Christianity Etc › Re: I Was Thinking Between An Atheist . . ., by thehomer: 11:51pm On Jan 04, 2011 |
Again this confusion of meanings.
Agnosticism and atheism address different concepts.
One can be an agnostic theist or an agnostic atheist among others. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Saint Dikeji Miyerijesu Nigeria's First Saint Ordained By God! by thehomer: 11:48pm On Jan 04, 2011 |
Damn he should have taped it or at least had photographers witness the scene. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 11:43pm On Jan 04, 2011 |
logic1: A big NO. Time as we know it did not commence with the expansion of the universe. Oh? Did time commence? logic1: Spacetime is not time! Time is not a spatial quantity. It is of a unique dimension. Space-time is not the point of reference when we speak of time. Time is an absolute dimension like length unlike the example of north you mentioned earlier. At the scale of the universe, one does not simply speak of time or length due to the large distances involved and gravity. Plus the absence of an absolute reference value due to the fact that the bodies in the universe are constantly in motion. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 11:37pm On Jan 04, 2011 |
logic1: Yes you are right. The fact that we can conceive of the occurence of something may not actually mean that that thing occurs.
However, what we are talking about here is not the occurrence of a phenomena but the absence of a physical phenomena. If we have observed the presence of a particular physical phenomena and we have isolated it as a phenomena then it can be absent.
If the absence was not possible, then we wouldn't have conceived of its presence in the first place.
Indeed, all physical phenomena occupy space and have an age. If something has an age it means there was a time when it did not exist. But the universe is different in the sense that time as we know it and measure it is within the universe and not outside it. And we are yet to obtain information beyond this universe. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Free Thinking! by thehomer: 11:32pm On Jan 04, 2011 |
Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> why can't one conclude this ? (any less than without Darwin we would not know the mechanics of Human Evolution) Alfred Russel Wallace had also arrived at a similar conclusion. But Darwin beat him to the publisher. Uyi Iredia: also note that i referred to his method before referring to him >>> the issue of a being as God is (or is concieved of) isn't one that deals on better information. also note that i never referred to him as the best authority (if i did show me where/how) >>> but as the forebearer of the information we have This still does not make him the best source of current knowledge or the best authority for the subject at hand. Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> kindly check comment #86 What about the comment? Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> i have, and i have brooded over this issue. i assert that you play the semantics card >>> you contradict yourself >>> see what you said
he is demonstrating a belief >>> question? why doesn't Person b demonstrate that he does not believe >>> Person B is demonstrating a belief not a non-belief. if i were there i would say that he believes fire doesn't harm. >>> prove that 2 +2 ≠ 3 What semantics? You may need to note that that is a negative statement. Person B has stated that fire does not harm him and to demonstrate this belief, he stuck his hand in the flame. To expand it, person B states that fire does not harm him and he wishes to demonstrate his non-belief in fire harming him by sticking his hand in the flame. Or, he demonstrates his belief in fire not harming him . . . . So what he is demonstrating is a negative belief which is that fire does not harm him. |
Christianity Etc › Re: THEHOMER: Now Lets Discuss The Big Bang & Time by thehomer: 11:15pm On Jan 04, 2011 |
Deep Sight: @ Justcool -
I thank you for your very insightful surmise, which I agree with almost completely.
I would only like us to note very carefully that the so-called "scientific" definition of time does not exist at all - or more precisely, time as defined by teh scientist does not exist, and I am most careful when i state this.
Just stop a moment and ask yourself - the "time" that supposedly "commences" and supposedly "moves" - supposedly proceeding in a forward manner - just where has this time ever been observed - and so observed to "move"? You're now confusing linguistic uses of time for the scientific use. Deep Sight: The reality is that it is events that occur, it is objects that move, objects cover distance - these things happen. Time, by itself, is not observed by anybody to move anywhere - rather events occur, things happen, objects move within the constant that is time.
To be succint about this point - the tardy and lazy thinker may look at a watch or a clock, a timepiece - and conclude that that is evidence of time "moving." He does not realize that the only thing that is moving is the tick-tock of the time piece. It keeps ticking endlessly, and for all we care it may tick and tick and tick. That is an event occurring - the thing that the time-piece is supposed to measure is not itself observed by anybody because it is intangible and cannot be seen. IT SIMPLY REMAINS THERE. A PERMANENT CONSTANT. I already addressed this. Time is a unit not a constant. Deep Sight: Nothing [i]happens to it: rather things happen within it.
If time were in fact what scientists make it out to be, then people would be able to move freely in either direction in time - forwards or backwards as they choose - for time would be a fabric within which people and objects may freely move in any direction. Of course. Just as people can choose to cool their bodies to -300 Kelvin. Deep Sight: However calm thinking should reveal that we only proceed forwards for one reason: namely that it is events that are occuring, succeeding one another - and not time that is "moving" - not time that is a fabric of a sort.
When time "passes" - we should realize that what has really happened is that it is we, and objects about us that have moved within the constant that is time. And you cannot return to where you have moved from for the simple reason that the constant is intangible: and as such there is nowhere to return to. I have to ask what you mean when you use the word constant because this is quite different from the general understanding of the word. Constants are generally arrived at by measurements and calculations. |
Christianity Etc › Re: THEHOMER: Now Lets Discuss The Big Bang & Time by thehomer: 11:06pm On Jan 04, 2011 |
Deep Sight: This frankly has nothing to do with a mind of any sort deciding to create anything. I doubt that you would have seen me make any such reference in this thread as yet. The contradiction I set out to you was simple, and you continue to evade and side-step it, as obvious as it remains -
1. You state, and have stated again here that time commenced at the moment of the big bang
2. You state that prior to the big bang all that existed was a singularity
3. You state that the singularity was physical.
Q: How could that singularity, being physical, exist without time?
Are physical things known to exist outside of, or without time?
Simple. Address that. I already addressed this with my proposal of a universe-like object. And, comparing objects and events within the universe to the entire universe especially when it comes to a condition such as the singularity is simply inappropriate. This is an example of a part to whole comparison flaw especially given our current knowledge of the universe. Deep Sight: No I am not. From where did you derive such a queer idea? The big bang refers to the expansion - that is clear. What I have said, and what i still repeat is that YOU averred that PRIOR to the expansion, there was a singularity. If time had not "commenced' prior to the expansion, then please produce your timeline for the existence of that singularity! Simple! I've addressed this see above. Deep Sight: In the same way as you demand of me a timeline for things outside this universe no?
Produce your timeline for that singularity, simple. It's not the same because you are proposing a causal mechanism which requires a time-line for it to be meaningful I am not. Deep Sight: If you cannot do this; then you perforce concede and accept that time already existed: and could not be said to be produced or commenced by or at the moment of the big bang.
You are really a funny chap. You accede that physical things exist in time and space. You accede that the universe is physical. And you wish to run away from showing in what time and space the universe itself must exist. Come on. I wish this to be a serious discourse and I am not prepared to countenance such blatant escapism. It's getting tiresome presenting the same concept over and over again. Deep Sight: This remains nothing but further escapism. The fact is indeed that we are aware that the universe is expanding. This certain knowledge makes the question as to what it is expanding into a very apt and necessary question. Unless of course you believe in magic, and you believe that things may just expand when there is nothing and no space or void to expand into. If you reflect on that sir: you will recognise how unseemly and illogical your approach in this regard is. The fact is that YOUR science has affirmed that the universe is expanding. Thus the question i posed logically follows as an apt question: into WHAT is it expanding. It is painfully obvious that you only resile from this question for the obvious fact that it shows that space (as i defined it in post #2) pre-existed the big bang. Otherwise there would be nothing to expand into. Simple. You really need to try to understand various concepts. Consider this, my proposal is that universe-like objects may just exist, justcool made a proposal of the universe undergoing cyclical changes of expansion and contraction, there is also a proposal chaotic inflation. All these proposals may be wrong but, if one were to consider that one of these among others were to be correct, then the answers one gets would be different. So, we do not have enough information to answer such a question. Deep Sight: No - it did not have to change. My position is that creation is nothing but the eternal outward radiation of the God-factor. As such there is no "change" involved for the God-factor itself. It simply remains what it ever is and ever will be. What does the phrase in bold mean? Is the God-factor God? And, "outward radiation" of the God-factor does not change this God-factor? Deep Sight: The contradiction is simple and obvious -
- If time commenced at the moment of the big bang, in what timeline was the singularity existing prior to that expansion? I've addressed this above and in previous posts. If you do not agree with my conjecture, that is fine. But, you're yet to point out the contradiction if one agrees with the conjecture. Remember that not all physical properties are bound with time e.g the kelvin is not bound by time. Deep Sight: - If space was created by the big bang into what is space expanding. I've addressed this question above. Deep Sight: These are simple posers, please do not let it become obvious that your insupportable "scientific" presumptions are just the same as the blind dogma of the religionist. Which ones are blind dogma? |
Christianity Etc › Re: THEHOMER: Now Lets Discuss The Big Bang & Time by thehomer: 10:19pm On Jan 04, 2011 |
justcool: I have already answered this question. It remains a speculation which may never be verified, scientifically, because you cannot put the universe in a test tube and experiment on it or test it.
If one wants to experience or verify the timeframe outside the physical, one has to drop one's physical perceptions and employ the organs of his/her subtler bodies. This is not science because science is confined with the physical. I generally avoid such appeals to mysticism. justcool: OK you are right to a very limited extent. When science is speaking about the universe and cosmology, it is speaking about something measurable; it is also human perception. Science remains confined to human perception, and cannever go above it. Science actually is human perception; it is a physical or intellectual perception of the physical world.
Like the theory of evolution, its based on the interpretation of evidence, the theory itself cannot be replicated in a lab, or tested in a lab. Like I said earlier, you cannot put the universe in a test tube to experiment on it. As long as the speculation does not violet any scientific laws, it cannot be discredited. Like I said a earlier its left to the individual to accept it or not. Sorry but the comparison of your proposal to the theory of evolution is not apt because, we do not have evidence that the universe previously contracted prior to this observed expansion while we do have lots of evidence supporting evolution. justcool: Physically we do not; but I maintained that the non-physical cannot be investigated with the physical. One has employ his/her non-physical organs; this is not science. Non-physical organs such as? justcool: I do not just believe in the existence of God, I am convinced in His existence. But I do not know what you mean by "Christian God." If by "Christian" you mean the Christian religion, then I have this to say: God is not bound or confined to any religion. God is God. He is not a christian, neither is He a Muslim nor a Hindu.
All religious orientations or persuasions are only perceptions or a view of God, and not God Himself. But I am not here to judge these persuasions; I only offer my humble perceptions, on certain issues, where they are needed or asked for. Was Jesus the Son of God? justcool: Behind every process, every law, stands the Will of God. He is the power that drives all the laws of creation, including the physical manifestation of these laws.
In order not to derail this fine thread, I will stop here. If you really want to know my views towards God and where He fits into the cyclic phases of the universe, then open another thread and we can discuss just that.
Thanks It seems you're begging the question because, we've not agreed on this God yet you assume him already and attribute to him everything. I may just open this new thread. |
Christianity Etc › Re: We're Just Assuming Now. What If The Second Coming Of Christ Were To Be In 2011? by thehomer: 9:40pm On Jan 03, 2011 |
Joagbaje: When the bible use the word "GENTILES" it refers to other nations. Spiritualy ,There are three races in the bible . The Jews the Gentiles and the new creation. So is "gentile" a spiritual designation? |
Christianity Etc › Re: We're Just Assuming Now. What If The Second Coming Of Christ Were To Be In 2011? by thehomer: 9:36pm On Jan 03, 2011 |
ajadrage: . . . .
Yes it did, even the Forest States of the West African Coast, including your people I believe, (and I mine too). . .
. . . . Where? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 9:31pm On Jan 03, 2011 |
logic1: If the universe has an age then it has a beginning. If it has a beginning it was caused by something.
If the thing that caused the universe is physical then it too has a cause and we can go on and on.
Conclusion: At the very beginning of the process there has to be an uncaused cause in the equation which is most definitely non-physical Why must there be an uncaused cause simply because you want to introduce your creator or you do not like an infinite regress? Why do you think it must be non-physical? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 9:25pm On Jan 03, 2011 |
logic1: The scientific cause for the universe is the big bang.
The idea of the big bang was hypothesized because everyone implicitly believes that everything has a beginning. No. It was arrived at based on evidence from cosmology. Prior to this, it was thought that the universe was in a steady state. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 9:22pm On Jan 03, 2011 |
logic1: Atheism is disbelief in the existence of God or deities Microsoft® Encarta® 2006. © 1993-2005 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved.
Agnosticism is the view that God's existence is unprovable: the belief that it is impossible to know whether or not God exists Microsoft® Encarta® 2006. © 1993-2005 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved. Again, read the definitions you provided carefully. The first is about non-belief in the existence of God or deities, the other is the belief that one cannot know whether or not God exists. Again, two different fields. logic1: For anyone to credibly defend atheism he or she must possess absolute knowledge about the creation of the universe as a start. Again, one does not need this. If e.g the God can be demonstrated to be logically contradictory. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 9:17pm On Jan 03, 2011 |
logic1: The existence of any God. I made the comments that led to this particular discussion because you profess to be an atheist i.e. someone who does not believe in the existence of any God. You see one does not need to become omniscient to come to the conclusion that there is no need to believe in your God. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 9:14pm On Jan 03, 2011 |
logic1: Time is a measure of "when" something occured. It is a part of the measuring system used to sequence events, to measure the duration of events or the intervals between them. Time is measurable. I don't think I said otherwise. Before means something, infact you posted the comment in quotes BEFORE I posted this one. Time as we use it currently use it commenced with the expansion of the universe. This is how I understand and apply time in my posts about cosmology. logic1: Please what are you trying to clarify with the north of the north pole question? A possible answer to the question is that there is no north of the north pole because the north pole is itself the point of reference when we speak of north. There you've said it. To apply your answer to my question, it would be phrased thus. There is no time prior to space-time because space-time is the point of reference when we speak of time. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 9:03pm On Jan 03, 2011 |
logic1: It means that there must exist the possibility of existence of the converse.
Numbers mean something because they explain something else. The real concept behind numbers is about estimating the presence of something, we have 3 cars, 3 means nothing if it does not refer to any other thing. In fact when the brain thinks of the number 3 it actually thinks either of 3 objects or of an object whose shape resembles the shape given to the figure 3. 3 can only mean something if there is the possibility of the non existence of 3 which is the possibility that the 3 objects imagined do not exist or the object whose shape resembles the figure 3 does not exist. So does three exist or not? logic1: Gravity is an explanation of the force of attraction between the earth and another physical body close to it. There is the possibility that 2 bodies can repel (rather than attract) each other, the converse Does the fact that we can conceive of such an occurrence mean that it actually occurs? The main point I'm trying to illustrate is that the fact that one can conceive of a phenomenon or an object does not mean it actually occurred or existed. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Why Do You Think You Got To See Year 2011? By Whose Grace? by thehomer: 9:46pm On Jan 02, 2011 |
[quote author=Ileke-IdI link=topic=577829.msg7449685#msg7449685 date=1293995535]. . .
Unfortunately, this did not answer the question. Please give it another try.[/quote]No it didn't but I'm guessing that it is the same answer for them all whatever it turns out to be. |
Christianity Etc › Re: THEHOMER: Now Lets Discuss The Big Bang & Time by thehomer: 9:36pm On Jan 02, 2011 |
Deep Sight: Dear Mr. Homer;
Really I hope you understand that you have not addressed the suppositions that I set out to you. I am all too familiar with your one-line riposte style which gives nothing in terms of value for that which it receives: and i am of the view that such an approach will serve us for nothing regarding the posers that this thread seeks to address. For this reason I am of the view that it will not serve us rich to begin to exchange witty and extensive ripostes on the subject at hand and thereby become lost in a labyrinth of definitions, suppositions and extensive averrments. I thought I had. I prefer concise posts due to the ease in following and I hope, understanding them. Deep Sight: For this reason I propose to ignore any temptation to extensive discourse: perhaps almost be as brief as you are yourself in your general responses: and this with one intent and one intent only: namely to deliberately and forcefully restrict the discourse to the very specifics of the lamentable contradictions that I did set out in the OP. And in this regard let me say as follows concerning your responses - Good. Deep Sight: This says exactly nothing: and addresses in no degree the problem raised - for you will recall that you demanded from me what timeline i would base the existence of anything outside this universe on: accordingly you yourself cannot posit the existence of anything without shewing a timeline therefore and thereof - and I state to you most simply that since you say time had not "commenced" prior to the big bang, then you cannot evince the existence of anything prior to the bang - and this includes your contradictory pre-bang singularity. By saying commenced, that is to indicate that I have not assumed a mind deciding to create. Deep Sight: Indeed, the very words "pre" and "prior" and "before" are all prohibited to you in this respect: since there is no timeline to evince a concept of before and after, given that in your words, "time had not commenced."
Do not be disingenious. You have repeatedly referred to the the existence of a singularity "PRIOR" to the big bang. Where is your timeline for its existence? You're using the singularity and the Big Bang interchangeably, I am not. Deep Sight: Respectfully: gibberish. For the universe is a physical thing. This is the worst form of special pleading. Which part is the special pleading? You may need to understand that while the universe is physical, it is not like other physical objects that we do know about which is why I introduced the concept of the universe-like object. Deep Sight: Respectfully: escapist. The question is simple. Space is stated to be expanding. INTO WHAT IS IT EXPANDING? ? ?
Querrying the propriety of the question is escapist, cowardly, and most unbecoming of you: for you know that the question is very simply and concisely stated. The fact that the statement is simply stated does not mean it is actually an appropriate or meaningful question. e.g based on what we know about the geography of the earth, do you think a question such as "What is north of the north pole?" a meaningful question? Contrast this to the fact that we have no information outside this universe, we even lack information about what the furthest reaches of the universe currently look like, we're not even sure of the shape of the universe whether it is open or closed etc, then how do we know that asking about what is outside of the universe is a meaningful question? If you feel you have enough information to answer this, then please go ahead. It is one thing to know that one doesn't know and another to not know that one doesn't know. Deep Sight: I never said that God changes. You considered this God as a disembodied mind. This mind had to change from what it was before the singularity to what it was from the singularity onwards. Deep Sight: I already did. Your first question is addressed in my OP and your second question in my Post #2 on this thread. I still did not notice the contradiction. The y part in the OP was just me not cosmologists and the x part, you attempted to address with the same question you raised above. Deep Sight: Thanks. You're welcome. |
Christianity Etc › Re: We're Just Assuming Now. What If The Second Coming Of Christ Were To Be In 2011? by thehomer: 6:28pm On Jan 02, 2011 |
Joagbaje: That's not what the scriptures say. Why don't you study the bible and stop assuming The Bible does not mention the Americas or Australia or do you think it does? |
Christianity Etc › Re: THEHOMER: Now Lets Discuss The Big Bang & Time by thehomer: 6:24pm On Jan 02, 2011 |
justcool: In addition to what I wrote above.
I will give an analogy(I know, as usual, thehomer will call it a bad analogy ) Imagine a can in a windowless car, a car in motion. To this man, his environment(inside the car) is motionless; the object dangling on the rear view mirror may appear to be the only motion in the car. This motion is in reference to the rest of the car(inside the car) which appears stationary. But once he looks out of the window he will realise that the entire car is in motion. This motion is in-reference to the street our side which appears stationary. Then if he opens himself further, or widen his outlook, he will realise that the street is a part of the earth, which is in motion. This motion is in reference to the sun and the solar system which appears stationary. Then the further he goes, he will realise that even the entire solar system is in motion in reference to other stars and etc. There is no end to this.
The movement of the object dangling from the rear view mirror inside a car represents the time within our present universe. The movement of the car represents time in the non physical plane directly above the physical plane(for those who believe in the non-physical). The movement of the earth represents the time in a higher plane(lets just say ethereal plane), and the movement of the solarsystem represents the time in the plane above the ethereal. It goes on till we arrive at the spiritual planes; each movement in my analogy represents the time frame in a different plane of creation. You know me too well it seems. justcool: Observing the time in the universe or the time that started with the big bang is like observing the motion of an object dangling on the rear view mirror of a car. As long as you remain locked inside this universe of a car or as long as you are limited to your physical perceptions, that's the only time you can perceive; but the more you widen your view the more you see.
Just as the motion of an object dangling inside a car is different from the motion of the car itself, which inturn is different from the motion of the earth, the solar system and etc; time very in all planes of creation.
The time-frame, or perception of time in the spiritual plane is different of that of the ethereal, which in turn is different from that of the astral, and likewise the astral time frame is different from the physical time.
Before the physical time frame came into being, the astral time frame existed, and before that the ethereal time frame existed, and etc. Before the whole creation(From the primordial spiritual to the physical) came into being, time exsisted. This time is eternal; it stands still and it has no measure; this is the real time.
What we perceive in creation as time is only a measurement of events, or the speed of events in the particular plane of creation concerned.
Time exists only with God, it has no beginning, neither does it have an end. It does not elapse. It simply is.
Thanks If the man has no other input of the external environment, then how does he know he is moving (ignoring the recoil pushing him back in his seat)? And I really do not accept your proposals of astral frame, spiritual frame, ethereal frame etc. Unless you have some evidence for this. When you say time does not elapse, what do you mean? justcool: @thehomer, I just saw your last post. I will treat it later when time permits me. I have to go for now. Ok then |
Christianity Etc › Re: We're Just Assuming Now. What If The Second Coming Of Christ Were To Be In 2011? by thehomer: 6:04pm On Jan 02, 2011 |
Joagbaje: This is the time for the nations . We are in what the bible call THE AGE OF THE GENTILES. That is why you guys needs to get saved fast now. The attention of God is not on israel at the moment because they are experiencing blindness. God attention is on Nigeria, America, africa, Australia etc. And all the nations you are advocating for. But after the rapture , the attention of God will shift to Israel again.
Romans 11:25-26 25 For I would not, brethren, that ye should be ignorant of this mystery, lest ye should be wise in your own conceits; that blindness in part is happened to Israel, until the fulness of the Gentiles be come in.
You can be part of the numbers of the gentile nations today. Of course this does not excuse the absence of such large landmasses, but then it seems like according to you, God has changed his mind about Israel yet again. And is determined to keep doing this until he damns a lot of them along with the majority of humans that ever lived. |
Christianity Etc › Re: THEHOMER: Now Lets Discuss The Big Bang & Time by thehomer: 5:47pm On Jan 02, 2011 |
justcool: @thehomer
Thanks for addressing my post; I will deal with the observations that you made accordingly.
It is a very scientific speculation, and a speculation based on scientific principles. The only problem is that it can only remain a theory that can not be proven because we(including our science) are limited to this particular universe that we live in. Therefore anything beyond this universe is beyond us and science; even if such a thing is physical, it is still beyond science because science is limited to our present universe.
But many eminent scientists have speculated it, even Stephen Hawkings. Read:
Stephen Hawking in particular has addressed a connection between time and the Big Bang. In A Brief History of Time and elsewhere, Hawking says that even if time did not begin with the Big Bang and there were another time frame before the Big Bang, no information from events then would be accessible to us, and nothing that happened then would have any effect upon the present time-frame.[40] Upon occasion, Hawking has stated that time actually began with the Big Bang, and that questions about what happened before the Big Bang are meaningless.[41][42][43] This less-nuanced, but commonly repeated formulation has received criticisms from philosophers such as Aristotelian philosopher Mortimer J. Adler.[44][45] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time
Read "The Beginning of Time" by Stephen Hawking.http://web.archive.org/web/20071228050500/http://www.hawking.org.uk/lectures/bot.html
Time before the Big Bang or time outside our universe remains an open speculation in science. A speculation which cannot be scientifically discredited.
It is left for the individual to go beyond our present limitation of science(what science has proven at the moment) or remain within this limitation in his/her thinking. Like I said, all you have is a conjecture until you have sufficient evidence to demonstrate otherwise. Can you propose a method by which we may be able to test this conjecture or aspects of it? justcool: Yes. "time as we perceive it" or "real time, layman's ordinary perception of time," which existed before science was born, can be considered abstract or illusory but not "scientific time" or "time as science perceives it". Scientific time is not an illusion, neither is it abstract as such. Rather, it is a physical quantity that can be measured, speed up or delayed. Science does not deal with the abstract. I already stated that I could understand such a reference to time being illusory, but when we are speaking about the universe and cosmology, we are not speaking about human perceptions, but about something measurable. justcool: Quite simple. The Universe, (including its cyclic motion of big bang and colapse) are only events. An event cannot occur without time; all events occur within time; and the time that was born during the big bang cannot be the time in-which the event(the big bang) that give birth to it occurred. It is simply illogical to state that an event occurred without time. Its like saying that an object exists without being in existence. You are making a serious leap here. We do not know that the universe undergoes cyclical events justcool: Every event is like motion; motion is always in respect to another object. You cannot say that an object that exists all by itself is in motion. How can it be? Motion already implies "in reference to another object." Likewise, you cant say that an event occurred without time or in isolation of time. Here I'm talking about "outside time," not the time born during the event, because the time born during the event(big bang) is part of the event(big bang) itself. We do not have access to any other time-line or other objects to make this claim of an alternate time. justcool: Yes I do. Do you believe in the Christian God? If so, how does he fit into this model? justcool: Thanks. You're welcome. |
Christianity Etc › Re: We're Just Assuming Now. What If The Second Coming Of Christ Were To Be In 2011? by thehomer: 2:26pm On Jan 02, 2011 |
Joagbaje: Several prophecies or the bible have been fulfilled. The bible still contains prophecies which are yet to be fulfilled. Its not an ordinary book . It's more current than tommorows newspaper. Not this again. Did the Bible writers know anything about the Americas, Australia or Antarctica? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Why Do You Think You Got To See Year 2011? By Whose Grace? by thehomer: 2:22pm On Jan 02, 2011 |
[quote author=Ileke-IdI link=topic=577829.msg7445942#msg7445942 date=1293916755]God's grace?
Allah's grace?
Or by your own actions. . . .?
Why did you get to see year 2011 and the other person didnt?[/quote]Why did Charles Taylor, Theoneste Bagosora, Augustin Bizimungu, Jean Kambanda, Pope Benedict, Chris Oyakhilome, T. B. Joshua, David Oyedepo etc see the year 2011? |
Christianity Etc › Re: 'how I Recovered From Snake Bite Using Psalms 3 & 4' by thehomer: 2:05pm On Jan 02, 2011 |
IDINRETE: 'How I recovered from snake bite using Psalms 3 & 4' Written by Tope Olukole Sunday, December 19, 2010
"LIKE the Biblical Jonah who brought misfortune to voyagers, Prophet (Dr.) J.B. Kumoluyi (General Overseer, The Word Bible Church) too plunged into series of misfortune before sailing to the shore in his pastoral work. Before finally yielding to the call of God, he lost two kids to utter disobedience. In this miserable and confused state, he visited a senior prophet in the ministry, Prophet Obadare who simply said: "What are you still waiting for? If you don't act fast you will soon lose your wife and life should you continue to reject the heavenly call." He revealed that it was then he yielded to the call starting with only four people in a house fellowship in Ketu, Lagos . Prophet Kumoluyi said he had been going up and down searching for nothing and doing menial jobs like a commercial driver and cement seller for a paint company. God murdered his children because he was not a pastor? IDINRETE: According to him, his walk in the ministry was not all a smooth ride as he experienced series of challenges, even at the inception. When the fellowship was barely three months old, he was stabbed almost to death in an argument that ensued over his sister's marital relationship. His act of pardon and forgiveness exhibited towards the culprit was quite remarkable that it led to her conversion. "I started seeing the hands of God in my life in 1988/89. Whenever I prayed, I saw visions and God spoke to me, though initially people who were very close did not believe God had endowed me with such anointing. Yet I could not go back because he who has called me is faithful,"he revealed. On what part of his body was he stabbed? IDINRETE: The work of God in ministries like this is not without its attendant challenges; recounting such challenges Kumoluyi stated that during his pastoral work, God instructed him to gather all those who were looking for the fruit of the womb to the mountain, all numbering up to four hundred. According to him, "I announced it and we all went to a prayer mountain in Ibadan; it was a prayer with marathon fasting. I sat on the side of the bush, sleeping and waking up. All of a sudden I just felt a bite. I quickly woke up to check what it was. Lo and behold, it was a snake and it ran away. Within a second, I found it difficult to talk. Before I realised what was happening, my hands and legs became numb. I managed to beckon on my wife. They took me into a room. I was there for 20 minutes; then I heard the voice of God saying 'take water, read Psalm 3 and 4.' From there, I signaled to my wife to read Psalm 3 & 4 over a bowl of water, which she did exactly. After which I slept off. Of course, the snake was probably not venomous. IDINRETE: "In my dream, I saw a white man with grey hair beckoning to me to stand up. But I did not have enough strength to do that. I was just telling him of how I brought the women to the mountain for prayer and I ended up being paralysed. He passed no comment but kept signaling with his hands - stand up. I stood up and followed him until he disappeared. After 4 hours, I woke up and stood up and went straight to the place of prayer. Everybody shouted, not knowing what I had gone through. When we started praying, the power of God arrested two women who confessed saying: 'Why did you bring us to this mountain? Did we tell you that we need children?' These are some of the challenges and to the glory of God too we have a lot of stories of victory and miracles to tell. Of course just like the Israelites. IDINRETE: "During one of our revival services, they brought a child to the service who had no eye, nose and mouth. I was just praying for miracles and I asked people to lay their hands wherever they had ailments; so at the back of the choir, people started shouting. I asked for what happened and they brought the child. It was a miracle, the organs of the body were all in place, people started jubilating. Wow. Can you please heal amputees. IDINRETE: "The second was the case of someone who had epilepsy and was healed. I have never seen that before in my life. During the prayers, I noticed a man bending down and so I said they should allow him do whatever he wanted. He vomited something like a lizard, epilepsy. It was a miracle indeed. We had several cases; a boy with a hole in the stomach was about been flown out of the country for surgery but I don't know how God covered the hole up during the miracle hour. Those cured from insanity were innumerable; another case was that of one of our pastors who was brought in insane. He was kidnapped for three days and left insane because of the charms used on him. I prayed for him for seven days after which he regained himself; he had been taken to several places to no avail before coming down to Jesus Christ at The Word Bible Church. Why does this man not go to the psychiatric hospital and heal those who have actually been diagnosed as being mentally ill? Then epilepsy? The fact that a person is not convulsing every 2 hours does not mean he has been cured of epilepsy. IDINRETE: "It's not an easy road, it's very tedious but the Bible says with God all things are possible. I thank the Almighty God who called me. He has been there for me; he has been assisting me to pass through calamities and spectacular experiences in the ministry. "Arriving at such fame and fortune in the ministry for some it could be well mapped out, but for Prophet Kumoluyi it was not an easy road; it took God and dedication," he said. . . . Of course he was called. |
Christianity Etc › Re: THEHOMER: Now Lets Discuss The Big Bang & Time by thehomer: 1:33pm On Jan 02, 2011 |
justcool: I believe that Deepsight is referring to "real time" or the layman's time. By "real time" I mean the eternal time, the phenomenon onto which events happen; the time that every body intuitively knows but very hard to define, very hard to capture with words.
But when science talks about time, they talk about duration of events or measurement of events. Thus "scientific time" is different from "real time." Scientific time can be measured; it depends on the event or the speed of events; and hence it is not constant. It speeds up or reduces in speed depending on how fast the object or system in question travels.
The problem is that science uses the same words that the layman uses; but science gives these words a different meaning. People encounter problems when they fail to realize that the scientific definition of certain words is different from the layman's or ordinary everyday definition of the same word. Scientific time is different from "real time" or the layman's time; just like scientific work is different from the lay mans conception of work.
Scientifically, time (scientific time) is a fundamental part of the structure or state of the universe. One can ague that the time(scientific time) in our universe started with the big bang; but this does not mean that time(in general or "real time" started with the big band. It is also very scientific to expect that before the big bang, before the scientific time was born that there was another time frame. It may be a reasonable conjecture but I don't think it's scientific to say that there is some other time-frame we can refer to. justcool: But the "real time", ordinary time or the lay man's times exists beside the universe, and unaffected by the big bang, it stands by itself. It stands still, and cannot be measured because it is eternal. This time existed before the entire creation came into being and will continue if all creation ceases to exist. This time is not physical and hence cannot be grasped by science; but every man senses it.
Viewed from the perspective of "real time", the big bang is just an event and not really the birth or beginning of anything new. At best, the big bang can be described as the birth or beginning of our present universe. This universe will eventually colapse, decay, and remodel for another big bang. Each big bang is a beginning or a particular universe not the birth of any components of the universe. The same components exist and eternally passes through the cycles of birth(big bang) and decay. I can understand if one says time as we perceive it can in some circumstances be considered a bit abstract or illusory. From what you've said, you assume that an infinite quantity exists outside the universe. How do you know? I ask because we don't even know if there is an "outside" of the universe. Do you agree with the cyclical universe you mentioned above? |
Christianity Etc › Re: THEHOMER: Now Lets Discuss The Big Bang & Time by thehomer: 10:24pm On Dec 31, 2010 |
Deep Sight: Caveats & Personal Definitions:
I state it clearly that i subscribe to the idea of the occurence of the initial expansion that is called the big bang. What I dispute herein is the averrment that time and space were thereby created.
I see time as an intangible constant that cannot be created. The experience of time may however differ from place to place and from state to state. This is my view of time.
I see space as the infinite continuum of void into which things may be endlessly interpolated. This is different from the space which is merely an energized bubble in which our universe exists. This energized bubble, is in my view interpolated in the infinite continuum of void into which things may be interpolated. This space is not creatable in my view. It is self-existent. This is my view of space. I really do not understand what you're saying because, time is not a constant but a unit of measurement. So I don't get what you mean when you refer to it as an intangible constant. So according to you, space is infinite and the universe exists in an energized bubble with its own space. But, how do you know this? |
Christianity Etc › Re: THEHOMER: Now Lets Discuss The Big Bang & Time by thehomer: 9:47pm On Dec 31, 2010 |
Deep Sight: Dear Sir; A merry chritmas to you and yours and the best wishes for the new year. Thank you, I wish you the same. Deep Sight: Recall that within this thread -
https://www.nairaland.com/nigeria/topic-556936.32.html - You had made the statement that critical thinking leads to a non-belief in God, a statement which I consider at odds with critical thinking itself. Ok. Deep Sight: Nonetheless you may recall that within that thread you had made made statements which I have traditionally contested with many scientists over and over again. Basically these statements are to the effect that -
(x) time and space were created by or at the moment of the big bang and - I prefer to say commenced. Deep Sight: (y) the physical singularity existing prior to the big bang could be self-existent - or in your own words - "could simply be the default state of universe-like objects." Ok. Deep Sight: I feel that (x) contradicts (y) lamentably, and I am also severely at odds with the fundamental presupposition contained in each of (x) and (y) as separate statements. I did indicate in that thread that I would open a new thread to discuss these, and you did indicate your acceptance of that proposition.
So here goes.
Premise 1
If time was created by or at the moment of the big bang, then it is not possible to speak about a period "prior to " or "before" the big bang. Accordingly it is not possible to speak of anything existing prior to that instant - and this includes the pre-bang singularity that you spoke about. Not quite. What I'm saying is that time commenced with the expansion of the universe. I have not referred to any time prior to the the singularity. Deep Sight: Premise 2
Physical things exist in space and time. You stated that the pre bang singularity was physical. You then stated that there was no space or time at the point of the existence of the pre-bang singularity. How is it possible for a physical thing or state to exist without space and time. Physical objects within the universe exist within space and time but, does this also apply to the entire universe? To say it does means that one refers to another space and time outside this universe for which we currently have no evidence of. This was why I said it may just be that universe-like objects may just exist. Deep Sight: Premises 1 & 2 evince the contradiction between (x) and (y).
Premise 3 - the problem with statement (x)
The problem with statement (x) is that if space was created by the big bang, please tell me what space is expanding into? That is an interesting question but, we do not even have enough information to know if that is even an appropriate question. Deep Sight: Premsie 4 - the problem with statement (y)
The problem with statement (y) is that it presumes a physical singularity to be self-existent. Aside from the fact that you have yet to properly articulate what that singularity is, the fundamental problem is that it is an illogicality to define any physical thing as self-existent because physical things are changeable whereas self-existence connotes immutability. What objects are self existent? The God that you claim as being a self existent mind that changes simply cannot be self existent because this mind changes. So again, what objects are self-existent? Deep Sight: Conclusion: Your belief, and the assertion of the scientific community that time and space were ignited by or at the moment of the big bang, is insupportable, and delivers more contradictions than answers. Please go ahead and demonstrate how the big bang theory is contradictory. Also, could you please present your idea that explains the cosmological discoveries? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Miracles Are Still Real (crippled Up Then Healed) by thehomer: 9:29pm On Dec 30, 2010 |
kris2glo: Jesus healed me from Black Magic
This is my testimony to the living Lord Jesus Christ which has been long over due but only recently have I realized the importance of a testimony. I belong to a Roman Catholic family (third of five children).
I married in 1982. Little did I know that my sister-in-law had a fling with my brother and was seeking to turn it into marriage which wasn’t my brother’s interest at the time. My husband and I started facing problems and started hearing noises. I could feel a tapping sensation every time I slept at night and I feared going to sleep. If I slept during the day, I would wake up with some part of my body swollen and palpitating. I had fallen very ill and had reduced to mere skin and bones. I visited my doctor due to pain in my abdominal area. The doctor said that my uterus had shifted and I would have to undergo surgery but he was unable to figure out what exactly was wrong with me.
I was then directed by a friend to a gifted Roman Catholic priest in Dec 1983. It was here that the priest told us that my sister-in-law had done black magic to me and cast multiple spells to break my marriage initially (which by the grace of God, though many hardships prior to and on my wedding day didn’t come into effect) and also cast a spell to stop me from getting children.
Prior to going to the priest, my family had me go to some Hindu tantric places (Please never go to these places, your problem only worsens as they converse with spirits). They too had mentioned that black magic was done by my sister-in-law. After going to these places, my problems still persisted.
The priest prayed over me and at that very moment I felt the world so much brighter. He then instructed my husband to pray (using the precious blood of Jesus) over my abdominal area everyday for the next couple of weeks. In the next couple of weeks by July ‘84, I conceived and was blessed with a healthy baby boy. On the 30th of December 2010, I will be completing 28 years of marriage.
I thank the Lord Jesus for these blessings. An interesting story. Congratulations on your marriage and child(ren). I have a few questions. 1. What does this shifting of your uterus mean? I'm sure that's not a medical term. 2. Did you have the surgery? 3. Were you able to confirm that your sister-in-law was performing black-magic? 4. This priest must have been an interesting fellow. Did he perform any exorcisms? Because I heard they were trained at it and even intend to resume training in exorcisms. Thanks. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Miracles Are Still Real (crippled Up Then Healed) by thehomer: 9:24pm On Dec 30, 2010 |
Joagbaje: Jesus had the cut off skin to heal back. Several people have done similar miracles.I've even placed back my own cut skin and it healed after few days! Does your amputees have the missing parts? for a missing amputee bone to be replaced ,that's not healing , it's a creative miracle. And it's posible if we have faith. And touching someone whose ear was cut off which proceeded to close up is not a creative miracle? How about raising someone from the dead? Or making a blind person see? Which of them should be easier? And it's now the amputees fault that his faith is not enough. It seems God really hates amputees since he has refused to give any of them enough faith. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 9:10pm On Dec 30, 2010 |
logic1: Science posits a beginning and a cause for the universe. And what was the scientific cause for the universe? logic1: The reason why science makes the above propositions is because it is established fact that every physical substance has a beginning. No. The conclusion of the Big Bang was arrived at due to evidence showing the expansion of the universe and other theories such as Einstein's theory of General Relativity. logic1: Everything in the universe including the universe as a whole is referenced by space and time. The universe has size (space) and has an age (time). Yes. So what? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Questions For Logic1 (if You Have Doubts Concerning The Christian Faith) by thehomer: 9:02pm On Dec 30, 2010 |
logic1: Now we have some improvement. If you do not know the answers to these things then you do not have enough information to disprove the existence of God. The existence of which God? Your God? You need to realize that non-belief in your God can be arrived at using multiple means especially when one considers the contents of the book he was supposed to have written. logic1: I think the problem with Atheism is the brazenness which most atheists have in the face of ignorance. This is interesting. What do you think atheism is? logic1: A more scientific stance would be agnosticism rather than atheism. One thing you need to understand is that agnosticism and atheism answer different questions. Agnosticism is about knowledge, atheism is a concept about the existence of Gods. |