Christianity Etc › Re: Science Disproves Evolution by thehomer: 4:37pm On Feb 15, 2011 |
OLAADEGBU: This is a typical example of how evolutionists use bifurcation, an attempt to claim that there are only two mutually exclusive possibilities, when they may be three or more options. What is your answer? Why don't you present the other options and give your answer at the same time. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Science Disproves Evolution by thehomer: 4:28pm On Feb 15, 2011 |
OLAADEGBU: Infact the correct title is the Preservation of Favoured Races in the Struggle for Life. This title reveals the racist motive behind all the evolution smokescreen. If this is not about the origins of life tell us what your foundation is, unless you are saying that it is to tell us all about the favoured races. You now wish to shift gears to the use of the word "race" in the title of the book. Here you go with a fallacy of equivocation. See here for the various meanings of the word race. You're equivocating between the second and fourth meanings. OLAADEGBU: Again, take my references to a proper library and conduct your own research if you are to get anywhere. I shouldn't have to do that if you properly quote people which is what one is supposed to do. OLAADEGBU: Do you know what the use of ad hominem is? Ad hominem, if you don't know, is directing an argument against the person making the claim rather than the claim itself. Saying that its a joke to learn from AiG is not only using ad hominem but also bluffing. Yes it is a joke as you keep demonstrating with what you generally post. OLAADEGBU: Bluffing again and missing the point. How does that miss the point. It demonstrates that you simply lied in claiming that I never asked for you to demonstrate how you came about those figures. OLAADEGBU: It may be meaningless to you and your evolutionists croonies but not to those with open minds and are ready to learn. To help you understand what we are talking about is that one of the components of life is information. The common factor in all living organisms is the information contained in their cells. Can you tell us, where and how did all this coded information arise, if you know? Tell us how life evolved from lifeless chemicals into a complex cell consisting of vast amounts of information. Explain the source of information and how this information was encoded into the genome, to start with. It is meaningless to anyone who understands how probability figures are applied. What you and your fellows demonstrate is that you do not understand how to use the tool of probability calculations. OLAADEGBU: What it was simply saying is that according to the laws of probability, if the chance of an event occuring is smaller than 1 in 10-50 (which I explained as 1 divided by 1050), then the event will never occur. What is the probability of ever getting one small protein of 100 left handed amino acids? Let me assist you with this, to assemble just 100 left handed amino acids would be the same probability as getting 100 heads in a row, we would have to flip a coin 1030 times (this is 10 x 10, 30 times). This is such an astounding improbability that there would not be enough time in the whole history of the universe, even according to your evolutionary time frames for this to happen. I know what 10 e[sup]-50 means what I'm asking is why that figure? Why not 10 e -40 or 10 e -60? What is the probability of getting 200 atoms of sodium chloride in the formation below? Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na Cl Na It's about 1.6069 e -60. Yet it happens all the time. Note that this is not even up to the 58.5g in my example and this example is in 2 dimensions while the crystal is in three dimensions which means a further reduction in the probability of such an occurrence. OLAADEGBU: I am surprised that you believe that physical laws are non-random, I thought all you propose is about randomness and the game of chance. But who says that physical or natural laws are the limit of what is possible? The biblical God is not bound by physical laws. I never claimed that they were non-random. You need to be consistent. Are the physical laws random or not? OLAADEGBU: You are merely begging the question here by assuming what you are attempting to prove. You say the Bible cannot be true because it contains miracles, and miracles violate the laws of nature. Yes, I agree that miracles can potentially involve a temporary suspension of the laws of nature since my God is beyond the laws of nature, He can suspend them if He wishes to. Because you assume that miracles cannot happen doesn't mean that you are right and the Bible wrong, you are just arguing in a vicious circle. When you are arguing this way you are just being illogical because it goes against your subjective assessment of what is possible. If you say that the Bible is unreasonable can you then tell me what standard you use to arrive at your conclusion? You really do not know what the begging the question fallacy entails. Do you not see that that is what you do each time you call on the Bible as some sort of source of evidence on why any one else should believe it is true? Keep in mind that I have not assumed anything. All I do is demonstrate that as far as we know, the laws are consistent. If you wish to claim that they are not consistent, you need to present evidence for this. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Obama's Unbiblical Declaration by thehomer: 7:46am On Feb 15, 2011 |
OLAADEGBU: An Atheist on a Talk Show
Caller:
"I'm an atheist, and I want to tell you Christians that if you believe Cain married his sister, then that's immoral."
AiG:
"If you are an atheist, then that means you don't believe in any personal God, right?"
Caller:
"Correct!"
AiG:
"Then if you don't believe in God, you don't believe there's such a thing as an absolute authority. Therefore, you believe everyone has a right to their own opinions -- to make their own rules about life if they can get away with it, correct?"
Caller:
"Yes, you're right."
AiG:
"Then, sir, you can't call me immoral; after all, you're an atheist, who doesn't believe in any absolute authority."
AiG:
"Do you believe all humans evolved from apelike ancestors?"
Caller:
"Yes, I certainly believe evolution is fact"
AiG:
"Then, sir, from your perspective on life, if man is just some sort of animal who evolved, and if there's no absolute authority, then marriage is whatever you want to define it to be -- if you can get away with it in the culture you live in."
"It could be two men, two women or one man and ten women; in fact, it doesn't even have to be a man with another human -- it could be a man with an animal."
"I'm sorry, sir, that you think Christians have a problem, I think it's you who has the problem. Without an absolute authority, marriage, or any other aspect of how to live in society, is determined on the basis of opinion and ultimately could be anything one decides -- If the culture as a whole will allow you to get away with this. You have the problem, not me." A poor distraction. Are you unable to respond cogently or have you realized your self contradictions? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Science Disproves Evolution by thehomer: 7:43am On Feb 15, 2011 |
OLAADEGBU: An Atheist on a Talk Show
Caller:
"I'm an atheist, and I want to tell you Christians that if you believe Cain married his sister, then that's immoral."
AiG:
"If you are an atheist, then that means you don't believe in any personal God, right?"
Caller:
"Correct!"
AiG:
"Then if you don't believe in God, you don't believe there's such a thing as an absolute authority. Therefore, you believe everyone has a right to their own opinions -- to make their own rules about life if they can get away with it, correct?"
Caller:
"Yes, you're right."
AiG:
"Then, sir, you can't call me immoral; after all, you're an atheist, who doesn't believe in any absolute authority."
AiG:
"Do you believe all humans evolved from apelike ancestors?"
Caller:
"Yes, I certainly believe evolution is fact"
AiG:
"Then, sir, from your perspective on life, if man is just some sort of animal who evolved, and if there's no absolute authority, then marriage is whatever you want to define it to be -- if you can get away with it in the culture you live in."
"It could be two men, two women or one man and ten women; in fact, it doesn't even have to be a man with another human -- it could be a man with an animal."
"I'm sorry, sir, that you think Christians have a problem, I think it's you who has the problem. Without an absolute authority, marriage, or any other aspect of how to live in society, is determined on the basis of opinion and ultimately could be anything one decides -- If the culture as a whole will allow you to get away with this. You have the problem, not me." The usual load of tripe. Please tell me, is it immoral for a person to marry their sibling? Please answer with a yes or no. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Science Disproves Evolution by thehomer: 7:41am On Feb 15, 2011 |
OLAADEGBU: Your escape clause is always to claim that evolutionary theory has nothing to do with origins, why don't you go read up on Darwin's book on the descent of the origins to see how you've been shooting yourselves in the foot. And here we have a change of scope fallacy. I said the theory says nothing about the origin of life just the diversity of life. You read Darwin's book and present the parts showing this shooting in the foot. OLAADEGBU: All my quotes are in context as I have given their proper references, go to the library and do some research. You need to learn how to quote people so that their ideas come through not what you simply wish them to say. OLAADEGBU: I am used to your tactics of bluffing and the use of Ad hominems to inflate your egos, empty drums sound the loudest. Where did I use this ad hominem? Can you show this? Be careful that you do not tell lies or your God will punish you. OLAADEGBU: All you needed to do was to ask how I came about the figures and not going off on a tangent to calculate what is not relevant to the subject we talking about just to divert the subject at hand, this is typical of evolutionists who have got no clue of what they are talking about. This I had done in my last three posts. Even in the post of mine quoted, read the question in the very first line. Do you not understand what I'm driving at? Do you not know how to calculate probabilities? OLAADEGBU: How does this relate to the issue of the probability of life forming by chance? Do you still not understand that placing probability figures to the formation of life is meaningless and is a poor tactic used by your fellow creationists to deceive gullible fellows like yourself? Assigning probability figures to this occurrence makes no sense. OLAADEGBU: This is what you should be asking instead of going on a wild goose chase. The said figure is equal to 1 divided by 1050 and is very small number. Probability expert Emile Borel wrote, "We may be led to set at 1 to the 50th power the value of negligible probabilities on the cosmic scale." (E. Borel, Probabilities and life, [New York: Dover Publications, 1962], p.28)) Read my previous statements and see that I've asked this several times. What you said above is not an explanation 10 e -400 is an even smaller number so what? My question is how was the figure arrived at? I do not need someone saying it is a small number I want to know how the person decided to use that number an not another. OLAADEGBU: Then tell us if you know anything different. It is a well known fact that physical laws are non-random. OLAADEGBU: It simply means reasoning in a vicious circle. You have decided in advance that there is not an all-powerful God who is capable of doing the things recorded in the Bible, and then you go on to argue on this basis against the biblical God. Such reasoning is not cogent at all. When you accuse the Bible of being illogical because it goes against your subjective assessment of what is possible, it turns out to be that you and not the Bible is the one who is being illogical. You have to tell us by what standard you use to assess the Bible. That is not circular reasoning. An example of circular reasoning would be using the Bible to demonstrate that the Bible is true. So many things are wrong with your statement above. Have you considered that the decision that this all powerful God is absent is due to facts like the logical contradictions of such an entity existing, the historical problems with the Bible and the nature of physical laws? Read more on circular reasoning here. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Bible Questions-1; Did The Bible Endorse Slavery? by thehomer: 12:19am On Feb 15, 2011 |
@pres-elect
One of the most effective ways of turning people away from the Bible is getting them to read it while thinking about what they're reading. Another is getting them to look into the history of the Bible.
Why are you afraid of losing your belief in this Biblical God? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Bible Questions-1; Did The Bible Endorse Slavery? by thehomer: 12:02am On Feb 15, 2011 |
JeSoul: Is this Prez in the religion section?
The bible does not exactly 'endorse' slavery, but it certainly did permit it and instituted standards by which slave owners should treat their slaves. Here's a quick summary quote from CARM (Christian Apologetics Research Ministry, a fantastic website (along with apologeticspress.org) by the way if you're looking for quality christian apologetics on practically any subject) http://carm.org/slavery Slavery was permitted in the Bible because of sin in the world. It existed before the Jews were formed as a nation and it existed after Israel was conquered. God allows many things to happen in the world such as storms, famine, murder, etc. Slavery, like divorce, is not preferred by God. Instead, it is allowed. Where many nations treated their slaves very badly, the Bible gave many rights and privileges to slaves. So, even though it isn't the best way to deal with people, because God has allowed man freedom, slavery then exists. God instructed the Israelites to treat them properly.
The Bible acknowledged the slave's status as the property of the master (Ex. 21:23; Lev. 25:46). This is obviously a crime against humanity. Did God not know that a human owning another human was the one of the worst crimes that could be committed against another person? Did he change his mind or was it humans that decided that such an abominable act was just too debasing to both the slave and the master? [quote author=carm.org]The Bible restricted the master's power over the slave. Ex. 21:20).[/quote]And the next verse? Ex. 21:21 check this out for cruelty. Bible Amp ver: But if the servant lives on for a day or two, the offender shall not be punished, for he [has injured] his own property. Beat him but not enough that he dies after one day or two days? Did God not know whether or not to choose 24 hours or 48? [quote author=carm.org]The slave was a member of the master's household (Lev. 22:11).[/quote]Of course only that he was a slave. [quote author=carm.org]The slave was required to rest on the Sabbath (Exodus 20:10; Deut. 5:14). The slave was required to participate in religious observances (Gen. 17:13; Exodus 12:44; Lev. 22:11).[/quote]i.e the slave was supposed to also observe his master's religion by force. [quote author=carm.org]The Bible prohibited extradition of slaves and granted them asylum (Deut. 23:16-17).[/quote]This has me confused. Does this person remain a slave? Who now owns this slave? [quote author=carm.org]The servitude of a Hebrew debt-slave was limited to six years (Ex. 21:2; Deut. 15:12).[/quote]What sort of moral debasement is this? Here is the quote of the first passage in full context. Bible amp ver: 2If you buy a Hebrew servant [as the result of debt or theft], he shall serve six years, and in the seventh he shall go out free, paying nothing.(A)
3If he came [to you] by himself, he shall go out by himself; if he came married, then his wife shall go out with him.
4If his master has given him a wife and she has borne him sons or daughters, the wife and her children shall be her master's, and he shall go out [of your service] alone.
5But if the servant shall plainly say, I love my master, my wife, and my children; I will not go free,
6Then his master shall bring him to God [the judges as His agents]; he shall bring him to the door or doorpost and shall pierce his ear with an awl; and he shall serve him for life. What sort of supreme, wise and good being will give this as law? To hold a man hostage because he loves his wife and children? The devil himself was not this cruel in the Bible. [quote author=carm.org]When a slave was freed, he was to receive gifts that enabled him to survive economically (Deut. 15:14).[/quote]So that is the payment for the Hebrew slave that didn't happen to be beaten to death shortly before his release. [quote author=carm.org]The reality of slavery cannot be denied. "Slave labor played a minor economic role in the ancient Near East, for privately-owned slaves functioned more as domestic servants than as an agricultural or industrial labor force."1[/quote]This no excuse for it. God could command people not to kill as though they knew no better but he could not command them not to own other people? Yet this God does not change? These Christian apologists should try to be consistent. The Bible clearly endorses slavery i.e people were encouraged to enslave people and the slaves were at the same time encouraged to obey their masters i.e slaves are not supposed to revolt. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Obama's Unbiblical Declaration by thehomer: 11:24pm On Feb 14, 2011 |
OLAADEGBU: Who taught you that, public education? I see you still are unable to present any evidence despite your claim to having some evidence. Are you lying? I thought you already said homosexuals cannot procreate. Have you considered that homosexuals are born in heterosexual households? OLAADEGBU: We will soon find out the moment you agree to taking the test. No we won't. You already implied that it's your fear of punishment that makes you not commit evil acts. You my friend are a dangerous person. OLAADEGBU: The moment you agree to the test you will find out how God decides what sin is. I see no reason why you should attach this to your test. It seems you simply wish to make more excuses for this God of yours. OLAADEGBU: That means you are not interested in knowing the answer to your question.  No. It means the test is useless. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Science Disproves Evolution by thehomer: 11:18pm On Feb 14, 2011 |
OLAADEGBU: There is no escape route for you here, the question of the origin of life or the universe is a very important question because it is tantamont to the very foundation or beginning of the entire evolution worldview. Without a cause there can be no life or explanation of the diversity of life. Real science is different from your so called evolutionary myth. I am not escaping anything. All I'm saying is that the theory of evolution does what it is supposed to do very well. OLAADEGBU: Just admit that you are being lazy and seek to be spoon fed as you are used to. I gave all the necessary references but since you are looking for what to google and you can't find any link you then cry foul. Rubbish. If [b]you [/b]are quoting someone, it is up to [b]you [/b]to quote them fully and in context. OLAADEGBU: I will try my best to break it down for you and I hope that will suffice and if not check up AiG for more details. But let me start with a quote from a Nobel prize-winning scientist George Wald who wrote and I quote: AiG is a joke for someone who actually wishes to learn. To demonstrate this fact to you, I'll happily shred what you present here as an argument. OLAADEGBU: "However improbable we regard this event [evolution], or any of the steps it involves, given enough time, it will almost certainly happen at least once . . . Time is the hero of the plot . . . Given so much time, the impossible becomes possible, the possible becomes probable, the probable becomes virtually certain. One only has to wait; time itself performs miracles." -- G. Wald, "The Origin of Life," Scientific American 191 (August 1994): 45.
When talking about life forming by chance and in the case of protein formation he said "given enough time", this is a fallacious statement which is not valid. When we look at the mathematical probabilities of a small protein assembling by random chance, it is beyond anything that has ever been observed. So, what is the probability of ever getting one small protein of 100 left-handed amino acids?
According to the laws of probability, if the chance of an event occuring is smaller than 1 in 10-50, then the event will never occur. What have real scientists calculated the probability to be of an average-size protein occuring naturally? Lets see the answers given by Walter Bradley, PhD, material science, and Charles Thaxton, PhD, chemistry, who calculated that the probability of amino acids forming into a protein is:
4.9 x 10-191 Not so fast. How did you come up with the figure of 1 in 10 -50 being the threshold for the decision that an event will never occur? Then here's something else for you to think about. What is the calculated probability of a sodium chloride crystal weighing 58.5g to arrange itself in the order below? i.e with one sodium atom surrounded by one chlorine atom? Avogadro's number is approximately 6.02 e 23[img] http://www4.nau.edu/meteorite/Meteorite/Images/Sodium_chloride_crystal.png[/img] To give you an idea of the scale, that crystal will contain approximately 6.02 e 20 molecules i.e 1.202 e 21 ions. Each of them in a particular position without two sodium ions being next to each other. OLAADEGBU: This is well beyond the laws of probability which is 1 x 10-50, and a protein is not even close to becoming a complete living cell. Sir Fred Hoyle, PhD, astronomy, and Chandra Wickramasinghe, professor of applied maths and astronomy, calculated that the probability of getting a cell by naturalistic process is:
1 x 10-40,000 How do you think he performed this calculation? Or are you simply spouting off what you do not understand? OLAADEGBU: So, you can see that no matter how large the environment one considers, life cannot have had a random beginning and the above probability of getting a cell by natural process is an outrageously small probability that could not be faced even if the whole universe consisted of your so called organic or is it primordial soup. Who says life had a random beginning? OLAADEGBU: It is the evolutionists circles of reasoning that are ultimately self defeating. They do not pass their own test. It is what is called "begging the question." Do you understand what the "begging the question fallacy" entails? I do not think it means what you think it means. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Science Disproves Evolution by thehomer: 8:38pm On Feb 14, 2011 |
OLAADEGBU: If evolution is unable to explain the origin of life through naturalistic means, then it has no leg to stand on scientifically, logically, rationally or reasonably and it is without a foundation. No. It does what it is supposed to do extremely well which is to explain the diversity of life. Do you expect the germ theory of disease to explain the origin of the disease causing micro-organisms? OLAADEGBU: I gave references for all the quotes all you need to do is to look them up if you are not lazy. Your references were not good enough and all I was trying to do was to educate you on the proper way of quoting people so that their quotes will not be taken out of context. So, do it right. OLAADEGBU: They are the probabilities that life originated by chance, and again you can check it out. My question was how did you arrive at them? Please show your workings. There is no way for me to check anything out since you're just pulling numbers out of some nether regions. OLAADEGBU: Atheists like you are the ones guilty of what you are accusing Christians of doing. You commit the logical fallacy known as "begging the question." You guys decided in advance that such things as miracles are not possible and thereby tacitly assume that the Bible is not true because it contains miracles, but this is the very assumption with which you began your reasoning. Now tell me, who is guilty of circular reasoning? No. What I'm saying is that using the Bible to say the Bible is true is a fallacious thinking. What miracles do you believe are possible? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Science Disproves Evolution by thehomer: 8:30pm On Feb 14, 2011 |
Martian: Hey homer, all these have been discussed and beaten to death. Prepare to be frustrated, but I know you have more patience than me and you're also a better debater so maybe you can make something click in his brain. I doubt it though. Thanks I'll do what I can. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Obama's Unbiblical Declaration by thehomer: 8:21pm On Feb 14, 2011 |
OLAADEGBU: Not discriminating against homosexuals does not make you an homosexual but actively promoting the lifestyle as an alternative lifestyle would put you in the same category in the eyes of God and man. There is ample evidence to confirm that learning experiences such as seduction, public education, molestation and experimentation lead young people down the path to homosexual behaviour. The homosexual lifestyle is sterile. Therefore, it follows that homosexuals must of necessity, through seduction and public education, recruit their next generation. Can you present this evidence? Do you know that homosexuals discover that they are homosexual while they are with their heterosexual parents? OLAADEGBU: The reasons are glaring, since you have no absolute authority what stops you from living as you are pleased? This is sad. Are you saying that because of your fear of God, you're not out there raping and killing people? Have you considered that I live the way I do for my happiness and that of those around me? OLAADEGBU: Why do you want to know where I got it from, do you want to arrest him? I might consider that. Or you may just be making stuff up. But, how does God decide what a sin is? OLAADEGBU: When you are ready let me know. Not interested. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Torture And Death Of Child 'witches' In Nigeria (akwa-ibom) by thehomer: 7:48pm On Feb 14, 2011 |
This the sort of rubbish that I read that makes my blood boil. This is one of the reasons why I simply have to keep fighting superstitious thinking by facing its most prevalent form which is religion.
I ask those Christians reading this, do witches exist? If yes to the above, what is to be done when one is discovered? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Drop Your Prayer Requests Here. We Pray, God Answers: Always! by thehomer: 7:37pm On Feb 14, 2011 |
Can you give us some information on the types of prayers that God answers? Because I'm thinking of praying for Pluto to to move in and become a moon for Venus. Do you think he'll answer? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Happy Valentine by thehomer: 7:31pm On Feb 14, 2011 |
Blueice4re: Do you know that Julius Ceaser fought for love, Romeo and Juliet died for love, Macbeth killed for love, Adam ate the fruit for love and most of all Christ Died for love ,he gave up for love. so what can you do to show that you love someone to day. please show love to everyone today and for ever Amen. HAPPY VAL TO YOU ALL. Adam ate the fruit for love? I thought he was deceived and this was why women had to suffer to bear children (until the arrival of modern medicine which effectively nullifies God's punishment at its worst for those who can afford it). Did Jesus die for love or did he commit suicide knowing that he will resurrect and float up into heaven? Was it really love or was it the command of his father God? Happy Valentine's Day to you all. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Stop & Think: Did God Create Any Religion? by thehomer: 7:27pm On Feb 14, 2011 |
Of course He did. He created mine. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Science Disproves Evolution by thehomer: 7:25pm On Feb 14, 2011 |
OLAADEGBU: @Martian and other evolutionists out there,
Since you are not forthcoming about the origin of life since you have no scientific evidence, let me assist you in making up your mind and answering the question at the same time. There can only be two possible origins for life, and these are:
1. Life evolved by natural processes as you have stated above; or 2. Life was created by an intellectual source, who I believe is God, the uncreated Creator as I have stated regarded the creation of the universe.
The first option comes from your evolutionary theory which believes the earth was formed about 4.6 billion years ago (even though you said 17 billion years ago) and after many million of years after it was formed chemicals somehow was formed in a "primordial soup", and after many more million of years chemicals bonded together to form molecules and after millions of years molecules bonded together to make a living cell. What a well thought out fairytale and dogma to believe. This according to the evolutionary myth means time and chance combined to form life. That is, something exploded, formed a full pool of chemicals, and duala!! here you are. The theory of the goo to zoo to you presented as science to be believed 
The Miller experiment even tried to similulate the building blocks of life in the 1950's but what the textbooks did'nt tell you was that Miller did not use oxygen and that he got the wrong type of amino acids for life and that the whole process was not left to chance it benefitted from his wealth of scientific knowledge.
Miller left oxygen out of the experiment because he knew that in the presence of oxygen life cannot start. He knew that oxygen was necessary to sustain life but is detrimental to the origin of life. But there is overwhelming evidence that this planet always had free standing oxygen in the atmosphere.
This quote taken from The Mystery of Life's Origin, 1992, p.80. by Thaxton (Ph.D. Chemistry), Bradley (Ph.D. Materials Science), Olsen (Ph.D. Geochemistry), states that:
"The only trend in the recent literature is the suggestion of far more oxygen in the early atmosphere than anyone imagined".
Since life cannot start on land due to oxygen neither can it start in the ocean because of hydrolysis can you explain how life started?
There are about 2,000 different types of amino acids out there but only 20 types are used in life. This means that life is very selective. Amino acids come in two shapes: the right handed amino acids and the left handed amino acids this is so because they are mirror images of each other. Just as you have your right and left hands(fingers), they are similar but different. There are no right handed amino acids in our bodies, in every amino acids and in every protein in your body you will only find the left handed type of amino acids, this fact has been left out of the textbooks in schools just because they want to promote this evolution propaganda and this is what I call the half truth and half false philosophy that has been used to deceive the masses.
What is the probability that life could have originated by chance?
[list] [li]The Law of Probability is 10-50 (anything more than this would be considered mathematically impossible)
The probability of the origin of protein is: 10-191
The probability of a cell is: 10-40,000[/li] [/list]
Let’s listen to what seasoned scientists say about probability and life:
- Bernard Lovell (Ph.D. Astronomy), In the Centre of Immensities – “effectively zero” - Francis Crick, Life Itself: Its Origin and Nature – “can never have been synthesized at all, at any time” - Robert Gange, Ph.D. (research in the field of cryophysics and information systems.), Origins and Destiny – “Zero”
What have they got to say on origin of Life:
Johnjoe McFadden (Evolutionist & Professor of Molecular Biology and Quantum Physics), Quantum Evolution, 200, pg. 85.
"The simplest living cells could not have arisen by chance. Just like the eye, the proto-cell must have evolved from simpler ancestral cells, presumably by a process of "natural selection". But this is where the first big problem with the origin of life arises. What were those simpler entities?"
Franklin M. Harold, Professor of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology at Colo. State University, The Way of the Cell, 2001, pg, 235.
"The origin of life is also a stubborn problem, with no solution in sight . . ., "
With all these answers from evolutionist scientists themselves we can then conclude that : If evolution is unable to explain the origin of life through naturalistic means, then it is without a foundation. Now that we have an understanding of the foundation of evolution. Why is evolution without a foundation? Because there is no natural process that can cause life to originate.
Why should I accept evolution when you cannot produce the evidence? I already have a faith. Tell me about your faith and I will tell you about my faith.
Therefore, it is not only rational but also reasonable to believe that God, not unknown magical events, created life. QED
The Bible which is the solid foundation declares:
"For by Him were all things created, that are in heaven, and that are in earth, visible and invisible, whether they be thrones or dominions or principalities or powers: all things were created by Him, and for him." -- Colossians 1:16 God created all life. God created all things by Jesus Christ. -- Gen.1:1; Colossians1:15-18, 20; John 1:3; Ephesians 3:9; Heb.1:1-2; 11:3; There are several things that you need to note. Attacking evolution does not make your claim any more true. Evolution does not speak about the origin of life. You need to be careful about quote mining. It is better to present the quote in full and in proper context. The probability figures you're giving are simply imaginary. Please present the basis for these probabilities. Using the Bible to claim the Bible is true is no better than using the Qur'an to demonstrate that the Qur'an is true. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Science Disproves Evolution by thehomer: 7:19pm On Feb 14, 2011 |
OLAADEGBU: . . . .
Some top and highly qualified Hebrew scholars, who are called lexigraphers wrote in the most widely recognised Hebrew lexicons and dictionaries, published in the 20th century says that the creation days written in the book of Genesis are literal days.
Below is a partial list of scientists who believe in the Bible's account of creation as is recorded in the Bible and through their professional fields have come to the scientific conclusion that confirms the Bible's account:
Danny Faulkner Ph.D. Astronomy John Byl Ph.D. Astronomy Tom Greene Ph.D. Astronomy James Dire Ph.D. Astrophysics Dave Harrison Ph.D. Astrophysics Steven Boyd Ph.D. Hebraic and Cognitive Studies Floyd Nolen Jones Th.D., Ph.D. Author of Chronology of the Old Testament Herb Hirt Ph.D. Biblical Exposition Robert Cole Ph.D. Semitic languages Brown-Driver-Briggs Lexicon Georgia Purdon Ph.D. Molecular Genetics Duane Gish Ph.D. Biochemistry David Menton Ph.D. Cell Biology Donald Chittick Ph.D. Physical Chemistry Tom Greene Ph.D. Astronomy Jason Lisle Ph.D. Astrophysics Russell Humphreys Ph.D Physics Don DeYoung Ph.D. Physics Terry Mortenson Ph.D. History of Geology John baumgardner Ph.D. Geophysics Bob Compton Ph.D. Physiology, DVM Andy McIntosh Ph.D. Combustion Theory John Johnson Ph.D. Mathematics Tommy Mitchel M.D. Andrew Snelling Ph.D. Geology Emil Silvestre Ph.D. Geology Esther Su Ph.D. Biochemistry David DeWitt Ph.D. Neuroscience Have you heard of Project Steve? It has collected the names of eminent scientists named Steve who agree with the theory of evolution. Read more here and here. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Obama's Unbiblical Declaration by thehomer: 7:08pm On Feb 14, 2011 |
OLAADEGBU: Who knowing the judgment of God, that they which commit such things are worthy of death, not only do the same, but have pleasure in them that do them (Romans 1:29-32)
Did you know that aiding and abetting is also a criminal offence? I notice your shift in scope but this is not what I'm talking about. I asked if not discriminating against people who were homosexual would mean that the person was also homosexual. OLAADEGBU: All these measures and more such as experimentation are implemented so as to populate the LGBT's community. This is just a lie. And I noticed how you have tried to evade simple questions. OLAADEGBU: Of cause I do know where I got it from but the reason why I quoted it is for you to know that God loves the sinner but hates the sin. Where did you get it from? How does God decide what is a sin? OLAADEGBU: Are you prepared to answer a little quiz so as to ascertain whether you are sinful or not? Nah I won't waste my time doing that. You're free to take your quiz though. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 7:02pm On Feb 14, 2011 |
Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> yes (to both your questions) >>> however your claimed fallacies are baseless because I presented a satire What part of your statement was satire? Please read this link and let me know the part of your statement that was satire. Uyi Iredia: and yes, I think the said quote is a proper analogy Then why did you claim I was committing a fallacy? Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> I did that by showing you what I meant when I said man is the measure of all things >>> and I wanted you to clarify what I meant >>> understand my position b4 you counter it When you make a statement, it is up to you to clarify what you mean. I can only demonstrate what I think you mean. Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> and you equivocate by assuming my posit that man is the measure of all things to mean >>> truth is contigent upon human minds >>> that was is the error u made that I am correcting That is not an equivocation. Also, that is a reasonable interpretation of what you're saying. And note that you are yet to clarify what you meant while being able to grasp what I understood from your sentence. Uyi Iredia: *4 >>> yes, inner significance >>> if a person does not beleve in a truth (statement) no matter how real or obvious it is >>> it is of no consequence to the person (whether the truth is true or not) When you say something is of "no consequence", what do you mean? If person A were to go out and shoot person B to death, would the gunshot wound to person B be of consequence to person B? Uyi Iredia: *5 >>> this is a fallacy of irrelevance (argumentum ad hominem) >>> this is not the reply that is apt to my question You are making the same error that I've pointed out to you several times and you have still failed to take correction. When you claim a person has committed a fallacy, you need to show the statement and how it is a fallacy. Uyi Iredia: *6 >>> what is your reason for this ? My reason for the term applying to cultural Christians is that they incorporate elements of a theistic religion without being theist or religious theists for that matter >>> I brought that link as a reply to your quip abou irreligious theist on this topic >>> BTW deists are irreligious >>> so there goes your set (into the dustbin) *make an asinine claim that deists are otherwise and I'll call DeepSight to whoop your butt* Is it not obvious that cultural Christians may not be theists making that link irrelevant? You're free to call on whomever you wish. So the set of people outside of religion may be both theist and atheist. You may note that even from the origin of this part of the discussion, you already agreed with me you may review it here #137Uyi Iredia: *7 >>> yes I have Where? This was all you wrote. Uyi Iredia: *7 >>> i have treated that below Uyi Iredia: *8 >>> your accusation equivocated my definition of belief to mean "the acceptance of a thing as factual" >>> whereas I defined belief as "the acceptance of a thing" Again, that was not an equivocation. Read the meaning of the word on Wiktionary here. You're free to look up its meaning in other dictionaries. You may note that one consistent fact is that the holder thinks that their belief is true. And I ask you again, are you saying that a person cannot hold false beliefs? Uyi Iredia: *9 >>> they are presented as (and predicated upon) truth statements but THEY ARE NOT truth statements >>> since a logical contradiction can be believed >>> why do you expect logic to apply to beliefs ? >>> you do that and you equivocate on the meaning of beliefs (refer to point eight ) I never said they were truth statements. The reason why I referred you to logic tables is that if they can be presented as truth statements, then the laws of logic can be used in their clarification. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 9:09pm On Feb 13, 2011 |
Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> this is a strawman attack and a farce >>> your fallacy doesn't apply to my original statement which was presented as 'a skit to put my thoughts in focus' (in other words, a satire)
*2 >>> my stance is that your fallacy does not apply to what I intended as satire >>> how is this false ? It seems you have sunk to outright lying. Please answer these with a yes or no. Were you referring to Socrates as an authority? Is this phrase "to roll over in a grave" an idiomatic expression in the English Language or not? Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> this is not a proper answer >>> this is because the meaning of your comment is not clear to me (except for the fact that you bother yourself over my semantics) Please answer this with a yes or no. Do you think the quote below is an analogy? Uyi Iredia: . . . "Hey ! Uyi, darkness can shine forth" . . . Uyi Iredia: *4 >>> my replies are as follows
to your 1st comment >>> this is a strawman attack >>> you simply need to clarify what is meant when I say man is the measure of all things Wow. You are again making another accusation without presenting your evidence. Could you please demonstrate the "strawman attack" I made. You now also want me to clarify your own words? Are you listening to yourself? Uyi Iredia: >>> my interpretation of this famous posit is that the comprehension (measure) of truth varies by the person >>> allow me to use your talk of water to clarify this >>> water means different things to different people to the chemist, H20 to a man dying of thirst, a means of survival to the seafarer, a means of transport to the fisherman, the promise of income It seems you wish to go with an equivocation fallacy here. When we speak of water, we're referring to a particular compound that is available whether or not there are humans. You on the other hand wish to refer to its chemical properties and its value to people. This is a bad method of evasion. What I'm asking is would water be water whether or not humans were present? (Please answer with a yes or no.) Uyi Iredia: to your second comment >>> this again is false when my statement is clarified >>> by essence (in the context of the said posit) I mean inner significance >>> I do not mean that truth will act out according to the caprices of a person >>> I mean that it is of NO AUTHORITY TO THE PERSON who does not believe (accept) it
>>> to use your example to clarify >>> if one believes that death by decapitation can be survived he can inquire scientifically as to means to avoid death by decapitation Oh? Inner significance? Here, you are again evading while agreeing with me that whether or not the person believes, the person will die therefore, it is of essence just that the person actively chooses to think otherwise whether due to ignorance, deception or anything else. Uyi Iredia: *5 >>> make your point My point is that you agree with me but simply wish to be evasive yet again. Uyi Iredia: *6 >>> this is the fallacy "extending the argument" (you overstate someone's point) >>> I said the term irreligious theist CAN APPLY to cultural Christians I know cultural Christian can apply to them since Western European and North American Christians are also cultural Christians but, have you not yet realized that this category does not falsify my set demonstrated here #137? A cultural Christian is not an irreligious theist. Uyi Iredia: >>> you were the one who first brought up the 'absurd notion' >>> I did not say word-for-word, or imply, that Dawkins is an irreligious theist Yes you did. Remember that you brought up the term and pointed a link to the Wikipedia article in which he was mentioned. I wonder if you read that article. Uyi Iredia: *7 >>> i have treated that below No you haven't. Uyi Iredia: *8 >>> my definition of belief is THE ACCEPTANCE of a thing (including truth, semantic values and truth statements) >>> IMHO saying that 'the acceptance of a thing' can be true or not true is absurd I never said this. Besides, think again about what you're implying here. Are you saying that a person cannot hold false beliefs? Uyi Iredia: Your explication makes sense if you remove belief and put in (truth) statement >>> I put truth in bracket so you realize that a statement is used to capture a truth (a statement is not in itself the truth) >>> see it Beliefs can be generally presented as truth statements. Uyi Iredia: note that, one can believe (accept) a logical contradiction Yes I know. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 5:03pm On Feb 12, 2011 |
Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> answer to your question >>> no
>>> You make a faulty deduction >>> your fallacy fails to apply given the fact that I presented with the intent of satire (not as an argument in a discourse) >>> your use of fallacy is mistaken >>> BTW be rst assured that I read the links again You stated here #138 that you considered Socrates an authority on this topic. This is a fallacy. Note this and study the links to the fallacy you're making. Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> your reply here holds no weight >>> by mendacity >>> I meant a fraudulent use of the fallacies in contention >>> you merely repeated what you said b4 (with toppings of sundry accusations) Of course I had to repeat it. Please read through what I said carefully and note the mistake you're making. You have still failed to demonstrate how my demonstration of your fallacy was inappropriate. You need to know when you're using an idiomatic expression which is different from satire. Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> your previous comment on 'strawman analogy' is baseless (it was your talk about strawman that I was referring to) Do you not realize that this statement in its context was a form of an analogy? Uyi Iredia: . . . "Hey ! Uyi, darkness can shine forth" . . . I really do not have the time to give you lessons in basic English Language while at the same time having this discussion. Uyi Iredia: *4 >>> demonstrate how this is false and dangerous >>> note that what we are reckoning are these 2 claims:
• man is the measure of all things • truth is of no essence to one who does not believe in it Both statements are false. For the first, even in the absence of humans, the truth remains the truth. Water will still be water. In the case of the second, whether or not a person believes they will die when decapitated, they will die if they are decapitated. So whether or not you believe something, it can affect you if true. This statement of yours here#120 (your 6th point) directly contradicts your second statement. Uyi Iredia: *5 >>> correction ! I am 'hand-waving' over the term 'application of reason' >>> this is so because I find it needful to call your attention to how vague the term is as I earlier did by asking how, when, and to what, reason should applied. I hope you have considered the context in which we are speaking. Uyi Iredia: as for your biting remark >>> note that, it is because such people are irreligious that I say that the term IRRELIGIOUS THEIST can apply to people who describe themselves as cultural Christians >>> an interesting detail to reckon Did you read the quote I posted from Wikipedia? So according to you, Dawkins being a self described cultural Christian is an irreligious theist? This is yet another demonstration of your absurd notions. Uyi Iredia: *6 >>> please post the comment nos you want me to reevaluate See here #123 (the last group of statements), here #126 (the last group of statements), here #130, here #137. Please show how I made the confusion you're claiming. Uyi Iredia: *7 >>> u said "no they are not the same" (in comment #137 point 4) >>> since truths, semantics and truth statements are not the same (in varied or mutual contexts) >>> why do you not see that you erred by telling me to read an article on Logical negation (in a debate about beliefs) ? A belief can be true or not true. It is not both true and not true. If one's belief is true, this means that the person believes that its negation is not true. This is an application of logic to beliefs. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 7:08pm On Feb 11, 2011 |
Uyi Iredia: answer to 1st question >>> nothing, if you disagree state effective reasons answer to 2nd question >>> no, i said he will "roll over in his grave in mock laughter" sic answer to 3rd question >>> it is satirical because i presented it as a skit to "put my thoughts [on what you said] in focus" sic answer to 4th question >>> neither, i meant what i said >>> a satire does not certainly, in all instances, mean that a person implies otherwise answer to 5th question >>> yes, he is an an authority >>> his dialectic method is one you apply frequently Now that you've made it clear with your last statement above, do you still not see your fallacy? I don't think I can spell it out better. Your reference to Socrates as an authority is a fallacy. You may need to re-read those links I gave you about the particular fallacy you're making here. Uyi Iredia: keep in mind that my accusation of your mendacity holds till you can refute it Did you not understand that your fallacy was on your reference to Socrates as an authority. "Rolling over in a grave" is an idiomatic expression not some sort of sarcastic expression. It seems you need further education on the use of common phrases in English Language. See here. And to avoid your confusion, Read my previous posts and try to identify what my statement of fallacy was referring to. Was it to your reference to Socrates or to the idiomatic expression? Another thing you need to know is that when you indicate that someone commits a fallacy, you need to demonstrate how the fallacy in question holds. You may review the way that I've used to demonstrate your fallacies. Uyi Iredia: your comment is baseless and without proof >>> please back it up with proper explanation and/or links What is this? You agree to my comment then what is this request for proof or explanation? Or are you saying that you do not understand how two people may believe mutually contradictory things? If you cannot understand this, then it seems I'm simply wasting my time. Uyi Iredia: answer to question >>> I agree to this >>> and this is why i say that truth is of no essence to one who does not believe in it and that "man is the measure of all things" This is a false and dangerous statement. This sort of statement was the basis for my examples on the free fall and the decapitation that you still fail to understand and refute. Uyi Iredia: then let me make it clear that i agree >>> but not fully for the forestated reason that the term "application of reason" is vague *even in legal circles an ambiguous clause usually gives room for much contention*
keep in mind, that you gave no answers to the question (on the 'application of reason') I forwarded >>> so I can safely ignore the trifles you present >>> however your quip about irreligious theist is quite intriguing >>> my reply to it is that cultural christians can fit into this set (they do not hold core theist beliefs but are culturally attracted to it) I see you're still trying some more hand-waving. This time with the word reason. You are free to use a dictionary if you feel your education is inadequate to enable you conceive of what is meant by reason here. And, your example of Cultural Christian is simply laughable. Here is a quote from the article you referenced. I hope you read it. Let me know if these people strike you as religious. Wikipedia: Evolutionary biologist and well known atheist Richard Dawkins has described himself as a cultural Christian. Likewise, non-believing sex advice columnist Dan Savage has described himself as a cultural Catholic: "I'm Catholic--in a cultural sense, not an eat-the-wafer, say-the-rosary, burn-down-the-women's-health-center sense. Uyi Iredia: 1st question >>> precisely Then read my responses asking for you to first demonstrate where you thought I made this confusion. You have been shying away from this. All you need to do is to simply follow the thread up and see where I asked you to demonstrate this supposed confusion. Uyi Iredia: 2nd question >>> which ones ? there is need to be precise so that our discourse is meaningful
what where you addressing when u said: "No they are not the same." >>> keep in mind that u have evaded my posers - again ! I said they are not all the same. Why do I have to keep repeating myself? Try to read and understand my replies. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Obama's Unbiblical Declaration by thehomer: 11:00pm On Feb 10, 2011 |
OLAADEGBU: Those who promote it and those who participate in it are one and the same. Do you mean to tell me that people who do not discriminate on the basis of sexual preference are also homosexual? OLAADEGBU: Did you note what I said? That this sterile lifestyle is generally present across the human population through molestation, seduction, public education being forced on us by the educational system and even declarations like the one Obama is enforcing on the populace. In addition, adoption policies and surrogacy are other ways you guys spread this lifestyle upon unsuspecting victims. Molestation? Like what the priests do? Seduction? Can a gay person seduce you? (I'm assuming that you are neither bisexual nor homosexual here), do the schools make you homosexual? Or does the statement by Obama make you want to become homosexual? And how about when adoption and surrogacy are done for heterosexual couples? OLAADEGBU: I am also wondering why you will assume that I will be quoting an atheist when explaining the meaning of the love of God. I have not made any assumption. I was wondering where you got the quote from. Do you know? OLAADEGBU: Do you not know that the unrighteous and the wrongdoers will not inherit or have any share in the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived (misled): neither the impure and immoral, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor those who participate in homosexuality, Nor cheats (swindlers and thieves), nor greedy graspers, nor drunkards, nor foulmouthed revilers and slanderers, nor extortioners and robbers will inherit or have any share in the kingdom of God. And such some of you were [once]. But you were washed clean (purified by a complete atonement for sin and made free from the guilt of sin), and you were consecrated (set apart, hallowed), and you were justified [pronounced righteous, by trusting] in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and in the [Holy] Spirit of our God. -- 1 Corinthians 6:9-11 (Amplified Bible)
This is an amplified version that shows that we have all been sinful before we became pronounced righteous as we trusted in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ for the salvation of our souls and as we have repented and forsaken our evil ways. The same can be done to you only if you realise that God loves you but hates your sinful lifestyle. Well I have not been sinful. Your claiming so does not make it so. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 10:51pm On Feb 10, 2011 |
Uyi Iredia: * 1 >>> because it was a satire (a skit that rounds off my position on what you said) those fallacies do not apply to what I forwarded as "a skit to put my thoughts in focus"
>>> since you love fallacies I have one for you : secundum quid >>> you obnoxiously apply a fallacy to what is a satire (your use of fallacy does not apply to my satire) >>> note tha,t since you forward the said fallacies as an argument >>> my accusation that you have made a fallacy has reason
>>> I obliged your request by reading the articles - again What is wrong with you? You say Socrates would not agree with me and that this is a satirical statement? What is satirical about this? If you say it is satire, then this implies that you meant the opposite of what you said. So which is it? Try not to confuse yourself. Do you consider Socrates an authority or not? Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> the difference is that one is actively explicated; the other (as I have said) is passive and redundant >>> consider the paraphrase of the quote in contention: you do not explicate an argument/notion/concept/truth that is not accepted
all you have explicated, really are beliefs >>> your counter-argument sounds like telling me "Hey ! Uyi, darkness can shine forth" - that's absurd And here you proceed with a strawman analogy. Do you not understand that two different people can believe mutually contradictory things? Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> if this debate was in a purely scholastic circle >>> your definition of free-thinking will be applauded >>> I do not fully agree with your definition (in comment #127) because of the ambiguity of the term "application of reason" >>> my skeptical side asks: what is reason ? how,when and to what should it apply? >>> My own conception of free-thinking (note that I did not use the word 'definition') is that >>> it is the means of viewing reality on the springboard of critical observation
>>> I have no qualms with the link on critical thinking >>> which I opine tends a person towards irreligion (which isn't solely atheist) And here you wish to agree with me without saying so. Have you not realized that the set of religion contains all theists and some atheists? If a person is out of that set, that person is an atheist? Or do you know of irreligious theists? Uyi Iredia: *4 >>> how so ? >>> back up this claim >>> while doing so consider this poser: are truth, truth statements, semantic values and beliefs the same thing in mutual or varied contexts? >>> make sure you answer my questions and my poser You want me to show how you have failed to demonstrate your claim of my confusion? How about you read the preceding statements asking for you to demonstrate this confusion? No they are not the same. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 10:35pm On Feb 10, 2011 |
Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> you did not answer any question >>> you only pretend to give one by talking about superstition in a way that deceptively implies that free-thinking is employed by atheists notwithstanding their superstition >>> however note that you have defined Atheism (do not forget this)
>>> please answer the bolded questions below (with yet more questions based on your latest reply I still do not understand why you're repeating questions that I've already answered. I won't bother repeating myself. Read what I wrote on atheism and on superstition here #133. Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> this is another chicanery on your part >>> you ignored the fact that I mentioned 'poor evidence' >>> now read my previous reply to what is a repeat performance (your talk of my claim to dogma) >>> to assist your comprehension this means that you should forget about the examples you treasure and consider whether a violation, in science, of the need for proper evidence, violates free-thinking
>>> now answer my bolded question below >>> and quit with asking for trifles >>> keep the answer simple and precise for clarity Your dishonest attempt to again shift the burden of proof is very sad. Please re-read what you posted. I've put in bold for you. Uyi Iredia: What of contexts (especially in science) when dogma or poor evidence is applied ? >>> is free-thinking violated ? Please give your example to which this applies in science i.e dogma or poor evidence before you proceed to make further claims on whether or not free-thinking was affected. And, where are you quoting from? When you do this, it presents your tactics as dishonest somehow implying that you've made this statement previously and I did not respond to it. Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> this is a cheap statement >>> you are the one who has been shifting the burden of proof right from the start (consider my defense wrt death by decapitation, death by high-altitude freefalls and now cosmological models)
>>> you have a clear burden to show why my talk of gravity and cosmological model does not evince that a physical law can work otherwise (asking for evidence for those laws is simply senile, a simple high school course in Physics will help) >>> you don't just discount it (in away that'll make Walmart blush) and ask me to present examples What is wrong with you? Do you not know how to read? Or do you not understand what you wrote? It seems that you do not understand that based on the law of gravitation that only one option would work. You were laying claim to some other law that would make other options true. This is the claim you are yet to present evidence for. You may go back to my questions here #31 to understand the ridiculousness of your statements. Do you have any laws where the other options would be correct? i.e either the moon being bigger than the sun or the sun and the moon being the same size. Uyi Iredia: the aforementioned laws work the same way yet we can explain them in ways that differ from actuality >>> how is such possible ? >>> you say a law does not work differently because we do not understand it, so I ask, what does an exception to a law (based on our understanding) imply ?
>>> if the models you refer to are based on reality >>> and why will someone understand such law(s) in a way different from what it is in reality ? Which law does this refer to? Which law do you have in mind? Are such laws in existence? You really need to do your work. This is why you need to avoid making such outrageous claims. I don't have the time to search around for nonexistent laws. Uyi Iredia: now to redeem yourself you have to give a good answer to the questions iterated below This is rubbish until you can actually indicate that there are such laws. So, present the law you're speaking about. Uyi Iredia: *4 >>> you mentioned 3 things - amongst others >>> they are sight, reason and telescopes >>> I ask whether all these particular items listed are human constructs >>> yes or no with explanations Some of them are human constructs, others are not human constructs. Uyi Iredia: *5 >>> I said that you should answer yes or no with reasons >>> and you start by saying "The fact that some elements of a fantasy are physical does not make it less of a fantasy." until you answer as I required I am not going to grace your fair speech >>> and don't you dare play the "you don't have a cogent point" card What you're doing here is committing a false dichotomy fallacy. The reason is that some fantasies are based on actual physical elements, others are not. And I still wonder what the relevance is to the actual physical objects being discussed. Uyi Iredia: *6 >>> give a step-by-step answer to my explication on my original posit that "Truth/Knowledge is absolutely relative and relatively absolute" in comment #132 (I have added to that post I see no reason why I should. Can a single entity be both relative and absolute? Have you noticed the contradiction yet? If something is relative, this means it is not absolute and vice versa.Uyi Iredia: *7 >>> then he fell to the ground He did not free fall to the ground. The free fall part ends with the point of first contact. Uyi Iredia: *8 >>> your arguments here come out sloppy >>> since both Alan Magee and Vesna survived a 'certain' death >>> BTW people are living with AIDS Your dishonest tactics after failing to meet the requirements is really sad. Do you not understand that there is a difference between a person's first contact being the ground and the first contact being some other material? Do you also not understand that a free fall outside a plane is different from one within a plane? You really need learn to admit that you were wrong and understand that a person's beliefs will not prevent certain death. I never said there were no people living with AIDS, I said people still die of it irrespective of their beliefs. Uyi Iredia: *9 >>> what is the evidence for this claim ? This is a simple thought experiment. Even in the absence of a human mind, water would still be water. Uyi Iredia: *10 >>> I showed with the proof that you first introduced machines into my talk of means >>> then you ask me to post links on your assumed machines >>> note that my talk of means was a supposition (I did not say anywhere that there is a machine that helps omeone avoid death by beheading) >>> 'means' - the method whereby some act (in this case, escaping death by beheading) is accomplished What means were you speaking of? This is the context in which you used it. So what proof was it again? Uyi Iredia: *6 >>> and what if the person's belief leads him/her to invent a means to avoiding a certain death when a guillotine is applied ? So after the guillotine, what "means" do you wish to use to avoid certain death? Uyi Iredia: >>> please answer my previous questions step-by-step Your question is still pointless unless you have outlined a way for someone to survive death by guillotine. And I'm not speaking about insects, I'm speaking about humans. Uyi Iredia: *11 >>> I gave you the answer you needed >>> why didn't you answer my questions ? >>> read them The question is pointless because truths are not limited to physical objects so your attempt to make them fallacies fails. Whether or not you can touch them, what is true is true. Uyi Iredia: *12 >>> this is a diversion >>> we have moved on from sun and moon >>> all you make are claims without explanation No we haven't. The mechanics of objects in this universe is what is being discussed if you actually think that the sun and the moon could be the same size or that the moon is bigger than the sun. Follow the thread up and read your increasingly ridiculous statements about this universe. Uyi Iredia: *13 >>> this doesn't stop you from addressing issues raised in the thread I posted Going by your various attempts at shifting the burden of proof on you on this thread and your sad attempts at confabulation, I don't think I'll waste my time on that new thread. I'll advice you to avoid fantasy when real physical objects and mechanics are being discussed. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 12:41am On Feb 06, 2011 |
Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> okay, so what does it mean ?
You have said that (you think) Atheism is the final conclusion of free-thinking (comment # >>> are there other conclusions of free-thinking aside from Atheism ? >>> if not, your statement effectively means that free-thinking must always lead one to Atheism
>>> since there are superstitious atheists who do not apply free-thinking and rational thinking (as you demonstrated in comment #127) >>> why do you still say Atheism is the final conclusion of free-thinking ? I already pointed out that these superstitious people have refused to subject their particular superstition to rational thought. Atheism is a concept about the existence of Gods. Superstition is a larger set of beliefs so a person can be an atheist and still be superstitious. Uyi Iredia: >>> I do not need to bring examples in science (it is quite irrelevant, my next point backs this up) >>> simply consider that in science there is the need to verify theories (with proper evidence), without the use of dogma, b4 they are accepted >>> is a violation of this by scientists opposed to free-thinking as you understand it ? by dogma, i mean a doctrinal notion asserted without regard to evidence or truth; an arbitrary dictum. If you want me to give examples, please state the relevance Yes you need examples because you made a claim that science also uses dogma. This was your quote. Uyi Iredia: What of contexts (especially in science) when dogma or poor evidence is applied ? >>> is free-thinking violated ? When you make such a bold statement, you need to back it up with some evidence. Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> again I do not need to give examples you impose >>> We are referring to the law of gravity and the cosmological models earlier mentioned >>> you assert in (comment #127) that my examples are not apropos
so I ask again (with an addition) Here again, you made a claim about the way some laws work. You need to back it up with evidence. It is a bad tactic to attempt to shift the burden of proof when you are the one making such outrageous claims. Please read what you wrote. Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> you did not answer my question >>> you merely clarified what you meant by real >>> I repeat your comment to you now that I understand what you mean by real >>> I implore you to answer the question >>> this is it or does your definition of real invalidate my question ? We perceive these objects by various means and tools like sight, reason and telescopes among others. Uyi Iredia: *4 >>> that is why I asked upon what is fantasy discovered ? >>> lemme 'double-phrase' it so that my meaning is clear >>> does a fantasy incorporate that which is factual ? are elements of reality in a fantasy ?
a simple yes or no with reasons would be appreciated The fact that some elements of a fantasy are physical does not make it less of a fantasy. Consider that leprechauns are based on small people, the pot of gold at the end of the rainbow also has lots of physical objects this still does not make it less of a fantasy. So I would advise you to steer clear of fantasy when actual phenomena are being discussed because that way madness lies. In fact, some fantasies can be based on other fantasies so the way to determine is by properly evaluating each claim. Uyi Iredia: *5 >>> let me go back to the root and trace the cause of our disagreement >>> I made this statement in comment #14 (paragraph 3) - note my posit in italic
in comment #15 you dump the notion of "truth is relative" on me I think you impose this "truth is relative" posit on me because of my response in comment #17 (point 3) >>> where I unwittingly opened Pandora's box >>> let me modify that by saying that I took 'going down this route' to connote my posit that: Truth is absolutely relative and relatively absolute I repeat that this is my posit >>> check them for inconsistencies >>> I have not modified any of them Please do revise what I wrote in comment #17 (point 4) >>> because I bolded the words "relative absolute" you replied by asking me what I meant by truth is relative (in comment #17) >>> I did not say it is relative >>> I said it is a relative absolute (the word 'relative' qualifies absolute) >>> to cut it short >>> my evaluation of our discussion up to this point reveals that we are arguing over a part of my posit (that I bolded in comment #17) >>> let me repeat it yet again that Truth/Knowledge is absolutely relative and relatively absolute and this is my explication of my posit from comment #14 (with additions) Now since you assert that knowledge is relative >>> affirm or deny my poser to you: Is knowledge absolute ? All this handwaving is even worse than I thought. I hope you realize that the term relatively absolute is an oxymoron which in this case makes little to no sense because truth is not relative to anything. It is knowledge that is relative. This is why I asked you to separate them since knowledge was not part of the original statement. So, truth is absolute, knowledge is relative. Stringing together an oxymoron and expecting me to explain it to you is bad form. Uyi Iredia: *6 >>> He did unless I'm mistaken You are mistaken. I hope you noticed that he hit glass first. Glass as a collapsing structure would absorb some of the impact. It was right there in your quote. Read the entire last sentence of the quote. Uyi Iredia: your talk of mortality rates remain impertinent to my line of reasoning >>> that the exceptions of Alan Magee and Vesna Vulovic (albeit in a plane during her free-fall) occurred should give enough chance for the belief that one can escape a 'certain' death from your talked-of 8000m freefall >>> you should seriously brood over my original posit (in comment #32 point 5) They are not exceptions. Neither of them met the requirements. Being in a plane is quite different and hitting glass first is quite different from one's first contact being the unyielding ground. That is no point at all. People die of AIDS whether or not they believe it, people die from falls whether or not they believe it so that statement is simply false. Uyi Iredia: >>> note that it is the human mind that conceives of a truth (unless there are other intelligent beings in other planets) So what? Keep in mind that even in the absence of a human mind, the truth is still true. Uyi Iredia: * 7 >>> did I say that there was a machine ! please show me where >>> you were the one who first talked about a machine (comment #117) >>> I asked (in comment #116 point 6) about inventing a means to avoiding a certain death after beheading (this is feasible since we know that cockroaches do not die after beheading) >>> this machine is clearly a wrong interjection (of yours) on my original statement (in comment#116 point 6) This is yet another dishonest attempt to shift the burden of proof. This time by playing with words. Please read this quote and explain to me what you meant by the word "means" here. Uyi Iredia: *6 >>> and what if the person's belief leads him/her to invent a means to avoiding a certain death when a guillotine is applied ? You really shouldn't stoop to such attempts. Uyi Iredia: Now, if the means of avoiding death by beheading is invented (e.g your machine) would the truth (that someone dies after beheading) still be absolutely valid ? >>> another question ? is death by beheading (irrespective of organisms considered) an absolute truth ? (yes or no) >>> note that cockroaches do not die by beheading >>> again recall this statement (in comment #122 point 6) You now wish to introduce cockroaches into a discussion that we are having about human features. Maybe I'll just skip ahead to superman and how he can shift Mars out of its orbit. Get real and stick to the discussion without introducing irrelevant side shows. What do you think was the reason for that example? Keep in mind that we are discussing physical mechanisms here. And the fact that whether or not you believe something, it can still kill you. Uyi Iredia: *8 >>> *for the purpose of passing my point across* my answer is No >>> are the listed numbers concrete real-life objects I can see and touch ? or are they human constructs ? Do you deliberately miss the point of my posts? Keep in mind that that part of the discussion was on truths where you attempted to bring up a fallacy. Truth is not simply about physical objects. It goes beyond them. Uyi Iredia: *9 >>> and what stands as a fantasy is relative to future knowledge/truths /possibilities to be discovered >>> answer me on this question: do you surmise that commoners of antiquity assumed technologies such as space travel, flight, matter transmutation as practical and not just fancies ? >>> where have those fancies brought mankind today ? >>> I do not WISH to retain my fantasy >>> I INDULGE in fantasies >>> note that animals (apes, sponges etc) don't fantasize (or do you demur ?) >>> fantasies are a crucial part to free-thinking >>> do not constrict free-thinking, set her free !
"The only way of finding limits of the possible is by going beyond them into the impossible"
- Arthur C. Clarke Why oh why are you again trying to change the scope of the discussion? To bring you back, we were discussing about the size of the sun and the moon. Do you understand the implications of your statements? Uyi Iredia: *10 >>> that was your conclusion >>> recall that the thread meandered over the odds and evens of science and religion; b4 I could pit my reply to your last post, the thread got locked >>> and as a matter of fact I had even started up a sequel to the topic as I had said click on this I don't think the thread is still locked. |
Christianity Etc › Re: 21 Year Old Virgin Pregnant With Twins by thehomer: 11:39pm On Feb 05, 2011 |
african1: The Issa/ Mariam miracle happened just once. It is one of the miracles Allah said only happens once. Which is more likely. That this miracle occurred or that it was simply yet another made up story. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Obama's Unbiblical Declaration by thehomer: 11:36pm On Feb 05, 2011 |
OLAADEGBU: Why not? If it smells like a duck, walks like a duck and talks like a duck who said that I can't safely conclude that it is a duck? All of us have sinned but God is calling us to repentance, not to be tolerated by to be loved. I still wonder how you managed to come to any conclusion. OLAADEGBU: The homosexual lifestyle is sterile. Therefore, it follows that homosexuals must of necessity, through seduction, molestation and public education, recruit their next generation. Rubbish. Have you considered the fact that it is generally present across human populations? Why do you think this is so? Did God make them this way? OLAADEGBU: Even a 6 year old knows that there are multitudes of folks that goes by the name Rob Price by simply typing the name into the search engine of facebook but you think all roads lead to your wikipedia, and BTW, Robert Price is not necessary the same as Rob Price. I was wondering if it was that same one you could simply answer with a yes or no or maybe you simply do not know. OLAADEGBU: The Scriptures here gives us an idea of what qualifies as sin:
" . . . fornicators, adulterers, effeminate, homosexuals . . . such were some of you; but you were washed, but you were sanctified, but you were justified in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, and in the Spirit of God." -- 1 Corinthians 6:9,11 Are murderers, slave owners, incestous couples and child abusers also sinners? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Obama's Unbiblical Declaration by thehomer: 3:30pm On Feb 05, 2011 |
OLAADEGBU: If you say that you are not ashamed of your sexual orientation can we then safely conclude that you are not proud of it? No you cannot conclude this because you do not know what it is. Just as you do not know my age, sex or height. OLAADEGBU: Jesus loves sinners but hates sin. Rob Price tried to explain the love of God and why Christians cannot keep quiet by this quote of his:
"If my six year old daughter was out on the road playing in front of my house and I saw a huge truck barreling around the corner, what would I do in that moment? Out of my love for my daughter I would not gently invite her to step away from the street. I would command her to change her direction, and get off the road! Why? Because of my love for her. I know that the truck would not be able to stop in time and it would run her over and kill her. The same is true of the Father's love for us. Out of His love, he commands us to repent, because at any moment the truck of sin and death could run us over for playing on the road of rebellion!" Is it this Robert Price? You are not speaking to a six year old child but an adult so your example is irrelevant. Besides, how do you decide what qualifies as a sin? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheists Based In Nigeria by thehomer: 12:03pm On Feb 05, 2011 |
Alcofrybas: Hello, I'm a non Nigerian atheist. May I join the club?.
P.S. Please let's be reasonable and stop bashing each other. Freedom of creed (including no creed at all), is a human right, and a constitutional right in many countries. The belief vs. unbelief debate is a waste of time because no one on each side will be "converted". This is not quite true as you can see on this page. It is not quite a waste of time. People do sometimes change their minds. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Obama's Unbiblical Declaration by thehomer: 11:59am On Feb 05, 2011 |
ifele: I dont agree with Obama on LGBT (Perverts) issue and full term abortion. Its crazy whats happening in North America right now. Devil is taking control gradually. Do you agree with the Catholic Church's approach to paedophile priests in their ranks? How do you know that it is the Devil and not God that is causing these things? After all, it may all be God's will. |