₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,398 members, 8,522,839 topics. Date: Sunday, 22 November 2026 at 07:01 AM

Toggle theme

Thehomer's Posts

Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 (of 210 pages)

Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 9:31pm On Nov 26, 2010
logic1:
Omniscience is the major issue and we have said that God cannot be omniscient in the way that you refer to the word.

Human free will is contradictory to God having exact knowledge.

If God created humans then He is in the best position to Judge Humans because he knows the capabilities He built into humans.
But God does not understand the human condition. i.e He does not know what it is to be human.

logic1:
It should readily occur to anyone reading this that only someone who is not part of a crime (the Judge) is in a position to judge the crime.
We would not expect one of the current members of Al-qaieda to determine the punishment of Osama Bin Laden
The judge is still human or a group of humans working based on human principles.

logic1:
It would not be an overstatement to say there is no human being living on the earth right now that has never sinned (except babies - who would not have the knowledge to Judge).
If we are all part of the crime, surely none of us is qualified to be Judge.
Not necessarily true. Besides, what if there was no crime? Or is simply being born a crime?
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 9:26pm On Nov 26, 2010
logic1:
Everything about the history of the universe (including science) are all BIG IFs with huge empirically unverified assumptions.
Do you have examples of this?

logic1:
Consider that science in general has many BIG IFs.
Even in something as basic as mathematics we still use assumptions that are only verified after the fact (and most times until someone else has a better mathematical solution)
Such as?
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 9:24pm On Nov 26, 2010
logic1:
The laws we are refering to here are NOT HUMAN LAWS.
That's why I said you're equivocating between human laws i.e legal and physical laws.

logic1:
We are talking about the laws/principles that guide the actions of a being that is external to our universe.
Are moral laws external to the universe?
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 9:19pm On Nov 26, 2010
logic1:
That you do not agree with something does not mean that that thing is not logically possible.
Once again, God that I am refering to in this thread is such that He has to be Just and Morally upright else He would not be God in the sense that I am refering to.
Look through steps 1-4 again.
Your evidence for his morality is questionable. Consider the dilemma I pointed out and your answer to it. This is a poor indicator of good morality. Plus, you did not address the other alternatives I presented.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:55pm On Nov 26, 2010
logic1:
The bible never used the word omniscient and has never (as much as I know - And I have read the bible through) implied that God is omniscient in the way that most people use it.
This is an interesting take. But he is perfect. Why did he create imperfection?

logic1:
I think God knows all the possible options that we can take but does not know the exact option that we will take therefore in a sense he has general knowledge on the possible places that one can end up not that he knows the exact place one will end up.
Ok then. So God does not know all just probabilities. He is also limited by time as humans are.

logic1:
If God knows the choice that we will make then we do not have free will.
I think I have also addressed this issue on Nairaland.
Sorry. I must have missed where you did.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:37pm On Nov 26, 2010
logic1:
Evil came as a result of the wrong choice of a being that had free will.

I think we have addressed that in this this thread.
How about suffering? How did this come about?
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:32pm On Nov 26, 2010
logic1:
Please post the bible verses so we can address them.
The place where the bible says God creates peace and evil, evil there means trouble/ chaos as a form of judgement not evil in the sense that we mean on this thread.
Judgement? Have you considered e.g Job?

logic1:
If your father punishes you for doing something bad that doesn't make him evil, it makes him GOOD
What if he punishes you by impoverishing you, inflicting you with disease and murdering your children or inviting someone else to do this? Would this make him evil?
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 8:28pm On Nov 26, 2010
Uyi Iredia:
this is an enviable environment for people of religious/irreligious leanings to discourse and learn on what free thinking is >>> i do not agree that religions are dogmatic per se >>> free-thinking could possibly as dogmatic as religions are acclaimed to be >>> Rhino's questions connote a meme that is quite popular >>> that atheism or agnosticism is synonymous with free-thinking >>> homer, as it were, has 'caught the bug'
What bug? Note that I never implied that they were synonyms but that one generally leads to the other.

Uyi Iredia:
a couple of questions >>> must one think ?  >>> as it were ? >>> and we aren't just talking about thinking >>> logical thinking of order attributed
to philosophers >>> must free-thinking arrive at an absolute truth ? >>> one which is universally accepted ? >>> doesn't it cease to become free-thought in so doing ?
Thinking is one of the major distinguishing factor of humans so in a simple answer, yes, one must think.

Uyi Iredia:
>>> i used to be averse to Kierkegaard's notion >>> but of recent i realize that he was right in positing that truth is subjective >>> we ultimately measure the kind of truth we subscribe to >>> in light of this I decided that : Truth is absolutely relative and relatively absolute
Truth is relative? Do you really want to factually go down this route?

Uyi Iredia:
*i won't attribute this quote to me because i am not sure whether this is a vague remembrance from a piece* It is absolutely relative because it is impossible to know all things >>> Knowledge is an infinite attribute >>> this is proven by the fact that there is always new knowledge to gain about the simplest of concepts/postulates/qustios e.g man, 1+1=2, what is evil ? >>> it is relatively absolute because inspite of the fact that there will always be knowledge we don't know >>> we are certain of knowledge we have

. . .
One doesn't need to know all things to be sure of certain facts.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Is A Religion by thehomer: 8:16pm On Nov 26, 2010
Uyi Iredia:
check my previous post again >>> i have 'filled in the gaps'
Which of them?
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:13am On Nov 26, 2010
logic1:
I did not say that it would and it is apparent that the universe would not collapse if humans were bad to each other.
This was what you said. What then were you trying to say?

logic1:
Furthermore the universe would collapse without justice at its most basic form (Cause and effect or Newtons 3rd law)
logic1:
The laws of universe can tell us about the character of the being that created the universe if we assume a creator.
Physical laws reveal something about the character of an entity to the exclusion of others? I'm all ears.

logic1:
In other words, the characteristics of a product may be able to tell us something of the character of the manufacturer.
Really? To stretch your analogy a bit, what does the fact that a perfume smells nice tell you about the manufacturer of the perfume to the exclusion of other perfume manufacturers?

Please understand that each time you assume a creator, you're begging the question.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:06am On Nov 26, 2010
logic1:
There can be at least as many possibilities as there are humans on the earth.
it would be impossible to go through all the various possibilities in order to come to a conclusion.
Then pick the strongest three or four and present those along with your view.

logic1:
There cannot be only an absolutely evil God. Why would an absolutely evil God create a sense of Justice in his creation.
Maybe the sense of justice is an illusion?

logic1:
If God were partially evil amd partially good then God is not stable and would not fit the description I gave in my former posts regarding Justice.
If this is what fits the observation, who are you to impose your own views on God about how he should be?

logic1:
You do not believe in the existence of God so you logically should not care if I argue for the existence of just one God as opposed to having one evil God and one good God.
I care about the logical reasons presented for the various sides of an argument.

logic1:
We have to eliminate the options one by one. If we attempt everything at once we'll be at risk of confusing ourselves
Then please do so.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:01am On Nov 26, 2010
logic1:
I have dealt with the alternatives by asking that we trace the logical conclusions of the atheistic and theistic worldviews.
I don't even this can be properly done. But you may try and let us examine the results together.

logic1:
The dilemma only surfaces if we are talking about moral goodness that is not necessarily based on Justice.
The moral goodness I refer to when talking about God is the same as Justice. In other words whatever is just is what I refer to as morally good.
Ok.

logic1:
If we assume that God would self destruct, and could not remain God except He is just then the dilemma vanishes. In other words, God cannot be unjust therefore whatever He commands is always Just and morally good in the sense of upholding Justice not just because God commanded it but because God cannot command something that is unjust.
The dilemma still remains.

This answer to the dilemma is disturbing. So God ordering the murder of babies and genocide is actually just and moral? I think your moral compass needs to be evaluated.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 7:56am On Nov 26, 2010
logic1:
Order is a reference to rank. If we rank all the beings being referred to in this thread then God is of a higher rank or order than humans if He created Humans.
quote

I know what the words "order" and "rank" mean. What I do not understand about your use is how you go about assigning orders or ranks to various objects. I presented you with a list to rank/order and present us with the reasoning behind this. I also recall that on another list, you ordered some objects without a reference to any form of creation.

logic1:
Is there anyone else who does not understand the above or that the creator of a thing is of a higher order or rank when compared to his/her creation?
If there is anyone who does, I'll like to hear what they understand by the use of order or rank here.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 7:52am On Nov 26, 2010
logic1:
When I refer to unknowable, I mean unknowable by scientific research.
This is an equivocation on the use of the word "unknowable" or are you implying that the scientific method of knowing is the only one?

logic1:
If we assume that God exists then it is possible and logical to say that God could have revealed some things to the author of the bible if He wanted to.
Why assume this when considering the Bible? Again, there are many other options more plausible than making this assumption.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 7:46am On Nov 26, 2010
logic1:
I considered the alternatives when I said the best way to go about it was to trace out the logical conclusions of atheism and theism.
How can you even make logical conclusions of such concepts? Attempting to make logical conclusions of these concepts is very hasty indeed.

logic1:
Atheism has something to do with the theory of HOW we came to be.
What does it say about this?

logic1:
Atheism may not constitute a complete worldview by itself, but it is the basis of some worldviews we refer to as atheistic worldviews.
Ok. This is why I think attempting to make conclusions using just atheism will be hasty due to the various possibilities.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 7:40am On Nov 26, 2010
logic1:
I'm in the process of describing the information I have. When we are through then we'll see if there's enough information to stick with the God as described by the Bible.
Ok then. But I still think you need to plug the gaps as you go along even before you arrive at your final conclusion.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 7:38am On Nov 26, 2010
logic1:
Yes, the best we know right now is that something cannot come out of nothing at least in our known universe.
I already asked why you assume "nothing" exists in the universe when we also accept that infinity does not exist in the universe.
Christianity Etc › Re: Nigeria Theatres Shut By Sharia by thehomer: 12:37am On Nov 26, 2010
These barbaric philistines are at it again. They now have a state supported militia that is separate from the police to enforce bronze and iron age laws.
Christianity Etc › Re: We Were Created By Extraterrestrial Beings. by thehomer: 12:31am On Nov 26, 2010
@ ROSSIKE

Maybe what was presented is simply more mythology demonstrating the richness of human imagination? Consider the various types of books written today from fantasy to horror would you believe these are also factual?
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 12:25am On Nov 26, 2010
[quote author=Rhino.4dm link=topic=556936.msg7215463#msg7215463 date=1290696159]@ nuclear boy.

Why must it be that whenever you said there is God you will be accuse of not properly using your free thinking ability?[/quote]I think it's because the word "God" is deeply associated with religions which of course come from other people.

[quote author=Rhino.4dm link=topic=556936.msg7215463#msg7215463 date=1290696159]Must conclusion of there is no God be at the apex of free/critical thinking?[/quote]I think it is the final conclusion of critical thinking.

[quote author=Rhino.4dm link=topic=556936.msg7215463#msg7215463 date=1290696159]Why not otherwise?[/quote]I think it's because including God as it is described in various religions is simply an unsatisfactory answer in the light of current knowledge to the numerous questions raised by human existence.

[quote author=Rhino.4dm link=topic=556936.msg7215463#msg7215463 date=1290696159]cant i arrive at God with my critical and free thinking ability? Why must it be perceive otherwise?[/quote]I don't think so. If you do, then I doubt that it's the same type of God as described in religious books.

Another important consideration about free thinking is that it requires asking of questions. Lots of questions. Difficult questions. Even questions that may be considered taboo in some societies.
Christianity Etc › Re: Religion And Education In Nigeria by thehomer: 12:05am On Nov 26, 2010
Uyi Iredia:
@ lng >>> i agree with some aspects of your post >>> i like as you mention that atheism spreads by beguiling with the notion of free thought >>> a misleading term >>> and when i first encountered freethought >>> i was bemused to find it was all atheist >>> i was thinking a discussion of science and stuff with mutual respect for religious differences
Why do you think your religious opinions ought to be respected? Do you respect Kim Jong Il's opinion on the best way to lead North Korea? Maybe you need to realize that some of us actually respect people too much to not respect their religious opinions.

Uyi Iredia:
however >>> i don't agree that one has to be religious to be ethical >>> not so >>> at least not the way you imply
Damn right. I'll go further to say ethical in the reasonable sense.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Is A Religion by thehomer: 12:01am On Nov 26, 2010
Uyi Iredia:
*1 >>> we'll talk on that later >>> meanwhile check [url=http://www.cosmicfingerprints.com/blog/this out[/url]
What argument do you wish to address?

Uyi Iredia:
*2 >>> i have
No you have not demonstrated how scientific evidence is ambiguous and subjective.

Uyi Iredia:
*3 >>> it would >>> inasmuch as constructs are similar at a given level >>> the resultant plasticity would allow my definition of language to apply to pigeon language
Did you read what you posted? It was specifically about human language.

Uyi Iredia:
*4 >>> yeah >>> which was why i said it was straw man
How is it a straw man?

Uyi Iredia:
*5 >>> so you think religious people didn't inquire into the constituents of water ?
Not just inquire but know that it was two parts of an element to one part of another element.

Uyi Iredia:
*6 >>> which is why i asked for an example >>> my post is replete with the evidences you hold so dearly
No it isn't. Your post is riddled with poor evidence or evidence that actually contradicts what you're trying to say. Here's an example. Can you present evidence of your religion helping us determine the distance from earth to the nearest star other than the sun?

Uyi Iredia:
*7 >>> bad logic >>> as i presumed that is hampering our discourse >>> my core point can be summarized thus : as long as one makes a dichotomy out of the concept of science and religion one invariably precludes their similarities >>>
I thought it was resolved that what we're discussing are the differences since we agree they are similar on some levels?

Uyi Iredia:
the relevance of this to my castigation of atheism (militant atheism to be precise) as a religion >>> is captured by the quote i made earlier >>> "A rejection of belief in deities is primarily founded upon materialistic beliefs embodied by a scientific worldview"
Not just that, there is also the poor evidence supporting beliefs in such deities even from the religious texts themselves and human reasoning.

Uyi Iredia:
*8 >>>
Nothing to add? That was an example for you.

Uyi Iredia:
*9 >>> it shows
Thank you.

Uyi Iredia:
*10 >>> not yet
Why not? How then do you actually wish to then point out that atheism of any sort is a religion if you've refused to clarify what you mean by religion?

Uyi Iredia:
*11 >>> and what can be carefully matched is random >>>
Huh? huh

Uyi Iredia:
anything can be chosen to be carefully matched >>>
What's the relevance of this?

Uyi Iredia:
true, multiple sects is a point against Christianity and science >>> BTW Christians also critique the Bible >>> resulting in skeptics as yourself >>> or other likely results
There you go.

Uyi Iredia:
*12 >>> so what ? >>> random discoveries/occurrences effectuate scientific theories
Random discoveries do not write theories, humans do.

Uyi Iredia:
*13 >>> j'adoube >>> but not because i made a false blunder >>> i'm aware that other species also make use of tools and this is a sign of cognition (not scientific thinking) >>> however your presenting of farming as evidence of scientific thinking is flawed
How is it flawed?

Uyi Iredia:
>>> there are a species of ant that engage in a form of farming *they capture another genus of ant and rear their milk* >>> i am also aware that bees produce honey (a type of animal farming i presume ?) >>> i came across these facts in an encyclopedia "Tell Me Why"_evidence of course >>> it is likely that other species can exhibit scientific thinking >>> i intend to check this out in the forseeable future
I suspect you're speaking of the aphid here. You're confusing a metaphor of a symbiotic relationship for farming. Honey production in bees? What does this have to do with agriculture?

Uyi Iredia:
*14 >>> based on what ?
Based on the fact that humans humans write theories and not discoveries since discoveries cannot think or write.

Uyi Iredia:
*15 >>> redundant and circular >>> those were solid pieces of evidence which you hogwashed >>> nevertheless google Thomas Kuhn >>> then let's talk >>> otherwise >>> kaput
What is circular there? I simply pointed out how your claim was flat out wrong.
And what's the relevance of Thomas Kuhn to this discussion?

Uyi Iredia:
*16 >>> same goes for the cleric
What is the specialized knowledge that the cleric requires other than just making stuff up as he goes along?

Please do not evade the questions I asked you.
Christianity Etc › Re: Religion And Education In Nigeria by thehomer: 11:30pm On Nov 25, 2010
Uyi Iredia:
oh! >>> homer, nice to see you on this post >>> wouldn't mind you taking me up anytime
Ok.

Uyi Iredia:
*1 >>> the presence of secularism would vex religious adherents >>> especially religious fundamentalists >>> as i connoted earlier religion is deeply entrenched in society and secularism as a school of thought wouldn't gain acceptance easily >>> it wouldn't be hard to imagine, say, a sect like the infamous Boko Haram going on another 'cleansing ritual' should something akin to CFA crop up in one of 'em Northern colleges >>> the inevitable fracas which'll occur due to the manifest of skeptic/secularist/'free-thinking' clubs would worsen the imbroglio >>> the very imbroglio the OP rightly articulates >>> This is what i mean when i say secularism will worsen the situation
Can it really be worsened because free thinkers are around? I hope you realize that these fanatics kill any one who does not agree with them. Also, consider the southern parts of Nigeria. Would it not improve things there?

Uyi Iredia:
*2 >>> I concur
Ok.

Uyi Iredia:
*3 >>> i'd propose you use the term religious fanaticism >>> not fundamentalism >>> all fanatics are fundamentalists >>> but the converse is not true >>> i, for instance, consider myself as a Christian fundamentalist >>> do i pass off for a fanatic ? as the likes of chakula, Mudley et al *as well as other fanatics, Christians much inclusive, who you must've have chanced*
Ok I will. But, I'm willing to bet that you are not a religious fundamentalist.

Uyi Iredia:
a fact to note is that >>> religious violence is much pervasive in the North than the South
Yeah and I think a dose of secularism and rational thinking will be a good thing. Especially when these people realize that no one group has some sort of monopoly on violence.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 11:22pm On Nov 25, 2010
logic1:
I'm pausing for contributions,
Contributed.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 11:21pm On Nov 25, 2010
logic1:
Step 8: Establish that the introduction of Evil must have created human suffering.

1. If God is good and created the universe good then evil was not present when He created the universe.
This is a circular argument because we are yet to establish that the universe was created good.

logic1:
2. If evil was not present when God created the universe and God would not remain God if He was evil then evil must have come from one of God's creations. (we have addressed this in a previous step)
But evil was present in heaven or is heaven a part of the universe?

logic1:
3. Suffering is not a good consequence therefore it cannot be a consequence for good actions.
4. therefore human suffering can only be the consequence of evil.
It may also be the consequence of bad diets, microbes, the environment etc.

logic1:
This is not to say that a particular person's suffering is always caused by his/her bad deeds. What we are saying is that the introduction of evil must have been what generated human suffering as its consequence (in general).
A bad cop out with too many assumptions. How about when God decrees it that way?
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 11:15pm On Nov 25, 2010
logic1:
Step 7: Establish that evil actions produce evil consequences and God is in a position to Judge.

1. We have established that God must be Just / Morally Upright
No we haven't.

logic1:
2. The universe has justice at its foundations (the law of cause and effect) in other words everything has a consequence.
This is a fallacy of equivocation. You're equivocating physical laws with human laws.

logic1:
3. If everything has a consequence then Good deeds should have a good consequence and Evil deeds should have an evil consequence for justice to be maintained.
This is a big if with huge unverified assumptions.

logic1:
4. If God created humans then He is in the right position to determine the evil consequences that evil actions deserve as He is in the best position to know the full effect of the evil action.
Another huge assumption. Besides, I don't think an eternal, omnipotent, omniscient entity is in the best position to judge humans who have none of those features.

logic1:
A human example of the above is played out in codes of justice in mose cultures that have spelt out punishments for actions considered evil to maintain a sense of Justice.
Humans are in a better position to decide.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 11:08pm On Nov 25, 2010
logic1:
I think posting steps 1 -6 again will really help so here they are:

Step 1: Prove that God exists.

My belief in the existence of God rests on the following pillars

1. The fact that we are discussing about the existence of God means we are real.
2. If we are real then we came from somewhere. Either we were created by another being or we somehow materialized from nothing.
3. I believe we were created by another being because as far as I know no human being has ever proved that something can come out of nothing at least not in the known universe.
4. If we were created by another being then that being is who I refer to as God.
We've been through this.

logic1:
Step 2: Establish that God is a God that thinks and is aware of His creation

1. A being can only create another being of at most equal order to it.

2. Human beings can think, they are aware of their surroundings, and they can create

3 If 1 and 2 are true and God created Human beings then God can think and is aware of His creation.

4. Therefore God is not "Nature" or a set of natural laws. God is a being of the same or a higher order than Human beings which are of the highest order that we are aware of physically.
You never clarified what you meant by "order".

logic1:
Step 3: Establish that God is of a higher order than Humans.

Humans do not understand everything about themselves. We don't have the cure to all diseases.
We have very little knowledge
Therefore if God created all the things that we know and the things that we don't know then God must be of an order higher than we are.
Again, same problem as above.

logic1:
Step 4: Establish that God is Just / Morally Upright

1. Human beings have a sense of a morality and since there has always been a sense of morality in all recorded history we can conclude that humans were created with a sense of morality.
Why assume humans were created? There are other alternatives.

logic1:
2. If we were created with a sense of morality then our creator must be moral as a moral law requires a moral lawgiver.
If you go by this assumption, you call up Euthphro's dilemma. To paraphrase, is what is morally good commanded by God because it is morally good, or is it morally good because it is commanded by God?

logic1:
3. Therefore God is Just and Morally Upright.
Don't be so hasty. Have you considered ruled out other options such as there being two Gods. One absolutely good and the other absolutely evil? How about there being only an evil God?

logic1:
Furthermore the universe would collapse without justice at its most basic form (Cause and effect or Newtons 3rd law)
This assumption requires a massive amount of hubris. The universe would collapse if humans were bad to each other? Wow. Also, what does Newton's 3rd law have to do with what you're saying here?

logic1:
step 5: Establish the existence of evil

1. Humans of all tribes have a sense that something is not quite right.
2. Humans of all tribes have a word for bad or evil and there is a general agreement that people do evil things
3. There are jails all around the world for the punishment of people that commit crimes.
4. Crimes that are considered inhuman have been recorded throughout history
5. We have examples of hitler, stalin, mussollini et cetera
6. Therefore Evil is a reality that cannot be explained away.
Ok.

logic1:
step 6: Establish that evil could not have come from God therefore humans were not created evil

1. We have established in step 4 that God is Just / Morally upright.
No we have not.

logic1:
2. A just and morally upright God cannot create evil
But the Christian God regularly uses evil.

logic1:
3. If God did not create evil and God created humans then it means that when God created Humans, humans were not evil.
Where then do you hypothesize that evil came from?

logic1:
4. Therefore Humans were not created evil.
I think your premises have fallen.

logic1:
Step 6a: The fact that God created the being that created evil does not mean that God created evil.
1. God decided to create a being with free will
But God is perfect and omniscient.

logic1:
2. That being (having free will - not manipulated by God) created evil
If God is omniscient, then he is an accessory to the origin of evil. He also does not shy away from using evil.

logic1:
3. The being could have created without God's intervention because the being had free will
4. Since the created being created evil independent of God then God did not create evil and is not responsible for it.
God is responsible since he had foreknowledge of everything. He is an accessory to evil.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:33pm On Nov 25, 2010
logic1:
The bible contains the revelations of God to humans but that does not stop you from quoting it if you think I am contradicting it.

You have to know the exact passage ( a part of the bible) I am contradicting to know that I am contradicting the bible.
You are contradicting the entire Bible because it is a revelation of what you consider to be unknowable. If it is unknowable, then how can it be known to the authors?
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:32pm On Nov 25, 2010
logic1:
yes you can have enough information to rule out certain creation theories (if they have irreconcilable contradictions)
Good

logic1:
The reasons become irrelevant if the premise is false.

An unknown premise does not make a logical case irrelevant.
It does if you do not consider the other alternatives rather than presenting just the one you like.

logic1:
Every theory of creation (including atheistic ones) is based on an unknown premise.
I don't think atheism has anything to do with a theory of creation.

logic1:
We don't know how life can be formed from inorganic matter yet that is the premise on which the entire atheistic worldview rests on.
Atheism is not a worldview. It is simply a non-belief in Gods.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:24pm On Nov 25, 2010
logic1:
I do not have 100% information, but I believe I have enough information to stick with God. It is the information I have that I'm in the process of sharing.
Ok but I don't think you do have enough information to stick with the Christian God.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:23pm On Nov 25, 2010
logic1:
It's not illogical statements that are welcome, I meant that if you notice any illogical statements you should point them out.
Oh ok.
Christianity Etc › Re: Religion And Education In Nigeria by thehomer: 8:57pm On Nov 24, 2010
Uyi Iredia:
articulate >>> was what came to my mind after reading the article

and naive >>> secularism would further add to the quandary of problems in the Nigerian context
How would it further add to the problems?

Uyi Iredia:
>>> furthermore skepticism, secularism and freethought >>> don't equate to critical thinking/inquiry and reason >>> an annoying demotic characterizing atheists
No they don't but they are crucial for critical thinking to rise and flourish.

Uyi Iredia:
however >>> i would be an ox-head to deny that religious fundamentalism is a grave problem in our schools >>> CFA wouldn't solve it_which is what is connoted in this post_the problem is much deeper than that
It will go a long way in reducing it.

Uyi Iredia:
and i'm too lazy to start highlighting them on this post >>> some other time >>> or if someone takes me up on it
Sure there are other problems but I think that of religious fundamentalism is quite pernicious.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 (of 210 pages)