Christianity Etc › Re: A World Without God And Death of Civilization! by PastorAIO: 11:48am On Dec 20, 2016 |
Anas09: Move along then. Ah, this must be xtian-ese for 'I've got no answer to your points'. |
Christianity Etc › Re: A World Without God And Death of Civilization! by PastorAIO: 11:46am On Dec 20, 2016 |
I cannot speak for Agent of Allah. I cannot only say how I understand him. Can you present the post where he discussed both social and biological evolution and then concentrated on social, so that we can discuss it? I agree with almost everything else that you say except when you ask if incest could improve our civilisation. I just think that is not a valid question. That is like asking if interracial breeding would improve civilisation. or the breeding of tall people with short people. First, we have to know what we mean by improvement of civilisation. Second, as we know that culture is contributed to by individuals, we have to ask if there is any special quality that individual inbred children will have that will either advance or hinder civilisation. Is there any type of breeding that will improve the qualities in individuals necessary for the advancement of a civilisation? etc shadeyinka: The quote that lead to my reply is presented:
-AgentofAllah described both biological and social evolution and he concentrated on social evolution as the cause of aversion towards incest. Hence the reason I made the difference. Social evolution needs a proof, there are usually reasons why the culture of a community change over time and they can be traced. If incest came as a result of social evolution, what are the evidences?
Its just a scientific fact. When inbreeding is sufficiently done, the organism loose out and most likely will become extinct. Its a known fact.
In every norm, there would be aberrations and that is why we are human. We can choose whatever we want for ourselves whether nature agrees with it or not. So, if our society (because we are now wiser and the god factor is now known to be a fable) agrees to allow incest, would it make our civilization better? |
|
Christianity Etc › Re: What is The Essence Of The Church And Christianity? by PastorAIO: 10:21am On Dec 20, 2016 |
Ubenedictus: yeah, he did preach about salvation, repent and believe, born of water and spirit, obey d commandments...yeah he taught about salvation, but all that seem preprogrammed to his death, his life finds meaning in his death and so does his teaching, only by dying does d grain bear. no death no fruit. Why do you say that it all seemed preprogrammed to his death? Can you give an example of a teaching of his (e.g 'if you would be perfect go and sell all you have, give to the poor, and come follow me. ) and how it preprogrammes his death? |
Christianity Etc › Re: A World Without God And Death of Civilization! by PastorAIO: 10:17am On Dec 20, 2016 |
Please next time you want me to answer your post you go park well. It is hard enough unravelling your convoluted lack of understanding but to then have to start copy and pasting to reformat is too annoying. availableisme: hmmm...
Darwin's TOE is still the go to model for seeking explanations for Everything. Literally everything. The fact that the theory is still undergoing development doesn't change that. In fact, everything in science can be developed or reviewed at any point.
Arguing into the future is not a healthy way to state facts. Evolution theory is still in its infancy and can only account for less than 10% of any form of knowledge so why use it as an authority when its still in the works. If something isnt conclusive then its not a go to model for anything YET!
Spontaneous order, also named self-organization in the hard sciences, is the spontaneous emergence of order out of seeming chaos. -https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spontaneous_order
Again order cannot emerge from chaos. Statistics refutes this. We can statistically attempt this and show the probability of its oocurence going by the acclaimed age of the earth and if we arrive at a figure like 1 in a quadrillion would you still think it would be possible for order to emerge from chaos especially when the said order from chaos had to repeat itself in millions of ways. Can anyone be that lucky?
Groups of human beings, left free to each regulate themselves, tend to produce spontaneous order, rather than the meaningless chaos often feared. This has been observed in society at least since Chuang Tzu in ancient China. A classic traffic roundabout is a good example, with cars moving in and out with such effective organization that some modern cities have begun replacing stoplights at problem intersections with traffic circles [4], and getting better results. Open-source software and Wiki projects form an even more compelling illustration. - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergence#Spontaneous_order
You are talking about evolution and now you shift to humans. Was evolution intelligent or random? Choose one please?
Anger, hatred, and bitterness can be easily explained by Evolution Theory. They serve to further an individuals success in the intense competition called life.
So love does not further ones intense competition in the evolutionary process? Is incest not love based? |
Christianity Etc › Re: A World Without God And Death of Civilization! by PastorAIO: 10:11am On Dec 20, 2016*. Modified: 11:49am On Dec 20, 2016 |
Anas09: You mean Jacob committed incest with his wives?
Sarai was not Abram's mother's daughter. Good try at grapping straws. Grapping (sic) straws, bwahahahahahahaha!! So in your dictionary incest is only when it's your mother's daughter. Sharing the same father doesn't count. Inside me and you who is really grapping straws? |
Christianity Etc › Re: A World Without God And Death of Civilization! by PastorAIO: 10:09am On Dec 20, 2016 |
KingEbukasBlog: All are assumptions . Anything about emotions in evolution is based on assumptions .
What about embarrassment , shame and feeling humiliated , they didn't make the cut ? Sorry o. Yes, Embarrassment, shame and humiliation can also be explained using evolution theory. Does that suffice or are there anymore emotions that you think I may have missed? |
Christianity Etc › Re: A World Without God And Death of Civilization! by PastorAIO: 10:01am On Dec 20, 2016 |
Anas09: I have explained that you in another post.
Who was Laban? A Syrian or a Jew?
Who was Abram? A Mesopotemian or Jew?
Abram was a Mesopotemian married according to their custom, Abraham was a Hebrew a Friend of Yahweh.
At the time of ignorance(Before the law was given), the Lord Winked at... This before the Law after the Law shizzle has no traction with me. Humans have always had Morality. It is part of what makes us human. Meaning that we have always known what is right from wrong. Law of moses or Not. The LORD saw that the wickedness of man was great in the earth, and that every intention of the thoughts of his heart was only evil continually.Genesis 6:5 I wonder how these people in genesis were judged to be evil since there was no Law, and if you follow the story to the end it is obvious that god was not just content to wink at them. Nay, he flooded the whole earth on account of their wickedness. So abeg if you wanna use a lousy excuse like that find someone else that is more gullible than me. |
Christianity Etc › Re: A World Without God And Death of Civilization! by PastorAIO: 9:53am On Dec 20, 2016 |
shadeyinka: I guess you should clearly separate social evolution from biological evolution.
Use goats for example, they have been doing inbreeding forbso long that by your theory of evolution, they should be wiped out by now.
Social evolution is a cause-effect thing hence, we must be able to show historical facts of how peoples behaviours were modified over time to the new social born. I have no idea what you're talking about here. I mentioned Darwin's theory of evolution, usually that is taken to mean biological evolution. I don't see what difference making a distinction with Social evolution would make. The Goats thing? I don't understand what you are saying. Humans do inbreeding too. Plants can pollinate themselves. etc etc. There is nowhere where you can quote me for saying that inbreeding species will be wiped out. I really don't know where you pulled that one out of. Human beings are hardwired with a Survival Instinct, a will to live. That doesn't mean that people cannot and do not commit suicide everyday. Does the fact of suicide mean that Survival Instinct doesn't exist? |
Christianity Etc › Re: A World Without God And Death of Civilization! by PastorAIO: 11:23am On Dec 19, 2016 |
Lennycool: Incest is practically supported in the Bible. And the societies that practice incest are largely theistic. Too much incest in theistic societies throughout history. |
Christianity Etc › Re: A World Without God And Death of Civilization! by PastorAIO: 11:21am On Dec 19, 2016 |
KingEbukasBlog: All are assumptions . Anything about emotions in evolution is based on assumptions .
What about embarrassment , shame and feeling humiliated , they didn't make the cut ? These are all easily explained by evolution theories. |
Christianity Etc › Re: A World Without God And Death of Civilization! by PastorAIO: 11:19am On Dec 19, 2016 |
Anas09: You mean Jacob committed incest with his wives?
Sarai was not Abram's mother's daughter. Good try at grapping straws. Genesis 29: 14 Then Laban said to him, “You are my own flesh and blood.” After Jacob had stayed with him for a whole month, 15 Laban said to him, “Just because you are a relative of mine, should you work for me for nothing? Tell me what your wages should be.” 16 Now Laban had two daughters; the name of the older was Leah, and the name of the younger was Rachel. 17 Leah had weak eyes, but Rachel had a lovely figure and was beautiful. 18 Jacob was in love with Rachel and said, “I’ll work for you seven years in return for your younger daughter Rachel.” Genesis 20:12 And yet indeed she is my sister; she is the daughter of my father, but not the daughter of my mother; and she became my wife. |
Christianity Etc › Re: A World Without God And Death of Civilization! by PastorAIO: 10:58am On Dec 19, 2016 |
availableisme: Is Sexual Immorality encouraged or a Sin in the Bible? If yes can you say a Christian who commits it is still a Christian? But Biblical Patriarchs were all incestuous. |
Christianity Etc › Re: A World Without God And Death of Civilization! by PastorAIO: 10:54am On Dec 19, 2016 |
availableisme: I know about evolution and it does not explain everything contrary to what you might think. Its still a hypothesis in the works. Statistically randomness cannot produce order so lets not go there.
If Natural selection is true then why did it not also deal with anger and hatred and bitterness since they are all emotional driven same way incest, homosexuality and sodomy are? hmmm... Darwin's TOE is still the go to model for seeking explanations for Everything. Literally everything. The fact that the theory is still undergoing development doesn't change that. In fact, everything in science can be developed or reviewed at any point. Statistically randomness cannot produce order so lets not go there. Spontaneous order, also named self-organization in the hard sciences, is the spontaneous emergence of order out of seeming chaos. - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spontaneous_order Groups of human beings, left free to each regulate themselves, tend to produce spontaneous order, rather than the meaningless chaos often feared. This has been observed in society at least since Chuang Tzu in ancient China. A classic traffic roundabout is a good example, with cars moving in and out with such effective organization that some modern cities have begun replacing stoplights at problem intersections with traffic circles [4], and getting better results. Open-source software and Wiki projects form an even more compelling illustration. - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergence#Spontaneous_orderAnger, hatred, and bitterness can be easily explained by Evolution Theory. They serve to further an individuals success in the intense competition called life. |
Christianity Etc › Re: A World Without God And Death of Civilization! by PastorAIO: 10:16am On Dec 19, 2016 |
availableisme: Is there proof that evolution deselected incest? If it did then why do people still either practice it or have cravings towards it? Why didnt evolution also deselect homosexuality or Hatred or bitterness as those are all emotionally driven same way incest is. Darwin's theory has 2 factors. The First is Randomness. The second is Natural Selection. Randomness produces all sorts of traits, but the Natural selection part favours some of the traits more than others. |
Christianity Etc › Re: A World Without God And Death of Civilization! by PastorAIO: 10:10am On Dec 19, 2016 |
availableisme: [/b]
I always try to stay on topic so try and do same please. I am too focused to be baited.
You are actually giving proof to what i am saying. Who determines where evolutionary involvement begins and when it ends when there are so many emotionally driven vices around. So why say incest was an evolutionary deselection when it most likely isnt. I thought the topic was about Incest. As far as I can see the topic is a disingenuous attempt to link our innate aversion for Incest to Atheism in order to make us feel repulsed by incest. However it fails to take into account the fact that the bible is full of incest, approved of by Yahweh. Who determines where evolutionary involvement begins and when it ends To someone who understands the full scope of Evolution theory it's involvement is all encompassing, it is used to explain absolutely every phenomena. In other words it begins everywhere and doesn't ever end. |
Christianity Etc › Re: A World Without God And Death of Civilization! by PastorAIO: 10:03am On Dec 19, 2016 |
Muafrika2: It has already been tested:
Hitlers Germany, The Marxism of the Soviet Union The Chinese and their Maoism
Terrible results¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ ... but These are not atheists govt...... Oh, Whatever? It's like talking to a brick wall. Please do some research and add the Atheist Empire of Ashoka the Great of the Mauryan Empire to your list of atheist nations. |
Christianity Etc › Re: A World Without God And Death of Civilization! by PastorAIO: 9:59am On Dec 19, 2016 |
availableisme: Who says people are not attracted to members of their family? There are those who would disagree which is why we have incest in the first place. There are those who know no other attraction besides an internal one. Why are they like that? Is it that evolution failed them or is there another reason why they are primed differently from others or grew to become like that? We all have a survival instinct. Yet there are people who commit suicide. Just because you have a few people doing something doesn't mean that Evolution hasn't by and large favoured the opposite. ps. have you any word on Abraham's incestuous relationship with Sarai, his wife? Or Jacob's with Leah and Rebekah? |
Christianity Etc › Re: A World Without God And Death of Civilization! by PastorAIO: 9:53am On Dec 19, 2016 |
Ranchhoddas: People are naturally not attracted to members of their family, the same way we are naturally averse to suicide or mass murder. That is why he said that religion or culture are simply secondary regulators against such behaviour. We are evolutionarily primed to see them as wrong. That's his argument. And further to that I also got an insight. That at no time did he ever espouse Amorality. In fact I don't know any atheists that do so. Atheists are just as moral as christians or moslems. The point he was making was on the SOURCE of the morality. Agentofallah explains the moral impulse in Evolutionary terms. The christians just say 'God did it'. According to Darwin Evolution would naturally select AGAINST incest. That revulsion that we naturally have for incest may later be attributed to a God by superficial persons but the fact that it has it's origins in evolutionary factors remain unchanged. |
Christianity Etc › Re: A World Without God And Death of Civilization! by PastorAIO: 9:47am On Dec 19, 2016 |
You ought to read AgentofAllah's post again. But this time slowly. And thoughtfully. availableisme: First of all, we need to agree on something regarding atheism. Atheism is not by definition a disbelief in God or gods. That is the foundation of atheism and not a final position as there are atheists who disbelieve in God or gods but believe in spirits and reincarnation and...everything that God or gods are which is spirit.
Atheism is a foundation which other things are built on. If the foundation is that they lack belief in God or gods then what is permissible to be built on such a foundation which would still hold to their core belief yet make them comfortable which is why there are different kinds and classes of atheists in the world even here on nairaland.
If an atheist says homosexuality or incest is alright as long as both are adults and its based on mutual agreement then this is like a direct affront to the position of God whom they disbelieve. If they do not believe in God then they also by extension want to assert this by also seeing nothing wrong with those things God abhors otherwise that would mean they are okay with Gods idea of morality.
However if you say that in some nations homosexuality is permitted or even bestiality or perhaps incest as the focus is simply for you to do what makes you happy but does that make it right?
Anas09 painted a very vivid picture in her comment and a mind with a conscience and morals would either be repulsed at the thought of it or seriously think about it.
Not everyone is aware of the problems inbreeding may cause and in fact it does not always cause problems as both parties can have perfectly healthy genes but does that make it right is the question? Is there nothing inherently wrong with it? can you tell me? |
Christianity Etc › Re: A World Without God And Death of Civilization! by PastorAIO: 9:35am On Dec 19, 2016 |
AgentOfAllah: Admittedly, religion, much like culture, promotes certain evolutionarily advantageous traits in terms of norms and taboos. Yet, you're wrong to attribute things you lack an understanding of to theism. Many old religions are silent on endogamy, yet incest has always been a social taboo in societies where these archaic religions were practiced. This makes it clear that religion and culture are merely secondary reinforcers of our aversion to incestuous relationships. In fact, this aversion isn't just human, there is insurmountable evidence that it is panmammalian (see Pusey, A. and M. Wolf (1996). "Inbreeding avoidance in animals." Trends in Ecology & Evolution 11(5): 201-206.).
Clearly, the underlying common denominator here is that incest avoidance is patently a consequence of natural selection. Murray R.D. has addressed this exhaustively in his peer reviewed article (see Murray, R. D. (1980). "The evolution and functional significance of incest avoidance." Journal of Human Evolution 9(3): 173-178.). In his conclusion, he suggests that: "...the primary function of incest avoidance is rooted in the origins of biparental reproduction in that it serves to maximize genetic variability necessary for adaptation. In accord, the human incest taboo is likely an extension of this biological predisposition, which does not exclude its incorporation in a multitude of additional social functions that have been addressed previously by several authors (Levi Strauss, 1970; Slater, 1959)." Obviously, from a natural selection viewpoint, pregnancy (that is, reproductive viability) is the natural factor from which the morality of mammalian aversion to inbreeding is derived, not any culture/religion. So you can't just whimsically assume it is ruled out and then proceed to debunk a hypothetical argument.
That said, having consensual sex with your family members will not cause any kind of far reaching damage to society, nor will it destroy civilisation (except your definition of civilisation has got something to do with sexual practices).
To answer your 3-pronged questions on incest (supposing pregnancy is ruled out, like you say): 1) It is an acceptable way of life. 2) It should neither be encouraged nor discouraged. 3) It was implicit in my explanation above, that morality is a by-product of evolution. Incest is no more (im)moral than exogamy.
While you're apt to contemplate the moral dilemmas of incest, be mindful that it is not a topic to be brushed over with partial reflectiveness. For one, it doesn't help to oversimplify complex human behaviours into religion/culture/morality; and it sure as hell helps to understand the role of cognitive bias in your musings and thought processes.
Finally, atheism has no stance on incest! You may find many atheists opposed to it, as you may find ones favourable towards it. The only stance of atheism (and all atheists) is that there is no evidence for god. The clue is in the definition of the word "Atheist". This is some deep information you're dropping here. I recommend that the op should research up and follow his references. thanks AgentofAllah. |
Christianity Etc › Re: A Fool Sayeth In His Heart "There Is No Santa Clause" by PastorAIO: 9:33pm On Dec 18, 2016 |
Anas09: You got the message. That's what's important. What message? |
Christianity Etc › Re: What is The Essence Of The Church And Christianity? by PastorAIO: 8:03pm On Dec 18, 2016 |
Ubenedictus: NAH, it is hard to find Jesus preach so explicitly about d importance of his death except in a few places. in jn he say 'and when i am lifted up from d earth i will draw all men to myself', this was in reference to his death, and of more importance he say, 'unles a grain of wheat fall and die it remains but a single grain, but when it die it yield a thousand fold', there he pretty much put his death as d single defining moment of his life, he also tell us dat we recieve d holy spirit only because he dies, 'if i do not go he will not come'.
in those few passages Jesus tell us d centrality of his death, after his anscension d apostles finally saw his death in dat light. But Jesus did preach, and extensively too, on the subject of Salvation. |
Christianity Etc › Re: A Fool Sayeth In His Heart "There Is No Santa Clause" by PastorAIO: 6:42pm On Dec 18, 2016 |
Anas09: Can you see? You are ignored. The purpose is archived. I hope it was achieved first before it was archived. |
Christianity Etc › Re: African Nurse Who Offered To Pray With Her Patients Sacked In The UK by PastorAIO(op): 8:04pm On Dec 12, 2016 |
Na so one christian nija teacher for one primary school for UK by force by force tore of the hijab of a little girl and started tell her how much she hated islam and it was evil religion.
Me, I say sack them all. Let them go to church. Pastor go find another job for them. Or Pastor fit open him own church and school and employ them. Any sick person wey enter, instead make them treat them , they go pray for them.
Na so we dey kee pipu for our country nigeria. |
Christianity Etc › African Nurse Who Offered To Pray With Her Patients Sacked In The UK by PastorAIO(op): 7:01pm On Dec 12, 2016 |
|
Christianity Etc › Re: The Mysteries Of The Kolanut & The Creation Of The Kolanut Revealed by PastorAIO: 3:11pm On Dec 12, 2016 |
Dear Osamaro Ibie, Thank you for the story.
Please we know that kola nuts grow best in the north of Nigeria. Would you say that people in the north respect their elders better than people in the south?
Secondly, there are people who do make an infusion by boiling kola nuts in hot water and then drinking it as tea. That would mean that your story is wrong to say that Obi are not palatable unless they are raw.
Thirdly, what odu did you get this story about the origins of Kolanut from?
Thank you. |
Christianity Etc › Re: What is The Essence Of The Church And Christianity? by PastorAIO: 10:42pm On Dec 11, 2016 |
Ubenedictus: The death and resurrection is d climax of d gospels, Jesus was always talking about 'my time', prophesying his death and resurrection. it is in d same motif that john d baptist identify him 'this is d lamb of God who takes away d sins of d world', d lamb has to die to take away sins. isaiah talks of d suffering messiah, 'by his suffering shall my servant justify many'.
the fullnes of understanding came after Jesus died, his apostles clearly put down d core of xtianity i.e d cross. We are all familiar with these inferences from various biblical passages. I only asked if Jesus preached that his death and resurrection were the basis of christian salvation. If you know of any passages where Jesus preached this I would be glad to hear of it. |
Christianity Etc › Re: What is The Essence Of The Church And Christianity? by PastorAIO: 4:35pm On Dec 11, 2016 |
hemartins: The center of Christianity is the death and resurrection of Jesus. Everything else in the New Testament, whether it be a command to love others, God's demand that we keep ourselves pure from sin, the New Testament teaching about divorce, and every other topic all stems from the death and resurrection of Jesus. Everything Jesus Himself said and did revolved around this. Take that away and Christianity has no foundation, no basis, no rationale, no center. Please where in the gospels did Jesus preach about his death and resurrection as the basis of salvation? |
Christianity Etc › Re: If The Old Testament Is Of A Perfect God, Why The New Testament?? by PastorAIO: 11:40am On Dec 06, 2016 |
pesty100: yes it does What attributes can we say about possibilities that makes them distinct from actualities? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Problems with Evolutionary Theory by PastorAIO: 2:12pm On Dec 04, 2016 |
donnffd: First of all, this has nothing to do with the question i asked...
Secondly, you twisted the reason why einstein edited his equations and lied about the defrauding matter. Both the special theory of relativity and the general theory of relativity have predicted accurately and are standards in physics, and even the blunder Einstein claimed he made wasnt actually a blunder, he was correct all along, the rate at which dark energy is expanded the universe is a factor of the cosmological constant whch Einstein taught was a mistake.
Get your stories straight(it had nothing to do with religion). Don't feed the troll, man. Clear Road for JagaJaga. |
Christianity Etc › Re: If The Old Testament Is Of A Perfect God, Why The New Testament?? by PastorAIO: 12:28pm On Dec 04, 2016 |
pesty100: Actualities is subjective to possibilities, if actualities exists then possibilities exist But ... Do possibilities exist that have never manifested as Actualities? |