Christianity Etc › Re: Linear Chance? by thehomer: 11:37pm On Dec 18, 2010 |
Deep Sight: What you need to do is address the scientific posers he raised on the cosmological question. I'll just respond to both posts. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Linear Chance? by thehomer: 5:18pm On Dec 18, 2010 |
Deep Sight: have you been able to review justcools posts above? Yes I have. It was quite long and rambling and was also sprinkled with insults. |
Christianity Etc › Re: "Einstein Was Right, You Can Be In Two Places At Once" by thehomer: 12:05pm On Dec 18, 2010 |
Deep Sight: Huh? You are familiar with a non physical spiritual realm? Wahala, gbaskalada. I meant familiar with in terms of understanding by communication with people who believe in such realms. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Linear Chance? by thehomer: 12:03pm On Dec 18, 2010 |
Deep Sight: And such laws which produce the intricately precise ornate patterns posted in the OP issue purposelessly and meaninglessly from nowhere? Do you really believe these things? What do you mean by "meaninglessly" Humans assign meaning. Deep Sight: Such laws look products of chance to you? Are you sincere about this sir? Are you going for the fine-tuning argument here? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Discussing Deepsights Concerns With Christianity:Part One: Problem of Evil by thehomer: 11:54pm On Dec 17, 2010 |
lagerwhenindoubt: ^^^ the debate can go on forever . (and i don't mean literally)
For me, I have long abandoned the quest to discover why Evil Exists and simply accepted the Lazy-man's deduction and to quote Sherlock Holmes Evil is compatible with Good thus God is the source of Pure Evil and Pure Good. This would imply either a bipolar entity or two Gods rather than one. But, how can an entity be considered the origin of pure evil and pure good? Would you not consider these properties mutually exclusive? lagerwhenindoubt: 1: Since we agree that Evil exists before Creation, we cannot suppose it existed before God (otherwise God will not exist to start with) 2: Since creation, Man has always had Free-will (even before the Fall at Eden) so the debacle from Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil was simply an exercise in KNOWING the consequence of Free-will. I ask then, Why give us Free-will and continue to intervene (Divine Intervention) in decidedly everything Good and stay your hand when it comes to Evil, Why not make sure Evil does not prosper at all? (His Mysterious ways are surely a wonder to ponder) 3: Evil will still exist in the New Heaven IMHO - If Man is created higher than the Angels, would it not make us less human and more robots to do away with PAIN, (Emotional and Physical hurt) SADNESS (Sorrow from the knowledge that a loved one did not make it to Heaven).
The last time I posed my dilemma to a very tolerable Muslim scholar, he simply surmised his answer thus You cannot know what is on God's mind just like a Child cannot understand why his Father lets him touch fire knowing full-well that it will cause him pain. At the time of Judgment we shall all understand truly why God does what he does Such an answer to such an important question is not quite satisfactory because, this implies that no-one knows what God wants so one is free to do whatever they wish. And will find out what God really wants at the time of judgement. |
Christianity Etc › Re: "Einstein Was Right, You Can Be In Two Places At Once" by thehomer: 11:41pm On Dec 17, 2010 |
nuclearboy: Why would you say to be careful "extrapolating discoveries in quantum physics to that of our regular macroscopic world"? Quantum physics and what you call "regular world" - do they not both fit into OUR existence? Would you call that the "supernatural" or "spirit world"? They do but the quantum world is still relatively very new to us and quite difficult to understand right now. So, a number of the results derived from that field are not directly applied to the macroscopic world we are more familiar with. The spirit world that I'm familiar with is non-physical but the quantum world is. |
Christianity Etc › Re: "Einstein Was Right, You Can Be In Two Places At Once" by thehomer: 7:58pm On Dec 17, 2010 |
That's an interesting story though the experiment did not demonstrate the topic.
One should be careful when extrapolating discoveries in quantum physics to that of our regular macroscopic world. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Linear Chance? by thehomer: 7:51pm On Dec 17, 2010 |
@ Deep Sight
What complex pattern showing hallmarks of linear design are you referring to?
Water crystals have those shapes due to physical laws. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 7:31pm On Dec 17, 2010 |
Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> i didn't make the argmentum ad vericundiam fallacy >>> Socrates is, a well respected figure >>> his dialectic method (which you use) >>> is one of the tools used in critical thought >>> and i am not bothered with current information >>> in my last post i simply pointed out that without him and people like him >>> we would not have the information we have >>> where does improper authority come in all of this ? One cannot conclude that progress would have been impossible without Socrates existing at a certain point in time. Whether or not Socrates was an atheist is still irrelevant in this discussion. Critical thinking also requires the use of the best information available when making a decision. Socrates did not have the information we currently do have yet you refer to him as the best authority we have when deciding current issues with better information available to inform our decisions. Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> the numbering method is supposed to clarify what points (you make) i'm tackling >>> i've modified my post >>> u made me work  Which post did you modify? Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> semantics again >>> Person B has not demonstrated that he does not believe that fir harms >>> you mus understand that a non-belief is passive in nature >>> it doesn't have a determinate stance >>> as far as i am concerned Person B has demonstrated thus : He believes that fire does not harm >>> this is all about lexicology >>> note that Person B brought the fire under his palm (apparently at a safe distance) >>> doing that is as a result of a belief/thesis/posit/plausit Person B has
>>> prove to me that Person B DOES NOT believe fire can harm >>> prove the non-belief >>> i hope i have hit the nail on the head Please read through what I posted. Person B did not believe that fire would harm him so he stuck his hand in it. Whether or not it harms him is beside the issue. Person B has stated that fire does not harm him and to demonstrate this belief, he stuck his hand in the flame. A passerby asks "Why did Person B stick his hand in the flame?" What would be your response? |
Christianity Etc › Re: ''All The Major Religions Are Part Of One Conspiracy'' - David Icke by thehomer: 11:57pm On Dec 16, 2010 |
@ ROSSIKE You keep skipping from one problem to another. Those people simply could not have made light bulbs for several reasons which include obtaining the filament, creating a vacuum, generating a high enough voltage, conveniently transporting it about etc. Here's the real explanation. http://www.catchpenny.org/dendera.htmlYou may go through this site for a thorough analysis including the fact that soot was actually present in the tomb. Plus the actual text of the hieroglyphs. http://doernenburg.alien.de/alternativ/dendera/dend00_e.php |
Christianity Etc › Re: ''All The Major Religions Are Part Of One Conspiracy'' - David Icke by thehomer: 11:22pm On Dec 16, 2010 |
Jenwitemi: Describing Smithsonian Institute as "reputable" is the biggest laugh. Reputable only for those who don't want us to know our true ancient history. Archaeologists make those claims, not i. And archaeologists know more about what goes on in their field of profession than you do. I gave a couple of links to show this. Here is another link on the skulls, http://www.thelivingmoon.com/42stargate/03files/Crystal_Skull.html Did you notice that even the site that you posted lifted quotes and images from the Smithsonian? And which archaeologists are you referring to? I need professionals outside of your fringe groups. Besides, did you know that in science, a well supported line of thought with evidence tends to elevate the originator of said thought? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 11:09pm On Dec 16, 2010 |
Uyi Iredia: the last post of mine that you responded to >>> check your profile >>> and your previous posts >>> you'll catrch my drift Why don't you simply paste the posts to which you're responding. This will make it easier to follow the discussion. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 11:06pm On Dec 16, 2010 |
Uyi Iredia: nope >>> but without his efforts and others similar to and copied from his >>> we would not have the information we have >>> he is a symbol of free-thinking >>> he wasn't atheist This is an appeal to an improper authority. Socrates did not have the information that we currently do have. Uyi Iredia: your response to my last post >>> i expect you to know ! It's difficult responding to your posts with my original posts absent from view while I'm composing a response. You also use some numbering method which makes it even more difficult to follow in this case. Uyi Iredia: quote >>> "You do not prove (nor explicate) a non-belief" that's long talk >>> all i ask is that you demonstrate a non-belief Person A meets Person B who says he does not believe that fire will harm him. Person A asks for evidence and Person B promptly ignites a lighter and hands it to Person A. Person B then proceeds to hold his palm in the flame of the lighter. What has Person B demonstrated? He has demonstrated that he does not believe fire will harm him. This is irrespective of whether the fire actually does harm him or not. |
Christianity Etc › Re: ''All The Major Religions Are Part Of One Conspiracy'' - David Icke by thehomer: 11:18pm On Dec 15, 2010 |
Jenwitemi: You must be kidding. Your source is an article from the Smithsonian Institute? That institution that is very notorious for destroying ancient artifacts that contradicts established scientific theories about our ancient past? You must be joking if you think i will take this article seriously. Provide another source, please. Any source but that of the Smithsonian institute will do. Provide a link to any article the says this. And no Smithsonian stuff, please. The Smithsonian Institute is reputable. You now claim that a museum actually deliberately destroys artifacts? Wow. The main problem that I'm having right now is that a lot of the evidence is available by purchasing the book written by one Joe Nickell on these crystal skulls. The name of the book is "Secrets of the Supernatural". You could use Wikipedia for an overview. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crystal_skull#Mitchell-Hedges_skull |
Christianity Etc › Re: ''All The Major Religions Are Part Of One Conspiracy'' - David Icke by thehomer: 10:59pm On Dec 15, 2010 |
Jenwitemi: ^^^^Evidence of modern metropolis in 200,000 bce is not even amazing any longer, at least not to me. When evidence of nano technology as old as 1 BILLION years has been dug out of South African mining cave rocks, nothing can possibly surprise me any longer as far as the age of high tech civilizations on this planet is concerned. Rossie, we are just getting started. Watch the date getting pushed further and further back with more of such archaeological discoveries in the next few years. We were definitely taught crap in school as far as our past history is concerned. Everything has to be rewritten now and these academics better go to work now. What evidence of billion year old nanotechnology are you talking about? |
Christianity Etc › Re: ''All The Major Religions Are Part Of One Conspiracy'' - David Icke by thehomer: 10:57pm On Dec 15, 2010 |
@ ROSSIKE
The article you posted above was quite long and entertaining but the important questions who dated the structure and how was this dating carried out were not plausibly answered. |
Christianity Etc › Re: ''All The Major Religions Are Part Of One Conspiracy'' - David Icke by thehomer: 10:43pm On Dec 15, 2010 |
|
Christianity Etc › Re: Jesus Was A Muslim by thehomer: 10:25pm On Dec 15, 2010 |
Sweetnecta: @thehomer and PastorAIO: « #10 on: December 12, 2010, 07:48 PM »While thehomer's lie was bad enough to make Pastor Onifade bust a grin, both of you are not aware that the Quran over 1400 years before answered by chapter 60 verse 12, where Allah states that Muhammad should be obeyed in "What is Good". This is also saying that you can disobey Muhammad if you want, but a believer must never disobey Muhammad (AS) in what is Good.
So I ask thehomer who is lying and the pastor who is grinning, is there a blanketed submission to Muhammad is that verse which clearly permits disobedience to him in what is not good? Hey what lie did I tell? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Jesus Was A Muslim by thehomer: 10:18pm On Dec 15, 2010 |
Uyi Iredia: it is OP (off point) posts like this one which make empathize with Mudley SOMETIMES
thumbs up to homer for his patience in dealing with the topic >>> and mine  You're welcome  |
Christianity Etc › Re: Jesus Was A Muslim by thehomer: 10:15pm On Dec 15, 2010 |
pocketndry: thehomer, you better pick race from Muslim. The day God will open your eyes you will shade tears and feel ashamed of mentioning Islam.  So are you requesting that I avoid Islam? If I do this, then how will I be saved? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Discussing Deepsights Concerns With Christianity:Part One: Problem of Evil by thehomer: 10:09pm On Dec 15, 2010 |
easylogic: . . . This is really good question and one that most christians have never sat down and asked themselves.How does the death and resurrection of Jesus "Save"?
Remember in my earlier post i talked of Free Will.God having chosen W1 where he has given human beings free will,then he cannot possibly interefre by preventing human beings from doing evil so as to reduce the prevalence of evil.So he's choices are limited.
Think of a scenario,there is a very beautiful girl at your work place whom you really like,but she does not show interest.You have to devise ways to make yourself look more desirable so as to attract her attention and hopefully fall in love with you.You can't force her to love you, she has free will to chose NOT to.
If God is defined as the true measure of perfection,the omnibenevolent creator ,then it is only right that we should try to emulate him as much as possible since,he is perfection.
This is where Jesus comes in.God is unable to force humans to be good/act morally,so he sends his son(personhood) of Jesus.By sending a person who emulates what a perfect human being should act and live like, humans have a living example of what a perfectly good morally character is.God does not stop there,by allowing the Crucifixion of Jesus,God again shows that He is willing to pay the ultimate price for human beings.The Resurrection is significant as it shows God can conquer death and good triumphs over evil.The resurrection was also very important for the first followers of Christ.Had he not resurrected,then Christianity would have died at the tomb. The concept of an innocent person being tortured and dying for another person is quite disturbing. But this case is a special one. This person was God, he was dying for all humans on earth at that time and to come later and he knew he would be resurrected and go back to heaven. These thoughts to me make this exchange a no-brainer. Such an exchange cannot be compared to that which Abraham wanted to offer or the one actually offered by Jephthah. easylogic: What was the result of the coming,death and resurrection of Jesus?Christianity! the world's biggest religion.The biggest milestone for Christianity must have been when Rome adopted it as its official religion.After years of killing and persecuting christians.It is a well known fact that many of todays Bills of rights and constituions all over the world have their foundations in Christianity.The impact of Christianity all over the world is truly immense. While the impact of Christianity is immense, you really shouldn't be so hasty in ascribing to it all the positive actions embraced by modern societies and at the same time, ignoring the negative effects. easylogic: Would the world have been a better place without Christianity? i don't think so.Romans seized most of their barbaric practices after adopting christianity by Constantine.Christianity is credited with the bill of rights etc. You wish to credit Christianity with the entire bill of rights?This is a huge leap. easylogic: According to the Bible,the ultimate fate of evil is defeat.In revelations and the gospel,Jesus will return,defeat the devil/satan and create a world where evil is non-existent.This is W4 in the free will defense.This world is heaven.And it is only actualizable because God is present.Some may argue that there is no Free Will in heaven. Hmm well heaven fails because there was once evil in heaven. And I notice that you were speaking of both evil and suffering in these worlds of yours. easylogic: In conclusion.
As illustrated Christianity,more than any other religion or non-religion for that matter addresses the problem of evil adequately.Evn though evil persists in our society,the life,death and crucifixion of Jesus proiveds humans with a benchmark,motivation and hope that they can too,live morally good lives and hope for eternal redemption. No it doesn't. It allows one to commit all the crimes they wish and get away with it if at the last minute, they convert before death. So, the serial rapist, murderer and traitor makes it into heaven if he accepts Jesus before his execution or death from cancer in prison. easylogic: If Christianity is false,then there is no way out from evil.If the Bible is false,then God does not show us anyway we humans should behave.We would depend on Naturalistic forms of ethics. Evil wins all the time,and the temporary victories of good,are all meaningless in the long run. What's wrong with naturalistic ethics? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Discussing Deepsights Concerns With Christianity:Part One: Problem of Evil by thehomer: 9:39pm On Dec 15, 2010 |
easylogic: Welcome Homer.Free will being in heaven is quite a controversial topic where most theologians have failed to agree.Let me try to put forward my position regarding the issue at hand. Ok then. easylogic: Whether humans have free will or not really depends on God's "epistemic distance" from us.This is to say,God's hiddennes. By NOT showing himself or making his presence overwhelmingly obvious,he is able to preserve free will.And Thus we are able to Sin thinking that God is not seeing us.But in heaven the full glory and presence of God is overwhelming and over bearing that it would possibly eliminate free will.Though some could that we can still have free will as in W4 above,but due to the full love and knowledge of God it would be absolutely pointless and silly to sin.Sort of Like,you have the ability to wake up tomorrow and jump off 24 floors thinking you will fly.While it is true you have the freedom to do that if you wanted to,but,you are also aware that it would be very silly if you tried to since you would die. So you're saying that God's divine hiddenness is a good thing? Mind you it is due to this excellent hiddenness that most of the humans will be going to hell. Also, the devil himself was also in heaven at one time. If he could actually choose to go against God and not him alone but with some other angels, how much more humans who can even deny themselves when captured on tape? To add insult to injury, this heaven that was corrupted by the devil, why did it too not need cleansing by blood? Remember that in the case of humans, there were just two of them but in heaven, the devil lead lots of angels away. easylogic: Thus in the same way,doing evil or sinning will seem soo silly/horrific/pointless that no one will chose to do it.It would be like a woman confessing to you that she has HIV and you still go ahead and have unprotected sex with her.Evil actions will seem MUCH MUCH irrationally than that in heaven.
It is upto you to decide which position sounds mote plausible. I don't agree. I think if there is free will and there are humans, some of them will simply perform acts that would be considered bad unless of course bad acts are outlawed. easylogic: And for your second question,we are discussing Moral Evil,not Natural evil like diseases,earthquakes etc.That would require another thread altogether. Moral evil as determined by who? God or man? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:28pm On Dec 15, 2010 |
Uyi Iredia: @ homer
* 1 >>> i do not think i need to >>> i expected you to give an answer
*2 >>> when i talk of atheism i refer to militant atheism >>> note that >>> and note, as well, the fact that i use both terms interchangeably
*3 >>> both atheism and religion are concepts that intertwine >>> how many times do i repeat that atheism is predicated on materialism and embodied by a scientific world-view
*4 >>> all you did was rearrange my question >>> how does adding other features redefine it >>>
*5 >>> you suppose so ! >>> oya !!! >>> prove that you do not believe that fire harms
*6 >>> your link was faulty >>> however, it is true that i said atheism is belief and by extension a worldview >>> i DID NOT state that atheism is a worldview because it is a belief >>> you misunderstand me
*& >>> i do not agree >>> you got my semantics wrong >>> i talked about beliefs not statements >>> haba !
*9 >>> suit yourself
*10 >>> that was the purpose of mt TED videos >>> check out Dan Dennet's profile and RDFRS
*11 >>> so why is it so hard for you to consider atheism as a religion >>> or at least, a worldview
*12 >>> that is not a contradiction >>> religions are both materialistic and non-materialistic >>> they incorporate the aforementioned to varying degrees Responding would be easier for me if I could see what you are also responding to. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 8:25pm On Dec 15, 2010 |
Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> and are falsifiable and therefore relative >>> do take a course in the history and philosophy of science
*2 >>> so what >>> his free-will isn't absolute >>> hence determinism
*3 >>> yeah
*4 >>> go and read GWR 2009 jor !!! >>> dat is an evidence i gave you >>> must i do all the dirty work
*5 >>> however it affects how a statement is regarded and the means by which it is verified >>> you are aware that logical positivism (which you effuse) is a position that isn't verifiable
lol Is this in response to my posts? If so, which ones? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 8:22pm On Dec 15, 2010 |
Uyi Iredia: CAVEAT : The following skit put my thoughts in focus
@ homer >>> those statements you made will make Socrates roll over in his grave >>> in mock laughter He may laugh but I won't because he did not have the information that we currently have. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 8:21pm On Dec 15, 2010 |
Deep Sight: ^^^ The burden is on you to burn him with fire. Ha I'm already on fire. What you need now is Jet A1.  |
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 8:17pm On Dec 15, 2010 |
Uyi Iredia: @ homer >>> so you can say we don't prove a negative >>> then stab me in the back by propounding the fact that my quote (shown below) is wrong
You do not prove nor explicate a non-belief
i'm waiting for you to prove to me that you do not believe that fire harms >>> if i'm correct you understand this to be a negative statement, not so ? What quote? One can demonstrate that one does not believe in hobbits but can one demonstrate that hobbits do not exist in the universe? You see these are two different things. Demonstrating a belief or non-belief is different from demonstrating the occurrence of phenomena or existence of certain objects. |
Christianity Etc › Re: ''All The Major Religions Are Part Of One Conspiracy'' - David Icke by thehomer: 11:27pm On Dec 14, 2010 |
Jenwitemi: Not entirely true. There are quite a number of them that have been shown to be fakes, yes, but not the Mitchell-Hedges skull. Oh yes including the Mitchell-Hedges skull. Jenwitemi: The Ica stones have not been proving to be hoaxes, even though there were clumsy attempts to make them look like they are by the authorities. You should inform yourself more about the Ica stones before posting. What are the special properties of the real Ica stones? I ask because it has lots of fakes with extra information floating around. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Discussing Deepsights Concerns With Christianity:Part One: Problem of Evil by thehomer: 11:18pm On Dec 14, 2010 |
@ PastorAIO
I really hope your predictions about this thread's demise do not come true.
@ easylogic
I'd like to add my question.
I'm assuming that there is not evil in heaven but, is there freewill in heaven? If there is, then where does heaven fit into your many worlds description?
Also, are we speaking only of evil with respect to one person's acts towards another or do we include suffering which is also present and which I think is a major problem when speaking of God in this instance. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Mazaje, State The Purpose Of Your Life! by thehomer: 10:56pm On Dec 14, 2010 |
Deep Sight: Another really enjoyable one.
I would like to invite thehomer to state the purpose of his life.
[size=3pt]I hope that will not in reality amount to re-inviting mazaje. . .[/size] I evaluate (and re-evaluate) my life's purpose as I go on living. What is the purpose of your own life? |
Christianity Etc › Re: ''All The Major Religions Are Part Of One Conspiracy'' - David Icke by thehomer: 10:24pm On Dec 14, 2010 |
Jenwitemi: And of course, there are the crystal skulls. . . they are supposed to contain all the records of events of that age and beyond. I think they are supposed to be 13 of them. The dr. Cabrera's Ica stones are quite interesting possible record keeping method of extremely ancient but highly civilized human past history too. The crystal skulls have been shown to have been made within the past 300 years. And that the stones were a hoax. So what method are you actually proposing? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 10:12pm On Dec 14, 2010 |
Deep Sight: I stated that you are yet to show how exactly critical thinking leads to a non-belief in God.
You responded -
I agree that we do not prove a negative. However you must realise that your statement that "critical thinking leads to a non-belief in God" - IS A POSITIVE STATEMENT and not a negative statement.
If you simply said "I dont believe in God" - that would be a negative statement for which you needn't adduce proof.
But when you make an addittional claim - namely that "critical thinking leads to a non-belief in God" - you have made a very positive statement declaring that critical thinking leads in a certain direction - and that, you MUST prove.
To do this you must lay out the essentials of existence, and then apply critical thinking to those essentials to draw up a logical conclusion that shows that critical thinking leads towards the tendency that you positively claimed it does.
Otherwise, you must concede that your statement is nothing but water in a basket. Due to the problems with defining a God, I usually try to find out what a person means by God. According to you, God is understood to be a pre-existent factor which caused the universe as we know it (and this is the general understanding of what God is) This was why I asked if one could consider a physical law as God or if one could consider the singularity as God. I also recall that you once mentioned something of a mind outside the universe. This concept is quite absurd. With regards to demonstrating the effects of critical thinking, I thought it's been demonstrated on this thread. What I'm saying is that with the required background knowledge in various fields such as biology, physics, anthropology, psychology and others, plus the use of tools such as logic and reasoning, one would tend to not believe in Gods as they are generally conceived. Biology gives us theories such as evolution with its implication about our origins on earth from simpler life forms over long periods of time, physics with its numerous fields such as astrophysics gives us information about matter, its origin and contents. Anthropology gives us some insights into the way human cultures and societies are organized. Psychology with its own insights into the way we think. Having knowledge in these fields and others of course, tend to make religious beliefs and lots of concepts of God redundant. |