₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,384 members, 8,522,751 topics. Date: Saturday, 21 November 2026 at 10:24 PM

Toggle theme

Thehomer's Posts

Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 (of 210 pages)

Christianity Etc › Re: The Atheist: The Inferrer by thehomer: 8:15pm On May 21, 2013
mkmyers45: Quite an unacceptable answer don't you think? They has to be a yardstick for you no? E.g It has to be direct or atleast proper inference then its evidence to me or do you pick at will to suit yourself?
The sort of evidence that will be satisfactory when it comes to mathematics is different from one in astronomy and different from one in philosophy and different from one in law. So, I need to know what subject you have in mind.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Atheist: The Inferrer by thehomer: 6:25pm On May 21, 2013
mkmyers45: For anything, If an subject is put forward and you say 'Its Impossible' What will you accept as evidence. Will you accept only direct evidence, word of mouth, inferred evidence (Because this is present/absent hence this must be this)? Don't you have a set standard to judge something to be true?
It depends on what the subject is.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Atheist: The Inferrer by thehomer: 5:09pm On May 21, 2013
mkmyers45: I am opening this thread based on the debated subject of evidence and its an avenue for atheists to step up and state in simple terms what evidence is and to what level should be infer it...

So to the atheist, what is acceptable as evidence? Only what you can see, feel and touch?
Acceptable evidence for what?
Christianity Etc › Re: Barack Obama Gay Sex Scandal New Evidence by thehomer: 4:52pm On May 21, 2013
Image123: unbelief, pride, disobedience etc. You don't know God like me or more than me, do you?
What? So it isn't only iron chariots that can stop God but unbelief (except when Gideon didn't believe and asked for evidence in Judges 6:36), pride (except when he made Moses lead the Israelites to the promised land), disobedience (except when he forced Jonah to Nineveh).

Looks like I know more about the idea of the Christian God than you do.
Christianity Etc › Re: Argument Against Supernatural God. by thehomer: 4:38pm On May 21, 2013
Deep Sight: What is the meaning of the word "necessary". I cannot do your homework for you, I know you are knowledgeable enough. That argument in the OP is as disastrously nonsensical as any i have ever seen, and you can see it clearly.
I've not asked you to do my homework for me. All I ask is that you show what the problem is. You could have done that by telling me what you thought the word "necessary" meant here and then gone ahead to show me what the problem was.
Christianity Etc › Re: Argument Against Supernatural God. by thehomer: 4:35pm On May 21, 2013
striktlymi: 'A' will only be in doubt if 'B' or 'C' did not exist...unless you are saying that 'B' existed of itself without anything or anyone causing it.
Of course. Otherwise, why accept that "A" existed of itself without anyone or anything causing it?
Christianity Etc › Re: Barack Obama Gay Sex Scandal New Evidence by thehomer: 7:23am On May 21, 2013
Image123: As usual, satan has blinded your mind from comprehending straight and simple grammar terms and conditions.
Rubbish. What terms and conditions can stop God from doing whatever he wants?
Christianity Etc › Re: Argument Against Supernatural God. by thehomer: 7:22am On May 21, 2013
striktlymi: Morning Kay,

. . . .

You have not demonstrated that God is not necessary...look at it this way...

'A' causes 'B', 'B' causes 'C'...your argument now is that since 'A' and 'B' are both causatives therefore 'A' is not necessary...but this does not follow because without 'A' existing, 'B' or 'C' would not exist.


EDIT:

If the argument is intended for Theists then it would make sense but to an Atheist, it would have failed from the beginning.
If all you can observe is C and maybe B, at what point can you introduce A?
Christianity Etc › Re: Argument Against Supernatural God. by thehomer: 7:19am On May 21, 2013
kambo: His spoken Living wrd.
Hebrews 11 v 3.
"...what is seen is made out of what is not seen..".

Suen created NL usg pre made tools. Made by other men etc.
God used tools created by other Beings? Analogy breaks dwn here!
Its breakdown means either that God didn't create the universe or that he used something that was already present.
Christianity Etc › Re: Barack Obama Gay Sex Scandal New Evidence by thehomer: 6:09pm On May 20, 2013
Well the deadline has passed round the entire globe and I've not been delivered. OLAADEGBU and Image123, what does this say about your God? Looks like he didn't listen to your prayer or wasn't able to deliver me.
Islam › Re: Muslim Students Reject Hijab Ban In Lagos Public Schools by thehomer: 2:52pm On May 20, 2013
Frankly this PRO person should pay more attention to his academics because as a PRO in an organization that should have good communicators, he makes some obvious grammatical errors. This is a press release and it must have been proofread by several people. I didn't study English Language beyond my secondary school level but the errors being made are so obvious that it is worrisome.
Christianity Etc › Re: Ghana Bishop Reveals That Pastor Chris & TB Joshua Are Agents Of Satan by thehomer: 2:19pm On May 20, 2013
Hmm. Maybe this pastor just wants a piece of the huge pie.
Christianity Etc › Re: Argument Against Supernatural God. by thehomer: 11:13am On May 20, 2013
Mr anony: God is the first cause of the cosmos in the same sense that Seun is the cause of nairaland i.e. a being bringing something into existence

I think my point has been made quite clearly
Is God really the first cause of the cosmos? Are you sure there isn't a natural explanation?

Seun didn't cause Nairaland out of a vacuum, he created it using machines that were already available, tools that were already available but what did God cause the cosmos out of?
Christianity Etc › Re: In What Way Is God Good? Inviting Mr Anony And Any Intersted Party by thehomer(op): 1:49pm On May 19, 2013
Ihedinobi: About the "tricky" part, you couldn't have possibly known thehomer before now although the tricks are quite discernible to an attentive person. It's the naive and inexperienced that are taken in by them or surprised.

The "funny" part I didn't know at all. I only found him funny when he wasn't quite meaning to be.
Mmhmm. Is that why you're yet to contribute to this discussion?
Christianity Etc › Re: In What Way Is God Good? Inviting Mr Anony And Any Intersted Party by thehomer(op): 1:47pm On May 19, 2013
Reyginus: I never knew thehomer is tricky and a bit funny.
Well, now you know.

Do you have anything else to say about the topic?
Christianity Etc › Re: About Abortion. by thehomer: 11:04am On May 19, 2013
Mr anony: Is the baby in the womb human?

As long as the baby is human, r[color=#000000]ap[/color]e is not an excuse to kill it. Emotional answers do not count here.
Well, is it human? You've not been able to show that it is without resorting to a fallacious line of reasoning.
Christianity Etc › Re: In What Way Is God Good? Inviting Mr Anony And Any Intersted Party by thehomer(op): 11:02am On May 19, 2013
odumson: God is good in all His doings towards His creatures. it is only when we donnot open our internal and spiritual eyes and minds that we may say God is not good. He is always Good to His creatures through His blessings, protections, and what have you.
Please read the very first post on this thread and explain to me how he was good to the people and animals in that passage from the Bible.
Christianity Etc › Re: About Abortion. by thehomer: 10:53am On May 19, 2013
striktlymi: ...and we take this because my Homy has spoken?

Yep!
No because your so-called modification didn't change your argument.

striktlymi: That really is not a change in life but simply a development in 'structure'...the life remains the same. The 'structure' of every human changes as it develops but the life still remains the same.

Now sniff the life out of that our beautiful "fertilized egg" and let's see what will become of our "several trillion celled human".
Is the life of an organism without a brain the same as the life of an organism with a brain?

striktlymi: Now you err my good sir...I have demonstrated the 'doggedness' of my argument...you want me to do it again?
False. You haven't.
Christianity Etc › Re: Argument Against Supernatural God. by thehomer: 9:23am On May 19, 2013
kambo: lets b a lil exact here. "primary FUNCTION as a cause" - wrong.
Function means bhvr e.g the primary function of ur hart is to pump blood . But d attributes of a hart aint pumping blood.
The attributes of a hart equips it to perform its "primary function"
Doesn't the heart cause the blood to circulate round the body?

kambo: "there isnt sufficien reason to have a supernatural cause supercede a natural cause.."

bogus.
Wat dyu mean by supersede?
A thng supersedg anoda thng only if dat other thng exsts, then
d superseding thng bcomes a replacement.
If a supernatural cause supersedes a natural cause then theyl b only one cause standg-d supernatural cause- and evry1 wud b in d supernatural realm.

Instead of typing so much to point out y ur arg is a misfit. Brevity requires mor economy. I.e just call ur prose crap or nonsense etc..
I couldn't make any sense of this response. Can you try to be a bit clearer about what you're saying here?
Christianity Etc › Re: Argument Against Supernatural God. by thehomer: 9:15am On May 19, 2013
Mr anony: Wow, I find it hard to believe that you of all people blundered this badly

Let me see if I can break it down for you:

1. The laws of logic are necessary laws

2. If the laws of logic exist, they necessarily exist

3. The laws of logic are non-physical

4. Laws can be physical

5. A law is either physical or non-physical

6. A law is not necessarily physical

7. Therefore the laws of logic are not necessary and hence cannot exist


See I've just disproved the laws of logic. Now spot the error in my argument (as you do I'm sure you'll spot the error in yours as well)



Have a Happy Sunday.

Mr Anony
The error in your argument is that you've made a category mistake.

God is supposed to be a causative agent but laws are rules we've derived based on axioms.
Christianity Etc › Re: Argument Against Supernatural God. by thehomer: 9:05am On May 19, 2013
Deep Sight: You didn't?
I didn't. Can you tell me what the flaw was?
Christianity Etc › Re: Argument Against Supernatural God. by thehomer: 9:04am On May 19, 2013
kambo: I may make an effort later to respond more fully to this incoherent babble by the OP.
but , if he's really convinced he did his best and is only being bashed out of wrong sentiments,
he can anonymously email his posting to a more respected authority (or authorities)
and observe their replies.
most wont bother replying
or will politely correct him
the impatient ones who've had a bad day will tell him the raw truth.

posting as if your learning rules of grammer and thinking at the same time while composing ur post..

interesting to see some atheistic solidarity here.
God or no God/ man can't do without a sense of FAMILY and that is God's invention. isnt God wise?

** terribly bored of this site,nowadays..**
God invented the sense of family? Yet it didn't occur to him to create a family rather than having Adam alone roam the garden? He didn't realize that Adam didn't have a companion from those animals? You must be joking.
Christianity Etc › Re: In What Way Is God Good? Inviting Mr Anony And Any Intersted Party by thehomer(op): 8:57am On May 19, 2013
Mr anony: ...and unless we accept that there can only be a right way or wrong way when there is a purposeful design, there is no need to jump to asking what the purpose is. You cannot ask what the purpose is without first accepting that the purpose defines the creation.
How do I know that the design is purposeful if I do not know the purpose? You're asking for a blank to accept whatever it is that you wan to peddle because for all I know, the purpose could actually be malicious towards humans.

Secondly, is "that which is in accordance with the will of your Designer" contrary to what I presented as well-being?

Mr anony: Refer to my answer above
Your answer above still doesn't help.

Mr anony: In that case your analogy fails because the person asking the question is not the creation
It is not an analogy. It is to show you that unless the purpose is known by some other party, then whatever it is that has been made cannot be assessed to determine whether or not it actually fits that purpose. Here, you're the other party who claims knowledge of the purpose, I don't so I'm asking you what the purpose is.

Mr anony: Lol, and he throws his retaliatory jibe. fairplay to you ser
Meh.
Christianity Etc › Re: In What Way Is God Good? Inviting Mr Anony And Any Intersted Party by thehomer(op): 8:21pm On May 18, 2013
Mr anony: These do not tell us anything about an objective well-being
Why on earth do you keep doing this? Do you accept the idea of well-being I presented there before you move on to whether or not it is objective? I just gave you a direct answer to your request for the meaning of well-being yet you turn around and do this?

Mr anony: My well-being is that which is in accordance with the will of my Designer
Does this mean you don't agree with what I said? I'm sorry but the phrase in bold is meaningless and cannot be assessed unless we have an idea of what the will of your designer is. i.e what your designer intends.

Mr anony: But you have not accepted that the designer has an intent? Also I have just shown you that what is objectively good for the creation is subject to the creator.
No, I said I don't know what this designer's intent is so can you tell me what it is? Well if the notion of good is similar to the notion of well-being you presented earlier, then you've not done that because as I said, that phrase in bold is meaningless.

Mr anony: Notice you've already granted that I have an intent. Also notice that in order to legitimately question my drawing, you cannot be my drawing, you must exist outside it and outside me (i.e. the creation cannot legitimately question what the creator is doing because the very rules it will use are subject to the creator.)
I never said this creator you had in mind didn't have an intent, I asked what that intent was.

You've somehow fundamentally misunderstood this example too. The point of that example was to show you that without knowing the intent, the outcome cannot be assessed. That is all.

Mr anony: That jibe was well deserved
grin Yet you've fallen flat on your face once more.
Christianity Etc › Re: In What Way Is God Good? Inviting Mr Anony And Any Intersted Party by thehomer(op): 7:48pm On May 18, 2013
Mr anony: Lol, he does it again. Thehomer's Moment Of Dishonesty season 2.
What I agreed to is that objective good is dependent on objective well-being. I did not agree to any specific definition of well-being. You didn't provide one.
Oh? You wanted a definition of well-being? You should have just asked for that. The definition is available in dictionaries. Last I recall, you were asking for a definition of "objective well-being".

Here's a conception of well-being I have in mind.

Wiktionary: well-being
a state of health, happiness and/or prosperity
Do you agree with this or not? If not, what then is your conception of well-being?

Mr anony: here's an example to explain what i mean.
Assuming the designer made human beings and programmed them to believe that forcing people to have sex with them against your will is not morally wrong, they simply will not see ra[color=#000000]p[/color]e as detrimental to human well-being.
In fact r[color=#000000]ap[/color]e victims (if we can even call them that) in this possible world will only judge [color=#000000]rap[/color]e at worst in the same way one will regard a person talking to him against his will.
They will not feel violated at all neither will they think the ra[color=#000000]pi[/color]st evil. At most they'll think of him as merely an annoying chap.
Also if someone came around and started arresting rapists, the people will think him sick and desperately evil for denying them their right to r[color=#000000]ap[/color]e
What is the designer's intention?

Mr anony: Lol, seriously? I hope you know that you have just said is that you can't accept that a person intended to do something until you know exactly what the particular intent is.

Do you listen to yourself sometimes?
Oh I know what I said. Please tell me what is wrong with what I said.

Look at it this way. If you intended to draw a car but what you drew looks more like a duck than a car, without asking you, how can I tell that you intended to draw a car?

Next time, try to read what you've written before trying to throw a jibe at me.
Christianity Etc › Re: Argument Against Supernatural God. by thehomer: 6:30pm On May 18, 2013
Logicboy03: lol.....Anony has truly lost his touch.....very rare that unfollow his threads!



Or maybe can take this as a good sign that atheists have finally cornered the christians.....
Just in the Nairaland religion section. grin

They might combine with Muslims to crush atheists out there in Nigeria. cry
Christianity Etc › Re: Argument Against Supernatural God. by thehomer: 6:21pm On May 18, 2013
Logicboy03: lol....but why...why did y do it? lol......



I am bored......nowadays, there is no difference between Anony and Ijawkid in terms of arguments.......

Is there no christian apologist anymore?
Oh they're apologists all right. They're just bad at it.
Christianity Etc › Re: In What Way Is God Good? Inviting Mr Anony And Any Intersted Party by thehomer(op): 6:19pm On May 18, 2013
Mr anony: Not when you left human well-being completely vague undefined. I can't read your mind bro
Yet you and I have agreed on it.

Mr anony: My apologies, I should have been clearer. I'll rephrase.
Explain to me exactly how you would know that the designer ought not to act in a certain way if he chose to design you to see that way as the right way to act
Why don't you try clarifying with examples of the designer's intention and the effect of its design.

Mr anony: You have not yet accepted that the designer's purpose is what determines how his creation ought to be
No I haven't and I can't until I know what it is. Since you know what it is, why don't you tell me?
Christianity Etc › Re: Barack Obama Gay Sex Scandal New Evidence by thehomer: 5:12pm On May 18, 2013
Still here, no disturbance in the force yet.

Looking forward to the deadline.
Christianity Etc › Re: Argument Against Supernatural God. by thehomer: 5:11pm On May 18, 2013
kambo: organize your thoughts properly before posting.. wat nonsense garbled garbage is this.
Your a disgrace to your atheist folks..
bullet lists of nonsense.
nonsense = not making/lacking sufficient sense to b understandable..
Which line or lines do you think make no sense?
Christianity Etc › Re: Argument Against Supernatural God. by thehomer: 5:10pm On May 18, 2013
kwangi: There's nothing to explain in your post.
It lacks coherence and common sense.
What line lacks coherence?
Christianity Etc › Re: Argument Against Supernatural God. by thehomer: 5:09pm On May 18, 2013
Deep Sight: Are you drunk or something?
Did you spot a flaw?

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 (of 210 pages)