₦airaland Forum

5. Who would you say was more accurate about Muhammad's beliefs - the Quran written 1400 years ago or Salman Rushdie? Or some untrusted scholars? Or the one who made it clear he wrote down what he heard faithfully?

4. If I wrote a FICTIONAL story book about a guy having a perverted dreams and weaved bits of Jesus' (peace be upon him) life into it and portrayed him to be a sick pedophile - would you believe it to be to be an accurate description of Christ's beliefs, especially as I am not a Christian?

3. Why do you insist that Rushdie's book is an interpretation of Muhammad's (SAW) beliefs - a claim that not even Rushdie makes. Or in the Qur'an?

2. If so, can you tell me where did Salman Rushdie say that his book, which he claims to be a work of fiction, a novel, was an intepretation of the beliefs of Muhammad (SAW)? Or where the content make things with the verses?

1. Have you read "Satanic Verses"--the novel and the alleged verses as well as their content?

Questions for you, folks, for I am grudgingly leaving:


1. Have you read "Satanic Verses"--the novel and the alleged verses as well as their content?

2. If so, can you tell me where did Salman Rushdie say that his book, which he claims to be a work of fiction, a novel, was an intepretation of the beliefs of Muhammad (SAW)? Or where the content make things with the verses?

3. Why do you insist that Rushdie's book is an interpretation of Muhammad's (SAW) beliefs - a claim that not even Rushdie makes. Or in the Qur'an?

4. If I wrote a FICTIONAL story book about a guy having a perverted dreams and weaved bits of Jesus' (peace be upon him) life into it and portrayed him to be a sick pedophile - would you believe it to be to be an accurate description of Christ's beliefs, especially as I am not a Christian?

5. Who would you say was more accurate about Muhammad's beliefs - the Quran written 1400 years ago or Salman Rushdie? Or some untrusted scholars? Or the one who made it clear he wrote down what he heard faithfully?

I'm just trying to find out where you're coming from.

Until I came back. Thanks[/quotes]

@olabowale, the comparison is not accurate. See the scenerio unfolding ,,,,,,,

1. Islamic writers al-Tabari and ibn-Sa'd wrote about satanic verses in their hadeeths.

2. muslims later discredit al-Tabari and ibn-Sa'd's hadeeths for recording the saga of the satanic verses.

3. many years after, an islamic writer produces a fictional novel with the title 'satanic verses'.

4. a muslim supreme ruler in Iran declares a fatwa for revisiting the satanic verses saga and ordered copies of the book to be burnt.

5. islamic countries rose against the author and the fatwa is validated in all islamic countries and copies of the book burnt in all islamic countries and the author seeks and get assylum in a foreign non-islamic country.

How then are you dissociating muslims from Ayatollah's fatwa?

And who are the "actors", "actresses", directors, and other crew of these films?

tayoTFC:
imagine if obasanjo, yaradua and other politician is a footballer what will be there nick name, lets talk

obasanjo = Baba obo
Yaradua = yaradull
dimeji = eyin labi
gbenga daniel = sumusumu
tinubu = ojuyobo
etc,

is it good for muslim to pay tieth if yes how and to who

Are you a christian convert who embraced Islam ?

And not many muslims go on porn sites, definitely not as much as christians, anyway.

And I never told you I was christian, did I?

Akanniade:
It looks like the house of reps have their own agenda. If their multiple commitees and sub commities had been working in the first place they would have been the ones to bring this banking mess to light.