Uyi Iredia: A straw man. Your opponent clearly described a case where drawing cartoons is oppressive (i.e Writings or cartoons by members of dominant communities vilifying the religion of minority groups that are targets of racism) Read properly b4 you reply.
You're still making the same mistakes that you've always made. How is it a straw man to point out that the cartoons weren't advocating violence and thus neither incitements to hatred nor oppression? I've told you time and time again that you need to actually demonstrate what you think is a fallacy and not just give the names of fallacies.
If Adam and Eve were the first humans and they had several children among them Cain, who did Cain marry? The account of Lot and his daughters is right there in the Bible check Genesis 19:31 to end.
Uyi Iredia: Uyi Uyi on what basis does reason, logic and law exist ?
They exist due to the need of human minds to form models. How does this lead to your God?
tbaba1234: Q1. Writings or cartoons by members of dominant communities vilifying the religion of minority groups that are targets of racism are just a manifestation of oppression and incitation to racial hatred. There is a reason why many countries have laws against hate speech. The danish cartoons were over the edge. Can you write a op--ed in the new york times using words like "ni__ga" or other racist slurs? Of course not, so there is a balance between freedom of speech and what is socially acceptable.
Really? A cartoon is now a sign of oppression and incitement to racial hatred? Sorry but you don't seem to understand the concept behind the idea of free speech. Drawing a cartoon isn't incitement to violence unless the cartoon actually encourages violence. Now the teachers who saw the cartoons and decided that a good approach would be to murder cartoonists and encouraged people to do so, that is incitement to violence. How is drawing a cartoon inviting people to kill or oppress other people?
tbaba1234: Q2. There is no other system that combines such mercy with justice. Saudi arabia for instance has one of the lowest robbery rates in the world, so it does work. http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/cri_rob-crime-robberies . I am not learned enough to make judgements on cases like that.
So amputation of people's hands is mercy. Saudi Arabia is a wealthy country. Why not look to Nigeria where for some reason, poor people get amputated. Also, you may want to take a careful look at that table because Nigeria isn't there. Then Pakistan, Bangladesh, and India rank below Saudi Arabia? I'm already deeply skeptical about the results on that table. So sharia has nothing to say about file sharing yet you think it is appropriate for these modern times?
tbaba1234: Q3. I know,you don't believe in miracles, i do. Just like moses stretched out his staff and the sea part, The prophet pointed at the moon and it split in two. This event was witnessed by companions of the prophet and disbelievers who claimed that he must have bewitched them. The Quran talks about this incident when it says:
The Hour [of Judgment] is nigh, and the moon is cleft asunder, But if they see a Sign, they turn away, and say, "This is [but] transient magic." Surah (54:1-2)
I hope you don't ignore your own signs.
Aren't they contradictions to scientific knowledge? You claimed there were no contradictions, I just pointed a few of them out so does the Qur'an contradict scientific knowledge or not?
tbaba1234: Thanks for this, my understanding of the verse was totally wrong.
I have dug deeper into the tafsir based on classical arabic understanding of the verse and this is what i find. Now debunk this.
The correct translation of ‘sulb’ is not backbone, nor does the word ‘tara’ib’ indicate the man’s ribs. Let us review the verse in question:
So let man consider from what he is created. He is created from an emitted fluid that issued from between the sulb and the tara’ib. (86:5-7)
The word ‘tarai’b’—according to the Arabic—is actually referring to a female body part. Much like the English word ‘joystick’ can only be ascribed to a male, the word ‘tara’ib’ can only be applied to a female.
This is not apologetic modernism or revisionism; the classical works of Quranic commentary throughout the last 1400 years confirm this view categorically. In other words, the sulb belongs to the male, and the tara’ib belongs to the female. This is the view of the Muslims since the last fourteen hundred years, and there is consensus (ijma) on this matter, since the time of the Sahabah (the Prophet’s disciples) until today.
Shaykh `Abd al-Wahhâb al-Turayrî of IslamToday.com writes:
The phrase “mâ’ dâfiq” (emitted fluid) is not restricted in meaning to Fluid but is used in Arabic for both the Fluid and the egg. Ibn Kathîr, in his commentary on this verse, writes: “It emanates from the man and the woman, and with Allah’s permission, the child comes forth as a product of both.”
…The words translated as “backbone” (sulb) and “ribs” (tarâ’ib) are not understood in Arabic to belong to the same person. Arabs understand the “sulb” to refer to a part of the male body and the “tarâ’ib” to a part of the female. Ibn Kathîr states: “It refers to the ‘sulb’ of the man and the ‘tarâ’ib’ of the woman…” He then quotes this interpretation on the authority of the Prophet’s companion Ibn `Abbâs. This same understanding is given in all the major classical works of Qur’anic commentary.
Many non-Arabs misinterpret this verse because they think that sulb and tara’ib refer to different body parts of the male. In reality, tara’ib is feminine, and refers to the female’s body part. For fourteen hundred years, all of the scholars have held this belief, and not a single classical scholar has ever differed on this point. The reason is that the Arabic makes it clear that tara’ib refers to a feminine body part, and not a male one.
[b]Lane’s Lexicon s[/b]ays: Tara’ib: … most of the authors on strange words affirm decidedly that it (tara’ib) is peculiar to women. (Lane’s Lexicon, p.301) All of the major commentaries of the Quran confirm that the tara’ib is peculiar to women. Ibn Katheer writes in his tafseer (commentary) of the Quran:
It (fluid) emanates from the man and the woman, and with Allah’s permission, the child comes forth as a product of both. (Tafseer Ibn Katheer)
Tafseer al-Jalalayn says: Issuing from between the sulb, of the man, and the tara’ib, of the woman. (Tafseer Al-Jalalayn)
Tanwir al-Miqbas min Tafseer Ibn Abbas says: That issued from between the sulb of the man and the tara’ib of a woman.
(Tanwir al-Miqbas min Tafseer Ibn Abbas)
AmericanPregnancy.org says:
Ovulation is assumed to take place on the day a woman has the most amount of wet fluid.
When a woman is fertile, each month a Graafian follicle travels to the surface of the ovary, bursts, and releases an egg and its fluid contents into a fallopian tube. (http://www.oncologychannel.com/ovari, er/index.shtml) The cilia in the fallopian tube push the fluid and the egg forward towards the uterus. It is the fluid which is the main force that causes the cilia to beat and thereby push the egg to its destination. Without the fluid, the egg will most likely not make it. One can read this medical article on the topic: The Effect of Ovarian Follicular Fluid and Peritoneal Fluid on Fallopian Tube Ciliary Beat Frequency
BACKGROUND: …At ovulation, follicular fluid is released into the peritoneal cavity and enters the Fallopian tube. We hypothesized that this fluid may provide the stimulus for the increase in CBF (Ciliary Beat Frequency) detected after ovulation.
…CONCLUSIONS: The increase in CBF detected after ovulation may aid ovum pick-up and transport along the Fallopian tube. Factor(s) within human follicular fluid and secretory phase peritoneal fluid may be responsible for this increase in CBF.
Fluid produced and secreted by the Fallopian tube provides the environment in which gamete transport and maturation, fertilization and early embryo development occur.
As for the proper definition of sulb in the context of this verse, it is ‘loins’ and NOT backbone.
Shaykh `Abd al-Wahhâb al-Turayrî of IslamToday.com writes: The word “sulb” should not necessarily be translated as “backbone”. This word has many possible meanings and backbone is only one of them. It is also quite commonly used to mean the loins of a man. This is how it is used elsewhere in the Qur’ân. Allah says: “Prohibited to you (for marriage) are…wives of your sons proceeding from your loins (aslâb, the plural of sulb).” [Sûrah al-Nisâ’: 23] There can be no problem with Fluid coming out from the area of a man's loins. Pickathal, a translator of the Quran, similarly translates the word ‘sulb’ as ‘loins’.
At this point in time, I think it would be appropriate to define the word ‘loins’, since many people nowadays have weak vocabularies. The word ‘loins’ refers to the Core and pubic area, or the Cores. So if the Quran says that Fluid comes from the Cores (and it does!), then how is this a scientific error?
Arabic-English Dictionaries and Journal Articles
We refer the reader to p.226 of The Concise Oxford English Arabic Dictionary. The English word ‘loins’ is translated as ‘sulb’. (source: http://www.amazon.com/Concise-Oxford, /dp/0198643217 )
We refer the reader to p.231 of Hippocrene Standard Dictionary Arabic-English English-Arabic by John Wortabet, in which once again, the only definition of the word loins is ‘sulb’. (source: http://www.amazon.com/Hippocrene-Dic, 6200382&sr=1-1)
It is a simple matter of driving down to Barnes and Noble or another bookstore to verify these definitions. But if the reader is too lazy to do that, here is an online reference. On p.146 of An English and Arabic Dictionary by Joseph Catafago, notice that the only definition given for the word ‘salbi’ is ‘proceeding from the loins’. (click here to view: http://books.google.com/books?id=42o, =5&ct =result)
Here is another online reference: on p.791 of A Comprehensive Persian English Dictionary: Including the Arabic Words, we see that the first definition of the word ‘sulbi’ is ‘proceeding from the loins’. (click here: http://books.google.com/books?id=knA, um=4&ct=result)
Still not convinced? Here is another online reference, this time from the YemenTimes.com, which translates the word ‘sulb’ as ‘loins’. It should be noted that this article has nothing to do with the verse in question, so the issue of bias cannot be brought up! (It’s a Bohra website, and Bohras are not considered Muslims by us.) We read: He was succeeded by his brother Imam Husayn (SA), Sayyid al-Shuhada, (Lord of the Martyrs) through whose sulb (loins) the tasalsul to the Imamat has continued and will continue, until the Day of Judgment. (YemenTimes.com, http://yementimes.com/article.shtml?i=656&p=report&a=1)
Cambridge University Press published a journal article in which the word ‘sulb’ was similarly translated as ‘loins’:
It is suggested that the Chelebi is derived from the Arabic salb or sulb, “loins,” and that it originally denoted “true born” or “lawful heir”… (http://www.jstor.org/pss/607751) The University of California Press published a book, written by Carol Lowery Delaney, in which the word ‘sulb’ was translated as ‘loins’:
The father’s side can be called sulb tarafi (sulb means loins, descendants, seed; spinal column, hard, rigid, firm)….
(The Seed and the Soil: Gender and Cosmology in Turkish Village Society, p.158, http://books.google.com/books?id=GjE, =5&ct =result) In the Persian Translator’s Introduction to Adab al-Suluk, the word ‘sulb’ is defined as ‘loins’. (‘Sulb’ is one of the many Arabic words used in the Persian and Hindu languages.) We read: …The starting point is the father’s loins (sulb); the second stage is the mother’s womb; the third stage is the physical world; and the fourth stage is that of the grave…
Perhaps the greatest proof is from the Quran itself. The word ‘sulb’ is used in another verse: Prohibited to you (for marriage) are…wives of your sons proceeding from your loins (aslaab, the plural of sulb). (Surah an-Nisa, 23) It is also used in the Prophetic sayings (hadeeths). For example, the Prophet [s] was alleged to have said:
…From the loins (sulb) of this (man) will come a man who will fill the earth with fairness and justice…
(At-Tabarani)
Proof from the Bible
The Bible uses the word ‘loins’ in the exact same way, in numerous verses. For example:
And kings shall come out of your loins. (Genesis 35:11.)
You shall not build the house (the Temple); but your son that shall come forth out of your loins, he shall build the house unto my Name. (I Kings 8:19.)
And all the souls that came out of the loins of Jacob were seventy souls: and Joseph was in Egypt already. (Exodus, 1:5)
Perhaps the most damning piece of evidence against the Christian Islamaphobes is that the Christians translated the Bible into Arabic, and they translated the word ‘loins’ as ‘sulb’! Exodus 1:5 reads: Exodus 1:5: And all the souls that came out of the loins of Jacob were seventy souls: and Joseph was in Egypt already. (American Standard Version) The word ‘loins’ in this verse is rendered as ‘sulb’ by the Christian translators at ArabicBible.com: 5وَكَانَتْ جَمِيعُ نُفُوسِ الْخَارِجِينَ مِنْ صُلْبِ يَعْقُوبَ سَبْعِينَ نَفْسًا. وَلكِنْ يُوسُفُ كَانَ فِي مِصْرَ (http://www.arabicbible.com/bible/doc_bible.htm)
when the Quran says that a human is created from a father’s sulb, suddenly they accuse the Quran of being inaccurate. Fairness dictates that if the Christians are going to mock the Quran for saying that Fluid comes from the male’s sulb, then they must also mock their Bible which similarly uses the word.
From a linguistic standpoint, the term ‘tara’ib’ means ‘an arch of bones.’ Because of this, some of the early Muslims thought that it could refer to the woman’s rib cage, which encases the uterus. During normal pregnancies, the uterus actually grows underneath and into the rib cage. Dr. William D. McIntosh (M.D.) says to one woman:
…Your uterus is still under your ribs, but the movement is frequently more intense on the right side due to the prescence [sic] of the liver.
The American Pregnancy Association (APA) writes: As your baby continues to grow, he/she takes up a larger portion of your uterus. You may not feel that your body can handle your growing baby, but it will compensate by allowing your uterus to extend underneath your rib cage.
The ribcage expands enormously during pregnancy to help make room for the expanding uterus and to maintain adequate lung capacity. Many pregnant women experience rib discomfort from this expansion, as well as the occasional little foot or knee that might habitually press against the ribs.
Another possible meaning for tara’ib could simply be ‘pelvic arch’, where the ovaries are located. Again, tara’ib literally means ‘an arch of bones’. The ribs form an arch of bones and this is why some of the early Muslims considered the tara’ib to be, but the pelvis certainly looks like an arch of bones as well. This is how Muhammad Asad translated the verse:
(7) issuing from between the loins [of man] and the pelvic arch [of woman].*
* The plural noun tarai’b, rendered by me as “pelvic arch”, has also the meaning of “ribs”, or “arch of bones”; according to most of the authorities who have specialized in the etymology of rare Quranic expressions, this term relates specifically to female anatomy. (Taj al-`Arus). (Quran, Ref: 86:7) Shaykh `Abd al-Wahhâb al-Turayrî confirmed this, saying:
It can apply to any region nearing the ribcage. Therefore, the area of the ovaries, the fallopian tubes, or the uterus can easily fit into the general area that is being indicated by these verses. The truth is that tara’ib is a very obscure word. Just open up Lane’s Lexicon to see this! We read:
The part of the bosom which is the place of the collar, or necklace : (T, M, K so by the common consent of the lexicologists : (T or the bones of the bosom: (M, A, K or the bones of the bosom that are between the collar-bone and the pap: (8 or the part of the bosom, or chest, that is next to the two collar-bones : or the part that is between the two bosoms and the collar bones :or four ribs of the right side of the chest and four of the left therefore : (M, K or the two arms and two legs and two eyes: (T, M, K ,
(Lane’s Lexicon, p.301)
And the definition goes on! It seems that the word ‘tara’ib’ can refer to quite a few parts on the female body.
The Quran is very much superior to any manmade book. The analogy barely suffices, since the work of man cannot be compared to the Word of God. Nonetheless, fairness dictates that the same principle apply here. If the Westerners will give credit to Shakespeare for using new words, then surely the same should apply to the Quran. In fact, the Quran revolutionized the Arabic language, using words in a way that was never ever seen before. The Quran’s beauty stunned both friend and foe alike.
The Quran could have merely used mundane language and said ‘testes’ instead of sulb, or ‘ovaries’ instead of tara’ib…yet this would have altered the literary flow and epic beauty of the Quranic recitation. We urge the reader to listen to the Quranic verses in Arabic, and see why we say this! Click here to listen to the verse of the Quran that uses the word ‘sulb’ and ‘tara’ib’:
Of course, the non-Arabic speaker cannot fully appreciate the eloquence and power of the Quranic recitation. Nonetheless, one can see that it transcends any manmade literature. The Quran had a profound and lasting impact on the Arabic language. There has never been a more beautifully written book, in Arabic or any other language.
Going back to the Shakespeare analogy, we see what effect he had on the English language. About.com says:
The English language owes a great debt to Shakespeare. He invented over 1700 of our common words by changing nouns into verbs, changing verbs into adjectives, connecting words never before used together, adding prefixes and suffixes, and devising words wholly original.
… Shakespeare also invented many of the most-used expressions in our language.
(http://shakespeare.about.com/library, /aa042400a.htm) Likewise, the Quran invented many words, and used common words in ways that they had never been used before, changing their usage from the mundane to the magnificent.
Why is there a need to invent words? The reason is that the language is not grandiose enough for the writer. Shakespeare invented words because he excelled above the capacity of the English language. He coined many phrases, such as the famous “star-crossed lovers”. The word “star-crossed” had never been used before Shakespeare. Yet, now it is—thanks to Shakespeare—engraved into the English repertoire as one of the most poetic of words. Surely the same effect would not have been conveyed had he simply used the word ‘unlucky lovers’ as opposed to ‘star-crossed lovers.’
Similarly, the Quran invented many words, and used words in a way that Arabs had never used before, thereby transcending the Arabic language and revolutionizing it. Nobody could use language the way God did when he gave us the Quran. If we look at the verse in question (i.e. verse 86:7), it is extremely eloquent and moving in its Arabic language; the words sulb and tara’ib convey a grandiosity that no other words could.
The Quran is quite literally the epitome of beauty.
You will have to pay for all this research . i needed to do it though.
To be clear, you're saying that sulb == loins or some other parts and tara'ib == uterus or some other female parts. I'll let this go since it is ambiguous enough to scale through.
tbaba1234: Q1. Drawing of degrading cartoons of the prophet or any other prophet do invoke feelings amongst muslims. It is the kind of cynicism that unfortunately exists in our society. Some muslims overreact, but most people will if their mother or father was insulted. Like i said, respect for other people's traditions is an important value. It's a big place, we can all get along.
So shouldn't such an expression be considered as free speech?
tbaba1234: Q2. Inhumane? THEFT Under an islamic system, wealth is redistributed by a system known as the Zakat system. Muslims give 2.5% of their wealth(not income) every year to the poor in the society, therefore the rich in the society are responsible for the needy in the society. Therefore, if a thief steals in islam because he is hungry or cannot feed his family, It is a failure of society for failing to provide opportunity for that person to create wealth for himself. Therefore, the person is let go without any punishment and provided with capital or a job by the state.
Now if theft is as result of greed or any other selfish reason, the punishment is the amputation of the hand. I know of a person who is serving 42 years in prison for stealing about $200. Ask that person if he would prefer to have an amputation of the hand and be with his family or remain in prison. The option will always be the first one. The harsh punishments are to serve as a deterrent as much as anything. It is to make you think about the possible consequences of your actions.
How is amputation the best approach? After someone is amputated, you do realize that such a person only becomes more dependent on the society. Also, in these modern times when e.g someone can copy a popular artiste's song unto their music device, this is considered as stealing. Should we also penalize this by amputation?
tbaba1234: Q3. a. There are no scientific discrepancy:
fresh water and salt water not mixing? It doesn't say so, I will try to explain.
“He has let free the two bodies of flowing water, meeting together: Between them is a Barrier which they do not transgress.” (Al-Qur’an 55:19-20)
In the Arabic text the word Barzakh means a barrier or a partition. This barrier, however, is not a physical partition. The Arabic word maraja literally means ‘they both meet and mix with each other’. Early commentators of the Qur’an were unable to explain the two opposite meanings for the two bodies of water, i.e. they meet and mix, and at the same time there is a barrier between them.
Modern Science has discovered that in the places where two different seas meet, there is a barrier between them. This barrier divides the two seas so that each sea has its own temperature, salinity and density.1 Oceanologists are now in a better position to explain this verse.
There is a slanted unseen water barrier between the two seas through which water from one sea passes to the other. But when the water from one sea enters the other sea, it loses its distinctive characteristic and becomes homogenized with the other water. In a way this barrier serves as a transitional homogenizing area for the two waters.
This phenomenon is also mentioned in the following verse of the Qur'an:
“And made a separating bar between the two bodies of flowing water?” (Al-Qur’an 27:61)
This phenomenon occurs in several places, including the divider between the Mediterranean and the Atlantic Ocean at Gibralter. A white bar can also be clearly seen at Cape Point, Cape Peninsula, South Africa where the Atlantic Ocean meets the Indian Ocean.
But when the Qur’an speaks about the divider between fresh and salt water, it mentions the existence of “a forbidding partition” with the barrier.
“It is He Who has let free the two bodies of flowing water: one palatable and sweet, and the other salty and bitter; yet has He made a barrier between them, and a partition that is forbidden to be passed. (Al-Qur’an 25:53)
Modern science has discovered that in estuaries, where fresh (sweet) and salt water meet, the situation is somewhat different from that found in places where two salt water seas meet. It has been discovered that what distinguishes fresh water from salt water in estuaries is a “pycnocline zone with a marked density discontinuity separating the two layers.”2 This partition (zone of separation) has a salinity different from both the fresh water and the salt water.3
This phenomenon occurs in several places, including Egypt, where the river Nile flows into the Mediterranean Sea. These scientific phenomena mentioned in the Qur’an was also confirmed by Dr. William Hay, a wellknown marine scientist and Professor of Geological Sciences at the University of Colorado, U.S.A.
Y
But they eventually mix. There is no barrier that stops them from mixing. Claiming that fresh and saltwater do not become totally mixed immediately they are in contact doesn't support the claim that they do not mix at all.
tbaba1234: b. Jonah being swallowed by a big fish, Mohammed cutting the moon into two? We believe in miracles because we believe that God has power over all things. These fall into the realm of miracles. Just like we believe Jesus raised the dead or Moses parted the red sea.
Well, those sorts of things contradict scientific knowledge. I mean, how was Mohammed able to cut the moon in two? Did he get a very long sword or did he fly to the moon or what?
tbaba1234: c. people being created from a liquid gushing from between the loins and the ribs?? Liquid gushing LOL, also inaccurate, You should keep off some of these sites.
"Now let man but think From what he is created! He is created from A drop emitted --- Proceeding from between The back bone and the ribs."
[AL-QUR'AN 86:5-7] In embryonic stages, the reproductive organs of the male and female, i.e. the testicles and the ovaries, begin their development near the kidney between the spinal column and the eleventh and twelfth ribs. Later they descend; the female gonads(ovaries) stop in the pelvis while the male gonads(testicles) continue their descent before birth to reach the scrotum through the inguinal canal. Even in the adult after the descent of the reproductive organ, these organs receive their nerve supply and blood supply from the Abdominal Aorta, which is in the area between the back bone(spinal column) and the ribs. Even the lymphatic drainage and the venous return goes to the same area.
Also, The seminal vesicles are anterior to the sacrum and coccyx (lower back, loin) and the ribs are anterior to the seminal vesicles. If one was to draw a line from the tip of the coccyx, to the upper portion of the seminal vesicle _ either one of the two_ and extend the line forward it will catch the ribcage.
The seminal vesicles from which the Fluid spurts out during Reproduction, lies between the ribs and the coccyx!
No it doesn't. It lies entirely within the pelvis. I'll address your longer post on this issue next.
tbaba1234: I will ignore the sarcasm in the Aisha statement.
Yeah you do that. My point is that we shouldn't follow that particular example.
tbaba1234: Q4. Some value their female relatives so much that they are willing to kill them for what they perceive as crimes. Should we let them commit such murders?
Honour killings are cultural pratices NOT based on islamic values. So anyone who commits murder should face justice.
My point is that honour killing is their value so should we respect such values? Apparently you do not think so.
tbaba1234: Q1. Sure I'll like that. How would sharia deal with issues such as free speech, separation of religion and government and teachings or scientific information that contradict the Qur'an?
Free speech: Absolute freedom of speech is a myth, racial slurs for instance are generally not acceptable in today's society; The muslim's approach to speech is defined by the sayings of prophet(peace be upon him) where he said "Whoever believes in Allaah and the Last Day, let him speak good or else keep silent". There is a huge difference between free speech and hate speech. Islam is for free speech whilst protecting the rights of people from hate speech.
In islam, I might disagree with you on a number of issues, and total freedom of opinion is a principle that was assured by Islam since it emerged, and applied by Muhammad (pbuh).
The prophet said: "The best Jihad is a speech of truth in the presence of a tyrant ruler." (Abu Dawud and Tirmidhi)
Challenging islam, the prophet or the Quran is fine as long as you don't result to insults and infringe on the rights of people. The Quran invites challenge when it states:
Surah 23 23. And if you are in doubt as to that which We have revealed to Our servant,then produce a chapter like it and call on your witnesses besides Allah if you are truthful.
Where would the drawing of cartoons, such as was done in Denmark and France, fall?
tbaba1234: separation of religion and government
In a Islamic state, there is no such thing, It doesn't mean the scholars become the rulers, It mean the state is ruled by the islamic values of Truth, Justice and mercy.
The Islamic punishment meted out to people can be quite inhumane. Is there a chance of reforming practices such as amputation?
tbaba1234: scientific information that contradict the Qur'an?
So far, i know of none. Attempts at finding scientific misinformation in the Quran are often laughable because they are mostly by people who don't even understand the classical arabic or rules of the language.
How about issues such as fresh water and salt water not mixing, Jonah being swallowed by a big fish, Mohammed cutting the moon into two and people being created from a liquid gushing from between the loins and the ribs?
tbaba1234: Q2. Like i said, the age of aisha is irrelevant. It was a different socio-cultural environment. If you talk about the values and lessons we can take from the prophet's marriage and the love and kindness he showed his wives. Those are the values muslims try to adopt and aspire to,
But not marrying 9 year old females. I understand.
tbaba1234: Q3. How can you tell if a certain statement or illustration is an insult? Deciding that something is an insult is a matter of taste so are you trying to regulate people's tastes?
Understanding the values of a people is what is important here. you would assume that a black man will take offence if a white man calls him using a racial slur, but some black men will shrug it off. It doesn't make it ok. It is about respecting people and their values and making a attempt to understand those values. That is why i have this thread.
Some value their female relatives so much that they are willing to kill them for what they perceive as crimes. Should we let them commit such murders?
tbaba1234: 1. Yes i do. The sharia law encompasses all aspects of law: family law, criminal law, an economic system, civil law: It is all encompassing. A lot of the negative impressions of the sharia is based on a lack of information on the legal processes of the sharia. I could explain further on the sharia if you want.
Sure I'll like that. How would sharia deal with issues such as free speech, separation of religion and government and teachings or scientific information that contradict the Qur'an?
tbaba1234: 2. There is no short answer to this so i will give a long one if you don't mind,
The age of A’ishah, daughter of Abu Bakr, when she married the Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him) is something that has only recently become controversial. The traditional account is that the marriage was consummated when she was nine years old, which naturally appears strange, if not uncomfortable, to many in a modern, western context. Hence, some recent Muslims (of varying levels of intellectuality, motivations and scholarly qualifications) have re-visited the sources. They have discovered some evidence in the classical historical texts, and reinterpreted the traditionally adduced narrations, to suggest that A’ishah may actually have been older (with various ages suggested). My aim is not to analyze the arguments for and against a young marriage age for A’ishah, but rather to contextualize the entire discussion with a bird’s-eye view that remains intact regardless of which view (if either) an individual chooses to commit to.
The first (and most) important point to note is, as indicated above, is that the controversy is a relatively recent one. The Prophet’s own contemporaries took no issue with the Prophet’s marriage to A’ishah; it was not problematic in their eyes. This includes both his disbeliever antagonists and his believing followers. Certainly, his antagonists were ever eager to discredit him, and the Qur’an itself records details of this. They accused him of being a sorcerer, a madman or a soothsayer. Yet they did not attempt to discredit him on the basis of his marrying a girl too young for him. Neither in the Qur’an nor in any historical source is there any mention of such an objection having been raised, despite the fact that these sources do mention numerous other strategies used by the Prophet’s opponents.
So, if the Prophet’s contemporaries did not object to A’ishah’s age of marriage, then we conclude with certainty that her age was within the norm. Logically, this in turn implies one of two things: either it was acceptable, in 7th century Arab culture, for older men to marry younger girls (even as young as 9), or the reason for their non-objection was that A’ishah was in fact older. Once again, my aim here is not to prove one or the other, but to put the whole issue in perspective. The age of A’ishah is not a central tenet of Muslim faith, nor should it eclipse the core message and teachings of Islam. Muslims contemplating the issue of A’ishah’s age might find it beneficial to recall that; ‘Part of the excellence of a person’s Islam is his/her leaving aside what does not pertain to him/her.’
Non-Muslims would serve themselves better by contemplating the Prophet’s teachings of monotheism and righteousness, and the Book he presented as God’s revelation, rather than dwelling on what is, at most, a socio-culturally historical oddity.
Hence, without necessarily putting the two possibilities (regarding A’ishah’s age) on equal footing, and without stifling those who wish to delve deeper into the scholarly (and sometimes non-scholarly) arguments on either side, it is sufficient for the Muslim to defer the issue to God, saying, “I believe whichever of the two is the truth before God.” There are many more useful and pressing issues for us to occupy ourselves with.
The Catholic Encyclopedia observes about the Virgin Mary (peace be upon her) that, “it is possible that Mary gave birth to her Son when she was about thirteen or fourteen years of age.”In Shakespeare’s classic play Romeo and Juliet, Juliet was only thirteen, yet her mother tells her that “ladies of esteem” younger than her are already mothers.According to the “Encyclopedia of Children and Childhood in History and Society,” both Christian Canon law and European civil law considered seven years as the age of consent, but judges in medieval England would approve marriages based on mutual consent at ages even lower than 7. As recently as the nineteenth century, ages of consent of 13 to 14 were common in Western countries. Now, we are responsible for acting in accordance with our conscience, and our own societal norms may well factor into this, but it may be a bit presumptuous to pass judgment on people of the past and future, and those of other cultures. People in the future may well look on some of our mores as bizarre.
The bottom line is: God knows best about all the details of things. And, it remains well-established that Islam’s central message is one of monotheism, decency and morality. It is to this that our energies can be more profitably devoted.
It was probably acceptable in a different socio-cultural environment, not now,
I take this as saying that we really shouldn't follow Mohammed's lead on the marriage issue.
tbaba1234: 3. As long as criticism is structured and not aimed at insulting him or islam. If you present your arguments in a coherent form with throwing abuses then it is ok.
How can you tell if a certain statement or illustration is an insult? Deciding that something is an insult is a matter of taste so are you trying to regulate people's tastes?
I didn't say you were. I said you're simply ripping off the work of a Christian apologist and substituting the Qur'an for the Bible. Will you be able to defend his work?
The internal problem of evil fails to convince, however the external problem of evil seems more persuasive because it seems to acknowledge the co-existence of God and evil in the world, but denies God’s existence due to the level of the evil in the world. The external problem of evil argues the following:
1. A good God that is omnipotent exists
2. Gratuitous evil exists
3. Therefore, God does not exist
For the Muslim statement (2) is subjective and not entirely true. The Muslim will believe that evil exists, but not that gratuitous evil exists, and since this is based upon human subjectivity then the external problem of evil carries no weight. The proponent of this argument will have to show that gratuitous evil or evil itself are objective without reference to human subjectivity.
The essential problem with this argument is shown in the following questions:
• What makes our value judgments objectively true?
• What are our definitions of gratuitous evil?
The proponent of the problem of evil faces a problem because God is required a rational basis for objective good and evil (whether gratuitous or not). Without God these terms are relative as there is no conceptual anchor, apart from God himself, which transcends human subjectivity. So the terms evil and good make no sense or are just ephemeral without God. Therefore in order for the atheist’s premise to make objective sense, God’s existence is necessary. In this light the Muslim or theist may argue:
1. If God did not exist, then objective moral values would not exist
2. Evil exists
3. Therefore objective moral values exists (from premise 2)
4. Therefore, God exists
Explaining the key premise: Premise (1)
The question about objective good or bad, in other words objective morality, has been discussed by many theists and non-theists alike. Many have concluded that there is no objective morality without God. Humanist philosopher Paul Kurtz aptly puts it,
“The central question about moral and ethical principles concerns this ontological foundation. If they are neither derived from God nor anchored in some transcendent ground, are they purely ephemeral?”
Wow. You're really ripping off the works of a Christian apologist. Will you be able to defend these views?
tbaba1234: 2. The absurdity of an infinite history of past events
Some philosophers such as Bertrand Russell argued that the universe is eternal, meaning it has no beginning and it will never end. However if we think about this we will conclude that this position is irrational. If the universe never had a beginning it means there must be an infinite history of past events. Yet does an actual infinite exist in the real world? Is it possible?
The concept of the actual infinite cannot be exported into the real world, because it leads to contradictions and doesn’t make sense. Let’s take the following examples to illustrate this point:
1. Say you have an infinite number of balls, if I take 2 balls away, how many do you have left? Infinity. Does that make sense? Well, there should be two less than infinity, and if there is, then we should be able to count how many balls you have. But this is impossible, because the infinite is just an idea and doesn’t exist in the real world. In light of this fact the famous German mathematician David Hilbert said,
“The infinite is nowhere to be found in reality. It neither exists in nature nor provides a legitimate basis for rational thought…the role that remains for the infinite to play is solely that of an idea.”[2]
2. Imagine you are a soldier ready to fire a gun, but before you shoot you have to ask permission for the soldier behind you, but he has to do the same, and it goes on for infinity. Will you ever shoot? No you wouldn’t. This highlights, the absurdity of an infinite regress and this applies to events to. Therefore, there cannot be an infinite history of past events.
3. Take the distance between two points, one may argue that you can subdivide the distance into infinite parts, but you will always be subdividing and never actually reach the ‘infinitieth’ part! So in reality the infinite is potential and can never be actualised. Similarly the ancient Greek Philosopher Aristotle explained,
“…the infinite is potential, never actual: the number of parts that can be taken always surpasses any assigned number.”[3]
So if we refer back to an infinite history of past events we can conclude, since events are not just ideas they are real, the number of past events cannot be infinite. Therefore the universe must be finite, in other words the cosmos had a beginning.
We know this universe has a beginning.
tbaba1234: 3. Astrophysical evidence
The ‘Big slam’ is the prevailing theory in cosmology. It was first formulated by the aid of some observations made by an American Astronomer called Edwin Hubble. While Hubble was trying to understand the size of the universe, he observed immensely luminous stars called Cepheid Variables and noticed something peculiar. He observed that some of these stars were further away than initially anticipated, and that their colour was slightly changed, shifting towards red, something now known as red-shift. From Hubble’s observations we were able conclude that everything seems to be moving away from each other, in other words the universe is effectively expanding. As time moves on the universe continues to expand, but if time is reversed, the theory is that everything starts to coalesce and come together. Coupled with the discovery of cosmic microwave background radiation, which is the radiation uniformly filling the observable universe, the idea of the ‘Big slam’ was born. In other words the universe began at a cataclysmic event which created space-time and all matter in the universe. The physicist P. C. W. Davies explains,
“If we extrapolate this prediction to its extreme, we reach a point when all distances in the universe have shrunk to zero. An initial cosmological singularity therefore forms a past temporal extremity to the universe. We cannot continue physical reasoning, or even the concept of spacetime, through such an extremity. For this reason most cosmologists think of the initial singularity as the beginning of the universe. On this view the big slam represents the creation event; the creation not only of all the matter and energy in the universe, but also of spacetime itself.”[4]
Although our understanding of what happened 10-43 seconds after the ‘Big slam’ is highly speculative, astrophysicists now concede little doubt that this universe in which we live is the aftermath of the emergence and expansion of space-time, which occurred approximately 14 billion years ago. John Gribbin, an astrophysicist at Cambridge University, summarises the importance of ‘Big slam’ cosmology,
“…the discovery of the century, in cosmology at least, was without doubt the dramatic discovery made by Hubble, and confirmed by Einstein’s equations, that the Universe is not eternal, static, and unchanging.”[5]
Thus the ‘Big slam’ model describes our universe as having a beginning a finite time ago. As Alex Vilenkin, one of the world’s leading theoretical cosmologists, writes,
“It is said that an argument is what convinces reasonable men and a proof is what it takes to convince even an unreasonable man. With the proof now in place, cosmologists can no longer hide behind the possibility of a past-eternal universe. There is no escape, they have to face the problem of a cosmic beginning.”[6]
Other models have been proposed to try and explain away the obvious metaphysical questions that arise from a finite universe, for instance P.C.W. Davies questions,
“What caused the big slam? . . . One might consider some supernatural force, some agency beyond space and time as being responsible for the big slam, or one might prefer to regard the big slam as an event without a cause. It seems to me that we don’t have too much choice. Either…something outside of the physical world…or…an event without a cause.”[7]
These models include the oscillating and vacuum fluctuation models. These models however still have principles that necessitate a beginning to the universe, in other words they are non-infinitely extendable into the past. Take the oscillating model as an example, this model maintains that if the gravitational pull of the mass of the universe was able to surmount the force of its expansion, then the expansion could be changed into a cosmic contraction or ‘Big Crunch’, and then into a new expansion, with the process continuing ad infinitum. However, there are a few issues with this model,
1. Firstly there is nothing available in modern physics that would allow a universe that is collapsing to spring back into a new expanding universe.
We do know that this universe expanded into what it is. We simply do not have any information on whether or not there was a previous universe since all that information would be lost.
tbaba1234: 2. Secondly the mean mass density of the universe, derived from observational evidence, has shown that it is not enough to develop the required gravitational force to stop and reverse the expansion of the universe.
That may be so if the cyclical model is correct but we do not know whether or not it is correct.
tbaba1234: 3. Thirdly, the second law of thermodynamics (as discussed above) implies the finitude of the universe. According to the oscillation model, the entropy is conserved from cycle to cycle of the various oscillations of expansion, crunch and expansion. This has the effect of generating larger and longer oscillations. Therefore the thermodynamic property of this model implies a beginning, as the universe that we exist in has not suffered a heat death, or thermodynamic equilibrium.
The information we have is that the early universe was chaotic thus there is no need of conserving entropy from a previous universe.
tbaba1234: Since we have presented good evidence that the universe began to exist. We can now address the logically possible explanations the Qur’an presents as rationalisations of the origins of the universe.
Again, it appears that you've simply taken the words of a Christian apologist and simply introduced the word "Qur'an" into this post. You need to do better than that.
I simply have to ask if what you have here is original work or if you're simply copying and pasting another person's work probably the work of a Christian apologist. I've encountered lots of what you're saying but they are often based on fallacies or cognitive biases.
tbaba1234: The Quran Argument for God's existence
“No question is more sublime than why there is a universe: why there is anything rather than nothing.”[1]
This is a problematic question because why do you think that a state of nothingness can exist?
tbaba1234: When we reflect upon our own existence we will come to the realisation, that at some point in time, we began to exist. Since we were once non-existent and are now in existence, it follows that we must have had a beginning. In light of this, the Qur’an raises some profound questions: were we created by nothing? Did we create ourselves? Or did we create the universe?
“Or were they created by nothing? Or were they the creators (of themselves)? Or did they create heavens and earth? Rather, they are not certain.” Quran 52:35-36
These questions can be addressed to the existence of everything temporal, in other words the entire universe. Therefore, the exegetical implications of these verses can be logically formulated in the following way:
Things that began to exist were either:-
1. Created or brought into being from nothing 2. Self caused or self created 3. Created or brought into being by something else that began to exist 4. Created or brought into being by a non-created or un-caused entity
Actually, (1) makes no sense unless you actually have some evidence about it being possible.
tbaba1234: Before we proceed, the first presupposition has to be subtantiated, as it forms the basis for the Qur’an’s argument for the existence of God. This first assumption is that the universe began to exist.
Did the universe begin to exist?
To substantiate the view that the universe began to exist we can bring into our discussion a plethora of philosophical and inductive arguments:
1. The second law of thermodynamic 2. The absurdity of an infinite history of past events 3. Astrophysical evidence 1. The second law of thermodynamics
The concept of entropy was introduced to explain the direction of various processes that occur in the natural world. Entropy is a measure of how evenly energy is distributed in a system. For example, heat always flows from a body of a higher temperature or energy (low entropy) to one of a lower temperature or energy (high entropy). Take the following illustration of a container with gas,
when the partition is removed, the gas in one end of the container will spread to the whole of the container, going from a state of low entropy (higher temperature or energy) to high entropy (lower temperature or energy).
Hence, according to the second law of thermodynamics, processes in a closed system tend towards higher entropy, as their energy is being used.
Applying the second law of thermodynamics to the universe we will conclude that it must have began to exist. Since the universe is a closed system, with enough time the universe will suffer a heat death or thermodynamic equilibrium. When systems are in thermodynamic equilibrium, they cannot transfer energy. This is because entropy can only increase over time. Therefore, as the universe continues to expand it will eventually become cold and dead. However this raises a question, if the universe never began to exist it would imply that the universe has existed for an infinite amount of time. If this is true then why isn’t the universe already in a state of heat death? This strongly suggests that the universe must have had a beginning, because if it didn’t it would imply that it has existed for an infinite amount of time, which would mean that it should already have suffered a heat death. Since it hasn’t suffered a heat death, it strongly indicates that the universe is finite, meaning it began to exist.
Who says the universe as we know it never began to exist?
tbaba1234: This seems to be major hurdle for many atheists, So i decided to help them out.
And please no emotional arguments,
The absurdity of an infinite history of past events
Some philosophers such as Bertrand Russell argued that the universe is eternal, meaning it has no beginning and it will never end. However if we think about this we will conclude that this position is irrational. If the universe never had a beginning it means there must be an infinite history of past events. Yet does an actual infinite exist in the real world? Is it possible?
The concept of the actual infinite cannot be exported into the real world, because it leads to contradictions and doesn’t make sense. Let’s take the following examples to illustrate this point:
1. Say you have an infinite number of balls, if I take 2 balls away, how many do you have left? Infinity. Does that make sense? Well, there should be two less than infinity, and if there is, then we should be able to count how many balls you have. But this is impossible, because the infinite is just an idea and doesn’t exist in the real world. In light of this fact the famous German mathematician David Hilbert said,
“The infinite is nowhere to be found in reality. It neither exists in nature nor provides a legitimate basis for rational thought…the role that remains for the infinite to play is solely that of an idea.”[2]
2. Imagine you are a soldier ready to fire a gun, but before you shoot you have to ask permission for the soldier behind you, but he has to do the same, and it goes on for infinity. Will you ever shoot? No you wouldn’t. This highlights, the absurdity of an infinite regress and this applies to events to. Therefore, there cannot be an infinite history of past events.
3. Take the distance between two points, one may argue that you can subdivide the distance into infinite parts, but you will always be subdividing and never actually reach the ‘infinitieth’ part! So in reality the infinite is potential and can never be actualised. Similarly the ancient Greek Philosopher Aristotle explained,
“…the infinite is potential, never actual: the number of parts that can be taken always surpasses any assigned number.”[3]
So if we refer back to an infinite history of past events we can conclude, since events are not just ideas they are real, the number of past events cannot be infinite. Therefore the universe must be finite, in other words the cosmos had a beginning.
Now that we have proved the absurdity of an infinite regress of causes, let's apply it to God
If you ask the question who created the creator? What stops you from asking: Who created the creator that created that creator? Let's continue : Who created that creator that created that creator that created that creator?
If this continued forever, will there be a universe? The absurdity of an infinite regress of causes means that the universe was caused by an uncaused cause,
We know that the universe had a beginning. How does this fact demonstrate your God? The argument I understand you to be making is that the universe exists therefore there is a God that did it. This is a non-sequitur unless you can tell us something about this God and how he did what you're claiming.
tbaba1234: I look through the religion section of Nairaland, and all i see are attacks against islam
I am creating this thread for non-muslims and muslims; who have genuine questions about Islam. I will do my best to provide logical answers Insha Allah.
Frosbel and Aloy-emeka should please avoid this thread.
I hope this helps create a better understanding,
Salam Aleikum
Excellent. I have many burning questions about Islam.
1, Do you think that Sharia law is an adequate legal system in this modern world? 2, How old was Aisha when she was married? And is this something to be emulated? 3, Do you think people should be free to criticize Mohamed and Islam?
I think these are good questions on which to start this discussion.
God2man: Ha! @mazaje, chrisjOO1, the homer, i do not like talking too much on the reality of God or how God answer prayers, all i know is that, you will be a happy man, if you can just put aside all criticism and investigate objectively, go to places, where people share testimonies and see with your eyes wide open, the reality about the existence of the almighty God.
So you think sitting around listening to people tell stories about their God would help you believe?
God2man: It will be a great blessing for you, if you can do this. I beg you, do not sit down at home, attend those places, where people claim God exists or where miracles happen, do not be a nairalander atheists, which do not exist any way.
Nairaland atheists do not exists thus the atheists on Nairaland vanish in a puff of logic.
God2man: Myriad of people on the face of earth today are calling on God, on things that are beyond them, they believed that human beings are limited, we are prone to errors, we often make mistakes, it is only God, who can see us through in this turbulent world, so if i have a supreme being, who has promised to assist me to release the burden on mind, is it not better to call on him for help? Think, think and think again, i think it is logical to leave like this. So, if you have a problem, that is totally beyond you, you just sit down and say that is the way it should be, whereas there is a way out of that predicament, if you can just seek and investigate properly. God bless you all. God2man.
A nice demonstration of the bandwagon fallacy. The fact that many people believe in some God doesn't make that true.
dalebutt1: @ Theomar, You know God is not human and he doesnt reason the way we do. But seriously am only staying strong I wish there was a situation when there were no promised implications for not trusting to believe and follow him, I would simply just forget it. Whenever my wife gets a break from work i always make sure i dont make any business plans towards that time, we would have had nice Holiday vacation planned already, then they will just call up and say its prayer time we need camping and thats so frustrating. I love God because I was raised by devoted xtian parents but they too have had challenges that i know of and its be going on for like 12 years and they would always rebuke me for not trusting enough. well I guess it isnt free afterall because now I wish i was alone and i never had to rely on God for problem solving but you just think about the consequencies and you need to carry on trusting .
Does anyone knows if its a Sin not to have faith in him albeit you try to live as holy as you possibly can. Can not having faith in him be regarded as a sin?
Actually, you don't rely on God for problem solving, you simply work out your problems on your own. Also, people do live good lives without believing in a God. Trying to gamble on believing in God is what is known as Pascal's wager. What you need to realize is that out of the thousands of Gods out there, how do you know you have the right one? Also, do you worry about what will happen to you in the Muslim hell? How about the Egyptian hell or the Greek hell? Such fear that religions have placed in people needs to be abandoned. People that rebuke you for not trusting enough, why don't they trust as much as they wish then observe and see if they are actually better off.
God2man: This is strange. Why are we lamenting that God does not answer prayers? Prayer is a two way communication. It is called the royal telephone. You speak to God, he speaks back to you. Yes, God has been talking you, may be in your dream or through other means, try to listen to his gentle voice. If your way is right and you pray the right prayer concerning your problem, he will give you a clue. The truth is, God may decide to be silence in some cases, he may want to know, whether you really trust him, he may delay the answers for some reasons best known to him. God is sovereign, he may be alerting you on some bad things you are doing, that is witholding his hand. @op, check your life, then be patient, continue to ask him, there is power in constistency. God bless you. God2man.
You've been hearing God speaking to you? Hmm interesting.
dalebutt1: Well as much as we shall carry on discussing this God existence, the truth is He lives and lives forever more. But I wonder when God speaks through his servants and the sometimes say the same thing without knowing eachother but the opposite happens, has chrisj2000 have said it is tough to give up this childhood belief, I was so frustrated at my mum yesterday, I said to her, mum am not into all this fasting and praying anymore, If my heavenly father wont answer my prayers so be it, no grudges at all, no ill feeling either, am not gona get worked out because i prayed and they have not been answered afterall he didnt promise a trouble free life but it hurts when you know you have a father that has so much power and glory and he wouldnt even answer to your request. it weakens someones faith no matter how strong a believer you are.
One thing is, I have stopped to ask for things from God hence no dissapointment and hopes for a quick fix to my situation, I pray he helps me live as faultless as possible but me, am done asking for things that I would never probably get an answer for.
And would a real father do this to you? Would a father who can do anything and who sees your problems still stay silent and do nothing?
I hope you realize that your present attitude of not making requests from God is probably because you suspect that nothing will come out of such supplication.
oluwabamis: This is a very sad story indeed, an acquaintance of mine (a woman) died after a 21 days dry fasting. This woman in her forties had not been able to give birth after a failed marriage. In order solve this problem in her second marriage, went for this fasting program organized by a church (not her church). After the fast she became so weak that she couldn't muster any strength, she died afterwards. Pls be careful when it comes to dry fasting, 21 days without food and water is not adviceable. May her soul RIP.
Without food and water she lasted 21 days? Hmm that sounds like a miracle in the making. Anyway, why didn't she or any of her relatives go to a hospital to at least try and find out if there was a problem? What were the people in the church doing when they noticed the excessive weakness knowing she had been fasting?
In this blog I have avoided naming names. This is because the consultation I have just come from did not name names. However, all I can say is, “If the hat fits you, put it on!
It means the man is just a joker. Is he saying he cannot identify these pastors with the information he was given or is he simply parroting what he heard at this mysterious conference? Doesn't he have any ideas of his own or is he unable to put two and two together? If he is really interested in passing across this serious warning, then he could either ask the organizers of the claimed conference or do some digging to give us good and accurate information.
mantraa: If the story of noahs ark is literally true as millions of christians believe it to be. How did kangaroos (and koalas etc) manage to get off Australia and make their way the thousands of miles to the middle east where Noah was building the ark?
This is a question that has been bugging me for a while now and any rational answer from someone who takes the story literally will be very welcome.
Respects
You're still wondering about the kangaroos. How about the sloths? The can move at speeds of up to 4 metres a minute when threatened. They also sleep for about 10 hours a day. Just ask yourself how long it will take for one of them to wander from South America to the Middle Eastern region.