₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,242 members, 8,521,947 topics. Date: Friday, 20 November 2026 at 10:23 AM

Toggle theme

PastorAIO's Posts

Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 (of 287 pages)

Christianity Etc › Re: Deepsight,pastor AIO, And Everyone Else, Lets Discuss CONSCIOUSNESS.. Again. by PastorAIO: 4:24pm On Jul 16, 2012
What do we mean by Alive, as opposed to Dead?

Are these words/concepts synonymous with Animate as opposed to Inanimate?
Christianity Etc › Re: Deepsight,pastor AIO, And Everyone Else, Lets Discuss CONSCIOUSNESS.. Again. by PastorAIO: 9:00am On Jul 16, 2012
plaetton: I do understand where you are coming from. After thinking about it, I think I 'll let it remain as is.
For example, Brain scans clearly show that narcotis do affect brain waves and neural impulses, and therefore do alter states of consciousness, which in turn, alters the perception of reality.
Okay, but then I'll have to say that what you are calling consciousness is not what I am calling Consciousness. We are talking about 2 different things.
Christianity Etc › Re: Deepsight,pastor AIO, And Everyone Else, Lets Discuss CONSCIOUSNESS.. Again. by PastorAIO: 3:15am On Jul 16, 2012
plaetton: Consciousness defines reality. An Altered state of consciousness produces an altered perception of reality.
The universe, is , ultimately, a projection of our consciousness.
Would you accept it if I changed where you say 'an altered state of consciousness' and say rather an altered mode of perception.

I am suggesting this because it seems that you are talking about Perceptions rather than Consciousness.
Christianity Etc › Re: Religion And Authority by PastorAIO(op): 2:39am On Jul 16, 2012
thehomer: They're broadly based on evidence and are generally open to revision with the availability of better evidence.
By what authority is evidence considered valid?
Christianity Etc › Re: Religion And Authority by PastorAIO(op): 2:37am On Jul 16, 2012
thehomer: Problems can easily creep in when one uses "authority" in this manner. [/b]It is easy to see that the "authority" that logical axioms represent is very different from the sort of "authority" that the Bible, the church or pastors and other people represent.
What is wrong with the 'manner' in which I use the term Authority? Is it grammatically wrong? Or am I twisting the meaning of the word? Please explain your beef. What you consider 'problems' can, you're right, easily creep in. In fact they don't creep in, they storm in, bashing down the fragile doors that keep 'Logic' intact.

Please read what I wrote again and tell me what you understand by it. I'll quote the most relevant portions again:

People in this world are ruled by so many different authorities.
Naturalists often rely on the[b] Authority of their Senses
. "I'll believe it when I SEE it!!"
Other people accept the Authority of their pastors. I believe it cos my Pastor says it is so.

It is helpful for us to meditatively consider what passes as Authorities for us.

Many innately accept the Authority of Consensus. "I believe it cos everybody believes it". Often when they argue they look around for supporters. 'who agrees with me, who agrees with me?' When lots of people raise their hands in agreement they relax. "you see, everybody agrees, so therefore I am right()".
Christianity Etc › Re: Religion And Authority by PastorAIO(op): 9:20pm On Jul 15, 2012
@thehomer, so what are your beliefs based on?
Christianity Etc › Re: Is Morality Possible Without An Authoritative Source? by PastorAIO: 7:14pm On Jul 15, 2012
Kay 17: improper analogy

Morality is portrayed inseparable from God, a necessary consequence of the Nature of God himself. Therefore moral contents shouldn't if God doesn't change. However following Bible passages, there is the substantial difference which is undeniable, is witnessed btw the OT and the NT.

Also, today's values are very different from the bibical ages which is not unnatural.
Difficulties: 'Nature' of God. Etymology of Nature - from Natus/nasci (latin) to be born. How was God 'born'?

It does not follow that if (big if) Morality is inseparable from God then morality mustn't change if God doesn't change.

Unless you want to equate Morality to God.

Creator creates Creation. Creator is unchanging, Creation undergoes constant evolution.

If I say that God is beyond our epistemological grasp KAG might wake up from the dead to accuse me of 'extolling the sense of the unknown'.

If you stopped trying to define God and stopped taking seriously those that do then you might find it a lot easier to deal with the evolution of morality. Or the evolution of absolutely everything else.
Christianity Etc › Re: Deepsight,pastor AIO, And Everyone Else, Lets Discuss CONSCIOUSNESS.. Again. by PastorAIO: 6:11pm On Jul 15, 2012
plaetton: Where is everyone?? embarassed
Wait till monday.
Christianity Etc › Re: Deepsight,pastor AIO, And Everyone Else, Lets Discuss CONSCIOUSNESS.. Again. by PastorAIO: 6:11pm On Jul 15, 2012
benodic: according to the The Cosmic Sea of Words, Eckankar Lexicon, Consciousness is that state of being in which the individual lives daily, which is divided into two parts, the phenomenal and the transcendental. the phenomenal depends upon the sense organs for its expression, the transcendental is independent of the physical senses and works directly with the ECK (Holy Spirit)
consciousness is also the reality of a particular kind of Awareness which is independent of the mind's activity.
Wow! I've never check out Eck before and I agree with some of the things you say here. However, I would not say that Consciousness is a state cos I define a state as something that one is passing through, a stage in a process which is different from an unchanging essential being. However this could just be a matter of definitions and how we use the word differently.

I often use the distinctions Phenomenal and Super-phenomenal, which I suppose is what you would mean by phenomenal and transcendental.

benodic: yes. all living creatures have consciousness and non-living objects too.
I am inclined to agree with this but I don't think that I could state it quite to authoritatively. The problem would be how to prove it.

benodic: consciousness is actually an attribute of Soul. the level of a Soul's consciousness determines where it will find its expression which can be at the mineral, plant, animal or human level.
I wouldn't call consciousness an attribute at all. I believe that it is more essential than that.
Christianity Etc › Re: Religion And Authority by PastorAIO(op): 5:53pm On Jul 15, 2012
au·thor·i·ty   [uh-thawr-i-tee, uh-thor-]
noun, plural au·thor·i·ties.
1.
the power to determine, adjudicate, or otherwise settle issues or disputes; jurisdiction; the right to control, command, or determine.
2.
a power or right delegated or given; authorization: Who has the authority to grant permission?
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/authority

I'm resurrecting this thread because of this other thread:
https://www.nairaland.com/990487/morality-possible-without-authoritative-source/4

Is Morality Possible without An Authoritative Source?

I say, is it only Morality?

What exactly is an Authority? It is something that cannot be questioned. What Authority says, goes. It's will is done. If it says green is Good then no one can argue that Green is Good. If it says brown is bad then similarly no one can argue that Brown is bad. The buck stops with the authority. It's pronouncements are axiomatic.

But is it only Morality that is based on an authority? No! For we find that almost everything that we do and think is based on some Authority or the other. There can therefore never be any agreement between two people that do not share an authority.

People in this world are ruled by so many different authorities.
Naturalists often rely on the Authority of their Senses. "I'll believe it when I SEE it!!"
Other people accept the Authority of their pastors. I believe it cos my Pastor says it is so.

It is helpful for us to meditatively consider what passes as Authorities for us.

Many innately accept the Authority of Consensus. "I believe it cos everybody believes it". Often when they argue they look around for supporters. 'who agrees with me, who agrees with me?' When lots of people raise their hands in agreement they relax. "you see, everybody agrees, so therefore I am right(huh)".

That Consensus one is tricky cos we all acquiesce a little bit to consensus. If you are debating with someone and you know that you are right but everybody else in the room ends up agreeing with the person that you are debating with, it really dampens your will to continue debating. It can even sow seeds of doubt even though (based on some other authority) you 'know' that you are right.

One way to undermine someone's argument is to questions their authorities. Even the authority of the Senses can be questioned. In fact there is a whole school of philosophy based on that in India. In Advaita Vedanta philosophy sensory experience is called Maya/Illusion.

Even in Western philosophy the fact of sensory illusions is often the basis of criticising people like Locke or Hume.

So even if someone says, 'I believe it because I saw it with my own eyes' you can always answer that ' . . but dude, that whiskey was very strong'.

St. Augustine realised this relationship between our Belief systems and apparently arbitrary Authorities that they are based on and used it to based his own Belief system.

Since everybody's belief system is based on some unquestioned Authority that is taken as axiomatic Augustine himself declared that His Beliefs were based on the two authoritative pillars of the Church and the Bible.
These two were to be unquestioned in his belief system. He would believe the Church before he believed any other possible authority (presumably even his senses).
Christianity Etc › Re: Is Morality Possible Without An Authoritative Source? by PastorAIO: 5:14pm On Jul 15, 2012
I have a feeling we might have to abandon this thread soon Due to Front page disease.

frontpageisis.
Christianity Etc › Re: Is Morality Possible Without An Authoritative Source? by PastorAIO: 5:13pm On Jul 15, 2012
Purist: I agree with Mazaje that morality is always dependent on place and time in history, and as you yourself rightly stated, "morality" is not possible without an objective reference point. I do see your what you're getting at here though.

However, the problem with "God" is that, considering the attributes generously bestowed upon him (omnipotence, omniscience, omnipresence, omnibenevolence), one would expect that his own sense of morality should easily transcend any time and place in history. According to the bible, he is the same yesterday, today and forever. Therefore, if God was "right" to have ordered genocide and slavery in the past, then by his very nature described in the bible, he still holds the same views today and tomorrow, and everyone should really be wary of him.

Now, if one of those super attributes were withdrawn, then maybe, just maybe, not many would have much "problems" with "God".
A ha! So we can start to see the problems we run into with those Savants that 'know' God so well and have him well-defined.

When we say 'God' is the same today yesterday and always what exactly are we referring to?

If a man is angry at 1pm and cools down by 3 pm and then is seen laughing at 5pm are we saying that he has changed and he is no longer the same man?

What remains essentially the same, and what is subjected to process? Can a thing be the same by yet manifest as different states of being?

What does the Emerald tablet mean when it says that all things are derived by the mediation of ONE thing?

Here is an translation of the first 3 lines by Idries Shah:

From Idres Shah


1) The truth, certainty, truest, without untruth.
2 )What is above is like what is below. What is below is like what is above. The miracle of unity is to be attained.
3) Everything is formed from the contemplation of unity, and all things come about from unity, by means of adaptation.


Here is Isaac Newton's translation:


1) Tis true without lying, certain & most true.
2) That wch is below is like that wch is above & that wch is above is like yt wch is below to do ye miracles of one only thing.
3) And as all things have been & arose from one by ye mediation of one: so all things have their birth from this one thing by adaptation.


Jabir Ibn Hayyan's translation:

1) Truth! Certainty! That in which there is no doubt!
2) That which is above is from that which is below, and that which is below is from that which is above, working the miracles of one.
3) As all things were from one.


1) Here (is) a true explanation, concerning which there can be no doubt.
2) It attests: The above from the below, and the below from the above -the work of the miracle of the One.
3) And things have been from this primal substance through a single act. How wonderful is this work! It is the main (principle) of the world and is its maintainer.



Read more translations here:
http://www.sacred-texts.com/alc/emerald.htm
Christianity Etc › Re: Davidylan Says Sorry by PastorAIO: 12:20pm On Jul 15, 2012
Deep sight, expect an email from me soon.
Christianity Etc › Re: Davidylan Says Sorry by PastorAIO: 12:18pm On Jul 15, 2012
Deep Sight: The only things i take real offence at are the one that go below the belt, such as when Pastor AIO shared an email i sent to him here publicly, or such as when Martian directed insults at my family members simply on account that i mentioned that they are pentecostal, and that i disagree and debate with them. One should not insult people one has not even intertacted with, and he vd he ceratinly hasnt.

Nah
Aaaa aaahh!!! Deep Sight! Deep Siiiiightiiii! Deeeeeep Siiiiightiiiiiiiiii!!! How many times I call your name? When did I share the email you sent me? Why now? Was it not you that published the email for all to read? I mentioned that I was unhappy about you emailing with ulterior motives. I mentioned the email, I did not publish it. it was you that then posted it for all to see. Abeg go read the thread again. This is not fair o!

Then secondly I'm still at a loss as to how it is offensive to mention a private communication on a public forum, especially when I haven't been told that it is a secret and not to mention it. That was the point I was trying to make. That I didn't see how that was a big deal.

But sha if the thing is still paining you like that up until now, then I apologise.
Christianity Etc › Re: Is Morality Possible Without An Authoritative Source? by PastorAIO: 11:22am On Jul 15, 2012
Kay 17: Atheism is simple. Disbelief in Gods (supernatural). It doesn't come with a code of ethics package, its doesn't define a way of life, it doesn't prescribe an ideology.

As a result, you can't blame atheism for moral deficiencies.

My morals are in line with those of humanism, which is more comprehensive than atheism.
Hmm . . . check the Paul Kurtz thread too:
https://www.nairaland.com/148054/paul-kurtz-great-public-intellectual
Christianity Etc › Re: Is Morality Possible Without An Authoritative Source? by PastorAIO: 11:20am On Jul 15, 2012
The following is from a previous thread back in the day.
https://www.nairaland.com/148054/paul-kurtz-great-public-intellectual/2
:

Krayola sir,  I think sometimes the best way forward is to go back.  May I refer you to some of my earliest posts on Nairaland.  It will help matters immensely.

JayFK:
If you want to quote, when you click on reply scroll down to topic summary, by the person's post you'll see "insert quote"
Thank you

JayFK:
Me I do not believe in god, and I do good because I'm a moral person, apathetic at times but moral.  I do good because well, its the right thing to do and I expect it to be reciprocated, it's like altruism.  Even among animals, the mother bison defenders her young from the lion, she's not doing it for a higher power its more like she's bound to it.
We are all moral people, it is ingrained in us. And you are right we are BOUND to it.  This is a complex subject and I fear that I might do it injustice if I don't tread carefully and take things step by step.  Being Moral means that we will always pursue what we believe to be the highest value.  or as some like to put it, The Greatest Good.  This highest value is different from individual to individual (and from society to society) but each one pursues his/her own highest value.
A lot of the time what you call the 'good' is merely what you have been taught by society as good.  A word of warning though. If you really expect the good you do to be reciprocated you will get mightily disappointed.  I just think you ought to know that, it might help buffer the shock.
I don't think the mother Bison is a good example though.  Her actions may be explained as instinctive rather than moral.  With morality I see a subject having a choice between two actions and choosing the superior one.  A mother's fierce protection of her young is not a choice but rather an instinct.

The thing about our morality is that it determines our behaviour.



JayFK:
Also, I think "morality" as we know it is an innate behaviour, something that we do not need a "holy book" to guide us for, do you understand my point?
Having a moral/value system is innate, but just what is contained in that system is arbitrary.  Everybody values some things higher than others, some actions higher than others, but just which things lie at the top of the morality scale differs from person to person, and from culture to culture.  For instance, in some societies bravery in battle/hunting is highly esteemed as is speaking and acting directly face to face.  In other societies Cunning might be higher esteemed than Upfrontery (my word that i've just made up. nice uh?).  In yet another society diplomacy may be higher esteemed than the sword while for their neighbours diplomats and people who talk are regarded with derision while the sword is respected. 
These various value systems are what give each culture it's characteristics.  And to the extent that individuals differ in their values, our various value systems give us our individual characteristics. 

Morality is a value system that shapes our character and behaviour.  That is all I was trying to say.
This value system that we carry around with us is informed by our environment and yes, accepting the bible as a guide in your life will influence your morals.  I'm that Bush feels no qualms about dropping bombs on Iraqi babies, his moral codes supply him with plenty of precedents that say it is okay. 

I suspect that you are coming from the school of 'Deep down in Everyone's conscience we know what is Good'.  I disagree.  If you were raised as an aborigine in Papua New Guinea you would have no qualms about having another human being for dinner.  I don't mean as a guest for dinner, but actually having him on the table, salted and peppered.  I don't believe in an Absolute Morality that lies within all of us.  Morality is relative.  Your so called innate moral behaviour is a product of your upbringing and your environment.




JayFK:
.  I believe that "morality" is innate and is constantly molded by the society we live in,.  Definition of "morality" is constantly changing I guess,  but my position remains that the bible is not needed for morality contrary to what many Christians may think.
I'm in total agreement with you here.  Everybody has a Moral structure, it is ingrained, innate, and hardwired into what we are.  It informs the way we think and the choices we make and the actions we commit.  There is no such thing as an A-moral human being.  And yes there have been moral codes in all societies since the dawn of time without the need of the bible.  And as immoral behaviour is shocking in christian society, so are behaviours that violate their moral codes shocking in non christian society.  And to the same degree of shock and revulsion and disgust. 

Where I think an important distinction must be emphasised is that the actual articles of any moral code are not fixed, absolute or universal.  Murder is not always despicable, not even in biblical Israel.  I've heard arguments from humanists claiming that everyone agrees that murder is wrong.  Yes every society disapproves of murder, but only within the society.  Theft, only within the society etc.  It's okay to kill the neighbouring tribe, and to steal their cattle and to take over their land flowing with milk and honey.  The injunction not to kill or steal was the code of conduct to be applied by israelites within the Israelite community.  It makes perfect sense that any society that allows it's members to kill each other is not going to last very long.  The bible has proved to be no different from the moral guides of other societies on this matter. 

The definition of Morality is a scale of Values with Good at the top and Evil at the bottom.  This is fixed and true for everyone.  The Specific articles that are contained within a morality, ie what is considered Good and what is considered Evil, is not fixed and neither is it true for everyone.  We are all moral creatures. In any situation every human being will always try to do what he thinks is best.  It's just that one man's morality is another man's immorality. 

I also do not think that if a man despoils a woman that he must then marry her.  The sheer fact that he had to resort to despoil in the first place would suggest that the woman wasn't much interested in the guy in the first place.  That laws comes from a mindset that does not take the feelings of women into much consideration.  My mindset is rather different.


https://www.nairaland.com/nigeria?topic=124453.msg2121735#msg2121735
Christianity Etc › Re: Is Morality Possible Without An Authoritative Source? by PastorAIO: 10:56am On Jul 15, 2012
MacDaddy01: Heroism/self-scarifice do not serve any self interest? You wouldnt protect your children with your life?
Heroism etc do serve an interest. Whether that interest is self interest or not would require us to make an appraisal of just what is the Self. In other words we must face the Problem of Identity again.
Christianity Etc › Re: Is Morality Possible Without An Authoritative Source? by PastorAIO: 10:51am On Jul 15, 2012
Zodiac61: Why don't you just ask the question you really want to ask - Is morality possible without god?
No that is not the question at all. When you go there you reduce the argument to another 'which religion is right' and 'which god is real', or 'whose delusion is superior' kind of argument.

You thereby lose a lot of the juice of the argument.

Is morality possible without Authority? Simples. Whether you want to call the Authority this god or that god or any god (or no god) at all is not the matter.

tobechi74: I think the basis for morality should be our conscience.....if we are about to do something,
so we can ask now, How much of an authority is Conscience and Why so?
Christianity Etc › Re: Is Morality Possible Without An Authoritative Source? by PastorAIO: 10:47am On Jul 15, 2012
Now that's what I call a good question!!
Christianity Etc › Re: Davidylan Says Sorry by PastorAIO: 9:14am On Jul 15, 2012
youngies: Good to hear of your new status David.
But honestly, I prefer your real self in that devastating, fire-spitting, tongue-lashing, caustic mode. It makes a good balance.
Please don't change cool
And no marvel; for Satan himself is transformed into an angel of light.


Sounds like praise and support, but these honeyed traps are part of what we should look out for.
Christianity Etc › Re: Deepsight,pastor AIO, And Everyone Else, Lets Discuss CONSCIOUSNESS.. Again. by PastorAIO: 9:08am On Jul 15, 2012
Well to start with . . . , can someone please help me to understand what KAG was talking about here when he draws a distinction between Awareness and Consciousness, and then claims to be able to demonstrate Awareness and Consciousness in the thread.

KAG: To explain being isn't as easy as it may seem; however, since it seems to be a sticking point, perhaps a provisional, concise idea of what I mean by being might do. Being, for me, indicates some level of awareness [and perhaps perception] towards something.
Pastor AIO: By awareness I take it you mean consciousness.  Of all the things we know for sure in Life Consciousness is the most subjective.  It is such a totally subjective experience that it cannot be demonstrated in anyway whatsoever.  (Which is a point I was going to bring up in another thread but I got distracted, but there are two types of Proof.  Demonstrable proof and subjective proof.  Subjective proof cannot be demonstrated and so cannot be raised in an argument to convince someone else.)

I know for sure that I am conscious because I experience it.  I can never know for a fact whether or not you are a conscious being.  It can never be demonstrated to me, your consciousness.  It could be that you are a very clever automaton or some form of Artificial Intelligence.  They have AI now that can have conversations and appear to think like conscious humans but in actually fact it is just sophisticated programming.  How am I sure that you are not just a cleverly neurologically programmed automaton.  I'll never know if you are in actual fact conscious because you cannot demonstrate or communicate that to me.  

I, for reasons of my own, actually believe that the entire universe is conscious, from the Rocks to the wind blowing through the trees down to Space and time itself.  And as for perception which is the ability to receive and retain information, everything can receive information.  A plasticene receives information when you imprint it with a stamp.  There are many qualities of consciousness and I fear that you might be taking ego-bound consciousness for the whole of consciousness.
KAG: No, I mean awareness.



I disagree, consciousness can be demonstrated and raised in argument. For the most part it would be human-centric, but it can be shown. In any case, that's another topic as consciousness wasn't my point.




I find the idea of a conscious Universe interesting. No, that's not what perception means. No, I have not used the ego as the catch-all for all consciousness.
Pastor AIO: Mr. KAG I have been so totally flummoxed by your standpoint that it has taken me this long to respond. Where does one start?


I am yet to understand the distinction between awareness and consciousness. But for your sake I will restate my position thus, that Awareness is a totally subjective experience and it cannot be communicated to another. I can never know if you are an aware being or not. It is more likely that you are a cleverly programmed machine. Greater minds than yours in the Atheist camp have conceded this fact.


Well I invite you to present your argument that will convince me that you are aware of your existence. And far from consciousness not being the point ( it might not be central to your point, but that is because you are not familiar with the territory covered by this issue) it is at the very core of the point.
KAG: I can appreciate not understanding the distinction between the two terms, as they can often seem syonymous, so perhaps, it would have helped if I had provided a definition of the term. [size=14pt]Awareness would be the abiity to realise a happening. It is cognizance at a most basic level. Consciousness, on the other hand isn't so basic a factor of cogizance, and implies self-awareness[/size].

So, no, awareness is not a "totally subjective experience [that] cannot be communicated to another." You know I'm aware because I'm acknowledging your ideas, parsing them, and responding accordingly.

What greater minds have conceded that awareness can't be determined?



The easiest argument is to point out that I am fully cognizant of being an I. That I can postulate that indicates awareness.
Pastor AIO: Okay Mr. Mechanical Engineer. I can presume that you have a high knowledge of mechanics. Is it or is it not possible to invent a machine that is sensitive to it's environment to such a high degree that it seems to be aware and reacts to the slightest changes in the environment.

There is a website called AskJeeves.com whom you can ask questions and it will respond accordingly. Is AskJeeves aware?

An entity or a body responding to it's environment is not a sign of awareness. Tree leaves swaying in response to the passing breeze is not a sign of awareness.

So though you are 'acknowledging my questions, parsing them, and responding accordingly' that tells me nothing about whether you are aware or not. AI can do the same.


So this: The easiest argument is to point out that I am fully cognizant of being an I. That I can postulate that indicates awareness.
[/b]
is not an argument to prove your awareness. I don't know that you're cognizant of anything. Not anymore than any of those clever japanese robots. You are just a more sophisticated version of AI. I can never know that you have the experience of awareness. The experience itself is much too subjective.

I quote Keith Augustine (a naturalist):

One of the most persistent difficulties for reductive physicalism has been the apparent inability of physicalistic explanations to capture qualitative features of conscious experience. It has been persuasively argued that qualia--the experiential feels of 'what it is like' to be in a conscious mental state--cannot be captured by any physicalistic explanations in principle because physicalistic explanations inherently refer to objective or public features of phenomena, whereas the experiential features of consciousness are inherently subjective or private (Teller 1992, pp. 190-191). While such arguments for the irreducibility of consciousness are not the last word on the subject, they have not been decisively refuted either--at least not in the view of several prominent philosophers. Although such difficulties may be resolved in the future, their current resistance to a clear resolution that gains widespread acceptance gives us good reason to resist simply identifying the natural with the physical.


This was taken from here: http://www.infidels.org/library/modern/keith_augustine/thesis.html

I was furnished with this source by either you or Huxley. It could be Huxley actually and I remain grateful.

As far as I know consciousness does not exhibit any qualities that someone else can now come and measure. The only effect that consciousness/awareness exhibits is the subjective effect that it has on the conscious person. Every other effect exhibited by the human being and observable by others can be explained by neurology. You don't need to be conscious to respond to questions if your brain has been programmed with the appropriate answers.

I'm on the cusp of giving up this thread completely but I'll persevere if we can make headway with just this point.
KAG: Sensitivity to environment isn't awareness.


An entity realising and that realising implicating a response would be a sign of awareness. The leaf isn't aware.



Any AI that can do the same has awareness. To acknowledge something as complex and abstract as the factorsin your arguments, then to parse those ideas and appropriate them and then respond accordingly, is certainly indication of awareness. Creatig an artificial intelligence that possesses those skills will be the pinnacle of technology as science will have succeeded in creating a being-it-itself.

Just to be clear, no AI can do the same at this point in time.



It wasn't an argument to prove my awareness, it was an argument for my awareness. What clever Japanese robots have not only demonstrated the skills mentioned earlier, and, further, awareness of an "I"?

The experience isn's subjective as a demonstration of the factors that implicate awareness are presentable and have been presented in this thread.


Are we talking about consciouness or awareness? What aspect of conscious is your referent point? I'll come back to this if necessary.
Pastor AIO: From what You've said above you seem to think that awareness is a result of the sophistication of an entity. So the more sophisticated the more likely to be aware. I refute this.


I'm beginning to suspect that you're just doing this to tease me. I thought you just defined consciousness as self awareness. so consciousness is awareness but in specialised form. what difference does it make whether I was there talking about broad awareness or just consciousness?


Bodily processes and states can be inspected by external observations. Thus a person’s bodily life is as much a public affair as are the lives of animals. But minds do not exist in space, nor are their operation subject to mechanical laws. The workings of the mind are not witnessable by other observers; its career is private. A person therefore lives through two collateral histories: one consisting of what happens to and with the body (public); the other consisting of what happens to and in the mind (private).



It's either an argument to prove (demonstrate) your awareness and you are capable of presenting such an argument, or it's not.


Then please present them, for God's sake. Demonstrate to me that you are an aware being. Demonstrate to me how you will prove that a clever AI is an aware being.
KAG: Second, looking through the thread, it's certain that I have been getting what you've been saying, so alluding to not getting your point is bizzare.


What? No. For crying out loud, I even gave an indication of its level in my brief explanation of what I mean by awareness. Here: "It is cognizance at a most basic level."



I said consciousness implies self-awareness, but I guess that's semantics at this point of the discussion. In any case, consciousness and awareness should not be conflated. Awareness, like I indicated is a basic form of cognizance and may be simply conceived as a realisation of a happening. Consciousness is different. Further, one can be demonstrated over the internet, the other can't.



Sure. To claim that an entity is aware, the entity has to realise that something is happening, .i.e. know in itself about an occurence, then that realisation is what causes a reaction.



Proof is for maths and alcohol. I see where the confusion lays on this particular point. I wasn't trying to prove as science doesn't do proof, so mypointing out that it wasn't an attempt to prove, caused confusion.

Anyway, I have made the arguments for awareness and it demonstrates itself.

The experience isn's subjective as a demonstration of the factors that implicate awareness are presentable


A part of my definition of being is awareness towards; and awareness was defined as an ability to realise happenings

I later pointed out that: 'So, no, awareness is not a "totally subjective experience [that] cannot be communicated to another." You know I'm aware because I'm acknowledging your ideas, parsing them, and responding accordingly.'

A claim that's easily understandable, as I need to be aware to display those skills. I pointed that out when I wrote: "To acknowledge something as complex and abstract as the factors in your arguments, then to parse those ideas and appropriate them and then respond accordingly, is certainly indication of awareness."

Alas, "Just to be clear, no AI can do the same at this point in time."
Pastor AIO: O boy, let's just leave it. I don tire.
Christianity Etc › Re: You Have 1 New Nairaland PM. Plz check ur e-mail by PastorAIO: 12:02am On Jul 15, 2012
I think PM must mean Prime Minister and not Private message.
Christianity Etc › Re: Davidylan Says Sorry by PastorAIO: 12:13pm On Jul 14, 2012
Davidylan I dey your back paparapa. You know that you've been one of the people I've had the most issues with on this NL forum, but for this gesture alone I am ready to become your best friend.

Whether it is delirium or not doesn't matter as long as the intent is sincere. Of course we are not perfect and there will always be a tendency to backslide into old ways, I know that as a fact from my own personal history, but with sincere intent I believe we can all grow. Even if we backslide sef, the important thing is that we recognise it quick and pick ourselves back up and onto the path again. So there is nothing wrong with backsliding, only with persisting in the backsliding.
Christianity Etc › Re: Best Religion Forum Topics by PastorAIO:
This is my new favouritest thread on Nairaland:
https://www.nairaland.com/989490/davidylan-says-sorry

I hope it doesn't degenerate to yabis.

We could be on the cusp of a new era on Nairaland.
Christianity Etc › IF Anybody Is Pm-ing Me . . . by PastorAIO(op): 11:57am On Jul 14, 2012
Please if anybody is PM-ing me cos they've got something to share with me, I have to inform you that I'm not receiving anything in my email accounts. I keep getting alerts that I have Nairaland PMs, but there is nothing in my personal email accounts.

I would suggest also that we had Private message sections on our profiles like on other forums, or even Facebook sef. Good idea, no?
Christianity Etc › Re: Cannibalization Of Muslims In Jos On Video: Where Is Our Humanity? by PastorAIO: 12:18pm On Jul 13, 2012
-Since there is a God then what he decrees is what is Good
He decreed to me that we should be loving and kind.

CHOMP!!

- Well, he decreed to me that I should eat you.
Christianity Etc › Re: Cannibalization Of Muslims In Jos On Video: Where Is Our Humanity? by PastorAIO: 11:43am On Jul 13, 2012
MyJoe: Carnibalism as a cultural practice has existed among tribes from ancient times in every continent of the world[b], [size=14pt]with the possible exception of Europe[/size][/b]. Unfortunately, this practice has survived into modern times in some places, including parts of Nigeria. The Berom are probably one of such tribes.

The practice varies from place to place. Somewhere, only enemies killed in war are eaten. Elsewhere, criminals are edible. At other places, any lost stranger would do just fine. Characterising this as Christians eating Moslems may be somewhat misleading. But it is understandable since the Berom are mostly Christian and the Hausa/Fulani are mostly Moslem.
Europe is not excepted o! It was part of the campaign to oust muslims from the Holy Land.


Radulph of Caen, an eyewitness to events at Ma'arra in 1098, wrote, "In Ma'arra our troops boiled pagan adults in cooking-pots; they impaled children on spits and devoured them grilled." (1)

The chronicler Albert of Aix seemed to rank Muslims lower than dogs when he wrote, "Not only did our troops not shrink from eating dead Turks and Saracens; they also ate dogs!"

Guibert of Nogent, in his work Historia Hierosolymitana, provides more details on the incident of cannibalism at Ma'arra. There he notes that whenever the Tafurs who took part in the expedition discovered "scraps of flesh from the pagan's bodies" cannibalism was practiced with little discretion. According to Guibert, the Tafurs were well aware that the Muslims feared them because of cannibalism. For that reason, on at least one occasion, the Tafurs publicly "roasted the bruised body of a Turk over a fire as if it were meat for eating, in full view of the Turkish forces." Guibert notes that the Franks also practiced cannibalism, but they did so "in secret and as rarely as possible.
http://www.crusades-encyclopedia.com/cannibalism.html
Christianity Etc › Re: Do Not Waste Time On Unholy People by PastorAIO: 11:27am On Jul 13, 2012
Too slow. I've already watched it. First thing I did after watching the clip above.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8l-onGQxICQ
Christianity Etc › Re: Do Not Waste Time On Unholy People by PastorAIO: 6:39am On Jul 13, 2012
MacDaddy01: The op is the kind of christian that can not live with people of other faiths/religion/



https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bOpva_iit-8
Wow! "They'll be on my prayer list to the day I die. Everyone of them, I speak that into existence. Everyone of them, I planted that seed and I will see the harvest".

ostensibly lovely words but it's amazing how she says it like a threat. A very vicious threat.
Christianity Etc › Re: RAPTURE: Why The Left-behind Theology Should Be Left Behind by PastorAIO: 6:23pm On Jul 11, 2012
As regards Pips V. T-. Abeg no expose, cos privacy is key to a man's peace of mind. There are things that mustn't mix in this world or the mix will be explosive. Like saltpetre and fire. you keep em separate.

That is my own contribution to Rapture sha.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Sun On The Cross: Astrononomy, Astrology And Religion by PastorAIO: 6:07pm On Jul 11, 2012
jantavanta: Aquarius (The water bearer): The Baptism by John the Baptist
Pisces (The Fish): Follow me, I will make you fishers of men

More examples will come later.
Aquarius and John the baptist are very tenuous. You should try looking into the myth of Ganymede, and also the Flood. Noah, and Deucalion, or Utnapishtim.

Please I look forward to more examples.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Sun On The Cross: Astrononomy, Astrology And Religion by PastorAIO: 6:01pm On Jul 11, 2012
jantavanta: Precession of the Equinox: The Lamb of God and Fishers of Men

Every approximately 2,135 years, the point of Vernal Equinox shifts as a result of the precession of the equinox.
This shift is expressed in religious texts. For example the era of Christianity was symbolized by the fish. The early Christians
were known as People of the Fish because the point of vernal equinox had shifted from Aries to Pisces.

In the celebration of Ramadan, the slaughtering of the Ram is also symbolic of the movement from the age of Aries (The Ram)
to the age of Pisces (The fish).

https://www.shiftoftheage.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/precession-image.gif?w=291
I hear you about the precession. The christians used Ichtus as a symbol, but since the precession is a global phenomenon how comes there is no other cult or movement of the period that used the fish symbolism too. Only Christianity. Or was it only christians that knew about the precession. Now if you come come up with a reference to fish symbolism in another culture around the same time that would really strengthen your argument.

But as for the Ramadan part, you are on thin ice there. For a start Islam started in 7th century CE long after the age of Pisces had been established. secondly, shouldn't they be sacrificing fish rather than rams, considering that rams belong to the previous age.

Perhaps if you delved into prehistory you might find examples of the precession away from Taurus into Aries and how that affected their cultural and religious symbolisms.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 (of 287 pages)