Christianity Etc › Re: Is There Anyone On Earth That Wants To Be Like Jesus Christ by thehomer: 10:54pm On Apr 21, 2010 |
Well I do.
What do you think the whole WWJD movement is all about?
Also, I think many people would agree to die/sacrifice themselves for say 100 million people if they already know that they will resurrect/be resurrected after three days and become a God. |
Politics › Re: Critics Call For The Pope To Be Arrested by thehomer: 11:31pm On Apr 13, 2010 |
Will the pope be arrested? I think that will be unlikely.
But should he be arrested? If the accusations of his aiding and abetting child molesters is true, he should face charges. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 10:22pm On Mar 07, 2010 |
viaro: Hello thehomer,
I'm sorry that your discussion has not yielded any fruit and that was why I let you be. Instead of going round in circles between propositions, I would rather discuss with others and grasp some substance from theirs.
If, on the other hand you would oblige me my request, I would be most glad to engage you. I cannot be repeating my request and only coming back to see your non-compliance.
As for the information bit, I can't think of information coming from non-information. Since you were quick to shout a confident "yes" to toba's question, I took you up on that just out of interest to see how you come up with any - ANY - such examples for your affirmation. So far, all the examples you have proffered have not stood for your own arguments, I'm afraid.
So, when and as you may oblige me my request, then I shall be glad to further this discussion with you.
Cheers. You still did not answer any of the questions I asked. I asked what "non-information" was because our definitions may be different. This would have led to some understanding but you just said information could not arise from it. Well what is it? And you've simply not answered any of my questions despite the fact that I answered several of yours. So good luck to you and your belief in the belief of a Christian miracle working physical and metaphysical God. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 9:51pm On Mar 07, 2010 |
toba: Who do u think is behind d force controlling d wind that is being felt&where do u think it comes from or goes to? Wind is generated by various occurrences e.g difference in temperature, terrain variability, rotation of the earth etc. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 9:35pm On Mar 07, 2010 |
@ viaro So please tell me what "non-information" is with examples.
Since you understand your subject so well, what are your postulates about God other than his being a metaphysical entity.
You're also yet to tell us what your metaphysical God does here on earth. Before you start speaking of reducing him to the physical, you should remember that he reduced himself to the physical by e.g performing miracles, commissioning people to write his "words" and allowing so many inconsistencies in his "words".
And you're yet to present your evidence whether by logic or metaphysics or any other means. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 9:26pm On Mar 07, 2010 |
toba: vivid information is perceived&felt with immediate experience.God gave us wind which is felt with immediate experience You've still not said anything. Wind is air in motion which is felt due to its impact on the skin. toba: thehomer.The data provided by God is d wind&air Please explain. toba: Im sure dis questn is a rhetoric,u should av directed it to your self.U would recall my asking u on d previous page if 'information could come from non information' you said yes&gave an eg of data&climate which viaro flawed completly.Your response presumes your knowing what non information is.Asking again will make me assume dat atheists are confused folks dat knows d TRUTH but ignorantly want to avoid it No it's not a rhetorical question. It seems that I do not know what [b]you [/b]mean by "non-information" since you disagree with my definition of non-information you could simply provide yours for clarification. |
Christianity Etc › Re: What If It Happens Tonight? by thehomer: 9:30pm On Mar 06, 2010 |
Madukaele: @poster trust me it will not happen this nite. Nimshi: Yeah.
Nor the next.
Nor the next.
Nor the next
. . . Ad infinitum. Damn right. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 9:26pm On Mar 06, 2010 |
@viaro viaro: My statement was not pointless - please stay on course. In science, it is not a matter of one-size-fits all; and the link I provided shows that same thing. You do not pretend that deductiive is the same thing as inductive - and you cannot just jump on any approach willy-nilly. They are pointing to 'scientific method', and I didn't argue against that; but you cannot just keep saying "scientific method" without knowing what exactly in that method you want to employ. It was pointless because the 'sub-method" I will use will depend on the sort of evidence you present. viaro: I did not "do it again" nor assume anything. If you can read, is it my fault? If you find metaphysics too much to your flavour, is that my fault, too? Why, if I may ask, have you been complaining about the metaphysics all along? But you have done it again. You requested for any other means capable of demonstrating the existence or non-existence of God and I gave you "the scientific method" with reasons why it is perfectly suited for it. You start asking for a metaphysical basis when the God you wish to present evidence for already is supposed to carry out physical activities here on earth. Though you've refused to give any other examples other than miracles. Do you think these physical activities would not be demonstrable by science? You gave an option of using logic to which I've also acquiesced you're still yet to do so. I've not been complaining about metaphysics. I already said you could give your evidence using metaphysics you've still not done so. viaro: I got bored already seeing the way you negotiate the issue of "information" and "non-information". I tried to see the sort of discussant you were by taking up that issue - and up until now, you have done nothing but present fallacy after fallacy. . . at the end of the day, we still don't have your example of "non-information". If that simple issue was far way out of your league, would I be surprised you can't habdle metaphysics? Please. I guess I should have asked this in the beginning since the simple issue is so obvious. What would you define as "non-information"? With examples. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 9:20pm On Mar 06, 2010 |
Deep Sight: thehomer your arguments surprise me.
the very existence of information excludes the the possibility of a pre-existent state of absolute void - except you are willing to further entertain teh absurdity that even the smallest block of information may emerge from non-information. Thus that pre-existence can only be conceived in terms of a permanent and non-contingent element which itself is, contains and spawns the infinite series of all conceivable information. You see what you've done is to devolve the discussion into another cosmological argument for the existence of a God which is simply not good enough. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 9:19pm On Mar 06, 2010 |
toba: U ve alleged dat information is superior to data.God gave vivid info about his existence. And how did he give the vivid information of his existence? toba: He doesnt need any data. Of course he needs at least if he still does anything here on earth. toba: But as a doubting researcher u can generate data for urself/be given a data to substantiate your claim. No my friend you're making the claim you provide the evidence to back it up. toba: Like i said information cant come from non information.Theists are informed about Gods existence&their information came from information provided by God,nature&man. Well before we go further, what is "non-information"? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 10:42pm On Mar 05, 2010 |
viaro: It makes no difference - whether data or datum, it still refers to information at its most basic level of abstraction. Neither data nor datum are examples of non-information. From your example with computers, the datum would be the bits that make up a byte. How much information can you get from a bit that would make sense in the whole scheme? It's either on or off, 0 or 1. It has to be grouped i.e to become a byte before one can make any sense out of it. To show how low level it is, you cannot even address one directly. Even at that there is very little sense to be made out of it. From your example with the blood groups, if you just said O without referring to other letters of the blood group or to the fact that you were speaking of blood groups what information do you have from it? For datum to become information, you have to either collect enough to form a group or add some vital piece of information to it. How can you claim that the whole group (information) is the same as a small bit used to make it up? Is the 5th bit in the 200th byte from the start instruction of the RAM the same as the whole byte? (You're yet to answer). viaro: Please search - memetics, even though its is pseudoscience, is still bandied about as a "science". No it's not considered a science. It's more of an attempt to explain some cultural characteristics that people share. viaro: I wonder why he then would have been trying to defend his pseudoscience of memetics when it has been criticised for what it actually is? It's simply not science (at least not yet). For it to be considered science, it still has several steps to go. Of course he'll try to protect it. He's proposing a hypothesis. In science, such new hypotheses are criticized. It's not a religion where someone makes a statement and all who believe the person just follow whatever he says. It simply is not considered science. viaro: Which is the more reason you should pay attention to the fact that it is not a matter of 'one-size-fits-all'. From the article you recommended, The deductive reasoning, inductive reasoning, and hypothetic-deductive or hypothesis testing are the three scientific methods, which are referred to by the generic name of the scientific method. i.e all three are used in science. For a scientific conclusion to have been arrived at, at least one of these methods must have been used. So your "one-size-fits-all" statement is pointless. All three are usedviaro: You only tell me things, never at one point do you ever show any demonstration. As soon as you tell me how science discusses and investigates the metaphysics, then we begin our discussion. Please do so, and let's discuss. What have I simply told you without demonstration? I have given you several examples (demonstrations) for you to easily grasp what I'm saying. You're the one who never demonstrates any thing. 1. You've not demonstrated what the metaphysical God does here on earth. (His present actions) 2. You've not demonstrated what you consider evidence. 2. You've not demonstrated your claimed evidence. 3. You've not demonstrated why the evidence should not be amenable to science while I've shown why it will. I had to give the example of miracles since you did not give any examples of the supernatural, which you tried to defend but couldn't beyond your anecdotal evidence. And I'm saying that the activities of this metaphysical God if they actually do occur, they must be detectable scientifically. You asked for my outline which I gave with reasons. viaro: I didn't assume anything. You show me what Stenger said about METAPHYSICS and let's take it from there. As far as I'm concerned, he was only preaching to the choir. You are [/b]doing it again. You have unilaterally assumed the [b]evidence for God must be metaphysical. Yet you said it was amenable to logic. You have also assumed no one could tell you anything different despite being shown with examples why your metaphysical God must leave evidence at least if he really performs miracles. I thought you were also able to present the evidence using logic. Which I said was amenable to the scientific method. Even if all you want to do is to present your evidence by metaphysics you may do so but I'll prefer you using logic. All you've done is to stretch this thread requesting for [b]your own[b] evidence for a God this far. You have not given the said evidence. I'm really getting bored with this. If you have no evidence or if you believe because you believe you've found evidence for this metaphysical miracle performing christian God whose word is the bible through philosophy then good luck to you. So you can go ahead and present your evidence whether through logic since you asked my preference and let's get on from there. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 10:29pm On Mar 03, 2010 |
viaro: Yes it is - and solidly so. It is not enough to just deny the clear fact, you ought to also discuss how those other references showing the fact are wrong, if at all. {"Strictly speaking, data is the plural of datum, a single piece of information"} - please refer. Aah I meant datum then not data. I thought data could be used singly that was why when I referred to it previously, I placed singular behind it. My bad. viaro: In all of this, the point is that you don't have any reference to "information" coming from "non-information". Data is not an example of "non-information", because it is clear that data is information at its most basic level of abstraction. I should have given the example as datum being the non-information not data and information. viaro: The 'scientific establishment', we all know, is highly politicized these days. Anyone may talk about the "scientific community" rejecting this and that as pseudoscience and pseudomathematics - but even in the field of evolution itself, most of the celebrated works are pseudoscientific - an example: memetics. I like the way this is discussed in Wikipedia:
[list]Memetics is an approach to evolutionary models of cultural information transfer based on the concept that units of information, or "memes", have an independent existence, are self-replicating, and are subject to selective evolution through environmental forces.[59] Starting from a proposition put forward in the writings of Richard Dawkins, it has since turned into a new area of study, one that looks at the self-replicating units of culture. It has been proposed that just as memes are analogous to genes, memetics is analogous to genetics. Memetics has been deemed a pseudoscience on several fronts.[59] Its proponents' assertions have been labeled "untested, unsupported or incorrect"[/list]
The funny thing here is that the "scientific establishment" celebrates such pseudosciences because it helps their politics, not because there is any scientific support for it. But all that is another matter entirely and should not distract us here on the subject of information. The scientific establishment does not support memetics. viaro: The thing here is for you to show any 'information' that comes from 'non-information'. It has nothing to do with digging up Dr. Werner Gitt's arguments against evolution - that would be as much as appealing to the fallacies of evolution highpriests (like Richard Dawkins) who like to wave their own pseudosciences in a celebrated fashion. Not even Dawkins himself in his memetics of "cultural information transfer" has demonstrated how information comes from non-information - care to dig on that one as well? I wasn't aware he was trying to do that with memetics. viaro: Not all are used in the same way, nor are the results a clone between themselves. Different approaches for different phenomena. viaro: It does - I already pointed out that I would like to approach my subject by LOGIC - particularly epistemic logic in propositional logic or metaphysical philosophy. Choose your poison and let's see you discuss your naturalism within the matrix of that kind of logic. You notice I have recently stayed on just this one question offered you by toba about information coming from non-information. I still don't see how you have demonstrated that you know what you want to argue, and that's probably why I feel we should not waste our time arguing back and forth where you don't know how to approach a subject. Ok what are the examples of what it does here? If you wish to approach it by logic, it should be amenable to scientific analysis. So go ahead and present your evidence. I've told you I will approach it scientifically. viaro: Dude, don't kid yourself. Stenger did NOT discuss anything about metaphysics, nor did he even look in that direction at all. I like the fact that the article summarises for me that he was "like preaching to the choir". What philosophy of reality did he even mention in that article? You're doing it again. You're assuming that it can only be approached metaphysically. I gave you Stenger since you asked for knowledgeable people approaching it scientifically. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Our Fore-fathers Will All Go To Hell? by thehomer: 11:18pm On Mar 02, 2010 |
Of course they'll go to hell. Except maybe those that were lucky enough to be captured and sold into slavery in places where the bible was preached.  Same as most of the people alive on earth now. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 11:08pm On Mar 02, 2010 |
toba: u talked about information coming from non-information,which science says its impossible&used data as eg of non-information.Code system requires data to give information,i gave dat eg to show u dat datas supplied into a code system can never be regarded as non information.In a census,u gather datas of male in a local govt as 50.d data has informed u dat there are 50pple dat re males,when u further analyse u may break down into age group,education,marital status etc using code system to give full information,however d fact that data tells u there are 50pple its an information&a guide. And like I've been trying to point out to you, counting just one person is not enough to get information about the whole community. You need to count enough people or use some sort of random sampling to get enough data to generate information from. toba: Same applies to existence of God,dat God exists came from us being informed of his existence through data/any other means What data did God provide for his existence? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 11:06pm On Mar 02, 2010 |
For me the rejection of Werner Gitt's whole information theory project against evolution, by the scientific community as pseudoscience and pseudomathematics is enough for now since I don't have the time now to go digging through his works and digesting them and then start trying to prove him wrong. viaro: @thehomer, No, it does not refer to them all without particulars - that is why such things are distinguished. All three are used in arriving at scientific facts. viaro: Of course, but I have not witnessed every case of a miracle - which was why I did not want to go down the route of 'anecdotal evidence'. I have seen cases of other types of healings; and I could also point to the "science" of such - but here is what I need to ask you pointedly: what would you be thinking of as "testable by science"? When I say testable by science, I mean phenomena that are observable, testable and/or logical. So does the God you wish to prove do anything here on earth for/to humans? viaro: I did not assume. Please go and ask atheists who are informed and they will tell you no different. Victor Stenger an informed atheist disagrees too. He is also a philosopher. Check here. http://legacy.signonsandiego.com/news/science/20020426-9999_mz1c26proof.html |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 11:04pm On Mar 02, 2010 |
viaro: There's actually no need to try to deny the fact that data (whether used as a singular or plural) is actually information at its most basic form. I didn't get that off the top of my head - it is incontrovertibly established that data is information. No it's not. viaro: There's no difference between "3" and "14159265" - both are still information at its basic level and therefore data. The reference to the idea of attaching "more information" is simply including more data that tend to a pattern - it is that pattern or form that becomes information at a higher level. Any unit of input one provides is information at its basic level, and that is what is meant by data.
Hang on, mate. Did you not realise that the link you provided was actually saying the very same thing I pointed out? Let me quote you an excerpt:
'The main difference is in the level of abstraction being considered. Data is the lowest level of abstraction, information is the next level, and finally, knowledge is the highest level among all three'
I very early noted that "data is actually a type of information at its most basic form", and that is nothing different from what that excerpt from your link says. The fact that the difference is simply a matter of the level of abstraction considered does not mean that it is only at the second level that we find "information" - no.
Information actually occurs at the basic level of 'data', and even the example used in that link is quite simply an allusion to data as a kind of information. That example says:
'the height of Mt. Everest is generally considered as "data", a book on Mt. Everest geological characteristics may be considered as "information", and a report containing practical information on the best way to reach Mt. Everest's peak may be considered as "knowledge"'
Lol, what has happened is that the height of Mt. Everest is actually the most basic information that has been provided - it is not meaningless, otherwise the author would not have been able to identify it as "height". You do not refer to a "height" as meaningless, because it immediately identifies a particular character of Mt. Everest - and this is a clear example where even Wikipedia authors sometimes confuse issues for themselves and the public. Data at its lowest level is not information. Sure at some higher levels, what may be considered information would depend on the person's point of view. In that example, you've been given several other pointers; the referral to Mt. Everest, the measurement given as height, etc. Now consider that all you were given was "8848". No units, nothing linking it to being a mountain. Would you consider this as data or information? How about "1989" what do you make of it without my adding anything else to it? viaro: I could go on and take up this issue in more practical examples; but the point is that data is still a form of information at the most basic level. The idea that data is "meaningless" is patently false - otherwise the example in your link would mean that "height" as an example of data is meaningless - then why is it called "height"? Data is a type of information. Oh yes discrete data points are meaningless. You need groups of data to make anything out. By the time you've given the height in relation to Mt. Everest it wouldn't be meaningless. But if e.g someone makes a statement like this to someone else on the street. "Something is 8849 metres high". Has the speaker conveyed information or provided data? If the recipient knows something about mountains, it would be information. But if the person doesn't know much about mountains, he would consider it data requiring more input for him to make sense of it. Another thing I should point out is that since you need multiple data to be grouped/processed etc for it to be information, how can you claim that the whole group (information) is the same as a small bit used to make it up? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 11:14pm On Mar 01, 2010 |
toba: Diverse definition,yet works sameway across diverse environment.Used for tabulation&statistical data. For a good result of code system u need your data from very intelligent source&in dis context your so called 'non-information' wouldnt work cause well equiped data would guide u.For e.g to use a code system for census, your data must be concrete&complete or else your population figure will av error.Hence d datas required cant be called information from non-information.Cause data is part of information I don't quite understand your definition of a code system. "A code system has diverse definition,yet works sameway across diverse environment. A code system is used for tabulation&statistical data." What's the relevance to the evidence of a God? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 11:12pm On Mar 01, 2010 |
viaro: There are indeed different types of science (please see this page and Wikipedia). You can also find an interesting list of many types of sciences at this page of the Phrontistery. I didn't mean the subgroups of scientific disciplines. I wasn't using "types" in that sense. viaro: Further, there are different types "scientific methods" - it is not a case of 'one-size-fits-all'. I recommend this resource (under 'philosophy of science') for your consideration. From the page you referred me to. http://www.molwick.com/en/scientific-methods/024-reasoning.html#texto[Quote] The deductive reasoning, inductive reasoning, and hypothetic-deductive or hypothesis testing are the three scientific methods, which are referred to by the generic name of the scientific method.[/quote]I was using the generic name. It refers to them all. viaro: I don't think you did, or you would not have said that I just "introduced" it after I had mentioned 'metaphysical discussions' long before that reply. The point was that you simply did not oblige me my requests, and beyond that point it did not seem you wanted me to take you seriously. From prior posts, you seemed open to another way of approaching the subject. But what you said before my post that you misquoted was that I was trying to apply the scientific method to what you on your own had just concluded was a metaphysical question. i.e you had already ruled out all other approaches and I had not agreed to ruling them out. The emphasis was on the phrase in bold not on "now". thehomer: You have now introduced more suitable in metaphysical discussions. And I've repeatedly given you the latitude to go metaphysical just provide your evidence. viaro: No, their actions should not "keep violating" what we already know - by that statement you demonstrate you did not have a proper understanding of the subject. Secondly, you argue that it is not a purely metaphysical one, and that was why I requested you to show me why and how. The source from an atheist did not indicate any different from what I stated about metaphysical questions; and I would have been glad if you discussed issues rather than merely saying this and that. How does the statement demonstrate this? The topic is not just about whether a God exists but also about the evidence for it. Or are you saying this God does not have any effects on humans? Does not interfere in human activities? viaro: That's okay with me, as long as you practically demonstrate the contrary. I did a few times with the examples of the amputee and the sickle cell disease patient. If the God effects a cure, it will be demonstrable scientifically. Or is there a way a cure could be effected without it being demonstrable by science? viaro: I chose metaphysics because that is the premise on which metaphycal questions are discussed. You have assumed it is purely metaphysical. This I do not agree with. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 11:04pm On Mar 01, 2010 |
viaro: Data is not an example of "non-information", nor is climate an example of "non-information". Depending on the type of area of application, it could be used to generate other types of information at higher levels; nonetheless, data is actually a type of information at its most basic form. I already said climate was not "non-information". Data (singular) is not information. Here's an example to illustrate what I mean. A man walks up to someone and says "3". That is data but not information. For it to become information, he could give more data "14159265". The other person may recognize this as pi. Or the person may attach some more information. e.g "that is how old my daughter is." Then it becomes more meaningful. viaro: (a) "The term data means groups of information that represent the qualitative or quantitative attributes of a variable or set of variables" (Wikipedia).
(b) "Strictly speaking, data is the plural of datum, a single piece of information. In practice, however, people use data as both the singular and plural form of the word" (Webopedia).
(c) 1. (plural: data) a single piece of information 2. (philosophy) (plural: data) a fact known from direct observation 3. (philosophy) (plural: data) a premise from which conclusions are drawn 4. (cartography)(engineering) (plural: datums) a fixed reference point ~ (Wikitionary) The link I gave http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data#Meaning_of_data.2C_information_and_knowledge already distinguished between data, information and knowledge. From the above link Data on its own carries no meaning. In order for data to become information, it must be interpreted and take on a meaning. For data to be information, it needs to be grouped and/or processed. viaro: That is an example of the ad hominem fallacy in discourses. The fact that he is a creationist or someone made an entry on him anywhere does not take anything away from the substance of his discussion on information. The fact here is that your example of "non-information" is flawed, and it would have been rather helpful to see what is said rather than the person who said whatever. The point I was making there is that he is already biased and his treatment of that topic and his conclusions had been refuted by other non-biased experts in the field. Plus his article was not published in a peer reviewed journal. This information was already presented on the same page. That's why I was referring the poster to the entry. viaro: "Examine what is said, not him who speaks" (Arab proverb). When it comes to issues in science, it is also important to examine who speaks. Some people who make statements about scientific facts may actually not be qualified to do so. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 12:05am On Mar 01, 2010 |
toba: I see wikipedia is your most reliable source of information. This is to show dat your information being given here comes from information from wikipedia. It's not my most reliable source of information. I wouldn't use it when it comes to specifics in my specialty. I like it because it is free and quite detailed on a wide range of topics. It also gets updated rapidly. I use it in these discussions for the other party to also check it out and follow the references if the person is so inclined. toba: Anyway,do u know a code system is always d result of a mental process(it requires an intelligent origin or inventor).It should be emphasized dat matter as such is unable to generate any code.All experience indicate dat . Thinking being voluntarily exercising his own free will cognition&creativity is required. What is a "code system"? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 11:14pm On Feb 28, 2010 |
viaro: 4. After I outlined how I intended to pursue this discourse, thehomer objected by indicating that it was one that should be detectable by "scientific means". No worries, my request was that he should tell me "what type of science" he thought could be used for such a metaphysical question, and then I would be glad to lead him in that same means to discover the supernatural - but from that point (post #74), he never once ever obliged my request and seemed to only have kept cycling round it. There are no "types of science" science has a clear method of approaching problems. viaro: 5. Where I lost it was when he (thehomer) boldly claimed falsely that I had "now introduced" the metaphysics into the whole thing - like that was supposed to be my escape hatch. I thought at that point, we had had enough of the games, and that was why I was curt with him. No no no. You said you wanted to use metaphysics I said fine. You asked how and why science is more suited to metaphysical discussions. I'm saying it is not purely metaphysical. The examples I was giving were meant to indicate that the activities of your claimed metaphysical entities influence events here on earth. If they do so, science is the best way to detect their actions here. Their actions should keep violating what we already know. viaro: 6. As far as I know, questions about "all reality" and the nature of being and existence are philosophical questions of metaphysics. The reason why I kept repeating myself on that same point was to help thehomer (and any other interested atheist) show me otherwise. This is a fact that informed atheists cannot deny, and so many established sources still bear out this fact - that metaphysical questions are best treated on metaphysical premises. For this reason, I excerpted an atheist source (Austin Cline) attesting to this and showing clearly a recommendation, that: "in truth, metaphysics is probably the most fundamental subject which irreligious atheists should focus on". That was coming from an atheist - and I don't know why thehomer was not facing up to that fact. Of course, I was hoping he would show me otherwise - but that was where it seemed the discussion had stalled. I'm of a different opinion. viaro: 7. It isn't that I was not willing to discuss at all - on the contrary, I was clear to repeatedly indicate that the question is purely a metaphysical one, and as such should be discussed on metaphysical premises. If my atheist discussant(s) agreed and were more inclined to "science", they should grant me just one request: please give me a specific outline of why "science" is more suitable for them, as well as how science answers metaphysical questions. I chose to use science because I did not feel it was purely metaphysical the actions of these beings are supposed to affect humans here. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 10:53pm On Feb 28, 2010 |
norri: thehomer In response to Post 174, no doubt science will keep pushing the boundaries. If everybody remains dogmatic to their religious books then the world would never progress. But as science doesn't have the answers to everything at present, religion and science can work together. By work together I hope you don't mean suppress science or prevent science from criticizing religious dogma especially where it affects other people. norri: I aplogise if my views appear to be forced onto people, that is not my intention. I was just trying to offer an opposing view. I wasn't referring to you in particular. Of course you can offer an opposing view. It's a free world and your right to speak and be heard should not be suppressed. norri: I cannot answer the question "what is the purpose of life?". To my knowledge nobody can, which is why many people are lead to believe in a God. And I'm saying not knowing enough about something now is not enough reason for me to believe or not believe in a God. For all we know, it may be unanswerable, or there may be no purpose or something else. It really doesn't bother me. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 10:50pm On Feb 28, 2010 |
toba: I disagree with u.Dr werner Gitt said we know absolutely for sure from science dat information cannot arise from disorder by chance.It always takes(greater) information and ultimately information is d result of intelligence Dr Werner Gitt is a poor source of information on this topic. You can check the wikipedia entry about him. He is already biased and is a Young earth creationist. While he is a scientist, he may simply choose not to apply that to his long held beliefs. And like I said with the aid of statistics, information can be derived from non-information (data) From wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data#Meaning_of_data.2C_information_and_knowledgeData on its own carries no meaning. In order for data to become information, it must be interpreted and take on a meaning. This is information that we can and do work with. You see one thing about science is that while there are notable scientists, there is no authority. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 10:31pm On Feb 28, 2010 |
viaro: Is the climate an example of "non-information"? No the data from which we get the current weather is the "non-information". |
Christianity Etc › Re: Rhapsody Of Realities: A Daily Devotional by thehomer: 1:11am On Feb 28, 2010 |
|
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 1:03am On Feb 28, 2010 |
norri: It demonstrates that no matter how many question science answers there are still more questions that science doesn't have answers for. I agree with that. norri: In your opinion what does this conclude? My conclusion is that science should keep pushing the boundaries of our current knowledge. norri: You may not choose to believe in a creator whilst others do. Who is right? We all have a right to believe in whatever we choose without being condemned by others. I'm not condemning you for your belief or lack of it. You do have a right to believe in whatever you choose to but do not try to push the beliefs into other people's business. norri: Many people have asked the same question. You may not believe it is a legitimate question but many others do. Ok so what is your answer? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 1:02am On Feb 28, 2010 |
toba: @thehomer 'can information come from non-information? Yes it can. Statistics demonstrates this. You can also consider something as complex as the climate. We get climate forecasts from the data which can at the same time be used to generate random numbers. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 1:01am On Feb 28, 2010 |
Deep Sight: I also urge you to consider the Five Arguments put forward for the existence of God by Thomas Aquinas -
The Argument of the Unmoved Mover
The Argument of the First Cause
The Argument from Contingency
The Argument from Degree
The Teleological Argument The problem of going down this path is that for the first three, your attempt to prevent an infinite regress is by your invocation of your God. Following this argument, in an attempt to create this God, another infinite regress must be prevented thereby necessitating another God. This is not good evidence. For the fourth, the claim that God is some kind of imaginary perfection of any being that must exist since we can conceive of is a bit baffling. So e.g I'm thinking of a perfect world does it exist? It makes a flawed assumption that whatever a person can conceive must exist. For the fifth, the claim that simpler things moving towards an end that is complex must be designed. This is the illusion of design from natural entities. Evolution is quite complex and it proceeds from simpler organisms to complex organisms and if you claim a designer is responsible for each of these organism, it is quite poor design. But evolution shows that given enough time, nature can come up with quite spectacular organisms. But does this God of yours do anything here on earth? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 1:00am On Feb 28, 2010 |
Deep Sight: -1 is not a quantity. In real terms is it not a detraction from zero - which signifies nothingness? Can you show me -1 apples on a table? But i can show you a table with zero apples. Thus in real terms it is misleading to set up an analogy with -1 as a quantity: it is not a quantity. The only reason I set up a zero equation was so that we see what nothingness (zero) will always result in nothingness (zero). Negative quantities can influence your life. e.g I cannot show you -$1000 but it can make you lose your house. Your analogy was going with real numbers I just helped it along to show you what you could end up with. Deep Sight: It is not relevant whether i used addittion, subtraction or division. Any operation performed on Zeros only will end with a zero; because zero is nothingness and you cannot derive something out of nothing. Not true. A division by zero will give you infinity. Deep Sight: This is one of the principles of the cosmological argument for the existence of God.
In summary, the cosmological argument proves the existence of God based on these premises -
1.Whatever begins to exist has a cause.
2.The Universe began to exist.
3.Therefore, the Universe had a cause.
,
4.Therefore, a First Cause (or something that is not an effect) must exist.
I do not assert the foregoing to be complete: the cosmological argument has raged for centuries and there are all sorts of perspectives including the philosophical and the scientific - but I believe that the premises are food for thought in addressing the question of God's existence. I will attend to it with the other four. This God of yours what properties does He/She/It have? Why should the God of your religion be this first cause? Are you sure it's not actually a group of Gods? Does this God of yours do anything on earth? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 5:41pm On Feb 27, 2010 |
viaro: Have you stopped lying? Please, let me know. I'm now very, very scared of your duplicity.  Be afraid. Be very afraid. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 5:39pm On Feb 27, 2010 |
viaro: @thehomer, Not only are you an illiterate, lying time-waster, you just enjoy being such a retard in the English constructs you employ to capture your duplicity so well.  Why should I be surprised that you regard my outline as 'philosophical babble'?  The viaro surprised? That's what it is until your evidence is presented. viaro: Look dude, I'm very well aware that most atheists OFTEN fear philosophy - that is the one thing they are most likely to evade and avoid, because anytime they display any bragado on that, they get roundly trounced and, as in your own particular case, shown to be shameless liars! To show this, I'd like to excerpt a few resources to show why you have been displaying the very same traits of your own atheistic idiocy as regards metaphysical discussions:
To recap from the above:
~ metaphysics is the study of the fundamental nature of all reality
~ the popular sense of metaphysics has been the study of any question about reality which cannot be answered by scientific observation and experimentation
~ for atheists, this sense of metaphysics is usually regarded as literally empty
~ Because metaphysics is technically the study of all reality, and thus whether there is any supernatural element to it at all, in truth metaphysics is probably the most fundamental subject which irreligious atheists should focus on. The viaro is ready to start dancing away into his alternate reality. I'm telling you again use your metaphysics. I will use my science. The claims from your metaphysical entities present themselves in this reality and I will investigate those claims scientifically. viaro: So, before you even typed your first dot in this thread about your strawman fallacy of Russell's teapot, I was very well aware that you'd be the typical atheist who's too scared to touch metaphysics - that is why you have scuttled round, evaded it with all excuses, and summarily tried to woosh it away as a babble. Nevermind, knuckleheads dismiss what they cannot understand - and that was just what you were doing. The wise viaro like his metaphysical entities already knows what will happen before I typed my first dot on the thread. Tell me have you already seen all this in your alternate reality? You have been babbling now present your evidence metaphysical or otherwise. Let me correct our great and wise philosopher. Russell's teapot is an analogy. viaro: Yet, as you can see from the excerpts above, informed atheists are aware of their own problem about their approach to metaphysical questions. Why? For the simple reason that metaphysical questions test our understanding about ALL REALITY. It was not a difficult thing for you to have simply stated in clear terms (as toneyb did) that you do not wish to discuss metaphysics, and we would not have come all this way with you now resorting to lying on top of everything that I only "now introduced" this issue about metaphysics. My point is not about me discussing metaphysics. It's about the claims made from your metaphysical entities presenting themselves here and being evaluated by the best means available. Science.  viaro: Dude, you're a comp[color=Black]lete id[/color]iot - a lying one at that, and an ultimate dunce. Beyond this point, the thread is left to you to come back and show your idiocy and evasions (I won't bother acquiescing with a rejoinder), and then you can go celebrate your duplicity in a bar somewhere. Boohoo. Get your point across without the attempts at insults. Please don't damage your keyboard. Well I'm back requesting once more that you present your evidence any way you can by typing, video or any other means your 2 brain cells are capable of accompling. (Don't let that whoosh over your head). So viaro, like the usual sophist, you have come in here praising yourself and claiming some mysterious evidence which you have failed to present. Despite repeated requests that you present them. You're quite a character dancing and dribbling yourself into metaphysics but still could not present your evidence after arriving at your metaphysics. Goodluck at your philosophy career. Just be careful with your sophistry. It won't get you anywhere with people like me. This is really something; a philosopher who just learnt about analogies, cannot present evidence or examples to back up his claim. You make me laugh.[quote][/quote] |
Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 5:35pm On Feb 27, 2010 |
viaro: @thehomer, I did not dodge anything. You're the one who has been dodging my repeated request, because you hitherto have said nothing concrete. Again through you latest reply, you dribbled round to say nothing. If this dribbling is all you can show for your atheism, I can now understand why you've been so dishonest from the onset. Great philosopher I have given you examples to show what I mean. Please present your evidence by any means you can. viaro: After all these, you of all thinking people come back to shamelessly LIE on top of everything that I have "NOW introduced" these things about metaphysics like it is the first time you read me mention that the subject is one about metaphysical questions? You must be such a lying idi[color=Black]ot cha[/color]mpioning your atheistic redundancy!  Wise philosopher  You wish to present your evidence via metaphysics please go ahead. |