PastorAIO's Posts
Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 277 278 279 280 281 282 283 284 285 (of 287 pages)
KAG:Okay I'll make a deal with you. I promise I'll honestly and with integrity consider the beam in my eye. Would you promise to look also to your own prejudices though they may only be a mote (compared to my beam). |
KAG: KAG:Okay Mr. Mechanical Engineer. I can presume that you have a high knowledge of mechanics. Is it or is it not possible to invent a machine that is sensitive to it's environment to such a high degree that it seems to be aware and reacts to the slightest changes in the environment. There is a website called AskJeeves.com whom you can ask questions and it will respond accordingly. Is AskJeeves aware? An entity or a body responding to it's environment is not a sign of awareness. Tree leaves swaying in response to the passing breeze is not a sign of awareness. So though you are 'acknowledging my questions, parsing them, and responding accordingly' that tells me nothing about whether you are aware or not. AI can do the same. So this: The easiest argument is to point out that I am fully cognizant of being an I. That I can postulate that indicates awareness. [/b] is not an argument to prove your awareness. I don't know that you're cognizant of anything. Not anymore than any of those clever japanese robots. You are just a more sophisticated version of AI. I can never know that you have the experience of awareness. The experience itself is much too subjective. I quote Keith Augustine (a naturalist): One of the most persistent difficulties for reductive physicalism has been the apparent inability of physicalistic explanations to capture qualitative features of conscious experience. It has been persuasively argued that qualia--the experiential feels of 'what it is like' to be in a conscious mental state--cannot be captured by any physicalistic explanations in principle because physicalistic explanations inherently refer to objective or public features of phenomena, whereas the experiential features of consciousness are inherently subjective or private (Teller 1992, pp. 190-191). While such arguments for the irreducibility of consciousness are not the last word on the subject, they have not been decisively refuted either--at least not in the view of several prominent philosophers. Although such difficulties may be resolved in the future, their current resistance to a clear resolution that gains widespread acceptance gives us good reason to resist simply identifying the natural with the physical. This was taken from here: http://www.infidels.org/library/modern/keith_augustine/thesis.html I was furnished with this source by either you or Huxley. It could be Huxley actually and I remain grateful. As far as I know consciousness does not exhibit any qualities that someone else can now come and measure. The only effect that consciousness/awareness exhibits is the subjective effect that it has on the conscious person. Every other effect exhibited by the human being and observable by others can be explained by neurology. You don't need to be conscious to respond to questions if your brain has been programmed with the appropriate answers. I'm on the cusp of giving up this thread completely but I'll persevere if we can make headway with just this point. |
So did anybody try this?? |
I do not think that what is practiced in most nigerian churches is actually religion. So I don't think religion is holding nigeria back. Extortion and Brain washing. That is holding nigeria back. People go to church in nigeria and come out hungry. CAn you imagine that? EVen if you had breakfast before you went, by the time you've endured the entire length of the service you will come out hungry. What kind of service is that? What are they serving that it leaves you drained not replenished. Is that religion? People who pour their energies into futile endeavours will reap the futility. |
It is spirituality that has a herbal undertone. |
KAG:In other words you are saying that something that hops like a frog, croaks like is frog, and is wet and slimy like a frog must be an orangutang. Just how many 'superficial' properties must be shared in common before it is no longer equivocation. That they both refer to the chosen is not the entire basis of my argument but it is a point to be considered. Please don't embarrass yourself with that talk about Zeus. If you know nothing about Greek Cosmogony it will not be held against you so you don't need to embarrass yourself by spouting crap. Go and read Hesiod. The World is created by Eros (love) who emerged out of Primal Chaos. Then other beings are created through Ouranos and Gaia. These two give birth to the Titans and Cronus is one of them. Cronus kills ouranos and gives birth to the Gods including Zeus. Zeus eventually Killed Cronus and thus became the king of the Gods. That is how Zeus came to be. He is not the creator of the world by any means. It seems that your knowledge is half baked. Perhaps you are just a dilettante which is cool but you ought to be aware that when you take a cursory glance at something and then quickly form an opinion or have[b] 'an idea of the concept'[/b] you should consider the fact that you could also be getting the wrong end of the stick completely. |
Mr. KAG I have been so totally flummoxed by your standpoint that it has taken me this long to respond. Where does one start? KAG:I am yet to understand the distinction between awareness and consciousness. But for your sake I will restate my position thus, that Awareness is a totally subjective experience and it cannot be communicated to another. I can never know if you are an aware being or not. It is more likely that you are a cleverly programmed machine. Greater minds than yours in the Atheist camp have conceded this fact. KAG:Well I invite you to present your argument that will convince me that you are aware of your existence. And far from consciousness not being the point ( it might not be central to your point, but that is because you are not familiar with the territory covered by this issue) it is at the very core of the point. KAG:To better contrast the difference between us, you have 'an idea of concepts' while I have Experiential knowledge. Almost everything you are saying just demonstrates your ignorance and you inability to think with Reason rather than regurgitate the textbooks and notes that you studied in university, concepts written and taught by people who are (importantly) not practitioners of the disciplines that they teach. It's the classic example of the blind leading the blind and now they are all writhing in the gutter. It is not extolling the unknown to say that God cannot be conceptualised or fit into the categories of human thought. However we are endowed with other faculties through which we can experience him. |
KAG:My entire argument is not based on the fact that both terms refer to being chosen. On numerous points the two are seen to be identical. They are creators and give form to the world. But I've already stated a lot of these points. Christ predates everything. |
KAG:By awareness I take it you mean consciousness. Of all the things we know for sure in Life Consciousness is the most subjective. It is such a totally subjective experience that it cannot be demonstrated in anyway whatsoever. (Which is a point I was going to bring up in another thread but I got distracted, but there are two types of Proof. Demonstrable proof and subjective proof. Subjective proof cannot be demonstrated and so cannot be raised in an argument to convince someone else.) I know for sure that I am conscious because I experience it. I can never know for a fact whether or not you are a conscious being. It can never be demonstrated to me, your consciousness. It could be that you are a very clever automaton or some form of Artificial Intelligence. They have AI now that can have conversations and appear to think like conscious humans but in actually fact it is just sophisticated programming. How am I sure that you are not just a cleverly neurologically programmed automaton. I'll never know if you are in actual fact conscious because you cannot demonstrate or communicate that to me. I, for reasons of my own, actually believe that the entire universe is conscious, from the Rocks to the wind blowing through the trees down to Space and time itself. And as for perception which is the ability to receive and retain information, everything can receive information. A plasticene receives information when you imprint it with a stamp. There are many qualities of consciousness and I fear that you might be taking ego-bound consciousness for the whole of consciousness. KAG:Being on Nairaland I would presume that you are nigerian. Of course that could be wrong, but if you are nigerian and even if you are not yoruba I would presume that you've come into contact with enough of yoruba culture to have some idea of their context. I don't blame you if you say that you've made an effort to avoid yoruba people for most of your life, but even then you ought to have some idea of the culture. I try to learn as much as I can about different african cultures because I feel it is inappropriate that I can quote european classics and yet have so little knowledge of my own motherland. Trust me Ori is a conscious entity in all of Yoruba land and it stretches further. I know in igboland it is called Chi and God almighty is called Chineke which means Great Chi. KAG:Oh, so I see now, the difference between us is that you have 'grasped' the Tao. I don't think that I ever said that anyone who extolled the unknown was a christian. |
KAG:I believe a Christian is a follower of Christ. In the gospel of John Yehoshu'a ben Yosef is identified as the Christ. What is Christ? Greek Christos is the translation of hebrew Messiah which means the anointed one, the Chosen One. Yoruba also call Ori Ayanmo meaning that which is Chosen. They follow the Chosen One. Christianity itself predates the term christian. The term was coined after the movement began. Prior to orthodoxy Christianity was itself a wide host of "conflicting" religions. Although I personally do not see the conflict. |
olabowale:K.oran says that God commanded the angels to bow. Not God commanded the Angels and the Jinn. Iblis should have been exempt from the command then. olabowale:God can make any command that pleases him, but can God contradict himself. Either he wants to be worshipped alone or He wants man included in his worship. olabowale:In other words there are conventions of expressions and jargon that are particular to Islam that an outsider would not understand. Such as reciting one letter merits one to say he has quoted the qoran. This means that the Koran should not be taken as a literal text but should only be interpreted within the islamic conventions. Ultimately the qoran is interpreted by the Ijma. Ijma is a form of islamic democracy, is it not. It means the general consensus. But isn't consensus subject to change like every other thing that humans do. That doesn't sit prettily in myheart to think that the proper way to interpret islam depends on what the majority of people think. Sounds more like politics than spirituality. |
olabowale:1) Iblis. "And behold, We said to the angels: "Bow down to Adam!" They bowed. Not so, however, Iblis, who refused." The Koran then later says, of Iblis, "He was one of the jinn, and he broke the commandment of his lord". Is Iblis an angel or a Jinn. 2) Iblis was punished for not bowing down to Adam. Yet his reason for not bowing to Adam is because God had told him to bow for no one but Allah. He was following his initial instruction. He was punished for an excess of zeal for Allah. 3) O thou, folded in garments! Stand to prayer by night, but not all night - half, or a little less, or a little more: and in slow, measured, rhythmic tones, say forth the Koran. For soon We shall send down to thee a weighty message. This is in the Koran. Should this be a part of the Koran for it plainly suggests that the weighty message was yet to come. 4)What is man made of? Dust and sometimes the koran states. Or from a clot of blood as it other times says. Oh . . and who's blood? ps. did you know that if Jamaican want to yab someone they call them a Bludclat? |
elizabetta:you ask a good question. On the subject of guidance and communication with God it is quite explicit: And I will ask the Father, and he will give you another Counselor to be with you forever-- {17} the Spirit of truth. The world cannot accept him, because it neither sees him nor knows him. But you know him, for he lives with you and will be in you. {18} I will not leave you as orphans; I will come to you. But the Counselor, the Holy Spirit, whom the Father will send in my name, will teach you all things and will remind you of everything I have said to you. The promise was of the Holy spirit to guide us in all things. There was no bible at the time. For many people the bible has usurped the holy spirit and they rather play semantic gymnastics with bits of biblical text then listen to the Spirit. |
KAG:I've mentioned in another thread that the accurate translation of Logos into Yoruba would be to use the word Ori. See what the Yoruba consider as Ori. They consider it a road map of their lives. They believe that prior to coming to this world they knelt before God and pick out an Ori. Ori is often described as destiny or Ayanmo (that which is chosen). Consider these words: Ise meta ni omori odo nse A pestle can be applied to 3 tasks Won a f'ori re gun'yan The head is used to pound yam Won a f'idi re gun elu It's base can be used to grind herbs Won a fi agbedemeji re ti ilekun dain dain dain It's middle part can be used to barricade the doors firmly Thus was declared to Oriseku (the non-starter, or the defective ori) child of Ogun Thus was declared to Ilemere (the short-lived) child of Ija Thus was declared to Afuwape (the fulfilled destiny) child of Agbonmiregun They went to the home of Ajalamopin to each pick themselves an Ori (destiny) They were prescribed Ebo. Only Afuwape tarried to comply. Lament: "If I had known where successful people choose their Ori (destinies) that is where I would have gone to pick mine. If I'd known where Afuwape choose his destiny from that is where I would have gone to choose mine." Response: All Ori (destiny) is chosen at the same place, yet they unfold differently for different individuals. The question that I wanna ask is, Does Ori sound like a being to you here or does it sound merely like a cosmological concept. A concept not dissimilar to Tao perhaps. Or statements like A a ki fi ori w'ori. We do not compare heads, or destinies. In other words don't judge a man's life by the measure of another man's destiny. But then again amongst the same people we find that they pray to their Ori. In fact Ori is the most venerated diety in Yoruba belief. 'Ori mi gbemi, ori mi la mi Gbemi atete niran a tete gbeni ku f'orisa Ori lo ngbeni, kii se Orisa Ori save me, Ori prosper me you are quickest to consider me you are quicker to my aid than Orisha It is Ori that saves one, not the Orisha So my main question is whether the Yoruba consider Ori to be a 'Being' (I'm still not sure what you mean by this though) or just a concept without 'cognizance'. Would you consider Ori to be a being? I would like to suggest that these traditional people were perhaps a bit more sophisticated than you are theologically and the problems lies in your inability to keep up. This same inability can be at the root of your problem with Heraclitus' Logos or the Tao. You see incongruity where they don't. |
This is actually a great question. The sense of identity was created and is part of the human psychological make up. It is an effect of the brain. It is possible for it to abate. For instance there are times when you might 'lose yourself' in a moment, like if you are engrossed in a task of some sort. That is one's sense of identity and self awareness, however such identity that another might form about you is a totally different matter. Someone might point to my physical body and say that is me. But is it? Someone might list a whole heap of characteristics and say that is me. But would it be? Does anyone really get anyone else, or anything else for that matter. Are we all not limited by our perspectives? As soon as we experience something or someone we immediately mold the experience into a concept. Preconceptions too affect the way in which we experience things and conceptualise the experience. So this question does not just apply to God but to everything that we might experience. Who is God? Who or what is anything? Any description is a distinguishing thing. it distinguishes him from other agents that would be described differently. To describe him as the creator of the universe is to distinguish him from other agents it would seem. Yet since everything has it's source and root from creation, actually what that does is it makes him the main Agent in every activities that occurs in the universe. In other words indistinguishable from every other agent. He is the original agent behind the agent. The source and the essence of all beings. Seeing how hard it is to define and distinguish God from any other aspect of the universe I think . . . . hmmmm what do I think? |
What constitutes proof? Evidence? Is seeing really believing? What about the possible of illusion? Would seeing be proof in that case? |
olabowale:Actually, knowing it was but a matter of time the idea was to pre-empt you. |
wisekid:Wise KID IS A wISE KID INDEED!!!! |
Any neutral person reading these posts would reasonably conclude that both parties are deluded and decieved but for reasons probably due to pride cling on to their delusions. "My delusion is greater than yours". The point is that everyone"s criticism is incisive and logical when applied to the others faith but all of a sudden blunt and daft when applied to their own. |
[quote author=~Lady~ link=topic=138395.msg2315489#msg2315489 date=1212165555]Please don't insinuate that Paul was saying he would steal and lie to win people. That's not what those verses are saying. It is saying that in order to win people you have to understand them. To understand them you have to move with them. Does that mean that you have to lie? Absolutely not. In order to win my muuuslim friend and understand her, I had to be close to her, I had to learn about her beliefs and why she believes what she believes. I never once declared anything under All'ah and I never lied. She knew what I was up to and I was open with it. ut I still took my time to know her and understand her. We went out together and sometimes prayed together. I just let the Holy Spirit work through me. So don't make any stupid insinuations, thanks.[/quote]Well done! I'm glad that we've got that covered. |
1 cor 9: 19 - 23 |
huxley:No Answers |
To neatly tie this all up and back into the initial subject of this thread would it be fair to summarise that ideological extremism of any sort whether it be religious or atheistic is detrimental to[b] intellectual integrity[/b] and will be a blight on our academic institutions. It seems obvious to me that to properly pursue knowledge one must be open to wherever the quest may lead and it is harmful to harbour prejudices or to be rigid in your preconceptions. Ultimately these will lead to a willful distortion of the truth. Another good example is Nazi science. |
KAG:The entire gospel is based on the fact that reality is a duality. The duality of flesh and spirit. There are two possibilities. Logos was a specialised term, a jargon, that belonged only to christianity and which christians understood in a sense quite different from how other people understood it. Or it was meant in the general sense in which case the Evangelist is laying claim to something that predates christianity. Does this make it any less christian? What about if Paul the apostle goes to Greece and finds there a shrine that has been raised to an unknown god. And he then subsequently starts to preach to the people about their shrine that he found in their country. Was that just opportunism? Or were the Greeks worshipping the christian god without knowing it. Could they thus qualify to be called Christians? |
Just a thought: was the word in common usage at the time the gospel was written. in what sense was it meant. and was the evangelist aware that there could perhaps be misconstruing of what he meant. |
The evangelist make no mention of a trinity |
KAG:Logos is not a concept for me. It is not definable. and if by cognizant you mean conscious then I would say 'he'( as per convention) is he above categorisation into conscious or not conscious. The more talk we carry on about this the more we will come to the point where we have to recognise that we are talking about something beyond human conceptions and which can only be experienced as a mystery. |
KAG:I think I ought to wait for Syrup to come speak for herself. But while it's you talking KAG, . . . I think that you are falling into the same trap of allowing categorisations and constructs to cloud your thinking. A discussion about the creator of the universe is a discussion about the creator of the universe whether or not you frame it in theology or philosophy. KAG:You're kidding.!! I would have thought from the forceful and determined way you posted that you had a fixed definition that you wanted to put across. Maybe that's just your writing style. My definition of religion is the practice of making whole something that is deemed to be fractured. For instance the relationship between a man and his diety. Religion is the act of seeking reconciliation. Yet it does not just apply to the relationship between a man and his diety, but also a man and his environment, and a man and the different parts of his being. Though the etymology of the word religion is unsure I am inclined to accepted the explanation that it comes from the latin roots Re Ligere. To bind back, or to bind again. I take it that you are an expert on the Tao too. What makes you so sure that the Tao is not conscious? I really wish you had your notes so I know better where you are coming from. I suspect that you are making some humungous assumptions about stuff you know nothing about. All I can say for now is that I hope you are aware that Taoism is a practice and those that are steeped in this practice are unequivocal about one thing. 'The Tao that you can talk about is not the real Tao'. The same thing goes for philosophy. That is not to knock your conception or understanding of what you have read which might even actually be an elegant conceptualisation. But ultimately it is just a conception. ps. What constitutes a 'being'? |
Well I'm sorry you consider it a joke. I'm not laughing so you'd better say something funny quick or just scram. |
KAG:You should tell Syrup that. She is the one that suggests that it's use in philosophy makes it untenable as a religious factor. (or that is how i understand it, if I'm wrong perhaps she would like to explain what it is she actually means.) I don't think the two are mutually exclusive and perhaps you don't like the word 'encroaching' so I withdraw that and say instead that they overlap. KAG:So by your definition is Buddhism a religion? Is Taoism a religion? I actually understand religion to be something other than the worship of a particular diety but that would be too petty if we reduced this to an argument over the definition of a word. For the purposes of this thread I will accept your definition. The Logos is the source and creator of the universe however ever Heraclitus is not religious because though he believed in the Logos he did not advocate worshipping it. I'll grant you that. What I really need you to explain to me is how you arrived at the notion from studying Heraclitus that he wasn't talking about a 'being of substance', whatever that is. I don't actually understand what you mean by that phrase but perhaps it will become clear as you explain. How can Heraclitus' logos which is the source, the creator, the molder of the universe, whose plan we had best adhere to in order to live a good life, . . . how is this different from the christian understanding of Logos? KAG:What do you think of this quote from Christ. 'Before Abraham, I am'. Or of all the mentions of Christ 'prior' to Christianity. All the prophets. Of Melchizedek. Of the salvation of those who lived before Christ. Did not the Law and the Prophets bear witness to this. The Logos precedes genesis and has been at work through out all of history. Those that know him are Christians whether the term or the religion christianity had been coined by that time or not. And as for those that don't know. . . Well you've got semantics. |
I've got an argument for you. It goes . , no and no and no and no again. . . .no . NO! no. nonononono. What are the steps of reasoning, how do I arrive at my point. Well, let's not let that minor detail bother us. no no no nno!! 'They told me to go to rehab I said NO NO NO' |
syrup:I'm really sorry but there is no way that you are going to convince me that left serves as an opposite of up. From what I learnt in school it lies on a totally different axis. left too is part of a pair and it is opposed by right. forward by backward. Your reasoning is like responding to a statement such as 'A man is either Rich or Poor' with the assertions that 'but he is married'. Of course they are related in the sense that they are states of being, just like left, right, up and down are related in the sense that they are directions. Or in fact everything is connected inthe sense that we are all part of creation. But that has nothing to do with the fact that everything is paired with an opposite that is mutually exclusive to it. You cannot move upward and downward at the same time. you can move forward and upward at the same time. ergo forward and upward are not opposite to each other. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 277 278 279 280 281 282 283 284 285 (of 287 pages)
