₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,397 members, 8,522,809 topics. Date: Sunday, 22 November 2026 at 05:54 AM

Toggle theme

Thehomer's Posts

Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 (of 210 pages)

Christianity Etc › Re: Obama's Unbiblical Declaration by thehomer: 11:57am On Feb 05, 2011
OLAADEGBU:
Are you too ashamed of your sexual orientation to say whether you are straight or not?
No I'm not but whatever it is, it is none of your business and it is irrelevant to the discussion at hand.


OLAADEGBU:
The answer to the above is in the affirmative. Read how this tough love is displayed as the nurse Clara in the cartoon gives them a straight talk about the love of Christ.
If he loves all these people then what is your problem? Why don't you simply leave the non-believers alone? They have made their decision and Jesus loves them so who are you to bug them?
Christianity Etc › Re: Obama's Unbiblical Declaration by thehomer: 5:31pm On Feb 04, 2011
I also notice that you are yet to address your inconsistency in applying Biblical injunctions which was pointed out here: #335 first statement.
Christianity Etc › Re: Obama's Unbiblical Declaration by thehomer: 5:27pm On Feb 04, 2011
Uyi Iredia:
it's not about how it stands >>> it's about presentation >>> I have told you what I want to find out, oblige my bias >>> if I act based on my intention to find out this orientation >>> in this case, by not arguing >>> why must it mean that I have no good argument to make ? >>> it only means what it is >>> that I have withheld my argument
It mean you have no good argument because a good argument stands on its merits not on the views of the other party.


Uyi Iredia:
I'm ready to present it sir/ma >>> please tell me your orientation >>> your previous and continual refusal heightens my curiosity >>> and delays the argument
My orientation is irrelevant. If you need irrelevant details to decide how to present an argument it just further demonstrates the weakness of your argument.
If you still cannot present your argument, then I'm done with you here.
Christianity Etc › Re: THE BIBLE,...THE WORD OF GOD AND IT/HIM ALONE. by thehomer: 5:15pm On Feb 04, 2011
More words

28 If a man happens to meet a virgin who is not pledged to be married and rapes her and they are discovered, 29 he shall pay her father fifty shekels of silver. He must marry the young woman, for he has violated her. He can never divorce her as long as he lives.

- Deuteronomy 22: 28, 29


17 “Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them. 18 For truly I tell you, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished. 19 Therefore anyone who sets aside one of the least of these commands and teaches others accordingly will be called least in the kingdom of heaven, but whoever practices and teaches these commands will be called great in the kingdom of heaven. 20 For I tell you that unless your righteousness surpasses that of the Pharisees and the teachers of the law, you will certainly not enter the kingdom of heaven.

- Matthew 5: 17 - 20

11 A woman should learn in quietness and full submission. 12 I do not permit a woman to teach or to assume authority over a man; she must be quiet.

- 1 Timothy 2: 11, 12
Christianity Etc › Re: Obama's Unbiblical Declaration by thehomer: 4:51pm On Feb 04, 2011
Uyi Iredia:
this implies an all or nothing fallacy >>> you expressly affirm that I do not have any cogent point to make simply because I wish to know your orientation >>> you do not consider the alternative - that I simply wish to know the orientation of whom I speak and tailor my arguments accordingly - this is my bias
Why? Can the argument not stand on its own? Is it that weak?
In this case, I have not committed a fallacy because, the sexual orientation of the other party in a discussion on homosexuality is irrelevant. Especially when one considers that there are homosexuals or bisexuals who can be against homosexuality and there are heterosexuals who do support the rights of homosexuals and vice versa.


Uyi Iredia:
note that ad hominem fallacy is valid when the argument to the person takes the argument out of context e.g

You are immoral because you are gay - this is ad hominem because it decontextualises the term 'immoral'
A gay can be immoral - this is not an ad hominem fallacy >>> it is a statement of probability which is verifiable
You're simply agreeing with me here. So, are you ready to present your argument?
Christianity Etc › Re: Terrible Things Is Happening In Jos. Pray For Peace To Reign In Plateau State. by thehomer: 4:36pm On Feb 04, 2011
Do you really think that prayer will change anything? How do you know that this is not all God's plan and that praying will not only annoy God but make him smite you? I think you need to first pray and ask God if it is ok for you to pray about this topic. Make sure you hear his response before you embark on this prayer.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Invasion Of The Funky Pastors & Commercialization Of Christianity by thehomer: 4:32pm On Feb 04, 2011
Christianity has almost always been commercialized. Consider the older arms of Christianity like Roman Catholicism and the Orthodox Churches and think about how they came about their currently observed wealth. So, these modern day pastors are not so unique.
Christianity Etc › Re: Is It An Insult To Call Religion A Scam? by thehomer: 4:25pm On Feb 04, 2011
The problem with calling religion a scam is due to the wide variability of religions. Some require lots of money from adherents while others require next to nothing from their adherents. So, I think a better approach would be to actually indicate certain practices that may qualify as being scams.
Christianity Etc › Re: Obama's Unbiblical Declaration by thehomer: 4:07pm On Feb 04, 2011
Uyi Iredia:
the inference is wrong, really ! >>> and let me state that the sex of a discussant on women's rights issue can lead to a modification of how to best present my point >>> however, I may or may not respond differently to the male or female >>> this, of course is subject to my whims >>> and not responding does not automatically mean I have no cogent point to make
If your response depends on the sex of the other party, then this implies that you're either being sexist or you intend to address the person rather than the argument. This is the basis of an ad hominem fallacy. This is why it is the arguments presented that are addressed rather than who makes the argument.
If on the other hand, you refuse to present any argument until the sex of the other party is confirmed, then this implies that you don't think your argument can stand on its own merit meaning that it is highly likely to be unsound.
Christianity Etc › Re: 21 Year Old Virgin Pregnant With Twins by thehomer: 2:16pm On Feb 04, 2011
PLASOTLE:
Who is this one? Can you not read - ? ? ?  - - -
An intact hymen does not automatically mean that the person did not have sexual intercourse. Besides, did you know that the sperm could be introduced without full penetration? Such occurrences need to be ruled out before claiming that it was the Holy Spirit at work or do you wish to accuse the Holy Spirit?

Read the first paragraph: hymen
Christianity Etc › Re: 21 Year Old Virgin Pregnant With Twins by thehomer: 8:54pm On Feb 03, 2011
PLASOTLE:
It has been reported that a 21 year old confirmed virgin in Awka, Ngozi Ibekwelu is heavily pregnant and shortly to deliver what doctors have detected is a pair of twins. As of today, routine gyneacological check-ups reveal an intact hymen, which has not been ruptured and which shows no signs of having healed from a previous rupture. The girl has repeatedly asserted that she had several visions about seven months ago in which a spirit being had informed her of her imminent pregnancy. According to Miss Ibekwelu, she had been told by the spirit being that the children to be delivered would not be mere mortals.
How was the virginity confirmed?
This is very exciting. She is about to give birth to two Gods. grin
Christianity Etc › Re: Obama's Unbiblical Declaration by thehomer: 3:42pm On Feb 03, 2011
Uyi Iredia:
which is why I ask for your sexual orientation >>> it will determine what I ask, how I ask it and how I'll reply you >>> either way lemme assure you that I'll proffer my sincerest opinion
If a person's sexual orientation will determine the questions and your responses, this implies that you do not quite intend to be honest in your approach. e.g if we were discussing women's rights issues, would the sex of one of the discussants define the questions you ask? Or the response you give? i.e would you ask different questions and give different responses if the other party were male or female?
Christianity Etc › Re: Faith? What Is It 2 u: by thehomer: 12:11pm On Feb 03, 2011
Faith is believing what you know ain't so. - Mark Twain.

Faith, n. Belief without evidence in what is told by one who speaks without knowledge about things without parallel. - Ambrose Bierce
Christianity Etc › Re: Faith? What Is It 2 u: by thehomer: 12:01pm On Feb 03, 2011
Joagbaje:
A man's level of faith is based on his knowledge in Gods word. We all recieve equal measure of faith at salvation. But our faith is not developed equaly , because we hear differently. That is why where we worship matters. Someone believes he shall know his fate of salvation in heaven another believes he is saved now.
Some other believes whatever happens to us like suffering is from God. The lord giveth , the lord taketh. But someone else believes we have a choice to live a good life.

A good example is the issue of sickness. A man at a level believe sickness is from God and there is no need praying against it. He only prays for God to see him through to remain faithful to God without compromising his relationship. He prays that God gives him faith to endure. But another has a bigger faith based on the understanding that it is Satan that brought the sickness. He knows God can But he is not sure if God will want to heal him since God has many people he is concerned about. So he prays if it is the will of God for him to survive let it be.
But yet another has the understanding that it is the will of God for him to be healed so he prays to God to heal him and have mercy saying " I know my redeemer liveth" some day I will come out of this " my lord will answer my prayer". But another one has an understanding that he doesn't need to talk to God about his sickness. He has been healed 2000 years ago. Jesus has paid the price and he has authority over the power of darkness. He Is a master to Satan and his demons. He doesn't need to beg God or beg Satan . he exercise his authority and rebuke the devil and command the pain to go. And he becomes free.

Now all these are expressions of faith at different level. Different sizes. The size of your faith is simply based in your awareness in God. but the strenght of your faith is based on your use of your faith. If you have faith and you don't. Put it to work , it will soon be a dead faith even though you have so much awareness and bible quotation. Yet someone else doesn't have so much knowledge of the bible , but the little he knows , he put it to work, he will have greater result than Mr theology who can't cast a devil out.
This is the sort of thinking that kills people. Rather than going to a hospital to get treated, you simply sit back and pray for God to do his will? Then again, faith comes in different sizes.
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 9:21pm On Feb 02, 2011
Uyi Iredia:
*1 >>> on the contrary, this is what I extrapolated from your statement in comment #8
One leads to the other does not mean that one is equal to another.


Uyi Iredia:
>>> does this apply to superstitious atheists ? >>> what is the definition of the term, reason, in this instance ? >>> What of contexts (especially in science) when dogma or poor evidence is applied ?  >>> is free-thinking violated ?
Yes it does because they simply choose to place some phenomena beyond rational thinking. By reason, I mean logical thinking.
Can you give examples in science where this occurs?


Uyi Iredia:
*2 >>> there appears to be an error here: the aforementioned laws work the same way yet we can explain them 
in ways that differ from actuality >>> how is such possible ? 

and why will someone understand such a law in a way different from what is factual ?
Do you have examples of such laws?


Uyi Iredia:
*3 >>> this couldn't be more invidious >>> and with what do we view such 'real' objects ? >>> and aside from what is based in reality, upon what is fantasy discovered ?
By real there, I meant physical objects since that was what the discussion was on.


Uyi Iredia:
Imaginative genius also involves escaping to fantasy >>> and this is a picturesque  part the vista of free-thinking and what mankind has accrued from it 
*consider how much we learn from fictional stories and metaphysical claims and consider scientific theories/technological feats previously framed unworkable*
This is irrelevant because we are discussing actual demonstrated physical objects not fantasy objects in a fantasy universe.


Uyi Iredia:
*4 >>> let us consider your statement 

what you know as true is dependent on what the truth actually is.
this is, in part, why i conclude truth and knowledge are relatively absolute (i.e certain/absolute wrt to what we do not know about truth itself) and absolutely relative (i.e certainly/absolutely bounded by the fact that we can never fully know the truth)
we are like the 7 blind men reckoning (using thought and all its constituents) an elephant (which symbolizes our reality, this reality_there might be another reality different or similar to ours)
This is again false. Truth is not relative. Knowledge is relative. So separate truth from knowledge. Whether or not you know the truth, whatever it turns out to be, it is not relative.


Uyi Iredia:
* 5 >>> then evaluate the peculiar case of Alan Magee >>> so what of those mortality rates ! it simply is not definitive when I consider the exceptions that can, and have occurred
Alan Magee did not hit the ground. Please read the articles on him again. You have not actually presented exceptions.


Uyi Iredia:
* 6 >>> I simply considered otherwise >>> you should be pleased - I am questioning a phenomena (in this case, death by decapitation) >>> this can lead to the discovery of yet another truth which would remain hidden had I not effected free-thinking

now type the words survive, and beheading, in Google and see how real,  real is
Do you have a machine that would enable a person survive for a year and a day after this decapitation? If you do, please post a link to it. I won't waste my time searching for something whose existence is just another fantasy of yours. Keep in mind that there is a time limit.


Uyi Iredia:
*7 >>> so you affect to shift grounds ! >>> what does an identity statement have with the subject of truth ! >>> clarify what you want me to demonstrate yet again 
Note that you said I should consider the statement : A=A is true (a truth statement) 
This is takes on the appearance of the petitio principii fallacy >>> I surmise this because you say that the statement A=A is true is based on the truth that A=A
It has everything to do with the subject of truth. That is not a fallacy unless you wish to say that mathematics is simply a fallacy. Consider these:
1 = 1 = (2 - 1) = (3 - 2). Are they fallacies? Are they true?


Uyi Iredia:
*8 >>> several reasons that weren't good enough >>> your talk of fantasy is much inconclusive, for all we know such mechanics might be available- or at least possible
You still wish to retain your fantasies. If these mechanics are available or possible, then can you please demonstrate this? Do you even understand the implications of what you're saying?


Uyi Iredia:
*9 >>> ehn ! enlighten me with the conclusion you saw
The conclusion was that atheism is not a religion. If you disagree, you know what to do.
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 8:45pm On Feb 02, 2011
Uyi Iredia:
*1 >>> his status as the symbol of critical thinking and my consequent satire directed against your stance that atheism is the conclusion of free-thinking
After you've made this statement, why do you still not see that this is a fallacy? Please read these links.
Fallacy of Irrelevant conclusion
Genetic fallacy


Uyi Iredia:
*2 >>> you appear to circumlocute here >>> I have said b4 Person B believes that fire does not harm; and that this is what he explicates 

>>> This is of course apparently different from not believing that fire harms (a redundant position I must add)
What is the difference? If it is redundant, this would imply that the two positions are the same. This is yet another contradiction in your position.


Uyi Iredia:
*3 >>> I agree >>> but I want to see you define both critical and free-thinking
I have shown what I mean by free-thinking. It is right there in my quote in your last post on the first line.
For critical thinking, see here Critical thinking


Uyi Iredia:
* 4 >>> I made a mistake in that post >>> I meant comment #112 point 3 >>> here it is (my explanation)
That is still not evidence demonstrating a confusion on my part between belief and truth.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Antichrist Will Be A Jew - Next President Of The U.s.a by thehomer: 7:01pm On Feb 02, 2011
ISuperior:
Antichrist will not be the next king of the U.S.A if he is I'm gonna blast his fat face.
Rememer how the he goat was killed bye _________.
"wink. All I have to say.
You do realize that the U.S is not led by a King.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Antichrist Will Be A Jew - Next President Of The U.s.a by thehomer: 6:58pm On Feb 02, 2011
whybanme:
The Antichrist will be a Jew. He will be the next President after Obama.
He/She will invade Iran and North Korea.

Her/His throne is already set. The Rotschilds, Rockerfellers and Other Powerful Jews have been pulling the strings for years for world domination.
They rule over the U.S banks, media, health, military, security etc.
Yet another conspiracy involving Jews. What will they do for you to leave them alone?
So, if the next President turns out not to be a Jew, what then? Will you simply push this Antichrist fellow further up the time-line?
Christianity Etc › Re: Obama's Unbiblical Declaration by thehomer: 6:47pm On Feb 02, 2011
OLAADEGBU:
This is what someone observed about these guys earlier on.  I wonder why it is difficult to say whether they are gays or not, what are they worried about?
It is irrelevant to the discussion in the same way that a person does not need to know your tribe to decide how to argue for or against the secession of any region of Nigeria.


OLAADEGBU:
Jesus loves you and is willing to set you free if only you will repent and accept Him into your life.
Does Jesus love gay people, slaves, Muslims, Hindus, atheists and other groups that disagree with the Bible and some of his teachings?
Christianity Etc › Re: Obama's Unbiblical Declaration by thehomer: 6:43pm On Feb 02, 2011
Uyi Iredia:
it will determine how I will tailor my response >>> plus I will ask you some risqué and not risqué questions >>> are you ready ?
You're free to ask your questions. I really don't care about how you tailor your response as long as it reflects your honest opinion.
Christianity Etc › Re: Obama's Unbiblical Declaration by thehomer: 7:14am On Feb 02, 2011
Uyi Iredia:
@ homer >>> it means that I do not which to state my arguments now based on your refusal not to give your sexual orientation
What is the relevance of my sexual orientation to the discussion?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Sees The Future Let's Discuss(prophets Only) by thehomer: 7:30pm On Feb 01, 2011
emmadaniel:
Are you anointed with a gift of Prophecy?

[center]FOLLOW HERE, [/center]

WHAT DO YOU SEE FOR NIGERIA?[color=#006600][/color]
I see more houses being built in Nigeria.
I see good things happening to many people and bad things happening to some people.
I see the death of three well-known Nigerians.
I see the birth of twins in Nigeria.

I also see some other things but you'll need to join my church and pay tithes of 12.5% to get prophesies concerning your immediate family. Note that the extra 2.5% is to show your dedication because anybody can meet the barest minimum requirements but special people receive special consideration.
Christianity Etc › Re: Obama's Unbiblical Declaration by thehomer: 3:11pm On Feb 01, 2011
Uyi Iredia:
my silence does not mean I have no cogent points to make !
What does it mean?
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 3:08pm On Feb 01, 2011
Uyi Iredia:
*1 >>> your conclusion is still biased >>> knowledge in the aforesaid subjects does not equate to critical or free-thinking (they simply use critical thinking) >>> by the way, the fact that there are people with ample knowledge of such topics who aren't Atheist should back me up >>> you seem to appropriate free-thinking as something arcane *this is why I asked whether one must think* and I reckon that this isn't quite the case
I never said it equated to free-thinking. Free-thinking is the application of reason to basically any opinion. I already pointed out that someone who chooses not to apply reason to their religious beliefs or other superstitious beliefs is not thinking freely on such topics but relying on dogma, poor evidence etc.


Uyi Iredia:
*2 >>> consider the following: that we now understand gravity to be a bend in the space-time continuum and not a force (as emphasized in Newtonian physics) >>> also consider that we now view the universe with Copernican lenses (or some other new cosmological model I do not know) as against the former revered Ptolemaic models 

These are good examples/analogies to evince what I meant when I said physical laws can work otherwise
No they are not good examples or analogies because the law still works the same way. Those are models based on reality. Not fantasy, not imagination but reality. So it would not work differently simply because you do not understand it.


Uyi Iredia:
Furthermore chimeras have a role to play in the vast concept of free-thinking >>> what we say is tenable is really limited to knowledge which is simply not absolute >>> on a slightly different note, lemme add that imaginative genius (in felicity with reality) plays a crucial role in free-thinking
Imaginative genius does not warrant a person choosing to escape to fantasy when interactions of real objects are being considered.


Uyi Iredia:
*3 >>> that is quite impertinent >>> I posit that both truth and knowledge are absolutely relative and relatively absolute 

However: Knowledge is different from truth >>> are you satisfied ?
No. Truth is not relative to what you know, what you know as true is dependent on what the truth actually is. Or do you wish to state what truth is relative to and what you actually mean by that turn of phrase?


Uyi Iredia:
*4 >>> I goofed ! She was in the plane >>> however, do me a favor by evaluating the footnote links >>> and that article is not irrelevant; 8000m or not, it outlines the means to increase chances of survival from high-altitude falls
I see no reason why I should because it does not have anyone surviving such an impact. You also need to take note of the mortality rates after certain heights.


Uyi Iredia:
*5 >>> how is it hand-waving ? >>> besides it is consistent with what I said earlier

I'd say the onus is on you to find such equipment
Are you serious? huh You actually want me to scour the web looking for a machine that you made up in your fantasy? Get real. If you know of such a machine prior to 2011, please present it or you can also admit that this fantasy machine of yours is simply that. A fantasy.


Uyi Iredia:
*6 >>> this is what I just did >>> and I am serious about truth based on contingencies >>> this is one of the founding reasons why I said that physical laws could act otherwise >>> contingencies (that consist of our perception of such laws and the dynamics of the laws themselves)  apply to them_as well as truth and knowledge >>> your talk of A=A is a simply a truth statement >>> not the truth
It is based on the truth that A = A. For you to properly disagree, you will need to demonstrate that A = ~A.


Uyi Iredia:
>>> please ! do not be tired we can amicably end this discourse >>> all I need is a good reason to admit my errancy >>> if you can't do such then examine your own stance or your way of presenting it
I have given you several reasons. You simply need to do something more than bringing fantasy mechanics and machines to discussions on this universe. If you have noticed anything wrong with my stance or presentation, you're free to raise it.


Uyi Iredia:
besides I have sacrificed a considerable part of my time-table on this discussion >>> I do not want it to end inconclusively as did the topic "Atheism Is A Religion"
I don't see how that discussion ended inconclusively.
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 2:38pm On Feb 01, 2011
Uyi Iredia:
* 1 >>> because you opine that critical thinking tends to atheism
And of what relevance is Socrates to this discussion?


Uyi Iredia:
*2 >>> notice that non-belief is in quote >>> why did you think I put the word 'non-belief' in quote ? >>> my answer: because there was no 'non-belief' in the first place >>> all Person B does is to evince why he believes that fire 

>>> Rephrase your question. I do not understand it.
Can you tell me what Person B believes?
And is this belief different from not believing that fire will harm him?


Uyi Iredia:
*3 >>> answer: to find out why this is so and do something about it
Critical thinking is different from free-thinking.


Uyi Iredia:
>>> then indulge yourself in correcting the 'flaws'_if they so be_in point 3 of comment #114 (this is where I explain why I supposed that you conflate belief & truth statements)
That was not an explanation. That was a claim please read what you posted again. My request was for your evidence backing up that claim. Do you have any?
Christianity Etc › Re: Obama's Unbiblical Declaration by thehomer: 10:20pm On Jan 30, 2011
Uyi Iredia:
no, it does not
This is simply an evasive tactic and I'm calling you out on it.

You are also strangely silent on the Biblical references presented. Can you demonstrate how they are out of context or will you also be silent on that too?
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 10:16pm On Jan 30, 2011
Uyi Iredia:
*1 >>> post a comment no >>> i did not see what you were referring to
Click on the link it will take you to the particular comment. I just did that again. But here is the number. It was #82 in my response to DeepSight.


Uyi Iredia:
*2 >>> comment no please !
This was from my comment #119 You could see the direct reference to freewill not freethinking.


Uyi Iredia:
*3 >>> Baguazhang appears to be your preferred style >>> lemme emphazize again that a given set of physical laws could possibly work otherwise >>> it is that simple, really !

i'd say u call my claims absurd because in my humble opinion you do not apply yourself to free-thinking >>> i wager that your kind of free-thinking is one that is inelastic
This is more made up stuff. Please present the physical laws that would make the other two options correct otherwise, I'll be forced to conclude that you simply are not serious and simply wish to make stuff up to suit you. This is not thinking rationally.
Do you think that free-thinking means that a person needs to imagine whatever they like and run with it? That my friend is fantasy not free-thinking. They are very different.


Uyi Iredia:
*4 >>> i merely went back to the root cause of this part of our discourse >>> check comments #14, 15 & 17
Read your post again. Truth is very different from knowledge.

Uyi Iredia: >>> i used to be averse to Kierkegaard's notion >>> but of recent i realize that he was right in positing that truth is subjective >>> we ultimately measure the kind of truth we subscribe to >>> in light of this I decided that : Truth is absolutely relative and relatively absolute
Your initial reference was to truth not knowledge. Again, please repeat after me knowledge is different from truth.

Uyi Iredia:
* 5 >>> stop interjecting my statements ! >>> where did i mention that she crawled into the plane >>> she free-fell from the sky & landed amongst the rear part of the wreckage
This is a direct implication from what you said. Here is your quote again.

Uyi Iredia: did you note that the plane tore apart b4 its downfall ? and that  she was found in the rear part of the plane's wreckage ? *how could she have been in a plane that was burning and torn apart*
I hope you understand that this implies that she wasn't in the plane since this is a rhetorical question.
And this was from the article.

Wikipedia: In an interview she commented that, according to the man who found her, ", I was in the middle part of the plane. I was found with my head down and my colleague on top of me. One part of my body with my leg was in the plane and my head was out of the plane. A catering trolley was pinned against my spine and kept me in the plane.
[url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vesna_Vulovi%C4%87#Fall]Vesna Vulović[/url]


So which is it? Was she in the plane while it was falling or wasn't she?


Uyi Iredia:
>>> again! you did not even read the footnotes and you did not comment on what i emphasized on the 2nd article - that one can survive high-altitude falls by 'playing upon factors'  >>> i'm well aware that that free-fall in a container and without are very different things
Rubbish. What was so fascinating about the footnotes? Can you provide a link that would point to a conclusion different from her not falling freely to the ground?
The second article had nothing on surviving an 8000 metre free fall to the ground. If you think it did, then please present someone who survived such a fall.
If you know that falling in a plane and falling freely to the ground are different, then why are you still presenting this single case when it obviously does not meet the requirements?


Uyi Iredia:
*6 >>> because free-thinking and physical thinking considers other factors and possibilities which cause that person's death >>> that is how science can make technological advancements >>> every fact/system/law/theory has loopholes per se >>> a scientist could investigate the death of the man of your example and find out that such a man can be resusciated even after decapacitation (directly implying that such a person is not dead)

your example boils down to simple induction: when men are decapacitated they die (this is a truth statement) >>> as a matter of fact there can be exceptions to this truth that your statement tries to photograph based on what you do not know
This is terrible hand waving. Do you have a way or mechanism that was available in 2010 to enable a decapitated person survive for 1 year and 1 day?


Uyi Iredia:
when i accused you of conflating truth and truth statements, this was my mentation >>> a truth statement is a statement (words) that we use to define what we observe in reality >>> it does not and can not fully do this (the limitation of language) >>> the person does not believe in your statement but the truth your statement tries to capture (which he might define in his own way) >>> this truth does not necessarily work the same way in various instances (it might, it might not) >>> truths are based on contingencies
Please demonstrate where I conflated this because as far as has been demonstrated on this thread, you are the one conflating them.
This is also terrible hand waving. Your claim that truths are based on contingencies is indeed laughable.
Consider this statement: A = A is true. When will A = A be not true?
Also, your evasive tactics are becoming quite tiresome.
Christianity Etc › Re: Science And Religion: The Unending Conflict. by thehomer: 11:40pm On Jan 29, 2011
Deep Sight:
^^^ There are frauds in every profession. That does not take away the fact that there are proper originals as well. If the Intelligence Agencies and Police departments had found ALL the psychics to be frauds, doubtless they would not still bother with any psychic, would they?

Those channels i mentioned are very scientific channels that churn out stuff researched by science professors in the best universities in the world. I do not know if you are able to boast of the level of education and research of some of the scientists studying these phenomena. But you know how silly sheep are. They glean an interesting endeavour such as science and ignorantly become more catholic than the Pope. Some of the things you deny here would not be denied by the most knowledgeble professors in the world. Simply because they are exposed to all sides of the facts. Both frauds and genuine instances. But then again, i spoke about peeps wanting to be more catholic than the pope. Just cos they know a little psuedo science. Ha, psuedo catholic.
The appeal to mysterious authority you're making here does not reflect well. You would do well to name names and compare these to other experts in the relevant fields.


Deep Sight:
If you believe they are all frauds, please write a memo to the CIA, KGB and M16 reprimanding them for their obstinate stupidity in continuing to employ and pay such frauds.

Frankly i believe you are ill-educated in this matter. A little knowledge is more dangerous than no knowledge at all. That is your problem. You look to the frauds and pointedly ignore the many legitimate cases abundantly available.Like I said, there are frauds in every vocation. If you are not aware of the application of psychic powers in criminal investigations and espionage, then you are simply pointedly ignorant.

I have nothing else to add.
If I am indeed ignorant, then please educate me. You are simply asserting that these agencies do use psychics and what not yet Osama bin Laden is still at large, numerous cases are still unsolved?
Please. You should know that you need to do more than simply assert that these agencies use psychics. And, even if they did use psychics, this does not mean that these psychics are indeed right. This is an appeal to an improper authority or in this case, authorities. Those government agencies are not the best to evaluate those claims besides, I hope you do know the effect of ranks in such organizations.
Here's another example of the effect. Do you believe in astrology? Would the fact that a U.S. president consulted an astrologer make astrological predictions more accurate?
Come on.
Christianity Etc › Re: Science And Religion: The Unending Conflict. by thehomer: 8:36pm On Jan 29, 2011
Deep Sight:
I will not argue with you because the facts are there: Police departments in the United States DO employ psychics - deny that if you dare. This is a fact. Also Intelligence Agencies the world over use the services of psychic remote viewers. Deny that as well if you can. These are facts and they speak for themselves. If you do not know, just spend more time watching BBC Knowledge and Crime & Investigation. I cannot shout.
Like mazaje has said, lots of them are frauds.
Here are a couple of links to demonstrate what I mean. Besides, the fact that some police forces use them does not mean that they are accurate.

police_and_psychics
police_reject_psychic_advice
psychic_failures
history_of_failures_of_sylvia_browne

Then on YouTube:
Anderson_Cooper_Sylvia_Browne
Larry_King_Rosemary_Altea

This is on dowsing another famous psychic phenomenon.

Like I said, I maintain a degree of skepticism. If there was good enough evidence for such phenomenon, I would change my mind.
And, you need to keep in mind that you are making a positive claim here so the burden of proof is more on you to demonstrate the veracity of these claims.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 (of 210 pages)