Jolar101: All the largest landscape in the north, what are they doing with them?
If I may ask you. Will you give your only land you are planting to cows
Only those accused that are still supporting these terrorists government - FFK.
Any Fulani herds terrorists in Biafraland should start relocating to their so called largest landscape in the north.
Deal With It I don't like talking to Biafrans. They think like herdsmen's cows
The only ting i am responding to is bold. Herdsmen is entrepreneurship and they are everywhere across the country. And everyone benefits from them. We buy cows during ileya. It is stressful for them to have to transport cows and other livestock all the way from the north to SW and East since you all buy and eat beef. By having ranches across the country and in the SW/SE will reduce inflation on these animal. Imagine buying a ram f0r over 100k that used to be 18k?. Once they have ranches in the SW/SE, you have to force them to reduce ram and cow prices. You dont need to force them actually, by default it will or we dont buy. Simple
As for the pictures you posted, you are just being emotional. No one wants to see anyone dies. Get over it and provide solution and stop being emotionally unstable. That doesn't solve anything.
kayjay69: Foolish one, you obviously don't know history. I am ashamed to even call you a fellow tribesman cos it is people like you that give the Yorubas a bad rap unless Ofcourse you are a Yoruba Muslim then I can totally understand where this comment is coming from.
You fail to even understand that history always repeats itself. What is happening now has happened before. How the hell do you think Kwara became overrun with the fulani? Go figure. If you choose to align yourself with religion more than tribe, then you will have proven naysayers right. Yorubas have for so long being held together by their common ancestry and their devotion to their tribe (irrespective of our differences within ourselves) but this upsurge of MURIC and co is disturbing. You really think Muslims outnumber Christians in the SW. Or is it because most of the ruling party in the SW are muslims you all want to start up some mischievous agenda along religious lines, choosing to align with the North rather than with common sense. I pity you. Give them land and watch as you become slaves.
[quite author=Empiree post=69080164]Illustrate are those people commenting here. The so called ancestral lands, abeg, ask them what they have been doing with them?. The lands are just sitting there useless and families kill themselves over it. I am telling you now, many Yoruba and Igbo want no peace. Before they start questioning my background, let me say that I am a yoruba man. Govt proposal make sense but they need to remove the word "colony" from any type of deal between herdsmen and govt. Lo ba tan
Now ask the opposition if they are content with cows roaming the street in 21st century?. Just yesterday i received a short video of roaming cows in the street of Lekki, and the ladies there are complaining. Abeg, ask them what they are complaining about if they dont want herdsmen to have enclosed ranches?. The so called "educated people in the South-west and East are actually bunch of morons. Hausa-fulanis are more intelligent than them. Do you know that Sardauna, Ahmadu Bello actually proposed ranches decades before while our so called educated people are busy killing one another over the so called ancestral land?.
Now, in order not to make it look like govt gave the land for free, i would suggest the govt charge annual income tax on herdmen's revenue. Govt and herdmen's proposal is in harmony with modern world. But this nigga called FKK and his cohorts are bunch of violent hypocrites.
Lands Should Belong To Govt. I Support Ranches. Embrace Civility People, Embrace The Herdsmen
I can not respond to you properly unless you quote me properly. The only thing i could read from my mention is you called me "foolish one". Educated people indeed
Koolking: Am actually disappointed FFK was one of the rulers running Nigeria.
Clearly, if we look at the bigger pictures, ranching will ameliorate the clashes between nomadic farmers and crop farmers. It will also contribute meaningfully to the Nigeria's economic development and growth. Let shun sentiment and give a try. Government has done it feasibility and cash flow projection.
Illustrate are those people commenting here. The so called ancestral lands, abeg, ask them what they have been doing with them?. The lands are just sitting there useless and families kill themselves over it. I am telling you now, many Yoruba and Igbo want no peace. Before they start questioning my background, let me say that I am a yoruba man. Govt proposal makes sense but they need to remove the word "colony" from any type of deal between herdsmen and govt. Lo ba tan
Now ask the opposition if they are content with cows roaming the streets in 21st century?. Just yesterday i received a short video of roaming cows in the street of Lekki, and the ladies there are complaining. Abeg, ask them what they are complaining about if they dont want herdsmen to have enclosed ranches?. The so called "educated" people of the South-west and East are actually bunch of morons. Hausa-fulanis are more intelligent than them. Do you know that Sardauna, Ahmadu Bello actually proposed ranches decades before while our so called "educated" people are busy killing one another over the so called ancestral land?.
Now, in order not to make it look like govt gave the land for free, i would suggest the govt charge annual income tax on herdmen's revenue. Govt and herdmen's proposal is in harmony with modern world. But this nigga called FKK and his cohorts are bunch of violent hypocrites.
Lands Should Belong To Govt. I Support Ranches. Embrace Civility, People. Embrace The Herdsmen
As for sheik Imran Hussein, you gonna have to watch his series of lectures because he talks about it in almost all of his lectures. So I can't possibly pick one.
I find it hard to believe Banks and govt aren't involved with it creation one way or the other.
Ok thanks. I get this now. I will try and find out more about Sheikh Imran, seems you're fond of quoting him lol.
reason is because he's well informed Islamically, socially, philosophically and politically. And he doesn't believe Quran is static unlike some scholars who keep quoting medieval tasfsir and keep repeating themselves in cycle without moving forward.
when it comes to cryptocurrencies or bitcoin, it is fraud. Have i not been saying this on this nl platform for 4yrs now?. When i raised the issue that paper money is haram some of you disagreed. I said further that they wanted to replace paper money with electronic or virtual currency but many of you said it is not haram. Here we are now, cryptocurrencies is here. It does have some good that come with it but it purpose nullifies the benefits.
Sheikh Imran Hussain has been saying this for over 20 yrs but they think he was crazy. So just watch when eventually paper money will disappear. There are many things you can no longer buy with cash now. And i was impressed by Sheikh Assim Hakim in his few mins clip where he recognizes cryptocurrencies to be fraudulent and haram after presented his analysis.
But the big banks aren't gonna present bitcoin in a way that scares the hell out of people. They drop the process softly until massess get used to it. It will create more and more wealth for the rich to be permanently rich and the poor permanently poor.
Now that we have seen our #1 hadith, let's see the popular argument for it.
This is not tenable, since Imam Muslim placed it in Book of Greetings. Many cases, hadith applications are not limited by the book in hadith they occur.
Apparently, the inclusion of Christians in this hadith nullifies this argument. Unless there is a point in history at which Muhammad was simultaneously at war with both a Christians nation and Banu Qurayza Jews. Thus, this can't be limited to Banu Qurayza expenditure.
Also, please note that a related hadith to this warn Muslims not to return the complete salam to the Christians and Jews that initiate salam.
If the Muslims were so much in war with Jews and wont initiate salam to them, why even respond to their salam? This again, is untenable. Also, why merely push the Jewish enemies to the narrowest side of the road? Was this all the Muslims could do to hurt their mortal enemies?
There are all kinds of unreasonable, untenable argument for this hadith and many other gross hadith by traditional scholars. But delving on all of them will detract from the this aim of this thread.
This is clearly a fabricated hadith at worst, a poorly reported hadith at best. Either way, it point to the flaw of science of hadith.
Thanks pal. Not a vacation exactly. Got inspired for this thread by recent bitter experiences and reflections on my part, regarding the Muslim society.
I believe you've read my counter argument for this hadith by now. I should have posted it alongside the hadith yesterday, because I did sift through the argument for the hadith, even before I posted it. I have very rigorous modus operandi for hadith criticism, am no amateur.
Oh no, dont get it wrong. I only cited Banu Qurayza due to its famous incident relating to the Jews. I didnt mean it is decisive in this case. There are of course series of wars and bickering between muslims and Jews. and pagan arabs.
Before i can even effectively reply you on this, you first all need to recognise islamic history in relation with Quran. Without this we may be wasting our time here. Yourself just cited a bit of history while ignoring facts on ground. As for your personal experience recently (maybe), that is a flimsy analysis here.
GoTV: Even though I'm a born again Christian, i think we Christians are heating up the polity with our hate speeches and unnecessary hatred towards Muslims cum Fulani tribe. Our irresponsible preachers like Oyedepo deserves to be arrested and tortured by the DSS for spreading fake news about islamization and encouraging self defense when the bible teaches us to love our neighbors as ourselves. Fiery preachers are mostly Christians and they are hell bent on tarnishing the image of Muslims and Fulanis. This is why i like organizations like MURIC working day and night to defend the interests of Muslims. I think we Christians are the problems in this country.
"Black Hue, an Isreali company, was engaged to hack into the medical records and email of then candidate Muhammadu Buhari... To intimidate the Nigerian voter, we also distributed violent and threatening content, anti-islamic messages portraying Muslims as violent extremists." (Whistleblower Christopher Wylie speaking to British MPs in April 2018).
It is not surprising having watched NCIS Los Angeles few years ago talking about destabilization of Nigeria by using Boko Haram. The statement was made by LL Cool J in the drama series back in 2011 and 2013.
GEJ administration messed up nigerian security apparatus
Paperwhite: Clueless government! Always passing buck & looking for what or who to blame.So corruption just started today? And why is the crisis just escalated in the Buhari regime? Keep on deceiving yourself.
You wanna know why?. Maybe you should watch this for a clue.
edlion57: The owner asked the truck to fail break or asked the driver to burn his truck and the product..... Pls focus that energy in fighting killer herdsmen
Anyways, your position is respected. Just need you to reason outside the box a little.
I am of the opinion that you first need to agree that Islam has its history. Quran is not just a Book revealed without some sort of historical background. If you fail to understand this, which you have been doing actually, you will never get out of your cloister. I do welcome your fair criticisms of some hadith even if they are alleged to be sahih.
Some hadith are lapsed and can no longer be explained and they need to be discarded due to inavailability of the data. Some are explainable and still valid. Your approach however is the opposite. A sincere muslim would ask question about what this and that means before making up his mind but you aren't doing that actually. That's just sad.
The hadith you quoted in your second post is still valid for as long as it is placed in the right context. Also it is not valid if a muslim is to utilize it on average friendly Jews and christians. The reason the hadith is still valid now is bcus, the hadith is placed in THE BOOK ON MILITARY EXPEDITIONS , not a customary or general rule Banu Qurayza incident comes to mind. The 9th century Persian Islamic scholar Abu Isa Muḥammad ibn Isa as-Sulami ad-Darir al-Bughi at-Tirmidhi (824 – 892 CE) placed this Hadith in the category of “The Book on military expeditions”
Also, the 14/15th century Shafi’I scholar Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani (1372 – 1449 CE) placed this Hadith in the category of “The Book On J!had”. So it is quite clear that among classical scholars of Islam, they deemed this Hadith report to be in relation to war only. NOTHING MORE THAN THAT. Could have been problematic if it was conventional or customary rule (Fatwa) but it is not.
PrettyCrystal: This is really shameful. Police officers had to be called in to settle a crisis which rocked the Celestial Church of Christ, Staten-Island Parish, in New-York City. It was gathered that the members who are mainly Nigerians (judging from their Yoruba dialect), engaged themselves in a heated quarrel between two factions as the chaos was too much that the police officers had to wade in.
Even when the police stepped into the church to restore peace, one of the female church members told an officer, "you're not supposed to come to the church with your sandal"as other church members hushed her down.
In the video footage posted online, one of the church members can be heard saying 'those people are coming back, they embezzled money and do sexual harassment in this church'.
The church members were told to vacate the church premises so it could be locked down.
Maket: I would have been shocked if i didn't see Ahmedu Bello Way His street is always in the heart of the town and one of the longest street that is usually named after him.
Some state like plateau had renamed the street after their indigenous person.
The north always getting good point in the south yet you can go to the north and see a good street name after someone from another religion.
The same thing goes to building of churches and mosques. In the north churches are confirmed to specific location and not supported by governors
Go to the south you see mosques every corners, some built by the governors.
ItsMeAboki: What a frustrated tortured soul, I can feel your pain but cannot sympathise with your hateful agenda; the only thing ppl like you from the south (East) want is to sow the seed of hate and discord to divide us in the north, through the use of religion and ethnicity to actaulise your evil aim.
PVision2020: Stop this high cost thing you're singing about. Do they have to have farms in every part of the nation to supply tomatoes, onions, beans etc? Why can't they do such for their cattle? Haven't you seen most cows transported via trucks to various abbatiors before? Day old chicks were transported to far north from Oyo and heaven did not fall.
what year was that?. This is 21st century.
States are beginning to enact anti open grazing bills and any herder that disobey will face the consequence (as seen in Ekiti).
So where should they go about their cows, transport them all to the north or buy lands for ranching in Ekiti?. Another thing is, don't Ekiti people buy cows from them?
Every state has a master plan so even if you acquire any land from any omo onile for the wrong purpose you risk loosing ownership and properties on the land. The case of Igbo transportation companies in Lagos should suffice. There can never be any cattle ranch in any place without the approval and authorization of the state Govt.
so they should transport their cows back to the north?. Is that your solution?. Just asking
farem: Correct! I don't know why this is a rocket science for some governors in the South and esp mid belt .,
Aregbesola will be a good national material as a president, Minister of works or agriculture IF he purge himself of Islamism
We knew all along this is your problem. Is the reason you can not come to reasonable solution with herders. In your narrow mindset, herders are islamists
Develpeast: Why are all these people shallow in thinking? I am only commenting because I feel some young people will be seeing reasons with whatever jargons this man is spewing. The bone of contention is land. If the herders want grass, they can ask the government to subsidize the price of grasses for them so that the cost of feeding the cows will reduce.
The government cannot provide land for farmers but can only reduce the cost of production through subsidy. Stop making people look like fools with your false analogy.
gratiaeo: As if fulani has monopoly for violence or Buhari will be on the seat forever. The day other Nigerians will reason their stupidity Muslim treatment in CAR will be a child play
PVision2020: lasticlacla abeg push am go front page make the world know say my amiable Governor is not giving an inch of our land to killers o. Aregbe, ogidi omoluabi, awa leyin re bi ike.
Cc:empiree
Mr. Governor does have the right to reject the idea. It is his prerogative. But you gotta brace for high cost of rams, cows and other livestocks when the need be. And you have no right to condemn herders for open grazing anywhere in the country.
Really, it doesn't have to be fulani only that do this herds business. Why can't Yoruba leaders encourage their people to be self reliant and create their own ranches?. Remember, even if you don't sell the land to federal govt but you want herders to buy the land themselves, you will suffer worst consequences, bcus the moment you sell the lands to them, you relinquish your rights of ownership. There should be reserved lands in every state for this.
LadunaI: Interesting, can you shed more light on how the Sheikh did the analysis? And your understanding of it so that we can learn from that.
Yes! I believe Qur'an story or narrativea are not static, with deep thinking one can see similar scenario playing out but in a little disguise.
He actually analyzed ahadith to arrive at his conclusions. He gave his analysis about Arab spring that started in 2011 back in 2001 in Sydney, Australia. That was dynamic and almost accurate when the incident finally happened in 2011. He simply use Quran, hadith and his firasa to derive his point.
@ highlighted part, if parallel with Nabi Ibrahim (as) case, them Arab ought to have been spare of this scourge of killings in term of ransom been substituted for supposed sacrifice. Or what do to u think?
the reason his analysis might right on this is bcus of hadith which predicted Arab slaughter. The hadith where nabi (saw) saw evil in his dream and he woke and said the hole of yajuj and majuj is opened. His wife asked "SHALL WE BE DESTROYED?". Nabi(saw) said "Na'am".
Pls canyou provide links for that video and possibly upload that book here Thanks.
There are several videos where he talked about it but this one is the only video i quiet remembered yrs ago.
End Time Destruction Of The Arabs: From Arab Spring To Arabs Slaughter
Let me remind you that the video above is not the actual lecture where he gave full detail of his analysis of the incident. Rather this is just a dialogue with another intelligent fellow (white man in the view).
Afonja007: in America if you find oil in your land it belongs to you buy here in Nigeria when oil is found in bayelsa state one gambo or dankwambo from north will claim it and government will sign it to him