Thehomer's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 (of 210 pages)
Uyi Iredia: It doesn't even mention killing. It DOESN'T cover it. Knowing you, I'll safely assume you'll contest this clear fact.Do you think that the Christian God's desires trump yours as a Christian? Uyi Iredia: Their talents are lost to earth. And an altruist considers the points I've raised before concluding killing children in the name of going to heaven is right.Which is better going to heaven after death or going to hell? |
Mr anony: A properly basic oneIf you like. Then it is a properly basic assumption that a person has the right to their life. Mr anony: We are in agreement then because in the same way merely waking up into life does not give you justification to claim the life as your property.Come on. Surely you know that life isn't property. I've shown you the difference between having a life an having a car. Mr anony: Lol, I can as well take for granted that people ought to be dead unless you come up with a good reason for keeping them alive.Then go right ahead and do that. Mr anony: Considered in which way? Because if you are going to talk about the moral value of his actions then it is not a different matter from determining whether he ought to be blamed.Considered in the fact that the murderer has unjustly denied someone of their life. Mr anony: Lol, interesting. notice that the context was "Do you believe that a person is free to lead his life in whichever way he chooses?"No, I'm saying a life isn't like a car that can be given to someone else to live. Mr anony: ...and here we come back again to the question of what you mean by an objectively better society and by what universal standard you arrived at that conclusion.We're not there yet. I'm simply pointing out that you took my statement out of context. |
Mr anony: In exactly the same way. In both cases the Jews die. Also you need to learn to detect analogiesPunishing Nazis doesn't kill Jews. Mr anony: ...and you don't think the "pro-choice" ideology is a terrible one?No I don't. |
Mr anony: Of course in the same way you can also be in favour of gassing Jews and still be in support of punishing the Nazi soldier for beating a Jew.Not the same way but I don't think Nazis were punished for beating Jews. Mr anony: In fact during the Holocoast, German soldiers were forbidden from ra[color=#000000]pi[/color]ng their Jewish prisoners but were allowed to send them to the gas chamber. Odd isn't it?Not odd just based on misinformation and a terrible ideology. You'll realize this when you consider why they were forbidden from raping their prisoners. |
Mr anony: Lol, that's interesting. Are you therefore conceding that at 1 week, 1 month, 3months, 6 months, 9 months the baby is a human being? the only issue is for you is at 12 hours?No I'm not. I'm just wondering how you determine that a fetus is a human being. |
Uyi Iredia: @ thehomer: There are 2 problems with the conclusion derived from premise 3. The first is that it doesn't logically follow from premise 3. The reason being that the morality of killing babies is not treated in any of your premises. It is simply assumed in the conclusion.Actually, premise 2 covers it. God's desires trump yours. Just ask Jonah. Uyi Iredia: The second problem is that even if we assume your syllogism is valid the conclusion ignores factors such as the grief caused to parents, potential loss of latent talents of slain babies and the legal right of the child to life.Their grief isn't as important as God's will being done. Their talents aren't lost, they'll be able to express themselves in Heaven. Note that what I'm ultimately saying which is that one who does this is the ultimate altruist. |
nnofaith: @thehomerLet's hope they realize this quickly. |
Sal C: Why did you choose 12 hours? Does this 12 hours has any particular significance as regard this topic?I chose 12 hours to make it easier to make a decision. |
ijawkid: It is what the scriptures teaches....Yeah that is one strain of Christianity. ijawkid: I take the bolded......Do you want to? That would mean God made that person kill the young children. ijawkid: If you say so.......it is the earth where all wickedness and madness is a thing of the past........Okay. Would you say that world is infinitely better than this one? ijawkid: The human definition of genocide which ofcourse isn't Gods view.....abi??......God's view isn't needed here just as it isn't needed to define what football is. ijawkid: ....Is the Bible a good source of information? I mean it talks about a global flood, plants existing before the sun, talking animals, a person living in a big fish and zombies roaming a city. ijawkid: Lol....I do know bro........because it is far from God to act unjustly.......You need to show some evidence that you actually know. The mere claim isn't good enough. Why was your God unable to save those children in Sodom and Gomorrah? ijawkid: Can you please explain how God could have done that??......God through his faithful servant had warned the people about there misconducts........besides the scriptures saysGod could have done it the same way he saved some people bitten by a snake from dying by looking at a bronze snake. I don't think they made that agreement. ijawkid: Answer na ............remember we want to find out if the creator of every life and thing really committed genocideNATO isn't the supposed creator of every life now is it? |
Mr anony: Lol, I don't think that arguing that something is objectively morally wrong is "emotional".The argument hinges on premise 2. Is the egg fertilized after 12 hours a human being? If not, then your second premise fails and with that goes your entire argument. |
Mr anony: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/may/13/kermit-gosnell-found-guilty-murderOne can be in favour of abortion and be in support of Dr. Gosnell's conviction. |
kazeemovic1: It's a condemnable act. Both Bible and Koran forbid it.No they don't. |
ijawkid: Exactly my point.......Okay that is yet another Christian view. In fact, it is one of the points of agreement with Jehovah's Witnesses. ijawkid: I understand your argument,I'm just giving a counter question...Okay. If the person doesn't know, they may be insane, mentally deficient or controlled by God. ijawkid: Nope my bro...I'm talking about ressurection.......I don't believe in re-incarnation......So is it the earth where children play around with lions? ijawkid: It does have a bearing my bro.....you can't just sit there and judge God that he is genocidalHey if the cap fits . . . . The thing is that what he's done meets the definition of genocide. ijawkid: Why can't I tell if God is good or evil..??.....Because you do not have enough information to determine whether or not he is good. ijawkid: God is all powerful and can do what he wants to accomplish his purposes which at the end of the day is for our own good........You don't know that it is for our own good. It may be for the good of the modern Jews or for the good of the aliens 50 light-years away who will need to eat or use humans for their own ends. You simply don't know that. ijawkid: What happened at sodom and gomorah was for the greater good....What greater good? Couldn't he have separated the adults from the children? You said he is all powerful didn't you? Or is God now limited to consequentialism? ijawkid: You still haven't answered clearly if the rebel groups/NATO carried out a genocide on gadaffi and his cohorts.....Again I don't see what bearing this will have. e.g If I say yes, then you've simply shown that people still commit genocide. If I say no, then it means non-combatants weren't being targeted neither was the aim to wipe out a tribe. |
striktlymi: I consider the above as your opinion on the matter and I respect it...What other person's opinion would I be expressing without clearly saying so? I for one don't respect other people's opinion simply because it is their opinion and I see no reason why you should feel that way about mine. If you don't like it, please feel free to criticize it as you've done before. For all you know, you might change my mind. (No matter how unlikely it may seem right now). striktlymi: I believe there are some practices some religious folks uphold today which are far from being acceptable but still mockery would be an ineffective tool if one wants such practices to stop...But, I've also read accounts of people who discarded some of their religious beliefs due to mockery of the ideas. |
Image123: 18th of May 2013, 6pm. If you are set for deliverance, i will give you further instructions on venue.Jesus didn't need a special venue to raise someone from the dead so surely you can do perform your deliverance ritual from any venue. Looking forward to that date. I'll tell you how things turn out on the 19th of May 2013. |
@OLAADEGBU Sorry I've lost interest in continuing this discussion since I've found something more engaging. Maybe I'll check back some other time. I'll still be looking forward to giving Image123 a report on the success of his deliverance. |
OLAADEGBU: After the test remember the time and date given to you by image123.What was the date and time? I must have missed it. Oh I just saw it. I'll let you guys know how things turn out on 19th May. And let Image123 know that Jesus was able to raise someone from the dead without meeting the person. Surely he doesn't need a special venue. |
OLAADEGBU: Answer the simple question instead of laying rabbit trails.Still rambling I see. I don't know how life originated but there are better answers than "God did it". |
OLAADEGBU: After the test remember the time and date given to you by image123.What was the date and time? I must have missed it. |
OLAADEGBU: Here is a test that you can do in the privacy of your four walls. Just be sincere in answering them.Didn't bother to even click through to that page. |
OLAADEGBU: Don't be a makebate. What has the rod of God's judgment got to do with the Virgin Mary?I think God has some other rod he'd like to "give" to Mary. That he in fact gave Mary. Or how does the Bible say she got pregnant? |
OLAADEGBU: If you don't understand the meaning of the word "discursive" why don't you go for your thesaurus?I would suggest that you look it up in a dictionary. |
OLAADEGBU: You have now confirmed that you didn't listen to the claim made on the videoclips and this explains why you remain flummoxed.Were you lying about what the clip said? |
cyrexx: Interesting thread, It's good to have Mr Anony back again. Im loving this discourseYou know me too well. I'm done with that troll. He really cannot see the problems with someone being willing to kill their child for some God. To paraphrase Ingersoll, if God can give such a command, what would the devil do? Can the devil do worse than that? |
Mr anony: I affirm nothing. I have not come across anything in the bible about the eternal fate of babies. You mistake "childlike faith" with "childlike mind".So you're sitting on the fence? Really? Who better than a child with a childlike mind can have childlike faith? Mr anony: I think three year olds have a will because they can make choices however I don't think they know the full moral consequences of their choices. The preceding is merely what I think.Let me go with something even simpler. How about one year olds? Mr anony: and once again, you conveniently miss the point of the analogy which is about authority.The mere presence of God doesn't grant him authority. Mr anony: It is not genocide when you destroy something that you have created and have absolute authority over.Genocide has a certain meaning. Unless you wish to redefine it, I think we should stick to well known meaning in English. So, are you saying it isn't genocide when God commands people to commit what is defined as genocide? Mr anony: The bible doesn't sayAnd many theologians and Christians would disagree with you. Now who is ignorant about Christianity? Mr anony: In the same way you are in no position to determine whether or not it is altruism in the Christian worldviewAgain, my assessment (and that of many other Christian theologians) is that those children go to heaven. Now if you don't know, then you're not qualified to participate in the debate until you do know. Mr anony: If by arbitrary you mean that God has unlimited power and authority, then yes He is. But if by arbitrary you mean God does things on a whim, then no He isn't arbitrary as He has a fixed character. Which do you mean?By arbitrary, I mean what you mean with your examples of people just destroying whatever they create without justification basically on a whim. If he had a fixed character, then he cannot be permitting genocide on the one hand and according to you, now disallowing it on the other. Mr anony: Are you equating human life to that of the salmonella? Secondly, are you saying that you lack the right to defend yourself against an attacker?No I'm not, you seem to be when you say that since man cannot create some life, they don't have a right to destroy it. I'm not saying that either. In fact, what I said before was the opposite of that. Now, do you think man has the right to kill? Mr anony: If God is all powerful and all knowing and good, then in order to contest the goodness of His decisions you must know as much or more than He does about the case case you wish to contest. As men, we don't have that ability.If men don't have that ability, then how do you know he is good? Or even all knowing? I don't have to know as much as he does to know that allowing children to die of malaria, when he can do something about it, isn't a sign of goodness. Mr anony: I'll give you an analogy:- Assuming the the government orders you as a junior police officer to arrest a Mr Okon who is relaxing at home with his family on charges of armed robbery. From where you stand, you don't know that he is guilty, all you know is that he is a happy family man. The only way you can legitimately contest the decision of the government is if you have more information than they do about Mr Okon.I don't think the government or the police works that way unless of course it is a very corrupt system. In which case, you cannot contest what they say or you too will be punished. I don't think you want to make that comparison with a corrupt system otherwise, one can simply say that it is exactly how your God is arbitrary. He claims authority because he thinks might makes right but obviously we as humans disagree. Mr anony: You have not even shown that the bible teaches that God permits genocide, you have only assumed it.God commanded the Israelites to commit genocide. Mr anony: And how do you know this without knowing what Christianity says about the matter?In my OP, I stated that it was a variant of the Christian God. Now since you claim to be ignorant of the fate of those children, I don't think you're qualified then to participate in the argument until their fate is sorted out. |
Mr anony: Actually, you have sovereign rights over things you own such as your house, your car, your clothes, your words etc.That is an assumption wouldn't you agree? Mr anony: but you simply woke up into life with no previous memoryThat still isn't enough justification to lay claim to a piece of property. Mr anony: All you've said here is "I've taken it for granted because I've taken it for granted"I know that is what I've said. Is there something wrong with that? Mr anony: I have not ignored the role of the agent. I just don't see why I should blame him when he hasn't created a worse condition for his subject.Whether or not you blame such a person is a different matter. The point is that this person has done something which has to be considered. Mr anony: Lol, interesting. Do you believe that a person is free to lead his life in whichever way he chooses? If you do, then he owns his life as he owns his car. Especially since he isn't responsible to a transcendent higher power (a.k.a. God)No he doesn't because the person can give away his car and watch someone else drive away with it but cannot give away his life and watch someone else live it. Mr anony: how is "preferable" different from "better than"? Was it not you that said and I quote:That was with respect to the choices to be made as a society. You shouldn't have stripped that response from its context. The fact that an business person would prefer to murder a competitor doesn't mean that such a society would be better than one where business people don't murder their competitors. Mr anony: Happily. I'm thinking of creating such a thread too myselfOkay. |
ijawkid: For the matured persons.....and those persons have special assignments which ofcourse a child below 3 yrs can't fit into......heaven isn't a K.G class.....Okay so not everyone goes to heaven. Does that mean most people who are good according to your Christian worldview would remain on earth? ijawkid: What if the person does not even know why he is doing it??.....That isn't the argument I'm making. ijawkid: They stay right on this earth which is there original Home...chikena....!!!........Okay. Are you talking about reincarnation or some earth in which it's all unicorns and rainbows where children play with lions? ijawkid: You should care bro...I really want to know wether the word genocide is all encompassing or if we humans just decide to call every killing genocide............My point was that it had no bearing on this argument. ijawkid: And like anony said you can't use our limited human knowledge to judge Gods actions...he is the source and giver of all life, so he knows how (and has the right) to act justly which in our eyes might seem to be unjust.........that is why I'm asking if the extermination of gadaffi and his cohorts(a group) carried out by the libyan insurgents supported by NATO was a genocidal act......In that case, you cannot tell whether or not God is actually good or evil because it may just be that those acts that seem in our eyes to be unjust are actually unjust and he enjoys watching people suffer. And if God is arbitrary, I see no point in bothering with him. |
Hmm. The religion of peace strikes again. [size=3pt][The contents of this message are not offensive. Should you feel offended, please ignore it and move on to the next responder.][/size] |
ijawkid: Those kids who have died are in Gods memory waiting until they are ressurected..........what are children going to heaven to do??......heaven isn't a place for children.....Who is heaven for? ijawkid: We've got to consider on what basis the supposed person carried out the act........The person carried it out on the basis that children who die below that age go to heaven. ijawkid: Yes.......but not life in between death and ressurection.....When these children are resurrected, where do they go? ijawkid: You are judging Gods act on sodom as a genocide?............But no it isn't .....how would you describe natos suPport of the libyan rebels against gadaffi and his cohorts??......I don't care about NATO and Gaddafi and I don't see what bearing that has here since I know people can commit genocide. Yes God's act fits the definition of genocide. Unless you want to redefine genocide. |
Mr anony: This assumes that the victim has a right to their life. The victim didn't bring himself to life neither does he keep himself alive. Who gives him that right?He has it by virtue of being human. That right can be denied with justification. Based on the reasoning you're expressing, no one has any rights to anything. Mr anony: You argument is similar to a man with no previous memory waking up in a house and then claiming rights of ownership over the house just because he happened to wake up in it.No it isn't because the amnesiac need better justification than simply waking up in a certain house. Mr anony: You haven't given a reason why they have any rights to the victims presence. You've only taken it for granted that they do.Yes I've taken it for granted because unless there is a good reason, people shouldn't be killed. Mr anony: Exactly, I'm stating that they are neither better nor worse than each other.Yet you ignore the role played by the agent causing the transition. Don't you think the role of the agent is important? Mr anony: Already having something doesn't give you rights over it by default.I see there's an equivocation here. He doesn't have something like he has a car, he has something by virtue of his own presence like having consciousness. Besides, even if the life he had were like having a car, you're once again ignoring the implication of this line of reasoning. Mr anony: Not really, actually we do compare life to death all the time. It is very easy to say that a state of death (feeling no pain and conscious of nothing) is better than a life of torture.No, what we do is to say that a state of death is preferable to a life of torture. Mr anony: Interesting question! Usually, I'll say that the only way we can determine what is objectively good i.e. how things are supposed to be - is to grant a designer who intends his creation to function in a certain way (a.k.a. God).Would you like another thread to hash this out in the context of my argument? |
striktlymi: Not when it is done with contempt...If what they believe is contemptuous, I see no reason why one shouldn't mock it with contempt. If I encountered an educated person trying to make arguments for e.g female genital mutilation contemptuous mockery will be coming their way. |
Mr anony: That's is what your argument advocates.Yes that is the conclusion of that argument. Mr anony: Don't put words in my mouth or suggest what I have not affirmed.Then what do you affirm? Where do these children go? The Bible seems to indicate that people with childlike minds get to go to heaven. Who has more childlike minds than children? Mr anony: okNo I don't think they do since they're unable to exhibit the sort of judgement that would make them liable for their actions. Now can you please tell me whether or not you think they do have a will? Mr anony: If the government arrests a man, that's fine. If you arrest a man by yourself (kidnapping), it isn't. How about if the Government gives you the authority to arrest the man. Is that fine?Kidnapping isn't arrest. In fact, there's an idea of the citizen's arrest. Besides, as I'm sure you'll quickly say if someone else tried to compare your God to the government, you would say God isn't like the government won't you? You're yet to answer the question I raised there. Here it is again. If God commands people to commit a genocide, is that fine? Mr anony: Again putting words in my mouth. You are not in a position to know what I think. What I said is that God as their creator reserves the right to end a person's life irrespective of the ageThat isn't my question. My question is: where do they go after their lives have been ended by God or at his command? Mr anony: As I said earlier, the bible does not tell him that heaven is an automatic for three year olds. He is killing them for his own personal reasons of what he thinks the bible ought to say. That is not altruism in the Christian worldview.Where do you think the Bible says they go? Unless you can actually answer this, then you're in no position to determine whether or not it is altruism. Mr anony: That's like saying it is special pleading that the police car has the right to go over the speed limit while you don't.Actually, it is only with the right justification that the police car can go over the speed limit. You can also go over the speed limit in your own car if you have the right justification. Declaring that God can do whatever he likes makes the God an arbitrary God. Is the Christian God an arbitrary God? Mr anony: Man neither creates the life nor sustains it and hence lacks the right to take it.So, since you didn't create the Salmonella that has infected you means that you don't have the right to take antibiotics to kill it. Mr anony: Lol, was this what you were trying to get at all along?Actually, you need to show that I have a poor understanding of Christian theology because there are multiple strains of it some of which are contradictory. You've just implied that the Christian God may as well be arbitrary and if he is, then he is unworthy of worship. Now you see why you should be careful to consider the justification for an action or entity before endorsing it. Mr anony: Does this mean that a modern genocide is people carrying out God's work? No, the bible teaches us that God in this dispensation of grace has allowed the wicked until the last day for their judgment. He doesn't give anyone the right to carry out His judgment for Him.Since you've implied that God can be arbitrary (which you've done over and over again), how do you know he hasn't decided to update the Bible that is if the Bible even teaches that he no longer permits genocide? Mr anony: No Christian led by the Holy Spirit will kill a man (whether into heaven or out of heaven) because that will be contrary to what Christ commands. It is impossible to serve God by disobeying Him.I'm not saying that one who does this is a Christian, I'm saying that one who does this is an altruist in the Christian worldview because such a person has paid the ultimate price to grant others the ultimate reward. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 (of 210 pages)
