Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / NewStats: 3,194,505 members, 7,954,925 topics. Date: Saturday, 21 September 2024 at 12:40 PM |
Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / Atheism Is A Religion (15141 Views)
Atheism Is Frustrating. / Atheism Is A Religion: Kolooyinbo Explains. / Even Water Proves That Atheism Is False. (2) (3) (4)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) ... (13) (Reply) (Go Down)
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by olojoro: 2:18am On Nov 12, 2010 |
Atheism is the religion of the innately stupid. Stupidity has to flow through your veins to insist that there is no God. |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by Purist(m): 2:26am On Nov 12, 2010 |
olojoro: Well, without holding brief for the atheists, the bolded can be said of theists too, mutatis mutandis. It all depends, really. |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by olojoro: 2:34am On Nov 12, 2010 |
I can't say I disagree with you buddy. Isn't it scary that most of the people on earth with us are that silly? Why does it matter if God exists anyways? Besides the whole imaginary afterlife thing |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by DeepSight(m): 5:01am On Nov 12, 2010 |
Indeed. There is no point dignifying the subject with any responses. I am rather surprised that some otherwise objective minds are found supporting the notion. Jesoul. I hope u realize that further to everything u hzve said, and just as thehomer pointed out, capitalism, communism, etc would all qualify as religions. Come on! |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by Nobody: 8:32am On Nov 12, 2010 |
Rhino.4dm: just passing. U used to be my friend before u went |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by InesQor(m): 9:01am On Nov 12, 2010 |
@Purist: Come on! We all know how you meant that. DO NOT hide behind the definition of "sarcasm". When you have been hit, it is only polite to accept your wrong and say "touche". As for the topic, do you care to show where I said Atheism is a religion? Isn't my point the fact that you are so immutably obsessed with religions, enough to make the birds of a feather phrase apply to you in some regards? And isn't that WHY i said ONLY Enigma seemed to get my point (or at least gave a response that shows that he did?) Or maybe it's the word "religion" that has gradually lost its pristine meaning and needs to be re-evaluated. |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by Enigma(m): 9:05am On Nov 12, 2010 |
InesQor: De thing na waaa o jare The 'evangelical' atheists here (some of them even aggressive if not militant) are obviously proselytising: seeking to prove that their own 'faith' {in godlessness or in lack of god, if they prefer} is right or trying to 'debunk' Christianity and other religions; basically they are trying to prove that their own belief or faith or religion (sarcasm alert!) is better than anyone else's. Now that's interesting, isnt't it? I would say it shows at least two forms of insecurity: (a) they do not know that their own belief, faith or religion (sarcasm alert) is right and thus need the reassurance from attacking 'weaknesses' in others; (b) they are ashamed to admit that they are indeed basically doing that which they accuse others of ---- practising a 'religion' (sarcasm only partly alert!!!). What with all the contention, criticising, proselytising etc? There are (let's say "passive" atheists who just exist day to day; do not even think about God let alone to consider or ponder his existence, yet let alone to consider discussing his existence with others, yet let alone to try to persuade others of his non-existence. These atheists just live, they just exist. God is not even in the picture at all for them. Compare those with our evangelical (aggressive if not militant) atheist friends who are indeed obssessed with this same God that they claim do not exist. Of all the threads and discussion on the forum they encamp in the religion section! |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by InesQor(m): 9:23am On Nov 12, 2010 |
Enigma: GBAM! GBAM!! [size=16pt]GBAM!!![/size] And the court rises. LOL! As far as I have observed, the only atheist that does not look like he actively proselytizes here is Seun Osewa (if I am right, he is an atheist). Manmustwac on the other hand, does that infrequently. The others are either rabid or so defensive that their militancy becomes obvious. They have a faith, a belief system as well. Do they not as well then have a religion? I laugh in pidgin Cantonese. |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by Rhino4dm: 10:00am On Nov 12, 2010 |
That wapt-senile gay stinking loon need to be quarantine , the coward shouldn't be ashame to admit that Richard fuC.king dawkins is his god. toba: you unleash your godmother [s]muki[/] on me No permanent friend or enemy on NL, only intrest! Namaste. . . . |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by DeepSight(m): 10:33am On Nov 12, 2010 |
Contrast - InesQor: And - InesQor: Respectfully sir: you are confused. |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by InesQor(m): 10:39am On Nov 12, 2010 |
@Deep Sight: Even if the respect is mine, the confusion is yours only. I said ATHEISM is not a religion. BUT some professed atheists go about it like a religion. Are they then atheists? Or does religion have to be redefined to suit them? This is a classical example of the fumbling Deep Sight. I clearly delineated the exception and you jumped in head first. |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by InesQor(m): 10:45am On Nov 12, 2010 |
Thats still why I said only Enigma understood me. The parts I outlined in Enigma's most recent post shows my points too. Which was why I asked in my first post: what are THESE dudes [you know who] doing here? If God does not exist, is it not futile to discuss religion? Do you see me opening threads in Politics to discuss Atlantis and other inexistent worlds? 1 Like |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by Enigma(m): 10:49am On Nov 12, 2010 |
^^^ Things like 'nuance', 'subtlety' etc are not easily appreciated by quite a lot of {our} people |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by UyiIredia(m): 11:26am On Nov 12, 2010 |
@ Texas Pete >>> SMH at you >>> didn't even bother to pit up the links I requested for. A lazy brushing aside off my points is all you did. I guess that wraps it up |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by thehomer: 12:01pm On Nov 12, 2010 |
InesQor: It is not futile discussing religion even if one does not believe it because we live in a world where people make decisions based on these religious beliefs that affect others religious and non-religious alike. About your Atlantis analogy, if I came across a person believing in Atlantis I may or may not comment but if there are enough of them who based on this try to influence public policy, I would be concerned and would try to engage in discussions about it. |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by UyiIredia(m): 12:02pm On Nov 12, 2010 |
There is a valid point that was raised by the homer & Purist - that theism isn't a religion. Correct. Question to both the homer & Purist >>> What is Theism ? (A. Philosophy B. Religion C. I have another answer) But we know that (most if not) all religions are classified under theism. This further proofs my point. In so far as religious thinking (embodied by religions) comes out of theism then it only goes to show that the same plausibly applies to atheism. Note my use of the word inchoate. To further prove Atheism as a religion (albeit inchoate), it is necessary to remonstrate the subtle use of faith by atheists by : The fact that religions are based on various 'isms' such as Taoism, Theism, Buddhism, Shintoism goes to show that religions can be ascribed to them. Note that Shintoism is in fact a religion_the official religion of Japan. Same goes to atheism_ we have seen modes of thought which have atheistic or agnostic underpinnings e.g evolutionism, secularism, communism e.t.c @ all posters >>> Depending on how you respond to this I might bring out the second part of my essay in this thread >>> or worse yet, start it as a new topic_with a less controversial title |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by Mudley313: 12:06pm On Nov 12, 2010 |
InesQor: maybe because religion and the belief in imaginary entities is a bane to our society. see boko haram, mutallab, all the 419 houses masquerading as churches in every street corner, not to talk of the dumbing down of an entire citizenry into reliance on imaginary friends up the sky instead putting their heads and hands to productive use many people are on the politics section not cos they're politicians but because they are not happy with the political situation in naija. same with non-religious peeps on here unhappy with the nauseating religious situation back home @ uyi. why not add racism, tribalism, feminism etc in your list of -isms that can be ascribed to religious thoughts |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by InesQor(m): 12:08pm On Nov 12, 2010 |
My point has been made. That is all. |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by UyiIredia(m): 12:09pm On Nov 12, 2010 |
@ Mudley >>> of course >>> feminism, in particular, is generally agreed to have been started by Simeone de Bouivare (sic) an atheist and a dear mentor of Paul Satre |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by thehomer: 1:08pm On Nov 12, 2010 |
Uyi Iredia: C. I think it's a concept about the existence of deities. Uyi Iredia: Not all religions are classified under theism. Theism is not a religion like I said. Sure Shintoism and Taoism in some forms may be considered religions so what? And in what country is atheism the official religion? Evolution is a scientific theory so like other scientific theories, there is no presumption of a God. Are you claiming that secularism and communism be considered as religions in this discussion? Uyi Iredia: Ok. |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by Mudley313: 1:12pm On Nov 12, 2010 |
Uyi Iredia: okay. i see. so she was a member of two religious institutions, atheism and feminism. makes sense. and while you're at it also add albinism, alcoholism, cynicism, skepticism to the list of religious beliefs. we learn new things everyday |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by Tonyet1(m): 1:42pm On Nov 12, 2010 |
Rhino.4dm i see you are doing 'em mudslinging with mudley. . .make sure u guys sure have a great time doing so. offtopic: here is my email: tonyet5@yahoo.com. hoping to receive a mail from you. its very important |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by Purist(m): 2:06pm On Nov 12, 2010 |
@InesQor InesQor: Quit dancing around words. Admit you goofed, and we'll move on. You obviously FAILED to sense the sarcasm in my intial post, and now you try misrepresent my own intention for me? Try again, dude. InesQor: You didn't need to spell it out explicitly. When you said this, you certainly had reached the same conclusion as the OP, which is further made evident by the way you went hysterical on Enigma's 'corroborating' post. InesQor: And isn't MY point the fact your 'fact' is wrong? If those who are 'obsessed' with the politics section or political matters cannot be said to be politicians just on the basis of their 'obsession', why then should the rule suddenly change for religion? And wait, don't shift the focus to "in some regards" just yet. That was NOT your point initially, at least, going by your first comment on this thread, and it's certainly NOT the point of this thread either. The topic says, atheism IS a religion. Full stop. InesQor: Obviously. InesQor: Naah, no problem with the word 'religion'. The problem is with you peeps trying to fit in odd concepts into the definition of the word. |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by Rhino4dm: 2:12pm On Nov 12, 2010 |
Okay. Expect me Tonye-t: |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by Purist(m): 2:36pm On Nov 12, 2010 |
@ Enigma Enigma: Well, you'd find that more often than not, this is usually the case in non-religious countries. Here in Finland, for example, you'd barely see a Finn bring up a religious issue with you. Even if you bring it up yourself, they'd rather just avoid such discussions altogether, because to most here, there's really no point in such discussions since God barely means anything to them. In a highly religious country like Nigeria however, where the actions of most people are influenced by their religious beliefs, and have direct and indirect effects on others - the non-religious inclusive - it becomes increasingly difficult for both the religious and non-religious to keep mum on religious matters. In a nutshell, people generally speak on things, not because they're obsessed or 'interested' per se, but because it affects them in one way or the other. When such effects are reduced significantly, then you should normally expect to see a proportionate decline in talks about them as well; and vice versa. |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by Enigma(m): 2:52pm On Nov 12, 2010 |
^^^ I don't see how any of that justifies the encampment by atheists in the nairaland religion section or how it justifies poking nose into discussions among Christians to work out/trying to understand their own faith, or how it justifies starting numerous threads to show that God cannot exist, Christianity cannot be true, Christian doctrine is man-made, made up etc. Accordingly, the obsession of some of the atheists here with the religion section and their activity or 'activeness' is not that distinguishable from practising a "religion". |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by UyiIredia(m): 2:56pm On Nov 12, 2010 |
@ Mudley >>> nah 'Mudleyism' is suffice to explain all the 'isms' you mentioned *typical Mudley schmuck* @ homer >>> thehomer: *1 >>> I don't agree to that 'answer'. Too ambiguous. Deism and Atheism can also be defined as concepts on the existence of deities. I'm going to hold you accountable at some point in time based on this 'answer' *2 >>> I said so too. Guess we're square on that, eh *3 >>> So >>> given that they are 'isms' under theism that are religions. Why can't the same be said of atheism? *4 >>> (In effect) Communist China and USSR (under Stalin's regime) _both are underlined by a serious repression of religions especially Christianity. *5 >>> B'cos of the effect of secularism >>> such wasn't the thinking during medieval times, when science was perceived as a means inquiry into nature & reality created by God >>> God was very much presumed in that age of learning >>> This quote by Einstein should put things in perspective "Science without Religion is lame and Religion without Science is blind" - Albert Einstein *6 >>> nope >>> but i demonstrate that in effect they resonate with atheism than they do with theism >>> this can be further explored >>> but I don't think this is the time to argue such |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by Purist(m): 3:01pm On Nov 12, 2010 |
Enigma: I quite agree with you. But the militancy of some atheists doesn't justify the claim that atheism IS a religion either. For me, the only connection I can possibly find between religion and atheism is in my signature. |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by UyiIredia(m): 3:12pm On Nov 12, 2010 |
Going by this, one can see that the examples of religions that I gave above do fit but neither atheism nor theism does. @ homer >>> using the definition of religion you gave Stoicism, Empericism, Idealism, and yes, theism and atheism fall under religions. It seems you don't note the fact that practices and beliefs which are highly sacred (to a person) are predicated upon these isms. They all have a belief in idea they regard as sacrosanct. The best definition of atheism (devoid of the hissy-footing present atheists characterize) is this : Atheism is the belief that there is no God. That nullifies all the twaddles about not playing cards not being a hobby et al. |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by JeSoul(f): 3:19pm On Nov 12, 2010 |
TheHomer, thanks for your last response. You are right in that some foundation needs to be laid on the meaning of certain words we're using here. The only side effect of undertaking that is that too often we see good threads spiral into the abyss of definitions of defintions. Deepsight and Homer, you both continue to insist that atheism is simply a lack of belief - I have tried (and thanks to posts from E and I) to stress that modern atheism is simply not just a lack of belief - it is an active belief that there in no God. Indeed you could reverse the case and say "christianity is simply a lack of a lack of belief in God". Both are based on beliefs that cannot be proven - and both are very active in converting followers. Christians have the bible as their holy text, while atheists have a revolving door library of holy texts - the most recent scientific books. You will both notice I mentioned twice I have no need or desire to flatter atheism with the title of religion - but just for kicks - what characteristics does a movement need to possess in order to qualify for the title of "religion"? Uyi already tried to address this in his famous "discombobulate" post but rather than show us where he was wrong, opponents simply dismissed it as a grammatical exercise - many of which the 'dismissants' themselves are famous for. |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by thehomer: 3:23pm On Nov 12, 2010 |
Uyi Iredia: Yes that is correct and this does not make them religions either. Uyi Iredia: Yeah just to make that clear. Uyi Iredia: Taoism and Shinto are [b]not [/b]under theism. Uyi Iredia: This still does not make atheism nor communism a religion within this discussion. Uyi Iredia: It was presumed then but we know better now and do not presume such when using scientific methods to gain knowledge. Besides, most of the people living then were religious so what view do you expect them to take? Uyi Iredia: I do not agree with Einstein's quote if the definition of religion is as I've accepted it in this discussion. And keep in mind that he too did not believe in a personal God. Uyi Iredia: So what if they resonate with atheism? |
Re: Atheism Is A Religion by DeepSight(m): 3:28pm On Nov 12, 2010 |
Inesqor - there seems quiet alot of confusion about you in this thread. You clearly contradicted yourself in one breath claiming that you did not say atheism is a religion and in another breath averring the reverse. And add to that the fact that you plain goofed in raising the definition of a politician as trhat very definition stands in stark contradistinction to everything you have tried to advance on this thread. With deep respect, you have it all terribly mangled up. However I am sorry to say that I consider the notion advanced in the OP as so irredeemably misconceived and disastrously preposterous such that I do not have the energy to invest in such a ridiculous discussion. Any person who asserts that Atheism is a Religion simply has no grasp of the English Language and basic precepts. I have no energy for this. Think what you will, sir, it matters not. I suggest we rather invest our time in some chess where I am yet to redeem my name from the embarrasment you handed out to me sometime ago. |
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) ... (13) (Reply)
Only A Fool Says There Is No God. / MINE Teenage Ministry Reacts As Coordinator Is Accused Of Sexual Harassment / 3 Things That Take The Place Of God In Your Christian life
(Go Up)
Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 108 |