₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,400 members, 8,522,865 topics. Date: Sunday, 22 November 2026 at 08:17 AM

Toggle theme

Thehomer's Posts

Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 (of 210 pages)

Christianity Etc › Re: Could You Give Me One Piece Of Significant Evidence Of A God? by thehomer: 10:29pm On Feb 24, 2010
After scrolling through most of the posts here, there was still no piece of evidence of a God.

manmustwac:
Thats a good statement when u look at it from an agnostic point of view but then the ball is in the court of the theist to prove what he believes. How do expect the athiest to disprove what cannot be proven?
As the above poster noted, you cannot disprove what does not exist. The Russel's teapot analogy fits quite well here. You can add to that any absurd object you can think of. e.g a pink unicorn, magic elves etc. Sure we cannot prove they exist but following the theists reasoning, they do exist.

Besides if any of the Gods exist, surely they should still be leaving some evidence that will be detectable by scientific means.
Islam › Re: Do Atheist Have Good Conscience ? by thehomer: 10:20pm On Feb 20, 2010
bawomolo:
This thread has to do with the illusion that there can't be morality without religion.

It's like hey humans can be moral without some big guy in the sky guiding us.

laughable.
The above speaker is quite right. Does the OP actually think that if people stopped believing in god that they will start robbing and murdering people all over the place? He then goes ahead to declare that they are the worst forms of humanity. Why do you hate atheists so much? After all they simply extend the non-belief in other gods to yours.
If the reason why you are kind to others is a fear of punishment or a reward in some other time, you are actually a very selfish and immoral person who cannot carry out good deeds for the basic fact that you are dealing with a fellow human being.
Islam › Re: Can A True Muslim Leave Islam? by thehomer: 9:38pm On Feb 20, 2010
I wonder if any of the other people followed the link.

This guy did what all muslims are supposed to do so how can you still say no?

To say no simply means you commit the No True Scotsman fallacy. In which you redefine a term (in this case "true muslim"wink to exclude anyone who carries out the mentioned action (i.e leaves the religion).
Christianity Etc › Re: Should Religious Dogma Be Free From Criticism? by thehomer(op): 10:59am On Feb 20, 2010
4 Play:
The questions you pose are obscenely ignorant.
Ignorance is not a crime. The problem arises when one is actually ignorant but claims not to be ignorant and goes ahead to demonstrate ignorance.

4 Play:
It's tantamount to asking whether Hitler was racist.
No it isn't. You have successfully committed the straw man fallacy. So there is no point refuting this.

4 Play:
There is a world of difference between a state without state religion and a state that is virulently anti-religion.

Stalin was viciously anti-religion,so much so, that he sought to abolish organised religion by waging a campaign of terror against it and religious adherents. Same applies to Mao. Their very own philosophy promoted non-belief and sought to impose this by force leading to the deaths of millions
I agree that both examples you gave oppressed religious freedom but both men also had Cults of personality. It can be argued that they did not want competition from any other form of religion.
The cause of deaths of millions was not due to the pursuit of extinction of religion but due to their authoritarian methods, the wars they fought, political oppression and terrible agricultural policies. You would do well to distinguish these from religious persecution. In Stalin's case, not to diminish the importance of a human life, but a total of less than 150,000 people were killed due to religious reasons through out his reign.

4 Play:
Surely, freedom should have flourished in such a situation where religion was in shackles, which is the premise promoted by this thread. Clearly it didn't.
This thread topic is clear. Besides your statement does not really follow because freedom of any sort is not influenced only by religion. So your conclusion is based on a faulty premise. Here let me clarify.
Right now we are criticizing Stalin and Mao who to some people are heroes in their own ways but it is generally accepted to criticize these people, their policies etc. But if one were to criticize religious concepts of crime and punishment, origin of humans on earth, miracles/weird occurrences, some people get offended enough to plan and carry out bodily harm, others feel it should be beyond criticism. This thread asks if Nairaland accepts that it is beyond criticism.
Christianity Etc › Re: Should Religious Dogma Be Free From Criticism? by thehomer(op): 9:08pm On Feb 18, 2010
[quote author=tpia. link=topic=399411.msg5535284#msg5535284 date=1266454774]your claims about darwin, marx, etc being discussed freely here.
use the search function to see your fellow atheists in action.[/quote]I meant in the society at large not just Nairaland. Even then, are there no caricatures of the above named people, are their ideas not being debated? No one characterizes such as blasphemy or goes as far as trying to kill people for a difference of opinion.

4 Play:
This is an incredibly ignorant question to ask. Seriously, what secular beliefs was Stalin pushing?
You call the question ignorant. Is there such a thing? There may be non-questions or questions based on faulty assumptions but ignorant? Generally when someone asks a question, it may simply be because the person does not know. You could answer the questions or at least help the person as to where the information can be obtained.

These are the two meanings that more closely show what I meant.
# Not specifically religious.
# Temporal; something that is worldly or otherwise not based on something timeless.

Pretty much all countries without state religions can be said to push secular beliefs so what is special about Stalin's case?
Christianity Etc › Re: Should Religious Dogma Be Free From Criticism? by thehomer(op): 12:41am On Feb 18, 2010
@tpia

Which of my claims?

4 Play:
Last time I checked, atheists in the Soviet Union, China, North Korea and the rest have massacred more people in the 20th century in pursuit of their rather secular beliefs than Christians and even Muslims have managed in the same century.
You have mentioned totalitarian regimes which of course encourages killings and in wars even civil wars/revolutions, people do die. What secular beliefs were being pursued because you seem to imply this as being the cause of the deaths.
One thing to be noted is that those deaths did not occur because their governments were trying to spread atheism.
Christianity Etc › Re: Abolish Religion ? by thehomer: 11:36pm On Feb 17, 2010
disciplex:
There is no doubt whatsoever that religion,true or false has been a major force in peoples lives,embedding that sense of responsibility,judgment and fear of god (deity) or punishment for whatever sin.That knowledge from childhood has helped shape our lives for better in many ways.
That may work for children but when it comes to at least adolescents and above, the sense of responsibility and other things are more influenced by their genes or the way they were raised than by religious convictions. A case in point being the rate of teenage pregnancies.

disciplex:
However,i'd quickly point out that it is equally responsible bad side that comes from extremism but how many people out the 1.2 billion Muslims or over 2 billion christians jump into suicide vests and blow people up? Extremists like Bin Laden or Christian extremists like Mr Bush and their entire clan account for only 0.1% of the over 3.5 billion people that follow the Abrahamic traditions.
And I say it's not because of the religion that they do not carry out these evil acts but more from the way they were raised in their families and societies.

disciplex:
Religion has its strong and weak points buts its intention weather true or false is good for mankind.
What do you mean by this statement? That is if the intention is deception it is equally as good as honesty?

disciplex:
The basic teachings of every religion is peace and love for each other.
Not necessarily. Lots of other religions have a myriad of laws attached that are to be followed. Some which are considered barbaric by today's standards.

disciplex:
I have seen people leave conflicts for God to resolve."Leave everything to God" is a common saying in nigeria.
This is not usually the best way to resolve conflicts. This sort of saying is one of the reasons why people refuse to stand for their rights. Someone steals public funds and you're waiting for God to either bless him or punish him?

disciplex:
Finally,i think atheists like the hitlers and stalins of our day should be kept in check as free thinking without the concept of God would lead to chaos just as history has thought us.I'm not sure about this but its quite believable that atheists may've been responsible for the atlantic slave trade. tongue
Hitler was not an atheist. Stalin also began as a christian but later became an atheist.
Your claim about freethinking without the God concept would lead to chaos. What is your hypothesis?
Actually what history has shown is that people will do anything for great control over other people.
Now you seem to believe that atheists were responsible for the trans Atlantic slave trade. Please show us your evidence since if I recall history correctly, slavery had always been a part of human history. You would do yourself a lot of good to read about the history of slavery and also consider that some people felt it was their religious right to have slaves.

disciplex:
What would life be without God?
Let me rephrase the question. What would our lives be like without religion?
Here's a quote to help you put it in perspective
"With or without religion, you would have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things. But for good people to do evil things, that takes religion." - Steven Weinberg
Christianity Etc › Re: Should Religious Dogma Be Free From Criticism? by thehomer(op): 11:09pm On Feb 16, 2010
[quote author=tpia. link=topic=399411.msg5526875#msg5526875 date=1266354675]^^ try criticizing Darwin, Marx, etc.

Go to the politics section and start a thread criticizing a political figure.

then compare your results.[/quote]This has already been done. We have cartoons and caricatures of politicians, scientists etc. Their merits and demerits discussed openly but religious ideas, no way. If the discussion forum is large enough, they claim discrimination. I say religion should not get a special pass.

JeSoul:
Point taken. And I draw the line when one's "faith" spills over from their personal lives and affects others. I have no problem with bringing the fury down on such - whatever the religion/faith/dogma may be. One cannot go round claiming religion while blowing up others or murdering abortion doctors.
Ok.

JeSoul:
What I question are the incessant, relentless attacks on religion from bored antagonists borne soley out of spite and a false sense of superiority, for the sole purpose of mocking and ridiculing beliefs they personally consider outlandish, directed at a harmless set of people who are minding their own business and contributing to their societies. In which case, I say leave them with their holy books. Live and let live.
I posit that this will be best served by a secular society (which does not affect your practice of religion on yourself) that makes policy decisions based on good scientific evidence. I also agree with your live and let live philosophy but with a caveat as long as no one takes my money for any unjustifiable reason.

jagunlabi:
One can do that, but only without criticism. grin
It cannot be done without criticism I mean how can you demonstrate to the person that the view they hold is wrong and should not apply to whomever they meet?

jagunlabi:
I think religious beliefs are just way too personal to leave open to public scrutiny.
I like and agree with the injunction that says, "keep thy religion to thyself".That way, nobody's feelings get hurt.
Don't tell me about your god unless i ask for it, and definitely never try to convert me, unless i voluntarily open myself up for conversion, and definitely never try to demonize my position and start throwing hells and demons and devils at me, because that will only elicit negative reactions from me.
We're learning . . .
I agree with that injunction too which is why I feel religion should not be in the public sphere at any level.
Christianity Etc › Re: Should Religious Dogma Be Free From Criticism? by thehomer(op): 10:35pm On Feb 16, 2010
jagunlabi:
I disagree with you here.Economic principles, philosophical principles, political opinions, etc, all elicit the same negative reactions to criticisms as do religious dogmas because they are all mind forms used by humans as their identities for theif worldly self.
Yes people tend to react negatively to criticisms of such things but it is acceptable to the public to discuss these things and point out the flaws on each side but I feel that religious opinions too should fall under the realm of things that can be discussed openly not to be protected in some sort of glass box.
Christianity Etc › Re: Should Religious Dogma Be Free From Criticism? by thehomer(op): 10:23pm On Feb 16, 2010
jagunlabi:
Thehomer, religious folks invest their entire being into their religious beliefs.Their entire worldly identity is in their beliefs, so if you only just oppose their religious worldview in the slightest, then you have insulted and hurt their very being in the process.
It is just the same thing with big football club suppoters.Remember the chelsea supporter who ran his car into innocent folks who he thought were against his beloved club?These folks invest so much of who they are and what they are into the club they support that some are even ready to take another man's life in a coldblooded manner.Does that sound familiar?
I understand what you're saying. But it is a commonly accepted practice to criticize football teams.
At the very least one person may be right in that one team won or that the stats were visible to be seen.  smiley
Also, when someone acts the way you described anywhere in the world, such a person will be punished by the law of the land. But in some regions, a person who carries out an act like that on the basis of religion will be praised.
Christianity Etc › Re: Should Religious Dogma Be Free From Criticism? by thehomer(op): 10:08pm On Feb 16, 2010
[quote author=tpia. link=topic=399411.msg5526772#msg5526772 date=1266352715]depends on who you're talking to.

The pendulum swings all ways- its not only religious people who do this.[/quote]My point is that it is perfectly acceptable to criticize economic principles, philosophical principles, political opinions etc. But when religious ideas are being criticized in a similar manner, the other party gets riled up in some ways at times with disastrous consequences. They seem to feel that religion should be some sort of class apart from these other issues that affect humanity.
Christianity Etc › Re: Should Religious Dogma Be Free From Criticism? by thehomer(op): 9:55pm On Feb 16, 2010
JeSoul:
But what is the motive and usefulness of critisizing a belief that affects no one but the individual in question? If I believe Mary was a virgin when she had Jesus, of what impact does that have on anyone but me? Especially if I am a contributing, functioning member of society, why the need to assault what I believe just because you disagree with it?
While I agree that the example you have given affects no one but yourself? There are lots of instances where it does affect others. e.g death of children due to their parents refusal of appropriate medical treatment. Or the spread of sexually transmitted infections due to refusal of condoms.

JeSoul:
Also I don't understand why the word "dogma" has befallen such a fate that it is viewed almost always negatively. Dogma is simply a set of beliefs - usually ones that prescribe attitudes towards moral living. Where's the beef?  huh
Your definition is incomplete. Here are two definitions from wiktionary.

"An authoritative principle, belief or statement of opinion, especially one considered to be absolutely true regardless of evidence, or without evidence to support it."

"A doctrine (or set of doctrines) relating to matters such as morality and faith, set forth authoritatively by a religious organization or leader."

The excessive dependence on one person's authority I think is the main problem.
Christianity Etc › Should Religious Dogma Be Free From Criticism? by thehomer(op): 9:21pm On Feb 16, 2010
I ask this because often when discussing with religious people, they seem to feel that their opinions on issues discussed in their holy books are above reproach. And sometimes take offense when these ideas are criticized.
What's Nairaland's take on this?
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheist Goes To Hell by thehomer: 1:30pm On Feb 14, 2010
From what has been written in so many religious texts, most of the people who have ever lived on earth (>90%) will end up in hell. This seems to imply that maybe hell was actually meant for humans generally. This is our result from a loving and just God.

blackcypha:
How come all these pple who experience these things describe it differently from person to person?
what about ike uzor nathan who said that he was taken to hell,and that there was nothing like fire there but pple wer just weeping/
or choo thomas who said she was shown hell by Jesus and she saw balls of fire chasing pple from side to side?
why is there CONFLICTING STORIES OF THE SAME PLACE BY DIFFERENT PPLE WHO R CHRISTIANS AND CLAIM TO HAVE BEEN TAKEN BY JESUS SPECIALLY TO SEE THIS HELL OF A PLACE?
This is a very vital question. Could it simply be that these stories are made up to scare people?

OLAADEGBU:
This unfortunately is the curse on humans.  We don't learn from history that's why history keeps repeating itself.  Most of us would rather experience danger than to learn from history.
While you are certainly right about history, has there been any history of hell occuring that we know of?
Christianity Etc › Re: Abolish Religion ? by thehomer: 11:45pm On Feb 13, 2010
Abolishing religion implies using force to stop people from believing whatever they want to believe. This would qualify as a form of tyranny.
People should always be free to believe whatever they want especially when they have been informed of the available alternatives.

I think a better approach will be to educate people well enough at the very least, encourage critical thinking early in their education.
The provision of some forms of general safety mechanisms, which would drastically reduce the feeling that control of basic situations is out of the hands of the individual members of the society e.g social security, health security etc will also go a long way to mitigate the effects of religion.


disciplex:
Do we want to? Religion is one of the few things stopping a lot of people making bad choices. If we were to abolish religion all of the life lessons that were taught to us by religion about right and wrong would be lost. I'm not religious but the only thing stopping religious people from hurting over people is their fear of God and going to hell.
This is a fallacious statement. Do you really think that if someone stopped believing in a god that such a person would start going about stealing, murdering and raping people? Some of the things taught by religion about right and wrong really should not be practiced in this day and age.

disciplex:
I'm aware of zealots using religion as an excuse for terrorism but I truely believe it prevents more crime then it causes. Not only that religion can give people hope in a way that nothing else can.
It can also fail people in a way that nothing else can.

disciplex:
It can give people strength and heal people in a way I guess similar to a placebo. Finally isn't a good idea to be just a little bit religious? Just in case? I always feel it's best to keep all options open. Whats gonna happen if God does exist? you guys who want to abolish religion are gonna have red faces.
The placebo effect is not healing. So which religion do you think is the best option?
If God does exist, nobody knows what will happen.
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is The Fundamental Difference Between Science And Religion? by thehomer: 11:17pm On Feb 12, 2010
sinequanon:
That's OK. You have Krayola to discuss with, and you can be doing your mo-fo and FTFY together.
Now you are simply using any excuse to run away from the issue after being called out.

You have been shown the full meaning of FTFY, you have been presented with a respectable link for you to independently assess the full meaning and I still do not see why you think it is gutter language.

Here's another site where you can see other meanings of the abbreviation in order of popularity I still do not see anything wrong since in this discussion just one of them fits after showing the modification made to your statement.
http://www.abbreviations.com/FTFY

Besides what do you think it means?
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is The Fundamental Difference Between Science And Religion? by thehomer: 10:39pm On Feb 12, 2010
sinequanon:
Kindly write it out in full in your original post, then there will be no gutter language/urban connotations.  wink
You are asking for too much. You could simply read it where I put it in that post. Any one who misunderstands can follow the thread of the discussion and see for themselves what it means.

Besides the effect would be ruined if I wrote it in full.

Though if you wish to reply to that statement, you could write it in full but note that you modified my post to do that as courtesy would require.

You could have simply researched it before you took offense and I still do not know what you thought it meant. Despite the fact that you've been given the meaning you persist in calling it "gutter language".
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is The Fundamental Difference Between Science And Religion? by thehomer: 10:14pm On Feb 12, 2010
FTFY means "Fixed that for you"
http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/FTFY

I'm using the third definition there.

What's wrong with this?
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is The Fundamental Difference Between Science And Religion? by thehomer: 9:18pm On Feb 12, 2010
sinequanon:
Independent of what, thehomer?
I reckon what you are unable to say is, "independent of scientific method."
Your point reduces to "science validates science." It is judge and jury. So what?
Through testing against religious principle, just as science tests against scientific principle. In both cases, the principles are interpreted with respect to the subject under test and some form of peer debate ensues.
I meant independent of whoever is carrying out the experiment.

I think an example of use of this similar method in religion would more clearly illustrate your point.

sinequanon:
I have said the case of ordination of women is a debate over interpretation of the bible. You say it is about ignoring parts of the bible (implicitly trying to impose your own interpretation of the bible). I am happy to disagree with you.
This is not my interpretation the laws are clearly stated. Is there another way of interpreting "homosexuals should be murdered" to become "homosexuals should not be killed instead they should be ordained"?

You still seem to be missing the difference. In religion no one is allowed to rewrite the religious texts. You claim reinterpretation. Is there another way of reinterpreting executing someone for sex outside of marriage? Some choose to apply this others do not. And I'm saying if your religion states in its text that such a person should be executed and this person is not, then what is the religious adherent applying? Is there a rewritten text giving them permission?

sinequanon:
Yes.
Would this universe have any sort of consistency?

sinequanon:
This goes back to my subtle point about consistency. These constants are not 'correct', they are consistent with the body of science. Anything that starts off inconsistent with them has to be reinterpreted until it is consistent -- alternatively, it may remain an unknown for a long period of time. In practice, the physical constant is not going to be the thing that will be changed to reestablish consistency. There may be many other less costly ways of establishing consistency without tinkering with core facts.

In addition to my last point, constants can also be a direct artefact of human intuition, reflecting some habit of perception. The fact, that we haven't conceived a way of escaping the constant, may not be a fact about 'the universe' but about how we habitually interact with it.

I, personally, do not believe in any such a category because I don't see scientific validation as anything particularly special. I do however say that scientists have labelled as supernatural phenomena outside their domain.
If the constant was wrong it would not be consistent with science. The physical constant not changing is due to the way it was arrived at.

I can see your attempt to delve into philosophy with our means of perception and all that which could easily end up with "Nothing exists" which frankly does not help matters.

Do you mean to tell me that you give equal credence to the biochemical basis of disease with respect to say sickle cell anaemia as to the belief that people with this ailment are in fact witches or mermaids sent to cause misery to their families?
Or to the germ theory of disease with respect to small pox as to the belief that this was a god that had to be worshipped until the death of this god?

sinequanon:
Excellent! 'Functioning', not 'accuracy'! That is what I call neutral terminology and was going to suggest 'utility', myself. Note that it also draws into question the notion of purpose.

So, you see, I am not asking you to play with words. I will accept neutral language. If something is fit for purpose (functions), how accurate scientific theory says it is is irrelevant. Even if current understanding in fluid dynamics predicts, to fifty decimal places, that a bee cannot fly because of it's geometry (flexible wing aerodynamics is still in its infancy), the bee can still fly. The term 'accuracy' carries an implicit bias towards science.
You've brought up another wing property of an animal. A little research shows that your statement is a bit off. The bees flight is explained but not by fixed wing equations but by:
"the unconventional combination of short, choppy wing strokes, a rapid rotation of the wing as it flops over and reverses direction, and a very fast wing-beat frequency"
Which is a scientific reason that works and was reproducible. But what is the religious reason that it flies? God did it.

sinequanon:
Independent of what? Verification against what?

Science and science, hmm?  cool
Like I said independent of whoever is carrying out the experiment.

But with religion, what you get depends on the "interpretation" of who you ask.

sinequanon:
The model of an atom is there to predict its behaviour. The predictions of 'the atom as a small bead' failed. The model, which is an interpretation and configuration of fundamental (scientific) principles, then got updated.

Similarly, if a prediction from the bible fails, the statement in the bible gets reinterpreted.
Here you are again with your reinterpretation. Why is this reinterpretation not written into the bible so that future readers will see this and know that there is no need for ambiguity since the reinterpretation is clearer?
Updating information is very different from interpreting it in another way.

sinequanon:
Updates are not available in the fundamental principles of science. The law of conservation of energy has not changed. If it doesn't work, you can devise a new form of energy to make it work and say you are searching for a new type of 'potential' energy. As I said, consistency is all that is required, not truth, and core tenets are rarely the pieces to be updated.

Notwithstanding, I am happy to disagree with you that the changes in the bible were all accidental. If you cannot agree to disagree, maybe you will just have to sit there and stress.  smiley
Updates are not yet available in the fundamental principles of science. FTFY  smiley

The reason why it has not changed is because it is true as far as we know. Well consistency is in fact required in a logical universe. So are you implying that by the inconsistency seen in religion that it is illogical?
Please show me the changes in the bible or other religious text that was due to updates in the current knowledge.

Also during this discussion you seem to be all about trying to poke holes. This does not make your position any stronger. You could also try to demonstrate why you disagree with the topic.

sinequanon:
That sounds typical of most bodies of knowledge. They have diplomatic roots in some communal concern but become increasingly dogmatic as they propagate into the mainstream. I would say that dogma and standardization go hand in hand because nature tends to respect variety.
Science is far from being dogmatic. So far religion, superstition and pseudoscience and maybe others have this claim to fame.
The reason why one is expected to carry out experiments for themselves in school is to show that it is not dogmatic.
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is The Fundamental Difference Between Science And Religion? by thehomer: 1:22am On Feb 12, 2010
sinequanon:
Independent of what, science?

Verified how, scientifically?

See how that can become a circular argument.

Prove that we live in a universe consistent with logic. What is your acceptance of universal logic based on?
Independently verifiable in the sense that you whether as a scientist or non-scientist can verify that the observed phenomenon is correct. e.g the fact that bodies fall at the same rate when acted upon by gravity and that the rate is about 9.8m/s2

How do you wish to verify anything? Religion has no mechanism for this.

Can you consider a universe not based on logic? For one there is a long list of physical constants like the speed of light, the masses of various elements, Planck constant etc. These values do not randomly alter themselves. If the universe were not logical, they should not be correct all the time.

The fact that the tools we use today would not function correctly if these constants were not constant. e.g the reliance of GPS on the interaction between light and gravity.

sinequanon:
I am not a scientist. I don't consider things supernatural. wink
Let me rephrase it what do you consider to be supernatural phenomena?

sinequanon:
I find this view extreme and oversimplified, but we can agree to disagree.
How is it extreme? What reason is given for the "rising and setting" of the sun?

sinequanon:
I'm sure you could find more recent articles. Things move on. It is also the case with religion. Homosexuality and ordination of women is no longer taboo within many churches.
It is not the case with religion I ask you again which religious text has been rewritten that you know of? This is the basis of the belief system of the religion.

sinequanon:
The term accurate is loaded with scientific connotations. Would you say that the shape of a birds wing is "accurate"?
Considering the large variety of birds how do you wish to draw up a standard? Accuracy requires a standard.

sinequanon:
Moreover, when you talk of science leading to accurate predictions you are invoking a statistical perspective and you are talking matters of degree. Can one prediction make a religion "accurate"? At what point does it become "accurate"? Who decides? If you invoke science to answer that question, you are building bias into your assessment.
Now you seem to wish me to play with words. This distracts one from the issue at hand. I used accurate there due to the low margin of error required for proper functioning.

Considering that religion has no method of independent verification and statistics can be seen to function adequately. So let me ask you what method do you wish to use to verify anything?

sinequanon:
"Atoms are indivisible." Do you really need a link?
That was a statement which has long been updated.
(Physics and chemistry) The smallest component of an element having the chemical properties of the element.
It was not a prediction.

sinequanon:
You say "ignored," I say "reinterpreted." Again, we may just have to agree to disagree.
The reason for the differences will be conjecture to some extent.
We are not agreeing to disagree you are evading the core problem.
You have still failed to show why despite the adoption of some of these practices in a minority of religions the updates are still not available in the religious texts.
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is The Fundamental Difference Between Science And Religion? by thehomer: 10:58pm On Feb 11, 2010
sinequanon:
This post by theHomer, I found most relevant,

My own opinion, here, is that religions do have parallel concepts but often to a lesser extent. So I, personally, would not call these differences fundamental.

Maybe, one day, something would supersede modern scientific methodology that would place it on a par with religion.
The differences are very fundamental.
Science is based on independently verifiable evidence.
Religion is based on this definition of faith (Mental acceptance of and confidence in a claim as truth without proof supporting the claim.)

So science already works at a level above religion it's up to religion to try to catch up to science.
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is The Fundamental Difference Between Science And Religion? by thehomer: 10:48pm On Feb 11, 2010
@ Sinequanon
What are the things you consider supernatural?

sinequanon:
This is essentially observation and interpretation, appraisal, reconciliation and reinterpretation. It is common to both science and religion if you use neutral terminology.
No it isn't. In religion there is only one hypothesis and one theory/law and that is God did it. There is no controlled experimentation carried out in religion.


sinequanon:
Specifically, it was, until recently, taboo for a surgeon or other scientist to investigate the claims of patients who had had a near-death-experience and had claimed to have witnessed events or seen out-of-view objects while clinically dead. We may have to agree to disagree on this one, unless I can find an article submitted by a group of (Paris-based) scientists, discribing the difficulty they faced in being taken seriously.
Well find this article and I'm sure I can get you articles that are recent. This just confirms my point that there are no taboo subjects in science.



sinequanon:
No -- fundamentally, no better than the 'amazing' natural constructs we see around us, like termite mounds with their accurate temperature and humidity control. In fact, much science lags behind innovation. Aircraft were airborne before vortex shedding (fundamental to the scientific model of wing technology) was understood. Semi-conductors were in use before their quantum description was developed. Modems were operating at higher speeds than predicted from the early scientific models. Civilisations long past have interacted precisely with the environment without what we know as the scientific method.
The point I was making there was that the development of the technology of computing and of space travel involves very accurate predictions that can easily be traced back to the use of knowledge acquired scientifically. And for these things to function properly, scientific predictions are constantly required.

Please feel free to show me the failed scientific predictions.


sinequanon:
Yes, religious interpretations have evolved and practices changed. Women priests are now aloud in the Catholic Church, if I am not mistaken.

I am not religious, so I have never received any 'holy book'. But I know that the Bible has been rewritten and revamped a number of times.
No female priests are no ordained in the catholic church.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holy_Orders#Ordination_of_women
And the churches that do ordain women have not rewritten the bible to show that they can do this.

No what happens is that some parts of the religious texts are ignored by practitioners who consider themselves liberal. This happens due to the evolution of human culture with greater respect for human rights in those places.
But the change of practices and of interpretations does no effect any changes in the religious texts from which they get the reasoning from.
What happened with the bible was that it was recopied a number of times with errors. This is why even varying denominations can use the same texts even when they have differences. The differences were not written back into their bibles.
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is The Fundamental Difference Between Science And Religion? by thehomer: 11:12pm On Feb 10, 2010
sinequanon:
Do expound. So far, this only looks like an artefact of social construction.

Also, I think any fundamental difference should not also be applicable between religions. Otherwise, it would not set science apart. It would merely put science on the same level as 'yet another' religion.
The scientific method generally follows the pattern of observation, hypothesis, experimentation leads to the formation of a theory, law or a new hypothesis.
This process is not observed in any religion.

sinequanon:
Investigation of near death experience has long been a taboo subject in science, to be avoided if you wished to maintain credibility among your scientific peers. Only recently, under the cover of 'discoveries' in the field of quantum physics, have a small group of scientists summoned up the courage to investigate the phenomenon. But, for as long as it was clear that the issue was a challenge to the existing principles of science, no scientist dared approach the subject without being prepared to become a laughing stock among his peers.
I would expect near death experience to fall more under the medical field but it is not a taboo subject.

sinequanon:
Isn't this a matter of degree rather than some fundamental difference?

Maybe an example would help, here.
The very fact that you are using a computer running on electricity with the ability to communicate with someone on the International Space Station moving round the earth at a speed of 27743km/h which was placed there using scientific means and whose position and velocity are predictable to the nearest metre is not a good enough fact?

Compared to the numerous predictions of the end of the world in the years gone by and these famous predictions by a popular preacher.
1989 Benny Hinn A short man appears within a "few" years who will rule the world as the Antichrist.
1990s Benny Hinn America's first female President will be appointed "in the next few years". Unfortunately, she ends up destroying the nation.
1995 Benny Hinn God destroys America's Homosexual community.


sinequanon:
What about ordination of women bishops, for example. That is a possible change that is being debated. Many churches evolve and even the Bible has evolved.
With the evolution of churches have the errors in the religion been corrected? Have you received an updated version of the Koran or Bible or Bhagavad Gita or any other religious text available? I'm sure you've not.
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is The Fundamental Difference Between Science And Religion? by thehomer: 9:39pm On Feb 10, 2010
I can think of a few fundamental differences

1. Method of acquisition of knowledge.
In science knowledge is acquired through the scientific method which should have been taught in entry level science classes. (Can expound on it)
In religion, knowledge is gained by revelation in an old text or divine inspiration.

2. Permission of free inquiry.
In science one is allowed to ask questions about whatever one feels is relevant in that field.
In religion, some questions are considered taboo.

3. Accuracy of predictions.
In science, the predictions are usually accurate and exceptionally accurate when enough information is known about the systems involved.
In religion the predictions are usually very vague or totally wrong.

4. Inbuilt updating mechanism.
In science it is allowed for new more accurate knowledge to supersede old knowledge if it is correct.
In religion change or correction is not allowed.

These are the few I could come up with off the top of my head.
Islam › Re: Muslims Reject Al-qaeda Offer by thehomer: 11:59pm On Feb 09, 2010
uplawal:
Naija muslims particularly most of the yorubas are weak and cowards, i thought as much when is a yoruba muslim that answered them,yoruba muslims would be the last to join the other muslim Army if eventually the need arise in the future, honestly, i feel ashamed if we can not unite as muslims and fight the enemies in accordance with the SHARIA
Are you serious? Do you really want to join the ranks of Al-qaeda?

For some reason the muslims on this forum are silent on these responses. What is their take on it? None of them not even the poster has given his opinion one way or another.
Literature › Re: Short, Witty Quotes! by thehomer: 12:29am On Jan 24, 2010
Build a man a fire, and he will be warm for a day. Light a man on fire, and he will be warm for the rest of his life. - Dr Twitchy


Give a man a fish; you have fed him for today. Teach a man to fish; and you will not have to listen to his incessant whining about how hungry he is. - Bottom
Islam › Re: Is This Section A Secular Muslim Forum Or An Islamic Muslim Forum by thehomer: 2:43am On Nov 27, 2009
Are there really secular muslims?

How do you wish to stop "unislamic muslims" or "secular muslims" from posting on it? It's a public forum.
Islam › Re: Fanatics, Extremists, Terrorists: What Do They Mean? by thehomer: 2:29am On Nov 27, 2009
None of the posters defined what they felt a moderate muslim should be. I like to think of religiosity as being on a scale with the highest being those who are very intolerant of other religions and 1 being able to allow others practice their religion or non-religion freely in their own home where it does not infringe on others rights, without also infringing on the rights of these other people. (May need further revision since it's just off the top of my head)

On such a scale, the fanatics etc. would include those so highly intolerant as to be willing to kill people based on their (or their leader's) own instructions received from the Qur'an.

A moderate would then fall on the median numbers. What I'd like to find out is what the consensus is on what the characteristics of this median group should be.
Christianity Etc › Re: KAG: Atheism & The Dialectics Of Spirituality by thehomer: 1:52am On Nov 27, 2009
Actually, it has not been proven that we only use 10% or less of our brains. It's a myth. Just sit back and think about what this means. Is it that we only use 10% of our neurons? Or the brain is highly inefficient wasting 90% of glucose and oxygen it consumes? If this were true? Why would highly intelligent animals have a high brain to body mass ratio?

Back to the topic.

I feel that the spirituality that goes with atheism is more of a beauty and wonder at the universe and the sense that matter at all levels display some sort of order or symmetry a lot of which we still do not understand. I think it also includes the joy of discovery of these natural phenomena.
Christianity Etc › Re: Why Christians Ignorantly Oppose The Theory Of Evolution by thehomer: 12:49am On Nov 27, 2009
Why are you attempting to give a religious view a scientific backing? I take it that your views on the origin of living things is from the Bible and this must be based on faith. I hope you understand that if these people could (though they failed miserably) prove that the earth is actually young, you would no longer need faith in this sphere.

Check this site out. http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/dinosaur/blood.html

Generally, wherever scientific fact is demonstrated, faith about these things is lost

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 (of 210 pages)