Christianity Etc › Re: A Sensible Religion. . . by PastorAIO: 7:16pm On May 04, 2011 |
JeSoul: ^ Spambot. It was showing earlier, but I can see its now tagged - that is the strange part. I've pm'd the admin to untag it. Thanks |
Christianity Etc › Re: One Of My Major Problems With Religious Morality. by PastorAIO: 6:34pm On May 04, 2011 |
thehomer: I really cannot say because purity is in the eye of the beholder and what one may consider extreme religious devotion may be heresy to another. My point is that countries do not generally progress technologically if her citizens did not allow science and reason to grow. My guy, I'm not talking about who is purer that who in whose opinion or who is heretic. I'm talking about the fact that England was an extremely religious place at the time when she was leading the world in scientific discoveries and even building an empire. Of course you cannot advance in science if you do not allow 'science to grow'. The same way that you cannot smell clean if you do not clean yourself, or you . . . I'm sure there is a name for it, not 'stating the obvious' but another single word name, but it escapes me now. Like when you say the water is watery, or that's fiery fire etc. The point of contention is your claim that being religious automatically means that you don't allow 'science to grow'. |
Christianity Etc › Re: A Sensible Religion. . . by PastorAIO: 6:29pm On May 04, 2011 |
|
Christianity Etc › Re: Miracle Pastors - All Their Tricks Exposed - Channel 4 - UK by PastorAIO: 12:15pm On May 04, 2011 |
EarsWide: What is really surprising is not the nonsense Joagbaje comes up with - it is that a he has a number of followers/supporters or fellow frauds. Are there really that many st*pid people out there ? Most of those 'followers' are actually himself under various guises. |
|
Christianity Etc › Re: One Of My Major Problems With Religious Morality. by PastorAIO: 9:46pm On May 03, 2011 |
thehomer: In China's case, I think they simply held on to their superstitions and of course generally felt that other cultures were simply inferior to theirs even when their technology had been superseded. Thank you. I also want to ask, what role extreme religious devotion of England in the 18th and 19th century had to play in her advancement. It was so extreme that they had a name for them, they were called the Puritans. That is to say these people were trying to be pure christians. |
Christianity Etc › Re: One Of My Major Problems With Religious Morality. by PastorAIO: 5:04pm On May 03, 2011 |
vedaxcool: In other words, you disagree with the late bin Laden's "revelation"? Yet for some reason, knowledgeable Islamic clerics and other educated people agree with his interpretation. How can one who is on the outside tell the difference?
Hommer the question is has this outsided=u ever tried to know the difference? there are a prepondrance of Islamic literature that refutes the use of suicide bombings the question is hae you ever tried knowing the truth?
Let me conclude by saying, Hitler followed what can be called social Dwarnism, that is a belief in te survival of the fittest, a direct interpretatoin of Theory of Evolution in social context, are you willing to claim that he Hitler and his hordes were actually following the theory of Evolution? Are you suggesting that 2 people reading the koran can come up with 2 radically opposed opinions of what Allah's will is? |
Christianity Etc › Re: One Of My Major Problems With Religious Morality. by PastorAIO: 4:47pm On May 03, 2011 |
divinereal: "Well the world population has grown exponentially with the application of science and reason. I'm sorry but I simply have to let you know that they cannot be victorious if they refuse to apply science and reason in their governments. "
Well said homer, can't seem to get this throught these people greasy thought process. The reason why people do not understand history and that the wests advancement over other nations in the past 500 years is because of science and reason. The methodology of reason not religion, race or culture. Reason is core to Western culture. A society based on religion will always fail regardless of the faith. Cultures and societies must evolve as everything else in the universe lest they die. When the West overtook China what religion was holding China back? Or was it lack of Science and Reason in China that caused them to fall behind the West? I don't think so! |
Christianity Etc › Re: Signals From Subconscious Soul? by PastorAIO: 1:39pm On May 03, 2011 |
sadboy, I recognise some of the things which you are talking about and my conclusion is that one shouldn't make a big deal out of these things otherwise it can become a vain obsession. Sometimes a get precognitive images constantly and then sometimes it just stops. often they are just flashes like I'll see a friend in a red jacket then an hour later that friend will turn up on my doorstep with that red jacket. Or often it is knowing that the phone is about to ring and who it is etc. Why I say that focusing on these things is vain is because I once went through a period when I felt that I had to 'develop' this ability. I thought that they were signs of spiritual development, but now I think otherwise. There were things that I felt influenced or caused it like abstinence from sex, physical exercises, diet and meditation, but then I found that one could practice all these things and still not make the experiences more developed. And on the other hand you can stop practicing and the impressions will still come. I've concluded that these things happen when they happen and I can't do anything to improve them or make them more frequent. And obsessing about them can be ruinous. Why? Well for a start I can not choose what I want to see precognitively. If I could I would choose to see tomorrow's lottery numbers. Often the things I see are not very relevant to anything. Like once I saw a plate of rice with meat and an egg on top. An hour later I was presented with a plate exactly like this. Now what difference did that make to my life? nothing. The only thing that it did for me is that it confirmed for me the existence of a supernatural existence. https://www.nairaland.com/nigeria/topic-279631.192.html#msg4003757I have offered a definition of Natural that says that influence passes from one event or object in a futureward direction across space.
Perception is nothing more than an impression made by an event upon the senses.
The impression cannot precede the event in a Natural world.
ie. I cannot perceive something before it occurs. I cannot see rosy-fingerred dawn before the sun is about to rise.
If I do see it (ie receive an impression of the dawn on my senses) accurately prior to the sun actually rising then it could not have occurred by natural means. |
Christianity Etc › Re: "It Doesn't Matter Who Wrote The Bible" by PastorAIO: 7:35pm On Apr 29, 2011 |
zataxs: @Pastor AIO
If Islam is what made muslims build Dome of the Rock does it make it Islam a good thing. What then of the Aztec religions?
So even if, though I disagree, that religion may have resulted in progress (religion has an uncanny tendencies of trying to attribute credit to itself when it is clearly not due), We need to ask ourselves, at what cost? , Ask Galileo.
It is too expensive. we cant just sit down and force ourselves to give the church credit on some pieces of art and ignore the atrocities and outright blocking of progress e.g stem cell.
religion is at odds with science. and with progress. I never said Islam was a good thing, or any religion for that matter. I said it would give a turbo-boost to your orientation, I didn't say it would give you that orientation. ( I don't know the dome of the rock, I know the Kaaba stone though, but I'll google dome of the rock later). I never said religion resulted in progress. I'm not sure if stem cell is progress. In fact on the issue of progress one must first establish a goal and then (only then) can we say whether we are progressing towards the goal or not. "Religion is at dods with science. and with progress.", so you say. Can you back this statement up? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Us Bible Belt In Pact With Satan by PastorAIO(op): 6:46pm On Apr 29, 2011 |
JeSoul: Re: Us Bible Belt In Pact With Satan
Lol. I hope the humor doesn't get lost on more than 50% of those who open this thread. The tendency has been to dismiss Pat Robertson, but I don't recall anyone standing up to him when he was making those callous and insensitive statements during Haiti's disaster. |
Christianity Etc › Re: "It Doesn't Matter Who Wrote The Bible" by PastorAIO: 6:39pm On Apr 29, 2011 |
vescucci: Mein Gott! It is so easy to communicate with you, Pastor. Some would disagree, but I won't mention Deepsight's name otherwise he will accuse me of picking on him! (and it's been a while since I've been addressed as God or Gott, but hey ho) vescucci: I agree with the point that love (I discount lust and class religion as love too , merely of some deity) causes man to excel himself. Or debase himself. Inasmuch as they can be factors to bring out the best in us, they're also the same things that bring out the worst in us. For instance, I find it that the only time I'm capable of hate is in defense of someone I love. I can easily dislike someone who doesn't like someone I like. I digress. But by love I didn't just mean the Agape love, I meant Erotic Love. Lust. Quite possibly it has a part to play in almost every aspect of human behaviour. (shades of Freud's Id perhaps). vescucci: My point is this: coincidence or not, it doesn't prove anything because evil is also resultant of religion. I think man has achieved some great things in spite of religion and not because of it. If you think of the ancient Egyptians and their mummies and pyramid, you still will be awed. No one knows how they did those things. It is due to religion. But algebra and many breakthroughs made in Arabia did not happen because of Islam any more than Christianity helped Farraday or Judaism/pantheism/whatever-the-dude-was-into helped Einstein. It is a bitter pill to swallow but most of the contemporary scientific breakthroughs are made by atheists, agnostics, skeptics and nominal whatevers. The progress due to religion is apparent but the regress is not, for you cannot miss what never was. The world is changing. The middle east is clamoring for secularism. Religion will soon be what it ought to be, a deeply personal affair. We may be heading towards that apocalypse. We may be heading towards utopia. No one knows how much better the world would have been without religion. It may well be worse. But I doubt it. But it does prove something. It proves that while it might not affect a person's moral compass, it will have the effect of turbo-boosting his activities in whatever direction he is orientated in. I think I've failed to properly express what I meant when I said that religion and sex drives us to excel. I think a distinction should be made between activities such as discoveries, and activities of self-expression, especially through art. The technologies used to build the pyramids may not have been acquired via religion, but the building of the pyramids themselves are an expression of religion. Yet having said that, I do not think that the discoveries of science are an altogether unspiritual experience. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Us Bible Belt In Pact With Satan by PastorAIO(op): 6:10pm On Apr 29, 2011 |
zataxs: for satan to exist, god must exist first. Yes we are not disputing that but rather what is the connection between the bible belt and satan. It is not the first time for tornado to hit that area. That was the centre of the atrocious slave trade etc. It is where jim crow and segregation was strongest. There is too much evidence of being in cahoots with some dark forces. |
Christianity Etc › Re: "It Doesn't Matter Who Wrote The Bible" by PastorAIO: 3:53pm On Apr 29, 2011 |
vescucci: It's difficult to learn anything from this section these days. Sigh.
Does it matter who wrote the bible? Well, if you're gonna treat it like Aesop's fables then of course not. But if you're gonna hang on every word dogmatically and hinge your life and afterlife on what it says then hell yes, it matters. It is my belief that God is not unreasonable and not everyone who rejects Christianity, for instance, because it's too fantastic for him does so because he is 'proud' as is often the favourite phrase. Faith comes from a foundation of proof and all the people I know who have genuine faith in something got that faith from a PERSONAL experience. Not because of some book or some Gandhi. It may well be from a passage in a book after all but that passage would resonate with the individual the way it wouldn't with anyone else. It is those resonances that are my key points of interest. I think I said this previously on the thread but can it be a coincidence that the 2 things that have most often caused man to excel himself (in good things as well as in evil things) have been Love (or lust) and Religion. And I am not even sure that the 2 things are that different sef. Look at all the great architecture from around the world, they were either built because someone had the hots for someone (eg the Taj Mahal) or due to someone's religious devotion. Listen to all the greatest music, look at all the greatest art. It is either erotica or religious devotion. My question is, What is it about religion that causes man to excel himself in this way? P.S. Does it occur to anyone that the author seems to be Jewish? I dunno. Is he? Seems to have escaped a number of people. Yes he says he is Jewish. And yes, that fact has a bearing on what texts exactly it is that he calls the bible. |
Christianity Etc › Re: "It Doesn't Matter Who Wrote The Bible" by PastorAIO: 3:24pm On Apr 29, 2011 |
Uyi Iredia: correction. It's more of a paradox. I am just as guilty. hence my next quote
"Human beings are irrationally rational and rationally irrational. We have an innate means of contradicting ourselves." - Uyi Iredia
I got this one after musing on a piece by Einstein that i have memorized. Here goes:
"Insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result."
BTW, I see nothing wrong with quoting myself. i use it as a means of expressing myself succinctly. Sir, you have a fan. Imitation being the best form of flattery I shall start to do the same myself. What a brilliant way to express yourself. |
Christianity Etc › Us Bible Belt In Pact With Satan by PastorAIO(op): 1:32pm On Apr 29, 2011 |
Storms hit the bible belt of the US and I am left wondering at the scale of the devastation and the possibility that they are paying for a pact with Satan that they made a long time ago. As Haitian Prime Minister Jean-Max Bellerive said "well over" 100,000 people may have died in the natural disaster, Robertson took to the airwaves Wednesday on his show and said that the country has been "cursed by one thing after another" since they "swore a pact to the devil."
"Something happened a long time ago in Haiti and people might not want to talk about," Robertson said Tuesday.
er the heel of the French, you know Napoleon the third and whatever. And they got together and swore a pact to the devil. They said 'We will serve you if you will get us free from the prince.' True story. And so the devil said, 'Ok it's a deal.' And they kicked the French out. The Haitians revolted and got something themselves free. But ever since they have been cursed by one thing after another," Robertson said. http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-504083_162-12017-504083.html |
Christianity Etc › Re: "It Doesn't Matter Who Wrote The Bible" by PastorAIO: 5:16am On Apr 29, 2011 |
Sweetnecta: Jeremiah 8 verse 8 already indicted the Bible. Tell me what indicts the Quran, from Quran or from outside it, except that you will be putting forward a guess work based on the "already indicted Bible"? can we trust your proof since it comes from such a porous source lacking true evidence, except when supported by the same Quran you want to put on trial? Satanic verses indicts the Koran. |
Christianity Etc › Re: "It Doesn't Matter Who Wrote The Bible" by PastorAIO: 2:24pm On Apr 28, 2011 |
Deep Sight: Hmmm. Nonetheless in your spare time, just as an excercise in self-improvement (we all need this) try and read through the thread and see if there is anything within the thought development that should excercise or annoy anybody. I particularly recommend this to yourself, Enigma and the OP. I don't understand what you are saying above. Is there anything in the though development that would exercise or annoy me? This doesn't make sense, in any language. Are you asking why I am annoyed? I'll admit that I can be belligerent and it is not something that I am proud of. However things have a cause. How do I explain this? The Chinese have a saying: If you hear that a son slapped his father, or that a servant killed his master, you will not find the reason for it within the morning and the evening of that same day. Meaning that the cause of things are not necessarily to be found in the immediate environment. In other words some things that are so bizarre are often found to have been a long time coming. But let us leave that for another day. Right now to talk about what is going on in this thread and why your absolute lack of logic infuriates me. I've known you to be one for whom the end seems to justify the means, any means whatsoever. So you are not above twisting logic and making illogical leaps. Not only here but elsewhere too. But lets stick to here. Let's imagine a scenario. We are told and it is confirmed that there are 6 honest men living in Lagos City. Would I be justified to then make the following statement? 'Lagosians are honest men!!' Please can you draw your ineluctably conclusion on to the last statement. Now consider what Olaadegbu said: But here is an interesting thing: Genesis opens with the words, "God said," 9 times in the first chapter. The statement, "Thus says the Lord," appears 23 times in the last Old Testament book, Malachi. So you have, "God says," from Genesis to Malachi. "The Lord spoke," appears 560 times in the first 5 books of the Bible and at least 3,800 times in the whole of the Old Testament! Isaiah claims at least 40 times that his message came directly from the Lord; Ezekiel, 60 times; and Jeremiah, 100 times. There are passages of divine inspiration in the bible will you therefore ineluctably conclude that the bible in it's entirety is a divinely inspired work? Please consider the 6 honest men in Lagos before you answer this question. If you are still at the same conclusion then I'll give up. I'll accept that we just think very different. You will note regarding yourself, that - you had been the one to raise the tangent to the discussion by insisting that the article was 'specifically" about the 5 books of Moses and also insisting that the bible does not claim divine inspiration. We pointed out to you that we felt the contrary. Rather than a logical rebuttal, you explode with insults. Sorry to explode with insults, but finding little logic in your responses I was at a loss as to how to respond logically. Now, you've probably met Jewish people before and maybe even discussed with them about their religion. What did they call their sacred book when(if) you discussed with them. I know that Jews refer to their holy book as the bible. Especially when discussing with christians. However it is not the exact same book that christians call the bible. The christian bible is the Jewish bible plus some. Now whatever book the article was discussing the fact remains that it's argument is based on the scholarship of the 5 books of Moses. The point argued was that it is impossible to dissect the text to find the original source materials. I do not see anything that you've written to address this. Then one last point that the writer makes is that it matter less ( or it doesn't matter at all) who wrote the book but rather the power of the book is what matters. I've spent the last few days thinking about why this should be such a sticking point with you and Olaadegbu. I think I've discovered why. The problem lies with what the bible is to you. To you the Bible is an historical text dealing with historical facts told by an authority in the history. To me it is something else. It is a key to open up dimensions of the spirit. It is a source of inspiration. If I am listening to some good music and I am jollificating along with it, it doesn't matter to me who wrote the song, or who the performers are. Yet there are other people who will straight away grab up the album sleeves and read all the credits. They they will go out and buy a book on the artist and learn all the information about him. Then they will become an expert in that artist. Ask them any question. They will tell you which day the song was recorded, what the original lyrics were that were subsequently changed so that the song could be more commercial, who the producer was, and why the drummer on the album was ill that day and couldn't make the session so they had to get another drummer. Yet upon all this I can still bet that their enjoyment of the song is not any better or deeper than mine. It is the same with the bible. The inspiration I extract from the bible is not dependent on who wrote it and when and who editted what where and when. Now the reason I say this is the following: note carefully - - - >
Quote from: Deep Sight on April 26, 2011, 01:42 PM Is it not true that the scripture that Paul was referring to, is today part of the Bible? ? ? ? ? I hope I have addressed this adequate with the 6 honest men in Lagos analogy. You even bolded the 'part' part. It really boggles my mind that you now fail to distinguish between the different books of the bible and Insist that Paul was talking about the entire bible which didn't even exist in it's entirety at that point. It frustrates me to have to thrash out these points line by line which is why I resort to insults sometimes. Surely you can now see the idiocy of what you were saying. plus I read somewhere above that Paul was referring to the gospel of Luke, I can't find where you said it, or was it Ola that said it. Ol boy, I know fit shout. All of Paul's letters were written before any of the gospels were written. Paul's letters are the earliest christian documents. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Churhes That Collect Tithes And First Fruits Are All Thieves by PastorAIO: 11:21am On Apr 27, 2011 |
Joagbaje seems to be talking to himself again. Forever praising his own posts written in disguise. Joagbaje: TELL THEM Beautiful !
TELL THEM
BEAUTIFUL.! God bless you |
Christianity Etc › Re: "It Doesn't Matter Who Wrote The Bible" by PastorAIO: 7:51am On Apr 27, 2011 |
An ineluctable and glaringly obvious lot. |
Christianity Etc › Re: "It Doesn't Matter Who Wrote The Bible" by PastorAIO: 9:10pm On Apr 26, 2011 |
Pastor AIO: I have no doubt now. You are just plain daft!! I apologize for this outburst. I don't mean to be so aggressive. I'm just a little bit infuriated by you. |
Christianity Etc › Re: "It Doesn't Matter Who Wrote The Bible" by PastorAIO: 8:46pm On Apr 26, 2011 |
OLAADEGBU: Here is another verse that attests to the inspiration of Scriptures which is another term for the Bible.
"Knowing this first, that no prophecy of the scripture is of any private interpretation. For the prophecy came not in old time by the will of man; but holy men of God spoke as they were moved by the Holy Spirit" -- 2 Peter 1:20-21 (The Evidence Bible). Sorry but the bible did not exist when that letter of Peter was written. And Scriptures is not just another term for the bible. There have been references to scriptures from way before the bible existed. The Bible doesn't attempt to defend its inspiration. But here is an interesting thing: Genesis opens with the words, "God said," 9 times in the first chapter. The statement, "Thus says the Lord," appears 23 times in the last Old Testament book, Malachi. So you have, "God says," from Genesis to Malachi. "The Lord spoke," appears 560 times in the first 5 books of the Bible and at least 3,800 times in the whole of the Old Testament! Isaiah claims at least 40 times that his message came directly from the Lord; Ezekiel, 60 times; and Jeremiah, 100 times.
There are about 3,856 verses directly or indirectly concerned with prophecy in Scripture. God's challenge to the world is, "Prove Me now . . . I the LORD have spoken it; it shall come to pass." (Malachi 3:10; Ezekiel 24:14). and finally, the book of Genesis does not open with the words 'God said'. Far from it, it opens with 'In the beginning . . .'. The quotations that you made are from the books of the prophets so why does it seem like such news to you that they are filled with 'God said' etc. They are not narratives like the five books of moses, or the books of Kings or Chronicles, or Acts etc. This is part of what puts me off nairaland. I'm sure that you are already aware of these things but you choose to play dumb when it suits you. |
Christianity Etc › Re: "It Doesn't Matter Who Wrote The Bible" by PastorAIO: 8:33pm On Apr 26, 2011 |
Deep Sight: The bolded - -
Interesting facts for Pastor AIO to reflect on! Perhaps he will state that these are not claims of divine unction since the books had not been collated and it wasn't called "the bible" at that time.
Sometimes one just has to shake one's head at this "capability." I have no doubt now. You are just plain daft!! |
Christianity Etc › Re: "It Doesn't Matter Who Wrote The Bible" by PastorAIO: 1:02pm On Apr 26, 2011 |
OLAADEGBU: "All scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness: That the man of God may be perfect, thoroughly furnished to all good works." (2 Timothy 3:16,17 The Evidence Bible). I'm sure that Pastor Olaadegbu is well aware that when the letter to timothy was written there was not such thing as the bible at that time. aletheia: @Topic: It does matter who wrote the Bible. If I look up to the yonder horizon and I see a wonderful vista that transports my soul to heights of sublime constancy, a setting sun sinking into a pillow of pink and purple clouds set upon a spread of mountain peaks. Surely I do not need to know who made that perfect dusk before I can appreciate it. Same as some wonderful work of poetry. Yet these things would be such an accurate portrayal of the soul of their creator. Ultimately, whether authorship matters depends on what exactly one is trying to get out of the text. If one is looking to get wisdom, and a guide to living, or a connection to spirit then it serves the purpose without need for knowing who wrote it. If however your interest is in marking historical facts, ie if you are interested in the facts[b] about[/b] (and around) the text rather than the content of the text itself, then authorship could matter. There are many tales in the bible that can also be found elsewhere and are in fact a part of the common lore of mankind. Those stories thrived because of their effect on the human soul. Not just stories but images too, and iconographies. I guess it all depends on what extent documenting history is a part of your religion and to what extent it overshadows your personal intimate experience of practicing religion. One I know for sure is that there are 2 things in the whole of history that have cause Man to extend himself beyond normal, to achieve great things, and to plumb the darkest depths. These 2 things are Love (or lust) and Religion. These 2 things connect with our motivations like no other thing in the rest of the world. I believe it is because of the symbolisms in religious texts etc, I believe that they resonate deep in Man's unconscious and can release energies that cause him to go beyond himself. If treated wrongly they can result in psychosis. But that is another story for another day. |
Christianity Etc › Re: "It Doesn't Matter Who Wrote The Bible" by PastorAIO: 3:01pm On Apr 24, 2011 |
Happy Easter everyone!! Dear DeepSight, I do not see anywhere in the article where he applies his argument to the whole of the bible. If you can identify such a place then please quote it out for us to see. All he argues against is the scholarship involving the 5 books of Moses. Having made his point, he then points out that the bible is 'important', it has inspired love and yes, it has inspired hate, and war etc etc, just as you've later said. The writer made that long before you were even aware of this thread. It seems that your new gripe seems to be that the bible claims divine authorship. Deep Sight: I stated in my very second post that we should take to the message and not the messenger. So it is very clear that we are not ignorant of that. The specific point is that in this particular matter, [b]we are speaking if a text that claims divine inspiration. We must be honest when we agree that that claim of divine inspiration has led many to die for scripture or be killed for it, because they trust it completely. [/b]Now let us ask ourselves sincerely: would that absolute trust be there if the adherents were properly informed about these cases of doubtful authourship within scripture? Please you will have to show me where in the bible the bible claimed divine inspiration, apart from the books of the prophets (including revelation). I am not aware of anywhere in the 5 books of Moses where a claim for divine inspiration was made, neither am I aware of it in the gospels or in the letters of the apostles. Please show it to me if I am wrong. |
Christianity Etc › Re: If Christianity Is About Wealth, why did Jesus not make any poor person rich ? by PastorAIO: 7:27pm On Apr 22, 2011 |
Jesus did not make any poor person rich because he lived during the old covenant, so the magic formula for wealth was only established with the new covenant. There is so much that was yet to be revealed about christianity but had to wait till after Jesus had died. |
Christianity Etc › Re: "It Doesn't Matter Who Wrote The Bible" by PastorAIO: 4:05pm On Apr 22, 2011 |
Dear DeepSight, are you aware of the fact that the article that we are discussing was written by a Jew and that he was referring specifically to the Jewish scriptures, the Tanakh. And his arguments are addressed at the sub-categorization of the Tanakh to 4 sources, J, E, P and D. He discusses why he thinks that such scholarship is nothing but an exercise in futility. Please can you demonstrate to us how what you've written below and elsewhere pertains to the thrust of his argument. He does not say that he accepts that moses wrote the pentateuch. What he says is that he doubts the claims for JEPD. Reason tells me to be open to the idea that somebody else had a hand in it. And there are definitely a few glitches in the text that back up those suspicions - notably the last eight verses of Deuteronomy, which describe Moses’ own death.
But try as I might, I just can’t believe that the Five Books of Moses were written by J, E, P and D – the four main authors whose oral traditions, biblical scholars say, were cobbled together to make the Torah. Deep Sight: In addittion I might specifically say that a particular aspect that is indeed worrisome is the undeniable fact that there were deliberate insertions within scripture with a view towards advancing specific dogmas - and some of these turned out to be controversial to the extent of leading to many violent deaths of people.
An eminent example is -
1 John 5:6
6. This is he that came by water and blood, even Jesus Christ; not by water only, but by water and blood. And it is the Spirit that beareth witness, because the Spirit is truth. 7. For there are three that bear record in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Ghost [NKJV: Holy Spirit]: and these three are one. 8. And there are three that bear witness in earth, the Spirit, and the water, and the blood: and these three agree in one.
The words in bolded blue above, which remain till this day within the KJV, have been found to be absent from the oldest manuscripts, and as such have been deleted from virtually ALL modern versions of the bible. Do not take my word for it. Check it out yourself.
Those words were a deliberate and later insertion designed to advance the Trinity doctrine.
What the OP fails to recognize is that what this shows is that the text has contained several and differring insertions, deletions and some good degree of engineering. Now, none of that may be relevant if it is not significant in degree, but what shall we say when, as in the instance I have cited, the alteration advances specifically controversial dogma?
That dogma is one of the pillars of reluigious disagreement between christians and other groups, and amongst christians through the centuries. This has actually accounted for the very violent death of many hundreds of thousands of people.
When we realize that such deliberate insertions have been the source of mindless and deadly controversies which in centuries past led to people being burned for heresy, it then beats the imagination that the OP can contend that "it does not matter who wrote the bible."
And it is even less helpful, when these issues are raised, for the OP to retreat in a most unseemly fashion into unnecessary arrogance, grandstanding imbued with insults and the like. One then wonders whether the OP merely desired people to read the article and nod in dazed agreement with everything therein. If that was the desire of the OP, then the OP needn't post such on a public forum.
I would have liked to see the OP forget about my distasteful personality and address these issues directly. Otherwise I humbly suggest that the OP deploys her powers as a moderator to delete or lock this thread, since it is not intended to accomodate contrary opinion? |
Christianity Etc › Re: "It Doesn't Matter Who Wrote The Bible" by PastorAIO: 10:04pm On Apr 21, 2011 |
I'm not sure if the bible ever says that the '5 books of Moses' are written by moses. In fact this thread has thrown up so many red herrings, in my humble opinion.
I think a summary of the gist of what the article is saying is in order. Or at least my perspective on it.
In my humble the writer is criticizing the pseudo-scholarship that passes for biblical scholarship. He cites his experience as an editor in a publishing firm, and demonstrates how impossible it is to unravel which specific element of a piece of literature came from which source. There is an awful lot of scholarship that revolves around this whole J, E, P, D categorization. I find it quite suspect too for the simple fact that if the tanakh was edited to make it seem like it was from one source then it was done very badly. The writer/editor of Genesis for instance must have been blind or stupid to not realise that at the very beginning he gives 2 accounts for the creation of the world that contradictory. I don't think he was stupid, I think it was intentional. it is the intention that I think scholarship would be more rewarding if it tried to find why. What was the motives in compiling the bible. Was it to give an historical account, or has his intention been misconstrued? If the writer was trying to be dubious and pull the wool over our eyes then surely he could do a better job smoothing the cracks over the bits that refer to Jahweh and the bits that refer to Elohim or El.
I don't know how the Islamists thought they could get some mileage out of this thread for exercising their futilities. It is a fact that Mohammad could neither read or write and that the Koran was written after his death and there were various versions of it. What puzzles me is whether or not Mohammad actually communicated with Gabriel face to face, with familiarity, or not. If he did and it wasn't that he was just imagining the interaction then I remain puzzled cos I cannot fathom how after such familiarity he could fail to tell the difference between Jibril and Satan. Can they be that similar? How come the Koran became infected with Satanic verses. |
Christianity Etc › Re: "It Doesn't Matter Who Wrote The Bible" by PastorAIO: 2:49pm On Apr 21, 2011 |
Simply excellent. And I see what you mean about his writing style. Obviously a professional writer. Great arguments too! |
Christianity Etc › Re: Last Words Of Famous People -- Anton LeVey by PastorAIO: 3:26pm On Apr 19, 2011 |
OLAADEGBU: It will do a lot of people good if you can point out the last saying of David Hume in the letter you posted. The last time I checked I even found the one you quoted about Mo in the link below:
http://users.belgacom.net/gc674645/grave/lastword.htm yessir, that must be because that is the website I got it from. When I was looking for the information source, I found it. That I quoted the mohammad saying is not an argument because it was obvious that I was only making a jibe and I was not expected to be taking with scholarly seriousness. Having said that, I ought to be more restrained with my criticisms of you, it could be that you are only joking too. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Last Words Of Famous People -- Anton LeVey by PastorAIO: 2:36pm On Apr 19, 2011 |
Sweetnecta: ^^^^^ While the hangmen of bagdad were yelling al sadah. . . .
the reformed Saddam Hussaine calmly declined the handkerchief to be wrapped around between his neck and the noose.
he said Bismillahir Rahmanir Rahim. Allahumma salli ala Rasulullah. Laa illa ha Ilallah.
This is a great affirmation of Mercy from the Merciful. The One Who deserves all worship, total submission and Who we must depend upon.
This is not the same as what you put forward, whereby your believers died on their lips associating god with God. The prophet Mohammed: "O Allah! Pardon my sins. Yes,[size=14pt] I am coming[/size]." I've always felt that dying in mid orgasm is the best way to go. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Last Words Of Famous People -- Anton LeVey by PastorAIO: 2:33pm On Apr 19, 2011 |
OLAADEGBU: David Hume, an atheist, his desperation was a horrible scene. He cried:
"I am in flames!" I wonder if you are just a deliberate liar or if you are just terribly misinformed. when you read stuff in whatever websites where you get your information it would help you immensely if you then did some follow up research on the things you read. You know, like looking up sources etc, stuff like that. The Death Of David Hume Letter from Adam Smith, LL.D. to William Strachan, Esq.
Kirkaldy, Fifeshire, Nov. 9, 1776. DEAR SIR,— It is with a real, though a very melancholy pleasure, that I sit down to give some account of the behavior of our late excellent friend, Mr. Hume, during his last illness.
Upon his return to Edinburgh, though he found himself much weaker, yet his cheerfulness never abated, and he continued to divert himself, as usual, with correcting his own works for a new edition, with reading books of amusement, with the conversation of his friends; and, sometimes in the evening, with a party at his favorite game of whist. His cheerfulness was so great, and his conversation and amusements run so much in their usual strain, that, notwithstanding all bad symptoms, many people could not believe he was dying. "I shall tell your friend, Colonel Edmondstone," said Doctor Dundas to him one day, "that I left you much better, and in a fair way of recovery." "Doctor," said he, "as I believe you would not choose to tell any thing but the truth, you had better tell him, that I am dying as fast as my enemies, if I have any, could wish, and as easily and cheerfully as my best friends could desire."
Mr. Hume's magnanimity and firmness were such, that his most affectionate friends knew that they hazarded nothing in talking or writing to him as to a dying man, and that so far from being hurt by this frankness, he was rather pleased and flattered by it. I happened to come into his room while he was reading this letter, which he had just received, and which he immediately showed me. I told him, that though I was sensible how very much he was weakened, and that, appearances were in many respects very bad, yet his cheerfulness was still so great, the spirit of life seemed still to be so very strong in him, that I could not help entertaining some faint hopes. He answered, "Your hopes are groundless. An habitual diarrhoea of more than a year's standing, would be a very bad disease at any age: at my age it is a mortal one. When I lie down in the evening, I feel myself weaker than when I rose in the morning; and when I rise in the morning, weaker than when I lay down in the evening. I am sensible, besides, that some of my vital parts are affected, so that I must soon die." "Well," said I, "if it must be so, you have at least the satisfaction of leaving all your friends, your brother's family in particular, in great prosperity." He said that he felt that satisfaction so sensibly, that when he was reading, a few days before, Lucian's Dialogues of the Dead, among all the excuses which are alleged to Charon for not entering readily into his boat, he could not find one that fitted him; he had no house to finish, he had no daughter to provide for, he had no enemies upon whom he wished to revenge himself. "I could not well imagine," said he, "what excuse I could make to Charon in order to obtain a little delay. I have done every thing of consequence which I ever meant to do; and I could at no time expect to leave my relations and friends in a better situation than that in which I am now likely to leave them. I therefore have all reason to die contented." He then diverted himself with inventing several jocular excuses, which he supposed he might make to Charon, and with imagining the very surly answers which it might suit the character of Charon to return to them. " Upon further consideration," said he, "I thought I might say to him, Good Charon, I have been correcting my works for a new edition. Allow me a little time, that I may see how the public receives the alterations." But Charon would answer, "When you have seen the effect of these, you will be for making other alterations. There will be no end of such excuses; so, honest friend, please step into the boat." But I might still urge, "Have a little patience, good Charon; I have been endeavoring to open the eyes of the public. If I live a few years longer, I may have the satisfaction of seeing the downfall of some of the prevailing systems of superstition." But Charon would then lose all temper and decency. "You loitering rogue, that will not happen these many hundred years. Do you fancy I will grant you a lease for so long a term? Get into the boat this instant, you lazy loitering rogue."
He had now become so very weak, that the company of his most intimate friends fatigued him; for his cheerfulness was still so great, his complaisance and social disposition were still so entire, that when any friend was with him, he could not help talking more, and with greater exertion, than suited the weakness of his body. At his own desire, therefore, I agreed to leave Edinburgh, where I was staying partly upon his account, and returned to my mother's house here, at Kirkaldy, upon condition that he would send for me whenever he wished to see me; the physician who saw him most frequently, Dr. Black, undertaking, in the mean time, to write me occasionally an account of the state of his health.
On the 22d of August, the Doctor wrote me the following letter:
"Since my last, Mr. Hume has passed his time pretty easily, but is much weaker. He sits up, goes down stairs once a day, and amuses himself with reading, but seldom sees anybody. He finds that even the conversation of his most intimate friends fatigues and oppresses him; and it is happy that he does not need it, for he is quite free from anxiety, impatience, or low spirits, and passes his time very well with the assistance of amusing books."
I received the day after a letter from Mr. Hume himself, of which the following is an extract.
Edinburgh, 23d August, 1776. MY DEAREST FRIEND,—I am obliged to make use of my nephew's hand in writing to you, as I do not rise today.
"I go very fast to decline, and last night had a small fever, which I hoped might put a quicker period to this tedious illness, but unluckily it has, in a great measure, gone off. I cannot submit to your coming over here on my account, as it is possible for me to see you so small a part of the day, but Doctor Black can better inform you concerning the degree of strength which may from time to time remain with me. Adieus" etc.
Three days after I received the following letter from Doctor Black.
Edinburgh, Monday, 26th August, 1776. . "DEAR SIR,—Yesterday, about four o'clock, afternoon, Mr. Hume expired. The near approach of his death became evident in the night between Thursday and Friday, when his disease became excessive, and soon weakened him so much that he could no longer rise out of his bed. He continued to the last perfectly sensible, and free from much pain or feelings of distress. He never dropped the smallest expression of impatience; but when he had occasion to speak to the people about him, always did it with affection and tenderness. I thought it improper to write to bring you over, especially as I heard that he had dictated a letter to you desiring you not to come. When he became very weak, it cost him an effort to speak, and he died in such a happy composure of mind, that nothing could exceed it." http://ourcivilisation.com/smartboard/shop/smitha/humedead.htm |