₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,398 members, 8,522,839 topics. Date: Sunday, 22 November 2026 at 07:01 AM

Toggle theme

Thehomer's Posts

Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 (of 210 pages)

Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 7:27pm On Nov 20, 2010
logic1:
What I debunked was the premise that if 2 things are similar then one of them evolved into the other.
This is a straw man because I did not present this view neither is this a part of the theory of evolution.

logic1:
The premise itself is apparently fallacious. We could keep giving examples forever. For example the fact that a Honda accord 2004 model looks like the Honda accord 2005 model does not mean the 2004 model evolved into the 2005 model. It simply means Honda created it that way.

I hope this is clear.
Again you use a very bad analogy. Analogies that you make using human artifacts and contrasting this to biological objects are simply bad. So you should at least use better analogies.

And I hope this is clear.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 7:21pm On Nov 20, 2010
logic1:
Yes it could.
The problem with the common ancestory theory a la evolution is that there is no documented evidence of it happening.
I already presented you with documented evidence of it. The scientific papers contain the details.

logic1:
There are evidences that suggest it MAY have happened, but there is NO evidence that it actually happened.
I'm sorry but you are simply burying your head in the sand trying to ignore evidence. There is as much evidence for evolution as there is evidence that the continental plates on earth were once together as a super continent.

logic1:
Common descent may have a lot more going for it when compared with competing propositions for diversity aside from the fact that the Creator created it that way.
No, it has more evidence supporting it. Even more evidence than you have of your creator making it this way.

logic1:
The only proposition that I am advancing is that the Creator created it that way. This is not a credulous proposition if we believe there is a Creator.
I have established the fact that there is a creator therefore it is not credulous to say that the Creator created the diversity of species we have today.
No you have not established the fact that there is a creator. Could you state this proposition clearly with the evidence you have for it?
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 7:14pm On Nov 20, 2010
logic1:
The argument is that If there is a Creator (and we have established that there is indeed one), then He could have created things to look similar to themselves just the same way Microsoft (the creator of windows) created windows Me to look like Windows 98.
No you have not established that there is one.
Also, you're using a bad analogy because we know that humans write computer programs. This is not enough reason to assume that therefore humans must have been "created" by some other humanoid character.

logic1:
Again, we have not yet established who this God is at this point. We will do so at a later point in the argument as we have to establish some characteristics of God for us to be able to determine who God is.
Ok please go ahead and establish this but please give us good reasons to accept what you're saying.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 7:10pm On Nov 20, 2010
logic1:
If you want to know someone's capability you consider the person's highest achievement.
For example Bill Gates can create a company like Microsoft as opposed to Bill Gates is computer literate.

Therefore If God created Humans who can think then He himself can also think irrespective of whether he created other animals that cannot think.
That's a big if. So are humans your God's highest achievement?

logic1:
Bacteria and fungi are also on this scale but are of an order lower than humans (at least in the possession of the ability to think)
Is it the ability to think that decides the ranking on the scale?

logic1:
That is not the point of the argument.

If Humans do not know everything about themselves then the person that created them (who obviously knows everything about them) is of an order higher than them (using knowlege as the object of classification)
You're assuming some God for whom you're yet to provide good evidence for.
Besides, it still is an argument from ignorance just using some words you're yet to explain.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 7:06pm On Nov 20, 2010
logic1:
I believe this is the same God of the Bible but at this point in the proof we have not yet established that fact.
At what point did you establish this?

logic1:
By order I mean rank.
You're exchanging one word for another without explaining what you mean by its usage here so I still don't understand what you mean.

logic1:
If we were to make a classification of all the beings in the universe, God would be higher than Humans.
How would you go about making this classification? What are the other beings in the universe?

logic1:
Note that this is irrespective of the object (e.g. knowledge, strength, cmplexity et cetera) of the classification
Please demonstrate this classification.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 7:03pm On Nov 20, 2010
logic1:
The question is what created the something that existed before.
Why should one assume there was a creator? If you assume there was one, then who created this creator?
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:57pm On Nov 19, 2010
logic1:
The reason why I believe that the arrival of humans must have been a deliberate process is because of the complexity of design that exists in the Universe.
What are the objects in the Universe that you assume to be so complex as to have been designed?

logic1:
There simply is no substantive evidence that order can come out of disorder without external influence.
There is evidence for this. Consider that crystals order themselves to a solid state from a liquid state given the right conditions.

logic1:
All the purported evidences for evolution are just a bid to prove similarity between species or to try to establish adaptation by natural selection.
The evidence shows the similarities among species because there is similarity among the various species. Are you calling the evidence "purported" because you do not agree with it or you is it because you think they are made up?
Why do you still continue with claiming that only adaptation occurs after being shown an example of evolution occurring? There are many examples of evolution occurring listed at the link I posted.

logic1:
Another thing worthy of note is that adaptation within a particular species does not automatically prove inter-species evolution.
Evolution is not linear it looks more like a tree with more related organisms sharing common ancestors more recently so I don't really get what you posted above.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:30pm On Nov 19, 2010
logic1:
Ok if something preceded the thing that is available, what preceded the thing that preceded the thing that is available.
We can keep going on and on like that.
What we do know now is that the Universe started expanding and when it did, the matter and energy currently available were already present.

logic1:
I don't see how this affects my argument though.
It affects it because you said "something" cannot come from "nothing". If "nothing" does not exist in the universe then that pillar breaks.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 3:32pm On Nov 19, 2010
logic1:
I believe the Creator created the diversity of species we have on earth.
I'm not asking what you believe about the diversity I'm asking for the reasons why you believe this and if this belief is good enough to explain this diversity.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 3:13pm On Nov 19, 2010
logic1:
All of the evidences referred to in the wikipedia document are based on the premise that because 2 things are similar then one of them evolved into the other.

I have debunked that premise in the previous post.
I have not noticed your debunking anything. All you're doing is claiming "God did it this way". I don't think you'll accept this as a reason for e.g the mechanisms for the earth having a day and night cycle.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 3:10pm On Nov 19, 2010
logic1:
For example, the observation that humans share 99% of genes with apes can simply be explained by the fact that God created it that way.
This is not a simple explanation. It assumes a God and it also assumes that you know what this God wants. On a more general note, proposing a God for an action does not answer the question. If I changed the word God to Rar, does this make your answer clearer?

logic1:
The fact that 2 things are similar does not mean that one of them evolved into the other. It can mean that the both of them were created to be similar by the same creator.
It could also mean that both share a common ancestor and this common descent just has a lot more going for it especially when compared with competing propositions for diversity.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 1:29pm On Nov 19, 2010
logic1:
Step 3: Establish that God is of a higher order than Humans.

Humans do not understand everything about themselves. We don't have the cure to all diseases.
We have very little knowledge
Therefore if God created all the things that we know and the things that we don't know then God must be of an order higher than we are.
This strikes me as a bad argument from ignorance. According to you, humans don't know everything etc so my God does.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 1:23pm On Nov 19, 2010
On your second set of proofs,


logic1:
Step 2: Establish that God is a God that thinks and is aware of His creation

1. A being can only create another being of at most equal order to it.
I don't understand what you mean by order here.

logic1:
2. Human beings can think, they are aware of their surroundings, and they can create
Ok.

logic1:
3 If 1 and 2 are true and God created Human beings then God can think and is aware of His creation.
According to you, God or Rar also created plants, bacteria, fungi and other animals that cannot think in fact, these are the majority. What does this say about God's thought process?

logic1:
4. Therefore God is not "Nature" or a set of natural laws. God is a being of the same or a higher order than Human beings which are of the highest order that we are aware of physically.
Again what do you mean by order? What other creatures are on this "order" scale?
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 1:08pm On Nov 19, 2010
I also noticed your attempt at proving the existence of God. And I take it that it is the Christian God that you are attempting to prove.

logic1: Step 1: Prove that God exists.

My belief in the existence of God rests on the following pillars

1. The fact that we are discussing about the existence of God means we are real.
Ok, I'll accept this.

logic1: 2. If we are real then we came from somewhere. Either we were created by another being or we somehow materialized from nothing.
This statement has several flaws that I can see.
The assumption that if there is something available, then nothing must have preceded it. Have you considered that if a concept such as infinity does not exist in reality, then maybe a concept like "nothing" also does not exist in reality.
You have also forgotten that the theory of evolution also has something to say about the arrival of humans on earth.
You also assume that for humans to be here, it must have been a deliberate process. Do you have good evidence for this?

logic1: 3. I believe we were created by another being because as far as I know no human being has ever proved that something can come out of nothing at
least not in the known universe.
I know that you believe this but what I want to know is why. Again, why do you assume that "nothing" exists in the known universe?

logic1: 4. If we were created by another being then that being is who I refer to as God.
Is this the same God of the Bible? What if I call this entity Rar? Can you demonstrate that this Rar is the same as the God of the Bible?
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 12:45pm On Nov 19, 2010
logic1:
If other substantive inferences could be drawn from the same combination of observations, laws and theories then it would not be known fact that the earth revolves around the sun.

It is when a theory is the only inference that can be drawn from a combination of all observations, laws and theories that it becomes accepted fact.
And do you have a better inference that explains the observations etc. that we have?

logic1:
Also the article at the link you posted refers to an instance of adaptation not evolution.
Evolution is based on adaptation but evolution is not adaptation.
So what do you think evolution is?

Also, I hope you realize that the two mosquito populations were distinct and cannot interbreed.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 12:41pm On Nov 19, 2010
logic1:
So what's the point of asking questions?

Maybe I'm misunderstanding you. What do you mean by fact?
Fact is hard to define but I'll try anyway.

A piece of information about circumstances that exist or events that have occurred.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 12:33pm On Nov 19, 2010
logic1:
by saying "why evolution ocurred" I mean facts from which evolution can be inferred.
Ok. I've given you some links to check out. Besides do you have a better explanation for the diversity we observe?
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 12:31pm On Nov 19, 2010
logic1:
Please post a summary of the facts that substantiate evolution.

I have never come across facts that substantiate evolution.
You could start a basic review from wikipedia.
Check this link out http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evidence_of_common_descent
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 11:38am On Nov 19, 2010
logic1:
Yes laws and theories are different.
So I guess you agree that the fact that one is not the other is not quite important.

logic1:
The theory of evolution has not become known FACT.
I really don't want to quibble over what is or isn't a fact.

logic1:
It has not been proven positively. It has never been observed. It has only been inferred from observations where other inferences could have been drawn.
It has been observed.
Check out this article http://www.nature.com/hdy/journal/v82/n1/full/6884120a.html
Even if all we had were inferences, that does not make it inconclusive. Consider the fact that the earth revolves round the sun. This is an inference drawn from observations, laws and theories.

logic1:
For example, the inference I draw from the fact that apes share 99% of genes with Humans is that God created it that way and that the major difference between humans and animals is imagination and all our other meta-physical characteristics.
Well the assumptions you need to make to draw that inference are so much and most of them are untested or untestable so you may also understand why others may not be inclined to agree with you.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 11:08am On Nov 19, 2010
logic1:
Yes I agree.

The theory of evolution is important but that does not make it true.
Yes this is why I ask if you have actually considered the evidence supporting it.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 11:06am On Nov 19, 2010
logic1:
If it is well substantiated it would have become known fact and not just a theory.
So NO, the theory of evolution has not been substantiated.
It is also a fact the main problem is that many people refuse to accept it mainly for religious reasons.

logic1:
There have been various explanations as to why evolution could have occured but it is not known for certain that it occured.
I think you have it the wrong way around. The theory is the explanation that it occurred with mechanisms etc but science does not generally answer cosmic why questions.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:51am On Nov 19, 2010
logic1:
I wouldn't say it is an assumption despite the fact that it is not directly confirmed by the bible for the reasons below:
1. The bible is a source of truth but not the only source of truth.
2. The bible encourages us to look at nature to decipher the truth of God's existense
3. Science HAS SHOWN that there were beings that lived more than 65 million years ago and since the bible doesn't say the opposite then I accept.
4. Science is the pursuit of truth through empirical methods. It may involve guess work but it is always in the pursuit of truth
      Note that science places evolution where it should belong -  As a THEORY not a law.
      Science is not evil. Science does not oppose God. Science does not seek to replace God

The problem most people have with science can be traced to intellectual laziness. Most people are not willing to question their beliefs in the light of empirically verifiable truth. I think this is the height of HYPOCRISY.
The fact that evolution is a theory does not make it unimportant, untrue or unverified. I take it that we are using theory in the scientific sense.
Scientific theories and scientific laws are quite different. In fact, scientific theories are ranked above and considered more important than laws. You should note that theories do not become laws neither does a law become a theory.
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:46am On Nov 19, 2010
This must be one of the few threads that I've actually bothered going through most of the posts before contributing. I have noticed a very common misconception about the theory of evolution.

logic1:
I do not think carbon dating was invented by evolutionists for the sole purpose of proving their theory right.

Radio-Carbon dating is based on the laws of science and Willard Libby got the nobel prize for it. This is quite in contrast to Darwin's theory of evolution which is just an unsubstantiated theory.
The theory of evolution is very well substantiated I wonder if you have considered the evidence for it. Besides, there was no way Darwin could have won the Nobel prize because he was dead before it was even commenced. The fact that a scientific theory did not win the prize does not make it unimportant.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Is A Religion by thehomer: 11:20pm On Nov 18, 2010
Uyi Iredia:
An iteration (and rephrasal) of points in my former post should keep our discussion in check.

>>> The errancy of polarizing science and religion is highlighted by my 2 core points:
[list]
[li]The fallibility of polarity[/li]
[li]Their immutability in philosophy[/li]
[/list]

At this point it should be obvious that my intention is to blur the line between science and religion by means of two crucial elements common to both of them. Reason and Faith.

*Polarity is fallible because it ignores parallels between two concepts. it ignores their ambiguity and the fact that ambiguous concepts are handled by arbitration. I gave an example using good and evil to explicate this point. When you polarize 2 concepts, you ignore their similarities ab initio

*Religion and Science are philosophies. I expect that anyone should know that various 'isms' (e.g theism, deism, stoicism, platonism, communism, materialism, monism, evolutionism inter alia ) overlap and intertwine as regards the concept of science and religion. The plan was to make one realize this: the fact that religious and scientific worldview causes one's perception of reality highlights their similarity (they are one and the same expressed in different ways).
I'm not sure of what you're implying here but the fact that two things are similar on some level does not make them the same across board.

Uyi Iredia:
*1 >>> Enmeshed in reality. In subjects like knowledge, values, reason, mind, and language. All of which follow from reality >>> Perhaps so, given the fact that we can never have absolute knowledge of reality in its entirety, perhaps not_going by your definition of religion of course. I'm ignoring their differences_obvious ones given in your arguments. I'm thinking similarities_obvious ones you ignore in my arguments.
Why are you ignoring their differences when that is the point of contention?

Uyi Iredia:
*2 >>> Going by your definition of religion and faith. This further goes to show how subjective perceptions can be. Why others don't come to the same conclusion puts a question mark ? on what you have said.
The very fact of subjective perceptions is one of the shining lights of science.

Uyi Iredia:
A pity that scientists have to preach the scientific method to the uninitiated.
Yes. Unlike religion and some other similar activities, scientific thinking does not come easily. One must work at it.

Uyi Iredia:
*3 >>>  In a dark room a person places a candle, then walks away. Two persons chance upon that room. One describes it as a dark room with a candle.The other person describes it as a candle in a dark room. Either way they are right, its a matter of perspective. I propose the same happens for science and religion who are the persons. The perspective is faith.
This is a poor analogy. Here's a modification to make it clearer.
One person describes it as a dark room with a candle another describes it as a room with spirits causing the darkness that are being chased away by fairies magically igniting their wands.

Uyi Iredia:
>>> the fallacy of equivocation in this context goes deeper than the change in how faith is effected. It is based on what faith is predicated upon reason (evidence). I excused myself from this fallacy by saying that while faith (belief) is the same the reasons for such faith is prone to ambiguity.
I don't see the reasons as being ambiguous. One has a lot of evidence the other very minimal evidence unless of course one makes some unfounded assumptions.

Uyi Iredia:
*4 >>>  undecided  not good enough. seen stuff like that
I put those up for comparison of evidence we have about religious activity and scientific thinking not tool use that has also been observed across other species.

Uyi Iredia:
*5 >>> no  >>> but accidental discoveries (like those of Oersted and Faraday) have further advanced science. don't get me started on this one
I'm not talking about accidental discoveries. I said modifications of scientific theory are done deliberately.

Uyi Iredia:
*6 >>> What's false ? My assertion ? or the examples given to support it ? perhaps the part where i mentioned clout ?  let me make this clear. science is primarily based on authority. the dissension here is the basis for such authority, as i denoted it isn't always evidence. Political clout wielded in scientific circles has a secondary role (if not a primary role_and arguably so) to play.
Your assertion is false and even your example backs it up. Einstein's theory was accepted because it worked not because it was Einstein that proposed it. Your claim about the modification being based on clout i.e the person proposing it is plainly false.

Uyi Iredia:
>>> furthermore, if i had any doubts about my assertion; this statement you made (note the bolded part)  erased it.

this further goes to show that science is asserting itself as the only viable means of perceiving reality. it is becoming an authority_an interesting fact
I really don't understand what problem you have with qualified people evaluating evidence in their fields. If you want to be able to evaluate it, then put in the work required.
I don't know what you mean about science being the only viable means of perceiving reality but one thing that I do know is that scientific methods are the best ways we have of gaining knowledge about the world we live in.

Uyi Iredia:
*7 >>> no >>> but they were most definitely revised
Since the texts were not rewritten then someone else can go ahead and use another interpretation. How then can you tell who is right and who is wrong if the text remains the same but two people in the same times draw different conclusions from it?

Uyi Iredia:
*8 >>> i can clearly see that
Good.

Uyi Iredia:
*9 >>> They ARE in a single category_in Life, in Nature (and as I've repeated by the dozen) in Reality
Which of course places it in with all other human activities. So will you now say that all human activities are the same because they can all be shown to be similar on some level?
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Is A Religion by thehomer: 10:44pm On Nov 18, 2010
Uyi Iredia:
*1 >>> You err by surmising that I don't believe in evolution because I haven't studied it well enough. that is the connotation in your post. I am well aware of (and keep abreast with) the 'evidence' and counter arguments against them. Evolution still requires faith, especially so, since it deals with the origins of man.

The evidences for a lie can be overwhelming.
Evolution is not really about belief it's about whether or not you accept a scientific fact.
I'm asking if you have actually considered the evidence and if so, what are your particular objections? I'm not implying that you've not studied it well enough.

Uyi Iredia:
*2 >>> inconclusively
What was inconclusive about it?

Uyi Iredia:
*3 >>> yes
Have you considered that it is because they are human constructs? I mean consider languages. Human languages are similar in some ways.

Uyi Iredia:
*4 >>> Straw man again ! Science and Religion are tied down to ideologies. Why ?  Look at the definition of ideology.

It applies to both science and religion. You don't equivocate my use of 'ideology' to your own definition of science and religion. I hope I have made this lucid.
If it is a straw man, you need to show the misrepresentation I'm making of your argument.
The point I'm making is that whatever your dogma, beliefs or myths, science works consistently if done properly while religion is tied down to dogma etc.
Please point out the straw man or state your argument clearly.

Uyi Iredia:
*5 >>> I know so. You ask

I reply that it is exactly what science says. It is a religious inquiry into reality that engenders science.
Can you present evidence of this in any religious text? Or are you simply saying this because it is now current knowledge? I hope you realize that when these religions were invented, the original practitioners did not know the chemical constituents of water.

Uyi Iredia:
*6 >>> i was particular to use engender (or cause). Your use of 'influence' implies that religion indirectly led to science_not so. Religion (or religious thinking) which birthed science still influences science (and the scientific method) today.
So do you mean religion in general or just Christianity? Your claim of religious thinking influencing the scientific method is simply false unless you have the evidence to back it up.

Uyi Iredia:
You only asserted otherwise. by the way, as i gave with examples (like Semmelweis'),
What does the story have to do with authority? Can you compare the authority of any scientist to that of the pope?

Uyi Iredia:
science relies as much on authority as religion relies on evidence.
Which is not at all.

Uyi Iredia:
The differences and similarities are obvious.
Yes and the similarities basically end on the fact that they are both human constructs. It's the differences that are so engaging.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Is A Religion by thehomer: 12:25am On Nov 17, 2010
Uyi Iredia:
This applies to evolutionism >>> think 'blind watchmaker' and 'altruism'

*1 >>> same goes for evolution >>> it largely offers circumstantial evidence and labels it as direct evidence e.g point to layers of fossils stratified in a sedimentary rock as proof beyond all doubt as evidence of evolution >>> hmmmph !!! i 'm skeptical about this  undecided
The evidence for evolution is quite overwhelming. Fossils are not the only line of evidence. There is also microbiology, genetics, comparative anatomy, embryology and others. Have you considered the evidence and your particular objections against them?

Uyi Iredia:
besides my previous talk on evidence treats this so >>> its up to you to make the contrast.
I think I've attended to it in my recent post.

Uyi Iredia:
*2 >>> Mutually inclusive >>> YES >>> I'm WELL AWARE of the wide chasms between science and religion. That's why their inseparable bond also piques me. >>> How can 2 apparently differing concepts be so similar ? >>> Science and Religion follow from a thinking being
Are you wondering why human constructs are similar at some level?

Uyi Iredia:
*3 >>> Straw man ! This is what I meant by ideology

Science can't be excused from this. U are well aware that it is the ideologies of a practitioner which defines principles and how such principles are put into effect (that e.g when he/she wants to invent a device).
How was my statement a straw man? You say science and religion are tied down to ideologies and I say whatever the ideology, science still works. Can you please demonstrate how I'm wrong or how I've misrepresented what you're saying?

Uyi Iredia:
*4 >>> seems you have animosity towards 'the Big Three' >>> religion does inquire into nature, and it does so, continually.
Do you think so? What does Christianity have to say about the composition of water? Or the diameter of the Earth?

Uyi Iredia:
*5 >>> the scientific method has its origins in such religious activities >>> then_in answer your question_it goes to show that science and religion are philosophical activities. They are philosophies. In the realm of thought, science and religion aren't sharply contrasted the way you eagerly do
So what if religion influenced science at the outset? The fact is that now, it doesn't. I think the differences are pretty clear. From the reliance on authority to reliance on demonstrable evidence, the differences are obvious.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Is A Religion by thehomer: 12:04am On Nov 17, 2010
Uyi Iredia:
*1 >>> This doesn't topple my assertion: That one errs by polarizing religion. At least not yet. I anticipated this (fallacy of equivocation) as well. But the fact is that >>> 'evidence' is based on what one observes in reality >>> which further goes to show that science and religion are enmeshed.
How does this show that they are enmeshed? I ask because when there is a difference in knowledge that involves science and religion, religion is most often wrong.

Uyi Iredia:
>>> furthermore the fact that 'loads of evidence' could well amount to 'no evidence' goes to show that what constitutes (i.e could be taken as) evidence is ambiguous. You commit the sin of 'convenient ignorance' because >>> you ignore the possibility that >>> what you take as 'little or no evidence' to the religious amounts to 'loads of evidence'.
I have looked at what is considered as religious evidence and found them wanting unlike scientific evidence which can and have been evaluated by qualified people. This is why i say it amounts to poor or no evidence.

Uyi Iredia:
>>> You never denied that science used faith >>> you just don't perceive that faith as regards both science and religion is the same. I do
Pointing out that the use of the word faith interchangeably in both fields is a fallacy of equivocation explains my view on it. Why do you perceive that they are the same when their implications are so different almost contradictory in both fields?

Uyi Iredia:
*2 >>> By 'immutability' >>> I mean that one immutably (inevitably) follows from the other >>> To this end I don't agree that religion existed b4 science >>> I opine that either history (i mean historical works, archeological finds e.t.c) is misinterpreted or incomplete
Since you don't agree that religion came up before science, here are some references for you to check out.
http://www.livescience.com/history/061130_oldest_ritual.html for one of the oldest signs of religion
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/25/science/25creature.html?_r=1 for one of our oldest signs of scientific thinking


Uyi Iredia:
>>>  angry SSMH (Seriously Shaking My Head in defiance) >>> homer I DO NOT agree that scientific theories are deliberately modified. You make it seem as if scientists at large readily wiggle their heads in assention to any new scientific theory. You are aware that many new scientific innovations and theories were vigorously opposed_in some instances by people who should've known better >>>
So how do they get modified? Accidentally?


Uyi Iredia:
example  huh >>> Einstein's theory of relativity was largely scoffed at by scientists until it correctly predicted the 'orbital discrepancy' of Mars and sub-atomic phenomena >>> I once read (in a book) of how the medical practice of washing hands was scoffed at, including its 'father' Semmelweis >>> The great mathematical physicist Max Planck once made a statement denoting the fact that new scientific innovations/theories aren't accepted,  not until a new generation of scientists are born who accept such theories/innovations

Scientific theories aren't deliberately modified >>> they are dogmatically modified (it isn't so much about reason, but about your clout in scientific circles) >>> though it appears to me that scientists are making efforts to obviate this trend >>>
This is totally false. In science, theories are modified based on the evidence supporting it. Are you now claiming that science is based on authority?

Uyi Iredia:
It is possible that scientific theories of a zeitgeist can influence (and indirectly modify) religious text >>> I'm aware for example that the father figure of the church St Augustine was hugely influenced Plato's work and that in facct many church doctrines were predicated on the type of ethics Plato advocated for >>> more importantly scientific theories /innovations directly influence how such texts are (or can be) interpreted >>> an example being the case of Galileo Galilei vs The Church_we all know who won  wink >>> To round it off: the scientific theories I mentioned seriously influenced how religions perceive themselves and how they were practiced_this doesn't apply 'hard-and-fast'
But, were the texts rewritten?

Uyi Iredia:
*3 >>> I might as well (but won't) drop my castigating of atheism as a religion >>> u articulate your points well enough_some I agree with >>> but if my surmise be correct I don't agree with your perspective in its entirety >>> You constrict terms_might as well say you're pedantic
If they appear too constrictive, it's for a reason. I may need to be pedantic in some cases to get my ideas across clearly.

Uyi Iredia:
my definition of religion would become clearer in time. It would go on to make its own value or essence. (that's my stake) >>> I do not agree to a strict use of your definition of religion >>> you should understand that Christianity in its infancy couldn't be called a religion (it could at worst be called a cult) >>> the Romans were confused since the Christians didn't worship idols nor humans (Romans deified their Emperor), weren't interested in aggrandizement or ostensible display of worship, and, worse yet, actively and successfully propounded their beliefs (something which was rather queer at that time) >>> it didn't even have the sacred texts or practices you were talking about >>> most of these came in with pagan influx (and their practices) into the Church during Constantinople's reign. I also don't see why u don't juxtapose religion (or at least religious cast of thinking) with say communism_ i see parallels between them.
Ok I await your definition of religion. But now, Christianity is a religion. Sure we see parallels between one human endeavour and others that does not mean we have to force them all into a single category.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Is A Religion by thehomer: 11:25am On Nov 14, 2010
Enigma:
You supplied the definition saying, inter alia, that the definition may be closest to what you wished to say! If you now want to refute the definition which you supplied, then say so patently. Otherwise, I repeat that evangelical atheism fits in properly within the definition of "religion" that you supplied and therefore evangelical atheism is a religion on that definition.

The conclusions do not necessarily have to be my business. It is not for me but for those who claim that communism etc fits in with your supplied definition of "religion" to show the proof. No one has so far done so; they are still very much welcome to do so. In my case I outlined clearly how evangelical atheism fits your definition --- that is all I needed to do.
I already said I agree that "militant atheism" is a religion if you also agree that communism etc are religions because the fit with your interpretation.
Again, it has to be your business because they are direct implications of your interpretation. So it still falls on you to discard them in some way if you do not consider them to be religions. But if you consider them to be religions too then that's fine.

Enigma:
Actually, I am going to use this point to make a direct allegation of double-standards against you: in our old debate on faith versus reason you pointedly omitted to make a similar acknowledgment or to do a similar exercise in relation to the question that if you accord to certain philosophical theories the status of an intellectual discipline, why deny the same status to Christianity in particular.
Christianity becomes reasonable only with a certain type of assumption that I don't think one has a reason to make. Intellectual disciplines as I understand it are based on human reason without appeals to some other entity.

Enigma:
Oh, I did not bother with that because the points you repeated there had been destroyed directly or indirectly in earlier posts by me and others on the thread e.g.

(a) you said religion needs 'sacred texts': we asked you for the sacred texts of Amadioha, Shango, Obatala etc and you did not have a satisfactory answer.

(b) you say religion needs ritual: not necessarily so as not all religions have 'ritual' unless the definition you wish to provide of 'ritual' is as fluid as the definition you provided of 'religion'.

(c) still relating to 'ritual', you describe it as repeated acts in expectation of a response from a deity: this is an exemplar of the problem you have in (b) above: not all religions necessarily have a 'deity' as is certainly arguable with Buddhism, maybe even ancestor worship (and I think Uyi Iredia was probing you on one or two; I can't be bothered to go back and check which); not all 'ritual' is necessarily directed at eliciting a response from a deity e.g. some 'rituals' may be done for self motivation or edification.

You see the problem you have you have yourself partly identified: you state that religion is difficult to define ---- perhaps that is indeed the reason why you should be cautious about arguing that evangelical atheism is not a religion when that "movement" as you acknowledged (or prefer to call it) actively carries out several activities akin to religion including evangelisation and proselytising which are normally seen as quintessential religious activities!
I already agree that it is difficult to define especially off the top of my head but that won't stop me from trying.
Like I said before, making it a religion also makes some other human activities that are not often considered as religious activities religions. Which is what you are demonstrating here and at the same time trying to ignore this effect.

Enigma:
OK, I'll deal with them as numbered.

(a) "Militant atheism" is an old expression and definitions are extant; google the expression and you will have an idea; I think even wikipedia has an entry on it.
(b) Much much more importantly, my primary focus has been evangelical atheism and I have provided enough on what is meant by that; I referred to aggressive/militant atheism secondarily - incidentally, you haven't asked for a meaning of "aggressive" so I wonder (not really) why the  insistence on definition of "militant" as a prefix to atheism!
Aggressiveness does not imply a willingness to use violent tactics but militant does and I think this is a very important distinction when describing prominent atheists today.

Enigma:
Your definition required proof of practices, beliefs and teachings that are highly valued: it did not necessitate let alone require proof of parity of practices, beliefs and teachings. So this question is really neither here nor there. I have pointed to practices, beliefs and teachings that are highly valued in evangelical atheism; if evangelical atheism chooses to place a high value on daft and idiotic things, that is its own look out; other religions may of course choose to place a high value on better things such as spiritual things.
The fact that you presented practices you ascribe to "evangelical atheism" means that you are willing to compare them to common practices in religions.

Enigma:
No, I do not think rational thoughts and actions are wrong! I think and act rationally all the time; in fact, i am doing so right now. I think the more pertinent question is whether you think/believe all non-rational thoughts and actions are wrong?
I simply cannot realistically answer such a question that requires absolute knowledge besides, I don't think that is the pertinent question. I asked that because it looked like you view regularly acting rationally as a detrimental activity.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Is A Religion by thehomer: 7:57am On Nov 14, 2010
OLAADEGBU:
The theory of evolution is not a scientific theory it remains a belief that cannot be proved scientifically.
It has been validated several times over. I think you simply need to study it. If you think it is not satisfactory, then present your theory that better explains the great biodiversity we see and also explains the fossils, microbes, genetics etc.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Is A Religion by thehomer: 7:53am On Nov 14, 2010
Enigma:
@thehomer re post 184

The fact is that on one definition - your own definition - evangelical atheism is a religion. You are the one who picked that definition. Whether others want to fit communism etc within that definition is not presently my business.
It was not my definition. It was one I picked out of four from a satisfactory site for the purposes of this discussion. The conclusions have to be your business because they are direct implications of your interpretation. If you also agree that communism and others are religions too then that is fine since you're being consistent with it.

You may also note that I actually did tentatively come up with my own description of what I think describes a religion in my previous response to you on my post #178 with some other points I made about the concept of highly valued actions being considered religious.

Enigma:
Meanwhile I really don't know what points you say I avoided.
The points were in forms of questions I'll state them here.
1. What is your description or definition of "militant atheism"?
2. Do you consider discussing or promoting one's views about God(s) publicly a highly valued religious practice on par with e.g the practice of regular communion, regular prayers at certain times of the day etc?
3. Do you think rational thoughts or actions are wrong?
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Is A Religion by thehomer: 7:27pm On Nov 13, 2010
Uyi Iredia:
@ the homer >>> my conception of militant atheism  is  Atheism that actively seeks adherents and denounces all forms of religion whilst accepting ev olution as the SOLE basis of man's existence. u forgot to correct my error; under what are Shintoism and Taoism classified ? >>> also note that what is sacred is predicated upon what is highly valued >>> the ONLY thing which distinguishes both is the concept of 'divine' i.e something wrt a deity) which applies PRIMARILY to anything sacred >>> of course I mentioned the defining theme which is sacred to atheism

*1 >>> like your reference of faith (in which u said u only mean religious faith when talking about faith) , this definition is constrictive. You effectively annulled this definition when u said that defining religion is tricky (which I'' take to mean that the concept of 'religion' is ambiguous) >>> U probably thought otherwise b4 entering this discussion ?
The fact that I pointed out that defining religion is tricky does not automatically mean my definition was wrong. You are also free to present your definition. The definitions tend to attempt to concisely describe what they are for.
I knew it was difficult to define but why should that stop me from contributing to the discussion?
I don't think what you mentioned was sacred to atheism in fact, I'll go further to say that atheism has no sacred practices.

Uyi Iredia:
*2 >>> Don't think 'religious' adherents will agree with that. Besides this definition creates a quandary when I consider stuff like "Atheo-Buddhism" or the so-called "New Age religions"
In what way?

Uyi Iredia:
*3 >>> This is the same 'sin' u committed in your definition of religion. Besides the fact that one can categorize religions under theism opens Atheism up to the same possibility. Virtually devoid isn't devoid
. . .
Classifying religions under atheism or theism does not make such concepts religions. I used virtually devoid because I have not sat and thought of all other possibilities. If you have, then you can help me make the statement more accurate.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Is A Religion by thehomer: 7:20pm On Nov 13, 2010
Enigma:
@thehomer regarding post no 178

I went by your preferred definition of religion, which you supplied which I even hinted was intellectually inadequate.

I believe that I have proven adequately that evangelical atheism is a religion ----- according to your preferred definition of "religion" which you supplied.

cool
Yeah it's inadequate and religion is hard to define. But of course going by your chosen interpretation, promotion of communism, socialism even the promotion of some aspects of philosophy are religious activities. If you're satisfied with this conclusion then that's fine.
You've also decided to ignore other aspects of the post that criticize some views you wished to promote.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 (of 210 pages)