₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,397 members, 8,522,833 topics. Date: Sunday, 22 November 2026 at 06:47 AM

Toggle theme

Thehomer's Posts

Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 (of 210 pages)

Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 7:36am On Dec 07, 2010
logic1:
You don't know for certain that the stories are mythological. They may sound mythological but that doesn't make them mythological.
You can prove that the stories are mythological by assuming a priori that they are mythological. That would constitute a fallacy!
smiley We can demonstrate that these stories are mythological with knowledge of comparative religion, scientific knowledge, anthropology etc.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 7:33am On Dec 07, 2010
logic1:
God is a JUST Judge because judgement in this case is based on the knowledge of the abilities Human beings have (and God knows our abilities if He created us).
So humans are judged based on their abilities and not what they've done, not done or could do?
Then how does he judge the 1 year old child that dies? Or he doesn't?

logic1:
For you to prove that God is not a just judge then you have to prove that God does not have the knowledge about the abilities Human beings have.
If you don't agree with what I've already demonstrated, then I guess you're implying that God has already judged everyone when he allows them to be collateral damage especially when one considers that people occasionally change their mind.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 7:25am On Dec 07, 2010
logic1:
1. The earth had been corrupted before Job came into the picture.
2. If God had not specially protected Job then Job may have gone through all the things he went through after God lifted the special protection he had been enjoying.
Hmm. I'm asking if you consider such an act just. Also, please remember that his children also died during this test. Yet you consider this a just act.

logic1:
You have to realise that God does not always specifically afflict people on the earth. There is already suffering on the earth and that suffering was caused by the corruption of the earth due to the SIN of humans. IT IS NOT GOD's FAULT!!!
No you claim it is the sin of Adam. The question is whether this is just. Punishing all humans for Adam's sin.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:56pm On Dec 06, 2010
logic1:
I'm not asking for what you agree with I am asking you to summarize WHY you agree with what you agree with.
Also please summarize the evidences and decisions.
I already said this. I believe these things because that is what the evidence points to.
The decision is that I agree with the theories formulated based on this evidence.
As for summaries of the evidence, I have presented you with some on evolution. And you can look up the evidence for the Big Bang. I think it's up to you to present what you think is wrong with them.

logic1:
Read up on randomness, skewness and assymetry. (You can start with Nicholas Taleb's Fooled by randomness).
You will discover that the fact that 2 things look alike does not mean that they have common ancestry.
Evolution is not based only on the physical appearance of two organisms.

logic1:
Yes you can be skeptical about God's existence but you cannot declare that He is inconsistent if you do not have a thorough knowledge about the situations you refer to as making Him inconsistent. If there is even 1 logical thought train that can prove consistency then you do not have enough evidence to say categorically that God is inconsistent.
No you have it the wrong way around. It's if there is one illogical train of thought then that idea is inconsistent.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:42pm On Dec 06, 2010
logic1:
Should I then assume that you have filled all the[b] holes and gaps [/b] in your what you believe?

I seriously doubt that you have filled all the holes.
If you have not filled all the holes in your theory you shouldn't then require someone else to fill all the holes in theirs. That would be hypocritical and would prevent you from really discovering the truth.

I have said before that the best way to make any comparisons would be to examine the logical conclusions of the various theories since all theories have holes because of the fact that as humans, we do not have infinite knowledge (at least not yet!).
My point is that if you are presenting your thoughts on topics such as this, in a sort of essay form, it is generally a good idea to counter the alternatives before the idea gets too long. Especially when they have been raised.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:38pm On Dec 06, 2010
logic1:
The analogy was of Justice not being about niceness. It is therefore not bad as it illustrates the point quite clearly.

As I have said before it is better that you actually state the instances rather than making blanket statements or else you could be making your decisions based on what you think rather than the FACT of what happened.
Ok. I was speaking of Achan in Joshua 7.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:33pm On Dec 06, 2010
logic1:
Ah! but I said what could have been considered as collateral damage could in fact have been just punishment for some other things the sailors may have done.
Then high collateral damage is acceptable especially in a fight since this is just punishment for their probable sins.

logic1:
Once you do not have complete knowledge of a situation you should refrain from passing conclusive judgement.
Well so should you and so should God since all he knows are probabilities.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:29pm On Dec 06, 2010
logic1:
God's laws should be as infallible as the laws of nature.

The laws of contract! You cannot choose to renege on an agreement when one party has given due consideration!

What my analogy was pointing out is that if you have enjoyed the benefit of a position (Jonah being a prophet or the choice to jump off the 30 storey building) then you cannot run away from the responsibilities (Jonah having to do what God told him to or getting killed as a result of falling from a great height).
So what you're saying is that Jonah had no freewill? I ask because it was my understanding that God chose his prophets and not the other way around.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:23pm On Dec 06, 2010
logic1:
Yes you do not understand, and yes maybe Adam did not understand HOW eating the fruit would lead to bacteria and viruses being pathogenic but inspite of his not understanding it He could still have refrained from eating it.
Yet you see this as justice.

logic1:
You do not need to understand HOW something happens for you to believe it.
If you believe a particular person then you can believe what the person is telling you and indeed this is how most humans including you and I operate.
Sorry I do not operate in this way. If someone is giving me a very implausible story e.g like the person met a talking snake, I would still be skeptical.

logic1:
There is simply not enough time to understand the HOWs of everything and in truth we cannot understand the HOWs of everything.
Yes I agree but this does not mean one should simply accept any story they hear because the person saying it was known to be reliable. After all, the person may simply be mistaken.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:18pm On Dec 06, 2010
logic1:
Adam and Eve were HUMAN BEINGS.
I meant you were speaking specifically of Adam and Eve not humanity in general.

logic1:
You can be skeptical about the authority of the Bible but[b] remember [/b] that you do not have enough evidence to prove that the Bible is false!
All I'm saying is that a lot of it is mythological.

logic1:
At any rate, we have not even gotten to that part of the argument.
If you do not take things one at a time you will NEVER be able to truly understand complex logical arguments.
Of course this is why I say that posting such arguments are better done when one also considers counters to it and effectively dismisses them before going too far into the arguments.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:10pm On Dec 06, 2010
logic1:
Job was protected more than others so he went through what others did not go through.
THIS IS NOT PARTIALITY
My point is that giving Job these things then setting him up for the Devil to torment makes him an accomplice and he becomes partial if others are not given these opportunities but were still tortured. I'm still baffled that you consider these permitted tortures to be some sort of just.

logic1:
If Job's friends did not enjoy the protection yet were afflicted as much as Job was then we can start talking about partiality.
How about others who have not had this protection yet were afflicted? I'm speaking of this current world.

logic1:
Yes God is not human but if he created humans then he should have enough knowledge about His creation to be able to act as Judge.
If humans can prove that they did not have the capacity to obey God then they have a case.
This is a case of a judgement based on the knowledge of inherent ability or are you saying a creator cannot know the ability of something He created?
I do not get your point at all.
You would do well to make a logical case knocking out God's qualification as the Judge of Humans[b] inspite of the fact that He created them[/b]
I thought I had made this clear. Since you have pointed out that God does not know everything only probabilities, and to this one adds emergent properties, and the fact that God does not know what it's like to be human, how then can he actually be a just judge even if one were to accept that he created humans?
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 9:34pm On Dec 06, 2010
Deep Sight:
You are making no attempt to either explain or understand the phenomenon of existence. It is lazy to simply state that the religionist is wrong and then sit back and sulk. You need to task yourself to propound what the right answer might in fact be.
I don't just state that the religious person is wrong. I also give reasons why. As to the right answer, for all I know, there may simply be no right answer. But, we may be able to identify wrong answers.

Deep Sight:
It tires me to deal with persons who are so good at asking questions but are never to be seen attempting to provide any answers of their own whatsoever.
I do provide answers of my own when they are requested as I have done on this thread and others.

Deep Sight:
Here is the task and the challenge that I leave for you:
Why something instead of nothing?
Provide your answer.
'Something' may simply be the default state of universe-like objects. The fact is that based on what we do know, this universe started with expansion from a very hot and very dense state. Why do you assume that there must be 'nothing'? Do you think that infinity exists in this universe?

Deep Sight:
Can you advance an intelligible reason for the commencement of the expansion.
I state to you that you can not.
No I cannot. For all I know, it may be based on unknown laws and interactions but whatever it is, we simply do not know at least not yet. This does not mean you are free to plug this gap in our knowledge with whatever you like and call it God.

Deep Sight:
Scientific laws do not exist in a vacuum.
You still have to address the founding question before you can discuss anything -

Why something instead of nothing?
Like I said, 'something' may simply be the default level of universe-like objects.

Deep Sight:
Time is an intangible non congintent constant.
The experience of time, is what differs.
Time itself is simply a constant, nothing more.
For this reason it is ludicruous to limit time to realm of matter.
It is an intangible.
This explanation goes against our knowledge of physics as Einstein was able to demonstrate and we have been able to verify experimentally, that time is not a constant but varies depending on the strength of gravitational force. This concept is much clearer when the dimension of time is also bound with that of space forming a single dimension of space-time.

Deep Sight:
What you and the misguided scientific community need to more correctly state is that you measure the time of the existence of this universe from the point of the expansion. That is altogether different from stating that time commenced with the big bang. That is hog wash. Time is an intangible constant and cannot be seen to "begin" or "end" anywhere, anyhow.
As long as one is in this universe, time for that person started with the Big Bang. Do you have some sort of access to some other time outside of this universe? Or do you wish to claim that time is infinite?

Deep Sight:
Explained above. Time did not commence with the expansion of the universe, contrary to what may be bandied about by misfooted science.
Time is an intangible constant and does not "begin." It cannot begin. It is a constant.
Then please present your evidence to rewrite our scientific knowledge.

Deep Sight:
Besides you still have not shown just why the law of cause and effect should not be seen to apply to the physical universe?
Because it is a law observed in physics and the universe is physical.
So sorry, THAT is special pleading on your part.
I already explained this in my previous post. Time and space as we know it began with the expansion of this universe. We know this because the space within the universe is expanding and time expands with it. This is not special pleading it is backed up with physical evidence.
On the other hand, you claim time was somewhere out there outside the universe. All I request from you is the evidence you have for this other time that did not commence with the Big Bang.

Deep Sight:
What are you talking about? Is it not true as I stated that motion requires energy? Is that not an elementary fact? ? ?
Can you explain to me from whence the energy in the pre-bang singularity originated from.
Oh, I forgot, the atheist santa-claus put it there.
You're getting things mixed up. I agree with the evidence at hand that this super hot and dense state started expanding. That is where I stopped because I simply do not have evidence to go further. You on the other hand posit some other entity that you identify as God being the cause of this state. So you are the one introducing an entity not I. So, if you wish to posit this entity, how do you explain it? Where was it? What created this entity that caused it to create this universe? This goes on till infinity unless you use a special pleading to create this God of yours. Your only claim so far is that "something cannot come out of nothing". So my question is why do you assume 'nothing' must precede this state?

Deep Sight:
Because non-belief in God equates a belief that things sprang out of nothing purposelessly. That is magic.
Have you considered that I have not claimed that 'nothing' must have been the default state?

Deep Sight:
The universe is an outward radiation of the intangible reality that is embedded in the singularity of God.
What does this even mean? This statement is not even wrong. How can you tell if what you have stated above was not the actual purpose of God?

Deep Sight:
I repeat that you are being lazy for limiting yourself to what your so-called "God-believers" recognize.
You have legs, use them to walk for yourself.
Please understand what you are doing. You are taking a word with an implied meaning to lots of people and you wish to co-opt this word to mean something that may not be recognized by these people. I say it is up to you to make your particular meaning clear and to avoid confusion, you may use another word for this.

Deep Sight:
There you have it: an admission that you are not inclined to probe. An admission that you regard inquirity and intellectual curiousity as a waste of time. That is most un-scientific indeed, for a man who screams "science!" before every meal.
Do you go about scientifically taxing and probing the existence of leprechauns? How about Zeus and Quetzalcoatl? Explanations for such creatures are already available so unless I intend to go into anthropology and similar fields, I don't deeply concern myself about them being real to those claiming they saw them or that they did things for them.

Deep Sight:
What shall you call upon to explain it then. . . the tooth fairy perhaps?
Again, you are the one calling on some entity I am not.

Deep Sight:
You imagination that the universe pops out purposelessly is a belief in magic - for which you ridicule the religionist.
What you have claimed to be a purpose is quite meaningless to me.

Deep Sight:
No, they could imply an animal or robot. They could even be a recorded sound.
So you see why you have demonstrated laziness again? - - - The truly inquiring mind keeps all options open and sets out to discern the correct one.
But you see I have not concluded anything. You automatically conclude that there must be someone causing something out there. I simply go where the evidence leads me.

Deep Sight:
This propably explains your misapprehension of the concept of time as something that could possibly have a beginning.
The concept of time that I apply is that used in the scientific field and this began with he Big Bang. So you again are attempting to use time in an unfamiliar way.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:47am On Dec 05, 2010
logic1:
@ thehomer

I think it will do some good if you can state the alternatives to the theistic worldview I am elucidating so that we can trace their logical conclusions first.

If you are this confident about your atheistic stance then surely you have a coherent atheistic worldview we can start with.
If you don't then labeling yourself an atheist is obviously just an exercise in self deceit.
I do not think you are deliberately deceiving yourself hence my conclusion that you have a coherent (at least to you) atheistic worldview.
I already presented them during this discussion. Here is a summary for clarity.

I agree with the best evidence we have for making my decisions. So;
I agree with the Big Bang Theory of the beginning of the universe.
I also agree that humans evolved on this planet sharing common ancestry with other organisms on the planet.
I see no reason for holding any particular books as holy especially when one considers the conditions of the times when they were written.
I am also skeptical about this God of yours who is so inconsistent and seems more like a character invented during the times he was written about.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:38am On Dec 05, 2010
logic1:
If you use this mindset for everything you do in life, you'll most likely NEVER make any decision to do anything. That's why as humans we have emotions that tilt us in one direction even though we may not have ample evidence to actually take that direction.
When we trace out the logical conclusion of the direction which our emotions tilted us in we can then decide to retrace our steps if we find the conclusions to be unpalatable or inconsistent.
I think this is how we make some of our very important decision. You consider the pros and cons of an argument. Besides, what we're talking about here is not just about making a decision but also about justifying it with reasons in a sort of short writing form.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:31am On Dec 05, 2010
logic1:
No, my friend, God did not kill the sailors.
I know he didn't. I was just illustrating a fact of collateral damage. We as humans when punishing people or even in wars in these modern times, we consciously try to avoid collateral damage and genocide. People who do not are considered criminals. Why does God not try to avoid collateral damage?

logic1:
For the consideration of the families of the sailors, you'd do well to understand that most criminals have families. Should we suspend the laws because of that fact?
But we do not punish the criminal and make his families also serve his punishment.

logic1:
Justice is not about fairness or being nice. God has to be JUST, He does not always have to be nice because it's not always good to be nice.
Consider that giving a little boy chocolate may be nice but may not be good if you consider that your actions can result to the child having tooth problems.
Another bad analogy. There are instances where God orders the deaths of families for the supposed crime of one person.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:05am On Dec 05, 2010
logic1:
No! it is not fair to enjoy the benefits of a position and then opt out when the responsibilities show up.
Jonah had free will to choose to become a prophet of God. As soon as he (Jonah) did and started enjoying the benefits of being a prophet, he could not run away from the responsibilities.
Hey but he has free will. He can choose to renege on an agreement. Though I don't recall Jonah having a say in his becoming a prophet.

logic1:
You can choose whether or not you want to jump off a 30 storey building but you cannot change your mind mid-air.
This is a weak analogy. We're talking about what a person with a mind would do not about laws of nature.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 7:59am On Dec 05, 2010
logic1:
Why should a table break if you apply enough force to it? Answer: the physical properties of the table which obey other physical laws dictate that it will break if you apply a particular amount of force to it.
The law is not bad. It is the application of that law that results in a bad outcome (for the table).
The earth was created to be subject to the activities of humans. If human's behaved the way they should have the earth would be "enjoying" the benefits.
You're not talking about humans, you're talking about Adam and Eve.

logic1:
If you trace your line of thinking to its logical conclusion what you'll be saying is that God should not have given humans free will since He knew that there was a small probability that humans would choose to do what was wrong.
No, my conclusion is that there are no good reasons to believe in this God of yours.

logic1:
Without free will, love cannot exist. I think God preferred to choose the creation of beings capable of love inspite of the small probability of sin (and was well within His rights to do so)
I don't understand what sort of law you're referring to because I don't see how a man eating a fruit lead to bacteria and viruses being pathogenic.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 7:53am On Dec 05, 2010
logic1:
The bible does not state that Job's neighbours were under any form of protection or enjoyed any of the privileges that Job enjoyed.
If God created Job then He has the right to do whatever He wants as long as His codes of Justice are not broken.
In that case, God was simply being partial yet you consider this justice?

logic1:
I think the major problem is that you are not really considering the premise "If God Created"
If you have that at the back of your mind and understand its ramifications then most of your questions will be answered.
I'm not considering it but even if I did, like I pointed out, it still wouldn't be just because God does not know what it's like to be human.
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 5:25pm On Dec 04, 2010
Deep Sight:
You must be. I must also respectfully add that your response was lamentably lazy. No offence intended bro.
Please explain.

Deep Sight:
Because the universe is a finite thing which had a definite beginning. It is not eternal in the past.
Everything that is finite and which has a definite beginning also logically has a cause.
Definite beginning in what sense? I hope you understand that all we do know is that it started expanding about 14.7 billion years ago. So are you claiming that it began expanding because of this undefined 'God' of yours?

Deep Sight:
Otherwise it would not have a definite beginning: definite beginnings demand a trigger. That stands to reason: and a position to the contrary is nothing short of believing in Santa Claus and the tooth fairy.
Would you consider scientific laws as causes? Please don't push your misconceptions on me. You are the one assuming some particular entity as being responsible for the expansion of the universe.

Deep Sight:
Perhaps I should place to YOU the very same question: why would any one expect the concept of cause and effect NOT to apply to the universe? ? ?
My point is that we simply do not know if it does apply to the universe because the only evidence we have for this can only be explained within a framework of time which also commenced with the expansion of the universe. And, it becomes absurd to speak of time outside of the universe.

Deep Sight:
The law tells us that no finite effects can be observed in existence where such effects commenced at a given point if there is no cause. This is cast in iron, and I positively challenge you to dispute it: and in so doing cite examples to validate that which you have imagined.
This concept requires time. And time as we know it commenced with our universe.

Deep Sight:
The laws of motion give us to know that nothing is observed to begin or commence movement without a trigger in the form of energy.
Do you wish to posit some sort of energy floating out there outside of this universe? Is this even coherent?

Deep Sight:
Demonstrated. And easily so. I state to you that your assertion that the end result of critical thinking is atheism is about as ludicruous as stating that the end result of critical thinking is a belief in magic.
Wow. I wonder how you relate non-belief in God with belief in magic. How do you draw this comparison?

Deep Sight:
For it denotes a causelessness and purposelessness to the wonder of the universe about us: and to the wonder of our innate faculties: which proposition is beyond absurd.
If you wish to propose a certain cosmic cause please go ahead with your demonstration. And a cosmic purpose please go ahead. I'm curious, what is the purpose of the universe?

Deep Sight:
Now this is the specific portion of your post which struck me as lazy.
Lazy? I'm simply pointing out that you do have your work cut out for you since you seem to wish to make God into something that God believers may not recognize.

Deep Sight:
It is simply not enough for the truly enquiring mind to address the religious ontology of God and remain stuck with it: seeing absurdities therein and not tasking yourself to think beyond that and into the philosophical and logical construct that is denoted by the reference to God.
Of course for the purpose of discussion, this may be fine. To me, it would simply be a waste of time.

Deep Sight:
Indeed all people have a notion of what that construct is: and it simply is the notion of that entity which is responsible for all else that exists. If you and I are able to discern internal inconsistencies in the religiously conceived ontology of that entity, it behoves us to task our minds to probe over and beyond the flawed religious ontology and reflect on that which may be the causative factor of this existence - which factor is what all peoples retain as the core understanding of what God is.
You fail to understand that I see no particular reason to call on an entity to explain the universe.

Deep Sight:
You are like a man who heard footsteps in his yard late at night: and because the neighbours concluded that the footsteps belonged to a ghost, finding that improbable - you conclude that the footsteps belonged to no one: you lazily do not task yourself to ponder the question - given that the neighbours are wrong - who in fact did the footsteps belong to? ? ?
You need a better analogy than this because footsteps already imply person.

Deep Sight:
This has nothing to do with special pleading.
It doesn't?

Deep Sight:
This proves to me that you have yet to get off the mark. I have spent too much energy discussing this in the past - I will only urge you to go and school yourself on the elementary philosophical distinction between necessary things and contingent things. Use google. Or wikipedia. That's at least a start.
Sorry I did not formally study philosophy but from what I've seen, we don't even have to get to this extent because assuming that this God of yours is an uncaused entity that causes the universe is simply a form of special pleading. Otherwise, do you consider the hot and dense state from which the universe began to expand as God?

And I still do not see why this God of yours is necessary.
Christianity Etc › Re: ..... by thehomer: 8:44am On Dec 04, 2010
Ymodulus:
First of all i will like to say a big thank you. Because you guys have evidently added to my current unshakeable state of been. That is you guys have made me strong from believing those false doctrines by those so called christendom. But i have just 1 question i will like to ask.

After much research and findings i came to find out that the following

Jesus is God -false
Hell is a place of torment -false
hell fire does exist - false
Tithing is biblical -false
and so many false errorneous theories promoted by christendom but i still havent get cleared on this


how do i know and believe God does not exist?

Please am been sincere with this Question?
Which God?
On a side note, why do you have a derogatory statement as your location?
Christianity Etc › Re: We Were Created By Extraterrestrial Beings. by thehomer: 8:40am On Dec 04, 2010
Jenwitemi:
An author once wrote a book about the 60 things ancient man did that modern man cannot do today with all his technology, and one of them is building huge megalithic structures.
Yet modern man has built stupendous sky scrapers, I think you really need to look up the stats for the space shuttles that are about to be retired to understand what I'm saying. Check the size the complexity and its reusability. It went into space several times. Then check the sort of technology required to make supersonic planes, compare this too to the modern computer, plasma televisions, ipods and other eletronic decices. Then come back and compare that to moving about a pile of stones while having a large labour force to do this. I'm not saying this feat was not remarkable given the time period in which it was done but to compare it to current technology I think is a joke.

Have you looked at the structures that have been built?
Given this particular claim by this author, I'm quite skeptical about any thing else that comes out of his book.
Christianity Etc › Re: We Were Created By Extraterrestrial Beings. by thehomer: 8:32am On Dec 04, 2010
Jenwitemi:
Superstition? Those structures were built to withstand time and any future cataclysms(like earthquakes, global floods, or earth crust shifts) that might occur, and they did. It has nothing to do with any "superstition" as you falsely assumed.
They were built as tombs for the pharaohs. And the mummified remains of pharaohs and some of their subjects have been found in them. Along with inscriptions and curses. They were built to last because they really honoured their pharaohs who were also considered Gods.

Jenwitemi:
It took a lot of technological knowhow to build such structures, knowhow that modern man still does not possess. The structures obviously some kind of future significance which we do not know yet, and that was why they were built to be standing for millenia. That is also why these structures were chosen as wonders of the world, because how they were built is still beyond modern man's comprehension, which means they have to have been built with ET technology.
That modern man does not possess? Do you think these people could have built skyscrapers, oil rigs in oceans and space shuttles like we have? Why do you think we cannot build such things when we have by far surpassed any of their structures as is expected with progress?
They were chosen as wonders of the world by a Greek traveler. The other six have long fallen. They did not stand for millennia so your statement is actually false.
How they were built is not beyond modern man's comprehension considering the sort of understanding required to build huge suspension bridges.

Jenwitemi:
To you, evolution in engineering is not being able to build structures that can stand up for more than 2 to 3 hundred years. No, it is engineering devolution. Modern is only just rediscovering the supreme engineering skills that once existed in the distant past.
Engineering is not just about building large structures. The complexity of the task and the sorts of materials used are also very important. Do you really think that in today's world, anyone actually has the time and resources to expend building such structures?
Christianity Etc › Re: We Were Created By Extraterrestrial Beings. by thehomer: 8:11am On Dec 04, 2010
Jenwitemi:
That stone weighed 1000 tons, homer. What on earth are you talking about? A thousand tons!! How do you quarry an obelisk of such mass so straight with metal tools? Get real, homer. This is actually getting ridiculous now. Does that stone look like a structure quarried with some metal tools? High tech was at work in that quarry.
So what if it weighed 1000 tons? They had the required tools to dig it up and carve it. What makes you think metal tools cannot be used to make objects with straight edges? How do you expect a limestone structure quarried with metal tools to look? You can try this yourself. Pick up a sharp piece of metal, and scrape it any limestone you find. Then let me know which of them gets scraped. Then imagine this being done by several people together.
What sort of high tech tools are you claiming were actually used?
Christianity Etc › Re: We Were Created By Extraterrestrial Beings. by thehomer: 10:09pm On Dec 03, 2010
Jenwitemi:
As primitive as laser cutters? What kind of tools would have been used to hewn such a huge stone out of a bedrock? And no, it was not built at the time of the romans. The date goes much further back, as well as the age of the pyramids and the sphinx. We have not even started talking about how these monstrous obelisk were transported because they were quarried far from where they were to be used.
That stone was not made of bedrock, it was made of limestone. Limestone is not very dense and it dissolves in acid. Please remember that these people already had metal tools. You may need to compare its density to that of metals.

Do you have some evidence of this new date you wish to present?
Christianity Etc › Re: We Were Created By Extraterrestrial Beings. by thehomer: 9:54pm On Dec 03, 2010
Jenwitemi:
Homer, do you realize that there is very few structures, if any, that modern man has built that can still stand in two hundred years, talkless of millenia? None of those things you mentioned would survive a millenia here on the planet. And yet, the ancient man, who is not supposed to possess any technical knowhow, succeeded in building such structures. What all these have shown us is that we have not been told the truth about our ancient past. We have been terribly lied to. Ancient myths the world over have told us that ETs were here but they removed their presence due to the reasons best known to them and we see the signs of their once upon a time presence on earth.
Huh? What does one have to do with the other? So you think the fact that we've moved on past the sort of superstition that makes people build such structures means such structures cannot be built today? Are you serious? Do you understand the revolutions that have gone on in engineering and building materials that makes such structures paltry by today's standards?

Jenwitemi:
As for modern man building pyramids with the same size and megalithic building materials, let us face it, he can't. So, it is better not to embarass ourselves by trying. Enough of the excuses. Why do you think the great Giza pyramid was chosen as a world wonder and not some space shuttle or whatever?
He can't? Are you for real? What's the relationship between these structures being chosen as World Heritage Sites to their being done by extraterrestrials? We are not building them because we do not need them.
Christianity Etc › Re: We Were Created By Extraterrestrial Beings. by thehomer: 9:45pm On Dec 03, 2010
Deep Sight:
Quote from thehomer -
What I simply mean is this: do you consider it likely that intelligent life exists only on the earth, given the approximate size of the universe.
To answer this we needn't make any comparisons with other universes - given that we know nothing of such.
I already said it was likely.

Deep Sight:
The real question in case you missed it is this: Since planetary engineering and also bio-engineering of living clones is already within the realm of human science and having regard to whatever you may consider is the degree of probability of the existence of intelligent life other than on the earth, would you consider it possible that other civilizations may also have engineered planets and creatures?
Sure it may be possible.

Deep Sight:
Do you consider it absolutely unthinkable, inconceivable and impossible - that the earth could be one such engineered piece?
What I think is simply irrelevant because, I will change my mind if there is good enough evidence for me to do so but so far, the evidence is not good enough. I go with the best evidence available.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 9:38pm On Dec 03, 2010
Uyi Iredia:
*1 >>> why will someone reject the notion of deities and be superstitious/religious at the same time ?
Well you'll simply have to ask those that actually do reject such a notion and remain superstitious or religious because such people actually exist.

Uyi Iredia:
*2 >>> i was referring to militant atheism >>> as for answers >>> i think you could as well check them out on Wikipedia >>> as you seem to have done
Oh you're shifting from atheism to 'militant atheism'? I didn't find any answers about the soul when it came to theism or atheism. Could you please provide them?

Uyi Iredia:
*3 >>> apparently both
Apparently both what?

Uyi Iredia:
*4 >>> how am i redefining atheism ? >>> demonstrate this ?
Your attempts to add other features to it and still call it atheism is an attempt at redefining it.

Uyi Iredia:
*5 >>> did you note how this was done >>> he demonstrated his belief that fire does not harm >>> as long as you do not believe you do not have anything to prove
Huh? Are these two statements not contradictory? He demonstrates his non-belief in fire being harmful and at the same time, one who does not believe has nothing to prove?

Uyi Iredia:
*6 >>> which of course is expressed as a belief >>> and please, i did not say, neither do i agree that a belief alone suffices for a worldview >>> however it is the defining element of a worldview
But you said atheism was a belief and by extension a worldview.

It's right here: the 469th post.
https://www.nairaland.com/nigeria/topic-552049.448.html#msg7259031

You also said there that trying to show that atheism is not a religion or worldview means that it is a belief and a worldview. How does that follow?

Uyi Iredia:
*7 >>> He either believes fire will not harm him, (positive belief) or he does not believe that fire will harm him (active/positive disbelief) >>> corrected
No. Both of those statements are negative. They both have not in them.

Uyi Iredia:
*8 >>> i am referring to militant atheism
This is plainly an attempt to shift the focus of the discussion.

Uyi Iredia:
*9 >>> it will of course define who and how you relate with others >>> and as i have previously said it is predicated on a worldview
You were never able to explain this worldview that is presented by atheism. Do you wish to do so now?

Uyi Iredia:
*10 >>> it is quite odd that one rejects the notion of deities and is religious at the same time >>> however as i statedatheism is primarily founded on materialism
Why is it odd? It seems you do not know the diverse abilities of humans to believe various things.
Making that statement does not make it true most especially as it is plainly false when you consider the example I've given you.

Uyi Iredia:
*11 >>> exactly
Ok then so we are agreed that religions are materialistic beliefs. This means we end up in another contradiction. Religions being both materialistic and non-materialistic beliefs. Since according to you, it doesn't have to be totally materialistic for you to call it a materialistic belief. You said this at the same post referenced above.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 9:05pm On Dec 03, 2010
logic1:
Since we have laid down the rules of the argument which will prevent us from overflogging one side to the detriment of the other and fortunately with a lot of atheists on nairaland, I think we can proceed to finish the Christian argument with little risk of not addressing the atheistic argument.
You may try but the way I see it, going by what you've presented so far, there are simply so many holes that simply rushing through without filling those holes would simply be pointless because the conclusion simply would not follow logically due to the numerous problems pointed out.
This is why I think if you're not going to also show how the alternative would not work, then at least, you would ensure that your premises are sound. If they are not, you would be better off finding ways to make them sound by modifying them or producing better ones so that each successive link remains strong.

But hey you may proceed as you wish I'll just try my best to point out the problems that I find.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:53pm On Dec 03, 2010
logic1:
Jonah was a prophet of God who like Job was already enjoying the benefits of being God's prophet, therefore like Job he had to bear the responsibility of the benefits of being a prophet of God.
So Jonah had no right to decide to no longer be a prophet of God? This means God can force Jonah to do whatever he wants and you say this is free will?

logic1:
Of course the sailors were not perfect saints and most likely deserved the little loss they experienced.
So sailors that were just bystanders should also be punished for being around Jonah? You say they are not perfect saints well how do you know? Even if they were not perfect saints, have you considered that they have families too? This to me is a terrible thing to say. Do you understand what you are implying here? That in a case of say a hostage crisis, do you think it is appropriate to go in and while attempting to kill the six hostage takers, you go in and kill the six hostage takers and another eight hostages out of ten. You then rationalize this by saying "well those hostages were not saints anyway, they probably deserved what they experienced".
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:33pm On Dec 03, 2010
logic1:
You have to realise that God does not usually actively afflict a person with a disease (as in the case of babies). Bacteria became disease causing organisms because of the sin of humans and since they are already disease causing organisms, they will cause damage and hurt to anyone they come in contact with regardless of whether the person has sinned or not.
And you call this justice for Adam?

logic1:
Bacteria may not be sent by God, bacteria are simply acting out the corrupt state of the earth.
Why should the earth become corrupt because Adam ate a fruit? Even we humans try to prevent the spread of bad habits why not God? Did he try and fail? Oh yes he did with Noah.

logic1:
Babies are born into a corrupt earth by corrupt parents so the responsibility is on their parents who gave birth to them in a corrupt world.
The world did not become corrupt because of the baby, the world was already corrupt therefore God is not responsible.
And I say God allowed the world to be corrupt why would he do that knowing babies would come in and die some before they are 7 days old.

logic1:
It is interesting that we always want to shift responsibility to someone else or something else everytime.
This is laying responsibilities where they should be if one is to believe in this sort of God. He knew these things will happen yet he set things up so that they would happen.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:27pm On Dec 03, 2010
logic1:
Humans were placed in charge of creation and their sin corrupted all of creation.
Why should the sins of humans corrupt all of creation? Was that really the best option?

logic1:
Antelopes and lions do not have a soul and are not personalities if you consider the Creation story as outlined by the bible (which is what we are considering presently).

Animals are simply biological robots, that's why it is not wrong to kill and cook an antelope or a lion.

According to the bible, the only reason why we are intelligent and are having all these arguments is that God did something that made us living souls. Animals are not living souls therefore there really is no case of fairness per se when it gets to them.
My question is whether lions started killing and eating antelopes before or after Adam committed his sin.
Animals are biological robots? Are babies less than 1 year biological robots? Do you think animals feel pain? Is it wrong to torture animals for pleasure?
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:11pm On Dec 03, 2010
logic1:
God may have protected Job because He knew that one day He would prove to the devil that some people could be righteous and therefore to maintain balance He first gave Job preferential treatment in preparation of the test which would otherwise be unfair.
So was his neighbour also under protection?

EDIT: And God actually kept Job as a test for the Devil?

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 (of 210 pages)