Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 11:38pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
Enigma: The point being made to you is that you don't! And that you and your science/evolution theory are making assumptions ---- the same thing you accuse others of. These are not assumptions. These are facts. E.g have you considered the fact that most of the animal life currently present were absent millions of years ago and that this fact is supported by multiple lines of scientific evidence? Enigma: A BMW shares a lot of "similarities" with a Benz; does that prove that they are from one source? Again with a terrible analogy. Why not go with something like the resemblance noticed across families, tribes and races? At least, the entities you're comparing have a biological basis. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 11:32pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: Yes the statements are clear. I am asking for the point the statements are trying to make.
For simplicity, A unicellular object is not complex while a multicellular object (containing at least one million different types of cells) is complex. Hold on here. So prions and stars are complex while bacteria, archaeans and protists are not? Please let me know how you classify objects into simple and complex. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 11:26pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: So do you have enough information to go in the direction you are going?
If you do not have enough information then you are making assumptions in taking that direction. That is what I mean by assumption. I have made no assumptions. I said I do not know. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 11:24pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
Enigma: The real question is whether the similarities prove that they are or can only be from one source!!!!!!!!!! Do you have better or even plausible alternate explanations? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 11:23pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: God is the creator of the universe. Is that his only characteristic? logic1: To prove that God cannot logically exist based on this characteristic you have to show categorically how the universe came into existence (including how the first matter and energy you said were there came into existence. Please present his other characteristics. Or I'll simply respond with my counter claim that Rar is the creator of this universe. Can you demonstrate that I am wrong? Or are we both right? logic1: Please answer the questions on evolution first before tackling this one. Your questions have been answered. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 11:18pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: by saying a creator should always be of an order or rank higher than his/her creation what I mean that in the order of their complexity from highest to lowest (1 = highest) we would rank them as
1. Creator 2. Creation This does not help at all. I'm asking for a way of "ordering" or "ranking" those objects I mentioned. I recall you ranking reptiles above bacteria. Does this mean reptiles created bacteria? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 11:16pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: Thank God. At least you now accept that similarity only proves the LIKELYHOOD not the certainty of evolution. Therefore, to prove evolution you have to get a different evidence not based on similarity of species. Science does not deal with proofs or 100%. logic1: I would like to see some other evidences not based on similarity of species. I already explained to you that the basis of understanding of various fields (not just in science) is similarities. e.g Can you demonstrate that the English Language and French Language are related without recourse to similarities? Plus, have you considered that lots of the evidence are also interlinked with other fields of science which also corroborate it? Besides, I'm still waiting for your explanation of the diversity using your creator. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 11:04pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: I assumed God exists because I don't understand how matter and energy created or evolved into life. Well that's a classic appeal to ignorance which is a fallacy. logic1: I think God exists outside of the universe because if He created the universe then He must have been existing somewhere before He created the universe. Well where was he? Who created the universe he was in before he created this one? And he's in it at the same time? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:59pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: Please cool off a bit. This is not a fight. I'm simply responding to previous posts of yours. logic1: I did not say science is wrong. I only said the evidence posted there is not sufficient for evolution as it still contains a MAY that can be explained by another phenomena. Well like I have pointed out, a lot of scientific theories and reasoning have this "may" yet you accept them. What better reason do you have for not accepting the theory of evolution? Other than asking for more evidence when there's so much already before you that you're still unable to account for? Well do you have this phenomenon available and explaining this diversity? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:53pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: By using the word MAYBE it is clear you are also making assumptions. By assumption I mean presupposition - to believe that a particular thing is trye before there is any proof of it. I did not assume anything. I'm simply pointing out alternatives which may or may not be correct. We simply do not have enough information to go in any of those directions. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:50pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: I think we unknowingly digressed from the original statement.
What I said was that If God created humans then God must be of an order or rank higher than humans. We do not even need to look at the object of classification to establish that.
A creator should always be of an order or rank higher than his/her creation. That should be very clear. I don't see the point of arguing over that. No we have not digressed. You keep using "order" in a particular sense that I do not yet understand and I think placing those objects in the "order" you mean would go a long way. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:46pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: Ok so if I dissolve salt in water and add more and more salt till I achieve a certain concentration at which point salt crystals begin to form does that prove order out of disorder? Yes. Solids are more ordered than liquids. logic1: Note that I originally had salt which is of the same order as the salt crystals. You are yet to explain what you mean by "order". logic1: I sincerely hope we can stop going back and forth with this. Maybe I will understand it better when you define evolution and give proof for it being responsible for the arrival of human beings. Nah try and find out what evolution is on your own first. logic1: One other point I'd like you to explain is how inanimate matter transformed into the smallest living organism. I don't know how life originated. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:42pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: Please clarify the point of the above statements. I think all the objects you mentioned above are complex and they did not come about by mistake. They were created. On the first, I think that statement is clear enough. On the second, I already pointed out that analogies made using human artifacts are bad analogies. All are complex? Even prions and stars? How do you decide an object is complex? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:29pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: Yes. If God cannot logically exist then everything I am saying fails.
If it can be shown that God cannot logically exist then I will have to stop everything.
If you believe that God cannot logically exist, please say so and I'll stop for you to prove it. It is very fundamental to my argument.
P.S. If God cannot logically exist I really want to know, This is not a joke and I am not being sarcastic. I'll need to know the characteristics of your God to be able to demonstrate this. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:24pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: The reason I said I don't think we are referring to the same evolution is that Evolution as I know it is heavily based on the similarity of species and you effectively said similarity is not a part of the theory of evolution.
By posting the wikipedia link, I'm sure you now accept that similarity is the most important part of the theory of evolution. I hope you understand that similarities are the basis of understanding in whatever field one is involved in. Consider one of the reasons why visible light and radio waves are both classified as being part of the electromagnetic spectrum is because of the similarities in their speed. Also, consider that one of the reasons why neon and argon are considered noble gases is because of their similarities in reactivity. Pointing out that evolution uses similarities as a basis of understanding does not make it invalid. In fact, it shows how much more likely it is to be correct. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:13pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: Finally we may be able to agree on one point. Yes we can assume the matter and energy of the universe could have always existed if I can assume that God always existed relative to our universe. If we can assume that matter and energy have always existed, then why introduce a God? logic1: Ah, I see one point on which you may be getting me wrong. I think God exists outside of the universe because I believe we are locked into our own universe and there may be more than one universe. What makes you think that God exists outside of the universe? The last I heard, he was hanging out on earth in multiple forms. What even makes you think that an entity being inside and outside the universe is coherent? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 10:08pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: The article you posted is titled evidence of common descent.
1. The fundamental point in this article is that because we are similar then we must have had common descent. The correct way to put it is that if we are similar we MAY have had common descent. If there is still a MAY then we cannot use it as a categorical point. We will therefore need other points other than similarity to verify evolution. This addresses points 1,2 and 4
2. The heading titled evidence from paleontology should be Possibility of evidence from paleontology. That section only explained how paleontology would go about giving evidence for evolution if there was evidence. I posted a link where leading paleontologists in a british museum concluded that paleontology has not given any conclusive evidence for evolution as the gaps are too wide. This addresses point 3 Are you saying that because science uses cautious terms unlike the absolute terms you're familiar with in your belief in God therefore, science must be wrong? I hope you know that by extension, the continental plates may have once been together at some point in time, the earth may be spinning on its axis, the earth may be going round the sun, dinosaurs may have once walked the earth. The moon may have been struck by meteors, I could go on. Your shift to playing with words rather than actually countering the evidence is simply a tactic I call "burying one's head in the sand". Please present something better than trying to include cautious terms. Also, I'd like to see your evidence for your creator and how this creator acts and explains diversity. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 9:58pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: This is not just between you and I, please post the evidences you can see in the scientific papers so everyone can benefit. Ok I've posted the evidence for it. logic1: I don't think evolution as I know it is what you are referring to. For the benefit of everyone, can you please explain in simple steps what evolution is and the proof that evolution ocurred. I think if you wish to even begin criticizing a scientific theory, you ought to at least try to grasp what it is before commencing. If you wish to do this, then please look up the theory of evolution on wikipedia. It is a nice place to start. I'm not going to do your basic work for you. Here is a link you can use. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Introduction_to_evolution |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 9:54pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: please ease of on the posts a bit so that I can answer some of the questions.
this way we won't be mixing things up.
Give me 10 minutes to answer your posts please.
I hope you do not see this thread as a contest.
I am just honestly trying to explain things and welcoming questions concerning my explanations in the process Ok. But, I think you can answer them in any order you like as long as you quote me properly in context. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 9:49pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: I said by order I mean rank and then I posted a definition of rank from the dictionary and yet you say I have not explained
This just proves that you are either not reading my posts or you are just purposefully ignoring them. I read it but you just substituted one word for another. I simply did not understand how one could go about classifying various objects based on that definition. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Is A Religion by thehomer: 9:49pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> Without an understanding of that explication, this post will tend to redundancy >>> i hinted this by saying that our discussion needs be put in check >>> state what you make out of that paragraph >>> (you should note) that it is the core of this debate I already said I don't understand what you were trying to say there. Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> as antagonisms against similarities you ignore >>> because of your rigid adhesion to your own definition of faith, religion and science I already said they had some similarities considering that they were human constructs. Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> same goes for religion >>> 'subjective perceptions' is one of several phenomena common to both science and religion >>> think 'revelation', 'intuition and 'imagination' (examples of aforementioned phenomena) You misunderstand me. I mean that subjective perceptions are one of the things science avoids but religion uncritically accepts. Uyi Iredia: *4 >>> if you think so by all means create a new religion >>> at the least a small church I really don't need to. We've seen the rise and fall of several religions. And, there are quite a few examples of new religions. Uyi Iredia: *5 >>> my analogy is apt for my conception of science and religion >>> yours is also suited for your own conception (or rather, definition) of religion in particular >>> we are both even in this regard No we are not. Your religious view accepts subjective entities such as demons and similar creatures I only included them there for clarity. Uyi Iredia: *6 >>> what kind of 'unfounded assumptions' ? >>> the evidence for a scientific school of thought crumbles when a new one comes up (think Ptolemy and Copernicus) >>> *at this point, i see our mentations and worldview, as equal to that of the characters Neo and Smith in The Matrix Trilogy. I hope you are thinking what I'm thinking* Scientific views do not randomly change. They change based on evidence. I mean unfounded assumptions like uncritically accepting the Bible as being absolutely true on all matters. Uyi Iredia: *7 >>> did you bother to compare dates >>> between the three ? *it seems at some point we are going to argue about evolution. sooner, than later* What's the point of doing that? Your reference was about a totally different fact. Uyi Iredia: *8 >>> i was hoping that you would infer that 'accidents' do modify scientific theories Why would I infer that? It's humans that modify the theories based on what has been discovered. Uyi Iredia: *9 >>> a rather weak argument since you jumped over how it was earlier rebuffed >>> also you reassert your point without even considering the possibility that my statement is true_with apt examples to back it up >>> Political clout has a role to play in scientific circles >>> please do some homework on this Then please present these apt examples of science being primarily based on authority. Political clout? I'm not speaking about scientific circles. I'm speaking about scientific theories. I think you need to present your evidence of political clout making scientific theories better. Uyi Iredia: *10 >>> I have no problem with qualified people >>> *another parallel between science and religion. i'm thinking 'teacher' and 'cleric'* >>> but >>> qualified people doesn't always equate to evidence/proof beyond all doubt >>> a lie can be syllogistically and logically proven Please what are the qualifications of the cleric? Science does not deal with "proof beyond all doubt". Uyi Iredia: *11 >>> i will >>> once you explain the notion of 'subjective perceptions' (which i opine equally applies here) >>> so you don't you accuse me of equivocating Yes it does. By subjective perceptions, I mean awareness via the senses that are made by an individual which are not demonstrated or demonstrable. Now, what do you mean by subjective perceptions? Uyi Iredia: *12 >>> i was being sarcastic >>> it is your pedantry (something you earlier accused me off when I 'came strong' against Deep Sight) that is causing conflict of our opinions I did? I don't recall doing that. Uyi Iredia: *13 >>> They aren't the same >>> but human activities are 'the same thing in different ways' or 'different attributes of the same thing' Good. Then I think a good approach then will be to focus on their differences rather than their similarities because I think we both agree that they are similar on some levels. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 9:19pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: For the benefit of all who will read this thread, please (as I have said before) post a summary of the evidences supporting evolution. Ok please just post the 3 strongest evidences that support evolution. It is not enough to say there is more evidence supporting evolution. please post 3 of the strongest evidences. Ok. Here you go. 1. Evidence from comparative physiology and biochemistry Although it has only recently become available, one of the strongest evidences for common descent comes from the study of gene sequences. Comparative sequence analysis examines the relationship between the DNA sequences of different species,[1] producing several lines of evidence that confirm Darwin's original hypothesis of common descent. If the hypothesis of common descent is true, then species that share a common ancestor will have inherited that ancestor's DNA sequence. Notably they will have inherited mutations unique to that ancestor. More closely-related species will have a greater fraction of identical sequence and will have shared substitutions when compared to more distantly-related species. 2. Evidence from comparative anatomy Comparative study of the anatomy of groups of animals or plants reveals that certain structural features are basically similar. For example, the basic structure of all flowers consists of sepals, petals, stigma, style and ovary; yet the size, colour, number of parts and specific structure are different for each individual species. 3. Evidence from paleontology It is possible to find out how a particular group of organisms evolved by arranging its fossil records in a chronological sequence. Such a sequence can be determined because fossils are mainly found in sedimentary rock. Sedimentary rock is formed by layers of silt or mud on top of each other; thus, the resulting rock contains a series of horizontal layers, or strata. Each layer contains fossils which are typical for a specific time period during which they were made. The lowest strata contain the oldest rock and the earliest fossils, while the highest strata contain the youngest rock and more recent fossils. And as a bonus, 4. Evidence from geographical distribution Many of the species found on remote islands are endemic to a particular island or group of islands, meaning they are found nowhere else on earth. Examples of species endemic to islands include many flightless birds of New Zealand, lemurs of Madagascar, the Komodo dragon of Komodo , the Dragon’s blood tree of Socotra , Tuatara of New Zealand, and others. However many such endemic species are related to species found on other nearby islands or continents; the relationship of the animals found on the Galapagos Islands to those found in South America is a well-known example. All of these facts, the types of plants and animals found on oceanic islands, the large number of endemic species found on oceanic islands, and the relationship of such species to those living on the nearest continents, are most easily explained if the islands were colonized by species from nearby continents that evolved into the endemic species now found there All from wikipedia the full content is here http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evidence_of_common_descentlogic1: I checked the link and I only saw evidences for adaptation not evolution. At what point would you say an organism is a separate specie? Again, what do you understand by evolution? One other fact you should realize is that due to the fact of common ancestry, these lines are blurry in some parts. logic1: I may be getting things mixed up so please post the evidences at the link you provided. Ok. You should also post your evidence for your creator and evidence of his creative abilities that explains the diversity we see. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:55pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: Please study what I wrote well. The analogy was to prove that if 2 objects are similar it does not necessarily mean that one of the objects evolved into the other. That analogy with human artifacts simply does not work because we are talking about biological organisms not human artifacts. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:51pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: OK, do you think bacteria are of a higher order than You using any kind of classification? Again, you have not explained what you mean by "order" so how can I use any kind of classification? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:49pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: Ok.
Simplified classification according to rank.
1. God 2. Human beings 3. Apes 4. Reptiles 5. Bacteria I need to know the method by which you are classifying your objects so I too can classify other objects if I want to. Also, you never answered about the other beings in the universe other than humans and God. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:46pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: I said I have not established it and you are asking me where I established it. Have mercy. lol I thought you had established it somewhere else since you said you had not established it yet at that point in your propositions. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:44pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: If we do not assume a creator then how do we explain how the matter and energy that were in the Universe came to be? Maybe it had always existed, maybe it came up by quantum fluctuations, maybe it had to come up as a function of this universe out of many others, maybe Rar set it up and went to sleep, maybe Rar and his brothers and sisters set it up and were destroyed in the process the fact is that we simply do not know and this is no reason for you to plug this gap in knowledge with whatever tickles your fancy. logic1: As was earlier pointed out by someone, historical science relies on assumptions just as we rely on the assumption of a Creator. Please can you explain what you mean by assumptions here or are you simply equivocating again? logic1: You've been saying that matter and Energy were always there. I am saying that the Creator was always there. both of us are assuming that something was always there, we only differ in what we believe was always there. No what I'm saying is that we do not know you are assuming a creator. If you're assuming a creator, then at least give us good reasons why. logic1: The only way then to choose among the above propositions or assumptions is to trace their logical conclusions and see which one fits reality as we know it. I hope this is clear now. Your assumptions really have no logical conclusions because according to you, your God can do whatever he likes. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:35pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: By order or rank I mean the relative position of an object in a classification or
The degree of importance or excellence of somebody or something in relation to other members of a group Microsoft® Encarta® 2006. © 1993-2005 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved.
Is this clear? This is not clear. How do you go about ordering a star, a galaxy, a stone, a human, a giraffe, a whale, a mushroom, a virion, a protein, a polypeptide, a prion, Clostridium tetani, an angel, a demon, a fairy, a tomato, a black hole? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:31pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: I used the term "purported" to mean that the evidences are just evidences for similarity (as you pointed out) not evidences for evolution. That similarity is what is explained by evolution so it is part of the evidence for evolution. Your alternative claims of a God does not explain a similarity better than saying "God wanted it this way" with bad analogies. But as I have pointed out before, it was not an explanation. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:27pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: A crystal or crystalline solid is a solid material whose constituent atoms, molecules, or ions are arranged in an orderly repeating pattern extending in all three spatial dimensions 1. A crystal is an ordered mass already! I know this. I said it orders itself from liquids which are more disordered. logic1: 2. You mentioned "given the right conditions". Those conditions were an external influence on the crystals. External influence? Are you about to go with a fallacy of equivocation because in the post of yours that I was responding to, your "external influence" meant a conscious entity. The conditions I'm speaking of are not conscious. They include temperature, pressure etc. logic1: 3. The mass produced by crystal growth is of the same complexity as a crystal the difference is just in size. It is apparent that a small diamond and a big diamond are of the same order. So what? The question was of the arrival of order from disorder without external influence. logic1: What we are talking about here is something of a different and lower order simply morphing into something else of a higher order of its own accord without any external influence. You are yet to explain what you mean by order and how one goes about classifying objects into various orders. To give you a chance to clarify, what do you mean by external influence? Because processes occurring on earth are influenced by the sun. So can we claim that the sun is the ultimate source of "external influence"? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 8:14pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: You (A human being) are one of the objects I consider to be so complex. You (A human being) are so complex that I think you must have been designed. I think evolution gives an excellent explanation of how humans came to be on earth. logic1: Your body contains trillions of cells that are different. One of those cells is like a miniature city. Another example of a terrible analogy. logic1: The most unnerving of it all is that all of this is built from one spermatozoa cell and one ovum. Imagine the complexity of the information inside the spermatozoa cell. This is a picture of what I describe as complex. What are the distinguishing features that when present, make you assume that the object is complex? logic1: This could not have happened BY MISTAKE. It must have been DELIBERATE. Did the elephant come about by mistake? Were they also designed? How about gorillas, chimpanzees, Escherichia coli, HIV, prions, Earth, The Sun, The Milky Way? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 7:38pm On Nov 20, 2010 |
logic1: That is a subset of the original question we are trying to address. The question is: Why do I believe Christianity is the right way. The reason is what I am elucidating in this debate. Please include how it explains the observed diversity. logic1: I think I have addressed this but for emphasis let me say it this way: If we continue asking what created the something that created the something that created the something (and on and on) that created the matter that existed before the big bang we will go on forever and never reach a conclusion. In other words it is asymptotic. What I believe is that God is at the beginning of the whole process. Why assume that some God started it off? It may simply be that the matter and energy present had always been present. If you introduce a God, then you simply have to explain how this God came into existence was it spontaneous or was it also created by a "higher order" entity? If you can accept that it had always been, then the matter and energy of the universe too could have always existed. logic1: My presupposition that God is at the beginning of the whole process cannot be proved invalid except science finds what is at the beginning of the process. It can also be invalid if this God logically cannot exist. logic1: Since the situation is asymptotic it is safe to say science cannot find what is at the beginning of the process. Therefore my presupposition stands. If this God cannot logically exist, then your presupposition again fails. |