Please discuss with open mind, no name callings, no other subject, strictly discuss just base on the subject alone. The aunthenticity of both holy bible and Quran.

I believe Quran is the word of God not bible.

They are both from God, Tora for musa, injil for ISSAH ( son of maryam) sabur for daud, Al quran for prophet mohammed.
GOOGLE the 1500years old bible. Then you will understand better

Who wrote them? How do you know it's from God?

the book of sango

salinakrogh:
Who wrote them? How do you know it's from God?

Sir, How do you know quran is from a god/supreme being and not written by some arabs? What are the proofs?

It's is not written by God, the Quran is a verbal revelation given to Muhammad (pbuh).And was then written as the Quran. Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) was illiterate, but one of his amazing capabilities is to memorize. However, he needs to compile all the revelations given to him.


He employed for this task a number of his companions whose number totaled 29. Many of these were of the highest caliber in their faith and integrity. They included all the first five caliphs, Abu Bakr, Umar, Usman, Ali and Muawiah. However, the task of writing the revelations was most particularly associated with two of them, Muawiah and Zaid ibn Thabit, despite the fact that Muawiah was a latecomer to Islam. Paper, as we know, was not yet invented. Those scribes wrote the Qur'an on various forms of writing material which was available to them. These included sheets cut out of the branches of the beet tree or other writing sheets made of wood, animal hide, stone or bones.

This started even in the period when the Prophet and his companions were a small persecuted community in Makkah. Many of the companions of the Prophet had some parts of the Qur'an written down and treasured in their homes. The Qur'an is divided into 114 surahs, some of which are short, while others are very long. The revelation did not proceed with only one surah at a time, but the Prophet might have continued to receive parts of several surahs at the same time. When a passage was sent down to him, it was followed by an order from Allah, through the Angel Gabriel, indicating its position in the surah to which it belonged. These manuscripts did not form a single or coherent set.

The Prophet did not keep anything written down in his own home. But most of his companions who were with him in Makkah and Madinah memorized much of the Qur'an, and some of them were able to learn it all by heart. The Prophet used to teach his companions either individually or in groups. We note that Abdullah ibn Masood, a learned companion of the Prophet, was pleased to assert that he memorized more than 70 surahs as he learned them directly from the Prophet. In Ramadan every year, the Prophet used to revise the Qur'an with the Angel Gabriel to ensure that he did not overlook any verse or part of it. In the last year of the Prophet's blessed life, Gabriel recited the Qur'an to him twice.

Unlike the bible, it was a written revelation, which Christians believed the writers on the bible was inspired by the holy spirit. However, how can there be many versions of bible ? If it's from God, how can God gives different versions of the bible? How can two bible differs? How can there be 80 books in one bible, 73 in another bible and 66 in another bible? Anything that is. From God should not be altered, when it is altered, that is a fabrication, and a fabrication is not authentic.

kevoh:


Sir, How do you know quran is from a god/supreme being and not written by some arabs? What are the proofs?

It is from God, written by Arabs.

salinakrogh:


It is from God, written by Arabs.

Sir, I said give me physical proofs not blanket statements. It is the same thing as me claming Spiderman comics is from ''god" written by Marvel comics.

kevoh:

Sir, I said give me physical proofs not blanket statements. It is the same thing as me claming Spiderman comics is from ''god" written by Marvel comics.

What do u mean by physical proof?

salinakrogh:


What do u mean by physical proof?

Proofs that have meaning and can be felt, experienced, touched e.t.c That an Arab or Arabs wrote the quran I can agree with you on that afterall the quran was first written in Arabic (Physical proof). Now show me how it was from god!

kevoh:

Proofs that have meaning and can be felt, experienced, touched e.t.c That an Arab or Arabs wrote the quran I can agree with you on that afterall the quran was first written in Arabic (Physical proof). Now show me how it was from god!

The Qur'an itself is a physical evidence, it is written in Arabic itself, if there is a translation, it will be written underneath each verse.

A physical proof of the Quran itself is the large number of manuscripts found , dating back to the early times of Islam. I do not have with me, to give to u to touch and feel.

kevoh:

Proofs that have meaning and can be felt, experienced, touched e.t.c That an Arab or Arabs wrote the quran I can agree with you on that afterall the quran was first written in Arabic (Physical proof). Now show me how it was from god!

Likewise I would.like to ask you if u have happen to have any knowledge of the bible, how can one do that? Feel experienced and touch it, show that it was from God?

salinakrogh:


The Qur'an itself is a physical evidence, it is written in Arabic itself, if there is a translation, it will be written underneath each verse.

A physical proof of the Quran itself is the large number of manuscripts found , dating back to the early times of Islam. I do not have with me, to give to u to touch and feel.

Still doesn't prove that it's from one supreme being(god). There are other manuscripts found that dates even earlier than the time of Islam. This stuff you have stated only proves that the manuscripts that gave rise to the Quran was written by ancient arabs and probably meant for arabs. I don't dispute that as I stated in my earlier post.

I asked for proof that it is from god.

salinakrogh:


Likewise I would.like to ask you if u have happen to have any knowledge of the bible, how can one do that? Feel experienced and touch it, show that it was from God?

The burden of proving the Bible is the word of god falls on the christians not me. I can't do their job for them. Go through my posts you will understand what I mean.