PastorAIO's Posts
Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 (of 287 pages)
A Cursory Look At The Mottled History of Reason I can't help noticing in discussions with various people that whenever Reason comes up the word is used in so many conflicting senses that often get conflated. For this reason (oops, unintended pun) I have decided to write this cursory overview of the life and times of Reason and of the various changes, adventures and misadventures that it has undergone. The english word Reason is derived from the french Raison which in turn is derived from the Latin Rationem. Ratio (rationem) is used to translate the Greek term Logos into Latin. Another Greek term similar in usage to Logos is Nous. Nous has always been associated with the Mind and mental activities in Ancient Greece, but it is in the work of Anaxagoras that we are first aware of another sense in which it is used. Nous is what created the cosmos, everything that exists has it's characteristics confered on it by the Nous. It was an ordering principle that brought the world with it's laws into being. In Plato's philosophy the world is brought into existence by the ordering principle of the Nous too (he calls it the Demiurge), but there is more to the Nous (often translated as intellect) in Plato's system. Nous is a part of Man's Soul. In other words there is a part of Man that is Rational and, he goes further in The Republic to claim, immortal, while the rest of it is irrational, or 'sensible' (derived from the senses). These different parts of Man's soul are orientated to apprehending different aspects of existence. Plato makes a distinction between a Temporal world were things are constantly changing or 'becoming' and an eternal world where things remain constant in state of 'being'. Reason is for apprehending the eternal world of being, while irrational sensations are for apprehending the temporal world of becoming. So in Timaeus we read, We must in my opinion begin by distinguishing between that which always is and never becomes (ie. the eternal) from that which is always becoming but never is (the temporal). The one is apprehensible by INTELLIGENCE with the aid of REASONING, being eternally the same, the other is the object of opinion and irrational sensation, coming to be and ceasing to be, but never fully real. . . . . Thus a description of what is changeless, fixed and clearly intelligible will be changeless and fixed - will be, that is, as irrefutable and incontrovertible as a description in words can be; but analogously a description of a likeness of the changeless, being a description of a mere likeness will be merely likely; for being has to becoming the same relation as truth to belief. Don't therefore be surprised, Socrates, if on many matters concerning the gods and the world of change we are unable in every respect and on every occasion to render consistent and accurate account. You must be satisfied if your account is as likely as any, remembering that both I and you who are sitting in judgement on it are merely human, and should not look for anything more than a likely story in such matters. Plato obviously esteemed the Nous, (Intelligence, Rational, and reasoning) above what he called Irrational sensation. Nous is a sort of mystical form of perception that does not rely on the senses but can give us access to a surer reality than that which the senses give us. It is this mystical perception that he extolls as Reason and Intelligence. Following Plato, Aristotle's work included an assessment of thought processes that he called syllogism. This is a study of how we draw inferences from facts that we already have. So for example if we know the following: All animals are mortal. and, All humans are animals. Then it is possible to infer that: All humans are mortal. This syllogistic process was considered a function of what Plato would call the irrational senses and Aristotle still made a distinction between that and Nous. In many modern translations of Aristotle's work Nous is translated as Intuition rather than reason and reason is itself identified as the syllogistic process. The philosophy of Aristotle prevailed over Europe for the next 2 thousand years during which time the shift in the meanings of various terms occurred. Reason was no longer used to refer to Nous but rather to the syllogistic process. Syllogisms were studied as the proper way to think and extolled as Reason. This study was called Logic which is derived from the word Logos. Logos had over this time lost all it's mystical connotations. The notion of a Nous as a faculty for arriving at the truth was pretty much discarded and forgotten about. Truth was to be arrived at through the proper processes of Logic. Meanwhile the only other means of arriving at Truth, according to the theologians, was through Faith, a very hazy notion that developed with christian theology and involved the unquestioning acceptance of certain authorities. So now there was a polarity of Faith on the one hand and Reason on the other. At first Tertullian in the 2nd century address the conflict so: "What does Athens have to do with Jerusalem? What have heretics to do with Christians?" Then St. Augustine suggested that they work together. "Believe and you will understand", he said. Then St. Thomas Aquinas claimed that they dealt with two very different orders of knowledge. He said, " . . . faith and science are not about the same things. Unbelievers are in ignorance of things that are of faith for neither do they see or know them in themselves, nor do they know them to be credible. The faithful, on the other hand, know them, not as by demonstration, but by the light of faith which makes them see that they ought to believe them." But before Aquinas' time there were doubts already being cast on the validity of Faith. Abelard, a monk and a philosopher from the start of the last millennium had this to say about faith. "How, then, is the faith of any people, however false, to be refuted, though it may have arrived at such a pitch of blindness as to confess some idol to be the creator both of heaven and of earth? As, according to your own admission, you cannot reason upon matters of faith, you have no right to attack others upon a matter with regard to which you think you ought yourself to be unassailed." And slowly over the centuries Reason began to prevail over Faith until the 18th century when it was considered to be triumphant. This perception was celebrated in the book by Thomas Paine called The Age of Reason. But long before Thomas Paine's call for Reason to subjugate Faith, Reason itself was being doubted in the work of the Enlightenment philosopher David Hume and others before him. Hume was influenced by the work of John Locke. Locke had noticed what Plato said over 2000 years before him that reason (Plato's irrational sensation) could only give you probabilities based on your experiences (ie the likely story). Therefore he sympathized with the King of Siam who branded all europeans liars when they told him about ice. The man had never experienced frozen water before why shouldn't he call anyone who tells him about it a liar. But Hume took it further and gave an in-depth analysis of the Syllogistic process, now called reason, in what is known as the problem of Induction. He questioned whether the fact that we know and have experienced something to behave a certain way means that it will always behave and has always behaved that way. In the King of Siam's experience water always flowed. He believed water to always be fluid. So therefore his syllogistic reasons would go as follows: Water always flows as liquid. Europeans say water becomes solid. therefore, Europeans are liars. These the first two propositions are what we are informed with through our senses. We see flowing water, and hear europeans telling us that water can be solid. These perceptions are, according to Plato, not rational, but 'irrational sensation'. So therefore according to Plato the inference that we arrive at, that europeans are liars, is only what is likely to be the case based on our experience. In other words the propositions on which we base what we call logic today is a product of our experiences and since we haven't experienced everything we are in no position to make absolute pronouncements about anything based on logic. Hume went on further to say that: "Reason is, and ought only to be the slave of the passions, and can never pretend to any other office than to serve and obey them." In other words Reason is not equipped to seek out pure, absolute, unbiased Truth. I would go further to say that the syllogistic process, known today as reason, is nothing more than a refinement of the brains ability to learn via the means of conditioned reflexes. In the 19th century there was a russian scientist called Ivan Pavlov who did some experiments to investigate conditioned reflexes in animal behaviour. He would basically ring a bell prior to giving a dog some dinner. After a few repeats of this he found that the dog would start to salivate whenever he rang the bell whether or not there was actually any dinner forthcoming. The dog had 'learnt' to expect dinner when it heard the ringing of the bell. Is there any difference between what went on in the dog's brain and what goes on when human's reason inductively. What's the difference between a conditioned reflex and the pseudo-reasoning processes? They are both based on the experience of the subject. The main differences that I see are one, deliberation, and two, immediacy of response. All thinking processes are, in my opinion, a combination of 2 abilities. The ability to generalize and the ability to make distinctions. Pavlov's dog takes an instance of a ringing bell and generalizes it leading him to always expect, at another instance of a ringing bell, the same things to happen. The ability to make distinctions, actually the opposite trend from generalization, allows for the consideration of subtleties that might affect the outcome of an event. When we think about a situation, rather than just react reflexively, we delay the reaction and analyse the situation more deliberately and critically, looking out for such subtleties that might come to play. Moreover it seems that the brains anatomy demonstrates these two types of information processing. It seems that the basic emotional urges are sourced at the Limbic system of the brain, while the pseudo-rational processes occur in the cortex and the neo-cortex. While the limbic system causes an immediate reaction to stimuli the Cortical system seems to be able to process information without causing an immediate physiological reaction. This ability to ruminate over information helps the brain to make more subtle distinctions between various instances thereby helping to make more accurate inferences. The information is processed in a more detached way this ability in turn confers us the ability to communicate. That information can be considered and processed in detachment from the biases of the organism allows the considerations to be shared with other organisms that can similarly detach their biases from the subject matter. However such detachment is not absolute, and the limbic emotional urges still always have some influence on our thoughts. This is the current situation in the 21st century. Pseudo-reason is still lauded but stands uneasily on her pedestal, while we have in universities across the world a new study called Critical Thinking that hopes to free her from the biases of her twin sister, the emotions. And lying abandoned and forgotten is the faculty of Nous which was once called Reason. |
I wrote this little piece called the mottled history of Reason because I have noticed that many people are not aware that the word has been applied to different things over the centuries, and held in various regards. I once started a thread called "Only a christian can be Logic" which couldn't even hardly take off before running into the ground. I thought that through the thread I would be able to talk about Logic and Reason in an ancient sense of the words. Then there was another thread started by Huxley called Critical Thinking that much to my frustration got moved out of the Religion section. https://www.nairaland.com/nigeria/topic-238976.0.html#msg3510196 Why it was moved, I don't know. Huxley and I hardly ever post outside of the Religion Section and it should've been obvious that we were contributing to the thread because of it's implications for religion. Anyway sha, off the back of that Critical Thinking thread I decided to write a short history of the lives and times of Reason. Coming up next, I hope you enjoy. ps. It'll be long sha |
Beam me up Scotty! |
Krayola:That depends on the source of the feeling to lie in bed soaking in your own fart. The human psyche has many sources for the impulses that it experiences. it is important to be aware of them and to be able to distinguish them. For many people their contrivances do not feel like contrivances because they have repeated them everyday through the most part of their lives so there is a kind of habitual 'flow' to them, but Habits is not the Flow that I am talking about. |
huxley:Well first I need to be tuned in to the Flow. I find that the best way to do so is to empty my mind of all sorts of hi4lootin thoughts and notions. plans and schemes, things I wanna do next week, Places I wanna be next year, Things I should have said to that guy that was rude to me, What I shouldn't have said to that girl who wanted to follow me home before I had to open my mouth and blow it. I find that if my mind is emptied of all these extraneous thoughts that I am aware of the flow better. You don't need to 'believe' in the flow, you just have to be tuned in to it. I do see people everyday not being in tune with it. I am often out of tune with it myself. It is a source of much angst and sense of impotence. There is an easiness to things and a harmony when you act in accord with it. |
Krayola:I can see why you'd think so because of my mentioning Art and Artifice. The answer is yes and no. That terminology was just current with the way everyone spoke back then when the Rosarium was written. Actually now I think more about it. Yes, it is related. |
ps. I am very happy for your line of questions because it introduces a new kind of thread to NL. One that is not about theories and notions, but rather is about practicals, and day to day living. Sometimes I really tire for the theoretical christianity. And the doctrinal arguments. |
Okay, let me put it like this. Because I believe that there is a natural flow to events in the world, and I believe that I am also able to act outside of this natural flow (I call it Art, or Artifice), and in fact I believe that many people act outside or contrary to this natural flow (What I call a contrivance) thus causing all manner of distress for themselves, I consider it very important that I am aware of the flow, tuned in to it, and act in accord with it. This is what I mean when I say that I try to eschew all contrivances from my actions. |
Don't you just love the arrogance of religious ITK-ism. At the start of the last millennium there was a christian theologian called Abelard who had this to say: How, then, is the faith of any people, however false, to be refuted, though it may have arrived at such a pitch of blindness as to confess some idol to be the creator both of heaven and fo earth? As, according to your own admission you cannot reason upon matters of faith, you have no right to attack others upon a matter with regard to which you think you ought yourself to be unassailed.For more on Abelard: http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/01036b.htm Interesting life he led too, he got castrated because though he was a monk he had his wicked way with a young lady called Heloise who was the most beautiful woman in Europe at the time. Her uncle thought since he was a monk it would be okay to entrust her to his care. lol! Theirs was one of the most famous loves in the history of Europe though, The Romeo and Juliet of their time. |
@Huxley Hey Huxley, what happened here: https://www.nairaland.com/nigeria/topic-376138.0.html I thought you were going to give some feed back. |
Religion must stop being for show. These newspaper articles and whatnot praising individual christians as paragons of the faith must stop. The churches much stop encouraging this. All ostentation in religion is from the Evil. |
Muu hahahahahahhHAHAHA eeeee, tee hee teehee aaaaaah! (sighs) |
divinepat:Christ is not divided but those that claim to be for christ are. But some are sheep while the others are Goats. |
Professor Agbaje will be along shortly to put you in the know. |
toneyb:O pari o! You don talk am finish. Nothing more to add. |
Joagbaje:Would you say that many churches that preach prosperity from morning to night actually sow discontentment in people? Are people not left feeling that they ought to make money or that means that they don't have God's love and God's blessing. Is the Love of money not actually encouraged in penterascal churches? Are people not taught to tithe in order to be blessed with more financial prosperity? |
na wa for you o, Huxley! |
JeSoul:Yeeess O! |
Deep Sight:What do you mean by this? ![]() 1. YOU EXIST (Thus the information exists)The subject in this case is not Me, but my Parasite status. Can I exist as a parasite, or better still Can a Parasite Exist Without Someone To Parisite Off? |
Deep Sight:So what is the function of the Soul? What does it do? |
Deep Sight:You asked if the soul or information could exist INDEPENDENTLY of bodies to host it. This would depend on what you mean by the word Exist because when you start talking about immaterial planes or abstract planes I then have to ask, where is the immaterial plane in relation to the physical plane? How do they interact? Also, and perhaps this should be easier, what do you define as the physical plane and as pure bodies (ie. bodies that carry no information whatsoever). Are there any such things as pure bodies? |
No it doesn't work and I'll break it down for you with an analogy. I am quite capable of parasiting off my brother. I am also quite capable of parasiting of my wife. I can even parasite of my co-workers. Does that mean that I can sustain myself without parasiting of anybody? Does that mean that I can exist independent of parasiting of someone just because I have a variety of means of doing so? |
MyJoe:Thank you. This makes me feel so much better. |
Deep Sight:When a king relies entirely on his prime minister to the point that no one in the kingdom has ever seen or heard the king. To the point where in fact there are people running around saying the king doesn't exist and yet the king won't take the reins of his government, still leaving everything to be done by his prime minister, then it is only a matter of time in realpolitiks that the prime minister will depose the king and take over the kingdom for himself. |
Deep Sight:No it doesn't!!!! Would you care to spell out the steps of your deductive reasoning that affirms it. |
toneyb:Nice one Toneyb. I would sum it all up by asking a simple question. What is the function of the Soul? What does the soul do? It doesn't make up walk cos the brain does that. It doesn't give us our emotional moods cos the brain does that. It doesn't give us a sense of identity cos the brain does that. So what the hell does it do? If absolutely every aspect of human behaviour can be caused by the brain then what does the Soul do? |
Deep Sight:This is brilliant. The question now is, can pure information exist without it being encoded on some sort of material or the other. I mean, the mechanical brain, the microchip etc are all material and so the information exists in some material form still. What about purely abstract information? |
easylogic:If the mirror test is indeed the most conclusive evidence that there is then the philosophy of cognitive science is indeed nonsense. That you don't recognise something as yourself does not mean that you don't have a sense of self. By saying that they are implying once you have a sense of self you ought to immediately recognise a mirror image. This implies that the self aware person is also aware of what he looks like. I once got chatting to a girl, a very beautiful girl, and she told me that we'd met before. According to her me and my friend sat up with her all night at a cafe in town chatting away. I couldn't remember. Yet she described so many details about me and about the things that I'm most likely to say. What really left me flabbergasted was when she told me that at the end of the night we just parted ways and that was that. "What!!?', me and my friend looked each other's face. My friend said, "That is just too totally out of character, didn't we even try to get your phone number?" Apparently we didn't. We just talked all night to a gorgeously beautiful woman and then said good night at the end of it. I don't recognise myself in what the girl told me, but no doubt it was true. Does that mean that I'm not self aware? |
easylogic:This is rubbish. That an animal or a baby does not recognise itself in the mirror does not mean that it is not self aware. It simply doesn't recognise the image in the mirror as itself. In fact to not recognise it as itself one must first have an idea of what itself is. |
It seems to me, though you lot seem little aware of it, that what you are trying to discuss is the old philosophical problem of Identity. When is something something and when is it no longer the something that it was. This is classically expressed as the problem of "Theseus' ship". I guess y'all didn't get that and that's why you ignored my post. Easylogic's OP was not the best example that could've been given. A better example that everyone will be familiar with and won't cause argument over scientific enquiry or philosophical enquiry (LOL) is this: When an amoeba bacteria is swimming along in a pond and suddenly splits into 2 amoebas as they tend to do, which one of the two amoebas is the original one and which one is the procreation? By the way, this is called the problem of Identity and Change and is at the heart of all philosophical enquiry usually called metaphysics. Good luck! |
huxley:Huxley, sorry for the delay, yesterday was a tough day. This is a big topic that I'd like to take time with but alas I'm short of time at the moment. For starters I would say that due to my religious practice I seek to eschew all contrivances from my actions. In other words I try not to do any thing by-force by-force. I believe in a natural flow to events that it is best that I flow with rather than strive against. |
Joagbaje:I prefer Fatai Rolling Dollar. Anyway, as I told you before, yoruba don talk am say, 'oruko li on ro eni'. Na name dey herald person. You name has exposed you. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 (of 287 pages)

is altered. When your brain dies, your soul dies with it.