Christianity Etc › Re: Does He Answer Prayers Too? by PastorAIO: 5:07pm On May 28, 2011 |
Zodiac61: I notice that none of the godbots has answered what is a really simple question And whilst you godists are struggling with that question, answer this one as well, "Why doesn't God heal amputees?" And this one as well "Why do christians die in car crashes, air crashes, of cancer and other illnesses?" I don't know about the others but those who die in car crashes and air crashes have definitely offended Ogun. Them suppose don give Ogun something. A couple of puppy dogs and plenty plenty palm oil. finito. No more accident lai lai. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Ten False Doctrines Of The Roman Catholic Church by PastorAIO: 2:38pm On May 28, 2011 |
I found this post I made years ago about a brief history of christianity. It goes into the institutionalisation of christianity as the imperial religion and also into the formation of some of it's core doctrines. This is a very interesting debate. I would like to offer a brief overview of the history of christianity.
From the very start it would appear that there were numerous group following Jesus which were not even aware of themselves. There is the instance in the gospels where the disciples come across a group preaching Christ. They tried to stop these guys. 'what right had they'? They reported this to Jesus and to their shock this group had Jesus' approval.
By the time of Paul's mission there were yet again evidence of many different christian movements. In Galatians chapter 1 vs 6 Paul is warning his followers against following another gospel. There were the ultra Jewish christians who did not see christianity as a religion for non jews. The divisions were mostly doctrinal and none were so prone to doctrinal deviance as the gnostics. The gnostics in fact put little importance in doctrine and emphasised rather the experience of christ. Consequently they felt free to adopt and invent doctrines as they felt would be most useful to their practice. This was the beginning of a centuries long conflict. Those that insisted on the importance of doctrine went to great pains to establish what they believed, and what concepts were acceptable. They called themselves the Orthodox christians. Orthodox means Right Thinking. To be orthodox you had to accept the 'Right' doctrine. Opposed to them were those who said that the direct experience of Christ and the holy spirit was what matter no the terminology and concepts that you formed to understand it. They felt free to experiment with doctrines and 'invent myths', as one of the church fathers put it.
One of the Orthodox bishops was Irenaeus of Lyon. To restrict the number of ideas going around he suggested that there should only be 4 orthodox gospels. The bible hadn't been compiled yet at this point. He began a campaign to ban other gospels and unorthodox writings. When Emperor Constantine made christianity the Roman state religion he established the orthodox bishops as the leaders and thus began a pogrom against the greater part of christianity which were gnostics or other doctrinal christians whose doctrines just happened to be considered Unorthodox by those in power. In fact many contemporary accounts state that when the christian bishops took over the previously pagan temples and offices what was most notable about them was the greed and avarice with which they went for the material wealth and political power.
Inspite of mass genocide against the majority of christians who were not considered orthodox (in other words their thinking wasn't right.) the church could still not unite under one doctrine that everybody accepted. Those christians that were not politically powerful were just killed off. There were 3 main centers of orthodox christianity that were to powerful to wage pogroms against themselves and so the differences were settled by church councils.
These 3 great parties were 1. The Church in Egypt, based in Alexandria. These were headed in turn by first Bishop Cyril and then Bishop Dioscurus. Cyril was canonised and is now Saint Cyril while Dioscurus was declared an heretic (heretic is basically someone who thinking isn't right. unorthodox, in other words they have a different opinion from you). The funny thing is that Cyris and Dioscurus said exactly the same thing. Namely that Jesus Christ was God. He was divine.
2. the second party was the Church in Antioch headed by Nestorius. They stressed the humanity of christ. Jesus was a human being. Nestor was eventually charged with heresy but his beliefs persisted throughout the history of christianity.
3. The third party was the church in Rome. The pope was concerned with getting a bit of respect as the descendant of Peter and therefore the Rock on which the church was to be founded. However he was just getting ignored. For a start Christianity was biggest in the middle east and eastern europe. And secondly because world affairs were centered in asia the Emperor constantine had actually moved his capital away from Rome and set up in Constantinople which is in modern day Turkey. So basically there was nothing going on in Rome and nobody was taking notice of that Pope guy.
Of course the problem with doctrine and doctrinal faiths is that no two people in the whole world can think the same thing or have exactly the same opinion on anything. subsequently the harder one tries to impose an orthodoxy the more heretics will keep popping up until you have slaughtered half your congregation.
When Nestor became bishop of Constantinople as an Antioch christian he insisted that Jesus was human. The argument started from the proposition that if all men are sinners and christ was not a sinner then Christ could not have been a man. The antioch guys countered this by saying that where there is a human soul in most men in Jesus was the Logos. Since the human soul is created in the image of the Logos it therefore follows that Christ was even more human than us because we have the copy while he is the original. What upset Nestor the most was the suggestion that the Virgin Mary could be considered the mother of God (theotokos in latin). His words apparently were,' I cannot speak of God as being two or three months old . . . Well, anyhow, don't make the virgin a goddess!".
Meanwhile Bishop Cyril of Alexandria together with the pope Clement l supported the idea of theotokos (mother of God). A synod was called in Rome where Nestor was denounced. Again in Alexandria he was denounced. As they were denouncing him in Rome and Alexandria he too was denouncing them in Constantinople. The yabis was flying back a forth all parties quoting scriptures at each other (nothing as changed much in 1500 years as you guys are still doing the same thing here on nairaland).
When the Emperor began to have enough of all the bickering (emperor Theodosius II) he called a council in Ephesus in the year 431 and told them to sort it out. It was at this council that once and for all the Virgin was declared to be Theotokos (mother of God). Nestor was condemned although he condemned them back one last time before he was removed from his post as bishop. He was eventually murdered by a monk in the egyptian desert. Cyril was made a saint and when he died his place was taken by Dioscurus. In rome the pope was now Pope Leo the Great, the first pope to be taken seriously. That was when some guy suggested a solution that Jesus in fact had two natures. He was divine and human. Pope leo denounced him. Theodosius called another council to sort it out. That was when Leo started making strong claims that if there are any councils they should be held in Rome. He was still getting ignored despite his writing letters to everyone that mattered. Slowly he was getting friends in high places. The council was held in Ephesus again and the guy was vindicated and it was accepted that Jesus had two natures.
When Theodosius died Pulcheria became the empress and she was better disposed towards the pope. They called another council and these time the poor guy was denounced. Not only that but Pope Leo made quick moves to banish Dioscurus from his see and he was declared heretic. That is how Cyril is a saint but his successor Dioscurus who had the same views is today a heretic. As a result of Banishing Dioscurus the Coptic orthodox church broke away and started appointing it's own bishops independent of the empire. Eventually orthodox christianity would split with Rome taking over western europe and eastern europe comprising of various orthodox churches from Greek orthodox to Russian orthodox.
This is getting long. I will continue part two at a later date. I hope you all find this informative. https://www.nairaland.com/nigeria?topic=127656.msg2165126#msg2165126I never got to do part 2. I think the catholics came down on my backside with such an onslaught that there was no longer any point. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Why Do U Love God by PastorAIO: 12:24pm On May 28, 2011 |
Pastor AIO: Yes lol, I can't think of any act that is more highly incentivised than the christians love of Gold.  When I read this I can understand why people were certain that I was an atheist when I first joined NL. I still doubt that many have actually felt the welling up of Love within them towards God and the world, but rather what they do is profess love and other such rhetoric because they hope to get a reward from it. Most 'christian' behaviour has incentives and is not a spontaneous act from their hearts. Anyway, I think this is a great topic and I would like to know from current NL contributors 'Why Do you Love God'? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Ten False Doctrines Of The Roman Catholic Church by PastorAIO: 11:30am On May 28, 2011 |
And for more unbiblical doctrines we mustn't forget the Doctrine of Trinity. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Ten False Doctrines Of The Roman Catholic Church by PastorAIO: 11:29am On May 28, 2011 |
I think this thread is quite interesting: https://www.nairaland.com/nigeria/topic-5922.224.html#msg2110455Read it through. Lady's contribution is interesting too about whether Mary was ever called Mother of God in the bible. The stance of the Protestants is that never was she called "MOTHER OF GOD" this is infact true. But let's also keep in mind that never did Jesus call himself GOD. The thread also has some nice side dishes served up by Pilgrim and Olabowale on Islam. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Good Occult Fraternities by PastorAIO: 6:06pm On May 27, 2011 |
I won't talk now because if I do it will just come across as if I am fighting against christianity. So I'll leave it. But the name of the book is the History of the Yorubas and it was written by Rev'd Samuel Johnson. Actually it was written by his son from his notes. The copy that he had written and sent to London ( the book was commissioned by the British Empire that wanted to document the history of the empire) was mysteriously lost when it got to London and that is why his son had to write another book from the notes he left over. Every now and again in the book we see flashes of Colonial mentality though all in all it is a great book. |
Christianity Etc › Re: How To Reap The Full Benefits Of Tithing by PastorAIO: 12:53pm On May 27, 2011 |
Joagbaje: 2 Corinthians 9:6 But this I say, He which soweth sparingly shall reap also sparingly; and he which soweth bountifully shall reap also bountifully.
Thank you for this advice, I was on my way to put some money on Man U to beat Barcelona tomorrow. I was wondering whether to just put a fiver or to put a tenner. I think I will now sow bountifully in order to reap bountifully, and by the grace of God I will not weep bountifully. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Power In Names by PastorAIO: 7:09pm On May 26, 2011 |
The Racist is a RAT. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Good Occult Fraternities by PastorAIO: 4:32pm On May 24, 2011 |
I found an interesting essay on the subject. It doesn't tally with my position but it is interesting all the same. I am also going to post a response to the essay that I thought was quite interesting too. Human Sacrifice in Ancient Canaan There is little doubt that many ancient Canaanite religions called for child sacrifice. The rites of both Chemosh of the Moabites and Molech of the Ammonites appear to have called for sacrifices by “passing through the fire.” This is generally understood to mean sacrifice by burning the victim to death.
Pretty gruesome and often offered by Apologists as a justification for the genocide the early Israelites were instructed by God to carry out on the Canaanite tribes. The more secular idea of refugees from civilized Egypt entering Canaan and being horrified by the practice works as an explanation too.
There’s only one problem. If the kingdoms of Israel and Judah actually emerged from the indigenous nomads of the highlands as Finkelstein and others propose, then there was no exodus from Egypt and there is no reason to assume the early Hebrew religious practices would be all that distinct from the surrounding cultures. One would expect to find that the early Israelites practiced child sacrifice as well as their neighbors. The question is whether, as we are led to believe by most interpretations, this was the result of the Israelites becoming enamored of foreign gods and adopting their rites or it was the result of internal priestly disagreements related to the proper worship of the Hebrew God himself. In other words, did early Israelites perform child sacrifices to YHWH as their neighbors did to Chemosh and Molech?
Exodus hints at the practice by talking about “redeeming” each first born male. In Kings, the Kings of Israel are repeatedly condemned for performing child sacrifice.
Exodus 13:2 Consecrate to me every firstborn male. The first offspring of every womb among the Israelites belongs to me, whether man or animal.
Rather a suggestive paragraph wouldn’t you say?
Exodus 13:13 Redeem with a lamb every firstborn donkey, but if you do not redeem it, break its neck. Redeem every firstborn among your sons.
I guess one could “redeem” a child the same way a donkey is redeemed, with a substitute lamb, but it’s interesting that it doesn’t specifically say that isn’t it? Then again, according to Numbers, it simply costs 5 shekels to redeem each firstborn son.
Exodus 13:14 In days to come, when your son asks you, 'What does this mean?' say to him, 'With a mighty hand the LORD brought us out of Egypt, out of the land of slavery. 15 When Pharaoh stubbornly refused to let us go, the LORD killed every firstborn in Egypt, both man and animal. This is why I sacrifice to the LORD the first male offspring of every womb and redeem each of my firstborn sons.'
Most Apologists would point out that either these paragraphs simply refer to dedicating the first born male to the service of God or that they refer to redeeming the first born with lamb’s blood as was done on the first Passover.
I don’t find the first explanation terribly compelling. Dedicated to God’s service in order to do what? The Levites were the priestly class weren’t they? If this was simply a call to dedicate the first born male to the service of God, then how come the practice isn’t referred to and expanded upon elsewhere?
The second explanation sounds much more likely and first born children would be redeemed with a substitute animal sacrifice. I wonder what happened if the family didn’t have an animal to substitute?
2 Kings 16:3 He (Ahaz) walked in the ways of the kings of Israel and even sacrificed his son in the fire, following the detestable ways of the nations the LORD had driven out before the Israelites.
2 Kings 17:17 They (the Israelites) sacrificed their sons and daughters in the fire.
The kings of Judah come in for similar criticism in this regard including Solomon.
1 Kings 11: 7 On a hill east of Jerusalem, Solomon built a high place for Chemosh the detestable god of Moab, and for Molech the detestable god of the Ammonites. 8 He did the same for all his foreign wives, who burned incense and offered sacrifices to their gods.
King Hezekiah and then Josiah, the guy with the white hat according to the Deuteronomistic History, take serious steps to put a stop to this practice. Unfortunately, their actions appear to get undone by the kings that follow them.
2 Kings 23:10 He (King Josiah) desecrated Topheth, which was in the Valley of Ben Hinnom, so no one could use it to sacrifice his son or daughter in the fire to Molech.
Josiah was not a man to trifle with. Undoubtedly cheered on by Jeremiah, he ripped down all the altars dedicated by past kings to foreign gods.
2 Kings 23:12 He pulled down the altars the kings of Judah had erected on the roof near the upper room of Ahaz, and the altars Manasseh had built in the two courts of the temple of the LORD. He removed them from there, smashed them to pieces and threw the rubble into the Kidron Valley. 13 The king also desecrated the high places that were east of Jerusalem on the south of the Hill of Corruption—the ones Solomon king of Israel had built for Ashtoreth the vile goddess of the Sidonians, for Chemosh the vile god of Moab, and for Molech the detestable god of the people of Ammon.
It sounds like the priests came off even worse than the altars.
2 Kings 23:20 Josiah slaughtered all the priests of those high places.
Josiah re-organizes how the Passover is celebrated.
2 Kings 23:21 The king gave this order to all the people: "Celebrate the Passover to the LORD your God, as it is written in this Book of the Covenant."
And what is this “Book of the Covenant?” Why it’s the book of laws fortuitously located by the High Priest Hilkiah in the Temple at Jerusalem. I say fortuitously because the book:
- Explained what the Israelites had been doing wrong and that got God all ticked off at them. - Explained how to improve the situation. - Established Judah’s ancient claim to the lands of the defunct northern kingdom of Israel
The book is of course Deuteronomy and the following historical books or at least the initial version of the histories. I find it a little strange that Josiah and company felt compelled to specify the Passover celebration.
Deuteronomy 16:2 Sacrifice as the Passover to the LORD your God an animal from your flock or herd at the place the LORD will choose as a dwelling for his Name.
The place is Jerusalem which pretty much puts the Kingdom of Judah, and Josiah himself, in the driver’s seat. It also guarantees that the Levite priests of Jerusalem would be the beneficiaries of the sacrifices.
Deuteronomy 6:20 In the future, when your son asks you, "What is the meaning of the stipulations, decrees and laws the LORD our God has commanded you?" 21 tell him: "We were slaves of Pharaoh in Egypt, but the LORD brought us out of Egypt with a mighty hand.”
Note the absence of any references to sacrificing the first male offspring, redeeming the first male or any references to the death of the first born of Egypt here as opposed to Exodus 13.
Josiah, Deuteronomy and the supporting histories make it pretty darn clear that human sacrifice will not be tolerated nor will any other rites associated with foreign gods. If Josiah was the driving force behind Deuteronomy, or even if he simply acquiesced to something being touted by Hilkiah and his son Jeremiah, the legal and religious reform that he brought about deserves to be considered one of the greatest influences on the western world and King Josiah deserves to be considered one of history’s greatest law givers up there with Hammurabi, Moses, and Solon.
Unfortunately, Josiah makes the mistake of stepping in front of an Egyptian arrow and it’s unlikely that he managed to fully root out the practice since both Jeremiah and Ezekiel have a few words to say about the topic as well.
Jeremiah 7:31 They have built the high places of Topheth in the Valley of Ben Hinnom to burn their sons and daughters in the fire—something I did not command, nor did it enter my mind.
I find it interesting that God has to specifically state that child sacrifice was “something I did not command” as late as the time of Jeremiah in the 7th century BCE.
Ezekiel 20:25 I also gave them (the Israelites) over to statutes that were not good and laws they could not live by; 26 I let them become defiled through their gifts—the sacrifice of every firstborn —that I might fill them with horror so they would know that I am the LORD.'
This is another one of those “suggestive passages.” One can spin it a number of ways but one has to wonder about paragraph 26 and exactly what is implied by God letting them become defiled through the sacrifice of every firstborn and why this would fill them with horror?
Ezekiel 20:31 When you offer your gifts—the sacrifice of your sons in the fire—you continue to defile yourselves with all your idols to this day.
This sort of implies that the practice was still going on around the time of the exile.
What I have never been able to understand is why so many of the kings of ancient Israel and Judah, at least according to the prevailing Biblical interpretation, fell into the habit of worshipping foreign gods. It seems like a pretty dumb thing to do. The cycle is obvious. The people fall into idolatry, God beats them over the head because of it, the people repent, God forgives them and restores their blessings and then the idiots immediately fall back into idolatry.
One has to suspect that this is the result of the cycle of success and failure that all nations and cultures experience. However, it usually takes something pretty major to turn a people away from their god. The first reaction is usually that the god is angry for some reason and needs to be appeased. This leads either directly to increased sacrifices or, if there is an ongoing debate between factions of the priesthood, a swing in which faction has the upper hand.
There certainly appears to have historically been some friction between the northern priesthood centered at Shiloh and the southern priesthood centered at Jerusalem. Allow me to speculate that the northern faction, in a more hospitable and more densely populated environment with more aggressive local neighbors, held to what they believed were the “old ways” which included the same child sacrifice as the other tribal religions, while the southern faction, in a much more sparsely populated environment, held the opinion that such rites were a perversion of the true worship of YHWH.
Since the north was the more powerful of the two kingdoms, its influence would tend to prevail and its theology would tend to dominate. After the fall of the northern kingdom, that influence would begin to wane but it would take a good while for it to disappear completely. If for no other reason than the strength of tradition, it might still hold sway unless strong liberal kings, like Hezekiah and Josiah, were on the throne of Judah.
I find it suggestive that the first great reform, that of Hezekiah, occurs right about the time of the fall of the northern kingdom. I also find it interesting that both reforms occurred during the period of influence of a great prophet. Isaiah was a contemporary of Hezekiah and Jeremiah was a contemporary of Josiah.
Upon the death of Hezekiah, Manasseh ascends to the throne of Judah. It’s a dangerous time. The northern kingdom has fallen and the king of Assyria is applying considerable pressure on Judah having even besieged Jerusalem during Hezekiah’s reign. Perhaps looking for a reversal of fortune, Manasseh undoes the reforms of Hezekiah.
2 Chronicle 33:2 He (Manasseh) did evil in the eyes of the LORD, following the detestable practices of the nations the LORD had driven out before the Israelites. 3 He rebuilt the high places his father Hezekiah had demolished.
2 Chronicles 33:6 He (Manasseh) sacrificed his sons in the fire in the Valley of Ben Hinnom, practiced sorcery, divination and witchcraft, and consulted mediums and spiritists. He did much evil in the eyes of the LORD, provoking him to anger.
As noted above, rather than appease God, Manasseh ticked him off to no end. To teach Manasseh a lesson, God let the Assyrians clean his clock.
2 Chronicles 33:11 So the LORD brought against them the army commanders of the king of Assyria, who took Manasseh prisoner, put a hook in his nose, bound him with bronze shackles and took him to Babylon. 12 In his distress he sought the favor of the LORD his God and humbled himself greatly before the God of his fathers.
Not exactly what the Prophet Isaiah had in mind when he prophesized:
Isaiah 30:31 The voice of the LORD will shatter Assyria; with his scepter he will strike them down. 32 Every stroke the LORD lays on them with his punishing rod will be to the music of tambourines and harps, as he fights them in battle with the blows of his arm. 33 Topheth has long been prepared; it has been made ready for the king. Its fire pit has been made deep and wide, with an abundance of fire and wood; the breath of the LORD, like a stream of burning sulfur, sets it ablaze.
So Isaiah envisions that the King of Assyria will be burned in the pit of Topheth just as all the child sacrifices to false gods? Then why is the fire in the pit started by “the breath of the LORD?”
At least according to Chronicles, Manasseh sees the light and turns back to God. Strangely, Kings is silent about this change of heart.
2 Chronicles 33:15 He got rid of the foreign gods and removed the image from the temple of the LORD, as well as all the altars he had built on the temple hill and in Jerusalem; and he threw them out of the city. 16 Then he restored the altar of the LORD and sacrificed fellowship offerings and thank offerings on it, and told Judah to serve the LORD, the God of Israel. 17 The people, however, continued to sacrifice at the high places, but only to the LORD their God.
Let’s consider paragraph 17. “The people, however, continued to sacrifice at the high places, but only to the LORD their God.”
What the hell does this mean? The “high places” were the places where child sacrifice to the foreign gods took place. This passage can easily be interpreted to mean that while the sacrifices remained the same, they were now only directed toward the god of Israel while in the past they had been directed toward multiple deities including the god of Israel (note that I use a small “g” because I can’t possibly be talking about God here).
I might even argue that is the simplest interpretation. Any other interpretation requires reading into the passage a change in the manner of sacrifice as well.
As for Isaiah, Jewish tradition has it that he was executed by Manasseh by being cut in half with a wooden saw. I guess Manasseh was unamused that he got a hook through his nose rather than the Assyrian monarch getting fried in a fiery pit. Manasseh reigned for fifty-five years! His successor, Amon, was assassinated after only two years.
2 Chronicles 33:22 He (Amon) did what was evil in the LORD's sight, just as his father Manasseh had done. He worshiped and sacrificed to all the idols his father had made. 23 But unlike his father, he did not humble himself before the LORD. Instead, Amon sinned even more.
Very strange isn’t it? Manasseh sees the light after getting a hook shoved into his nose but Amon doesn’t learn anything from that. I might also point out that the passage sort of implies that sacrificing to idols is ok as long as you humble yourself before the LORD.
2 Chronicle 33:24 At last Amon's own officials plotted against him and assassinated him in his palace. 25 But the people of the land killed all those who had conspired against King Amon, and they made his son Josiah the next king.
This sure sounds like another event in an ongoing internecine struggle. This time it’s a failed palace coup.
Josiah ascends the throne next at the tender age of eight and doesn’t begin his reforms until twelve years later. Coincidentally, Jeremiah gets his first person to person call from God in the thirteenth year of Josiah’s reign.
The untimely death of Josiah and Judah getting caught between the millstones of Egypt and Babylon sort of pushes the theological struggle into the background but it’s the Babylonian exile which finally appears to settle the question.
Historically child sacrifice in Canaan seems to have continued in some places until the Romans took measures to stamp it out once and for all in the 1st century CE! It took the empire to succeed despite the fact that both the Greeks and the Jews, after the Babylonian exile, abhorred the practice.
The traditional understanding is that the people were constantly being seduced into worshipping false gods and performing their abominable acts. I suspect that it was a little more complicated than that. I suspect that early on there was some disagreement over whether the God of Israel required such sacrifices as well.
I suspect that the priestly faction of the northern kingdom insisted that such sacrifices were right and proper and based this argument upon a distorted interpretation of the book of Exodus. If you learn nothing else young Padawan learn this, NEVER entrust a priest, or anyone else that calls himself a “man of God,” with the authority to make decisions related to law or justice. Feel free to use them as moral advisors if you must, but leave the authority, in the hands of secular leaders.
Not until the fall of the northern kingdom does a minority southern viewpoint, which holds child sacrifice an abomination of false gods, begin to replace the distorted northern view. Not until Josiah produces the Book of Deuteronomy, which clearly refutes child sacrifice by providing an alternate set of rules, is there a book of Moses that supports the southern viewpoint, but, as indicated by Ezekiel, it still takes a hundred years or so for the conflict to finally be resolved. Perhaps the practice was finally abandoned at the insistence of the Babylonians who, despite the sexual myths recorded by Herodotus, seem to have practiced a reasonably high morality as free of human sacrifice as the Egyptians.
Yes, yes, it’s all speculation and undoubtedly being driven by my ignorance and lack of understanding. Actually it’s being driven by my philosophy of “accept nothing without questioning everything.”
Clearly my suspicions and ramblings are totally meaningless since there is no way to verify them one way or the other. This is merely an exercise in cherry picking passages and twisting the interpretation to fit some pre-defined conclusion. But isn’t this basically what all biblical interpretation consists of?
I find amusing the position that the Bible is simple to understand except when it appears to say something uncomfortable. Then one needs years of training in biblical interpretation and exegesis in order to understand what it REALLY means.
I’m certainly not saying that I believe child sacrifice was a part of the early worship of the Israelite God. I’m well enough trained to be able to consider an idea that I don’t accept. There are a few that do accept it however starting with the anthropologist Patrick Tierney.
I find it interesting that I only encountered Tierney AFTER I wrote the first drafts of the above speculation. While I thought Isaiah would have been supporting Hezekiah’s initial attempt at reform, Tierney believes the passages from Isaiah 30:31-33 are an acceptance of the sacrificial practices. I’m not so sure. I think Isaiah was speaking metaphorically and cheered on Hezekiah all the way. Perhaps that was another reason Manasseh decided to shorten his existence.
I’ve found some Apologetics on this topic but not much. No one tries to refute the idea since the overwhelmingly majority interpretation of the scriptures is that they are referring to the repeated descent into idolatry and the worship of false gods. Doesn’t God, when he stops Abraham from sacrificing Isaac, make it clear that he abhors human sacrifice?
Well, not really. You could interpret it that way, and lots of folks do, but God never actually says that. Well then surely when God stopped Jephthah from sacrificing his daughter he makes it clear then. Oh wait, God didn’t stop Jephthah did he? Nope, not one word of protest. As a matter of fact, if you think about it, Jephthah’s oath in Judges 11:31 “whatever comes out of the door of my house to meet me when I return in triumph from the Ammonites will be the LORD's, and I will sacrifice it as a burnt offering” sort of has built into it the possibility that it could be a person. Jephthah couldn’t have been so stupid that he didn’t realize that could he?
Christianity has the problem that Jesus is fundamentally being pushed as a human sacrifice for the atonement of man’s sins. Most folks don’t raise this point since it tends to be viewed as a terribly offensive suggestion. I did find one Apologetic refutation of the idea though, which went through great pains, primarily by playing fast and loose with some Hebrew bible translations, to establish that it’s only child sacrifice that the bible condemns! And he was quite content that he had addressed the issue. What an idiot.
Josiah’s Deuteronomy clearly declares human sacrifice an absolute no-no along with a number of other abhorrent practices.
Deuteronomy 18:9 When you enter the land the LORD your God is giving you, do not learn to imitate the detestable ways of the nations there. 10 Let no one be found among you who sacrifices his son or daughter in the fire, who practices divination or sorcery, interprets omens, engages in witchcraft, 11 or casts spells, or who is a medium or spiritist or who consults the dead. 12 Anyone who does these things is detestable to the LORD, and because of these detestable practices the LORD your God will drive out those nations before you.
This means that all the phony mediums and psychics fleecing people by claiming to speak to the dead are performing actions that are “detestable to the LORD.”
As for Jesus as human sacrifice, these laws are given to men. It’s God’s sandbox so I guess he’s not necessarily bound by them. Besides, dying is only a temporary, although awfully painful, inconvenience for a god-man isn’t it? Posted by Alencon at 4:42 PM Tony Malone said,
Dear Alencon: Very interesting and entertaining essay. Please consider these points, if you will (your words are in quotes):
"This is generally understood to mean sacrifice by burning the victim to death."
A more correct statement would be "generally BELIEVED". There's no archaeological support for child sacrifices in the Middle East. And as you point out yourself, the real wording is "pass through the fire". This refers to initiations into secret religious societies, which all wealthy and powerful people's sons go through - societies that were first set up in Egypt, long before Israelite culture existed. I don't believe human sacrifice ever went on there. It's a misreading of the Old Testament, coupled with mass hysteria, that has created a myth that the Canaanites actually burned up their kids. You know what proof historians offer? The Bible, and their mis-reading of those words! When they look for archaeological proof, the best they can offer is the "topeth" at Carthage (which today would be Morocco), a cemetery with jars that hold infants' bones. But this grave is from 300 BCE, during Roman rule. The Biblical period of concern would be 1200 - 500 BCE. So how do they even relate? And no one's really sure why the grave or those bones are there. There's no consensus that those children were sacrificed (what if there was a disease that swept the area briefly?). Therefore, there is no archaeological proof that the Canaanites, or anyone in that area at any time, sacrificed their kids.
"I guess one could “redeem” a child the same way a donkey is redeemed, with a substitute lamb, but it’s interesting that it doesn’t specifically say that isn’t it? Then again, according to Numbers, it simply costs 5 shekels to redeem each firstborn son."
The donkey had to be redeemed because it was an unclean animal. Clean animals were the ones that the priests liked to eat. They didn't eat donkeys or camels, but they still expected a sacrifice when your donkey had a baby. So you bring a lamb instead. If you won't bring them a lamb, you have to kill the newborn donkey. God requires a sacrifice of some sort, and the owner doesn't want to kill a useful donkey so it's better to just bring a lamb to the priests. Then comes the order "Redeem every firstborn male among your sons." The human son HAS to be redeemed. Bring a lamb, no options. You can't kill your kid (it appears that it was the ISRAELITES who thought they should sacrifice their children - they were constantly being told not to).
"I don’t find the first explanation terribly compelling. Dedicated to God’s service in order to do what? The Levites were the priestly class weren’t they? If this was simply a call to dedicate the first born male to the service of God, then how come the practice isn’t referred to and expanded upon elsewhere?"
If we want to believe the Bible for a minute, it was custom in Shiloh to receive children as gifts (Samuel for instance), who could then be trained to do service. They may have been like altar boys and janitors in a modern church, doing various duties that were beneath the priests. Samuel was groomed for the priesthood, so a dedicated human gift could rise up the ranks, too. The Levites seem to have copied this style in Jerusalem, but eventually abolished it and decided that if someone wanted to donate a slave, the slave would be evaluated and then the cash would be taken instead (Leviticus 27:1-8 and see that whole chapter).
"the legal and religious reform that he brought about deserves to be considered one of the greatest influences on the western world and King Josiah deserves to be considered one of history’s greatest law givers up there with Hammurabi, Moses, and Solon."
I tend to think of Josuah as a shill for the blood-thirsty power-obsessed Levites. Destroying everyone else's churches and killing all their priests and forcing your religion and its laws on them is not something I'd congratulate anyone for. Hinkiah and his "found" book (which he and his friends probably wrote) were a power grab, and a move for religious centralization in Jerusalem.
"exactly what is implied by God letting them become defiled through the sacrifice of every firstborn and why this would fill them with horror?"
In Monotheism proper, all things come from the one god, good or bad. If the Israelites went to other religions and put their sons through the fire, it was because their god let them, and he had a reason. He wanted them to become horrified by what came of their practices. It's a pathetic plea, like saying, "Just wait! You'll see what'll happen!", when it's possible that nothing bad will come at all.
"This sort of implies that the practice was still going on around the time of the exile."
The practice of "passing through the fire" still goes on today in the intitiations for every Egyptian-related secret society. You know of course that many current world leaders (including at least four generations of the Bush family) are menmbers of Bohemian Grove, where rituals are regularly played out for the god Molech. Mock human sacrifices take place at their festivals.
It is more than likely that Satanic influences have always been present in the world: death cults and other creepy stuff. But I don't suspect that there's ever been a whole people that subscribed to any one religion like this. I believe it has always been as it is today, where there are shadowy cabals of abominable humans roaming around, killing and stealing on scales that the average criminal never even thinks about.
"while the southern faction, in a much more sparsely populated environment, held the opinion that such rites were a perversion of the true worship of YHWH."
Don't forget, when the Israelites went nuts with their own child "sacrifices", they occurred in Ha Gehinnom, the valley south of Jerusalem. The southern territory. Jeremiah and Ezekiel cursed Jerusalem, and considered the Levite priests evil bastards. There was nothing about the southerners that made them more virtuous than their northern cousins.
"So Isaiah envisions that the King of Assyria will be burned in the pit of Topheth just as all the child sacrifices to false gods? Then why is the fire in the pit started by “the breath of the LORD?”"
Topeth was obviously a place of shrines to various gods, all hated by the Levites. Destruction was in store for them - they would all be smashed and burned when Israel's glory days finally arrived. Isaiah envisions the Assyrian king burning up on one of the altars to his own gods. And it would be YHWH's work, the fiery breath of the Lord having sweet revenge.
"Let’s consider paragraph 17. “The people, however, continued to sacrifice at the high places, but only to the LORD their God.” What the hell does this mean? The “high places” were the places where child sacrifice to the foreign gods took place. This passage can easily be interpreted to mean that while the sacrifices remained the same, they were now only directed toward the god of Israel while in the past they had been directed toward multiple deities including the god of Israel."
A "high place" was simply an altar where regular public animal sacrifices and rituals went on. There were two high places at the entry gates of Jerusalem (2Kings 23:7). You could be a king loyal to YHWH,in that he is the one god you worship, while still allowing your subjects to sacrifice to whatever gods they chose. This would be half-acceptable to the Levites. If the king is pro-Levite, they have lots of power over his decisions. But only when they have religious exclusivity can they control the whole population. So all other religions were bad, and it was bad to let the Israelites worship other gods.
"despite the fact that both the Greeks and the Jews, after the Babylonian exile, were abhorred by the practice."
abhorred means: hated. You can say that someone abhorred (hated) a certain practice, but you would not say that the practice abhorred them.
“accept nothing without questioning everything.”
This is a very respectable position. My own philosophy is: Consider everything - believe nothing.
Jephthah's oath and Abraham's preparation to sacrifice Isaac add weight to my thought that it was the Israelites who were into human sacrifice, and who had to be weaned off it.
"This means that all the phony mediums and psychics fleecing people by claiming to speak to the dead are performing actions that are “detestable to the LORD.”"
Actually it means that going to an astrologer, or anyone who might give you advice on which move to make next in your life, is forbidden. Why? Because those things can be self-empowering and make you independent. Certainly they can descend easily into quackery, but the practices have existed throughout all civilization, so they must have some substance to them, and the biggest danger they could pose would be to a ruling priesthood who do all divining and speaking to god, and who want to tell you how to live and tell the army who to kill and tell the king how to think. If you're thinking for yourself and seeking your own answers and making your own decisions, you don't need a priesthood to guide your life.
Thanks Alencon for a great essay - lots of good labour and thought in there. And thanks for making me think about a few things I hadn't noticed. You provided a good challenge. http://alencon13..com/2006/06/human-sacrifice-in-ancient-canaan.html |
Christianity Etc › Re: Good Occult Fraternities by PastorAIO: 6:57am On May 24, 2011 |
GODSON2009: its not about the creative intelligence of the reader,its about getting the essence the exegesis like i have stated before and the purpose,if you have noticed the bible is like layes upon laters of interwoven incidents,you simply cannot pick out an incident and then talk about it independently of the supporting verses. What is an exegesis, is it not an interpretation? If I recall it is you that advised me to read verse 16 independently of verse 15. GODSON2009: i never said that GOD did not accept burn offerings,in fact examples abound in the old testament where burn offering was offered unto him either to appease him or to ask for favours. the city being burnt contains properties of the inhabitants,if you check the bible other exampes abound where the israelites are told to burn everything without taking any "booty" king saul actually lost his kingdom because he disobeyed GOD not to take anything i.e booty from a vanquished enemyyes,that is what i believe actually its not a red herring and even though the bible did not categorically state what that jephtah did at the end of that chapter,we could look at another incident of similar situation in the bible and rationally deduce. example where similar happened samuels's mother made a vow to GOD that any child she gets will be dedicated to GOD fore ever he was not killed or slaughtered. I never said that you said that God did not accept burnt offerings. I hope you are not hallucinating. Please it would help if you just stuck to what I said and leave your imagination out of this. The City being burnt contained properites of the inhabitants, ba? What about the inhabitants? Are you going to tell me that they were carefully removed from the city and given a decent burial before the rest of the city was offered up as burnt offering? The story of King Saul and his failure to totally destroy the 'amalekites' (I think it was the amalekites, I can't remember off hand) has no bearing on what we are talking about now. At least in that case he wasn't told to burn them up as a burnt offering to the Lord. But what I find most shocking and demonstrates that you hallucinate is when you say that the bible did not categorically state what Jepthah did at the end of that chapter. 30Jephthah made a vow to the LORD and said, “If You will indeed give the sons of Ammon into my hand, 31then it shall be that whatever comes out of the doors of my house to meet me when I return in peace from the sons of Ammon, it shall be the LORD’S, and I will offer it up as a burnt offering.”
34When Jephthah came to his house at Mizpah, behold, his daughter was coming out to meet him with tambourines and with dancing.
39At the end of two months she returned to her father, who did to her according to the vow which he had made; The bible explicitly states that Jephthah did to her according to the vow. The bible also explicitly states that the vow is to offer her as a burnt offering to the Lord. Samuel's mother[b] did not[/b] offer Samuel up to God as a burnt offering. She offered to dedicate his life to God and that is what she did with Samuel, she brought him to the temple to serve God. This is a totally different case from Jephthah and his daughter and you are just struggling to connect the two out of desperation. there is no where that GOD will demand for a human sacrifice,and i added the link and short recital to show an enlightened explanation from someone who was more knowledgeable than i am concerning that incident You forget the tale of Abraham and Isaac, where he bound Isaac to be sacrificed. Did God not demand it? and i will state for the umpteenth time that the vow was to give the daughter unto a lifetime of service to GOD sort of like a nun,if you traverse the length and breath of different religious persuations like seventh day adventists,jehovah's witness others this is what they all believe and subscribe to.since you are not a christian you cannot know about my religion more than i do by applying literal meanings,its like when jesus said he will demolish the temple and build it back in 3 days, fair enough? And I will state for the umpteenth time that you are deluded if you read the passage and came to that conclusion. Even if you add the Moonies, and the Hare Krishnas to your seventh day adventists and Jehovah's witnesses to support the nonsense claim that a promise to make a burnt offering was fulfilled by sending her to a nunnery, that doesn't change the facts of what the passage says. since you are not a christian you cannot know about my religion more than i do by applying literal meanings,its like when jesus said he will demolish the temple and build it back in 3 days, fair enough? Hey stop there!! you should say that I am not the kind of christian that you are. But you cannot claim total monopoly of christianity. Of course I cannot know your christianity more than you do. Afterall you make it up as you go along, there is no way that I can catch up with your innovations. However if it is literal meanings of the Bible that you don't like then you will have to explain to me what the criteria are for when to take the bible literally and when not to. I don't see what Jesus had to say about building the temple in 3 days after it is destroyed has got to do with what we are talking about. lets address this one after the other,as you have bolded it,the instruction of GOD to the israelites was that once they have taken control they were forbidden from practicing any of these sort of sacrifices,now irrespective of its origins and the people that practice it the bible which you have quoted copiously from to back your assertions have equally shown that its totally against human sacrifice that is the buttom line now i would like you to justify the article i posted n the other comment about the violated 5 yrs old girl and then generally justify and rationalise the human sacrifice indulged in as a form of idol worship which you have failed to do. both you and tudor in trying to ease out of a difficult situation find it easier to attack christianity rather than explain,rationalise and justify the sacrifice of human beings that is the crux of this whole argument and i dont see anyone rising to it. I find it difficult to follow your grammar above. All I demonstrated to you was that the rite of passing through fire has nothing to do with human sacrifice, though you (and many others) have tried to force it to mean that. There is nobody on this thread (as far as I am aware) who is condoning human sacrifice. If your beef is against people who perform human sacrifice then we are on the same side. I thought that you were making claims that there was no human sacrifice in the bible, or the Jehovah did not permit the wholesale slaughter, genocide actually, of vast hosts of people, some of them sacrificially. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Good Occult Fraternities by PastorAIO: 3:09pm On May 23, 2011 |
GODSON2009: english comprehesion sire the burnt offering starts from vs 16 "THEN" MEANS the action in 16 has been seperated from 15 so in effect everything in 16 i.e the booty. the meaning of booty in the freedictionary online
boo·ty 1 (bt) n. pl. boo·ties 1. Plunder taken from an enemy in time of war. 2. Goods or property seized by force or piracy. 3. A valuable prize, award, or gainand what was the action the father did to the daughter?guess in your haste you didn even bother to find out?? i have copied and pasted this article i found after a cursory google search maybe this will serve to enlighten you, Thank you so much for explaining the meaning of booties and showing me how to read the text. In fact it illustrates my point that any text can be read in any way depending on the creative intelligence of the reader. I will take your point and read the passage only from verse 16, ignoring verse 15. This is still what I get: 16“Then you shall gather all its booty into the middle of its open square and burn the city and all its booty with fire as a whole burnt offering to the LORD your God; I still see a city being burnt (with all it's booty, not just the booty alone). Since we have separated the booty from the rest of the city what does the city that is being burnt consist of? GODSON2009: and what was the action the father did to the daughter?guess in your haste you didn even bother to find out?? i have copied and pasted this article i found after a cursory google search maybe this will serve to enlighten you,
Did Jephthah really offer his daughter as a burnt offering to the Lord? Did Jephthah really offer his daughter as a burnt offering to the Lord? (Judges 11:29-40).
To this one would fain be able to reply, as not a few commentators and others have done, with a definite NO. Their reasons and arguments have been so clearly set forth in a recent article elsewhere, that we cannot here do better than enumerate them in the order given. (1) It is pointed out that human sacrifices were expressly forbidden by the Law (Deuteronomy 18: 9-10). (2) In verse 31, the marginal reading “or” (of the A.V., not R.V., as stated) is adopted, as showing that two alternatives were in Jephthah’s mind: “Whatsoever cometh forth . . . shall surely be the Lord’s, or I will offer it up for a burnt offering.” And it is remarked that, according to Leviticus 27:4, a person thus vowed might be redeemed for money. (3) The daughter’s words, “that I may bewail my virginity” (v. 37), are taken to imply that this was the real outcome of the vow, that she was pledged by her father to perpetual celibacy; and further proof of this is found in the statement of verse 39, “And she knew no man.” (4) At verse 40 the reading, “talk with”, of the A.V. margin, is given preference to the textual reading, “lament”; and it is suggested that for four days in each year the daughters of Israel went to talk with Jephthah’s daughter. We may hope, if only for Jephthah’s own sake, that this view is correct; but there are difficulties in connection with each of the points mentioned which may not be ignored. If we enumerate these also, we shall perhaps put the questioner and others in a position to form their own judgment as to what really took place. (1) While there can be no doubt as to the Lord’s disapproval of human sacrifices, our passage nowhere states that Jephthah’s action met with His approval; and the question is not what the Law forbade, but what a man such as Jephthah, who had lived for some time among the idolatrous Syrians of Tob, might say and might do http://gospelhall.org/faqs/bible-questions-and-answers--other/did-jephthah-really-offer-his-daughter-as-a-burnt-offering-to-the-lord.htmlsource; I don't know why you quoted the above. Is it that it is what you believe, or is it a red herring? Or could it really be that you quoted it 'to serve to enlighten me'? The article does not actually state what happens. It seems to me that it is just wriggling about trying to squirm its way out of the difficult position. After speculating whether or not Jephthah could have done such a thing, it then says that whether he did it or not it doesn't matter cos it doesn't say that God approved of it, and in fact God in Deuteronomy expressly disapproved. It is all rather long-winded, and I have a preference for just following what the bible said in simplicity. 39At the end of two months she returned to her father, who did to her according to the vow which he had made; What was the vow? To offer her as a burnt offering! simples. Deuteronomy Chapter 18 9 When thou art come into the land which the LORD thy God giveth thee, thou shalt not learn to do after the abominations of those nations. 10 There shall not be found among you any one that maketh his son or his daughter[b] to pass through the fire,[/b] or that useth divination, or an observer of times, or an enchanter, or a witch, Now to come to this very interesting bible verse. This is what you and also the writer of the not-very-interesting article you quoted use to show that God would not condone human sacrifice. Alas for you, human sacrifice is not mentioned in the text. What you seem to understand as human sacrifice (and many other translators have made this error too so you are in good company) is the line 'to pass through the fire'. However to accept this translation is to betray an ignorance of Canaanite religion, and also other pagan religions the world over. To Pass over the fire was means, quite literally, to pass over fire. This was a rite that was done to purify the celebrants. In some parts they jump through a ring of fire or they jump over a bonfire. These practices were usually tied to the solstice celebrations and they are still practiced in Europe and other parts of the middle east till this day. A lot of solstice rites are still practiced within christendom as Christmas celebrations and Midsummer's Eve Celebrations (themed around the birth of St. John the Baptist). In Croatia, midsummer is called Ivanje (Ivan being Croatian for John). It is celebrated on June 23, mostly in rural areas. Festivals celebrating Ivanje are held across the country. According to the tradition, bonfires (Ivanjski krijesovi) are built on the shores of lakes, near rivers or on the beaches for the young people to jump over the flames.
Estonia
"Jaanipäev" ("John's Day" in English) was celebrated long before the arrival of Christianity in Estonia, although the day was given its name by the crusaders. The arrival of Christianity, however, did not end pagan beliefs and fertility rituals surrounding this holiday. In 1578, Balthasar Russow wrote in his Livonian Chronicle about Estonians who placed more importance on the festival than going to church. He complained about those who went to church, but did not enter, and instead spent their time lighting bonfires, drinking, dancing, singing and following pagan rituals. Midsummer marks a change in the farming year, specifically the break between the completion of spring sowing and the hard work of summer hay-making.
Understandably, some of the rituals of Jaanipäev have very strong folkloric roots. The best-known Jaanik, or midsummer, ritual is the lighting of the bonfire and jumping over it. This is seen as a way of guaranteeing prosperity and avoiding bad luck. Likewise, to not light the fire is to invite the destruction of your house by fire. The fire also frightened away mischievous spirits who avoided it at all costs, thus ensuring a good harvest. So, the bigger the fire, the further the mischievous spirits stayed away.
Germany
The day of sun solstice is called Sommer-Sonnenwende in German. On June 20, 1653 the Nuremberg town council issued the following order: "Where experience herefore have shown, that after the old heathen use, on John's day in every year, in the country, as well in towns as villages, money and wood have been gathered by young folk, and there upon the so-called sonnenwendt or zimmet fire kindled, and thereat winebibbing, dancing about the said fire, leaping over the same, with burning of sundry herbs and flowers, and setting of brands from the said fire in the fields, and in many other ways all manner of superstitious work carried on---Therefore the Hon. Council of Nürnberg town neither can nor ought to forbear to do away with all such unbecoming superstition, paganism, and peril of fire on this coming day of St. John."[citation needed] Bonfires are still a custom in many areas of Germany. People gather to watch the bonfire and celebrate solstice.
Hungary
On June 21 Hungarians celebrate "Saint Ivan's Night" (Szentiván-éj) (Iván derived from the slavic form of John, translated as Jovános, Ivános, Iván in Hungarian). The whole month of June was once called Month of St. Ivan until the 19th century. Setting fires is a folklore tradition this night. Girls jumped over it, [/b]while boys watched the spectacular.[11]
In Latvia, Midsummer is called Jāņi (Jānis being Latvian for John) or Līgo svētki (svētki = festival). It is a national holiday celebrated on a large scale by almost everyone in Latvia and by people of Latvian origin abroad. Celebrations consist of a lot of traditional elements - eating Jāņu cheese, drinking beer, singing hundreds of Latvian folk songs dedicated to Jāņi,[b] burning bonfire to keep light all through the night and jumping over it, wearing wreaths of flowers (for the women) and leaves (for the men) together with modern commercial products and ideas.
Lithuania See also: Saint Jonas' Festival
Midsummer is commonly called John's Day (Joninės) in Lithuania, and is also known as Saint Jonas' Festival, Rasos (Dew Holiday), Kupolė, Midsummer Day and St. John's Day. It is celebrated in the night from the 23rd of June to the 24th of June and on the 24th June. The traditions include singing songs and dancing until the sun sets, telling tales, searching to find the magic fern blossom at midnight, jumping over bonfires, greeting the rising midsummer sun and washing the face with a morning dew, young girls float flower wreaths on the water of river or lake. These are customs brought from pagan culture and beliefs. The latter Christian tradition is based on the reverence of Saint John. Lithuanians with the names Jonas, Jonė, Janina receive many greetings from their family, relatives and friends.
Russia and Ukraine Night on the Eve of Ivan Kupala, by Henryk Hector Siemiradzki.
Ivan Kupala was the old Russian name for John the Baptist. Up to the present day, the Russian Midsummer Night (or Ivan's Day) is known as one of the most expressive Russian folk and pagan holidays. Ivan Kupala Day is the day of summer solstice celebrated in Russia and Ukraine on June 23 OS and July 6 NS. This is a pagan fertility rite, which has been accepted into the Orthodox Christian calendar.
Many rites of this holiday are connected with water, fertility and autopurification. The girls, for example, would float their flower garlands on the water of rivers and tell their fortunes from their movement. Lads and girls would jump over the flames of bonfires. Nude bathing is likewise practiced.
Spain Bonfire at Almadrava beach on Saint John's night. Bonfires are very common in Spain and Portugal.
The traditional midsummer party in Spain is the celebration in honour of San Juan . . . Fire: Bonfires are lit, usually around midnight both on beaches and inland, so much so that one usually cannot tell the smoke from the mist common in this Atlantic corner of Iberia at this time of the year, and it smells burnt everywhere. Occasionally, a dummy is placed at the top, representing a witch or the devil. Young and all gather around them and feast mostly on pilchards, potatoes boiled in their skins and maize bread. When it is relatively safe to jump over the bonfire, it is done three times (although it could also be nine or any odd number) for good luck at the cry of “meigas fora” (witches off!). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Midsummer |
Christianity Etc › Re: Good Occult Fraternities by PastorAIO: 1:48pm On May 22, 2011 |
GODSON2009: where my problems rise and the moral of my many comments and preamble is that 1.the old testament christians absolutely did not offer human sacrifices at all.they fought and killed in a state of warfare.
2.now with the pre colonial progenitors,they did not only do the same thing like i have pointed out above but they sacrificed human beings for the sake of several gods. they killed millions of people in cold blood this is my main issue,
please do two things for me 1.show me where all these happened in the bible 2.justify/rationalise this for me and i will accept whatever you want 15you shall surely strike the inhabitants of that city with the edge of the sword, utterly destroying it and all that is in it and its cattle with the edge of the sword. 16“Then you shall gather all its booty into the middle of its open square and burn the city and all its booty with fire as a whole burnt offering to the LORD your God; and it shall be a ruin forever. It shall never be rebuilt Deuteronomy 13 30Jephthah made a vow to the LORD and said, “If You will indeed give the sons of Ammon into my hand, 31then it shall be that whatever comes out of the doors of my house to meet me when I return in peace from the sons of Ammon, it shall be the LORD’S, and I will offer it up as a burnt offering.” 34When Jephthah came to his house at Mizpah, behold, his daughter was coming out to meet him with tambourines and with dancing. 39At the end of two months she returned to her father, who did to her according to the vow which he had made; Judges 11 |
Christianity Etc › What Is The Significance Of The Works Of Jesus To Christians? by PastorAIO(op): 11:06am On May 18, 2011 |
Time and time again I keep hearing that Jesus' teachings were referred to Jews who were still under the law and the era of christianity only started after his death. Subsequently very little, if anything at all, that Jesus said actually has any bearing on the modern christian.
If that is the case then I wonder what was the point of Jesus going around preaching. Why didn't he just come, hang out for a little while and then die, leaving Paul and others to then explain the significance of his death to the world?
Considering that the law was soon to be made redundant why did Jesus continue to preach under the law to the Jews? Why didn't he just explain to them that he was going to die soon and once that happens that will usher in a new age and a new covenant?
Ultimately I want to ask, Does the teachings and works of Jesus have any bearing on the life of the modern Christian? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Why Doesnt Paul Quote Jesus? Have Been Thinking! by PastorAIO: 10:52am On May 17, 2011 |
bobbyray: My Verdict The Gospels and letters have different purposes. The Gospels provide a record of what Jesus said and did. The letters of Paul and the apostles explain the meaning and practical implications of who Jesus was and what He did for us.  That begs the question, didn't Jesus say or teach anything that had any 'meaning or practical implications of who he was and what he did for us'? What then is the import of what Jesus said and taught? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Why Doesnt Paul Quote Jesus? Have Been Thinking! by PastorAIO: 9:31pm On May 16, 2011 |
Joagbaje: @Bobbyray
Paul wasn't a disciple in Jesus lifetime, but he received direct teaching and instruction from christ which he makes references to from time to time
Galatians 1:11-12 11 But I certify you, brethren, that the gospel which was preached of me is not after man. 12 For I neither received it of man, neither was I taught it, but by the revelation of Jesus Christ. Well that's a sure sign of divine intervention if Paul quotes Jesus verbatim in the 'worker deserves his wages' quote yet was never taught the teachings of Jesus by any of his disciples. I wonder why Paul called it scripture when they were only oral sayings of Jesus. That is a sure sign that the gospels were considered scripture even before they were written. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Why Doesnt Paul Quote Jesus? Have Been Thinking! by PastorAIO: 9:00pm On May 16, 2011 |
Joagbaje: Pls don't muzzle me . Abeg dey wack your corn dey go jare, I will not muzzle you!!  |
Christianity Etc › Re: Why Doesnt Paul Quote Jesus? Have Been Thinking! by PastorAIO: 7:21pm On May 16, 2011 |
Thank you for that. I was not even aware of that. I know the ox muzzling quote from corinthians. It gave me plenty of laughs especially when considered in light of the greedy pastors we have. You had better not let Joagbaje be aware of the quote, the next thing you know he'll say that you're muzzling him and God said he shouldn't be muzzled. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Why Doesnt Paul Quote Jesus? Have Been Thinking! by PastorAIO: 6:24pm On May 16, 2011 |
KunleOshob: I don't know what bible you have been reading, but Paul quotes Jesus several times in his writings and practically all his writings are based on the teachings of christ. You cannot compare the writing style of matthew, mark, luke and John(gospel books) to paul's writings cos the gospels are an historical account of the life of Jesus whereas paul's letters were addressed to different groups of early christians to teach them and address specific issues the early church had problems with. Where did Paul quote Jesus several times in his writings? Could you give us a specific instance? chyke27: There is an interesting parallel between paul's writings and that of other great christians throughout the church age. Try reading the writings of great followers of Christ such as Watchman Nee,Charles Spurgeon and even our contemporaries Miles Munroe and Gbile Akanni. You can't help the feeling that such writing are not from men but from God. The similarity is in the concord with the words of Christ and expounding it as authority. There messages were all the same theme; the crucified Christ and its meaning and benefit to man. I'm afraid Nee, Spurgeon, and Munroe and Akanni are not Jesus and the topic is 'where did Paul quote Jesus?'. Please don't give ammunition to those people that say Men of God is now equal to God of Men. bobbyray: parallel preaching is not the same as quote
1. One possible reason that the letters of Paul do not have more “red letter” sections is date. How could he have quoted the Gospels when he was writting before they were penned? Yet the teachings of Jesus were being passed orally amongst christians. so Paul ought to have been familiar with them since he became a christian. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Why Doesnt Paul Quote Jesus? Have Been Thinking! by PastorAIO: 6:16pm On May 16, 2011 |
OLAADEGBU: If you are looking for direct quotes, Paul surely quoted the gospel of Luke who quoted the words of Jesus and calls it scripture. He also quoted Moses in the verse below:
"For the scripture says, You shall not muzzle the ox that treads out the corn. And, The labourer is worthy of his reward." -- 1 Tim. 5:18,
"And the same house remain, eating and drinking such things as they give: for the labourer is worthy of his hire. . . " --Luke 10:7
"You shall not muzzle the ox when he treads out the corn." -- Deuteronomy 25:4 Please sir, could you kindly furnish us with the chapter and verse of Luke that paul quoted. Where did Paul make the quote? |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Kingdom Of Heaven by PastorAIO(op): 10:26am On May 12, 2011 |
Grey Beard: But back to "The Kingdom". @Pastor AIO - if I may I would like to focus for a minute on one of the parables you mentioned and its relationship with the Kingdom of God within us:
I believe there is much more to this parable than is immediately apparent. In this parable, Jesus uses the analogy of a man, a seed, a known action (casting/planting), an unknown action (germination) and the eventual fruit & harvest to describe the Kingdom of God.
By far the most intriguing aspect of this parable is the unknown action which is outside the control of the man but is a kind of law of the earth:
"For the earth bringeth forth fruit of herself".
In other words, when the seed is inside the earth, this phenomenon will occur. This unknown action indeed seems to be the essence of the parable because without it, every other action in the parable is futile.
However, if we examine what we know about this phenomenon it is obvious that a seed cast or planted in the earth must first die before a new plant can grow out of it. This is the phenomenon of germination. How it happens that new life comes from death is indeed the mystery here. But it seems that essentially what Jesus is telling us is that essence of the Kingdom of God here on earth is in the mystery or the law of new life coming from death.
So my questions would be: [list] [li]For the Kingdom of God inside us to be fully manifest here on earth, are there things within us that must first die for this phenomenon to take place? (e.g. certain negative emotions and desires etc)[/li] [li]Is this phenomenon somehow related to being "born again"? Must part of us die for us to be born? Again?[/li] [li]Is Jesus' death and resurrection also a manifestation of the essence of the Kingdom of God here on earth?[/li] [/list] Indeed in the process of the development of the Logon there is a period that far from being progressive is actually marked by reversals. It is like a man that wants to travel from Lagos to Ibadan, but at the very outset of the journey finds himself trapped and carried off on a boat into the atlantic ocean, from the atlantic ocean he finds himself come ashore on the coast of the Congo. The process then carries him from there to South Africa and then from SA he catches a plane to Abuja. It is from abuja that he manages to catch a bus to ibadan but the bus breaks down en route and he gets a lift from someone but that person is going to Ife not Ibadan. From Ife he then manages to eventually get a lift to Ibadan. But the sweetest thing about it is that when he reaches Ibadan he finds that it is the most opportune time to reach there. If he had got there earlier as planned he would not have been at such fortuitous advantage as his late arrival. It is established that persecutions will arise as a result of the Logon. But are these persecutions/setbacks etc really retrogressive? It depends on what we mean by progressive. In a system that is linear, ie starting at a point and progressing in a line up until the finishing point, then going backwards is not progress, only going forward is progress. However in a system that is cyclical, ie. starting at a point and then progressing up until one returns to the starting point, then in an attempt to reach the apex of the circle it does not matter if one first starts with a descent and goes through the nadir before rising up again eventually reaching the apex. especially if there is a current that carries him along this process. I hope this makes sense. In this sense Death is not a terminal end but can just be seen as the nadir which one must go through in order to rise to the Apex. |
Christianity Etc › Re: "It Doesn't Matter Who Wrote The Bible" by PastorAIO: 1:27pm On May 11, 2011 |
@Deepsight, I get where you're coming from, and I also see how you've read it conjunctively.
*Ducks to provide you with ample space to perform your long jump* |
Christianity Etc › Re: "It Doesn't Matter Who Wrote The Bible" by PastorAIO: 12:14pm On May 11, 2011 |
Deep Sight: *sigh*
The exact argument made was that it did matter who wrote the bible exactly because of the attribution of divine inspiration. . .which attribution has influenced events on a colossal scale throughout history. . .surely you get that?
You cited the book of Ezra. You queried if it was actually divinely inspired on account of its contents. As such you recognise that the origin of the book is important. If the people of Israel for example regarded the writer as a rogue prophet, that would make a huge difference. They may choose to place no stock by his words. They may not even regard it as scripture. You cannot deny that. This is very simple and clear.
They regarded the words of Moses as law - exactly because they believed God spoke to him. If they found that this was not the case, and Moses was either a rogue, or the words were not written by Moses at all, do you not realize that this would be key in framing their approach?
I think what you should say is that it doesn't matter for YOU - beacause YOU will still approach the book critically. You need to realize that that is for YOU. For others, it actually should matter because they approach the book with faith: regarding it as sacred, inspired, and thus the complete truth. They may not feel that way if they found it to have been written by a rogue, for example. Or by persons other than the named writers.
*Runs away very fast in anticipation of yabbis* The igbo is starting to work again o! ( small yabis) The exact argument actually made in the OP and even in the title of the thread is that[b] it doesn't matter.[/b] Not that it does matter, abi are you reading a different thread. I didn't say I queried if it was divinely inspired on account of it contents. I merely queried if it was divinely inspired. And I mentioned it's contents separately. *Runs away very fast in anticipation of a long-assed protracted argument that leads nowhere at a furious pace* |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Kingdom Of Heaven by PastorAIO(op): 11:57am On May 11, 2011 |
lagerwhenindoubt: @Pastor, intriguing post
The Kingdom of God is within us truly , but what does it really mean.? (Listen then to what the parable of the sower means - truly listen)
Is Jesus talking plainly or was he expressing a deeper concept that he could only breakdown in lay-people terms. It got me wondering why Jesus would be clear about what Heaven is and choose to call it the Kingdom of God. looking at the references below, I propose that he was not preaching about Place or Statehood of Christlike Governance. he was talking about the State/Position of the Spirit Man on the Spiritual Hierarchy as God intended
Mathew 6:33 but seek first his Kingdom [/b]and his [b]Righteousness, and all these things will be given to you as well. What other things?
Romans 14:17 For the Kingdom of God is not a matter of eating and drinking, but of Righteousness, Peace and Joy in the Holy Spirit, Ultimately Man must achieve this state before he can be truly prepared for the Kingdom of God
Luke 11:20 But if I drive out demons by the finger of God, then the Kingdom of God has come to you. A Revelation of Knowledge to the Kingdom of God
Mark 4:11 [/b]He told them, "The Secret of the Kingdom of God has been given to you.[b] But to those on the outside everything is said in parables A Revelation of Knowledge to the Kingdom of God
Mark 1:15 "The time has come," he said. "The Kingdom of God is near. Repent and believe the good news!" perhaps in discernment of the varying levels of Spiritual Understanding of the people
John 3:5 [/b]Jesus answered, "I tell you the truth, no one can enter the Kingdom of God [b]unless he is born of water and the Spirit. Obviously a requirement of elevation from our fallen state. a pre-cursor to another rung on the heirarchy
Matthew 25:34 "Then the King will say to those on his right, 'Come, you who are blessed by my Father; take your inheritance, the kingdom prepared for you since the creation of the world. My thoughts go to Paradise or the Garden of Eden.
Acts 28:31 Boldly and without hindrance he[b] preached the kingdom of God[/b] and taught about the Lord Jesus Christ. A spiritual doctrine IMHO
Luke 18:17 I tell you the truth, anyone who will not receive the kingdom of God like a little child will never enter it." perhaps like our Adamic state before the fall. but please if you disagree then let me have your take on what he meant there
Mark 12:34 When Jesus saw that he had answered wisely, he said to him, "You are not far from the kingdom of God." And from then on no one dared ask him any more questions.
I have always wondered which took precedence in the order of spiritual matters from Gods point of view, Our going to Heaven or Our achieving the Spiritual State we where prepared to achieve before Satan threw a spanner in the works. - The Union of Immortality and The Revelation of Wisdom (Knowledge and Understanding) through the Holy Spirit I would agree that by the Kingdom Jesus is referring to a state of spiritual awakening in people rather than to a place (I am presuming that you are saying what I think you are saying). Mathew 6:33 but seek first his Kingdom [/b]and his [b]Righteousness, and all these things will be given to you as well. What other things? The other things that he mention just prior to this verse, namely things like what we shall eat and where we shall shelter etc. Everyday worries and stuff. Romans 14:17 For the Kingdom of God is not a matter of eating and drinking, but of Righteousness, Peace and Joy in the Holy Spirit, Ultimately Man must achieve this state before he can be truly prepared for the Kingdom of God Jesus did not say this, this is from a letter of Paul. Luke 11:20 But if I drive out demons by the finger of God, then the Kingdom of God has come to you. A Revelation of Knowledge to the Kingdom of God
Mark 4:11 [/b]He told them, "The Secret of the Kingdom of God has been given to you.[b] But to those on the outside everything is said in parables A Revelation of Knowledge to the Kingdom of God
Mark 1:15 "The time has come," he said. "The Kingdom of God is near. Repent and believe the good news!" perhaps in discernment of the varying levels of Spiritual Understanding of the people I couldn't really follow your reasoning in these parts. John 3:5 [/b]Jesus answered, "I tell you the truth, no one can enter the Kingdom of God [b]unless he is born of water and the Spirit. Obviously a requirement of elevation from our fallen state. a pre-cursor to another rung on the heirarchy I believe that Jesus is referring to an aspect of our being, the 'Spirit' that must be awakened in order for one to be part of the Kingdom of God. I'm not exactly sure of what you mean by an hierarchy. Luke 18:17 I tell you the truth, anyone who will not receive the kingdom of God like a little child will never enter it." perhaps like our Adamic state before the fall. but please if you disagree then let me have your take on what he meant there I am aware of a number of different interpretations of this. I favour the interpretation that because the child is not yet fully socialized it is easier of them to enter the Kingdom. The more adult we are and the more we have learned the ways of our society the harder it will be. |
Christianity Etc › Re: "It Doesn't Matter Who Wrote The Bible" by PastorAIO: 11:27am On May 11, 2011 |
Deep Sight: Oh please what a question sir. I thought it doesn't matter who wrote the bible. . .
[size=40pt]? ? ? ! ! ![/size]
You now ask the quetsion of divine inspiration. When I asked that same question in relation to the argument in the OP, you bin wan break my head.
Case closed. If I talk, now, na abuse go follow. Abeg, no abuse me o. Clear out jor, you mumu guy, I go yab you o!! What has asking the question of divine inspiration got to do with whether it matters or not? I don't think that the letters of Cicero are divinely inspired but I can draw a lot of wisdom from them for living. Of course I read them critically. I don't think the letters of Paul are divinely inspired however I can draw a lot from them for my life. Of course I read them critically not just swallow everything lock stock and barrel. The whole point of whether it matters or not is that regardless of who wrote a book can the contents of the book have any useful bearing on your life. Surely you get that, or do I have to mix yabbis inside. |
Christianity Etc › Re: "It Doesn't Matter Who Wrote The Bible" by PastorAIO: 8:35am On May 11, 2011 |
On the issue of divorce and what Jesus said about Moses giving the Jews a law on divorce on account of the hardness of their hearts, that leads me to another book in the bible, one I have a particular distaste for, the book of Ezra. The book of Ezra has the dubious honour of being the most racist document I've ever come across. Was this book really from God?
Ezra Chapter 10:
2And Shecaniah the son of Jehiel, of the sons of Elam, addressed Ezra: “We have broken faith with our God and have married foreign women from the peoples of the land, but even now there is hope for Israel in spite of this. 3Therefore let us make a covenant with our God to put away all these wives and their children, according to the counsel of my lorda and of those who tremble at the commandment of our God, [b]and let it be done according to the Law. [/b]4Arise, for it is your task, and we are with you; be strong and do it.” 5Then Ezra arose and made the leading priests and Levites and all Israel take oath that they would do as had been said. So they took the oath.
What happened to all the provisions made for the 'stranger within thy gates' in the early days of Israel nation? The book is full of pure race this, and holy race that, and basically ethnically cleansing the cities by driving out the non hebrews. Of course I know the argument that they were influencing the Jews to worship other gods but what about if they agreed to convert to monotheism. Wouldn't that be a better course of action than breaking up families? Imagine Ezra had been around in the Time of Ruth. Then there would have been no King David and no stem of Jesse.
Maybe this is a bit off topic, but I thought I'd throw it in. |
Christianity Etc › Re: "It Doesn't Matter Who Wrote The Bible" by PastorAIO: 8:07pm On May 07, 2011 |
aletheia: ^ Why sir, by now you should know my views sufficiently enough to discern that is not what I am saying here.  Only making sure, not only for my benefit but for others who would read this thread. ^You agreed with me that slavery is an economic system, but you discount that it was an economic system backed by law. There were two legally recognized ways for a slave to gain his freedom: 'Backed by Law'. The state worship of the Imperial cult was backed by law and was a necessity of the entire empire. Can the same arguments you provided above also be applied in this case? |
Christianity Etc › Re: "It Doesn't Matter Who Wrote The Bible" by PastorAIO: 6:45pm On May 07, 2011 |
aletheia: ^ Your thesis is weak and a misrepresentation of the facts. First of all the system of slavery is an economic system just like capitalism, or serfdom or other systems that have existed through the ages. Is the suggestion here that religion does not impinge on the world and its systems, economic and political? I would beg to differ. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Holiness And The Danger Of Prosperity Gospel by PastorAIO: 5:50pm On May 07, 2011 |
OLAADEGBU: "Whosoever therefore shall confess me before men, him will I confess also before my Father which is in heaven. But whosoever shall deny me before men, him will I also deny before my Father which is in heaven." (Matthew 10:32-33). [size=15pt]21 Not everyone who says to Me, "Lord, Lord," shall enter the kingdom of heaven, but he who does the will of My Father in heaven. 22 Many will say to Me in that day, "Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in Your name, cast out demons in Your name, and done many wonders in Your name?" 23 And then I will declare to them, "I never knew you; depart from Me, you who practice lawlessness."[/size] |
Christianity Etc › Re: Holiness And The Danger Of Prosperity Gospel by PastorAIO: 4:18pm On May 07, 2011 |
|
Christianity Etc › Re: The Father's Love Is In You - Pastor Chris by PastorAIO: 10:18am On May 06, 2011 |
In light of all the child abuse sexual scandals that have been going down the phrase 'Father's love in you' has a very dodgy ring to it. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Benefits Of Being A Muslim Woman: by PastorAIO: 11:58am On May 05, 2011 |
The Imperial Harem (Turkish, Harem-i Hümâyûn) of the Ottoman Empire (1299-1923) was one of the most important elements of the Ottoman court Role of the Valide Sultan ("Queen Mother" The mother of a new Sultan came to the harem with pomp and circumstance and assumed the title of Queen Mother (Valide Sultan) upon her son's ascension. She was paramount chief and ran the Harem and ruled over the members of the dynasty. The Valide Sultan who influenced the political life of the Ottoman Empire during various periods of history had the authority to regulate the relations between the sultan and his wives and children. The Valide Sultan was a majestic symbol of the Ottoman dynasty and wielded great power. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imperial_Harem |
Christianity Etc › Re: One Of My Major Problems With Religious Morality. by PastorAIO: 8:42am On May 05, 2011 |
thehomer: I didn't say that. Though being highly religious does stifle science (which is distinct from general education) because science at its core is the direct opposite of faith which is required in religion. Please, how much thought have you given to what you said above? I'm asking so that I know how to respond. |