₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,278 members, 8,522,158 topics. Date: Friday, 20 November 2026 at 04:42 PM

Toggle theme

PastorAIO's Posts

Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264 (of 287 pages)

Christianity Etc › Re: What's This About Firstfruits? by PastorAIO: 2:30pm On Mar 05, 2009
coolruler:
Thanx y'all,
To tell the truth, I couldn't do it(i.e pay the firstfruit). What will I tell my family? After waiting a while, the Pastor came right out to ask me, and I told him why I couldn't do it. I informed him I paid my tithe, but he said tithe is not acceptable to God in place of firstfruit and I should pray for deliverance from the Devourer.
After this came a series of soft harassments- u know, innuendoes, veiled aspersions,e.t.c all calculated to make me see the "error" of my ways.
I however don't know why things should be like this. Firstfruit should be between me and God right? why then his(Pastor's) vested interest? And its not as if the man is a pauper, No. He drives a BMW X3 for Christs sake. Me? I don't even have a car.
My brother, can I advise you to find a group of christians that share your devotion to the gospel and meet and fellowship with them regularly. Pray with them, support each other in your growth in christ, and Share dinner with them when you meet.
I don't know how many warning shots you want to hear before you decide to take to your heels. (If you had a car that would help speed your getaway, but till then your heels should suffice).
Christianity Etc › Re: God Without Religion by PastorAIO: 2:13pm On Mar 05, 2009
But when we look closer it would seem that man was terribly uninventive with creation of Gods, don't you think.  So the norse people came up with a hammer wielding Thor that caused lightning, the Yoruba came up with a hammer wielding Sango that caused lightning, the Greeks came up with a hammer wielding Zeus that caused lightning.  Goodness gracious me, everywhere you go all cultures come up with the same (give or take a few traits) diety that caused lightning.  In Dahomey it is Khevioso, in Igbo land it is Amadioha.  Why this lack of inventiveness?  Have you ever known human beings to be so uncreative?

ps. I don't think Invisible flintstones suspended in the sky are less believable than invisible Personalities suspended in the sky.
Christianity Etc › Re: God Without Religion by PastorAIO: 1:20pm On Mar 05, 2009
Why would anyone seek an explanation that was outside or his experience. For instance if I can make sparks by smashing two flintstones against each other and then I see a flash in the sky, am I not more likely to think that perhaps there were giant invisible flintstones in the sky. That just seems more obvious than concocting a god.

I think that belief in God involves a lot more than you are allowing for, Bastage.
Christianity Etc › Re: Dogma, Recalcitrance And The Fear Of Truth by PastorAIO(op): 10:41am On Mar 05, 2009
huxley:
Of all the properties of water is one is the most intrinsic to its waterness? Is it the fact that it is a clear liquid? Is it the fact that it taste a certain way? Is it the fact that it has a certain density, viscosity, etc, etc.

Do you need all of these properties acting together to make it water? What if you modifiy one or more of its properies, say by heating it or subjecting it under some pressure, thus changeing some properties. Is it still water?
The thing about ostensible reality is that it is conditional. Everything depends on the conditions. The description of water's properties include what it does under various conditions. If it didn't boil at 100 degrees, standard atmospheric pressure then it doesn't fit the description of water. Heating or subjecting to pressure is merely changing the conditions and it should be expected that water should do whatever it is that water does under the change of condition.

Bastage:
I would say improbable. We are limited by our own perceptions.
Anything we view as water is water.

Incidentally, that link is cool. It went clockwise for me and then anti-clockwise. Then I found that I could change direction at will.
We are indeed limited to our perceptions . . . apparently. Can we ever experience the substance of things? Or are we limited to perceptions. Are our senses the only faculties we have for perceiving reality?

I would further streamline what you said above and say, 'Whatever we view to ostensibly be water is ostensibly water'.
Christianity Etc › Re: Dogma, Recalcitrance And The Fear Of Truth by PastorAIO(op): 10:27am On Mar 05, 2009
huxley:
Interesting. You experience water by experiencings its properties. OK, is it possible for something to have ALL the properties of water and yet not be water?
This is interesting. The way I would approach this question is like this. The properties I experience as water are actually my Interpretation of a deeper Substance. When I use the term Substance I mean it in a sense closer to that Locke meant it as that which lies underneath - Sub Stantia (Stands beneath). So I divide the world into two, The Ostensible part (ie my perceptions) and the Substantial part (that which has been interpreted into my perceptions). One has to be careful with that term in philosophy because it has had numerous uses over the centuries.
http://www.formalontology.it/substance.htm

http://books.google.com/books?id=vCWIVryXXbEC&pg=PA480&lpg=PA480&dq=sub+stantia+substance&source=bl&ots=alXKC0GRUd&sig=lBvbd8_mbUF-XzJ7_dmuCZAW8xQ&hl=en&ei=rZSvSeT8Mc3dtgfVzYjmBQ&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result#PPA480,M1

So my perceptions are the product of my senses interacting with substances. The properties of water that I experience are not the substance of water. Yet they have been derived from the substance of water.

The question now is 'What can we say about substances, if anything?' How many substances are there? Is it possible for two different substance to effect the ostensible properties of water? Is it possible for a single substance to effect the properties of both water and, say, Fire?

If a different substance can effect the ostensible properties of water then yes, it is possible for something to show the properties of water yet deep down not be water.
Christianity Etc › Re: Dogma, Recalcitrance And The Fear Of Truth by PastorAIO(op): 6:19pm On Mar 04, 2009
I'm not really interested in what that site says about left brain or right brain. What I get out of the experiment is that fact that Interpretation occurs at the most basic levels of perception. So . . . Is it conceivable that water is not H2O? I say that whatever water really is, one interpretation of the experience of water is as H2O.
Christianity Etc › Re: Dogma, Recalcitrance And The Fear Of Truth by PastorAIO(op): 4:47pm On Mar 04, 2009
huxley:
Wholesale paradigm shifts in science are rare and far between. Why is this so? Because the scientific institution meticulously and painstakingly checks and rechecks its work before anything is held out as an accepted "scientific fact". Look at most of the major scientific theories of the last 200 years - few, if any have undergone drastic revisions. That is not to say that they may not be changed, but the chances of major change are pretty small.
When you say science what do you mean? How old is this science you talk about? Thousands of years, or just a couple of centuries. I'm asking because there have been numerous scientific traditions and when you say paradigm shifts are rare and far between I'm confused. Once there's been a paradigm shift can we say it is the same tradition. Can we say that The Germ theory of disease belongs to the same tradition as the theories of Galen? If the tradition you are talking about is only 200 years old can we say that there has been enough time for a major paradigmatic shift.

In fact, I have started to study such idea in more details in the areas of philosophy called metaphysics (ontology) and philosophy of science and I remember many years ago (about 20 years in fact) when I started having questions about the nature of reality. One of the questions that haunted be was;


Is it possible that there could be some other reality, distinct from our present reality, but available to us, that has not been captured by our current epistemologies?
I'm glad to see that you ask questions like that. What do you think of the image here?

http://delicategeniusblog.com/?p=552

What direction do you see it spinning and can you get it to spin the other way? Make this little experiment with yourself and then we'll talk more about it.
Christianity Etc › Re: A Question For Tithe Payers by PastorAIO: 1:36pm On Mar 04, 2009
pinky lady:
@kunleoshob

you are only saying this b/cos your understanding has not yet open to the mystry concerning tithe.
Na wa o! So Tithe na mystery now.
Christianity Etc › Re: Dogma, Recalcitrance And The Fear Of Truth by PastorAIO(op): 1:29pm On Mar 04, 2009
huxley:
I agree. Dogmatism is a human quality, just like selfishness, bravery and cruelty. And like all (most) human qualities, dogmatism can be learned and unlearned. The difference is that some cultural institutions deliberately promote and cultivate dogmatism.

Individual scientist may be dogmatic but I doubt the scientific institution as a whole is dogmatic. Scientists may have strong opinion about their ideas/views/hypothesis but I am sure they will all be willing to move their position should their position be contradicted by the evidence. In fact, it is important that scientist strongly fight for their ideas, otherwise who else would fight for them.

A case is point is Wagener who proposed plate tectonic. He was opposed by every geologist at the time. There was a measure of bulldoggedness on both sides, until he was able to provide the evidence to support his hypothesis.
Yes, but the advantage that many scientists have is that Science is not often that political. Religionists too have their views peer reviewed. What else is all those Church Councils about? However the consequences of a shift in religious doctrine has grievous political repercussions for those who hold the former doctrine. Check out nestorius here:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nestorius

Nestorius (in Greek: Νεστόριος; c. 386–c. 451) was Archbishop of Constantinople from 10 April 428 to 22 June 431. He was accused by his political enemy Cyril of Alexandria of a heresy that later bore his name, Nestorianism, because he objected to the popular practice of calling the Virgin Mary the "Mother of God" theotokos; he instead preached that "Mother of Christ" would be more fitting.[1] He was condemned at the Council of Ephesus before his supporters could arrive and he was then dethroned. His views were widely held in the East, and the consequence was the separation of the Assyrian Church of the East from the Byzantine Church[citation needed].
Smear science with a little bit of politics though . . . , for instance making the mind boggling leap (which we all do) from science to ideology, eg Big Bang theory to Atheism, or Evolution Theory to Eugenics or Racial ideologies as is found in Nazism . . . and you'll find the same resistance to evidence.
Also if your job is based on a certain scientific theory and that theory is about to be disproved that will give you impetus to resist the challenge. That too is political.

If there was to be a new discovery that would require a large enough number of scientists to go back to school, I dare say that you find the scientific institution as a whole become dogmatic.
Christianity Etc › Re: Stealth Religion by PastorAIO(op): 12:29pm On Mar 04, 2009
I've made bold some phrases above just to emphasis certain points.
The truly enlightened liberal should experience a twinge of doubt about the very blackness and whiteness of it
A useful rule of thumb in life is to raise your guard when things are explained in very simple black and white terms. Simple solutions such as 'it's the jews fault, let's kill all the Jews then everything will be alright' or 'It's religion and when africa stops being so religious everything will be alright' must be guarded against. Of course every Ideology promises great things if very simple ideas are followed. In my experience Life just ain't like that.

factual and practical realism.
Friedrich Nietzsche always disdained people's claims of rationalism or objectivity. Personally I share his distrust of such claims.
“they pose as having discovered and attained their real opinions through the self-evolution of a cold, pure, divinely unperturbed dialectic: while what happens at bottom is that a prejudice, a notion, an ‘inspiration,’ generally a desire of the heart sifted and made abstract, is defended by them with reasons sought after the event
- Nietzsche, Beyond Good and Evil.

In fact what many people laud as rationalism is merely another form of the emotionalism that it claims to be superior to.

Scientific theories are not immune. Many scientific theories of the past become weirdly implausible with the passage of time, just like religions. When this happens, they are often revealed as not just wrong but as purpose-driven. Scientific theories cannot be expected to approximate factual reality when they are proposed, but only after they have been winnowed by empirical evidence.
Now ain't that something. That only after a theory has been disproved does it become clear the extent to which it was informed by purposes other than a pure quest for truth.

Furthermore, we cannot always separate a scientists need for funding from the manner he presents his theories if not from the actually theories themselves.
Christianity Etc › Stealth Religion by PastorAIO(op): 12:13pm On Mar 04, 2009
In today's polarized world, the conflict between atheism and religion is shaping up to be the fight of the century. In this corner, the new atheists, flexing their muscles with books such as God is Not Great by Christopher Hitchens and The God Delusion by Richard Dawkins. In that corner, the religious fundamentalists, who are responsible for 9/11, the Christian takeover of America, polluting the minds of their children, and numberless other atrocities. It's science and reason against dogmatism and blind faith, making it obvious who the enlightened liberal should root for.

Well, not quite. The truly enlightened liberal should experience a twinge of doubt about the very blackness and whiteness of i[/b]t. Let me show you how a bit of evolutionary thinking can paint a more interesting picture in shades of gray.


The new atheists hate religion for causing between-group conflict and especially for its wanton disregard of the canons of rational thought. Yet, both of these problems extend far more widely than religion. Between-group conflict pervades the animal world. Ant colonies, lion prides, and chimp troops don't have religion, but they do have between-group conflict. As for the canons of rational thought, to the extent that brains evolved by natural selection, their main purpose is to cause organisms to behave adaptively in the real world--not to directly represent the real world.

This leads to a crucial distinction between what I call [b]factual and practical realism
. Consider Hans and Igor, who are mortal enemies. Hans understands that Igor is much like himself, even to the point of competing for the same square of ground. Igor regards Hans as an inhuman monster, completely unlike himself. If Igor's belief makes him fight with greater determination, then it counts as practically realistic, even if it is factually incorrect. Now imagine similar contests among beliefs--and the brains that create beliefs--taking place over thousands of generations of genetic and cultural evolution. Voila! We arrive at a conception of human mentality that is far more nuanced and interesting than the black-and-white cartoon of atheism vs. religion.

Factual and practical realism are not always at odds. To pick an obvious example, a hunter needs to know the exact location of his quarry. The point is that the relationship between the two is complex and that our minds are prepared to massively depart from factual realism, when necessary, in ways that motivate effective action. This is not a sign of mental weakness but a time-tested survival strategy. Moreover, adaptive fictions are not restricted to religions. Patriotic histories of nations have the same distorted and purpose-driven quality as religions, a fact that becomes obvious as soon as we consider the histories of nations other than our own. Intellectual movements such as feminism and postmodernism are often shamelessly open about yoking acceptable truths to perceived consequences. That's what it means to be politically correct. Scientific theories are not immune. Many scientific theories of the past become weirdly implausible with the passage of time, just like religions. When this happens, they are often revealed as not just wrong but as purpose-driven. Scientific theories cannot be expected to approximate factual reality when they are proposed, but only after they have been winnowed by empirical evidence.

These and other belief systems are not classified as religions because they don't invoke supernatural agents, but they are just like religions when they sacrifice factual realism on the altar of practical realism. The presence or absence of supernatural agents--a particular departure from factual realism--is just a detail. It is humbling to contemplate that the concerns typically voiced about religion need to be extended to virtually all forms of human thought. If anything, non-religious belief systems are a greater cause for concern because they do a better job of masquerading as factual reality. Call them stealth religions.
Read the rest here:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/david-sloan-wilson/atheism-as-a-stealth-reli_b_76901.html
Christianity Etc › Re: Dogma, Recalcitrance And The Fear Of Truth by PastorAIO(op): 12:08pm On Mar 04, 2009
That websites has got some really great write ups from all kinds of perspectives.

What many people won't admit is that the resistance to change happens amongst scientists as much as amongst religionists. It is an innate human characteristic and is not something caused by religion as some would like us to believe.
Christianity Etc › Re: Friendship (?) by PastorAIO: 3:56pm On Mar 03, 2009
There are quite a few odu that talk about friendship. I remember hearing one that talks about 2 friends Owo (money) and Ore (friend). It was quite funny, in the odu they fell out over some financial matters and in retaliation Owo took his walking stick and poked Ore in the Eye. Apparently that was where the yoruba expression 'owo ti ba oju ore je' came from. It means money has spoilt the face of friendship.

Then I know that Ose meji talks a lot about friendships too. I don't know the details but I know that there is a verse about the friendship between the pail and the waterpot.

Here's another one that can be found under Ose Ogbe:

Mo wa o dele, N o ba onile
I came looking for you at home but I didn't meet you
Ona ni mo pade Esu Odara
I met esu odara on the way
Esu Odara lo juwee re han me
Esu Odara told me the way to meet you
Pele omo ookun meji tii mi ragbada rgbada lori ewe
Greetings Omo Ookun meji that heaves ragbada ragbada on the leaves
A dia fun Aworokonjobi nijo ti oun ati Awoko jo n sore.
Was divined for Aworokonjobi on the day that he and Awoko were doing friendship together.

May I ask why you are looking for these odu. Anyway sha, I hope that this can be of help.

Are you the white Awo that came by a few weeks ago and cause a whole brouhaha in Nairaland?
Christianity Etc › Re: Should We Stop Giving Tithe? by PastorAIO: 12:39pm On Mar 03, 2009
I think it is a bit too damning to state that they cannot be redeemed. Yes, the situation looks daunting from our perspective, but it doesn't happen by our powers, no matter the strength of the arguments.

Perhaps we should stop relying on our own understanding and our abilities to argue. The Truth cannot be arrived at via rhetorical arguments. The important thing is that you say what you have been inspired to say. The job of convincing anyone is not ours.
Christianity Etc › Re: Religion And Authority by PastorAIO(op): 9:47am On Mar 03, 2009
I love your use of that term 'Candyman'.  I'm going to start using it too.  You're right about the power of the media.  But ultimately does this not apply to every communication.  Isn't every expression, every superfice, every facade a concealment as well as a display.  If I wave my left hand in front of you and say, 'look my left hand', am I not also distracting your attention from my right hand.  Is this not what magicians do when they play tricks on us.  They attract our attention away from the hand that is actually doing the trick.  When I wear my best suit am I showing off myself or am I concealing my unclothedness.  Behind everything that is said there is so much more that is left unsaid. 

In a discussion with a friend we came to the conclusion that people are often the exact opposite of what they show themselves to be.  And the more forcefully they consciously attempt to project a certain image then the more likely it is that they are the exact opposite of that image.  And even in the case where the institution or person projecting an image of trustworthiness isn't being dubious, the sheer fact that they become widely and heavily trusted is enough to invite all sorts of corruption.  Considering that only someone you trust can dupe you, it follows that the more you trust someone then the bigger capacity he has to dupe you.  Is it only a matter of time before that capacity is actualized? 

Yet human society, and most human interactions cannot happen without trust.  Trust is required to be truly human.  The present financial crisis is largely brought about by a disintegration of trust.  Banks won't lend money cos they don't trust that they'll ever see the money again.  Once trust goes, the whole society and the whole economy goes with it.  Because so much is at stake, I believe that the betrayal of trust is one of the greatest crimes anyone can commit against society. 

So trust is a double edged sword.  It is part of our humanity to trust, if not everyone, a chosen few.  And those we trust we can do business with, we can invite into our homes and share our lives with, and we can take their words at face value.  Authority depends on Trust.  At the same time Trust exposes us to all sorts of deceptions.
Christianity Etc › Re: Hindu A Religion: How It All Came About by PastorAIO: 8:42am On Mar 03, 2009
I don't know about sikhism but I do know that the islamists will not like being lumped together with the others. Besides the british were already aware of Islam. Why not Sikhism? I don't know.
Nairaland General › Re: Learning Critical Thinking Skills - Some Useful Resources by PastorAIO:
I've looked up CT some more and I see what you mean that it is quite a broad subject. In fact the links you put up do it no justice at all.

I don't think that it is really one topic as such but a cocktail of all the various ideas on logic through the ages.
huxley:
Supposing such a scientist were studying the cosmos and they were to discover a fact about the cosmos which is at odds with their religious view - such as was the case with Galileo. What should he do?

1) Deny that he has made such a discovery because it conflicts with his religions view?

2) Abandon the view from his religion as they are not in agreement with observed objective facts?

3) Re-interpret the religious view to make it agree with the facts?


One of the things you would learn in CT training are the various logical fallacies. Logical fallacies are a description of certain types of faulty reason and the range from adhominen, argument from person experience, etc, etc, etc. The arguments from personal experience deals with the issue of personal urges and emotions and how one should control or avoid making decision (where objectivity is required) on urges or emotions.
Funny you should use Galileo. I was reading about Galileo just today. I can't find where though. Perhaps it was one of the links you referred me to. Well, to answer your questions about Galileo, I always put the testament of experience above any other opinions or views. Personally I don't see how the fact that Jupiter has moons conflicts with anything in christian doctrine. I would say that the Holy See in Rome was just extremely paranoid (as one should be I guess if his position relies on a rigid orthodoxy).
But let's imagine that it conflicts with his religious beliefs. The human mind is compartmentalised. It is very easy for a person to hold two contradictory views without having issues as a result. Hypocrisy? or just elasticity of the human mind? I don't think that the issue was with Galileo. The issue was with the Holy See and soon enough they made their issue his issue in the way only despot's can. smiley

The arguments from personal experience deals with the issue of personal urges and emotions and how one should control or avoid making decision (where objectivity is required) on urges or emotions.
How does one control or avoid emotions and urges influencing decisions according to CT? I happen to think that Thinking is just a derivative of what happens in emotional processes. Nietzsche thought that it was impossible to be truly objective and that we are all driven by what he called the Will to Power.
In Beyond Good and Evil, Nietzsche begins with a chapter entitled “On the Prejudices of Philosophers.” Almost immediately he begins to tear into the lack of integrity on the part of traditional philosophers who present their ideas as the product of pure reason. Nietzsche declaims, “they pose as having discovered and attained their real opinions through the self-evolution of a cold, pure, divinely unperturbed dialectic: while what happens at bottom is that a prejudice, a notion, an ‘inspiration,’ generally a desire of the heart sifted and made abstract, is defended by them with reasons sought after the event” (Beyond Good and Evil, which will be referred to as BGE, I.5). Thus, philosophical insights are not the universal claims to truth that philosophers have presented them as and wished them to be. The philosophy of an individual is precisely that, not a product “of a cold, pure, divinely unperturbed dialectic.”
This is taken from here:
http://www.stolaf.edu/depts/philosophy/reed/2001/perspectivism.html

Indeed I find that most cognitive processes start with a bias and then think up clever rational arguments to support the bias. I wouldn't go as far as Neitzsche to claim that that is the sole purpose of our rationality, ie to make our biases look good, but I find that in most people the cognitive shifts begin with traumas of heavy emotional experiences of one kind or another. Many people turn to God after someone close has a fatality. But then again, many people turn away from God after someone close to them experiences a fatality.

I'm very curious to know how CT proposes that we can think without Bias.
Nairaland General › Re: Learning Critical Thinking Skills - Some Useful Resources by PastorAIO:
huxley:
Obviously, thinking is nothing new to humans, but[b] there is good thinking and there is bad thing. The questions is - Why are we, humans, so prone to bad thinking? What are the barriers to good thinking?[/b] This is what subjects like CT are attempting to address, by drawing from the fileds of the cognitive sciences, logic philosophy, linguistics, etc.
Every body thinks more critically about some things than about other things. We are all filled with urges that drive our behaviour. Each individual is driven slightly differently by his urges and that's what makes us individuals. When you feel an intense urge about an issue then that urge subjugates all the others and one will quite likely think more critically about how to satisfy the greatest urge.

For instance there are certain people drawn to discovering religious truth. These people will think more critically about religion. On the other hand some other people just see their religion as a form of social Identity. 'I'm a catholic, what are you?'. Such people will not peruse religion too deeply, but if their religion is questioned or attacked, what that becomes is actually an attack on the person's identity. That person will react the way anyone would if his person was being attacked. That doesn't mean that they are incapable of thinking critically. It just means that religious Truth matters less to them, and personal dignity matters more. Put the same man in a laboratory and he might prove to be the smartest scientist in the country. Obviously his drive to find scientific truth makes him more critical in that field, more likely to appraise and reappraise his experiences etc.
Nairaland General › Re: Learning Critical Thinking Skills - Some Useful Resources by PastorAIO: 4:47pm On Mar 02, 2009
Huxley, let's put it this way: What is the scientific basis of the following statements . . .


The Mind's Three Distinctive Functions
The mind has three basic functions:thinking, feeling, and wanting.

■ Thinkingis the part of the mind that figures things out. It
makes sense of life’s events. It creates the ideas through which
we define situations, relationships and problems. It continually
tells us:This is what is going on. This is what is happening.
Notice this and that.
■ Feelingsare created by thinking — evaluating whether the
events of our lives are positive or negative. Feelings continually
tell us:“This is how I should feel about what is happeningin my
life. I’m doing really well.”Or, alternatively, “Things aren’t
going well for me.”
■ Our desiresallocate energy to action, in keeping with what we
define as desirable and possible. It continually tells us:“This is
worth getting. Go for it!”Or, conversely, “This is not worth
getting. Don't bother.”
The basic functions of
the human mind
Thinking Feeling Wanting
The mind has three basic functions:thinking, feeling, and wanting.
huxley:
I agree, lets talk about CT.

What is the difference between Critical Thinking (CT) and Thinking Critically (TC)?
Critical Thinking is a subject apparently taught in universities which has as it's primary basis and principles a description of the mind as set out above by Dr. Linda Elder, and Dr. Richard Paul. It divides the mind into Thinking, Feeling and Desire.
http://www.criticalthinking.org/files/SAM-TheHumanMind1.pdf

I remain unconvinced that anything found in the link above about the subject of CT has any basis in Scientific facts.

Thinking Critically on the other hand is something we all do everyday to varying degrees. The more subtlety there is in our perceptions when thinking, the more critical will be our thinking.
Christianity Etc › Re: Existing Forever by PastorAIO: 3:35pm On Mar 02, 2009
Is it truly possible to contemplate non-existence? You can never remove the dreamer from the dream even if the dream is of non-existence.

You've never contemplated pure non-existence therefore you do not know what you're talking about.
Christianity Etc › Re: A Question For You - Huxley by PastorAIO: 3:30pm On Mar 02, 2009
[quote author=tonye-t link=topic=241487.msg3533187#msg3533187 date=1236003223]you are welcome to either oppose or back my motion, welcome and say something

everyone saying something here should take a side
[/quote]Must I take a side.  How about if I just sit on the fence?
huxley:
How do you know a god created the universe?   When did he create it all?
What is a god?  Any definitions?  Just so that we know what we are talking about.
benedictac:
so what would you call those that say God doesnt exist? the wise?
The unconvinced?
[quote author=Okija_juju link=topic=241487.msg3533157#msg3533157 date=1236002980]@ Benedictac

What would you call a man who believes in SANTA CLAUSE??[/quote]A Big Baby!  Oh, I Forgot.  I'm not benedictac.
[quote author=tonye-t link=topic=241487.msg3533170#msg3533170 date=1236003085]yeah i put it to you now that a personality created this world and av got the bible to proof it

if you say no, then bro you should have a written proof to back your claim aint it?
[/quote]What do you mean by personality?  definitions please!
Nairaland General › Re: Learning Critical Thinking Skills - Some Useful Resources by PastorAIO: 3:19pm On Mar 02, 2009
huxley:
Is is important to know when it is appropriate to use authorities. Supposing you where a defendant in a case where it is important to present some biological forensic evidence, say about DNA. You have some basic knowledge of DNA and crucially you are aware that there are experts in this field, with years of experience of forensic analysis, DNA and presenting evidence in a court of law. What do you do?

1) Do ignore the services of such experts and decide to do all the work by yourself and present it in courts?

2) Do you hire one such experts and work with him to defend your case?

3) Having hire hire, would you immediately feel a strong sense of low self-esteem with respect to your expert since he is clearly an authority on the subject?

I have issues with your very clumsy premise, namely that withhold a personal opinion is tantamount to low self esteem. Low self esteem has many precursors, the greatest of which is a persistent bad image of one's self, which could create a feedback loop, which further depresses the self-image. Ignorance of a subjects, by itself is rarely the cause of low self esteem otherwise everybody would be suffering from low self esteem as nobody knows all there is to know about everything.

How much does Stephen Hawkins know about composing music, for example? Could he offer an intelleigent opinion about the circuitry of neuron in the brain? Should he suffer from low self esteem because he may not have opnions on this subject?

Should all currently practicing mathematicans feel a sense of low self esteem because their lives are graced with the work of John Nash, who is probably one of the greatest living mathematician? If not, why not?


Your arguments are simply too crude and is unbecoming of a man of you learning.


What is your own personal opinion about the following?

1) String Theory
2) The idea that the universe is expanding

It is all very well to have ideas and opinion, but how would you know your ideas describe the true nature of reality?

Did I imply anywhere that I accept ALL their ideas as dogma? What I said was that this is a very difficult subject and that many thinkers from time immemorial have been thinking about it. And that in venturing into this, it helps to know what these other past and current ideas are.

Why did I not just present one of the ideas from the books I have read as my own? If I had done that, would you have been any the wisers? Not only would that have been dishonest, I happen to be aware of the pitfalls of some of this ideas.
I hope you don't mind but I'm going to ignore all of what you said above, despite finding it interesting and wanting continue down that line, cos I consider it a red herring. Perhaps we can do it on another thread.


huxley:
Are you asking this in gest? I thought you are the one lampooning critical thinking?
Hey, wait a minute. Lampooning critical thinking?! We are conflating two different things. There's Critical thinking, let's call it just CT, which is a system and methodology for considering issues that is (you claim) taught in universities and divides cognitive processes into Thinking, Feeling, and Desire. Then there is just plain simple Thinking Critically which man has always done from the dawn of time way before there was such a university subject or even the subject of Logic. Man has always thought critically to varying degrees.

Yes, I'm lampooning CT. I am saying, quite unequivocally, that CT is a Quack subject. It has no basis in the science of how the mind works and it's premises are superficial. That is the conclusion that I've come to after thinking critically about CT.
I did pose a conundrum about evaluating various courses of action if you were faced with a medical situation. You seem to exercise really good critical thinking in that case. I did go further to ask that if there was a scientific basis to the process of thinking in evaluating the options you presented.

Now, are you suggesting that what you did in evaluating the various options was NOT CT? If it was not CT, what were you really engaged in then? Do you think some people are better at making such decision than others?
No, I did not use any of the methods that are found in the links of CT that you gave me. I just thought about the matters you presented to a certain critical level.

I asked you quite simply, WHAT IS THE SCIENTIFIC BASIS OF CT? Vaccinations have their basis in the science of Immunology. Is there anything in neuroscience that suggests that cognitive processes can be partitioned the way it has been in CT? I put it to you again that CT is a quack science.

Much of thinking lies in the ability to make distinctions. The more critically one thinks, the more subtle distinctions one can make. There is a whole range from total dumbass who sees things as black and white to super intelligent that perceives all the subtle shades of grey and how each one applies differently.
Christianity Etc › Re: The God Virus by PastorAIO: 1:28pm On Mar 02, 2009
huxley:
Allow me to turn the question round to you. Say you were reading a book on some philosophical issue and you found that in the generall sense, the book hits the mark and deals with the issue fairly and, from your point of view, correctly. Does that mean that you endorse every minor or substantial issue in the book? If you don't, could you still recommend the book to others?

By the way, in what sense do you use the word "endorse" here?
In the sense that you are happy to have your name associated with it and you are happy to be identified with it.

I am happy to recommend a book even if I totally disagree with it. Like I've said many times before, I am always interested in various opinions. I could recommend a book to you for no other reason than to see what you think of it.

With you however I get the feeling that you are a bit evangelical with your postings, like you want to use them to bring about a change in people's opinions.
Christianity Etc › Re: The God Virus by PastorAIO: 12:19pm On Mar 02, 2009
Huxley, please before we go any further tell me, Is this your opinion? Are you endorsing this? Or are you just putting it up here to invite discussion?
Christianity Etc › Re: The Meaning Of Life by PastorAIO: 12:14pm On Mar 02, 2009
Pastor AIO:
All these meanings are valid. Just because they are not absolute and pertain to everyone does not mean that they do not actually exist or that there is no meaning in the world. It means that Meaning is a lot more subtle than you realise.

Meaning (ostensible) in a particular context is a derivation and an extrapolation from Essential meaning.
I want to address what I said in bold above about meaning being more subtle than you realise and connect it to the other thread about critical thinking. To think critically one has to be aware of subtleties in an issue rather than making sweeping blanket statements.

ps. I don't see why this thread can be in the religion section yet the Thread on critical thinking is moved out of the religion section.
Christianity Etc › Re: Hindu A Religion: How It All Came About by PastorAIO: 11:58am On Mar 02, 2009
ROIC007:
Marriage was only permitted within the same caste. There were restrictions on the choice of occupation and on personal contact with members of other castes. Central to the caste system were the ideas of samsara (reincarnation) and karma (quality of action). The belief is that if one obeys the rules of caste, reincarnation into a higher caste is possible, but women may only have the privilege of coming back as an animal if they are good enough. Are you okay with this Pastor
Well, as a Good 'hindu' do you obey the rules of caste and refrain from coming into contact with white people in the hope that maybe in your next life you might be white.

Am I okay with this? Actually, I'm not. I detest any system whose function is to inhibit the chances of every human being to explore and express their full potential. The idea that if I am not a brahmin I cannot study religion but must stick to a restricted profession that I may or may not be skilled at. I think the sheer fact that a shoe maker can have a son that will go on to be a scientist and a soldier can have a son that can go on to become a priest is enough for me to see the utter fallacy and evil nonsensicality of the caste system, or varna system if that's what you want to call it, and subsequently the Hinduism (whatever that is) from which it stems.
Christianity Etc › Re: Anyone Help With Rituals, Ife,juju,black Magic Etc. by PastorAIO: 9:34am On Mar 02, 2009
Me personally I believe in Essential Nature and Truth. If your business is in concordance with your essential nature then no financial crisis or world issue can destroy it. If however your business is at odds with your 'portion' in life, your Ayanmo, or call it what you will then no juju or whatever you call it can save it.
Christianity Etc › Re: I Am Suing Pastor Chris Oyakhilome For N200 Million by PastorAIO: 9:27am On Mar 02, 2009
fyneguy:
lol

Funny people

and you really think this has brought Pastor Chris down?

It's obvious you guys know little or nothing about this man's ministry.

Well, the man's ministry is bigger than what your little minds can bring down. It's too late.

You must be thinking that Christ Embassy is just one of those roadside struggling churches which can fall like a pack of cards with the blow of the mouth.

You know what? - Keep wishing Christ Embassy speedy downfall while God continues to increase it in grace and growth.
Good point! I can imagine a situation whereby CE gets irrefutably disgraced and exposed, While Chris Oyakhilome dies in abject ignominy and wretchedness leading subsequently to his organisation growing exponentially and CE spreading further abroad, increasing in 'grace and growth', maybe Chris himself gets hailed as the second coming while his followers then start to await the 3rd coming. Such is the way of History!!
Christianity Etc › Dogma, Recalcitrance And The Fear Of Truth by PastorAIO(op): 9:10am On Mar 02, 2009
It's always a pleasure to tell people about a wonderful book, especially when the subject of the book is of universal and critical importance. Evolutionary geneticist Jerry A. Coyne has given us such a book (Why Evolution Is True. New York: Viking, 2009)

Many biologists (and I'm one of them), when they find themselves in the midst of a debate about the validity of evolution, feel as though they're on the Moon. The question that pounds in their heads is why are these people so obstinate about knowing the real world? Isn't it better to know the real world rather than some concocted fantasy about the world?

The answer, of course, is that when the fantasy has been an important part of your world-view since childhood, you don't dump it so easily no matter how many clamoring scientists surround you and chant: "Look! Look! Look!"

Yes, it's not easy. Even just looking at the evidence is not easy. It's not easy now, and it wasn't easy when Galileo held out his telescope and said, "Look!"

Galileo is the man whose very name has come to signify the perpetual battle between dogma and science, a battle in Galileo's time won by dogma, a defeat now recognized as a disaster for human society.

The story of the Church against Galileo has been repeated (and often distorted) over and over again in history and literature. But what was the crux of it? Some say that the officials of the Church of that time were aware of the truth of Galileo's assertions that the Earth revolved around the Sun, but were incapable of publicly admitting this because of fear of demolishing the philosophical structure upon which the Church rested -- the theological position, originating with the ancient Greeks, that a mechanistic interpretation of nature could never be more than a model, an intellectual artifact, since between theory and reality there would always be a gap that could not be bridged by human reason. The Church had received from the ancients a fundamental view of the Cosmos that the Church had preached since the beginning of Christianity, and that view could not be denied without demolishing the foundations of the religion itself. At least, according to this interpretation of the crux of the conflict, that was the view of Church officials of the 17th century. Of course, eventually, after two hundred years, the Church did accept the Galilean/Copernican view of the Solar System, and without destruction of its theological foundations. (Some may argue that if anything the foundations were strengthened.)

The other view of the crux of the matter is simpler and focuses on the elemental battle between dogma and reality, the refusal of the dogmatists to acknowledge reality, the stubborn efforts of the dogmatists to contrive and deny even when one is handed a telescope and told to look at the moons of Jupiter and see whether or not they are real. So goes the story of the Church and Jupiter's moons, although if officials of the Church refused to look, many academics, the so-called philosophers of Pisa, also refused to look.

Why not look? Because to look and see what Galileo (and others) said could be seen would demolish the foundations of one's reality. The dogma was that the Earth did not move. And even of those who accepted the Copernican idea that the planets (other than Earth) revolved around the Sun, many would not accept the idea that the Earth itself revolved around the Sun -- because they believed the Earth would then lose its moon. Thus, to see the moons of Jupiter was to understand that a planet could revolve around the Sun without losing its moons, and that the Earth could do this also.

So the story of Galileo is about looking, and similarly the story of the refusal to accept the biological evolution of humanity is about looking. It's all about looking at evidence.

Galileo discovered the moons of Jupiter in the year 1610. On 22 June 1633, he received the final sentence of the Church, with the following words read out to him:

"You have rendered yourself vehemently suspect of heresy, namely of having held and believed a doctrine which is false and contrary to the Sacred and Divine Scriptures, that the Sun is the center of the world and does not move from east to west, and that the Earth moves and is not the center of the world; and that one may hold and defend as probable an opinion after it has been declared and defined contrary to Holy Scripture."

Had the Church had the same absolute power everywhere in the Western world in the 19th century that it had in the 17th century, you can bet Charles Darwin would have faced the Church and the rack and possible execution by burning for his heresy of proposing the biological evolution of humanity by natural selection.

So it goes. When Harvard University was founded in the year 1636, the assembled university scholars did not accept Galileo's work and they remained firmly committed to the Ptolemaic theory of the Universe. Were they too busy to look at Jupiter's moons?

Galileo's major work on the Solar System, Dialogue On the Two Chief World Systems, was not removed from the Roman Catholic Index of prohibited books until 1835, two hundred years after the Church forced his recantation.

Dogma is not easily melted. People don't want to look at the real world when looking turns their personal world upside down.

Meanwhile Jerry Coyne's book on evolution should be read by any anti-evolution hold-out with even a glimmer of an open mind. It's a book that may change the way you look at things -- if you dare.
from here:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dan-agin/book-review-why-evolution_b_166531.html
Christianity Etc › Religion And Authority by PastorAIO(op): 8:39am On Mar 02, 2009
Is there a basic human need to rely on certain authorities whereby they can suspend all critical thinking and simply get spoon fed?

In one of Dawkins books he argues that there is an evolutionary advantage in trusting authorities and suspending our own critical faculties. The evolutionary advantage comes from the fact that children need to trust and accept what their parents tell them in early life in order to survive.

I often wonder how, in the finance world, people can give large sums of money to someone like Bernard Maddoff without questioning how he intends to invest it. Apparently when questioned about it, he would start talking some complicated jargon and people would assume that he was on to something but that something was just too complicated for them to understand.

It seems in this world if you want to convince people you don't really need to talk sense, all you need to do is talk authoritatively.

Dawkins says that this tendency to yield to authority is part of what allows religions to be so successful. However I wonder, presuming that he is right, whether it is fair to stop at religion. In every aspect of our lives whether from the way we organise our finances, to the ways in which we vote and the various beliefs and ideologies that we uphold, are we prone to acquiescing in the face of authorities whether or not the authority deserves merit.
Christianity Etc › Re: Hindu A Religion: How It All Came About by PastorAIO: 8:09am On Mar 02, 2009
I didn't realise that there was anything such thing as Hinduism. I thought it was just a blanket term that the British used to describe all the various religious forms that they found in India, many of which stood in contradiction to others.

If there was no invading Aryan race, then please can you tell me how the caste system originated.
Nairaland General › Re: Learning Critical Thinking Skills - Some Useful Resources by PastorAIO: 7:54am On Mar 02, 2009
huxley:
In fact, to be fair, lets give credit where credit is due.   Compare to most of these innovators ( the great scientist and pholosphers of the past like Faraday,  Archimedes, Descartes, Laviossier, Priestly,  Darwin, Einstein, Newton, Boyle, etc, etc)  I have constributed nothing to human civilisation.   Have you?   Show me your grand theories or contribution.

These people deserve respect and credit for their innovations and contribution to civilisation.   Yes, it is only fair that credit is given where it is due.
It is one thing to give credit where it is due and it is quite another thing for one to discard one's native intelligence in order to kowtow to Authorities.  That you have thus far contributed nothing to human civilisation does not mean that you are incapable of doing so or that you cannot have your valid opinion about various issues.  It is your reluctance to present your own personal insights on account of the fact that others have made 'greater' contributions that I find worrisome and leads me to say that you've given them too much credit.

huxley:
But how does this relate to low self-esteem?


I take it that you have attended establishments of learning (maybe up to university level) and have been taught and mentored by consummate professional intructors and teachers.  People who are 1st class in their field.  Now, as a student starting out to learn in this field, did you have low self-esteem vis-a-vis your instructors/teachers/mentors?

I am not a professional philosopher of the mind, nor a cognitive scientist, but I have a developing interest in these areas and see the amount of work that have been carried out before as quite impressive.  Some of it may be leading down blind alleys, others may not.  Anyone starting out in this field would have a daunting task appreciating this volume of work.

Now, are you a professional philosopher or cognitive scientist?   Can you show me your body of work that puts you on a par with some of the contemporary workers in this field?   If you have not yet got a body of work published or documented, do you mind having such work reviewed by experts in the field should you manage to document them?

In fact, do you think that the process of peer-review and replicability, built-in with contemporary scientific practice is a worthwhile process  and would you submit your work to be evaluated under this scheme?
If you don't see how refusing to cultivate your own opinion on account of thinking that others are greater than you is related to Low Self Esteem then I don't know what argument I can use to convince you.  In my case, even at school I always challenged authority and I had a healthy opinion of my own native intelligence. 

Tell me, when you read your 'philosohers of the mind', as you read, do you evaluate what they are saying or do you just think, " the author who is a very clever guy says so therefore it must be true".  In other words are you capable of thinking critically or not.

I am happy to have my thoughts and ideas reviewed and criticised by experts and even by fellow contributors to this forum, ati omo ati eru ('and freeborn child and slave', cos yoruba says that it is the same way we give birth to the free that we give birth to slaves). 
[size=17pt]But all this is a terrible distraction isn't it?[/size]

We need to get back to the true subject of this thread which is Critical Thinking. I've asked you what is the scientific basis of critical thinking and I am stilling waiting for my answer.  I'll restate my question:
Pastor AIO:
When I ask for the scientific principles that CT is based on I meant it in the sense that when you have a methodology or system for doing something then that methodology needs to be supported by scientific principles.  For instance, when I go for a vaccination to protect myself I am confident in the treatment because I know it is based on the scientific principles of immunology.  If there is no solid scientific principle discovered about how the mind works then what is CT based on?  Are they quacks?

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264 (of 287 pages)