PastorAIO's Posts
Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 (of 287 pages)
OlaAjia: I had hoped we might both be able to reason things out logically, but it is clear this doesn't interest you so good day to you too.There is no such thing as reasoning things out logically in this Religion section of Nairaland. It is always awful to have your hopes dashed but the sooner we wake up to the reality on the ground then the sooner we are no longer living in 'delusion', cos that would be the delusion if there was any delusion at all. |
That What is Intelligence thread is closely connected (in my mind at least) with this one: https://www.nairaland.com/238976/learning-critical-thinking-skills-some/1#3534636 Unfortunately Huxley was being extremely cagey and defensive so we couldn't fully explore some of the issues in it. And I was also sorely aggrieved when it got moved out of the Religion section into some wasteland called the general section despite the fact that neither Huxley nor myself ever posted outside of the religion section and the topic though not religion itself was very pertinent to religion and the Atheists' criticism of religion. Actually . . . while we're on the topic, may I request for the thread to be moved back here to the Religion section. Please. Pretty please. Pretty please with icing sprinkled on top. |
MyJoe: This one is not strictly religion, but it's one of my favs:Wow! I've just read this one again. It kinda ends on a cliff hanger. There are so many interesting tangents that could have emerged each deserving a thread of it's own. There really was a golden age of Nairaland Religion section. What happened?? |
At least the Witnesses stand by what they believe. They live by it and die by it. Some other people will preach something from the rooftop but when push comes to shove they will compromise it, not even to stay alive but merely to become rich. |
OLAADEGBU: A fool, according to Psalm 14:1, is an atheist.What do you think about the subsequent 2 verses of that psalm: 2 The Lord looked down from heaven upon the children of men, to see if there were any that did understand, and seek God. 3 They are all gone aside, they are all together become filthy: there is[b] none[/b] that doeth good, no, not one. Are we all atheists? Certainly not all professing atheists, however we all behave and conduct our lives as if there is NO God watching us. Our professing of Atheism is not with the mouth ,but worse still, with our actions. |
italo: @ Pastor AIO, are you Catholic? If not what's your creed?No, I'm not a signed up member of the Catholic church establishment, I'm Church of England, but I have an interest in the entirety of man's religious experience and expression of this religious experience. I've developed a lot of resentment over the years towards people who try to denigrate other people's beliefs especially when they are also being hypocritical and not applying the same stringent criteria on their own beliefs that they use on others. This is probably why I seem to come into threads on the side of Roman Catholics, as well as the fact that I think C of E is not part of the catholic Church due to an accident of History rather than due to any real ideological differences. However I also like to downplay the membership of any establishment as a part of religion. I think religion is a lot deeper than that. |
frosbel: I concur, because he used Jewish tradition, culture and terminology to explain the scriptures.What were these aspects of jewish tradition, culture and terminology that he used and that no pagan would have been able to understand? |
seeklove: @ Pastor AIOI stand by the 'unsentimental' and add that far from making them bad it is what gives them their strength in ways that the British don't have. seeklove: I don't know your level of education but your ignorance is astunding! Germany exsisted even during the time of the roman empire. I think the romans refered to them as Gull. Read Julius Ceacer's "gullic wars". The German empire was formed in 18 January 1871. They became a republic in 23 May 1949. But before the empire, Germany had been in exisitance for decades of years. I repeat, Germany is older than America which was born in July 4, 1776. America got their indepence from Great Britain. Germany got their indepence from the roman empire, just like Great Britain. At first they were called the Holy Roman empire, which was formed in 962. Pastor AIO: I believe that the Holy Roman Empire is not Germany. In fact the Holy Roman Empire still exists today and it is called Austria. Before then it was a massive empire that covered most of western Europe and was created by a guy call Charlemagne. The Gauls were a tribe in Europe that spread from France to parts of Germany. HRE (holy roman empire) was set up by Charlemagne who was a Frank. The Franks were another tribe that lived in France (guess were the name France comes from) and what is today called Germany. Europe was full of so many different tribes. To call any of them the German nation sounds ludicrous to me, but then as you say, my 'ignorance is astunding!'. Perhaps it was just out-stunned -ed.Seeklove and I posted some historical inaccuracies there. Charlemagne was crowned Holy Roman Emperor on christmas day 800AD not in the 10th century like I said. Germany, or more accurately, the lands beyond the Rhine river and the Danube river was never under the rule of the roman empire. This was called the land of the Barbarians and was inhabited by savage germanic tribes. These peoples poured westward into the Roman empire after it weakened and could no longer keep them out. That brought about the end of the western Roman empire. Gaul, present day France, was within the Roman empire as was Britain (up to Hadrian's wall). Quite rightly Julius Caesar conquered Gaul and made it part of Roman empire. |
seeklove: @ Pastor AIOI stand by the 'unsentimental' and add that far from making them bad it is what gives them their strength in ways that the British don't have. seeklove: I don't know your level of education but your ignorance is astunding! Germany exsisted even during the time of the roman empire. I think the romans refered to them as Gull. Read Julius Ceacer's "gullic wars". The German empire was formed in 18 January 1871. They became a republic in 23 May 1949. But before the empire, Germany had been in exisitance for decades of years. I repeat, Germany is older than America which was born in July 4, 1776. America got their indepence from Great Britain. Germany got their indepence from the roman empire, just like Great Britain. At first they were called the Holy Roman empire, which was formed in 962. Pastor AIO: I believe that the Holy Roman Empire is not Germany. In fact the Holy Roman Empire still exists today and it is called Austria. Before then it was a massive empire that covered most of western Europe and was created by a guy call Charlemagne. The Gauls were a tribe in Europe that spread from France to parts of Germany. HRE (holy roman empire) was set up by Charlemagne who was a Frank. The Franks were another tribe that lived in France (guess were the name France comes from) and what is today called Germany. Europe was full of so many different tribes. To call any of them the German nation sounds ludicrous to me, but then as you say, my 'ignorance is astunding!'. Perhaps it was just out-stunned -ed.Seeklove and I posted some historical inaccuracies there. Charlemagne was crowned Holy Roman Emperor on christmas day 800AD not in the 10th century like I said. Germany, or more accurately, the lands beyond the Rhine river and the Danube river was never under the rule of the roman empire. This was called the land of the Barbarians and was inhabited by savage germanic tribes. These peoples poured westward into the Roman empire after it weakened and could no longer keep them out. That brought about the end of the western Roman empire. Gaul, present day France, was within the Roman empire as was Britain (up to Hadrian's wall). Quite rightly Julius Caesar conquered Gaul and made it part of Roman empire. |
Funny, after some months of growing, learning, and reflections, I find myself coming closer to Justcool's position. While I wouldn't quite say that German people are spiritually superior to others, I would say that they are CULTURALLY superior to some others. But no, that doesn't really convey what I mean. I would say rather that German culture is Younger, more vigorous than the other european cultures which are older and more decrepit. I do think that there is a connection between culture and a people's spiritual condition. I also believe that cultures go through a process whereby they start of young and full of vigour and creativity and then end up bankrupt of meaning and impetus after they become old. (I believe a lot of west african cultures are in that decrepit stage and have been for a few centuries). I believe the key is not genetic but cultural and that it is culture that shapes a People and not their genes. The very things that I said that seemed to be an attack on the German manner are actually products of that youthfulness. The brashness, the competitiveness etc. Other writers had noticed it before. I believe Nietzsche referred to it a lot. (at least in my understanding of Nietzsche. ) |
I find it weird that it is called the letter to the Hebrews. Were there any people or church in those days known as the Hebrews? Where were they? In Israel? Or some other part of the Roman Empire? We know that the letter to the Romans was written to christians in rome, the letter to the Galatians was written to christians in Galatia etc etc. Who exactly was the letter to the Hebrews written to? |
Kay 17: It wouldn't spoil anything if humanism is considered a religion, with a faith of hope and a better world. But its best represented as a philosophy.That too would depend on what we mean by philosophy. Is every thought that a man can think his 'philosophy'? |
This Psalm 14 matter is really paining me o!!! It is not so much about avowed atheists but rather about hypocrites that say in their HEARTS that there is no god. you can say in your heart that there is no God yet blast out praises to God with your mouth for all to hear. Yet what is in your heart will manifest in your behaviour. If you practice corruption and various crimes then in spite of your open declaration of God, obviously in your heart you don't believe he exists. That is what makes you a FOOL. The corrupt man, whether he professes religion or not, is a FOOL. 4 Have all the workers of iniquity no knowledge? who eat up my people as they eat bread, and call not upon the Lord.The entire psalm just reminds me of our leaders, religious and secular, in Nigeria. If our leaders are Fools, then that must make us even bigger fools. But all that is tangential to this topic. In this profile of Hatetheist can we please, OP, try to draw up an understanding of why atheists are behaving the way they do and why there has been a increase in the vocal expression of atheism and, worse still, anti-christianity in the last 10 years. |
thehomer: Hmm I see. In that case, what are currently called religions may as well be called "movements" or "ideologies" or something along those lines. And those who follow them no matter their devotion will have no special exemptions.. . . in the case of special exemptions being removed from religions, or any other 'movements' or 'ideologies', the answer would be Yes. |
I don't know why my post was deleted. Maybe because I put the link. Let me do it again without the links. The book the quotes come from is The Vision of Arda Ardaf, a zoroastrian book from Persia. 18. And there stood before him his own religion and his own deeds, in the graceful form of a damsel, as a beautiful appearance, that is, grown up in virtue; (19) with prominent breasts, that is, her breasts swelled downward, which is charming to the heart and soul; (20) whose form was as brilliant, as the sight of it was the more well-pleasing, the observation of it more desirable. 21. And the soul of the pious asked that damsel (22) thus: 'Who art thou? and what person art thou? than whom, in the world of the living, any damsel more elegant, and of more beautiful body than thine, was never seen by me.' 23. To him replied she who was his own religion and his own deeds, (24) thus: 'I am thy actions, O youth of good thoughts, of good words, of good deeds, of good religion. (25) It is on account of thy will and actions that I am as great and good and sweet-scented and triumphant and undistressed as appears to thee. (26) For in the world the Gathas were chanted by thee, and the good water was consecrated by thee, and the fire tended by thee; (27) and the pious man who came from far, and who was from near, was honored by thee. (28) Though I have been stout, I am made stouter through thee; (29) and though I have been virtuous, I am made more virtuous through thee; (30) and though I have been worthy, I am made more worthy through thee; (31) and though I have been seated on a resplendent throne, I am seated more resplendently through thee; (32) and though I have been exalted, I am made more exalted through thee; (33) through these good thoughts and good words and good deeds which thou practicedst. (34) They honored thee, and the pious man after thee, (35) in that long worship and communion with Ohrmazd, when thou performedst, for Ohrmazd, worship and proper conversation for a long time. (36) Peace be from it.' (12) And in that wind he saw[b] his own religion and deeds as a profligate woman,[/b] naked, decayed, gapping, bandy-legged, lean-hipped, and unlimitedly spotted so that spot was joined to spot, like the most hideous, noxious creature (khrafstar), most filthy and most stinking. 13. Then that wicked soul spoke thus: 'Who art thou, than whom I never saw any one of the creatures of Ohrmazd and Ahriman uglier, or filthier, or more stinking?' 14. To him she spoke thus: 'I am thy bad actions, O youth of evil thoughts, of evil words, of evil deeds, of evil religion. (15) It is on account of thy will and actions that I am hideous and vile, iniquitous and diseased, rotten and foul-smelling, unfortunate and distressed, as appears to thee. (16) When thou sawest any one who performed the Yazishn and Dron ceremonies, and praise and prayer and the service of God; (17) and preserved and protected water and fire, cattle and trees, and other good creations; (18) thou practicedst the will of Ahriman and the demons, and improper actions. (19) And when thou sawest one who provided hospitable reception, and gave something deservedly in gifts and charity, for the advantage of the good and worthy who came from far, and who were from near; (20) thou wast avaricious, and shuttedst up thy door. (21) And though I have been unholy, I am made more unholy through thee; (22) and though I have been frightful, I am made more frightful through thee; (23) though I have been tremulous, I am made more tremulous through thee; (24) though I am settled in the northern region of the demons, I am settled farther north through thee; (25) through these evil thoughts, and through these evil words, and through these evil deeds, which thou practisedst. (26) They curse me, a long time, in the long execration and evil communion of the Evil spirit.' 27. Afterward, that soul of the wicked advanced the first footstep on Dush-humat and the second footstep on Dush-hukt, and the third on Dush-huvarsht; and with the fourth footstep he ran to hell. Anyone that wants to look these up further should just google the Book of Arda Viraf. |
tpiah: pretty general statement.Actually I meant all orthodox churches. Both the Eastern Orthodox churches and the Roman catholic church. |
thehomer: I don't think the word "religion" is what makes it able to cause harm, I think that lies more with the tenets of the religion and the sorts of leaders that arise in them and of course the sort of society they find themselves in.One way in which it can cause harm is by pulling a screen of untouchability over many nefarious and criminal behaviours. Con men fleece the naive and do it tax free all under the banner of religion. All manner of nasty things are tolerated once they are under the banner of religion. Once we recognise religion as meaning just any belief that one adheres to strongly then all ideologies will be able to be exploited commercially without having to pay tax. They will be able to make race hate, and other minority hate, statements respectfully. Nazism as a religion would get away with so much more. That 'very broad category' is exactly what is needed for the classification and subsequent reduction of religion to meaninglessness. |
Excellent OP!! |
2good: Atheism is not a religion but a lack of belief in religion!That totally depends on what you mean by religion. If religion merely means a belief that you hold strongly then the world is full of more religions than are accounted for. A lot more, probably more than we can actually count, considering that new religions are being formed every minute. And Atheism would be one of them. However if Religion is a PRACTICE, an activity, whose aim is to bring harmony to the life of the practitioner, then that is a different kettle of fish altogether . . . . |
thehomer: This makes no sense. Is a successful free speech campaigner a religious free speech campaigner? How about a successful conservative? Is that person a religious conservative? You see, when such concepts of religion are used, they simply destroy the meaning of the word "religion".Perhaps it would be a good thing if the meaning of the word 'religion' were destroyed completely. At the moment it is only partially meaningless which is an extremely dangerous way to be. Once it is totally meaningless it loses a great deal of it's ability to cause harm. I think that it is good that all words constantly undergo change in their connotations and denotations. |
Enigma: Oh just in the way you avoided this post of mine (and others elsewhere) like the plague?I read it but I didn't realise that a response was required. I felt you'd made your point and I got what you were saying. Anyway, welcome to this thread. |
Deep Sight: ^^^ No, please see the bolded in red: that is where they defined it and that definition refers for the other instances of the usage of the word -As indeed the example of "the service and worship of God or the supernatural" does not qualify many religions. Most notable of which is Buddhism. And even in the case of the red bolded the many ways in which the God is served and worshiped have similarities such as the sacrifice of victims, and prayer. |
Deep Sight: No, because in def. 1 it gave a def without using the word "religion" so that when the word is used in subsequent defs, then you can refer to def 1 for what the word means.1 a: the state of a religious <a nun in her 20th year of religion> b (1): the service and worship of God or the supernatural (2): commitment or devotion to religious faith or observance Deep Sight: That is impossible because there are almost infinite practices and infinite differences. Don't let Enigma catch you there.In spite of infinitude there are certain practices that are found in almost all religions. ie. Sacrifices, fasting, prayer etc etc etc. It is possible to draw general lines around what religions involve. I have a funny feeling that Enigma won't turn up here, in fact he'll avoid it like the plague. |
Deep Sight: Why dont we just stick with the dictionary -For a number of reasons. It does not tell us anything about defining PRACTICES of religion. I am keen to know what practices religions have in common and why they practice them, and also where and how they differ. Secondly, the dictionary is defining religion in a loop. Ques: What is a religion? Ans: A religion is something that deals with religious things. Any definition of religion that needs to use the word 'religious' is a poor definition. Thirdly, . . . . hmmmm . . there was a thirdly but it has escaped my mind. I'll be back . . . |
[quote author=izi-n-bizi]Let him that hath ears listen and heed the beckon of Spirit. Mankind is evloving towards Spirituality and only those that are prepared will be delivered during the intense period of Spiritual starvation and extreme religious aggression, those times are near - Discover your essence for yourself.[/quote]Funnily, I heard differently just yesterday. I heard that Mankind was evolving towards Atheism. logicboy: However, religion does become toxic because hostility towards non-members arises. We have seen slavery and genocide of unbelievers. Human beings have now evolved or are evolving away from religion. The world is so interconnected that we do not need local religions appreciate/understan the importance of a co-operative effort in creating a better world for human survival or the survival of the human race.https://www.nairaland.com/934680/hive-psychology-origins-morality-religion#10792910 |
The reason that I'm bringing this thread up again is in order to re-ignite a conversation as to what makes something a religion. What is the definition of a religion? What are it's most salient characteristics? It think discussing this will be very helpful for a lot of people. |
MyJoe: True, Deep Sight, but it is, or can be, a little more complicated. I have not the energy to go into it right now, but a doctor of Ayuverdic medicine will tell you that garlic and onions may be good for you but bad for someone else. I don't go near garlic and onions, for instance, because I have GI and duodenal complications. The Ayuverdic doctor will assume we require different stuff to balance our humours. But that is not given. So the doctor would advice us both to take a test to determine what is good for us to eat. It's called dosha.Indeed, I think that what is good for one person is not necessarily good for someone else. In Ayurvedic medicines and other alternative forms of medicine what they first do is determine the constitution of the patient. And then they prescribe foods and medicines that help sustain and support that constitution. Thus a person that is naturally very Kapha will only eat those things that agree with and support Kapha, while a Pitta patient would have to undergo a totally different diet. Similarly in many religions in the world there are various taboos associated with various deities. In Yoruba Orisha cults for instance devotees of Obatala cannot drink alcohol, while devotees of Ogun will drink a lot and it won't upset their constitution. All the objects and foods that a deity favours for sacrifice are also permitted for it's devotees to consume. The deities taboos are also the devotees taboos. Almost every religious cult has food taboos and tabooed activities. |
Enigma: ^^^ Go and read the John Gray piece; when you understand it come and tell us what you get from it.You know full well that I am Not going to read the John Gray piece. My interest is in the part you quoted in order to buttress your point that Atheism IS a religion. Is belonging or being grouped with religion in some particulars the same as being a religion? That was my simple question for which I asked for a simple answer. Yoruba says that try as you might to group Adiye and Eyele together the fact is that chicken cannot fly like pigeon. Don't let the chicken's wings deceive you. Is Atheism a religion? why? I think a lot of this depends on what we understand as a religion. What are the essential characteristics of a religion? What does it seek to do or achieve? Any failure to address this definition will have everybody going round and around trying to say that something is or is not an ill-defined or vague, if not nonsensical activity. So a guy claims that his religion, Atheism, is being restricted. Is this guy the authority to what is or is not a religion? The court treats his case differently which is considered an error cos . . . . The problem with the district court’s analysis is that[b] the court failed to recognize that Kaufman was trying to start a “religious” group[/b], in the sense we discussed earlier.Does that mean that the court that passed the judgment did not consider atheism a religion? But as Logicboy says . . . logicboy01: The Kaufman vs McCaughty case doesnt not make atheism a religion. The court (in the case) only declared that atheism gets equal protection as religions under first ammendment issues.Ultimately it seems that Atheism is a religion because a prison inmate says so. Please I believe that we need to establish a definition of religion for the purposes of this thread. |
Let me add some small spice to proceedings: go4value: @op...........christianity,is neither a religion or a group........IT IS A WAY OF LIFE.except a man is born of God n Holyspirit,he cannot enter into d kingdom of God.https://www.nairaland.com/964686/christianity-religion-group-what#11119821 |
Enigma: If anyone wants to show Communism, murder etc to be a religion, I will read quite happily.This is not what I asked you. You quoted John Gray . . . Enigma: Something for the road --- just before I change my 'signature'.I presumed that you were using John Gray to buttress your point cos you agreed with him. So I ask you, is 'belonging' with a religion mean that something is a religion itself? A simple yes or no answer will suffice. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 (of 287 pages)

