vedaxcool: Truly you sound quite like an illiterate, as the Paganism was the dorminant religion in Mecca. Indeed you do not think.
Why does Islam share so many characters found in Judaism and Christianity though we know it came later?
vedaxcool: It is good you assert that you cannot reason for yourself, instead you call your self an atheist in order for people to call u intelligent,
That was an assertion? Have you heard of the concept of punctuation marks? Did you notice that the sentence ended with a question mark? i.e this sign ?
vedaxcool: It did but because you no longer use your brain, it became beyound you to understand did you say: ans : What is this?? ans:
It seems you do not recognize rubbish analogies when you make them.
vedaxcool: Ignorance is actually your middle name, as the simple question is what did the JEws worship before Yaweh. Simple
Go sit and watch the video again.
vedaxcool: The Arab took ALLAH to be the sole diety and associated partners with him it is written for you to see: Pre-Islamic pagan Arabs believed in a blind, powerful, inexorable and insensible fate over which man had no control. This was replaced with the Islamic notion of a powerful but provident and merciful God.[27]
Allah was not considered the sole divinity; however, Allah was considered the creator of the world and the giver of rain. The notion of the term may have been vague in the Meccan religion.[4] Allah was associated with companions, whom pre-Islamic Arabs considered as subordinate deities. Meccans held that a kind of kinship existed between Allah and the jinn.[15] Allah was thought to have had sons[16] and that the local deities of al-ʻUzzá, Manāt and al-Lāt were His daughters.[17] The Meccans possibly associated angels with Allah.[18][19] Allah was invoked in times of distress.[19][20] Muhammad's father's name was ‘Abdallāh meaning the “servant of Allāh.” or "the slave of Allāh"[19]
Why does Islam borrow characters both mythical and otherwise?
vedaxcool: But again did you say I never said Mohammed knew how to read. One does not need to know how to read to recite poems in their oral traditions. Please learn to think. You do not seem to understand the concept of burden of proof. Please look it up and avoid displaying such ignorance when resources are available.
so the dullard in you tells you the arab took the oral traditions of the Jews and spent time talking about it, instead of their own history? again did u say
Your confusion runs deep indeed. Who says they had to take the oral traditions of the Jews? Did you know that cultures are influenced by surrounding cultures? I refuse to believe that one can be this ignorant and confused when simple ideas are presented.
vedaxcool: A description of how poor you arguement.
Deep Sight: Each time i read your posts on this issue, i just feel disillussioned and discouraged from continuing. Then a few days later I suddenly feel I can still make you see what I am saying. Maybe I will try a different approach. Cross-Examination. I will ask some questions, you will answer. The truth should become obvious within those questions and answers, I hope.
I'm sorry you feel that way. I may also have some questions for you too as we go along.
Deep Sight: Q. 1. - True or false - the words "before" and "after" can only be used in the context of time and space - i.e: you cannot have a "before" or an "after" and there cannot be a "past" and a "future" if there is no time - as the whole idea of past, present and future is itself a reference to time.
Please answer, thanks.
Yes the words refer to events that occur in a time-line.
@OP A pretty long post. Didn't read it all but I find it curious that this Victoria Nehale character must be special to have visited hell at least once too many. I also noticed it's dark and hell is hot. The ability to recognize skeletons as people one once knew and this breed of demons that have crocodile heads and walk on all fours is quite curious.
Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> to let you infer that critical thinking doesn't necessarily tend to Atheism
*2 >>> same as above - plus the sarcasm
You see the reference to Socrates because he was an originator of an idea is a fallacy. Whether or not Socrates was an atheist even if he was one of the originators of the idea is irrelevant to the discussion. Besides, I never said it necessarily makes one an atheist especially if a person chooses to suspend critical thinking when it comes to certain issues e.g their personal religion.
Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> saying is false is an affirmative statement (a positive belief that a=b is false is true) *I hope I'm clear* >>> saying a=b is not true signifies a suspension of judgement as to the value of the equation (i.e whether it is true or false)
No it's not. You may need to refer to logic tables to clarify this error.
Uyi Iredia: *4 >>> phew! I'd say that the fact that Person B _referring to our earlier argument_has reasons for a stance and can articulate it shows that he has a belief in it >>> There is no such thing as an unbelief if you have, even a bit of, knowledge as regards an issue.
If his belief is directly contradictory to yours, this means he does not believe your statement is true thus is an unbeliever in your belief.
Uyi Iredia: *5 >>> i have already said that non-belief is passive as regards an argument >>> it is a redundancy much the same way the 'not equals to' symbol is redundant >>> non-belief is a mere adumbration of a belief, whether it be +ve or -ve
Passivity would be a null value or a response such as I do not know (but be careful with this because even if one does not know an answer, one can still be quite clear that an answer is not correct).
Uyi Iredia: *6 >>> I intend to especially since my upcoming GST 311 (History & Philosophy of Science) exam deals with it and (apparently) our argument on science and religion. BTW, I rummaged through my Dad's archives and got the 'Tell Me Why' book where I read that animals engage in farming practices. I'll scan it later so you can evaluate it.
Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> my response (as it has been) is that Socrates is the forbear of the information we have >>> besides the information we have is much inconclusive since there is an infinitude of things to be discovered
So what's the relevance of whether or not he believed in a God?
Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> okay >>> yes, he didn't have it but we owe what we have to him and his likes
Sure he did a lot of work there. Still, what's the relevance of this to whether or not he believed in a God?
Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> then your inferences were wrong
So what did you mean by your reference to Socrates?
Uyi Iredia: *4 >>> semantics ! >>> false and not true are two different things >>> that I learn in philosophy class
Oh? Could you please expatiate? e.g a = 1, b = 2.
If I said a = b is false, and a = b is not true, what's the difference?
Uyi Iredia: *5 >>> this is so because there are no 'unbeliefs' >>> only beliefs and their antecedents
Huh? Could you please clarify what you mean? In general parlance, non-christians are "unbelievers".
vedaxcool: Ramble is what atheism is about, It very interesting that you could not even answer a single question of what I asked, keep deluding yourself that you are rational. As for your question you will get no answer until you can explain why/how coincidence brought the perfect Universe of ours. Like I have long said that You atheist in NL are atheist by desperation not of logic, you have only prove what I have asserted long, in the thread which I asked Between agnostics and atheist who is more rational, all yyour atheist buddies could not answer a simple question, Yet they came intelligence. Intelligence indeed.
So you refuse to answer whether your religion was a coincidence or if it was a deliberate copying from Christianity and Judaism. I'll answer it for you. It was no coincidence. It was simply copying from other dominant religions in the region.
vedaxcool: she is your god because you accepyt all she says without question in fact God is the only Being I follow without questions asked. Point out the absiurd claim let us see. If you answer questions like these I am wasting my time with you, always making allegation without proof.
I accept what she says without question? So also is Mohammed your God. Not just him, so also angel Gabriel and other mythical entities.
vedaxcool: Yes, did you undrstand mine?
Your response made no sense.
vedaxcool: Then you and your Narator + your god are just Daft imbec!les, who prefers to make bogus claims without proof, How wil,l any sensible person claim that he is telling a History of God, yet left out very important religions that should explain monotheism. I never claim I have all the answers but I have sufficient answer to prove that you are just a simpleton whose mind has been ensalve and who finds it easy to believe in things without proof. You despite my encouragement to think,u prefer following a god that only give answers in maybes, probably, we shall never know . . .
You're dumber than a post. So you think that if someone decides to limit a discussion to the Judaic, Christian and Islamic God, the person must also include Roman Gods, Aztec Gods and all Gods ever created by humans? Are you on some medication?
vedaxcool: Nonsense thought maybe the earth is flat, maybe the sun is flat maybe the moon is flat, I conclude the earth is flat. Wonderful think process, Your insane god kept asserting she could read peoples mind, again when she state an event, then state that the person did this because he was thinking . . ., I never knew Atheist were mind readers, especialy of the dead.
What is this?? You need to learn how to think and reason.
vedaxcool: have u heard of common sense? I ask you pls help us ask your god what the Jews worshipped before Yaweh and why did they only copy gods instead of religious practice more question no sensible atheist answers, again like I said have you considered the possibility that there might be similarities between Languages? I laugh in Mesopotemia.
Maybe I'll pardon your ignorance here because there were several occasions where the Israelites did worship other Gods. It is in the Bible.
vedaxcool: first you and your Ignorant god,Again you failed to show how Yaweh became ALLAH, Islam never derived God from Judiasm as any comparison between Judaistic God and the Islamic one will leave you disgrace, both in conception and Behavior, again your Ignorant God failed woefully to tell you that Pre - Islamic arabs worshiped several diety and ALLAH was the chief diety, in fact the Islam restored the sole divinity of ALLAH more info http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allah, bi=ut your pathetic god failed to take into cognisance this reliaty, You said 'It is a fact that the important figures in the Koran were initially from Judaism, then Christianity and finally Islam,' unless you show us a chronogical order of how this happened in the Qur'an, THen you are just exposing your simpleton mind to the NL, as any sensible person will tell you the Qur'an does not revovle around people instead it revovles around ALLAH and even the worst translation will indiate to you it is a formof preaching, I asked again that the mere fact that the style that the Qur'an is written differs in every way from the bible.
You simply wish to ignore the evidence before you. And learn how to read while you're at it. The Israelites said Yahweh was the only God hence their monotheism. Did you read your reference to wikipedia? I hope you're not as illiterate as Mohammed. Read the first two paragraphs and answer what yourself.
vedaxcool: Pls I am not a maybe person, if you have facts that point to that Muhammad PBUH knew how to read then your arguement would have some solid facts, as in any sensible court your case wil be thrown out as Muhammad PBUH clearly said that ALLAH revealed the Qur'an to him, hence the burden of proof falls on u to prove him wrong.
I never said Mohammed knew how to read. One does not need to know how to read to recite poems in their oral traditions. Please learn to think. You do not seem to understand the concept of burden of proof. Please look it up and avoid displaying such ignorance when resources are available.
vedaxcool: Court: Hommer: Your honor, Mr. K copied from mr. H. Judge : How do u know that? Hommer: They wrote similar things. Judge: so? Hommer: They copied Judge: Did any body see them copy? Hommer: No Judge: Do you have any other evidence? Hommer: Timeline your honor? Judge: Hmm, can you explain Hommer: You see Mr. H entered the room first then mr. H followed, hence the sequence of copying occured. Judge(visibly irritated): Ok, what if what you say is true, have you checked the style they wrote in are they similar? Aren't they supposed to be writing the same exam? Hommer: Yes, they wrote differently to decieve us that they were not copying, DUh Judge(Bust out in a fit of laughter): Yes, that sounds credible, but do you know between Mr.k and Mr. H, there were mr. I, Mr. l o p q r s, t, why did mr. K go and copy directly from Mr.K? Hommer(Covulsing): I said they copied they copied timeline says it all they copied they copied final. Judge:Case dismissed, we canno trial people on conjecture thankyou. hommer: I said they copied they copied timeline says it all. Judge: shakes head.
vedaxcool: Heheh, I usually laugh at People like yourself who assume they are too smart to think, Pls NLanders help me ask this man why? why does he believe that the same coincidence explains how the entire Universe came about? was it a coincidence that the earth occpies the position it stands? ws it by the same coincidence that the sun occupies the same position it revovles? was it the same coincidence that Jupiter stays in a position that allows it by gravitational pull prevents massive boulders(Astroids)to knock the hell out of earth? was it the same coincidence that allowed the right amount of Carbondioxide to be present during the formation of the earth of wich too much would have made the earth extremely hot that live wouldn't have thrive on it and too little would have made it extremely cold as carbondioxide traps heat? Was it the same comincidence that the Qur'an states 21:33. It is He Who created the Night and the Day, and the sun and the moon: all [the celestial bodies] swim along, each in its rounded course, when the knowneldge of orbits only came recently? was it the same conicide that made the Qur'an state that 21:30. Do not the Unbelievers see that the heavens and the earth were joined together [as one unit of creation], before we clove them asunder? . . ., which scientist call the biig band? was it . . . Pls you athesit should learn to be honest with your criteria when you use your faaulty logic? to term some things coincidence while other things as being beyound coincidence.
There's no need to ramble so much about what we do know about the solar system. Do you think it is a coincidence that Judaism, Christianity and Islam share so many characters?
vedaxcool: Like I said you have refused thinking instead you prefer regurgitating what your gods like karen amstrong, the atheist elders commitee, etc said, again without pondering you rushed to conclude your gods are beyound questioning, that is pathetic . If you assert that coincidence cannot not be the explanation for the similarities between Judaism and Islam( which you have point only a bunch of prophet rather than God, whom you claim you are telling his history), then coincidence can never explain why the entire universe is the way it is. But people like you wil quickly conclude that the universe came by coincidence. Hypocrisy in every step!
So according to you, Karen Armstrong is my God? How did you come by this? Or are you simply loosely associating any words that strike your fancy? Again you're making an absurd comparison when we consider what we do know about how cultures and religions evolve.
vedaxcool: Obviously, you can hardly score an E in Logics.
Did you understand my reply?
vedaxcool: yes I have confirm that, but how will any rational person claim to be telling a "history" of God without recourse to tp Zoroastrianism and even Akhenetan story truly the book is very misleading indeed. On reading part of the book, your god kepyt using the terms likely mean she is only giving a theory, but to u she has given irrefutable proof against God, I had to laug my heart out when I got to the pages she talked of Islam(by the way she has not showed us any evidence how Muhammad copied the bible) she made funny claims against the Prophet Muhammad PBUH saying all his action were done by political consideration but her innate stupidity stopped her from telling you Mugus that the Pagan meccan offered the Prophet Rulership of them for him to recant Islam, yet if he was a political tactician he would have accepted that proposition instead he refusd and suffered many trials. again madam Ignorance said in her book The death of a god, the quest of the goddess and the triumphant return to the divine sphere were constant religious themes inmany cultures and would recur in the very different religion of the One God worshipped by Jews, Christians and Muslims. . . . pg16, I laugh oh No sensible Muslim has ever uttered such blasphemy of the death of god etc, yet her ability to lump religions togother in other to simplify her lies is very intriging.
You need to learn to read and understand before you post. The creator of the video was referring to a particular God (that of Judaism, Christianity and Islam) there is no need to also go into all Gods that have ever been invented by humans. So, your reference to Zoroastrianism etc is irrelevant. I understand that religious types such as yourself think that you already have all the answers. This is one of the signs of deep ignorance with refusal to learn.
vedaxcool: Example of how conjecture forms the basis of her evidence are
They may not all have worshipped the same deity: it is possible that the God of Abraham, the 'Fear' or 'Kinsman' of Isaac and the 'Mighty One' of Jacob were three separate gods.pg17 We can go further. It is highly likely [/b]that Abraham's God was El, the High God of Canaan.pg17 The deity introduces himself toAbraham as El Shaddai (El of the Mountain), which was one of El's traditional tidespg 17, El SHaddai literally means almighty
This insistence may preserve the distant echoes of a very early debate about the identity of the God of Moses. [b]It has been suggested that Yahweh was originally a warrior god, a god of volcanoes, a god worshipped in Midian, in what is now Jordan. {17} [size=18pt]We shall never know where the Israelites discovered Yahweh[/size], if indeed he really was a completely new deity. Imagine all the fuss about History, hommer keep folllowing Conjecture while rational people follow facts.
Did you look at the thought process that lead to such conclusions?
vedaxcool: see above
What about their differences? rational my trash can!
What evidence you are relying on rational arguements not any concrete evidence and Like I said your god amrstrong failed woefully in explaining what the JEws worshipped before YAweh? or were Jews initially misguided atheist your assertion will live many questions with few answers and I have asked you this question yet you who represent your god-amstrong do not have any answer. you shocked with with you low rational . Now you could just ponder a moment, you would ask why did the mesopotemia religion had a head god? Again could the alledged similarities between the god in Judiasm be due to similarities in Language? Going through this list given http://ancienthistory.about.com/library/weekly/aa102197.htm I could hardly find Yaweh or and like I said Muhammad PBUH could not even read then how could he have copied? no evidence I have come to learn is needed to prove anything by an atheist.
Have you ever heard of oral traditions and folklore? What on earth are you rambling on about? Did you miss the reference in the video to the relevant Gods on the list you referred me to?
vedaxcool: Ignoramus how can you be sure he was unknown? without showing us what the Jews worship before Yaweh means you have no ground to stand on, as we know that a lot of history is missing and you people can only speculate. Christianity got mixed with roman ideas that is why you have the endless formation of denominations. Like i said you are wholly ignorant of Islam, as you could not even explain how Yaweh tranmitted into ALLAH despite the fact that I gave you a lInk to learn more of Islam, all u have been blabbing is about Prophets, what of God, isn't that what you claim we copied. The Qur'an remains the source of info in Islam, the Qur'an is written in an entirely different method compared to the Bible, again you did not show us the arabic bible Muhammad copied, again merely comparing the Qur'an and the bible, the difference become clear, the bible is written in stroy manner, t=while the qur'an gives answer in very short and precise manner. Again people like you have forgotten that there is a possibility that The Language spoken in Mesopotemia could have some similairties to what the Hebrew wrote.
Go back and watch the video again to find out about the onset of the Jewish God from which Islam derived their own God. It is a fact that the important figures in the Koran were initially from Judaism, then Christianity and finally Islam. Your rambling is simply an attempt at obfuscation which will not work because, Judaism is older than Christianity which is older than Islam yet they share important characters. You think about how this happened and how likely your conclusion is.
vedaxcool: hush, bring evidence that point out this copying theory, Christianity was brought by a jew whom kept emphasizing that he did not come to abolish the Law. As for Islam until when you and your god can bring solid evidence then you would betaken seriously, comparing Islam to Christainity is like Comparing Hard and weak, the difference in their conceptionsof God and a lot of doctrines is very much an evidence against you weak speck of "evidence". Non evidence have you brought to show how the trinity Became ALLAH. Yet you are suppose to be rational.
Some of the evidence is in the pages of your Koran. Read it then think about the ages of the religions involved, the first appearance of these characters both mythical and otherwise, then think about how an illiterate prophet was able to know about these characters while also referring to the religions that came before his invented religion.
Why should theives bother to respect these so called men of God when they bleed just like the rest of the population. Some bleed more than their congregation due to their being better fed.
Sweetnecta: thehomer is weak in thinking and logical argument, except that he is stubborn and hard nosed.
Awww I like the ad hominem it really brings out the colour of your eyes.
Sweetnecta: my opinion is based on my letting her know that there is at least UFO under the heavens, and he ignorantly equated it to indicate that am saying that Angel must be a genie/ufo.
What's the relevance of extraterrestrials in this discussion? Whether they're there or not, we do not know. What we do is that we speculate that they may be out there when we consider the size of the universe. What part do angels and genies play in this?
Sweetnecta: i will not respond to him on any of his silly premises, again. youth is almost similar to lack of experience and ability to peel of the onion layers to the truth n this case.
You're free to not respond. But your gullibility is a sad thing to witness. You actually wander the earth expecting people to believe your stories of angels and genies. Genies. As in Aladdin and the magic lamp genies. Sheesh.
vedaxcool: which evidence have you relied on? You and your narator without evidence merged Islam into Judaism and Christianity, then you fool yourself that you prove that the three religions copied each other and your are rational, Rational my foot.
The evidence of the copying is quite clear I already gave you a bunch of people and entities that simply cannot be considered coincidence.
vedaxcool: Wow see how atheist prove things = Coincedence=facts=similarities = copied=LOGICAL THINKINg. Now let me ask you 1 + 1 = ?, I bet if every one were to send the answer to a single mail box, to hommer we all copied each other because we got the same answer. WOW WOW very intelligent way of reasoning. Logics by Conspiracy.
Are you comparing results in mathematics to that obtained in a field like anthropology or comparative religion? You really have your work cut out for you.
vedaxcool: Yes. Did you?
I did. He was referring to the God of Judaism in particular.
vedaxcool: Mr.Conincedence bring facts not fiction and again your silly Documentary claimed there was not any monotheist religion before Judiasm, yet I showed you two "coincidence" of monotheist religion.
See above. The claim was not that there was no monotheism before Judaism but that the God of Judaism became one during a certain period of time.
vedaxcool: Like Is said earlier try thinking sensibly for a change, instead of this pseudo "intelligent" statements and pass yourself off as being an atheist that reasons. If you had any common sense the other explanationto similarities bewteen Christianity and Islam and Judaism is because they are from the same primary source - GOD the almighty- but I see your conicidental brain that does not provide any proof but relies on coincidence to prove things, well good luck to poor thinking indeed.
So your solution is to say that Judaism, Christianity and Islam share similarities because they come from God is common sense? You make me laugh. Which one is more likely and has more evidence supporting it? That a previously unknown God (if available) suddenly manifested himself to Jews (with the issues raised in the video), then to Christians (looking so different from before that for all intents an purposes is a difference character), then to Muslims (who claim characters from the preceding two religions and simply appends one who says he's the last <how does he know?>. Or, going by what we do know about human culture transmissions through fields of study such as anthropology and comparative religion, and the obvious time-line which can be traced from Judaism to Christianity to Islam, that these religions simply copied themselves down the line.
You're welcome. You could also subscribe to the youtube user to follow some of his videos. He also has a series on his deconversion from Christianity which I think you'll like if you liked the one in the OP.
Sweetnecta: @TheHomer; « #20 on: Today at 10:31:16 PM »apply the 'is more than coincidence can explain' creation and its Creator, a relationship you probably think does not exist or not in fullness of it as people like me proclaim it.
Apply it to what?
Sweetnecta: Karen's opinion, is just that. Her own opinion, quite different from the reality. Where ever you may be located on earth, there is something or somebody directly opposite you, whose feet or base will be directly pointing to yours. While neither of you fall away from the earth, yet the earth is moving in two intricate ways. The Holder of you in place is not you, not an unknown, but God Almighty Who has made all the forces acting on you and in you to be at equilibrium. Glory to Him.
She also presented reasons for coming to her conclusions. Those I think are the things you need to attack. So God is holding the entire biosphere to the surface of the earth? You may need to review summaries of Newton's classical works.
Sweetnecta: It is a myth because you dont believe it. You want to see it am sure. A young child told her classmate once in response to the teacher who said God does not exist because you cant see Him, asking if anyone in the class had seen the brain of the teacher. On Youtube, a clear figure with wings in very brilliant light is recorded at it appears prostrated on the top of the Kaaba. Do Angels and Genie exist? You bet.
Existence of an entity or phenomenon is not only based on the ability of a person to see it. You're free to question the teacher on how he came to such a conclusion. The comparison to that of the teacher's brain to me is not a good way to address this question.
Sweetnecta: If you are truly a scientist, I wonder why you dont believe that there could be other beings, like aliens, which many call UFOs, and possible beings in other planets?
Are angels extra-terrestrial entities? Can you demonstrate that ETs are angels and that they have been on earth?
vedaxcool: Who could have stated the fact the way it is? How can any sensible or rational person without proof of any kind just throw caution to the wind and merge Islam with the theories of Judaism and Christianity?
Sweetnecta, one thing I know of this hommer guy is his over Ignorance when it comes to Islam.
Sure I'm ignorant to some extent but the same can be said about virtually any field of knowledge. The difference between us is that I try to educate myself and rely on evidence.
vedaxcool: Going thru the Documentary we come to the conclusion that the Jews/Hebrews never had any god until they mixed up with other people, as he asserted with Elohim, Yaweh, as being derivatives of gods from other Lands, the Question emerges how is it possible for an entire race not to have a god of their own? One thing the author of the entire bogus nonsense failed to note is the fact that even if we were to agree with his notion, then he must be able to provide the god the Isrealites worshipped before the advent of JEDP or whatever that theory is.
Now on Islam, the author including the Op(whose Ignorance of Islam is universally acknowledged) failed to Point how ideas of the OT and The NT came into Islam and thru what medium and at what time. The first point the Ignorant herd of atheist do is to claim that Muhammad PBUH copied from the bible(Just like the Op said in the thread about what happens to people when the die) Now, wt no form of evidence, these herd of Ignoramus will claim we have proven that Muhammad PBUH copied the bible. Note this claim actually was propounded by Christians and Jews, which the atheist accept uncritically (being less logical than Agnostics we couldn't expect any less from them), it funny how this unthinking men will easily follow people they claim are irrational. Talk about intellectual laziness this dudes will come up tops. No where will this herd tell you that Muhammad could not read nor write talkless of copying from the bible. But trust people like homer they always prove things without proving things (Take it as a sort of their religion). No where will this 'herds' tell you that ALLAH in censures certain ideas the biblical Yawehetc. Like look at this verse:
Surah 50:38. We created the heavens and the earth and all between them in Six Periods, nor did any sense of weariness touch Us.
This verse was a direct refutation to what the bible claim God did after he created the earth. Again th Qur'an gave strong criticism of the OT and NT, which it termed corrupted.
Wow so you do not see the similarities in the reference to 6 time periods?
vedaxcool: The documentary posed a strong Lie when it says there was no evidence of Monotheist religion before Judaism, maybe he never heard of Akhenatan: Akhenaten (pronounced /ˌɑːkəˈnɑːtən/;[1] often also spelled Echnaton, Akhnaton, or rarely Ikhnaton; meaning Effective spirit of Aten) was known before the fifth year of his reign as Amenhotep IV (sometimes given its Greek form, Amenophis IV, and meaning Amun is Satisfied), a Pharaoh of the Eighteenth dynasty of Egypt, ruled for 17 years and died in 1336 BC or 1334 BC. He is especially noted for abandoning traditional Egyptian polytheism and introducing worship centered on the Aten, which is sometimes described as monotheistic or henotheistic. An early inscription likens him to the sun as compared to stars, and later official language avoids calling the Aten a god, giving the solar deity a status above mere gods. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akhenaten
Zoroastrianism is a monotheistic religion which was once one of the largest religions on Earth. Zoroastrianism was founded in either the early part of the 12-10th century BCE or possibly as early as the 18th Century BCE. The religion is based on the teachings and philosophies of Zoroaster. The Zoroastrians (or "Parsis" are sometimes credited with being the first monotheists and having had significant influence in the formation of current, larger world religions. Today, some figures put the number of adherents to Zoroastrianism at up to 3.5 million,[43] ranging from regions in South Asia and spread across the globe. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monotheism
Did you watch the video?
vedaxcool: Islam Main articles: Tawhid and Hanif
The holy book of Islam, a religion considered by some as the most monotheistic, the Qur'an asserts the existence of a single and absolute truth that transcends the world; a unique and indivisible being who is independent of the creation.[17] The indivisibility of Allah (God) implies the indivisibility of Allah's sovereignty which in turn leads to the conception of the universe as just, coherent and moral rather than as an existential and moral chaos (as in polytheism). Similarly the Qur'an rejects the binary modes of thinking such as the idea of a duality of God by arguing that both good and evil generate from God's creative act and that evil forces have no power to create anything. Allah in Islam is a universal god rather than a local, tribal or parochial one; an absolute who integrates all affirmative values and brooks no evil.[18]
Tawhid constitutes the foremost article of the Muslim profession.[19] To attribute divinity to a created entity is the only unpardonable sin mentioned in the Qur'an.[18] Muslims believe that the entirety of the Islamic teaching rests on the principle of Tawhid (Oneness of God).[20] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monotheism
On a final note the entire crap documentary of yours is all based on suppositions such as claiming the Isrealite started copying other people's god without even having one of their own, again it supposed that the Isrealite must copy other people's gods once they find themselves in any community different from theirs, Again it suppose that Islam must have some where some how copied the OT and NT, whose ideas are usually refuted and which I have show that Muhammad the founder of Islam could not read nor write, the burden of proof falls on you. etc, rather than hard core facts, the atheist commentator of the documentary showed my earlier assertion that atheist are hardly rational as they want us to think. To him he uncritically accepted the entire garbage because it suited his pre concieved idea about religion, in fact that seems to be the way of western thinking, they come up with an idea and find "evidence" that support that idea. We thought that atheist are supposed to deal with matters rationally, but like I have come to reliaze thay are simply below the peak of rationalism which leaves them always making claim by approximation/despiration. Hommer you need to start thinking instead of regurgitating what othes think.
I notice the noise you generate here without actually thinking and considering the evidence before you. e.g, we do know that Judaism and Christianity came up before Islam. Then, consider the shared characters claimed as prophets in Islam e.g Adam, Noah, Abraham, Jacob, David, Moses, Solomon etc. How about the shared mythical angels e.g Gabriel, Michael, Raphael etc. Try to think about these seeming "coincidences" then come back and repeat your confusion. A parting thought, banging your head against a wall or floor will not change facts. It will only earn you a concussion.
Sweetnecta: @TheHomer: « #15 on: Yesterday at 08:56:46 PM »It is your lack of belief that will engineer your thought and conscience to the extend that you can ignorantly believe that 1 Complete God has to be formulated from axiom of ancient multiple gods or god.
There is evidence for this some of which was presented in the video. Opinions on what should be considered as libel depend on who you ask.
Sweetnecta: New information for you. I am certain that if you didnt know that before, it is now an information you cant deny. Some day, you will know that you and your ilk did not come out of an ape. There is A Creator Who actually created you that you come out of your momma's tommie as a modern man. He created Adam completely matured,ready to be a father of babies. This is a testament to the Power of our Creator.
Don't mistake my sarcasm for agreement with your proposal. Who says man came out of an ape? You simply do not understand the theory of evolution. I advice you to look it up. Adam? Do you not see that these "coincidences" of characters especially when one religious faith comes before another is more than coincidence can explain?
Sweetnecta: I have known about her for over a decade. She was part of many religious documentary miniseries. Most people will have a problem in one area, but broad stroke the whole mansion with the same paint. I remember a christian just this past week saying to me that because the muslims wear long robes, he thinks they are no educated, while one of the Iranian Ayatollah's has a Ph. D. in Classical German Philosophy, something former President George Bush could never have been able to acquire.
You've known about her? Good for you. So what if one Iranian Ayatollah has a doctorate in Philosophy? Did you know that Catholic Bishops too are well educated? What's the relevance of your reference to George Bush in this?
Sweetnecta: You almost made sense with your temper tantrum until you added the myths. Again, it shows your poor judgment of reality. Shared personality is Odumegu Ojukwu to Nigeria. No where was he the head of state of Nigeria, but Biafra. See what I mean? Illusion and reality are two different things. You and Karen are in some strata of illusion. Thank God, you are both on earth, even then. The Mercy of God extends and covers all.
Temper tantrum? Are you saying Islam has no myths? Have you looked at mythical creatures like angels, how about creating humans from a clot?
Who does the pastor pay his own first fruits to? How is it to be paid? Is it the first week, first month or first year's salary (considering this is the beginning of another decade).
Sweetnecta: @TheHomer: « #4 on: Today at 07:19:11 AM »Since Christian God is in Triune, Allah will not be the same as the Christian God. The answer is no.
Of course Jesus son of Mary [as] and Muhammad [as] are Messengers and Prophets of Allah, the non-Triune Deity Who is One Lord God The Creator.
And how about characters such as Moses and Abraham who were mentioned in the video? You may wish to know that not all Christians agree with the doctrine of the trinity.
Sweetnecta: You thehomer dont believe God exist anyway. Maybe I am wrong in this assumption.
Whether I believe or not is irrelevant.
Sweetnecta: Karen Armstrong in her quest recently believed there is God. You need to get her views on Islam. She is not a radical rejector like your ilk. Her problem emanated from her being 17 year old girl going into the convent, and probably in less than 7 years later based on the raging femininity in her discovered that she needed a man.
So that was her problem. Interesting but even if what you say were true, so what?
Sweetnecta: I saw her interview with Texan Moyers on PBS, yesterday along with others in the past including NPRs. At best, like most orientalist experts, she mixed falsehood with truth.
You saw the interview, good for you.
Sweetnecta: Islam stands alone. We are not part of the derivitive[s] of neither Judaism, which she spoke about in what you posted, nor Christianity that is obviously a form of Judaism.
Whether you like it or not, Islam is a part of it especially when one considers the shared prophets and myths.
TCD: Pls give me a link to the video page on Youtube or better the Title of the video so I can search it out. I'm on mobile and can't see embeded videos. Thanks
The title of the clip is A History of God Part 1. It was made by the Youtube user Evid3nc3.
Sweetnecta: @the poser; suddenly your guy, the narrator lump Islam with his difficulty with the Bible.
this is strange, considering that Islam declares its uniqueness from both Judaism and Christianity, and we never say that our God is the Author of the Bible, a book sprinkled with confusion and contradictions.
Have you ever examined the Quran and see that there is no similarity between it and the Bible?
I understand; you guys dont read arabic, and the christian arabs will rather hang their hope on a man who was unable to know everything, rather than follow guidance from a man [as] from them telling them to turn to the God that is always existing.
Islam does not give an indication that the earth begins just the other day, as the Bible wrongly said, if your narrator is rightly quoting from it.
Is Allah the same as the Christian God or not? Were Jesus and Muhammed prophets of the same God or not?
The title of this thread is deceiving. You should have named this thread, "A History of man's perception of God" not "A History of God".
Thanks
I disagree with the claim of deception. The video was about the origins of the Christian and Jewish God and by extension, the Muslim God. I mentioned this in the body. If it were about say the Pantheistic God, then it would have been misleading.
A pretty engaging video on the monotheistic God of Judaism and Christianity and by extension, Islam. With such knowledge, the reasons why this God was so different in the New Testament and many passages in the Old Testament become clear.
Deep Sight: Really I had severally contemplated responding further on this thread, but was absolutely disillusioned. My disillusionment arose from the realization that there will never come a time that thehomer will recognize the contradictions that i point out. Perhaps the terms that we use are simply chasms apart.
However, some of the contradictions are so unbelievably simple, obvious, and self-evident, that I just cannot resist pointing them out again, in some vain and surely mis-placed hope that mr. homer would see that which even the blind would surely see.
What you're calling contradictions are simply due to your failure to understand the required concepts.
Deep Sight: You say "universe-like objects may just exist as the default state of existence." How is this possible sir?
I said existence may be the default state of universe-like objects. It can be considered when one realizes that matter and energy are and have been converted and are being converted into each other. Plus, the fact that the energy of the universe seems to be reducing as the dimensions increase. From this, one may conclude that all the energy and matter within the universe had always been present.
Deep Sight: You are therewith stating physical things to be self-existent. How can you substantiate this claim sir?
You introduced this concept of self existence and defined into its properties which frankly make little sense to me.
Deep Sight: This is really a very nice way to escape the need to answer a clear question regarding physical things. Because we are not speaking of a factor such as motion within the universe for example. We are speaking of the very implicit nature of that which is physical. Thus you are being entirely disingenious and deliberately and fraudulently so. For when I ask -
Can anything physical exist without time or outside of a construct of time? -
The clear answer should be "no," - especially as you have acknowledged that yourself by demanding from me a timeline for things outside the universe! You could not make such a demand if you did not accept that anything material must have a timeline. You thus absolutely cannot argue that the "whole" universe is "exempt" from a requirement from a timeline! Indeed, this is directly contrary to everything you yourself have said.
To make it clear again: you state that the singularity was physical. I ask you under what timeline it existed - and then you state that that is a part-to-whole flaw. Jesus Christ, I am yet to come across a more dumb-founding escapist attempt.
You are dumbfounded due to your inability to grasp the concept that time as we know it and as one of the dimensions of this universe proceeded within the universe. You also need to grasp that if you are proposing a causal mechanism for the universe, the entire concept of causality requires time. Please look it up. It requires events preceding others. You propose this as being outside the universe.
Deep Sight: Because i do not even speak of a part or whole. I speak of the singularity. If it was physical, then it could not exist without or outside any time. And if this is the case, then following your own logic, no singularity existed. Besides this, even under your part-to-whole argument you cannot conceivably claim that a part of a thing must exist in time, but that the whole thing itself exists without or outside time. That is an impossible logical reverse and is quite simply the height of absurdity because given that the "whole" is physical, it must naturally also have a context in which it exists.
Your argument is just plain logically warped - for the explicit reason that the question is begged - in what does the whole exist? ? ?
This is plainly your difficulty in grasping concepts rearing its head again. Time is a part of this universe and commenced within it. We do not know if there are other universes, neither do we know that a concept such as "outside the universe" is coherent.
Deep Sight: Thus if you state that your cells exist within your body, we must naturally wonder what your body exists in. It exists in the atmosphere of the earth - and this by analogy forms its own environment. What is the "environment" for the universe. In what "environment" does it exist? I hope you catch my drift.
Your cells make up your body. Does the fact that the brain cells dwell in fluid mean that the entire body must dwell in a fluid?
Deep Sight: Don't make me laugh. Son, go and revise this statement before i respond to it. FYI, science does not propound a causeless universe. It states that it is still investigating the cause. Science is not as voodoo-istically inclined as you are - as to suggest that motion may magicallyy occur without a trigger. You well know the laws of motion: i set them out to you in a previous thread - and the point was made abundantly clear.
Oooh I'm now proposing voodoo? And you've come in with the laws of motion after you've been corrected on its application? Please go back there and read my reply.
Deep Sight: Your suggestion of causelessness is eminently and irredeemably unscientific.
And your proposal of a disembodied mind is scientific? Besides, how is my proposal unscientific when we do know that the energy content of the universe is still the same and not mysteriously increasing or decreasing.
Have you heard of the concept of a random string of numbers? Does the previous number determine the next?
Deep Sight: It is already tiresome responding to illogical voodoo-istic pseudo-science which does not scratch the surface of any logic or research whatsoever.
Pseudo-science which appeals to magic and voodoo, such as motion without a triggering factor, self-existent physical things, and physical things existing outside time! Your suggestions are worse than the most fabulous tribal myths and religious dogma!
Just say you do not understand rather than labeling what you do not understand as voodoo. If you do not understand, you can ask for help. All you're doing is confusing your proposals with mine and demonstrating your inability to grasp concepts as presented.
Deep Sight: I am certain that not even you can derive any sense from this above.
There you go. I posted it because it makes a lot of sense. There are other proposals about how the universe came into existence. Asking a question which if one of them were true would make the question you ask meaningless and pointless.
Deep Sight: Yes. I state it that way to make you recognise that I am not referring to Santa Claus. No it doesn't because the outward radiation is intrinsic to the nature of the eternal light which is God.
Oh so the God's nature is to "radiate outwards"? What does it mean to "radiate outwards"? (I'm ignoring your "eternal light" phrase).
Deep Sight: Let us use a simple though limited analogy. Let us imagine a fire. Can the fire exist without emitting light? Does the fact that it emits light change the fire? I hope that is simple enough for you to grasp.
Fire? Do you know what a fire is? Fire is an oxidative reaction involving a material, via combustion releasing light, heat and the products of the reaction. We call it fire because we see the light not that we see the light because it is a fire. What part of this analogy refers to the God-factor?
Deep Sight: I laugh. I did not point out contradictions? Such as your space created by or at the moment of the big bang, which is contradictorily expaning into some already existent space? That is not a contradiction?
I never answered this due to the lack of adequate information.
Deep Sight: Such as your singularity which is physical and yet exists outside time - notwithstanding that you go about demanding a timeline for everything? That is not a contradiction?
I simply request time-for proposals of causality because the concept of causality requires a time-line.
Deep Sight: Like your "parts" of the universe which need to exist within time, but were all contained in a singularity that existed without time? That is not a contradiction? Friend, ALL of these are starkly IMPOSSIBLE logical reverses.
Deep Sight: The Kelvin is a unit of measurement of temperature. Stop being preposterous.
But it's physical. Does that mean it's bound with time?
Deep Sight: O, such as your magical "just-existing" universe-like objects, no?
<sigh> It's not dogma. It's just a proposal that I'm making which may or may not be true. If there was evidence demonstrating that it was not true, I would discard it.
Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> the 'appeal to misleading authority' fallacy is self-descriptive and my reply to your claim against this fallacy is one i have dealt with previously in Comment #93
And my response was that Socrates was not an appropriate authority to appeal to.
Uyi Iredia: as for my reason why the genetic fallacy doesn't apply >>> my first use of Socrates was intended as a satire (not as an argument) >>> where it became an argument (thereby changing the context of my mention of Socrates) was when you said that Socrates didn't have the informaton we currently have
I guess the satire didn't come through the medium. And he didn't have the information.
Uyi Iredia: (check comment #89) >>> i agreed to this when i said 'nope' (check comment #92) >>> the rebuttal i made was saying that without him and like-minded people we would not have the information we have >>> that is my argument
Your argument implied was that if Socrates, one of the founders of this dialectic method of argument, was not an atheist, then no one who uses a similar method should be an atheist. This is the genetic fallacy. The fact that we know Socrates pioneered this method and that he was not an atheist does not mean anyone who uses a similar method must not be an atheist.
Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> by non-belief >>> i understand that a person has no belief whatsoever (in a given topic/issue/argument) by negative belief (as i have previously stated) >>> i understand that a person accepts a given topic/issue/argument as not true
This is a simple repetition. If a person does not believe something, does it not mean he thinks the proposal is false or not true?
Uyi Iredia: non-belief is a position that deals with belief (it is passive as regards an argument)
No it's not passive especially when one can demonstrate it. A person who does not believe a statement or proposition must have a reason.
Uyi Iredia: negative belief deals directly with the argument
Actually, they both deal with the argument.
Uyi Iredia: Example >>> for clarity, i'll stick with your example >>> Person B needs to prove that he has no belief that fire harms (i.e he proves his non-belief) >>> you state that he does this by sticking his hand in the flame and showing that no harm occurs >>> he has only proven a negative belief (he believes that it is not true that fire harms) >>> expressing what person b has proven as a positive belief, i say that Person b has proven that he believes that fire does not harm
So demonstrating a belief that fire does not harm a person by his sticking his hand in the flame is different from demonstrating a non-belief in fire harming a person by sticking his hand in the flame? This is getting ludicrous.
Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> oh yes! he did >>> and i surmise elements of evolutionary thought in the Eleusinian mysteries which doubtless influenced Aristotle >>> Darwin is the forbearer of evolutionary philosophy he personifies it >>> without him (and T.X Huxley) they would have been no ground for the present knowledge of evolution which, by the way, is still inconclusive >>> i assert again Socrates is the forbearer of the information we have and is widely acknowledged as a symbol of critical thinking
You need to look up these fallacies: the genetic fallacy and the appeal to misleading authority. They are what you're doing.
Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> okay
*3 >>> *sighs* semantics again >>> this is a contradiction that stares at you in the face
therefore Person B has demonstrated a negative belief and not a non-belief
So, is a non-belief a positive belief? What's the difference between a non-belief and a negative belief? Could you demonstrate this with examples?
logic1: However, you need to be omniscient to come to the conclusion theat there is NO GOD and that was what I was trying to point out.
Given the above and the fact that you do not have absolute knowledge then you cannot logically be an atheist.
You do realize that there are monotheistic religions available. If the God of this monotheist does not exist, then for such a person, God does not exist. But, due to the numerous definitions of God available, this can be quite problematic.
Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> whilst Aristotle beat both of them to it >>> this piece of info is one i got from reading the preface of the Origin of the Species >>> right, but he is the forebearer of the information we currently have
Really, Aristotle did? Whether or not he was the first to think of it still does not make him the best authority currently available. Even Darwin would not be considered the best authority on evolution because, he simply did not have the knowledge that is currently available.
Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> i modified it to fit in the points I was addressing
Ok. I guess I've lost my train of thought there. I'll probably come back to it later.
Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> you err by confusing 'statements' and 'beliefs' >>> the statements by both persons are to explicate a belief >>> the objective of Person B was to evince that he does not believe that fire harms >>> negative belief ! huh ? this is still semantics >>> we are talking about a non-belief (a belief that isn't there) not a negative belief >>> which can be conversely expressed (i.e it is exposed positively)
What about that statement do you not understand? Person B was trying do demonstrate that fire does not harm him. He believed that fire does not harm him i.e he does not believe that fire will harm him. This is a non-belief (that fire harm him).
Uyi Iredia: by negative belief, i understand that a person accepts a thing as not true by positive belief, i understand that a person accepts a thing as true
Yes and Person B accepts that fire harming him is not true.
logic1: Time is of a dimension such that we cannot speak of a commencement of time.
Length is also a dimension. Did it commence?
logic1: A period can commence but time did not commence. Time is simply a measure of the interval between 2 events.
Not quite. Time is the unit that we generally use to refer to the interval between events. You may also note that time itself is measured by some events which have been shown to be regular.
logic1: At the scale of the universe we can speak of time. Indeed the interval (time) between the big bang and now is about 14 billion years. (This is time not space time)
Yes but I meant more in the sense of locating a particular event at the scale of the universe and not the general onset of the various dimensions of the universe. e.g to locate a particular supernova, one would need to state the position and time of the occurrence.
logic1: The fact that we can measure time within a frame of reference is precisely what should tell one that time itself is an absolute dimension that does not reference something else.
Huh? What do you mean?
logic1: The dimensions of the universe are known so there is something like "outside our universe".
Sorry but we do not have enough information to know that such a concept is viable.
logic1: Richard Dawkins even posited the idea of multiverses and there have been multiple scientific propositions based on multiple universes.
Yes and there are other propositions that universes give rise to other universes we simply do not know which one is correct.
logic1: The universe is finite and it is made up of physical matter. The physical matter in the universe must have been caused by something. Science points to a big bang but since the big bang is a physical phenomena it must have been caused by something else.
Again with this assumption of yours referring to a causal factor without your evidence for this alternate time-line.
logic1: You have to bend over backwards and break scientific laws to even argue that any physical body can spontaneously come into existence in a vacuum. It is not scientifically tenable that there was always physical matter because physical matter cannot just exist without having been caused/created by another process - something outside of itself
This is not my argument. My proposal is that objects such as the universe physically exist in some form.
logic1: This is precisely the reason why scientists don't argue with the concept of the uncaused cause.
Causality is more in the realm of philosophy than science.