Mkenya2019: And stop arguing about DATA Your debt servicing ratio is SOLID DATA Your project taking 10-20yrs is solid data
Look at the Blue Line - mere 35kms - not yet finished - phase 1 took 15yrs - phase 2 will take another 20yrs. 2008: A metro is proposed for Lagos, allegedly with a completion date of 2011. 2009: Construction commences on the Blue Line.[1] 2016: Phase I (the Blue Line from Marina to Mile 2) planned to open in December 2016. 2018: After an Alstom review of the project, Phase I (the Blue Line from Marina to Mile 2) is now set to open in 2021. 2021: The Lagos State Government announced that the Blue and Red Lines will open in December 2022.[3] 2022, January: LAMATA purchases two Talgo VIII trains. On Jan 24, 2023, President Muhammadu Buhari inaugurated the first phase of the Lagos Mass Transit Blue Line Rail Project.[4]
Take to correction. You said redline and I corrected you. So what are you on about?
Shma2023: Redline break ground in 2013, that's pretty much 9yrs - 10yrs.
Accept facts as they are. Debating is not ego massaging contest!
Redline started in 2021 by this present Governor.
Blue line started in 2013 but was abandoned by the previous Governor for 4 years. The new Governor continued with it after COVID in 2020 and also kickstarted the redline same time. Now redline is almost done.
Mkenya2019: You're arguing with your own data or why you're getting hot on your collar. If Nigeria is spending 80% (let me take the lowest ) of it's revenue to repay debt - then it barely has money to pay for salaries, electricity, build roads - without significant borrowing If we take the realistic figure of 100% plus debt servicing ratio - then Nigeria is of course the Zoo we know. The zoo where a project like that 14km redline takes 10yrs. Projects in Nigeria take average of 20yrs - the country is littered with Julius Berger towns. You know why projects take years - because Nigeria gov cannot release funds.
And of course why is a Nigeria a ZOO where nothing works - because it's macro-economic are crazy - lowest revenues (similar to kenya) - huge debt (compared to revenues).
The best way to know if you come from a zoo - try to turn on your electricity or water - and let us know.
Let me solve your puzzle for you. Nigeria has other forms of internal revenue generation and internal funding not captured officially.
Redline is 2 year old project not 10 years and redline is not 14km.
So whether 120% or 80%, we've been having such debt servicing to revenue ratio for a while and it hardly matters because they are just official figures. Clear now?
Mkenya2019: Anything above 33% mean you're on your knees. Therefore 80 percent or 120 percent isnt going to help Nigeria. What we need to know is how Nigeria is able to finance salaries,recurrent expenditure and development if any. They are either borrowing more and more Or they arent doing any development - which is likely the case - as Nigeria the Zoo has rotten without any roads being maintained or built Also despite sky high inflation - salaries have not been raised. We saw lecturers last year strike for almost a year - with universities closed.
In short Nigeria is a ZOO precisely because it uses 80-120 percent of it's revenue to pay debt leaving it with nothing for social, infrastracture or any investment - no electricity, poverty, sky high inflation, millions of kids outside schools, kidnapping. nothing works.
Kenya has to avoiding getting there - and go back to below 33% debt servicing ratio - like we have always been - except for last few years.
And kenya will be back healthy in 2025 - we have tough 2024 - then by 2025 our macro-economics will be very solid - we will have brought debt to gdp to 55%; we will have budget surplus on recurrent expenditure,
we will be spending 33% on debt; 33% on development; 33% on salaries, operation & maintenances.
That is how an individual or company or a country is supposed to run 1/3 spend on debt, 1/3 to O&M, 1/3 on investment.
You are fvcking hilarious. In 2022, how many African countries came close to Nigeria in all round spending and infrastructure development? NNPC is even drilling new oil fields in several Northern states by themselves ( not a small thing to do).
Lagos is almost completing a red line train covering several areas of Lagos ( that began 2021) after first phase of blue line. State Governors commissioned projects upon projects, roads upon roads. Several gas projects worth billions of dollars ongoing. Renovation of Airports, etc.
You can't just borrow alone to do all of these. If we just borrowed more only, we would have been bankrupt now with all of these projects and the allocation from Federal Government without fail for salaries and other things. What was the increase in our total debt in 2022 compared with the over 20 Billion dollars released as allocation in addition to several ongoing projects? Let's argue with logic.
The guy thinks he knows Nigeria. He doesn't know for most parts of 2022, Nigeria from Federal level allocated on average over 700 Billion naira monthly (over 1.7 Billion dollars) to states and Local Government without NNPC remittances to CBN and Government for the most part.
Mkenya2019: Tomorrow I will explain what is going on after I research. Yeah it crazy. Imagine kenya we are crying murder at 60 percent. Nigeria is at 120
Please do the research for us. This Nigerian magic must be exposed.
FYI our debt servicing ratio to revenue for the entire year on average closed at 80% but we are not on our knees, so maybe you can help us with the explanation .
But I'll give you some expo though.
Nigerian FIRS revenue in 2022 was 10.1 trillion naira. However, we have that:
Nigeria’s debt service to revenue ratio is reported as 80.7% according to the information contained in the 2023 Budget presentation made by the Minister of Finance.
The report reveals a total debt service of N5.2 trillion in the first 11 months of 2022 out of a total revenue of N6.49 trillion.
So it's simple to see why we are not on our knees. The revenue report here says we made 6.49 trillion naira at the federal level while the FIRS collected 10.1 trillion naira. Our total debt servicing was 5.2 trillion naira.
Put one and two together, you get the answer to the puzzle.
rvp20182: Why shouldn't I - you think he has personal beef with Ghana or Nigeria?
Again I dont use one story - It combination of many things that show Nigeria is SICK.
I asked you to bring debt servicing ratio? You went MIA
You rather engage in personal attack against an illustrious proffesor trying to help your realize the depth of the hole.
Stop being delusional. Nigeria must confront its problem.
We dont hate Nigeria. But it's a ZOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO.
Debt servicing ratio to revenue has been 120% since January 2022 until now and we just borrowed all through to share federal allocations worth over 20 Billion dollars throughout the year to states and local Governments. Nigeria also built several infrastructures and bought more army equipments same year altogether worth billions of dollars. Yet the increase in our public debt in 2022 was not even up to 10 Billion dollars ( both local and external). That's the magic Nigeria somehow performed in the economics of rvp2018 😄.
If you believe that, you'll believe anything and no need going at it with you further.
vaxx: lol...I am also on Wikipedia . Show me his literature that is what I ask you to do not his biography . You are even more stupid showing me wikipedia page of him .
Didn't he has published work
I don't know why he takes that Steve Hanke of a guy so seriously.
vaxx: You are idiot. only poor wretched country consider the option of not paying salaries when there is evidence of high cost of living and distress in the country . Debt restructuring on the other hand is what country who still prefer to stay in the financial market will consider. Russia (With a more successful economy than any africa country ) once did it and works . Only poor nation will consider the option of not paying workers .
That is damn stupid
But if you default and do local debt restructuring, then there would be haircuts which would affect the big private sector players and which in turn has its effects.
When you default on your external debts, there becomes the problem of trust. Trust is important in all business deals. Would you be trusted to get good loans in the future? That's the thing.
On the other hand, if you try to plug loopholes or reduce the size of your civil service especially non productive civil service workers, then you can manage the situation.
The only problem is that if your civil service is large and forms the core of your middle class then you have a problem there as well.
FG of Nigeria has been unable to recover about N8 trillion (18 Billion dollars) taxes withheld by international and local oil companies, GSM operators, insurance companies, pension fund administrators, and gaming and betting companies.
The withheld revenue was uncovered by the 🇳🇬 Financial Intelligence Unit.
Nigerian biggest problem with revenue generation is corruption.
I'd say I agree with rvp2018 in this case. Withholding civil servant salaries for now (alongside cutting down the cost of Governance) would be better than outright default.
Kenya is doing 75% of revenue... Kenyan wages, salaries and compensation takes 55% of revenue
There's no way to balance this and that is why Kenya is bankrupt and has defaulted of so many debt. Now you don't want to pay workers.. the headache is on Kenya to solve and the IMF couldn't save you from this train reck.
Neither Ghana or Nigeria has gotten to this level of mess yet. This is why you can see big budget financing projects going on in both countries but not in Kenya.
rvp2018: Yes at least you were able to nail the domestic debt restructuring - domestic creditors have little in negotiating power. Now go and negotiate with Chinese Tell China-man to take haircut - and you'll know China man doesnt joke around.
Luckily though, Ghana didn't borrow much from China unlike Zambia.
rvp2018: What is Nigeria Debt Servicing Ratio. Kenya one has risen from 24% to 33% to 40% to 50% to now 60%. Ideally 33% is benchmark for gov or your as individual. 1/3 of your salary or revenue should go to debt repayment - obviously Kenya has dropped the ball - hence the occasionally cash crunch.
Argue with facts or just throw facts outside like Ghanians - and rant like a mad man.
What is Nigeria Debt Servicing Ratio.
I have told you before. Nigeria prepares her budget based on estimated oil revenues for the year. In the first three quarters of 2022, Nigeria did not make up to that estimated revenue from oil due to lower than expected oil production (some record lows despite high prices).
So the debt servicing ( mostly maturities from 2014-2015) surpassed the revenues.
In all of those times, Nigeeia was successfully allocating FAAC allocations from the Federal Government of around 2 Billion dollars to states monthly as well as the equipping of the military and maritime with billions of dollars. NNPC was even exploring new oil fields and repairing refineries. All of these were not from borrowing.
Nigeria was building infrastructures and doing a lot of stuff, not all came from borrowing. Otherwise Nigerian borrowing in 2022 would have been the most outrageous in Africa.
rvp2018: Nigeria debt servicing ratio is 100% - that mean your federal gov cant pay salaries and recurrent expenditure without borrowing. That is why entire year lecturers were on strike - universities close. Your Zoo is beyond redemption.
You've been saying this nonsense since 2021. if that were to be the case we would have been bankrupt by now, it's a no brainer. The fact that we aren't tells you, you do not get the full gist of the story just surface headlines.
Even in your salary payslip - 1st charge is loan repayment. The same for gov - 1st charge is to repay debt.
@the bolded, you mean some Nigerian state Governors (very few states at the moment) do that to state workers. The federal workers hardly have such problems.
rvp2018: Opposition propaganda from a party that nearly took Kenya to Ghana - default. Mps were paid salaries.
The new administration has worked very hard to avoid Ghana default.
Lol, when you were quoting opposition opinions from Ghana like Ato Fortson and the likes, didn't you know some were also biased opposition propaganda? This is not just mere opposition propaganda though. Kenya is going through a lot.
vaxx: Despite Ghana woes, paying salary has never become a problem.
Kenya is indeed broke and distress, she can't even pay common salary. This only happens when too much of your revenue goes into debt servicing..
I swear down.
Wandayi said that civil servants and MPs have gone to Easter without salaries despite the government's efforts to increase revenue collection. revealed that only the police and military have been paid. "Today, about six months into this regime, Kenya cannot pay salaries, leave alone finance its other operations.
Celebration of Ghanaian independence anniversary in Lagos. Ghanaians in Nigeria laud their host for hospitality and called for more collaborations between entertainers in both spheres.
chrisooblog: If you had asked me this question in 1999 I would have agreed wholeheartedly with you but having seen how things have progressed not just in Nigeria but other parts of Africa I'm not sure 100%.
In terms of curbing impunity and corruption democracies all over Africa haven't done too well although I will have to admit democracy has helped improve infrastructure in most countries on the continent Nigeria included.
Military rule really did a number on us. From General Buhari, IBB, Abacha and Abdulsalami no major investment in infrastructure like power plants, refineries, hospitals, dams, etc. Even though Abacha built some roads especially in Northern Nigeria it wasn't widespread to have a big impact on people's lives.
One thing though was that Abacha was heavily sanctioned by the west too. The cruel dictator had no breathing space and began to stash so much cash abroad.
SUFFERInSMILIIN: Come December this year the suffering and smiling she would be back with a twist. This time it will be suffering and smiling show broadcast live from Lagos and all City including Abuja
Emperormartin: As Buhari government tried everything humanly possible to arrest Nnamdi Kanu...
I'm guessing Tinubu government will do the same to Simon Ekpa
Knowing Tinubu and his political ways of old, I believe he would rather strategically plant moles in Simon Ekpa's camp causing division there until it comes to nothing or he may continue with Buhari's method of pure force. Time will tell.
vaxx: This is the country some individual are trying to compare with us . Even Benin republic is way advance than this shit-hole
To be honest, if they love Kagame and he is good for the country, I see nothing wrong with this. It's only wrong if he is the one imposing this on the people.
rvp2018: 23 billion - okay - minus oil subsidy of 12B - remainder 11B - minus debt servicing of 11B - BROKE. You then go to borrow to pay salaries and recurrent expenditure at crazy interest rates. Ideally you should default - and stop borrowing. Then address that mess. But you fear being laughed out like Ghana
rvp2018: Last I checked it was 10B from Federal Revenue; 15 or 12B from oil/royalties - which was immediately converted into stupid fuel subsidies; So basically usable revenues are 10B; Usable forex I hear are about 15B; far cry from official figures; Just like forex exchange going by black market is almost double the official rate. Nigeria has been in the red for sometime - with debt servicing ration long exceeding 100%. What is stopping your from defaulting is just national pride. - you rather pay 100% of all money to service debt What is also stopping your from devaluaing Naira is the same national pride.
Eventually you must confront the your economic demons if you want to stop manufacturing poverty at industrial scale like you're doing now - and your federal gov is totally dysfunctional.
Give me data from a reliable source not Steve Hanke. You and your fellow Kenyans are the only one ones here who takes that clown seriously.
The Nigerian revenue from FIRS (taxes) at the federal level only was 10.1 trillion naira in 2022 which is 23 Billion dollars at federal level only. Estimated revenue for this year is also same 10 trillion naira though it may likely surpass that.
rvp2018: Federal revenues is 10B Federal external debt is approaching 50B - if Naira is devalued so you can have unified exchange rate - it will mean doubling of debt obligation.
Again states have their revenues and their debt
The 10 Billion you got from your ass without proof? If you can't give proof, then the argument becomes a waste of time.
You said if naira is devalued, but naira has not been devalued.
rvp2018: External debt...overvalued naira..will eventually devalue..doubling your External debt. With 10b dollars in revenue you already cant repay debt.States are also choking in their debt.I called out Ghana default years before due to their External debt.Nigeria is heading there
Okay wait until the devaluation happens. For now it's 30 Billion dollars revenue. External debt is 40 Billion dollars. Not that much of a problem I believe.
rvp20182: I predict Nigeria will file for bankruptcy this year. No way with revenues of 10B dollars they can fulfill debt obligation. They will join Ghana soon.
The East AfricanRest Of Africa Nigeria’s debt at $103b, GDP wanes as inflation, redundancy rise TUESDAY APRIL 04 2023
President Buhari and his Vice President Osinbajo Nigerian President Buhari (right) and his Vice President Osinbajo. They will leave office on May 29, 2023 bequeathing an economy hit by debt, inflation, unemployment and poverty to their successors. PHOTO | PRESIDENTIAL VILLA
Summary A report revealed that Nigeria’s inflation rate will average 20.5 per cent in 2023. Data revealed that debtors who owe Nigeria’s government agencies refused to honour obligations but were still being paid. Nigeria expected to spend 60 percent of its total revenue on debt servicing in 2023. ADVERTISEMENT
General ImageBy MOHAMMED MOMOH More by this Author
Nigeria’s economy is weakening as its total debt climbed to $103.11 billion with spiralling inflation and unemployment. The dire economic situation is what the country’s outgoing President Muhammadu Buhari would hand over to the incoming president on May 29, 2023.
According to Nigeria’s Debt Management Office (DMO), the total public debt stock of the country consisted of the domestic and external debts of the Federal Government of Nigeria (FGN) and its 36 state governments.
Advertisement
DMO in a statement on its website took a comparative debt stock and reported that Nigeria’s debt as of December 31, 2021 was $95.77 billion. In terms of composition, DMO said the country’s total domestic debt stock stood at $61.42 billion while total external debt stock was $41.69 billion.
“Among the reasons for the increase in total public debt stock were new borrowings by the Nigerian government and its state governments, primarily to finance budget deficits and execute projects. The issuance of promissory notes by the country’s regime to settle some liabilities also contributed to growth in the debt stock,’’ the office said in its latest release in Abuja
What in this report says Nigeria is going bankrupt? and how do you get this your 10 Billion dollars revenue? It is10 trillion naira which is 23 Billion dollars at federal level from taxes.
With Lagos and other states, the total revenue of Nigeria for 2022 should be above 30 Billion dollars from both FIRS and states. There are other sources of revenue as well that are not in that.