Deep Sight: Can you tell me how "critical thinking" would support the incongruity of an uncaused universe?
Why would any one expect this concept of cause and effect to apply to the universe as a whole at the time of its expansion?
Deep Sight: What does the law of cause and effect tell us?
About what?
Deep Sight: What do the various laws of motion tell us?
About what?
Deep Sight: I am sorry, Homer, but this statement of yours is farcical and absolutely ill-considered or not considered at all.
It was well considered. You're free to demonstrate the problems with the statement.
Deep Sight: I would adjure you to draw a distinction between the gods set out within the cosmogony of religion - and that element which perforce must pre-exist to render the universe extant - which element I state to you as GOD. For I say to you that while it may be apt to discard the cosmogony of God as conceived by religion, critical thinking certainly cannot discard the conception of God as a philosophical and logical construct as the uncaused, necessary and non-contingent element the existence of which is cardinal to render the universe extant.
Why should I? If you wish to redefine God in some way, you're free to do so but do not expect others who have a conception of what the word 'God' means which is actually shared by a very large number of people to simply make way for you and your new definition. You're also perfectly free to use another word for this 'God' of yours.
Why is this 'God' of yours necessary and non-contingent? Do you wish to go with a fallacy of special pleading to explain his necessity and non-contingence?
Yes it's biased towards statements that are verifiably true.
Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> no
Why not? I ask because this person has free will and wishes to exercise it this way.
Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> correct but, so what ? >>> the point it is >>> it wasn't self-evident to both right from the start >>> hence relativity
Whether or not it was evident, only one of them was actually true.
Uyi Iredia: *4 >>> i said "truth is relatively absolute and absolutely relative" >>> however it could so be that with future knowledge gained B could turn out to be a lie
Truth is relative to what, falsehood?
Uyi Iredia: *5 >>> as a matter of fact your statement is false >>> people can, in fact, survive such a fall >>> one greater than that >>> check GWR and get yourself wowed >>> i get and agree with your point though >>> but it doesn't simply apply hard-and-fast as you connote >>> i still assert that truth makes meaning to those who believe in it
People such as?
Whether or not one believes a statement is true would not stop the statement if true from affecting such a person when necessary.
At the southern entrance of Baalbeck is a quarry where the stones used in the temples were cut. A huge block, considered the largest hewn stone in the world, still sits where it was cut almost 2,000 years ago. Called the "Stone of the Pregnant Woman", it is 21.5m x 4.8m x 4.2meters in size and weighs an estimated 1,000 tons.
How the bleeding hell did the ancient man cut a stone of such size with primitive tools, homer? Please, explain.
How primitive were the tools? Remember that it was built during the time of the Roman Empire. The same civilization that brought us Roman columns, Roman roads, Roman aqueducts and the Colosseum.
These guys already had metallic tools to quarry stones with.
Jenwitemi: Homer, has modern man built a pyramid, the size of the ones at Giza, using millions of 2 ton blocks? If modern man has built such a structure, where is it? If modern man has not, why? Could it be that they can't? If ancient man could, with only primitive tools, why can't modern man with all the technology at his disposal, if only to prove that he could do it. What is stopping modern man from repeating this engineering feat?
Modern man has built far superior structures like the space shuttle, super tankers, skyscrapers more than 4 times taller than the pyramids, oil rigs in the ocean, laboratories in space etc, have you considered that modern humans don't waste time building such a structure again because they are not currently useful?
ROSSIKE: thehomer, regarding the pyramids of Egypt, I actually think the real problem here is that they precisely cut and arranged rock in ways that were superior to what we know we can do with primitive tools, So, how did they do it?
Have you considered the fact that we are not familiar with using these primitive tools? Besides, I don't think anyone will put up the time and money to test our current abilities of moving and arranging stones at that scale using primitive tools.
Quote: The passages inside the pyramid are all extremely straight and precise, such that the longest of them, referred to as the descending passage, which is 350' 0.25" long deviates from being truly straight by less than 0.25 inches, while one of the shorter passages with a length of just over 150 feet deviates from being truly straight by a mere 0.020 inches. These and the above statistics prove the pyramid to be literally the most accurately constructed building on the face of the earth despite having been created several millennia ago. All theories which sufficiently allow for this level of accuracy assume a level of technology approximately equal to or exceeding current technology, at least in the area of tool making and construction.
logic1: ok, but I have to do things one at a time.
I think in this case, before progressing too far down a particular branch, it would be better to handle such diametrically opposed views simultaneously to prevent the rebuttals from being too cumbersome on one side of the argument making the other side seem nonexistent.
logic1: Please post the questions I have not responded to.
Here are some of them.
This is still partial because people are still suffering. Why did God choose to protect Job in the first place and not his neighbour? Or was he protecting them both but decided to remove Job's protection for the benefit of the Devil's test? And do you think whichever way it went, God's action was just? Remember that it was for the Devil to have the opportunity to torture Job while God looked on to see what he would do.
Wow. So bacteria and viruses were there all along but became pathogenic because of sin? And lions started eating antelopes because of sin? What did the antelope do to deserve such a fate brought about by human actions?
Yes and there are many that are disease causing entities. Not just for adult humans but plants, animals, even human babies. What did the babies do to deserve such "justice"? Or is God simply still punishing them because of Adam and Eve even after the flood and the death of Jesus?
You seem to have forgotten Jonah who despite knowledge of God and his abilities tried to escape a task and what happened? He lived in a fish for three days. After scaring ignorant sailors of course.
logic1: If God created us for Himself then he owns us regardless of whether He created us with free will or not. This should be apparent except I'm missing something.
This is one of the reasons why I already stated that he did not create humans.
logic1: It would indeed be very profitable if you trace out that line of argument but we have to do things one at a time.
I could but you're the one presenting himself as the one with the answers to questions. So I need to find out if you actually do have an understanding of what the world would be like if this God figure of yours did not exist.
logic1: How is the Biblical God an accomplice. If you do not know enough about the biblical God then you are not in a position to determine if He is an accomplice or not.
It will be better to post actions you think make God ad accomplice rather than saying categorically that He is an accomplice.
I already pointed this out with the cases of Job and Jonah. You were yet to respond to some of the questions.
logic1: The architect is not free to demolish a building if he build it for someone else. We are not talking of an architect, we are talking of a creator who created something by himself and for himself.
If we do have free will, then we are not for simply for this God.
logic1: Remember we have established that you do not know enough to say that God did not create humans and we are tracing out a line of argument witht the premise that God created humans.
This is why I think it would be a good idea to also trace out the line of argument with the premise that God did not create humans.
logic1: Let's not stray away from the central question of God's qualification to judge humans. The point of my analogy was to show that someone who we know has the ability to do something can be judged based on our knowledge of that ability and the surrounding circumstances that affect that ability irrespective of our lack of knowledge of the exact decision the person will make tomorrow.
Humans are just as capable of this and are in a much better position than God to tell since, they are actually humans.
logic1: God that we are discussing here is not an accomplice.
If you're talking about the Biblical God, then he is an accomplice.
logic1: If we agree that God is the creator you cannot then refer to Him as an accomplice.
Then I do not agree that God is the creator.
logic1: In your own words, you seem to be equivocating between God and Man.
No I'm not. I'm simply pointing out that humans are more qualified to judge humans than God is based on what we do know.
logic1: Once again, I maintain that it should be clearly evident that a creator has absolute rights over his creation especially if he/she created it without the help of another person.
No a creator does not have absolute rights over his creation. If a person were to take their say skin cells, clone this and deliver it as a baby, would you claim that the original owner of the skin cell has absolute rights over this baby?
logic1: If God created us then HE is in a position to judge.
Then I state that God did not create humans therefore he is in no position to judge.
logic1: If God created us for a specific purpose then He has the right to destroy us if we do not fulfill the purpose for which He created us, or if we behave in a manner in which He has told us not to behave.
He does not have the right to destroy humans since he did not create humans.
logic1: A creator by virtue of him/her being the creator has absolute rights over his/her creation.
This is false and it is a very dangerous proposition to make. The fact that an architect designed/created a building does not mean that he is free to demolish it as he sees fit.
Jenwitemi: Haven't you heard of spacetime bending technology that can be used to traverse vast space within a very short period of time? Alien civilizations would have such technologies, so itr is no big deal. What about interdimensional shifting technology? That also takes seconds. Not all ETs are from our dimension. The problem with you is that you are still on old technology. Vastly more is possible. . .
Do you have such technology available or are you simply inventing for the extraterrestrials them to make your stories more believable to you?
Jenwitemi: Many artefacts have been found that are beyond human comprehension. Many. Evidence of nano technology have been found deep in the earth crust dating hundreds of millions of years. Have you heard of Michael Cremo?
Such as? What nano-technology? I would advice you to avoid an appeal to authority fallacy and more especially, an appeal to an improper authority.
Jenwitemi: We shouldn't? Supposedly stone age civilizations with only crude and primitive methods building monuments tha modern man cannot even attempt? And you think that is plausible? NO, it is not.
Such as?
Jenwitemi: Yes, it is. Modern archaeologists have tried to move megalithic boulders with such tools and they failed woefully. The megalithic structures strewned all over the planet clearly showed that whoever built them did it with ease.
This is simply not true. The fact is that most of these structures are at World Heritage Sites and are not supposed to be needlessly disturbed. And no one will put up money to demonstrate that we can actually move these objects easily especially when you consider that they would have to quarry it at another site, select an appropriate environment then drag it around. What evidence do you have that all these structures were set up by the same cultures?
Jenwitemi: This is just ridiculous. No wooden rollers can support hundreds of tons of weight. They would pulverise immediately. Even if massive blocks can be moved by 200 oxens, what about the delicate and precise placements of these blocks in megalithic structures like the Giza pyramid? You are grasping at straws here, using weak arguements that have been abandoned a long time ago. Update up!
Rollers can support those weights. One important fact that you need to realize is that those stones are not dense.
Jenwitemi: Magnificent structures that we can't build today, and these ancient bronze age civilizations are supposed to be primitive? Who is thinking irrationally here? Do you know tha the great Giza pyramid was built with a structural precision that cannot be matched by today's engineers with all their technologies? You really do ned to update up.
Structures that we cannot build today? I hope you realize that we are able to build oil rigs far out in the ocean, space shuttles for multiple missions, airplanes, sky scrapers, super tankers three times longer than the height of the pyramids etc and you think we cannot move a pile of stones and set them up in a stable pyramid form?
Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> your statement comes of as false when i consider how you said that atheists too are superstitious/religious >>> thus free-thinking isn't the distinguishing feature of atheists
Are you deliberately misquoting me? Please go back and read through my posts.
I said atheists can be superstitious or religious. And I never said free-thinking was the distinguishing feature of atheists. I said the non-belief in a God is generally the end result of critical thinking.
Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> yeah
Can a human decapitate himself, turn his head around and stitch it back on?
Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> i wasn't trying to be trickish >>> both of those statements were at points in time held to be truths
That is simply irrelevant. The fact is that only one of them was true all along. Whether or not they knew it.
Uyi Iredia: *4 >>> B is the only one that's true
Why? You said truth was only relative. So if someone believes A is correct and says so but another believes C is correct and says so, are they both telling the truth?
Uyi Iredia: *5 >>> so what ? >>> truths that are believed in turn out to be lies with new knowledge gained >>> truth loses essence if it is not believed in >>> (or put another way) truth has no meaning to a person who doesn't believe in it >>> "man is the measure of all things" . . .
This is simply absurd. The fact that a person does not believe that they would die if they fell freely to the ground from a height of 8,000 metres does not mean that the person will not die. The truth is that such a person will die whether or not they believe it.
Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> this appears to be discordant with your definition of religion
In what way?
Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> the stance of atheism is that there is no soul; only brain states that create a consciousness. The usage of the term 'soul' alludes to a transcendent reality one that is at variance with militant atheism in particular >>> of course most theistic religions (including Catholicism) agree that there is a soul (that we have no emperical evidence for)
This is simply false. Jainism does accept a belief in souls. And I'm not just talking about belief in the existence of a soul but also about what happens to the soul after death? Where does it go etc.
Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> precisely >>> but atheism (or rather militant atheism) is not just a single statement about god. in the video i TED video posted Prof Dawkins states that a true understanding of evolution leads (or propels) someone to atheism >>> that is not a single statement, d'accord ? >>> that is a worldview, a mentality that has a predicate (evolutionism)
You need to closely examine the definition of atheism and compare that to a definition of theism then compare that to Catholicism. Check to find out which is more comprehensive with instructions on how one is to approach life.
Uyi Iredia: *4 >>> as i have come to believe it seems that we are merely making looking at different sides of the same coin >>> i posit atheism is a religion because one adds features to it >>> atheism is not a 'mere belief' nor is it a 'single statement'
If you posit that atheism is a religion, then define atheism, then go ahead and explain how an agreement with that statement explains how someone who agrees with it would view the world. You are attempting to redefine atheism again. Once you start adding other features and stances to it, it is no longer simply atheism.
Uyi Iredia: i do not see how you have negated my quote >>> i still assert that: you do not prove (or explicate) a non-belief. >>>
But you already accept that one can demonstrate that they do not believe fire can hurt them. What more do you want the person to do for you to understand that he does not share your belief?
Uyi Iredia: the fact that you are so willing to assert that atheism is not a religion or a worldview shows clearly that atheism is a belief and by extension a worldview >>>
It's not a belief it's a negative belief, a non-belief. And are you saying that all beliefs are worldviews? This is simply absurd. Consider this statement. I believe that Saturn has 200 moons is this a worldview? How about I do not believe that Jupiter is a star is this also a worldview?
Uyi Iredia: you have not demonstrated anything as regards your 'fire example' >>> your so called "does not believe" is in fact "i believe that" >>> the man who does not believe that fire can harm believes that fire does not harm >>> a non-belief is actually a belief per se
That's your belief what does the other person believe? He either believes fire will not harm him, (negative belief) or he does not believe that fire will harm him (negative belief). Both statements are negative statements.
Uyi Iredia: *5 >>> hopefully >>> you realize that i said that "rejection of belief in deities is primarily founded upon materialistic beliefs" not "rejection of belief in deities is primarily founded upon scientific worldview" >>> to make things very simple when i wrote "embodied by a scientific worldview" it was because of the fact that most if not all atheists regard the scientific method as the one, true means of understanding reality >>> which is not so
This is plainly false. As I pointed out to you, Jainism is not "embodied by a scientific worldview".
Uyi Iredia: your argument was directed at the latter and not the former >>> straw man ? how does "materialistic belief embodied by a scientific worldview" sharply equate to "knowledge of science" ?
For one to have a scientific worldview, the person must have a knowledge of science. Can one have a Catholic worldview without knowledge of Catholicism?
Uyi Iredia: *6 >>> no >>> i'm saying i chose Wikipedia's definition of Atheism as "a rejection of beliefs in deities" >>> thing is; this 'single statement' (i.e "a rejection of beliefs in deities" expresses a pre-adopted belief system/worldview
Again, how does that statement tell you how one ought to relate with others? Or a view about what happens to souls?
Uyi Iredia: *7 >>> thus i presume that they are atheist and transcendental ? >>> this, of course, seems dubious >>> the religions you even gave as examples are also quite materialistic
What do you mean?
Uyi Iredia: *8 >>> they do not have to be purely materialistic >>> they only needs incorporate elements of materialism for me to call them materialistic beliefs
In that case, pretty much all religions have materialistic beliefs.
I usually do not bother with referrals to external links especially when it involves multimedia files but I made an exception in this case. I was disappointed. I was unable to watch the first clip to the end due to the obvious falsehoods being presented mixed in with myths.
The underground city being referred to was only exceptional due to the size it had attained but it was not unique in the region. There were multiple underground cities in that region. Those cities started small and gradually grew over centuries as various cultures populated those caverns. I did not notice anything extraordinary about those buildings especially when the fact that the rock was soft was mentioned. Contrary to what was said, the structure was dated to about 8th to 7th century B.C. built by the culture present there at that time. There is already evidence that early Christians hid in those caves and that there were chapels present in some of them.
The further absurd claims that those structures would have protected the dwellers from aerial bombardment by civilizations with the ability to traverse galaxies is simply absurd. Civilizations currently present on earth have the ability of penetrating bunkers made of reinforced concrete above a depth of about 6 metres with better ones being currently available. Imagine what would then happen if it exploded with the softness of the rock used for the buildings? How much more a civilization with the ability to traverse a galaxy?
This sort of appeal to ignorance (we do not know everything that happened here therefore the myths of the region actually meant extraterrestrials) is simply absurd given what we actually know.
I think you actually need something better than myths and falsehoods to demonstrate your links between humans and your claimed extraterrestrials.
logic1: The fact that it involves human beings is the main point. Once human beings come into the equation everything becomes complex. No one on earth can really predict human behaviour with 100% success everytime. At any rate, not being able to predict human behaviour does not still remove the capacity to judge.
This is not simply about being able to judge but whether God is actually qualified to judge when one considers the entirety of humanity.
logic1: What determines if someone can judge a matter is if the person knows what the parties involved in that matter were capable of doing under the circumstances that surrounded the matter in question.
Yes this is important and humans can determine this as well as God. The reason why God should excuse himself is that he is an accomplice in placing the person in the questionable situation and still decides to judge the person. This is one of the reasons why we do not allow the same groups of people to be law makers, judges and executioners because we know that this tends to create tyrants.
logic1: For example, if one is in primary 6 one should be capable of passing a primary 5 examination under normal circumstances. If a primary 6 pupil cannot pass a primary 5 examination then he has FAILED and should be demoted. Those are the rules.
And how about people who pass professional exams? Should they be required to keep repeating the exams each time they are available and if they fail, should their license to practice be withdrawn?
logic1: I was just trying to point out that if one knows the capability of what he built that knowledge alongside the knowledge of the surrounding circumstances and stimuli puts one in a position to judge accurately whether the system is performing optimally, maximally or not.
Emergent properties do not in themselves remove the ability to judge a system if one understands the nature of those emergent properties.
Oh yes they do. They make it very difficult to make predictions about certain behaviours under certain circumstances.
logic1: No that's not the point. The point is that everyone is assuming to an extent about the history of the universe and life in general and the only way to justify any claims is to trace the logical conclusions of each theory and see how well it corresponds to present reality.
And how can you make conclusions when so little is known? And as far as has been demonstrated, the best method of gaining knowledge about the universe is using scientific methods.
logic1: Economics is a field that concerns human behaviour that's the reason for all the unexplainable properties of economic systems.
No. Economics is a field that deals with production and consumption of goods and services. Oh? Human behaviour is responsible for all the unexplained properties?
logic1: So in a sense when we talk about economic systems what we have are human beings trying to impose a set of rules on themselves. If we had a system of economics where all the participants in that system were robots then we would not have any emergent properties or situations that cannot be explained or anticipated.
This is still false because economic systems involves more than just some people making decisions. It's more about the availability of goods and services. In some cases, one can say that the goods and services determine human behaviour. Besides, I do have other examples that have nothing to do with humans such as the weather, swarming behaviour in animals and computer A.I.
logic1: If one knows that this computer has the capacity to perform at 5 teraflops then we can JUDGE whether that computer is performing optimally or not.
Optimally or maximally? They are quite different you know. And what's the relevance of the above to emergent properties?
logic1: Yes Evolution by itself says nothing about the origin of life. for evolution to be meaningful, life has to have started. Anyone, including theists can safely believe in the theory of evolution.
I'm glad you finally understand what I've been saying.
logic1: What we are talking about here is evolution used to advance an atheistic worldview.
Oh really?
logic1: Science is not simply evolution. The big bang theory is held in almost the same light as the theory of evolution in scientific circles. If there are still big unexplained holes from the big bang to evolution and then to present day human species then science has some BIG IFs.
What's the relevance of this? Science does not have all the answers therefore God did it?
Jenwitemi: Use the google, mate. I am not about to do any work for you.
You're not doing any work. I need more specific references than "underground tunnels that cannot have been made by humans". This is so broad that one does not even know where to start. I need to know the particular ones you're referring to rather than me barking up the wrong tree.
Jenwitemi: Going back to the original theme, there are 10s of fantastically futuristic looking pyramids beneath the world oceans. Also, Beneath our feet, there are thousands of miles of artificially built, arrow straight tunnels that have been discovered centuries ago, but hidden from the public eyes. These tunnels were built with tunnelling technologies that were only available to "modern" humanity in the late 60s to early 70s. Now, that's a puzzle for you!
Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> you said this: "I think it is the final conclusion of critical thinking."
A hallmark is not necessarily a conclusion it's a distinguishing feature.
Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> yes, it is >>> i would say that necessity of function does restrict freedom and thus, free-thinking.
Ok. So do you think humans have freewill?
Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> yes, the were *i'm thinking Ptolemy and Copernicus, and the famed lady, Hypatia, who advanced Ptolemic models of the universe* >>> before the space age settled things of course
It seems you are attempting to shift focus by introducing some unnecessary details. Here is a direct question.
Which of these statements is/are true. You may pick more than one option.
A) The moon is larger than the sun. B) The sun is larger than the moon. C) Both objects are the same size.
Uyi Iredia: *4 >>> people can see a fact, know an axiom and conclude different things from it >>> people do not open up their beliefs/creeds/philosophy to falsifiability they open it up to verifiability >>> this cartoon by OLAADEGBU should give you the picture
Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> of course, militant atheism (and even atheism) isn't only such >>> it is also has a worldview
I think it is now up to you to demonstrate how atheism is a worldview.
Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> so atheists are religious
Sure some can be religious they just do not believe in Gods.
Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> go to comment 9 in the topic "Atheism Is A Religion" >>> note what i wrote in point 3 >>> i also put in a quote from my first post in the cited topic >>> this to be precise: "Time and Time again in the religion debate atheists seek to distance themselves from religion and religious connotations." >>> note it >>> and yes, belief in god(s) is not the only form of fable
I still do not see how that applies. I said atheism is not a religion neither is it a worldview. Not that atheists cannot be religious.
Uyi Iredia: *4 >>> in fact both are
No they are not. I think you need to reconsider what you mean by "worldview". For consideration, can you state the stance of e.g Catholicism towards the soul? What is the stance of atheism? What is the stance of theism?
Uyi Iredia: *5 >>> a glib 'demonstration' >>> whaddya mean by atheist philosophical stances ? >>> what does this clause - "many facets in life" - portend ? >>> b'cos as far as i'm concerned saying that there are atheist philosophical stances is equal to saying that atheism is a worldview
What I mean about many facets of life are the guiding principles about how one lives and acts. A single statement about the existence of Gods is simply not enough to explain how one interacts with others.
Uyi Iredia: Note that it is from a belief that a school of thought flourishes. Varied people contribute to such a belief and articulate reasons for such a belief till it becomes the very cornerstone of the existence of such people. It isn't hard to see parallels between the way militant atheism (in particular) is currently spreading, and how Christianity spread. (culled from comment 9 "Atheism Is A Religion"
You have pretty much pointed it out yourself. Atheism is simply not a religion until one starts adding some other features to it.
Uyi Iredia: *6 >>> SMH >>> of course he will demonstrate it as a 'factor of belief' : he will try to prove his belief that fire does not harm >>> if you have other ideas >>> state 'em *and they would most likely be semantical gymnastics* and do try to PROVE me wrong
I have demonstrated to you how you were wrong it is now up to you to demonstrate what makes you right. Also, even if I was unable to demonstrate how you were wrong (though I have) you still have to demonstrate how you were correct.
Uyi Iredia: *7 >>> you are so right over a wrong >>> the interpretation - your assumption (straw man) was wrong >>> let's analyze my quote
"A rejection of belief in deities is primarily founded upon materialistic beliefs embodied by a scientific worldview"
i chose the definition of atheism that was on Wikipedia >>> this definition is with the intent to repel any notion of belief with Atheism >>> the best option, clearly, was for the definition of atheism to be depicted, as in my quote
Please could you point out the straw man argument I made?
Are you saying your quote above was from Wikipedia because I could not find a reference to it being "primarily founded upon materialistic beliefs embodied by a scientific worldview" there.
Uyi Iredia: i said "primarily founded on materialistic beliefs" because more likely than not atheists disbelieve in a transcendent reality - they have a materialistic belief whether they know it or not >>> in fact, those reasons you gave for atheism, are as a result of these materialistic beliefs
This is false because there are religions that do not appeal to deities that are not simply materialistic.
Uyi Iredia: hopefully >>> you realize that i said that "rejection of belief in deities is primarily founded upon materialistic beliefs" not "rejection of belief in deities is primarily founded upon scientific worldview" >>> to make things very simple when i wrote "embodied by a scientific worldview" it was because of the fact that most if not all atheists regard the scientific method as the one, true means of understanding reality >>> which is not so
Whether primarily based on materialistic beliefs or scientific worldview, your statement is simply false because some beliefs such as Jainism and some forms of Buddhism are not purely materialistic or scientific.
Uyi Iredia: *8 >>> that's why i said i prefer the term 'variegated' >>> the definition of God is sharp in those instances your examples connote >>> if you disagree with this >>> then you'll allow the fact that the definition of Nature or Reality is cloudy as well
Yes nature and reality are difficult to define but the main difference is that both of us can agree on some concepts such as nature and reality but on the concept of God, even some that believe in one may not agree.
logic1: That a property is emergent does not mean that it is unknown.
Emergent properties can be quite unexpected.
logic1: If a property is known then the performance of a machine based on that property would be JUST.
Huh? What do you mean?
logic1: If someone has the capability to build a complex robot, that person would most likely have the capacity to understand all the properties of that complex system including emergent properties.
This is not true. The fact that humans were able to develop economies does not mean that humans are able to understand all the properties of economic systems. And I hope that you would agree with me that economic systems are complex.
logic1: I think you have carried the argument on something abounding freely in nature too far.
How have I done this?
logic1: As far as we know it, living cells which we are made up of only exist on the earth. Living cells have not been discovered elsewhere in the universe.
Yeah so what?
logic1: According to the most widespread scientific view, there was no life present just after the big bang.
Yes
logic1: The theory is that there exists a way whereby a DNA strand (the basic building block of life) can metamorphose from non-living matter.
Yeah so? Please understand that such hypotheses have nothing to do with the theory of evolution.
logic1: Evolution as a support for an atheistic worldview does not make sense apart from the above.
So what? Evolution says nothing about the origin of life just about the diversity. Again, not the origin. And this diversity includes humans.
logic1: Even if you believe that some aliens came to drop the first seeds of life that's still a BIG IF because we have not heard word from the aliens so far.
Well I never made this argument. This is simply a strawman.