Thehomer's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 (of 210 pages)
zoe80:Please what country's Christianity is God's standard? Please present your examples. So you want the U.S to become a country supporting witch killings, murder of homosexuals and adulterers? I guess you want humans not to think. They should simply follow whatever their religious leaders say or whatever aspect of the bible they want. That my friend is a guaranteed recipe for chaos and destruction. |
princekevo:Your claim about a referendum on how Christian he is will give as varying a response as that of any other American political leader. You do need to tell how he's a disgrace to Africans and humans. Not everyone believes in your bible or your principles. princekevo:Not everyone shares with you what you consider to be principles. You think he's compromised on this? You don't seem to know him as well as you think. princekevo:If he does win then what? Will you run away from Nairaland or donate some money to charity in his name? |
princekevo:Well what was the view of their founding fathers? Because from what I understand, they intended the country to be a secular one not a religious one. princekevo:You should say he's not the kind of Christian you are or want him to be. But remember he is the president in a country of more than 150 million adults. They are not all Christians but all should have equal rights before the law. What makes you think that you are the best type of Christian? princekevo:Well what does it say about abortion? Nothing the last time I checked. And homosexuality? Well I think it says they should be murdered. Do you want him to honour this? You must really be living in the bronze age or something. And I guess adulterers, fornicators and others should also have their just reward since he's behind the bible. princekevo:How do you know Obasanjo is not born again? Does he have to apply to you personally? A person being born again is not written on their forehead. |
Pastor AIO:Hi there Pastor AIO Pastor AIO:I think he implied that all along. The phrase "survival of the fittest" was not simply the most fit physically (may not even be the most physically fit) but the one that was able to propagate its genes to the next generation. Also, the theory has progressed beyond Darwin. Pastor AIO:Though you feel that it has no survival aim, it clearly fulfills its purpose by attracting the female. Pastor AIO:Other factors such as? I ask this because survival and sex do explain quite a lot about the animals we see around us. Pastor AIO:Abilities like what? Discarding the theory with so much evidence behind it and that has made so much information clearer about living organisms in general for some unknown perfection seems to me a pretty bad idea. In the absence of a better reason than the unknown is too great, not a failure of the theory itself, I think we'll make better progress into the unknown with the theory than without it. Pastor AIO:Please could you expatiate on these patterns of evolution itself as a more viable area of study. |
princekevo:How did you make this discovery? Are you implying that fighting discrimination and prejudice is a bad thing? Or that it would lose him his office? princekevo:I wonder how you evaluate a person being a disgrace. I for one consider it a bold statement against discrimination and would like to see your reasons for thinking he's a disgrace. |
[quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6206325#msg6206325 date=1276430573]Maybe, but what would they need any kind of advantage for? We're weren't evolving in competition with other animals, merely to survive and adapt to our environment.[/quote]We were competing with other animals for food, shelter etc. Only recently has it become more like an extermination. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6206325#msg6206325 date=1276430573]Let me head where I'm really going. You know when people take LSD, they 'see' gods and demons and galaxies and all sorts of weird things. LSD stimulates a part of the brain and these images are produced. That something can stimulate the brain artificially means the same part can be stimulated naturaIly. Without LSD or applying electricity to parts of the brain, people see 'visions'. hallucinations, mirages and 'aliens'.[/quote]You're quite right about that. In fact, that was how some drugs were discovered to function. The natural stimulation of these parts of the brain is usually supposed to go through the normal sensory channels i.e special senses. Natural detection of e.g demons by the eyes would require some physical difference in the eyes of those individuals otherwise, it cold be misfiring of some neurons as seen in some seizure disorders that are localized, abnormal associations in the brain or even chemical imbalance in the brain. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6206325#msg6206325 date=1276430573]Its presence in our brains means our ancestors developed and used this part of their brains for something, or it would not be in ours.[/quote]This is not necessarily true because it could also be a left over inadequate functioning of a previously important feature. e.g in constructing say a building, scaffolding is used which may have to run through a building. After construction and the scaffolding is removed, the holes created by this scaffolding may be weaker than the rest of the material used to cover the building so are likely to become exposed over time. These holes in this case would be unwanted side effects of erecting that building using that scaffolding. Or it may be something that has been dormant in humans that just happens to manifest itself when the appropriate tools e.g complex speech and expression became available. We really can't say or list the possible reasons for now. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6206325#msg6206325 date=1276430573]Look at this alien abduction stories.There is a lot of lies, honest mistakes, celebrity-status seeking, hoax, auto-sugestion, planted suggestion by psychologists and 'hypnotists', but there are some very, very few compelling stories that the, er, abductees seem to believe had really happened to them. Is it this part of their brains that abductees use to 'see' their abductors, which is why there has never been any physical evidence?[/quote]I doubt it. I think it's more of a testament of what the human brain is capable of. Our fiction, ghost stories, fantasy stories etc seems to me to demonstrate that humans if left on their own can come up with some of these associations. Plus, while there are many stories, all these stories cannot be true but they can all be false. The fact that there are a lot of them does not make it more likely. But now with all the satellites in space, I would expect that such large interstellar travelers to be detectable at some scale but who knows? [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6206325#msg6206325 date=1276430573]These sort of stories have been with men as long as they've existed, stories of sighting strange beings or seeing strange things. Are all these people, from time immemorial, hallucinating?[/quote]No I don't think they were all hallucinations. I think these stories are also used for social cohesion similar to the roles myths and folklore play in human traditions. And other uses to which we have put such untested/untestable stories to. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6206325#msg6206325 date=1276430573]Why are there prodigies and autistic savants who use connections in their brains we don't? Not can't, since our brains are the same, but don't know how? Why would we have such a faculty at all?[/quote]Actually our brains are quite different structurally and functionally due to the different neuronal associations we've made from birth. Prodigies too have quite different brains from other people this is demonstrated through the use of fMRIs in research. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6206325#msg6206325 date=1276430573]Our normal eyes developed as a response to the needs of this environment.What if some of these people aren't 'hallucinating' but seeing things that are actually there, only not in this environment? I mean, look at all the NDEs and Clinical Death Experiences, some of them in involving groups of people sharing the same 'after-life' experience together, maybe all were in a bus that crashed and they 'died', or some other scenario. It isn't just individuals, groups have the same experience, all of them seeing their bodies below, seeing and talking to each other outside those bodies, then seeing the same strange 'beings' and sharing all the experiences that follow, like a class being taken on a tour.[/quote]It has been proposed that one advantage was probably that the fear of the unknown aiding survival in that it is generally a better survival tactic to be cautious of sudden noises, strange occurrences etc With respect to groups, shared hallucinations do occur. Coupled with the fact that the data for these cases is simply not compelling enough, I wouldn't make any conclusions from mostly personal accounts. Humans are quite suggestible when in an appropriate state. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6206325#msg6206325 date=1276430573]The human brain is extraordinary, and I don't think natural selection was left to its own devices concerning us. It's far too complex, way above what we need to survive as a species.[/quote]While it is complex, but we do not know what would be enough for us to survive as a species since we are now self-conscious entities. The traits themselves while boosted by natural selection arise through some other mechanisms e.g mutation, genetic drift, recombination etc Plus with the realm of space opening up, who knows? Further evolution of currently the only species able to leave the surface of this planet may just occur given enough time. |
Oh my what a story. It simply raises more questions than answers. I wonder what language the "Welcome in Hell" was written. |
[quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6205849#msg6205849 date=1276421236]Yes, Mr Last-Word-Freak whose arguments I don't get. You're not listening to a thing, and confuse a dry recital of facts with presenting scientific ideas.[/quote]Of course I must have the last word, because I'm always right. ![]() All I'm saying is that one cannot simply present the facts to the public and expect them to accept it. Presenting scientific ideas requires presenting more than just the facts. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6205849#msg6205849 date=1276421236]I have questions on evolution. The human human brain is too big a response to adaptation and the challenges of our environment. Much simpler equipment would suffice. You see other land animals who shared and evolved in the same environment we did. Why didn't they evolve something even close to the human brain and human intelligence, whose workings still hasn't been fully understood? Our brains as evolved response to adaptation and the challenges of survival is like killing a mosquito with a mac truck.[/quote]I'm not some sort of expert on evolution but I'll try to answer those that I can. Now the human brain of course developed gradually over a long period of time plus, the unique features of being one of the primates e.g opposable thumbs, ability to move upright etc aided in its development and increased chances of a better survival. So when humans arrived at their current level, the brains plus these other features were a tremendous advantage over other animals. Other animals not in the ape family simply did not acquire the features present in the human brain because their bodies did not need them for better survival. Plus keep in mind that the environment in which we survived and evolved is also very different from what we have today. |
[quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6205537#msg6205537 date=1276413590]When I said look at the bestseller lists, it's so you could see books on science were bestsellers in every sngle year. The brief list on wikipedia you're presenting are not the best-selling books for those years, it merely showed which books were NUMBER ONE New-York times best-sellers for a given week. You do know what 'topped the bestseller list' means, don't you? Science is one non-ficition field of many. There are others, from politics to cookery to esoterica. A book may sell millions and not be at number one, because huge quantities of books in every non-fcition field are devoured. You don't have to be the number one best-seller, to be a best-seller.[/quote]You see going by the law of large numbers, it would be very surprising if no scientifically inclined books were bestsellers by your definition. The very fact that they are so few and far between should be an indicator of how popular they actually are. Why don't you simply present the source of your list to put this aspect to a rest. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6205537#msg6205537 date=1276413590]There are scientists writiing on difficult subjects whose every book have been bestsellers, like, one of many, Steven Pinker. There are and have been so many scientists writing best-selling science, I don't even know where to begin. Carl's Sagan's fact-presenting science tv progamme, COSMOS, was watched for its entire duration by hundreds of millions of people in over 60 different countries. His books are bestsellers. From the late Stephen Jay Gould to E.O Wilson, hundreds of scientists wrote best-selling books on their field. Even NON-SCIENTISTS who write on science discover their books are runaway bestsellers, like Bill Bryson, who wrote A Short History of Nearly Everything, which explored almost every field of science from its origins. I have the book. One of the best books on science you'll ever read.[/quote]Once again, from the law of large numbers, those events should occur. I've not seen Cosmos so I looked it up on Wikipedia. Looking at the first two episodes, I could see that the facts were not just simply presented. In the first, there was an illustration of life on other planets but the fact is that we know no such thing or how they would look like. In the second, there was speculation of life in Jupiter's clouds which is also not a fact. Such methods are used to encourage viewers. It is not just a presentation of facts. About the books, what you're doing is simply picking and choosing what may very well be exceptions. The fact that you have the book simply indicates that you're interested in science. But, the fact that the books did not make it to number one I think is a testament of what the public is actually hungry for. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6205537#msg6205537 date=1276413590]To be perfectly honest, I have no idea what stand you've been taking, or what you've been arguing for, exactly. "Presentation of facts don't work" and "It is religious personal interpretation that work in presenting facts, but it's dishonest so scientists leave it out of journals and research". And all the rest. Argument for argument's sake, I don't do very well.[/quote]You have partially stated my stand though you've presented it as a false dichotomy. Firstly, I think it should be clear that some facts can only be presented mathematically and that any attempt at producing some sort of images will be inherently flawed. The alternative methods of presenting these facts also include dramatizations, illustrations, and other similar elements that appeals to people in general. Religious personal interpretation does work for some but it's not the only alternative method. I indicated other elements there towards the end of that post. So I don't think I'm arguing for the sake of argument. What I think is stated if it's not clear, I'll clarify it. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6205537#msg6205537 date=1276413590]You do realise you're entitled to your own views on any matter, don't you? Perhaps we should get back to discussing evolution: Darwin, fossil records, evolutionary psychology, meteorites, the alien-origin-of-life ideas, hominids, dinosaurs, ice age, adaptation, trilobytes, primeval mud, etc. I've a lot of questions and I bet, so do others.[/quote]Of course we're all entitled to our views and I think presenting them anywhere means you're confident about these views and can take other opinions and criticisms that may not agree with these views. Sure so on to the discussion of evolution? |
[quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6201155#msg6201155 date=1276350954]Presenting the facts does work. Science has been doing nothing else. What's the alternative you're proposing, lol,: presenting non-facts? I don't know what would communicate 'it has worked' to you in telling people phones don't cause cancer, or cannabis isn't as dangerous as alcohol: if everyone bought extra phones, or if we all got together to get high? Would presenting the facts have worked then? Presenting scientific ideas and discoveries is one thing, telling people how to live their lives is another. Don't confuse the two.[/quote]No one is trying to tell people how to live their lives. One way of showing the communication has worked would be the reduction in fear of mobile phones and other electronic devices while in the case of cannabis, it would be demonstrated by better legislation on alcohol and marijuana. Also, when facts are presented, it is generally expected that if they are agreed with, a change in behaviour is a good indicator on how accepted it is. |
It's nice to see the OP on the thread he started after so long. On to the discussion. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6201155#msg6201155 date=1276350954]Lol, homer.You seem unable to criticize something bad if atheists are doing it, and must offer a knee-jerk defence.[/quote]This is news to me. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6201155#msg6201155 date=1276350954]You know science and its ideas, like the theory of evolution, are religiously NEUTRAL. They are about empirical ideas. They have no religious colouration whatsoever. Science is the investigation of natural phenomena, extracting facts and what works from it. There is NO evidence in science for scientists to use to 'support' and promote atheism or any other unproven belief in the name of science.[/quote]But scientists who have done so have indicated several things in their personal books. e.g The imperfect "creations", the differences between conclusions drawn from evolution and that of various religious texts etc. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6201155#msg6201155 date=1276350954]Disproving or promoting atheistic and other religious belief is the domain of academic Religion, Theology, Philosophy, Journalism, Art, Literature, etc and there are many atheists in these fields: yes, including Theology and Religion. Scientists promoting atheism and presenting scientific facts in the light of personal belief, is NOT and has never been the domain of science and scientists.[/quote]So you're saying scientists should just shut up and work in their labs? Do they not have any rights of personal expression? Your claim of presenting facts in light of personal beliefs not being in the domain of scientists is simply not true. Do not forget that there are scientists who are also religious they can also present these views. Saying that presentation of evidence to support one's opinions not being allowed for some people due to their jobs to me smacks of a poor class of censorship. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6201155#msg6201155 date=1276350954]You know personal belief has no business in the interpretation and presentation of scientific facts by scientists, and you were saying a few pages back that religion should be kept out of science. I see now you meant Christians should keep their beliefs out of science, but "some atheist scientists feel it supports their view and they use it". It's 'human nature', you know, since science/evolution equals atheism and it's their right. Very telling.[/quote]You have selectively gone through my posts. Here's one carefully explaining what I meant though it was in reply to someone else. It may have skipped your notice. thehomer:So you see in context, my statements meant something different from what you were implying. What I'm saying is that when people write personal books, it is normal for them to present evidence in a way that suits them but, if the book is to be used in teaching, such biases should be eliminated with proper reviews and editing. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6201155#msg6201155 date=1276350954]If I'm not considered a 'Christian' by some others because I accept evolution, it's because silly scientists have been on a campaign to equate 'science', 'evolution', 'rational' and 'high intelligence' with 'atheist'.[/quote]You're blaming scientists for your shortcomings. It is better for you the believer to educate other believers. If they are not willing to listen to you who believe similar things that they do, what makes you think they'll listen to scientists? Or do you think ordinary believers will not understand as you do? [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6201155#msg6201155 date=1276350954]It's the public that's now asking if promoting science is one and the same with promoting atheism. Still, you heard Bastage say the pope has accepted the theory, and since he does the thinking for Catholics, that means Catholics may now be accepting it as well, and they constitute 80% of Christians. Needless to say many other Christians accept it, and are the ones who tend to view the fundamentalist, literalist minority group that hasn't as boffins.[/quote]Simply viewing these fundamentalists in that way is condescending. Have you tried interacting with them? They share some of your beliefs. Calling them a minority does not make it less significant. If you can say greater than 500 million people globally are a minority. And this is for Christianity alone. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6201155#msg6201155 date=1276350954]Yes, you could, homer. But it would be about a problem that no longer exists in science:[/quote]The problem still exists that was why I gave you those examples. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6201155#msg6201155 date=1276350954]How to present scientific facts and ideas effectively. Scientists have long studied what works in the presentation of ideas to the public and what doesn't. Dry recitations of facts, formulas, percentages, homilies, moralizing, scare tactics, technical language, etc, don't work.[/quote]I don't think that scientists use homilies, moralizing or scare tactics. That's for some other group. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6201155#msg6201155 date=1276350954]Other things- wit, humour, a 'fireside chat' approach, a story format, arresting visuals, lively sentences,etc- works. People who already have a deep interest in the subject may appreciate those things, but don't even need it. Science knows how to get its ideas across, and has been doing so very nicely for a millenia.[/quote]So you think humour, fireside chat, story format etc are "simply presenting the facts"? People who already have a deep interest in the subject and in science in general are quite few and in the minority. If it had been doing it well for a millenia, then why was the sudden increase in scientific knowledge more rapid over the past 400 years than the previous 1,000? [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6201155#msg6201155 date=1276350954]And if you're implying the public isn't interested in scientific facts, you're incredibly wrong. A glance at the non-fiction bestseller lists over the past several decades might be instructive. The public is ravenous for scientific facts and ideas, and have been so for ages. Newton's books were bestsellers, in spite of their difficult material. Darwin's On the Origin of the Species sold out.[/quote]You did not mention the number of copies that were printed. The public ravenous? I think the New York Times Non-Fiction Bestsellers lists disagrees with that statement. Check the lists here the current list http://www.nytimes.com/2010/06/20/books/bestseller/bestpapernonfiction.html?ref=bestseller 2008 list: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Times_Non-Fiction_Bestsellers_of_2008 2007 list: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Times_Non-Fiction_Bestsellers_of_2007 2006 list: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Times_Non-Fiction_Bestsellers_of_2006 I don't really want to continue on down but the glowing absence is the absence of scientifically inclined books. Also considering the 100 books considered the most influential books written, I think one can count the number of scientific ones using the fingers. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_100_Most_Influential_Books_Ever_Written [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6201155#msg6201155 date=1276350954]The trend continues to this day. If science couldn't present its facts effectively it would have closed shop long ago.[/quote]It almost did but was revived and it is unlikely to close shop now due to the quality of products made from these advances. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6201155#msg6201155 date=1276350954]Presenting the facts does work. Science has been doing nothing else. What's the alternative you're proposing, lol,: presenting non-facts? Hey there, Seeker.[/quote]No, my friend, it does not work. Like you've pointed out, presenting science to the general public requires stories and a story line, plots, antagonists, protagonists, suspense, tragedy and other elements that make a good movie. If you want just the facts, then attend scientific conferences that deal with a lot of abstract and similar elements and let us know how interested you were in simply hearing the facts of e.g the mechanism of action of the proto-oncogene c-myc in causing Burkitt's Lymphoma or methods of light speed reduction in a cold gas. |
Deep Sight:That is not the only consideration in coming to the conclusion of it being natural. It is not even a good consideration. I only mentioned it because some use that to justify their bias against homosexuals. Other considerations include its presence in most human civilizations, the fact that they are simply a variant of human sexual tendencies. Others include bisexuality and asexuality. Another consideration is that there is simply nothing physically or mentally wrong with homosexuals. They have normal human feelings and drives. Plus people do not simply choose to be homosexual, they simply are homosexual. I don't think people deliberately choose whatever sexual orientation they want. They simply find themselves there. Deep Sight:I don't understand what you're driving at here. Are you implying that because an activity is not carried out by most animals it is therefore unnatural? Or is it that you need a list of the different animals that have been noticed to have been involved in homosexual practices before you can conclude it is natural. Though to be frank, I don't think that animal behaviour is adequate to be used to explain human behaviour. Deep Sight:How do you want to define homosexuality? For one no one knows what an animal thinks or how it thinks. Deep Sight:Maybe it's because humans have that capacity to reason and know what they like and what they do not like. Deep Sight:Here's on instance to refute your claim. It was quite a story when it was published http://www.nytimes.com/2004/02/07/arts/love-that-dare-not-squeak-its-name.html Deep Sight:Sure it isn't but that is not the only reason given for concluding that it is natural. Deep Sight:We do not know how animals reason. Or if they can. Deep Sight:Concluding that something is unnatural simply because it applies to a minority of a healthy population is discriminatory. Deep Sight:Are you now claiming that a deviation from the mean behaviour is something bad or unnatural? Please remember that a deviation from a mean cuts off two extremes. In this case, that would be exclusively heterosexuals on one side and exclusively asexual on the other when sexual orientation is considered on a scale. Deep Sight:What you're attempting to do is to impose your views on the naturally observed world while denying what has also been observed as being "too negligible to matter", or "mindless". Deep Sight:You're also now ascribing to a complex human behaviour a hypothesis of it being a hormonal thing. Your claim that it is a fact does not make it so unlessyou have some good evidence to back it up. Actually, both males and females have varying levels of hormones of the other sex, but the sexual orientation occurs in the brain. The hormones mainly influence their physical body structure not their previous sexual orientation. Deep Sight:No homosexuality is no more abnormal than being say a stay at home dad is abnormal. Hormonal treatment is used especially in transsexuals to improve their body image. Plus, it has its own health risks. |
babaearly:Oh he's an employee like a secretary or like "all presidents of the U.S. must be Freemasons"? Please tell us how you know this. |
noetic16:Homosexuality is natural. There are several instances of it occurring in other animals. Plus it has been with humans for as long as civilization. See here http://www.merckvetmanual.com/mvm/index.jsp?cfile=htm/bc/140208.htm and here http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/article1288633.ece Does the support of laws against the killing of witches, homosexuals or adulterers make a person an antichrist too? Since if one is not for Christ then that person is against him? |
[quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6194938#msg6194938 date=1276263367]@homer What evidence shows presenting the facts doesn't work?[/quote]I meant simply presenting scientific facts does not work. e.g presenting the facts that cellphones do not cause cancer has not worked, presenting the facts that cannabis use is not as dangerous as using either tobacco or alcohol has not worked, I could go on. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6194938#msg6194938 date=1276263367]Is it presenting a personal religious interpretation to it that does work?[/quote]As a matter of fact that does work. But it is not an honest means of doing it. So is avoided in scientific text books and journals. Novels and biographies on the other hand , [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6194938#msg6194938 date=1276263367]I accepted evolution because the facts were presented, as did many Christians. And not just Christians, but believers in other religions. By what other method but presenting the facts did you think we accepted it?[/quote]Maybe you did but you should realize that among many Christian groups, you would not be considered a Christian based on your acceptance of the theory. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6194938#msg6194938 date=1276263367]There are atheists who don't accept evolution, who have their own weird ideas about how we got here. I'll repeat that: There are atheists who don't accept evolution. Evolution is not some Atheism Creed to which they must all automatically subscribe. There are atheists who understand evolution and accept it. There are a great many atheists who accept evolution because, well, 'what else is there?' And there are atheists who don't accept it: 'There's no God. But I didn't come from monkeys either. When you find out how we really got here, let me know.'[/quote]Of course atheism has nothing to do with evolution but some scientists feel it supports their view and they use it. It is something that humans do (i.e try to support whatever opinions they have with some sort of evidence). [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6194938#msg6194938 date=1276263367]Then there are a group of atheists who see evolution as a counterpoint to, and a substitute for, religion. They twist the facts and use it as a weapon to 'bludgeon' religion, which they hate. It is within this group that the lunatic fringe in science resides.[/quote]I doubt anyone sees evolution as a substitute for religion. The closest thing to a sort of moral philosophy with atheists is Humanism. I've read a few books written by some atheists and I've not come across this "twisting of facts to bludgeon religion". Could you give some examples? Also, this "lunatic fringe" in science, I'm also not aware about. There may be scientists whose methods you do not approve of but calling them lunatics etc. really does not help your point unless you present what they did that you're classifying as lunacy. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=371029.msg6194938#msg6194938 date=1276263367]There will always be people to challenge any new idea, whatever its merits. It has nothing to do with religion. The history of science is full of bitter rivalries and scientists whose correct and visionary ideas weren't accepted by their colleagues for decades, and sometimes not till after they were dead.[/quote]Of course there will but some do this solely due to their beliefs in some religious text. And are unwilling to look at the evidence presented unlike yourself who was willing to consider the evidence. |
@ Mad_Max The evidence shows that simply presenting the facts does not work. As was demonstrated with HIV causing AIDS, and now with the extent of humans affecting the climate. One that was resolved after a lot of noise was the link between smoking and lung cancer. Also, I don't understand why people keep attacking scientists for doing what humans do all the time. Some have presented their views on religion and evolution in books. Should they not do so? They feel the evidence of evolution supports their views. Should they not write these books out of fear of offending religious people? Some people have become non-religious due to these books others have learned more about other people's views which I consider a good thing. When they do write text books for class education, they are reviewed and the bias is removed this is why text books unless written with some religious or political bent are good sources of information. With regards to religious people who do not agree with evolution, I don't think there is a reason for any one to make excuses for them. There are Christian groups that agree with the theory, and on this forum, there are religious people who also agree with it after reviewing the evidence. In this information age and the presence of sites (some which have been posted on this very thread) simply presenting the evidence without a religious bent, they actively choose to ignore the evidence before them. Atheist scientists meddle with religion more than religionists meddle with science.The above quote of yours is simply untrue. Atheist scientists have not attempted to stop religious books or materials being published neither do they try to stop private religious practice. Religious people have tried and succeeded in delaying research in stem-cell at least in the U.S. This was just recently overturned. |
Osama10:Do you really want to know? The short answer to that is that we cannot say it has stopped in humans. For the long answer to that, I think you should try to educate yourself a bit more on evolution. |
KunleOshob:What do you think illogical about evolution? Why do you think it's a myth? |
TV01:The thing with evolution among organisms like humans is the duration of time it takes and, how beneficial the mutation is to enable the organism propagate it through its progeny above that of those without a similar benefit. TV01:I posted some links about evolution being observed in recent times. Here they are again for your perusal here http://www.jstor.org/pss/2446125?cookieSet=1 and here http://www.nature.com/hdy/journal/v82/n1/full/6884120a.html and here's a web page with a list of some instances of speciation. http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/faq-speciation.html#part5 |
[quote author=@You link=topic=454057.msg6181647#msg6181647 date=1276089577]What do you mean? I think this is just whats going to happen, MOST of the people are going to fall, and only the ones that love him will be with him in the Heavenly kingdom. Matthew 7:13 "Enter through the narrow gate. For wide is the gate and broad is the road that leads to destruction, and many enter through it." It is what is easer to do [the broad gate].[/quote]My question is, why should it be this way? Why should God design things such that most humans go to hell and still claim that it was not for humans? Even most of those that love him or loved him would end up there. |
[quote author=9-11 link=topic=454057.msg6120791#msg6120791 date=1275247898]Hell is for souls that failed to do the will of God while they were living on earth (the unrighteous). It’s not for the living; and God's mercies are for the living and not for the dead as David accounted in Psalms 88 (please read the entire chapter with emphasis on verse 10 - 12). Hence God's benevolence cannot be questioned in his meting out punishment upon the souls of people that died in sin (the souls of the unjust and unrighteous).[/quote]Then why should most of his human "creations" go to hell? |
This is a guy willing to deny his sexuality. |
Jenwitemi:Please could you shed more light on this? |
JeSoul:Of course you may. It's an open forum.It is a theory based on how it was arrived at and its function. i.e It was arrived at after considering the facts e.g fossils, common descent of animals shown in their DNA, shared proteins, geographical evidence. Predictions made based on it that have been confirmed e.g new fossils found where expected, Evolution observed in some organisms. e.g here http://www.jstor.org/pss/2446125?cookieSet=1 and here. http://www.nature.com/hdy/journal/v82/n1/full/6884120a.html All the above have been considered in formulating it. Also, new evidence presented has helped in clarifying certain aspects of it and making it approach what has been observed and what is expected to occur. So in science, when a concept has been described as a theory, it is the availability of evidence demonstrating otherwise that will make it either be totally discarded or modified for increased accuracy. Some view this process as a weakness in science but it is actually a strength because, more knowledge will be acquired as better tools become available. So as a theory, what is left is for it to be falsified, or advanced but for it to be proven true would require absolute knowledge which is not currently feasible. So the use of the word Theory has different meanings in plain English Language and in Science. |
justcool:Theories in science are formulated using observations and experiments that have been borne out. They are to be demonstrated to be false with good evidence not to be proven true. The proponent of the theory says it is correct for some reasons when it is examined, it may be found to hold, or its predictions may hold or it may fail. If it fail, it will be discarded. A thesis is not yet a theory until it has withstood several probes. Before one can even start to compose a thesis, the person must first have some facts at hand. These facts must also be correct. Please don't let Nairaland lose you your job. ![]() |
justcool:Your feeling about my desire for a believers vs atheists battle is simply not true. I am more interested in getting across the reasons behind the theory of evolution than in debating whether or not anyone should believe in a God. That would not be useful on this particular thread. I think you should also research into the difference between scientific theory and scientific law. Like I said before, in science, theories do not get promoted to laws. And like I've also pointed out, they serve different purposes. And are also quite distinct from a hypothesis. Saying a theory cannot be proven correct indicates a misunderstanding of the purpose of scientific theories. As a sort of generalization, a theory is meant to explain not just an occurrence but reasons behind it by connecting previously acquired facts, experiments etc. It can be falsified by evidence. But until such evidence is available, the theory continues to be valid. A scientific law describes observed phenomena within some parameters and is usually mathematical. As such, theories are more comprehensive than laws. In science, there are no 100% proofs since, there isn't 100% knowledge. Have a nice day at work. |
justcool:The car analogy does not work with evolution because it is a natural process. It is more like a crystal organizing itself in a certain pattern. The final pattern that the crystal assumes is not designed. If humans were designed like cars, that would call into question the capabilities of the designer. justcool:My point is that you cannot tell whether a specie is transitional or not unless it becomes extinct. A transitional specie does not mean that the specie wanted to evolve or not. It is simply that its descendant diverged into something quite different from itself. The assumption that humans as we are will not evolve into something else simply cannot be known now considering the timescales of evolution and the human ancestry. justcool:The material you quoted agrees that amphibians evolved from a group of ancient fishes. It's not all fishes that evolved but those that had some advantage in surviving better than other fishes out of water to some extent. justcool:How does the existence of "end products" prove evolution is guided? Remember that what you assume now to be "end products" can be extinct, or may evolve later. Also, why are the "end products" seen today not seen far up in the fossil records? Why go through so many organisms just to get to the ones we have now? By a "guided process", are you implying nature or a known religious entity? What is the aim of evolution? |
justcool:Your statement that I put in bold is not correct. A theory remains a theory, a law remains a law. Both serve different purposes. Theories are not promoted to laws in science. See here. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_theory#Scientific_laws justcool:This depends on who you're talking to. justcool:Evolution not dealing with the origin of life does not make it bad or wrong or incomplete. It does what is meant to do well which is explain the origin of the modern lifeforms we see today and of ancient lifeforms we have evidence to show were once present on earth. Creationism does not deal with the origin of life in the sense that it does not offer any insights into how it came to be or how it can be replicated. In creationism, statements made thousands of years ago are taken to be true and facts are then made to fit it. justcool:It says nothing about God since it (the theory) does not need God to explain the current observations. justcool:So what are you implying? That they are both correct or both wrong? Or that they deal with different things? Because from the evidence before me, it seems that evolution is more likely to be correct in explaining the diversity of life (which is the purpose of evolution) than creationism does the same. |
justcool:How did I misunderstand your post? Please feel free to indicate this from my statements. Well what are you talking about? Flaws in the theory of evolution? Seeking harmony between religion and science? I think i clearly expressed my views on these. justcool:I didn't simply want to be posing questions but to also express myself on points of yours that I disagreed with, which were quite a lot. Please feel free to point out my errors. justcool:I'm not waging any battle I'm simply pointing out that from your posts, it seemed as though you had not considered some information currently available on evolution. Like I said I don't care much about your belief. But in a situation like this where there is pertinent information to be considered, I felt that it ought to be presented with respect to the topic. justcool:I have re-read your post and I do understand the difference between a scientific theory and scientific law. And I'm not sure if you realize this but in science, devising a Theory is actually more valuable than formulating a Law. justcool:On earth, a specie either keeps surviving and reproducing or it become extinct. So could you please clarify what you mean by "end product"? Because to me "end product" implies all currently extant organisms not just humans. Sorry if my reply seemed harsh I may have been under some stress. Cheers. ![]() |
justcool:He did not point out any flaws. Neither have you. What do you mean by the word "proven". Because evolution is now a scientific theory. This means it has passed several tests and made predictions that have been observed. justcool:We cannot repeat what happened on the scale that it did on earth but it has been observed in nature and in the lab. justcool:Oh? Threatening believers with what if I may ask? Some parties threatened others with hell, excommunication etc. Why do you feel that these people who feel they have the truth with some evidence for it have to keep quiet in order not to upset religious believers? After you define the God you speak of, you may proceed to present your evidence for his actions because evolution explains what was supposed to be the domain of God. Present your alternative hypothesis. justcool:The battle will not cease until people learn not to introduce religion into science. justcool:No. Creationism does oppose evolution. Just depends on the type of creationist you're referring to i.e level of involvement the creationist wishes to attribute to God. Many religious people do not agree with your view. What do you think should be done? Educate on the available evidence or leave them in their literal translation of their holy books? justcool:There you go. You assume man was created. This is an assumption that proponents of the theory of evolution do not make. justcool:It is accepted until anyone can present good evidence to falsify it. justcool:This is another claim for which you have no evidence. justcool:No. Bacteria do evolve. Those that have not, either fit their niche very well or are extinct. justcool:Another claim for which you have no evidence. How do you know an animal is an end point if it does not go extinct? justcool:Scientists do not accept such claims without good supporting evidence which is clearly lacking. Why should they? The current theory fits and works very well. justcool:That is your belief which you're entitled to. Though it may be wrong and open to criticism. You may spice it up whichever way you like but please keep your beliefs without evidence out of science education. |
[quote author=the_seeker link=topic=371029.msg5176088#msg5176088 date=1261610262] THE EVOLUTION MYTH AND THE ‘GOD QUESTION'[/quote]Which God are you referring to? [quote author=the_seeker link=topic=371029.msg5176088#msg5176088 date=1261610262]In 1831 a young British scientist set aboard the H.M.S Beagle naval frigate on a five-year expedition around the world. He was strongly influenced by the similarities and variations of life, especially on the Galapagos Island. In 1959, he summed up his observations and findings in his book The Origin of Species. The name of this scientist is Charles Darwin and he had just propounded what was to become the most controversial subject of modern science- The Theory of Evolution. Today, evolution theory has become the Holy Grail of science and anyone who dares question it stands the risk of being excommunicated from the fold of ‘enlightened’ scientists.[/quote]One of the ways science is progresses is by questioning it. That was how we arrived at Einstein's theory giving better results than Newton's. The theory of evolution has been questioned but has withstood those tests. If you have evidence that falsifies it, please present it. [quote author=the_seeker link=topic=371029.msg5176088#msg5176088 date=1261610262]But what really is evolution? And is it a science or a myth? According to the theory, life emerged on earth by chance as a result of random complex chemical and energy interactions.[/quote]No. The theory of evolution says nothing about the origin of life. [quote author=the_seeker link=topic=371029.msg5176088#msg5176088 date=1261610262]This ‘first life’ subsequently multiplied and under variable environmental conditions, transformed to all species including man, To put it frankly, we are here (on earth) by chance and not a product of special creation.[/quote]Well that is correct but depending on how you wish to use the word "chance". But special creation simply has poor to no evidence supporting it. [quote author=the_seeker link=topic=371029.msg5176088#msg5176088 date=1261610262]This ultimately raises the ‘God’ question and the inevitable clash between science and religion ensues.[/quote]Some religious people do not see your inevitable clash. [quote author=the_seeker link=topic=371029.msg5176088#msg5176088 date=1261610262]However in the light of recent findings in paleontology, microbiology, embryology, comparative anatomy, population genetics and biophysics evolution has become a theory in crisis. As a geologist and a scientist, I do not seek to preach religion as an alternative to science, I only wish to separate proven science from invalid hypothesis.[/quote]Oh please enlighten us on the crisis in the theory of evolution because those fields you mentioned actually support evolution. So please present your evidence from these fields. [quote author=the_seeker link=topic=371029.msg5176088#msg5176088 date=1261610262]As a rule, for something to be established as a scientific fact, one must to be able to run a repeatable experiment to demonstrate it. There is however no empirical evidence to support evolution.[/quote]Oh but there is. http://evolution.berkeley.edu/evolibrary/news/060901_mussels [quote author=the_seeker link=topic=371029.msg5176088#msg5176088 date=1261610262]To take a line of fossils and claim that it represents a lineage is not a scientific hypothesis that is testable. Why then do evolutionists assert that evolution theory is proven fact? The candid answer is that it excludes the existence of God.[/quote]No. But when all the facts from the various scientific disciplines are taken into consideration, they account very well for what we observe today. The aim was not to get rid of your God. That is left up to the individual. [quote author=the_seeker link=topic=371029.msg5176088#msg5176088 date=1261610262]They assert that it is not scientifically permissible to consider the possibility of a supreme being. This assertion is closed-minded because it excludes a viable alternative to how life came about on earth. The alternative hypothesis is called Intelligent Design or ID. It states that life in all its manifestations is specially designed and specifically created by a super human intelligent being- God[/quote]How is this assertion close minded? So far religious people have yet to provide observable or testable evidence of their Gods. I assert that you are close-minded because you refuse to consider evidence that is before you. Intelligent Design is misguided at best, dangerous at worst. [quote author=the_seeker link=topic=371029.msg5176088#msg5176088 date=1261610262]In its purest form, Darwinism (evolution as originally proposed by Charles Darwin) has become obsolete even among modern evolutionists. Darwin based his theory on the assumption that acquired traits could be transferred from parent to offspring. To put it in layman terms, a body builder who acquired his huge muscles from weight lifting can simply transfer such acquired trait to his offspring. Today we all know this is untrue, Darwin’s ignorance can however be excused because it was some years later that Gregor Mendel established the basic laws of genetics and heredity.[/quote]So what? We simply know better now. Darwin did not have the tools and knowledge that we have now. This is one of the reasons why his work is considered a great achievement. He formulated the theory using only what he could see and test at that time. So the fact that the theory he formulated has been modified in light of better understanding is a good thing. This is how science progresses and is one of the characteristics distinguishing it from religion. [quote author=the_seeker link=topic=371029.msg5176088#msg5176088 date=1261610262]Darwin also tried to explain evolution using NATURAL SELECTION. He stated that organisms within a population are in continuous struggle for survival, fiercely competing with each other for food and space. Hence, SURVIVAL OF THE FITTEST AND ELIMINATION OF THE UNFIT. For instance, in a pack of wolves an unfit member is unable to fend for itself and thus unlikely to survive. This a mechanism by which nature eliminates weak and diseased genes from a population. Stephen Jay Gould- a strong proponent of evolution commented that ”the essence of Darwinism lies in a single phrase; natural selection is the creative force of evolutionary change. No one denies that selection will play a negative role in eliminating the unfit, Darwinian Theories require that it create the fit as well”. And thus, ‘arrival of the fittest’ instead of survival of the fittest. The truth is that no matter how much nature eliminates the unfit wolves and preserves the fit ones; wolf will remain wolf and will not evolve into another species.[/quote]One thing you have misunderstood is the time scale required for evolution. Indeed if an organism is very well adapted to its environment, it may not evolve as we've seen such organisms whose forms are still the same as they have been for millions of years. I wonder, since you claim to be a geologist, if you can give us an estimate of how old you think the earth is, and how long you think humans have been on it. [quote author=the_seeker link=topic=371029.msg5176088#msg5176088 date=1261610262]Based on the above stated inadequacies of Darwinism it began to loose popularity. The ideology had however won some faithfuls among respected scientists. To solve the problem of genetic stability (genetic homeostasis), the new concept of MUTATION was introduced. Mutation is the spontaneous or induced random transformation of an organism genetic structure due to damage or relocation of genes. Evolutionist paired mutation with natural selection to give rise to the so-called SYNTHETIC THEORY OF EVOLUTION. By this, evolutionists claim, an organism could acquire exotic more beneficial hereditable traits through genetic mutation. Natural selection then acts to select upon the products of such mutation until it become dominant within the population. With subsequent progressive mutations, a new species appears in a period of a few million years. Evolutionists have finally found the magic wand that could transform blue-green algae into a human being in a couple billion years. A closer examination of mutation will reveal it is not he kind of mechanism that can cause organisms to ‘evolve’ to a new species.[/quote]Oh? But no one said it was just mutation. It was combined with natural selection. You said it yourself. [quote author=the_seeker link=topic=371029.msg5176088#msg5176088 date=1261610262]The DNA is a very complex molecule and random effects can only damage it. All the known cases of mutation in human are negative and destructive. These include mongolism, albinism, progeria, cancer, Down syndrome and the over 4500 documented genetic diseases.[/quote]Your claim that random effects can only damage it is wrong. The effect of crossing over seen during sexual reproduction actually is beneficial. So you agree that mutation can be harmful but you don't think it can be beneficial? Have you considered that there are silent mutations i.e mutations that are not observed in a population unless the need arises? [quote author=the_seeker link=topic=371029.msg5176088#msg5176088 date=1261610262]How then can a good-effect evolution to a higher form of life-result from mutation practically all of which are harmful?[/quote]This is a fallacy. We know those ones because they cause observable diseases. [quote author=the_seeker link=topic=371029.msg5176088#msg5176088 date=1261610262]The only example of “positive” mutation that evolutionist put forward is sickle cell anemia in Negroes. This is very deadly genetic disease that makes the red blood cells deformed and unable to carry sufficient oxygen. Evolutionists claim that the partial immunity that victims of this disease have to malaria is a positive mutation and thus an example of evolution in humans. Even if we suppose that sickle cell anemia gives total immunity to malaria, would anyone prefer sickle cell anemia in exchange for a lifetime free of malaria? Or that in the ‘evolutionary future’ we should all have sickle cell anemia and forever be free of malaria. This is absurd and can only be described as a gift from the devil.[/quote]There are other genetic differences that confer benefits above that of the local population when inherited in a heterozygous fashion. Support for this line of thought is seen in guess the animal used most for understanding genetics? , the fruit fly. Check the abstract here http://www.springerlink.com/content/v52t84t0r1x57262/ In humans, here http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2278105/?tool=pmcentrez and here http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10073943 You have decided to commit the straw-man fallacy. The population advantage is noticed in those who are heterozygous for sickling gene. More evidence will be available with more research in humans. [quote author=the_seeker link=topic=371029.msg5176088#msg5176088 date=1261610262]It is like saying being born cripple is an advantage since one would not be able to walk around freely and is thus unlikely to engage in traffic accidents. How ludicrous![/quote]Now a straw man analogy. ![]() [quote author=the_seeker link=topic=371029.msg5176088#msg5176088 date=1261610262]In reality, mutation does not in anyway lead to evolution. For instance the bacteria produce the highest number of mutants of all species, yet it has remained more or less the same for over 1 billion years. This lead Pierre Paul Grasse- former president of the French academy of sciences to say “what is the use of their (bacteria) unceasing mutation if they do not (produce evolutionary) change?”[/quote]What? Please do you know what the most successful organisms on earth are? They are the bacteria. They are able to survive in the most disparate conditions on earth. [quote author=the_seeker link=topic=371029.msg5176088#msg5176088 date=1261610262]In a futile attempt to generate 'evidence' for evolution, evolutionists have been inducing mutation (using radiation and chemicals) in Drosophillia (fruit flies) for decades. On this Gordon Taylor- an evolution geneticist admittedly said “it is striking, but not much mentioned fact that, though geneticists have been breeding fruit flies for 60 years or more in labs around the world- flies that produce anew generation every 11 days- they have never yet seen the emergence of a new species or even a new enzyme”. They only succeeded in producing sick and deformed often-sterile flies that often die off.[/quote]An expert edit. But you failed to mention that they were mostly used for genetic studies not simply to "generate evidence for evolution". Also, if the lab environment suits them perfectly, they will not evolve. The process is called natural selection for a reason. [quote author=the_seeker link=topic=371029.msg5176088#msg5176088 date=1261610262]Further attempts to provide evidence from other fields of biology have also proven unsuccessful. Such evidences either slowly fade away or are unceremoniously withdrawn. Some of the failed evidences include embryonic recapitulation theory, vestigial organs and Homology. Ernest Haekel proposed recapitulation theory, where he claimed that living embryos re-experience the evolutionary process that their psuedo-ancestors underwent. This theory has been confirmed to be totally baseless in science.[/quote]So a failed hypothesis is discarded. Again that is how science works. It is not simply held on just because it was proposed or written somewhere. [quote author=the_seeker link=topic=371029.msg5176088#msg5176088 date=1261610262]Organs like appendix, spleen, tonsil, thymus and parathyroid that evolutionists once claimed were useless evolutionary relics (vestigial organs) have now been discovered to constitute part of the lymphatic system that helps the body fight diseases. Also evolutionist earlier claimed that since all quadrupeds (i.e. man, do[/quote]Please complete your statement. About the vestigial organs, opinions were revised in light of new and better information and not held onto dogmatically. I would advise you to acquaint yourself properly with the theory of evolution before trying to knock it. Also, please review the evidence supporting it that is currently available before you attempt to refute it. A word about your Intelligent Designer, why would this designer not design these objects perfectly the first time around? Why not make the organisms fully utilize potentials he also made available in other organisms? |
mantraa:I don't think the book is actually free. I also feel that it is best to support book authors by actually purchasing copies of their books. But the review is ok to post. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 (of 210 pages)
. God will not change His word or repent of His stance on infidelity and all forms of immorality. Num.23:19
It's an open forum.