors in minorities area, happened to those in Igboland. But I guess ignoring those in Igboland while magnifying those in Minorities area is an easier way of promoting the propaganda of Igbos forcing Minorities Into Biafra that Awolowo, Enahoro and Ayida were running, rather than taking the harder option of UN supervised plebiscite Ojukwu and Effiong were proposing to put the propaganda to test, right? I think I should rest on this thread for now. I am getting bored of all this argumentI am sure you will be back. Anything to keep Nigeria united so that you can exploit all, eh? |
horsepower102:The (COR) area is far from homogenous , and many of the other tribes expressed at least as much fear of the Efiks and Ibibios as of the Ibo. It would leave the Ibos of the Ibo Plateau surrounded by a state whose reason for existence was hostility to themselves: the Ibos are an expanding people…” See the bold. |
YorubaHero12:What are you on about. Eastern region left as a whole and chose the name Biafra which by the way was suggested by an Ijaw member of Eastern region an Ijaw man by the name Frank Opigo. If the oil was in Eastern region, then it was in Biafra when Biafra seceeded. Seaport and crude oil were never major agenda when they were already in Eastern region. How can what is already in your region be a major agenda, does it make sense to you? If they were an agenda, they were to Yoruba and their Northern partners. Ojukwu and Effiong was open to UN and OAU suppervised plebiscite on the minorities areas. Gowon and Awolowo knew what the result would have been and backed down. But rather decided to continue using military force why telling the world The Igbos were cornering Minorities oil against Minorities wish. Even Saro Wiwa admitted during his trial when he was facing death that majority of his Ogoni people were against him and were rather for Biafra. It was after the war that Saro Wiwa won them back. It's nice for Ijaws to sing of Boro. But Boro wasn't the Ijaw leader those days. The likes of Frank Opigo, and many Ijaw chiefs were with Biafra. It's hard to tell the truth this days in these areas because Biafra lost. Dokubo is from Buguma and openly admitted that his grandfather the then king of Buguma was pro Biafra. British intelligence noted that only 1/3 of the Minorities would have voted against Biafra if a referendum were conducted. I had posted it here before. So when you say Biafra was relying on minorities crude oil and seaports to survive, you make it seem like those minorities were not part and parcel of this Biafra you are taking about too. "In an authoritative and detailed memorandum on the background, cause and consequences of the Nigerian civil war issued in November 1968 by more than sixty British subjects, including Sir Robert Stapleton, the last British governor of the Eastern region( 1959-60), it was concluded that of the 37 percent of the population which they estimated that minority group represented in Biafra, only 10% would favour continued association with the federal government". The. New York review of Books, Volume 14,Number 8. April 23, 1970 "The unprecedented mingling of all groups and settling of many minority people in the Ibo heartland during the course of the war was simply taken for granted. Nonetheless, the Biafran regime was unreservedly committed to plebiscites in any disputed areas within Biafra, or on borders, so that people involved could determine their allegiance. It was proposed that these plebiscites be conducted under international( UN or O.A.U)supervision, and with adequate safeguard against punitive retaliation The federal government rejected the plebiscite proposal, obviously because it implied the recognition of Biafra and the substitution of a democratic vote for force of arms. Had the plebiscite been held, a ceasefire would have had to be declared, neutral observers would have been on scene, and the secession would have been revealed as a people's movement". The New York Review of Books, Volume 14, Number 8. April 23,1970.
|
Some weeks back on one of your posts I made a rebuttal about the erroneous and mischievous rants of some of my (our) misinformed Niger Delta brothers. First and foremost let me tell you all a little story for the avoidance of doubt. I am from the Agbo ethnic group in Cross River State. We are located in Abi Local Government Area which is a coastal settlement and unarguably the smallest LGA in Cross River State in terms of landmass and to a large extent population - slightly a few thousands ahead of Bakassi LGA. My fore bearers both on my maternal and paternal side were given the opportunity to serve in then Eastern Nigeria regional government. My grand uncle Dr.S E Imoke of blessed memory was an all influential cabinet minister in the regime of Dr M I Okpara. He held the Trade portfolio and was also Finance minister at the time until the unfortunate incident of January 1966. He was the longest serving Education minister. His son the Urbane Liyel Imoke is the immediate past Governor of our state “Cross River”. During the outbreak of the war, he was the Biafran Commissioner for Refugees and Humanitarian affairs. One of my maternal uncles also served as Permanent Secretary in the ministry of health at Enugu. My maternal grand father was also a front-line member of the Eastern Nigeria regional house of Chiefs. Outside my family circles, another great Cross Riverian M T Mbu was nominated a Federal Minister for Transport and Navy by the Igbo controlled NCNC. It's on record that Mbu was Nigeria's first Ambassador to the UK, UN and the USA. He is from Boki in Cross River state. Boki is another minority ethnic group just like my native Agboland. The Igbos gave him the opportunity to excel ahead of their own worthy sons at that time. He is the father to a Senator MT Mbu jr. Another person who is noteworthy is the late Chief Michael Eta-Ogon who was the Administrator of the oil rich Port Harcourt province in the first republic. He is also from the same Boki with Mbu. Thomas Weir Ikpeme an Efik man from Odukpani in my native Cross River was the longest serving Permanent Secretary in the Eastern Regional Ministry of Education. The key point is that the Igbos were comfortable with us “the minorities” that was why they entrusted education solely in our hands. Not only education but other critical areas like Public Works and Transport etc. N. U Akpan an Ibibio man from Akwa Ibom state was the technocrat behind the eastern regional public service. He was the Secretary to the regional governement Thompson Akpabio, an Annang man from Ukana in present day Akwa Ibom state was the regional minister of health. The former Governor of Akwa Ibom state Godswill Akpabio is his nephew. There were other high ranking cabinet ministers of minority origin like one of our family good friends, HRH Amanyanabo E P Okoya, Agada III the Ibenanowei of Ekpetiama in Bayelsa State, Chief. Erekosinma of Rivers and a whole lot of others who are too numerous to mention. During the secessionist struggle, an Ogoni from Rivers state, Chief.Ignatius Kogbara was Biafra's Ambassador to Britain. My dad's friend Chief. Lekam Okoi, from Idomi in present day Yakurr LGA of Cross River state was one of Ojukwu's trusted drivers. He is today a successful lawyer and a former commissioner in the Federal Character Commission. Capt Akpet a minority from Cross River was also Ojukwu's dependable aide on intelligence. Secondly for the avoidance of doubt, aside these political appointments, our people enjoyed immense goodwill from the Igbo dominated region by way of My dad's immediate elder brother received a scholarship from the regional government that enabled him study for a PhD in soil science. He is the first man “arguably” in Africa to obtain a doctorate in Soil science. I have friends across the Niger Delta whose parents, uncles, aunties and relatives also benefited from the benevolence of the Eastern regional government. Unarguably our Niger Delta region received it's last major face-lift in terms of infrastructure when we were under the Eastern region. Till the abolition of the regional system of government, the Eastern region was the most united region, they was never a recorded case of ethnic skirmish or BLOOD letting between the Igbos and other minority. During the pogrom of 1966 we all carried the same cross to “Golgotha”, both Igbos and Eastern minorities were killed in their thousands across Northern Nigeria by the blood thirsty Hausa Fulani/Northern folks without blinking an eye. It doesn't really matter if you were Igbo, Ijaw, Efik or a miniature Agbo person. I never really wanted to bore you with reading this lengthy essay but it's my moral responsibility to tell the truth at all times. I was thought by my fore bearers never to distort history and to always separate facts from fictions. If we were not marginalized by the Igbos during the “analogue” age, how then can the Igbos marginalize us in this digital https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.legit.ng/amp/1092790-opinion-why-igbos-never-marginalize-minorities-by-rex-egbe.html |
From the Willink report. It's obvious why COR movement wouldn't have succeeded without a military fiat. 1. Eastern region was run on equity, justice and fairness. All minorities were given sense of belonging. They could complain of Igbo domination, but there was no truth to it. Every single Eastern region appointment and projects, always reflected 1/3 population representation of the minorities. They were never cheated. 2. NCNC had many minority heavy weights who were part and parcel of Zik inner cycle. They knew the party was never tribal. Mbu, Akpan, Imoke, Akpabio. They knew the truth and were always going to keep the East united. 3. In as much as the minorities were scared of Igbo domination, they were scared of Each other too. The Ikwerre, Etches, Ogba, Abua, in Rivers province were weary of Ijaw domination if they joined Ijaws to form Rivers. They were lukewarm to the agitation. Likewise the minorities in Ogoja (Northern Cross River) were scared of Efik/Ibibio domination. It cancelled out their fear of Igbo domination and stagnated the COR movement. |
WILLINK REPORT 1958 THE FOLLOWING ARE EXCERPTS FROM A THE REPORT OF THE COMMISSION APPOINTED TO “ENQUIRE INTO THE FEARS OF MINORITIES AND THE MEANS OF ALLAYING THEM”, OTHERWISE KNOWN AS “THE WILLINK COMMISSION REPORT OF JULY 1958” January 4, 2014 News 727 Views THE HISTORICAL AND POLITICAL BACKGROUND. 1. “More than 98% of people who inhabit this area (the ‘Ibo Plateau’ of the Eastern region) are Ibo and speak one language, though of course with certain differences of dialect. There are nearly five million of them and they are too many for the soil to support: they are vigorous and intelligent and have pushed outward in every direction, seeking a livelihood by trade or in service in the surrounding areas of the Eastern Region, in the Western Region, in the North and outside Nigeria. They are no more popular with their neighbours than is usual in the case of an energetic and expanding people whose neighbours have a more leisurely outlook on life.” 2. “Though there has been no great kingdom or indigenous culture in the Eastern Region, the coastal chiefs grew on their trade with the (European merchant) ships and they adopted customs, clothing and housing more advanced than those of the peoples of the interior on whom they had at first preyed for slaves. They came during the 19th Century to regard the people of the interior as backward and ignorant, and it was therefore a blow to their pride, as well as to their pockets, when the Ibos began to push outwards into the surrounding fringe of the country and particularly into the Calabar area, to take up land, to grow rich, to own houses and lorries and occupy posts in public services and in the services of large trading firms.” “It was among the Ibos, formerly despised by the people of Calabar as source of slaves and as a backward people of the interior, now feared and disliked as energetic and educated, that the first political party formed.” 3. “It is important to remember that of this (Ogoja) Province’s 1,082,000 inhabitants, 723,000 are Ibos, almost entirely in Abakaliki and Afikpo (Divisions), while the census classifies 350,000 as “Other Nigerian Tribes.” 4. The Rivers Province …includes the two divisions of Brass and Degema, both overwhelmingly Ijaw, and the Ogoni Division. The former Rivers Division also includes over 300,000 Ibos of whom 250,000 are in Ahoada Division and 45,000 in Port Harcourt. Port Harcourt is a town of recent growth and of rapidly increasing importance; it is built on land that blonged originally to an outlying branch of the Ibo tribe, the Diobus, but is largely inhabited by the Ibos from the interior who have come to trade or seek employment….Of the total 747,000 in the Rivers province, 305,000 are Ibos, 240,000 are Ijaws and 156,000 are Ogonis.” 5. “The strip to the south of the Ibo block, is physically, divided by a block of Ibo territory, tipped by the important Ibo town of Port Harcourt and tribally divided between the Ijaws and the Ogonis.” 6. “In the whole of this non-Ibo area there is present in varying degree some fear of being over-run, commercially and politically, by the Ibos….. if Ahoada and Port Harcourt, which are really Ibo, are considered with the solid centre of Ibo population, there are 54 seats for the Ibo area and 30 for COR (Calabar, Ogoja and Rivers) in (Eastern Regional House of Assembly).” THE FEARS AND GRIEVANCES OF MINORITIES 7. “It was suggested (by non-Ibo petitioners) that it was the deliberate object of the Ibo majority in the Region to fill every post with Ibos (in public post and services).….when, however we came to consider specific complaints about the composition of public bodies, we found them in many cases exaggerated or unreasonable.” 8. “The allegation was put forward by counsel (to petitioners) that the Judiciary (when not European) was predominantly Ibo, with the implication that this caused fear among those who are not Ibos. But it was clearly stated in evidence by Dr. Udoma, the leader of UNIP, that no occasion could be adduced of the judiciary acting with partiality. The fact is that the legal profession is largely Ibos and the reasons for this do not seem to be Government action. It is therefore inevitable that there should be an Ibo preponderance among Judges and Magistrates. Further, it is the declared policy of Government that the Judiciary should be federal and this does not indicate a desire to control it. Again, the operation and composition of Public Service Commission here, as in the West, appeared to us in no way open to reproach.” 9. “In the Police, which in this region alone is wholly Federal, the number of Ibos in the higher appointments is not out of proportion to the Ibos in the region. The force is now federally controlled and although there are a large number of Ibos in the lower ranks, this is due to the fact that it has for long been a tradition among the Ibos to offer themselves for recruitment in this force in far greater numbers than any other tribe.” 10. “we noted that in five years, 1952 – 1957, from a total of 412 secondary scholarships, 216 were awarded to persons living in the COR areas, while the figures for post-secondary scholarships were 211 out of 623. The latter is about the right proportion of one-third, the former considerably in excess. It was suggested that scholarships awarded to non-Ibos were of an inferior kind and that the best scholarships went to Ibos, but we were, unable to see that this claim held any validity. On the evidence before us, we conclude that the allegations of discriminations in the matter of scholarships are unjustified.” 11. “It was further suggested that loans by the Eastern Regional Finance Corporation, the Eastern Region Development Board, and the Eastern Region Development Corporation were made with some degree of preference to Ibos. It did appear that most of the loans made by these bodies were to Ibos, but that is not to say that this was necessarily improper. Ibos constitute two thirds of the population of the region and have a bigger share of financial and commercial responsibility than their numbers warrant.” 12. “That there should be modern streetlight in Onitsha, and not Calabar, was also quoted as example of discrimination; it proved however that Onitsha Urban District Council had financed this measure from their own resources.” 13. “The question of land was repeatedly raised, it being resented by the Efiks and Ibibios that the Ibos should acquire land at all in their territory while the methods by which it was obtained were also questioned. There is no doubt that on the Ibo Plateau there is insufficient land for the people and the Ibos ate thrusting outwards where possible they acquire land and use it either for cultivation or building…..This is a matter which will require legislation sooner or later and it will be delicate to handle, but the economic process is in itself healthy and we had little sympathy with a witness who remarked that there is much undeveloped land in district and he was anxious that it should not fall into the hand of the Ibos….We believe that Governments in Nigeria should be careful not to try to protect minorities by introducing measures that would restrict development.” 14. “A group of miscellaneous grievances and charges against the Ibos from Calabar may be treated together; we were told that the Ibos did not observe local customs in the markets….We formed the impression that jealousy of the Ibos successes in the markets was the main factor.” THE PROPOSAL FOR NEW STATES 15. “The Ogoja state proposed to us would include former Ogoja province, whose population of slightly more than One million include more than 700,000 Ibos…the main intention would be separation from the central body of Ibo population, but in which they will still be linked together with as a minority with their Ibo neighbours in Abakaliki and Afikpo…A majority of evidence we heard from Ogoja was direct that they preferred the present situation to any association with Calabar and that they were at least as much afraid of domination by Efiks and Ibibios as by Ibos.” 16. “The (Calabar, Ogoja and Rivers or COR) state proposed would consist of Calabar, Rivers and Ogoja provinces excluding the two Ibo Divisions of Abakaliki and Afikpo. The population of this area is 2,649,000 and the following would be the five largest tribes: Ibibio 717,000 Annang 435,000 Ibo 428,000 Ijaw 251,000 Ogoni 156,000 As already explained, the small but important Efik tribe of 71,000…The (COR) area is far from homogenous , and many of the other tribes expressed at least as much fear of the Efiks and Ibibios as of the Ibo. It would leave the Ibos of the Ibo Plateau surrounded by a state whose reason for existence was hostility to themselves: the Ibos are an expanding people…” 17. “The area claimed for Rivers state consists of the whole of the Rivers province, that is: The Division of Brass, Degema, Ogoni, Port Harcourt and Ahoada, together with the Western Ijaw Division from the western region, and two small sections in the Eastern Region from outside the Rivers Province, Opodo and Andoni being one, Ndoki the other.” 18. “Port Harcourt is an Ibo town and it is growing rapidly and the indigenous branch of the Ibos who are original inhabitants are already out-numbered by Ibos from the hinterland.” 19. “The people of Ahoada, a Division of which a pan runs down to meet Port Harcourt, appear at one time to have favoured the idea of a Rivers state, but have changed their views and before us expressed themselves as strongly against it. Comparatively few of them live in the low-lying swampy country of the coastal strip and they have voted for the NCNC consistently, they said themselves that a main factor in their change of front had been the inclusion if the Western Ijaws in the proposed state. So long, they said, as the Rivers state was to consist of the River Province only, the Ibos would have been the most numerous tribe within it: but the inclusion of the Western Ijaw Division put them at a numerical disadvantage beside the Ijaws and they therefore preferred to stay out. Whether or not this was a line of reasoning that really had a wide appeal, the fact remain that before us they were opposed to the idea of the state. This is not surprising because their problems are different from those of the ijaws.” 20. “To include within a River state Ahoada and Port Harcourt, would, we believe, create a problem as acute as that with which we were asked to deal at present and and would be sharply resented by the Ibos of the central plateau.” |
The COR movement was a movement for the creation of separate minority region from the then Igbo majority Eastern region by some members of the Eastern region minorities . Its an acronym for Calabar-Ogoja-Rivers, representing the minorities provinces in the now defunct Eastern region of Nigeria. The Eastern region existed between 1939 to 1966. In its composition were Igbos, Ijaws, Ibibio, Annang, Ejagham, Oro, Agbo, Boki, Ugep, Ogoja, Ogoni, etc. It was estimated that minorities on the whole constituted roughly 1/3 of the population of the region, while Igbos constituted 2/3 of the region total population. The relationship between the Igbos and the minorities were relatively peaceful but not without intrigues. There were often innate fears and cries of Igbo domination by significant members of the minorities who usually called for creation of a minority region from the Eastern region. These demands led the colonial government to constitute the Willink commission of 1957 whose aim was to look into the grievances of the minorities and offer a recommendation. The report of this commission can be found below this post. The commission found no real marginalization of the minorities and maintained that Igbos have been fair in their dealings with the minorities, all the accusations brought to the commission by the minorities were found to have no substance and were dismissed. The commission noted that division of the Eastern region was not necessary. Nevertheless, the yearnings of the minorities for a separate existence outside Igbo area of influence never died. It gathered pace once more when having lost out in Lagos, NCNC members found a way to replace Eyo Ita with Zik as the leader of the Eastern government. The aggrieved Eyo Ita left NCNC with both his Igbo and non Igbo supporters and founded a new party where he lost the elections to NCNC. However, rather than concede defeat, Eyo Ita embraced and vitalized the COR movement in retaliation. This rattled the Eastern region, but with NCNC party loyalists from COR areas like Mbu, Akpan, Ibanga Akpabio, Imoke against Eyo Ita, he soon ran out of steam and conceded defeat, while admitting that the people from COR didn't really want separation from the Eastern region. Eyo Ita would later reconcile his differences with Zik and rejoined the NCNC. To know more about Eyo ita saga :https://www.nairaland.com/2730983/see-no-wisdom-south-south/3 Appended to this post is a copy of Eyo Ita statement on his resignation from championing the COR movement. This was sourced from Chibuzo Ihuoma collections via his blog:
|
YorubaHero12:Never did I claim that SE was feeding the minorities. My point was that SE between Coal and palm oil, contributed the most to the region. And it couldn't have been said that the region depended on Niger Delta crude oil wealth which only came on board in 1958. You were the one that wanted to create the impression of minorities feeding Igbos in Eastern region. The report you posted was more about ENDC effort to improve Eastern region palm oil export which concentrated more on places with more Empty lands with room for improvement of plantations. Owerri and Onitsha are major production belts yet not mentioned in the report. Abakaliki was never a major palm oil belt, but because the population density was low, ENDC was looking to start palm oil plantations there too. The report you posted never provided stats on output contributions of each province , so I don't know what to make of it. If you subtract what only Lagos take from the allocation and the rest of 5 SW States in.comparison to what SE receive, Ondo crude oil contributions become low. And lets not forget that while Abia and Imo crude oil wells were ceded to Rivers state(Egbema and Oyigbo) by dubious boundary adjustment program, Delta state crude oil wells were dubiously ceded to Ondo state by OBJ administration. Lagos still robes Niger Delta till today, too many oil servicing companies are still headquartered in Lagos paying taxes to Lagos state government. |
YorubaHero12:Don't worry, your lies will be busted. I will also make a thread on the COR movement and why it died a natural death. With Eyo Ita letter withdrawing his support for the movement. The likes of Mbu, Imoke, Akpabio, Akpan, who were core members of NCNC and from COR opposed Eyo Ita and won in the end. But shady Ibadan express way media propaganda would as always spin the story to Igbonize NCNC and present Ndiigbo as the ones who opposed COR creation. Btw, there is nothing like Aro- Calabar. Arochukwu is Igbo and Igbo are not related to Efiks. We are just neighbors. Alvan Ikoku and his son were proud members of Igbo state Union, and Arochukwu was in Umuahia /Bende zone and not Calabar. |
horsepower102:It will be not just one thread. It will be many threads. A series. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 (of 453 pages)