PastorAIO's Posts
Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 259 260 (of 287 pages)
posakosa:Ifa, I believe, is the divination system and the the religion. Orunmila is the diety/personification associated with it. Often in Ifa verses Orunmila is the protagonists of the verse and as such he can either by the client who is divined for or he can be the diviner. |
devayid:You're right that it isn't really a scientific process. It's not thorough enough. Let's call it a pseudo scientific project. However you're wrong in saying that it isn't a logical argument. Perhaps you can tell me how it fails to meet the constraints of logic. As an investigation into the correlation between religion and Misery I don't think I've put a foot wrong yet, logically speaking. KAG:You're right too. We should consider more examples in order to be more accurate. North Korea is a society without religion too. And so is Sweden. How are we to measure misery? That's a difficult one, but there is a school of thought that links Religion to Misery. I'm not sure how they measured the Misery themselves. I suppose they took a look at the level of Social security there was, I don't mean just like unemployment support and health insurance but also Job security (for those in work) and national security (for those with belligerent neighbours). Another related claim that is often made is that there is a negative correlation between religion and technological progress in a society. I suppose that lack of technological advancement is thought to feed into Human misery. However whenever I look at the history of technological progress I find that many advances are actually made within the cloisters of various religions. Which leads me to doubt that there is any correlation in religion as such ('the infantile belief in imaginary beings') and technological backwardness. What I suspect however is that wherever there is a Powerful Status Quo with massive interests in preserving that status quo then much will be done to stem the advance of thought and technology. It doesn't matter if that status quo is religious or secular. What do you think? |
I want to take a scientific approach to look at the relationship between religion and human misery. Now according to the scientific method when we want study such a relationship we must follow a set pattern. 1. First the relationship is hypothesized. So we make an Hypothesis: Religion is related to Human misery thus: It is the cause of Human misery. 2. Then we take a look at the facts and we find indeed that there is plenty of religion about and plenty of misery about too. In many cases we also find that where there is a great amount of Religion there is also a great amount of Misery and where there is little misery there is also little Religion. This all seems to support our hypothesis nicely. There is a positive correlation between the two phenomena. 3. But we must make a control too. Let's us take a look at such societies that are not based on religion, where religion is minimal or non existent. Will we find that Misery is eradicated too? History gives us a perfect example in Communist USSR. That was an irreligious society based on nonreligious principles that actually made a point of suppressing and eradicating religion. Were the issues that brought about human misery eradicated in such societies? Hmmm. 4. As a scientist where does that leave me? What do I conclude about this hypothetical correlation between 'infantile beliefs of religion' and human misery? . . . let me go away and think about that one. |
mecylee:Huxley claims to be a Humanist. That is his ideology. Or his religion, if you will. At least christians and muslims stand up for their beliefs but Huxley will never answer a straight question about his humanism. |
I've always wondered about the eternal recurrence. Can it actually be called a recurrence? If something were to happen again and exactly so in every particular could it really be said to be another occurrence or rather the very same occurrence. Why would I gnash my teeth at the reoccurrence of this very moment if I'm not gnashing my teeth now. As I am ignorant of any previous occurrence of Now and live it, as it were, as if it were the first time so will I be in the future ignorant of it. |
debosky:Okay, I can buy that. |
vanitty:When someone tells me that they have documents proving something then I expect them to state the facts of the matter categorically and incontrovertibly. As you say 'Might is used when there is a possibility things could or could not have happened'. So even with the documents they've received they still can't tell us for certain that the plane could not have been bought by Adeboye. It is not because of the word 'might' that I've come to the conclusion. The word 'might' merely raised the alarm. I don't know every single business in the world but I'm prepared to bet my bottom dollar that every business in the world seeks to advertise it's services. Even the most clandestine businesses in the world, take drug dealers for instance, will try to let potential clients know that they've got 'some good stuff just flown in from columbia'. The only people they will be hiding from are people that can spoil the business like the police. Perhaps you can tell me of a legitimate business that operates under secrecy. Then I'll accept that I was wrong. debosky:Good lord!! Those planes were not bought by proxies of SPVs or whatever. The documents that Thisday had said they were bought by 5 individuals for the purposes of commerce. I'm only going by what the article said. Businesses sign confidentiality agreements with their employees. Not with the media or with clients. Perhaps you can give me an example of businesses that don't advertise. Yes, advertising a business does not need to include the personal names of the investors in the business, but the company involved must have it's name there. When Guardian advertises you are informed that if ever you want 'conscience nurtured by truth' then the place to go to is Guardian newspaper. This jet was not bought by a company, according to ThisDay but rather by 5 individuals who don't want to advertise their business. |
vanitty:I'm afraid I cannot oblige you there. Whether I'm stupid or not, apparently or without doubt, I will always speak my mind and you and your kind will never scare or bully me into doing otherwise. This is a public forum for discussion. If I say something wrong or foolish even then the thing to do is to produce arguments to debunk what I've said. You've failed to do this and merely resorted to telling me how ignorant I am. Yes, I do know that I know nothing and that is obviously a damn sight more that you know. Anyway you're right that this is unnecessary pettiness. Let's get back to the main issue of contention. Here's what I had to say about the matter we're discussing. Have you any comments? Pastor AIO: |
Shouldn't you be asking this question in the Islam section? |
tenry: noetic: tenry: noetic: |
vanitty:I know that I know nothing; And that is more than most people know. - Socrates |
huxley:I don't know what to say to this. Firstly you are a man that claims to be very interested in philosophy yet you do not know what Existential means! Or perhaps you have been selective in your philosophical reading, limiting yourself only to books that attack religion. Secondly, I've already provided you with the wiki definition of the word and you are still asking. So I don't know whether you read my post or not. Yet you responded so you obviously read it. Wikipedia defines it as: Existential philosophy is characterized by what has been called the "explicit conceptual manifestation of an existential attitude"[5] that begins with a sense of disorientation and confusion in the face of an apparently meaningless or absurd world.[6][7]Perhaps you don't understand the english. Let me try to rephrase what it says. When faced with meaninglessness or absurdity in the world, it has the effect of disorientating people. This state of disorientation is called the existential state. My question to you is how does one create an ethical system in such a state of disorientation. Ethics give you a scale of values (moral values), do they not? Ideals exist at the top of the scale and they are striven for, while at the bottom of the scale are the lowly valued things and they are striven against. Thus Ethics give us an orientation. We are oriented towards the ideals. If however the basic state of reality is acknowledged to be existential (ie. disorientated) then on what are the Ethics to be based on. |
Dear Huxley, You seem to not be around at the moment, however when you do get back could you please answer a question for me. What is your definition of Naturalism? |
anonimi:I don't need to pay tax because the people that pay for my services have already paid their taxes. ![]() And I guess my accountant and my lawyer don't need to pay their tax either cos I've already paid mine through the people that employed my services in the first place. |
annyplenty:I think you'll find the point I'm trying to make if you read through the thread I linked. Basically I'm trying to say that this True Nature (al-fitra) is more subtle than what can be codified into a set of 5 pillars etc. |
KunleOshob:What I know about Ifa is that they believe that every human being has what they call Ayanmo, or Akunleyan. That is a chosen destiny. This determines many of the qualities that a person has, ie what his virtues are. What occurs during divination is to find out where the divinee is in relation to that which has been appropriated for him. How in tune is he to his true path in life? When he is in tune then he will reach his ultimate goal which is called Iwa Pele. That is a state of Being (Iwa) which is harmonious (pele). At the basis of this belief is the belief that things are not just random in the world but that there is a Form, or a format and that happiness is best achieved by adhering to this format. I believe that it is the same thing that the Taoist's in China call Te. tefrom here: http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/585059/te I believe it is also what the Buddhists and Hindus call Dharma. The term dharma' (help·info) (Sanskrit: dhárma, Pāḷi dhamma), is an Indian spiritual and religious term, that means one's righteous duty or any virtuous path in the common sense of the term.[1] In Indian languages it contextually implies one's religion. Throughout Indian philosophy, Dharma is presented as a central concept that is used in order to explain the "higher truth" or ultimate reality of the universe.from here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dharma I believe it is what muslims try to articulate by Al-Fitra: As such Al Fitra is the innate nature of a human as originally created by the Divine to be containing the Law in its very texture. To live according to the Fitra should not be confused with living according to one's instincts, and giving one's self complete freedom in fulfilling her/his lusts and desires. Al-Fitra is the hidden sacred goal for all the creations. Al-Fitra reveals for the human's heart the purpose of existence, and guides her/him to live according to her/his ultimate goal of Life.From here: http://www.esscr.org/g203_1.htm But I think that it gets twisted by organised religion and codification of mores and virtue. That is why I started this thread in the Muslim section: https://www.nairaland.com/nigeria/topic-150020.0.html . . . called Al-fitra, so what more do you need? |
IDINRETE:Please what odu is this from? Is it Obara Irosun? |
debosky:A number of things make the Thisday article appear inauthentic. 1) Instead of reporting the facts as facts they seem to be hedging by saying: The purchase of a private jet, a Gulfstream 4XP with registration number 707EA, might have been attributed to the General Overseer of the Redeemed Christian Church of God (RCCG), Pastor Enoch Adeboye, in error. Might? Is that how you report a news story? They either made an error or they did not make an error. If they made an error I am very interested to know how the error was arrived at. It is not an easy error to make. What was the initial source of the story? Some church members buy a jet for commercial purposes and this gets misconstrued and reported as Redeemed bought a Jet! 2) They claim to have seen documents but failed to narrate to us any of the contents of the documents that prove that it was purchased by 5 entrepreneurs. Now ever seen I've been aware of business dealings, I've never heard of business men that want to keep their names confidential. I don't know about you o, but most business I know try to advertise. Thisday says: The five members of the church, whose names are being withheld for confidential reasons, So, say, I'm a potential client and I want to charter their plane . . . I don't know who to go to to discuss terms or availability. Remember, the plane doesn't belong to Redeemed so I can't go to Redeemed to negotiate terms for the charter. How ridiculous is that? A confidential business entrepreneur. Not even 1, but 5. 3)Who is this other source that ThisDay then quote. He tells us that the business plan is well laid out. Is he one of the entrepreneurs that he knows the business plan so well? Does the document first alluded to also give details of the business plan? Sorry but the whole things just smells very fishy. It smells of a PR exercise in damage limitation. |
KunleOshob:More so, the very manner of thinking about the world about us has implicit in it the sense of an Author. The only thing that allows anyone to undergo cognitive processes while denying the existence of an Author is the ability we have to withstand Cognitive Dissonance. This is what baffled Nietzsche in his parable of the Madman. http://www.historyguide.org/europe/madman.html |
There are denotations and connotations in every word or phrase. If you are enquiring into the humanity of Jesus then there are less offensive ways to go about it. You do realise that discussion of a person Instruments would be considered, at best, insensitive in european culture and definately so in nigerian cultures. I don't know about cameroon, though. However in the context of your other posts it is quite clear to me that your words carry a connotation intended to insult. Anyway sha, I've answered your questions on the Paul Kurtz thread and I am waiting for your response. https://www.nairaland.com/nigeria/topic-148054.0.html |
[size=20pt]Let this thread and the OP stand as a testament to the vitriolic and hate infested state of Huxley's mind. What is the Rational line of enquiry that is pursued here? [/size] |
. . . So Huxley How do you INVENT an ethical system that is free from the spectre of Existentialism? If not you, then how has Paul Kurtz done so? Do you know what existentialism is? Just in case you don't: Existential philosophy is characterized by what has been called the "explicit conceptual manifestation of an existential attitude"[5] that begins with a sense of disorientation and confusion in the face of an apparently meaningless or absurd world.[6][7]From here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Existentialism |
THE MADMAN----Have you not heard of that madman who lit a lantern in the bright morning hours, ran to the market place, and cried incessantly: "I seek God! I seek God!"---As many of those who did not believe in God were standing around just then, he provoked much laughter. Has he got lost? asked one. Did he lose his way like a child? asked another. Or is he hiding? Is he afraid of us? Has he gone on a voyage? emigrated?---Thus they yelled and laughed The madman jumped into their midst and pierced them with his eyes. "Whither is God?" he cried; "I will tell you. We have killed him---you and I. All of us are his murderers. But how did we do this? How could we drink up the sea? Who gave us the sponge to wipe away the entire horizon? What were we doing when we unchained this earth from its sun? Whither is it moving now? Whither are we moving? Away from all suns? Are we not plunging continually? Backward, sideward, forward, in all directions? Is there still any up or down? Are we not straying, as through an infinite nothing? Do we not feel the breath of empty space? Has it not become colder? Is not night continually closing in on us? Do we not need to light lanterns in the morning? Do we hear nothing as yet of the noise of the gravediggers who are burying God? Do we smell nothing as yet of the divine decomposition? Gods, too, decompose. God is dead. God remains dead. And we have killed him. "How shall we comfort ourselves, the murderers of all murderers? What was holiest and mightiest of all that the world has yet owned has bled to death under our knives: who will wipe this blood off us? What water is there for us to clean ourselves? What festivals of atonement, what sacred games shall we have to invent? Is not the greatness of this deed too great for us? Must we ourselves not become gods simply to appear worthy of it? There has never been a greater deed; and whoever is born after us---for the sake of this deed he will belong to a higher history than all history hitherto." Here the madman fell silent and looked again at his listeners; and they, too, were silent and stared at him in astonishment. At last he threw his lantern on the ground, and it broke into pieces and went out. "I have come too early," he said then; "my time is not yet. This tremendous event is still on its way, still wandering; it has not yet reached the ears of men. Lightning and thunder require time; the light of the stars requires time; deeds, though done, still require time to be seen and heard. This deed is still more distant from them than most distant stars---and yet they have done it themselves. It has been related further that on the same day the madman forced his way into several churches and there struck up his requiem aeternam deo. Led out and called to account, he is said always to have replied nothing but: "What after all are these churches now if they are not the tombs and sepulchers of God?" - Friedrich Nietzsche |
Chrisbenogor:You are a very wise man and the Atheist with the most integrity on Nairaland. Yes sir, a gentleman and a scholar. |
I was raised in a Christian family in Cameroon and my family was a religious vagrant, moving from catholicism, seven days adventism to apostolic to full gospel to . . . I started having doubts about the claims of religion when we were SDA and as you may know SDA are great stickler for the bible and I did read the bible alot as a teenager. I was about 11 when my family converted from Catholicism to SDA, and my ever abiding memory as a new SDA convert was the criticism I would get from my Catholic friends that we were encourage to read the bible, together with the mockery of going to church on saturdays while everyone else went on Sunday. Nice story, Huxley. However you forgot to add the episode where your best friend died when you were very young and you were distraught and blamed God for it. |
This is an excellent question. I have often tried to make the distinction between carrying the title of Christian on the head and actually living the christian life. This is a very important distinction and one that Christ makes himself. "How terrible it will be for you, scribes and Pharisees, you hypocrites! You are like whitewashed tombs that look beautiful on the outside but inside are full of dead people's bones and every kind of impurity. I know for certain that it is not the professing of christianity that makes one a christian. On this forum I've been accused of being all sorts from being an atheist (simply for agreeing with evolution) to being a babalawo (for having knowledge of Ifa) etc. Over the last few weeks I've given some thought to these accusations (I say 'accusations' because they were phrased as accusations). While I've not being initiated into Ifa so I cannot by any means be called a babalawo there are many precepts found in Ifa that I agree with and would strive to live my life by. If the aim of Ifa is to achieve Iwa Pele, that is a harmonious state of being, then I share that ambition. I might go about it differently from the way most Ifa worshippers go about it but I appreciate the common goal. Outwardly then I am not a babalawo but inwardly I might even be more aligned to it than the initiates. When I read the Tao Teh Ching, I find many precepts that I can apply to my life and take. Does that make me a Taoist? Just because I am not wearing the label and going to the group meetings many Taoists might say 'no' I'm not one of them. But really? Does it require recognition by A group to become a member of the religion? I don't believe that anywhere in the world God leaves himself without a witness such that any discerning person can perceive. The heavens declare the glory of God. 1 The heavens are telling of the glory of God; And their expanse is declaring the work of His hands. 2 Day to day pours forth speech, And night to night reveals knowledge. 3 There is no speech, nor are there words; Their voice is not heard. 4 Their line has gone out through all the earth, And their utterances to the end of the world. True knowledge of God is all around us. My position is that all these tags and labels are highly overrated and are often quite meaningless. Most christians are christian in nothing but the name, while many others are very christian in everything but the name. |
huxley:By Spirituality I meant reality that is not based or composed of Material bodies. ie not composed of matter and extended in space. I was surprised that you feigned not understanding my post. Perhaps you are not feigning but actually did not understand so I'll try to explain what I was saying by rephrasing it. I said: At 02:35 the interviewer says, "you have spent the lion share of your career, Paul, searching for ethical alternatives to religiosity".To find an alternative to something you must first have an idea of what that thing does, what it's function is. Then you seek out something else that can fulfill that function equally or better. This statement suggests that he recognises that religion does provide a useful function. However I make the point that there is a lot more to religion than the provision of ethics. I say: Spirituality is based on experience. To say it was invented to give us ethics is like saying light was invented so that we can play darts. Of course not. We can see light because it exists and we have an organ with which to perceive it. It is a happy consequence of this that we can therefore play darts. If one now claims to be able to play darts blindfolded and then argues that subsequently there is no need for sight . . . well . . . I don't know what to say about that. An alternative approach to ethics does not invalidate religion as neither does the ability to play darts blindfolded invalidate sight.I've defined spirituality above. So I'll rephrase: Awareness of non material entities is derived from the experience of them and they are not an invention for the purpose of creating ethics. I drew an analogy with light and playing darts. Light is not invented so that we can play darts but rather we can play darts as a happy consequence of having light and being able to see. Likewise religion is not invented so we can have ethics but rather we have ethics as a happy consequence of being spiritually aware. I said: This all rests on whether or not there is an experiential basis for spirituality.And that is the crux of the matter. It is not about definitions and ontologies but rather about experience. And if the experience is indescribable that does not invalidate it as a reality. There are many real things that we see in everyday life that we cannot properly describe either. We are often lost for words etc. And such things are not even on par with spiritual things. Now all that wasn't even the main thrust of my criticism, but rather the misappropriation of philosophical terms. you asked: Was hard to make any sense to what you were saying here. To help me out, can you give your understanding of the following words/concept and how they relate to what you just said and to what Paul Kurtz is saying. Please, don't beat about too much as you have done above.I don't know how directly quoting Plato is beating about too much. I'll try again, but I must quote Plato, because he is an authority in greek philosophy. Plato discusses cosmology in his book Timaeus, yes? In this book he says this: We must in my opinion begin by distinguishing between that which always is and never becomes (ie. the eternal) from that which is always becoming but never is (the temporal).In other words he is saying that there is an eternal reality and a temporal reality. The Eternal is the world of BEING. While the Temporal world is the world of BECOMING. There is a distinction between things Being, and remaining in their state of Being and Things BECOMING, ie in flux in a state of constant change. Things are continually becoming. If you cannot grasp these concepts that you should just stop deceiving yourself and give up on philosophy altogether. Plato then says: The one is apprehensible by INTELLIGENCE with the aid of REASONING, being eternally the same, the other is the object of opinion and irrational sensation, coming to be and ceasing to be, but never fully realAnd there's your definition for you. Reason and Intelligence are the faculties that we use to perceive Eternal things, while opinion and irrational sensation are what we use to perceive Temporal things. I agree that the use of these terms have changed over the centuries and irrational sensation is now equated with Reason but Plato would be shocked at this development. Today, the word Sensible is now the same as intelligent. When they say you are a sensible guy, you are being praised. Yet originally it meant to be overly affected by the senses, to be influenced by the emotions. Sensibility refers to an acute perception of or responsiveness toward something, such as the emotions of another. This concept emerged in eighteenth-century Britain, and was closely associated with studies of sense perception as the means through which knowledge is gathered. It also became associated with sentimental moral philosophy.From here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sensibility So I hope I've answered your request to define Reason and Rationality. And as regards devotees looking outward to find God, I believe we've covered that extensively enough already. All that's left is to answer the charge of caricaturing religion. You said: In fact, it was this carricaturing of your own religion, blatantly refusing to acknowledge what YOUR religions says that caused me to not respond. What is the point of responding when you are being blatantly dishonest. Was this willful dishonesty or was it out of ignorance? The latter is excusable, but the former is NOT.What is a caricature? A caricature is either a portrait that exaggerates or distorts the essence of a person or thing to create an easily identifiable visual likeness, or in literature, a description of a person using exaggeration of some characteristics and oversimplification of others.[1]From wikipedia (don't you just love wikipedia) Is there any portrayal, portraiture, description of anything by anyone where the person is not picking on a few salient points and using that to represent the whole things. This is true whether rhetorically, or in literature, or in visual art. No artist can pick up every nuance of a persons face but limits himself to a few lines that he feels captures a certain essence of the subject. Is this not so? Caricatures are loaded with meanings. The meanings are those that the artist intends to portray. Even photography which should have the minimum of artifice becomes an artform where the artist/photography manipulates light to bring out certain characteristics that he is trying to portray. Does the photography misrepresent his subject by doing so? So I don't know what the accusations are, especially as this thread is not about religion, but rather about the false claims of Mr. Paul Kurtz. When you say this: I shall deal with the rest later when you have address this and you begin to straighten up and present your religion as it is ordinarily understood, rather than the carricature you are wont to present.. . . you are basically saying that you don't want to discuss the issue of Paul Kurtz talking kaka. That's like me saying that I will not discuss with you until you change your name back from Huxley to T. Paine. What has your name got to do with anything? What has my understanding of religion got to do with the fact that he is misappropriation philosophical jargon. I will not deny that religion can and has been used to manipulate people, or that religious devotees often Look for God as for something outside of themselves (either in idols or in pastors or in gurus etc), however to make the sweeping statement that this is what religion does is wrong. There is ample evidence in every religious tradition that this is not the case. Is it caricaturing to point out this evidence? [quote][/quote] |
This post https://www.nairaland.com/nigeria/topic-148054.32.html#msg2477582 shows why I know kurtz is wrong about philosophy. Especially where he claims that his 'philosophy' stretches back to Athens. |
huxley:I made a mistake. I overlooked that that was a question. I meant that religion DOES say to look within to find the God, and that Kurtz was wrong by saying that religion says look outward. I'll restate my position for clarification: 1.The Kingdom of God is Within you. 2.Knowledge of God and atonement with God is a source of Great benefits. huxley:I believe that my first long post discussing the video already does that. He misappropriates a lot of philosophical terms, for a start. |
My brother it is either you want to talk about Paul Kurtz - the great intellectual, or you don't want to talk about Paul Kurtz the great intellectual. which is it? huxley:The words that you say have evoked such strong sentiments (highlighted in red) were that Paul Kurtz was demonstrating little knowledge of philosophy or religion. If you disagree then what you have to do is tell me how he demonstrates that he actually has this knowledge. When you go on at length about some issue that has no bearing on the subject of discussion then I sorry to say but that is a RANT. Take a strong view about the violence of religion when we are discussing the violence of religion, by all means. Otherwise it is an aside, which is okay in small doses, but if it goes on at length then it is a RANT. Did you check out the meaning of the word rant? huxley:It does suit me a lot more and I will answer the question in the affirmative. God is a source of help and many benefits. And to contrast this with what Mr Kurtz is saying that humans (without God) can solve all their problems by themselves, I know that to be absolute kaka. Can you demonstrate or even suggest an argument as to how this will be possible? By the way, Religion does not necessarily take man out of the center of the equation (as it were) but rather seeks to make Man whole, complete, fulfilled, ie fully man. In order for man to be fully man he must come to atonement with God. This is my religious stand, just to make this clear. |
A rant is a speech or text that does not present a well-researched and calm argument.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rant_(disambiguation) rant [rant] Show IPAhttp://dictionary.reference.com/browse/rant |
Please Huxley, don't get me angry. The issue is not whether or not your rant was true or untrue. The point is that your rant was Irrelevant! The interviewer say that Kurtz is seeking an ethical alternative to religion and I respond that ethics is a product of religion but not what religion is necessarily about. Then you started to rant about religions has historically caused this ills and that ills. What did you smoke man? |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 259 260 (of 287 pages)



