PastorAIO's Posts
Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 (of 287 pages)
Does anyone in this conversation listen to Ravi Zacharias? Just curious. |
The Occultists are hidden. |
Kay 17: ^^hmmmm. . . . what if the consciousness of any object is the same consciousness as mine? I'm not saying it is, I'm just throwing it out there as an hypothetical notion. |
I apologise in advance if the above comes across as arrogant. I don't mean it that way. |
Kay 17: I'm not aware of your consciousness?! An AI is at most is aware, but a sophisticated AI could be self conscious, given aware of one's identity as the criteria.I don't want to get into a round and about argument over whether or not you can be aware of my consciousness when I know that all those who have dedicated their lives to the issue, even professionally, admit that it is an inherently subjective phenomena. This is admitted by Atheists philosophers as Keith Augustine above as well as everyone else that has tried to tackle the issue. I've had these conversations before and I don't really fancy going there again. Perhaps if you had a look at the matter here: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qualia/ . . . . . . . and after reading you subsequently felt that you had an insight that hasn't been touched on yet by philosophers etc, then I would be delighted to hear what your insight was. |
One of the most persistent difficulties for reductive physicalism has been the apparent inability of physicalistic explanations to capture qualitative features of conscious experience. It has been persuasively argued that qualia--the experiential feels of 'what it is like' to be in a conscious mental state--cannot be captured by any physicalistic explanations in principle[b] because physicalistic explanations inherently refer to objective or public features of phenomena, whereas the experiential features of consciousness are inherently subjective or private[/b] (Teller 1992, pp. 190-191). While such arguments for the irreducibility of consciousness are not the last word on the subject, they have not been decisively refuted either--at least not in the view of several prominent philosophers.http://www.infidels.org/library/modern/keith_augustine/thesis.html#distinction |
I thought Krishna was an avatar of Vishnu who has always existed. |
Kay 17: No, but we have no experience of awareness/consciousness floating in mid-air.The only consciousness we have experience of is our own. I cannot experience your consciousness. You cannot experience my consciousness. As far as I may be aware you might just be a well programmed neurological robot, An AI. |
thehomer: No one is doing that. It is simply accepted with good practical reasons.And for good reason too. dropping a ball by releasing it is not the entirety of Induction. thehomer: I really don't see a problem here.Great! Why is that a problem? Don't make a problem out of not seeing a problem. Where there is no problem there is no problem. |
thehomer: I really don't see a problem here.And regardless of what you see, they still say what they say. thehomer: Now, if the question is how reliable is what you're seeing or how reliable is what your friends are telling you, that will be a different question.Bingo! |
thehomer:When someone tells you that pigs fly in mongolia that probably isn't true but that doesn't mean that they aren't telling you, it's just that it isn't true. And when you friends tell you that there's a dirty pig there, it doesn't match your perception of the white horse, but you are still hearing what they are telling you. |
thehomer: I know about the problem of induction and I can see the problem with in philosophical thought but I don't see it as a practical problem. What would be a practical problem is for someone to consistently act as though induction was unreasonable.What would be a problem would be if you were to confer absolute reliability on Induction. For the most part it works. That is fortuitous. |
Kay 17: Awareness at least in a basic state, is a readily product/effect of matter, of which consciousness an advanced state must exist.You say that so authoritatively. As if you've done the experiment by configuring matter in the lab in such a way that Awareness was produced. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]So your problem is with the word "authority" abi? Have it your way then, "reliance" it is. Thank God we are now in the clear[/quote]Phew!! |
thehomer:If the likes of Russell and Frege are too mathematical for you you might like to check out instead the works of Hume and Locke. Hume laid out the Problem of Induction. The problem of induction is the philosophical question of whether inductive reasoning leads to knowledge.[citation needed] That is, what is the justification for eitherhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Problem_of_induction I love that quote: "induction is the glory of science and the scandal of philosophy" |
thehomer: @ Pastor AIO I said: Such as? A few examples would be nice here. thehomer: Like[b] numbers, mathematical processes[/b] etc. They're very different from someone simply telling you something.This is quite wonderful cos I've already mentioned Bertrand Russell and Wittgenstein. I should just stick with Russell though cos he is the one that made famous the questionability of Numbers and mathematics, and furthermore the Contradiction (or paradox) at the heart of numbers. He made the problem famous and that is why it is called Russell's paradox but in fact it had been noticed by mathematicians and Logicians way way way before him. Some people might say that I was stretching the argument if I say that it was recognised by philosophers even thousands of years before the 20th century, but I firmly believe that even though they might have not tackled the issue head on they certainly alluded to it in many texts. So what is Russell's paradox? Russell had been researching into the foundations of Mathematics and Logical processes (in fact that was the main bulk of his life's work) when he came upon it. He was writing The Principles of Mathematics at the time. Russell’s discovery came while he was working on his Principles of Mathematics. Although Russell discovered the paradox independently, there is some evidence that other mathematicians and set-theorists, including Ernst Zermelo and David Hilbert, had already been aware of the first version of the contradiction prior to Russell’s discovery. Russell, however, was the first to discuss the contradiction at length in his published works, the first to attempt to formulate solutions and the first to appreciate fully its importance. An entire chapter of the Principles was dedicated to discussing the contradiction, and an appendix was dedicated to the theory of types that Russell suggested as a solution.http://www.iep.utm.edu/par-russ/ |
thehomer: Because some of those other sources of information are inherently different.How about if, rather than use the word Authoritativeness, I used the word Reliability. Various people therefore Rely on different sources of information seemingly arbitrarily. Some rely more on the information provided by their senses to determine 'truth'. Others rely on Consensus to determine whether something is 'true'. Others rely on what their teachers in school tell them. Others rely on their pastors. Would you really say that some sources (eg. the Senses, as you have been claiming) are too inherently different from other sources to be Relied on? |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Ok, are you then saying that we cannot possibly know the truth with any certainty except by supernatural means? If this is the case, How does one go about showing another person the truth that he /she has learnt supernaturally and get the person yo actually understand this truth?[/quote]I am saying that if we can grasp Truth with certainty it will NOT be by means of our 'logical' faculties. Since Truth if grasped by some other faculty cannot be articulated in language (which, it seems, uses the same terms as knowledge, or rather belief) then it cannot be spoken or argued or demonstrated to another person. As Wittgenstein would say: 7 What we cannot speak about we must pass over in silence. However, someone can guide another in such a way that the other will come upon the ineffable Truth for himself. eg. I might not be able to tell you what is going on in Room 303, but I can tell you to walk down the corridor, take a left, then a right and enter into Room 303. When you come back from Room 303 you will know what I'm not talking about. Check out Plato's Allegory of the Cave. ( i know, i know, it seems like I bleat on about this incessantly). |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Do I really have to always ask you the same question twice before you attempt to answer? or perhaps you are really more interested in playing semantics with thehomer?[/quote]I thought that I'd already answered it here: Pastor AIO: Oh, the Truth Can and Does exist, BUT we cannot grasp it with Thought (as based on axioms and inferences) and neither can we articulate it in the terms of Thought, or Knowledge. |
thehomer: @ Pastor AIOSuch as? A few examples would be nice here. thehomer: @ Pastor AIO Say for instance a style guru says that Green is the best colour for this fashion season, many who accept her authority as a fashion guru will insist that Green is indeed the best colour to go to the party in. The green part is fruitless speculation. How does that affect the argument in anyway? |
thehomer: Why do people find it so difficult to back up their claims?From what I seem to understand you saying, you insist that an Authority must be a Person, a personality, or a Book. But it cannot be any other source of information. Why? Why can Authoritativeness not be applied to every source of information? |
thehomer: You'll need to show me how you think I misunderstood his premise because it seems to accept pretty much anything as being an authority which doesn't make sense based on the definition of the word in English. Pastor AIO: [size=15pt] |
InesQor: *Tracta[b]t[/b]usThank you jare. It's actually Trata[b]t[/b]us Logico Philosophi[b]cus[/b]. Very sweet book. Also look for a book called Logicomix. It tracks the history of 20th century Logic and philosophy of Mathematics. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]I'm not sure I quite get this but if I am right in my reading, I think you are saying that we cannot possibly have truth with any certainty. If this is indeed what you are saying, wouldn't this imply that truth does not and cannot exist?[/quote]Oh, the Truth Can and Does exist, BUT we cannot grasp it with Thought (as based on axioms and inferences) and neither can we articulate it in the terms of Thought, or Knowledge. Even when our thoughts and beliefs approximate the Truth it is due to some measure of fortuity. Consider Gettier's Problem. A farmer wants to check if his black Cow is in the field. He sees a black cloth hanging on a tree and presumes (due to his poor eyesight) that it is the Cow. He concludes that the Cow is indeed in the field. It so happens that the Cow is indeed in the field. However can the Farmer really be said to know it? He arrived at the truth via a faulty process. So a very important distinction must be drawn between Belief and TRUE KNOWLEDGE. Just because a belief may be true does that really mean that the believer KNOWS the fact. He believes it and the truth of his belief is quite fortuitous. Now how does one arrive at said TRUE KNOWLEDGE? The axioms will have to be valid/true and the process of inference will have to be Valid/true. How can we be sure this is the case? We cannot hence we can only believe things to be True but we cannot Know them to be true. Not with our carnal reasoning in any case. (making room for the possibility that there my be another way). |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]@Pastor AIO With such differing "authorities", how can one ever know truth? About truth, can there be multiple truths? This is because different people defer to different "highest authorities" Please answer my questions, I've been waiting[/quote]I would say that the Truth cannot be grasped with certainty using the tools and methods of a) establishing axioms and then b) following the inferences from these axioms via a system of logic. If we arrive at the truth by these means then there is a certain measure of fortuity what would be required. The system will always be open to doubt. This fact has in fact been established MATHEMATICALLY through the work of philosopher/mathematician Bertrand Russell and others like Wittgenstein. Wittgenstein wrote what in my opinion is the most deliciously titled book in the whole of Philosophy. It was called Tractacus Logico Philosophorum. And furthermore the final line of that book is also in my opinion the most delicious way to end any book. 7 What we cannot speak about we must pass over in silence.Actually it starts off quite deliciously too: 1 The world is all that is the case. |
Since we know that the senses deceive us all the time how can you confer such a high authority on the senses. People have been hypnotised to feel pain. Pain has been hypnotised away. There are so many effects that can be created by messing with the senses. It is ridiculous to place such a high stock on sensory information. Imagine a scenario. You are with four friends and you see a white horse and you point at it and say to them, 'look at that beautiful white horse'. They respond, 'what beautiful white horse are you drunk? There is nothing there, or , oh, you mean that dirty pig wallowing in the mud' You don't see a pig but you still see a beautiful white horse. Which Authority will you accept more. The Authority of your senses or the Authority of Consensus. 4 different people are seeing things differently from you. |
Wow! success!!!! The entire website is about sensory/optical illusions check it out: http://www.michaelbach.de/ot/index.html |
Let's put it this way. An Authority is what you rely on to determine the TRUTH. When you get contradicting information you take the more authoritative source to be True. In thehomer's case it is his senses. Now, can the authority of the senses be undermined? the answer is a very simple yes. You know that drink and substances and varying emotional states affect the perception of the senses. Even without varying mind states the senses feed us with wrong information all the time. Now I want to put up a link for you to study but I'm afraid that it is this link that got me banned last time so I will first put it in non-link form. and then put the link up later in another post. http: // www.michaelbach .de/ot/mot_feet_lin /index.html Please join the 4 lines above into one http address and check out the page. |
This spambot is really yabbing. Just when I was getting into the flow. I glad to see that Mr Anony took up the baton adequately though. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 (of 287 pages)