₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,384 members, 8,522,752 topics. Date: Saturday, 21 November 2026 at 10:34 PM

Toggle theme

Thehomer's Posts

Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 (of 210 pages)

Christianity Etc › Re: Still About Death: Inviting Mr Anony And Any Other Interested Parties. by thehomer(op): 10:34am On May 16, 2013
vedaxcool: Yes I have, and u are yet to respond to what I wrote, is this a new set of questions? Coz apparently your OP failed woefully, and to me your new question seem nothing more than a SAVE MY FACE question, any way let me be merciful to you, Abraham followed the commandment of God to sacrifice his son, which his son consented to, and that's is historical fact, Abraham action gets my vote any day! But off course this has nothing to do with your OP which I have shown to be poorly reasoned!
Wow. This is why people like you are a menace. If you cannot see the problem with a man ready to murder his own son for the sake of voices or visions, then I really don't think arguments can help you.

Good luck to you and yours. You surely need it.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheists Becoming More Aggressive In America by thehomer: 8:24am On May 16, 2013
ijawkid: Because it is false........does nt in anyway tell us how the first man came into existence and how the first animals came into existence before producing there kinds......cheesy

And its good to hear you say its a theory......
That isn't what the theory is supposed to explain. By that same line of reasoning, one can say the theory of plate tectonics is false because it doesn't tell us how the earth itself came into existence.
Christianity Etc › Re: Dawkins Tells Atheists To "Mock Religion With Contempt," And Ravi's Response by thehomer: 8:22am On May 16, 2013
striktlymi: Morning Homy,



Like I said before, it is rather rude and condescending...



Cracking a joke is quite different from mocking someone.
Not really. One can be mocking someone by cracking a joke.
Christianity Etc › Re: About Death: Inviting: DeepSight, Thehomer, Ihedinobi, Reyginus, Kay 17 etc. by thehomer: 8:20am On May 16, 2013
Mr anony: How and why has the murder victim been wronged
The murder victim has been unjustly denied their life.

Mr anony: So what? They didn't have any rights to his/her presence to begin with.
Actually they do have rights to the victim's presence unless there are good reasons for denying them that presence.

Mr anony: I didn't skip over it. I argued that since death is not worse than life, the person who causes death has not put the person who died in a worse state.
You're still making a category error. Death and life aren't the sorts of things that can be better or worse than each other. The person causing death has unjustly denied the victim the life they already have. So, you're basically still ignoring the fact that justification is needed to cause the death of someone.

Mr anony: But we haven't established whether life (a conscious state of existence) is better or worse than death (the non-existence of the person). . .also I don't hold that a thing is better just because someone prefers it. There are such things as bad preferences.
I'm saying you you cannot establish that one is better than the other because they're not the sorts of things that can be better or worse than each other. They're in different categories. It is an apples to whales comparison.

One can say that someone living a life without painful cancer is in a better state than someone living a life with a painful cancer. We can say someone who dies painlessly in their sleep at 106 years died better than someone who died at the age of 22 years after being tortured and sleep deprived for 5 days. But we cannot say that someone who is living a life without painful cancer is in a better state than someone who died in their sleep at 106 years.

To put it simply, we compare life to life and death to death not life to death.

Mr anony: I'll put it like this; a thing ought to be preferred because it is good NOT good because it is preferred.
How do we determine what is good?
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheists Becoming More Aggressive In America by thehomer: 7:18am On May 16, 2013
ijawkid: Why do you guys want to indoctrinate the little naïve kids with evolution which is false..??......cheesy.......

Ona wan spoil them??........
Why do you think the theory of evolution is false?
Christianity Etc › Re: If You Had A Chance To Ask God A Question What Would It Be? by thehomer: 7:15am On May 16, 2013
abdulwizzy: i have always wondered alot of things about GOD and the earth cos if GOD created everything then my biggest question is who is GOD and who gave him power over everything.
Why have you expertly hidden yourself away and why do you continue hiding yourself?
Christianity Etc › Re: Dawkins Tells Atheists To "Mock Religion With Contempt," And Ravi's Response by thehomer: 7:12am On May 16, 2013
striktlymi: Now you are trying to make it look subtle but it's not.

Mocking someone's beliefs is not the way to go.
I know you think so but why do you think so? Shouldn't comedians mock people's beliefs? Or do you think no one should ever be mocked?
Christianity Etc › Re: Still About Death: Inviting Mr Anony And Any Other Interested Parties. by thehomer(op): 6:58am On May 16, 2013
ijawkid: i am not sure you do......
Really? Let's take a look shall we?

ijawkid: exactly...Thats why created them in thefirst place
Okay.

ijawkid: Yes he would....but not all humans will and can go to heaven.....the better way to say it is:: if God would prefer all humans gaining everlasting life....the answer is YES...
Okay.

ijawkid: Nope,,,the scriptures does not say..besides little children arent candidates for heaven...what would they gothere to do?? cheesy
Are you saying that children don't go to heaven when they die? If so, then where do those children that died of diseases and other acts of God go?

ijawkid: the question is who is or should be doing the killing?,.....
I'm making the argument that assuming these children go to heaven and the person who does this killing goes to hell, then that person isn't evil, but is an altruist.

ijawkid: until persons are ressurected i dont believe in persons living in some form after death......and God remains the same...
Resurrection is life after death isn't it?

ijawkid: God never committed genocide to start with.....we as humans do not have the right to say the creator ever committed genocide,.....
His attack on Sodom and Gomorrah was indiscriminate. He also commanded people to commit genocide so your claim there is wrong. Genocide has a certain meaning that has to apply once the causative agent is sapient. Saying otherwise simply commits the fallacy of special pleading.
Christianity Etc › Re: Still About Death: Inviting Mr Anony And Any Other Interested Parties. by thehomer(op): 3:54am On May 16, 2013
Mr anony: I'll suppose you want us to talk about God from a Christian perspective. Bearing this in mind let us look at your argument.

First of all, let us look at your presuppositions here. What is your argument taking for granted?

1. You are granting that God (the ultimate creator of all things) exists and He loves people
2. You are granting that there is an afterlife where a person may have a better or worse lot than he/she currently has i.e. heaven and hell. (note that from a christian perspective, hell is punishment for sin while heaven is God's gift of grace)
3. You are granting also that since God loves people, naturally He wants to give them the gift of eternal life in Heaven.

If the above are true, then killing for God is not necessarily a bad thing regardless of the age especially if God is killing the person into heaven.
Okay. Your statement in bold says it all.

Mr anony: Now let us look at your arguments


true


true. He has given heaven as a gift for all who will choose to accept it


I don't know this to be true. This view is not supported by the bible, besides it looks to me like an ad hoc rule sneaked in so as to enhance the shock value of baby killing which will come up later on (why 3? why not 4 or 20 or 67?).
Saying you don't know this to be true means that you think (like some Catholics did) that they maybe end up in Limbo. It is at three because at that age at the very least, they're considered as being innocent. i.e they're unable to actually sin.

Mr anony: While this might sound true on the surface (especially if premise 3 were true). It has the problem of forcing people into heaven against their will.
If it is God who is doing the killing here, then He really hasn't given them heaven as a gift but rather has forced them into heaven. Maybe it is for the "greater good" but then it will mean that God will be doing a disservice to those whom He allows to live beyond age 3.
Do children have a will? You're saying if God does it that's fine but if people do it, it isn't. How about if God commands people to do it? Is that fine?

Mr anony: (note however God still reserves the right to do this as their creator)
This argument raises the question of whether he really does this since when you say you're not sure they'll get into heaven, it means that you think God may be sending them somewhere else.

Mr anony: If all your premises were true, then a person (and I'm assuming a person other than God here) who kills 3 year olds with the intention of forcing them into heaven will not be an altruist because he is forcing them to go to heaven against their will in much the same way as a person forcing gold coins into your pockets against your will is not an altruist.
Actually, such a person is an altruist since they're sending people who don't know better into paradise without caring for the fact that they'll end up in hell themselves. i.e they're helping people get the "ultimate reward" while they themselves get the "ultimate punishment". If that isn't altruism in the Christian worldview, then nothing is.

How is someone helping another person out not an altruist? Maybe you're mistaking the meaning of altruism for something else.

Mr anony: (also he/she doesn't have the right to take a life he/she neither creates nor sustains)
Does anyone other than God have this right? How exactly does God even come to have this right? Such things must be resolved before declaring absolutely that he does have this right otherwise it simply sounds like special pleading.

Mr anony: I honestly don't see how your argument does any kind of job against God.
It does the job that the writers of the Old Testament didn't foresee and you've further revealed this problem by saying that killing for God isn't wrong. Saying this means that it is possible that when we hear of even a modern genocide, those people may just be doing God's work so who are you to criticize them or say otherwise?
Christianity Etc › Re: Still About Death: Inviting Mr Anony And Any Other Interested Parties. by thehomer(op): 3:34am On May 16, 2013
vedaxcool: Is this a new set of question? As clearly your train of "thoughts" as conveyed by the OP has been thoroughly refuted and shown to be a train of banter!
No you haven't. You should have responded to my point about Abraham. Here it is again in a way I hope you can understand.

Should Abraham have followed your God's command to kill his son?
Christianity Etc › Re: Barack Obama Gay Sex Scandal New Evidence by thehomer: 7:23pm On May 15, 2013
OLAADEGBU: I'm just advising you in preparation for your deliverance. You don't have to be impervious.
Just tell me when the deliverance is to hold.
Christianity Etc › Re: Still About Death: Inviting Mr Anony And Any Other Interested Parties. by thehomer(op): 7:22pm On May 15, 2013
Logicboy03: Guy, go back to your cave in the islam section.
A similar mistake the Americans made until they shot Osama in the eye in a three storey building in a city. They've moved out of caves and enjoy modern amenities while embracing bronze age ideas.
Christianity Etc › Re: Dawkins Tells Atheists To "Mock Religion With Contempt," And Ravi's Response by thehomer: 7:19pm On May 15, 2013
striktlymi: Hallo Homy,

Mocking is rude and degrading...one can disagree with a belief without mocking it.
Mocking ideas is sometimes effective. It often plays a role in making people think about what they claim to believe.
Christianity Etc › Re: Barack Obama Gay Sex Scandal New Evidence by thehomer: 6:59pm On May 15, 2013
OLAADEGBU: You have to pass the preliminary test before you go for that deliverance session that image123 is about to conduct. The test is as follows:
Asked and answered here.

You really need some new "tests" to peddle.
Christianity Etc › Re: Still About Death: Inviting Mr Anony And Any Other Interested Parties. by thehomer(op): 6:49pm On May 15, 2013
vedaxcool: grin grin grin grin and God told Humans to kill babies? Your conclusion is just as false as atheism, since God forbade humans from taking the life of another, it then follows, Obedience to God is more important than any false altruism, . . ., after all God could have simply ended the life of the children if it is his will, since it is not his will, then his will, which he clearly has expressed, "we should not take the life of anybody", holds true for any action we want to take.
You need to learn to follow a train of thought. Is it important to obey a God who commands genocide? Or who commands Abraham to kill his own child?
Christianity Etc › Re: Dawkins Tells Atheists To "Mock Religion With Contempt," And Ravi's Response by thehomer: 6:46pm On May 15, 2013
hisblud: What i intend to ask is not whether science will ever fail because sure it does -- Chemotheraphy for instance is how an aspect of science has failed... but what is your CONVICTION [/b]be about science aka chemotherapy , if you are faced with this scenario i.e having cancer of the lungs , and you were hoping that chemo would help but alas it causes your condition to grow worse? Will your [b]conviction be positive or negative towards science?
You still seem confused. Now is cancer a failure of science or is chemotherapy a failure of science?

A well known actress chose to undergo a double mastectomy to prevent her possible development of breast cancer. Is that a failure of science?

What exactly is a failure of science?
Foreign Affairs › Re: Dead Man Wakes Up At His Funeral by thehomer: 4:42pm On May 15, 2013
I wonder what will happen to the doctor who certified this man as dead.
Christianity Etc › Re: Dawkins Tells Atheists To "Mock Religion With Contempt," And Ravi's Response by thehomer: 4:36pm On May 15, 2013
striktlymi: In a world where grown-ups are encouraged to mock others with contempt just because of their beliefs, I wonder what hope is there for our kids...

Really sad!
Are you saying mockery is never justified? Because I think mocking someone for their beliefs especially when they should know better can be justified.

Or should we mock people for their skin colour, physical appearance, deformity or what?
Christianity Etc › Re: Dawkins Tells Atheists To "Mock Religion With Contempt," And Ravi's Response by thehomer: 4:33pm On May 15, 2013
hisblud: If i asked a begging loaded question... you are to break it down to manageable bits that you could answer instead of avoiding the question all together.
My question is this [size=15pt]IF EVER,(generally speaking) science should ever fail, what will be your conviction towards science?[/size]
That's just it. I don't see how I can break it down because your examples aren't showing a failure of science because you're using science to assess science.
Christianity Etc › Re: Barack Obama Gay Sex Scandal New Evidence by thehomer: 4:29pm On May 15, 2013
OLAADEGBU: His philosophy subsists on sophistry. Don't you think that his masters would shrink at the idea of deliverance?
If they'll shrink, then why don't you try the deliverance? Or don't you want me to be "saved"? All I ask is that you let me know when you're climbing the mountain to pray so I can report back to you with the results.
Christianity Etc › Re: Barack Obama Gay Sex Scandal New Evidence by thehomer: 4:27pm On May 15, 2013
OLAADEGBU: Evidence based on reasonable premises you say? That is what the Bible is and it is more of a reason than your birth certificate. When you look at a building, how would you know that there was a builder since you can't see, smell, hear, touch or taste him/her, is it possible to know who the builder is?
The age old fallacy of the bad analogy. The universe is not like a constructed building. The Bible on the other hand is just a bunch of bronze age fairy tales with a 2000 year old twist.

OLAADEGBU: I don't really need to give you more evidence for the existence of God because you really know in your heart of heart that He exists. Another analogy of your behavioral inconsistencies is an atheist who is angry and upset after seeing a violent murder on the news. He is outraged and hopes that the murderer will be punished for his crime. But with his worldview it is unreasonable for him to be angry let alone be outraged because in an atheistic, evolutionary universe where people are just animals, murder is the order of the day and is not different than a lion killing a goat or do we punish a lion for killing a wild goat in the jungle? or rather, if it is true that people are just chemical accidents, then why should we punish a person for murdering another human?
Sure you refuse to present evidence for your God because you really know in your heart of hearts that he doesn't exist. An analogy of your behavioural inconsistencies is a Christian who is angry and upset after seeing the death of a child. He is outraged and hopes the perpetrator is punished but with his worldview, it is unreasonable for him to be angry. After all, God is just taking back his property and the child will live happy in heaven.

OLAADEGBU: At the name of Jesus every knee shall bow. It's either you bow now and worship Him or bow before Him at the Judgment throne, one way or the other your knee will bow and tongue confess Him as Lord.
Come on. Make me kneel. You've been writing and praying but I'm yet to kneel. I for one cannot worship a man made tyrant. No matter how much you guys try to gussy him up.

OLAADEGBU: Paul, even though was not married had the best instruction for marriage and not only for heterosexuals but also stern warning for homosexuals. Hear it from the horse's mouth here:

"And likewise also the men, leaving the natural use of the women, burned in their lust one toward another; men with men working that which is unseemly, and receiving in themselves that recompense of their error which was meet. And even as they did not like to retain God in their knowledge, God gave them over to a reprobate mind, to do those things which are not convenient" (Romans 1:27-28)

You can at least see the link between atheism and homosexuality from this reference.
For all you know, Paul himself may have been homosexual. He just avoided all that in order not to get killed by his fellow Jews. We've seen many people rant against homosexuality only to be caught in the act.

OLAADEGBU: You don't have to banalise every post of mine and make it yours, try being original for once.
Your posts aren't original. I'm just trying to show you how effective they are as arguments. grin Embarrassingly poor arguments that is.

OLAADEGBU: What's the difference between a humanist and a naturalist are they not both materialists who believe that we exist as a result of chemical accidents?
What makes you think that it is what they believe?
Christianity Etc › Re: Barack Obama Gay Sex Scandal New Evidence by thehomer: 4:16pm On May 15, 2013
OLAADEGBU: image123 is accurate in tagging you as the master of fallacy and, you've proved this with the loaded question you are now asking.
Wrong. It is not a loaded question. Your God met with Mary and she supposedly got pregnant without having intercourse with any man. How did she get pregnant?

Saying it is a loaded question means Mary wasn't pregnant and that would raise the question of who Jesus was and whether he even existed.

Be very careful with bandying fallacies about without bothering to understand the implications. It could easily come back and bite you in the rump.
Christianity Etc › Re: Barack Obama Gay Sex Scandal New Evidence by thehomer: 4:13pm On May 15, 2013
OLAADEGBU: Yon't have to be discursive. The point I was making by posting that videoclip was for you to see the use of parables by the Doctor in driving home his point and how the POTUS looked befuddled just as you've been on this thread. tongue
Nothing wrong with being philosophically discursive. Why should I care about his use of parables when the policy he's pushing makes no sense and just shows his ignorance about formulating healthcare policies? This is an example of your confusion. You simply mistake bad ideas as being good because you're against the president.
Christianity Etc › Re: Barack Obama Gay Sex Scandal New Evidence by thehomer: 4:11pm On May 15, 2013
OLAADEGBU: You are beginning to sound lugubrious. Did you see the question marks there at the end of the phrases? What did you hear from the person making the claim if you played the videoclip at all? huh
I didn't bother wasting bandwidth playing the clip. I just went with what you wrote. Unless what you wrote was written out of confusion. This is what you wrote:

OLAADEGBU: Bible prophecy in the book of Daniel insinuates that the man of sin would be gay, could the POTUS be gay [size=18pt]as this videoclip portrays[/size]? There are damning evidences that this man is Gay or bisexual that the press is suppressing. Could this be true?
You said the clip portrays Mr. Obama as being gay. Should I believe you and your clip?
Christianity Etc › Re: Barack Obama Gay Sex Scandal New Evidence by thehomer: 4:08pm On May 15, 2013
OLAADEGBU: Stop the hornswoggle and answer the question!
Asked and answered. Read the topic of this thread.
Christianity Etc › Re: About Death: Inviting: DeepSight, Thehomer, Ihedinobi, Reyginus, Kay 17 etc. by thehomer: 4:04pm On May 15, 2013
Mr anony: How and Why?
How what and why what?

Mr anony: How and Why?
They've been denied this person's presence by the deliberate action of someone else. i.e another sapient agent.

Mr anony: What have I leaped over? What logical steps do you think I have neglected or not considered?
You skipped over the agency of the death in murder in a haste to claim that fact of death is all that matters.

Mr anony: This is a vague and unjustified claim. Nearly everything done in a society affects the society one way or the other.
But we're talking about whether or not something is better or worse than another. With the assumption that we prefer what is better.

Mr anony: You can open a new thread on this topic and let's discuss
Good. I'll see you there.
Christianity Etc › Still About Death: Inviting Mr Anony And Any Other Interested Parties. by thehomer(op): 4:03pm On May 15, 2013
As I said before, I have a counter argument for you (Mr Anony) which I think does a better job against God.

Premise 1: God exists and cares about humans.
Premise 2: God would prefer it if most or all humans go to heaven.
Premise 3: All children who die below the age of three years will go to heaven.
Conclusion: It would be right to kill all children below the age of three years until the human species goes extinct. Following from this, the person who does this is the ultimate altruist.

The God here is a variant of the Christian God. And you may assume that people go on living in some form after their death.

In fact, this reasoning has been used as a justification of God's command to commit genocide.

How would you respond?
Christianity Etc › Re: Barack Obama Gay Sex Scandal New Evidence by thehomer: 8:42am On May 15, 2013
Image123: lord of the fallacious, well i guess its ingrained in the genes. When you are set for deliverance, I'll give you further instructions.
Just give me a date and time and I'll be ready. I'll tell you 24 hours later whether it worked or not.
Christianity Etc › Re: Dawkins Tells Atheists To "Mock Religion With Contempt," And Ravi's Response by thehomer: 8:40am On May 15, 2013
hisblud: Lol grin grin

So you dont have the guts to own up to a simple conviction of yours, even if its an assumption, rather you keep sidelining and dodging the question. Lol

Is badu right after all



Most of the science you believe in are based on assumption, and now am asking you..a pointed question, WHAT IF the assumption ever fails, what will be your conviction towards science... stop dodging my friend...
What assumption? Do you have a better alternative?

What you've done is presented a loaded question. Simply take a look at that article and you'll notice that your accusations of me dodging the question are well noted.

What you need to do is to show me in what sense science has failed rather than presuming that it has and going on with your poor question.
Christianity Etc › Re: About Death: Inviting: DeepSight, Thehomer, Ihedinobi, Reyginus, Kay 17 etc. by thehomer: 8:33am On May 15, 2013
Mr anony: Good I believe you've gotten a good grasp of the argument I am making nonetheless I'm going to go one step further: I am arguing that a state of living is not an advantage over a state of death therefore, killing a person is not wrong not only in cases of self-defense but including cases of murder because the murderer has not put his victim in a worse state of being.

Your thoughts...
The process of living and the process by which someone dies are important. Someone who dies from murder has been wronged, the people who care about this person have been wronged. So to go from "there is nothing wrong with death" to "there is nothing wrong with murder" is a huge leap that I don't think has been justified.

The effect of murder is beyond the victim, it has an effect on the society.

Mr anony: p/s: My apologies for not keeping to our march 29 appointment
No problem.

I have a counter argument for you which I think does a better job against God.

Premise 1: God exists and cares about humans.
Premise 2: God would prefer it if most or all humans go to heaven.
Premise 3: All children who die below the age of three years will go to heaven.
Conclusion: It would be right to kill all children below the age of three years until the human species goes extinct. Following from this, the person who does this is the ultimate altruist.

The God here is a variant of the Christian God. And you may assume that people go on living in some form after their death.

In fact, this reasoning has been used as a justification of God's command to commit genocide.

How would you respond?
Christianity Etc › Re: About Death: Inviting: DeepSight, Thehomer, Ihedinobi, Reyginus, Kay 17 etc. by thehomer: 4:17pm On May 14, 2013
Hmm.

Ihedinobi: My twin's back! Yay!....Is he? undecided

Well, here I am. And I think that Death is evil.

I think it is because

1. Evil is a corruption, distortion or, perhaps, outright negation of good or that which is true and right.
What is "that which is true and right"? Is a light bulb "that which is true and right"? Or is Hip Hop "that which is true and right"?

Ihedinobi: 2. Harmonious relationships is true, good and right as nature evidences that when things are rightly and properly related to one another, the best outcomes are realized.
So stochastic relationships aren't good and right yet we find that they're useful in the way we live our lives and even obtain information about the world we live in.

Ihedinobi: 3. Death is a rupture of relationships. The physical type ruptures the relationships between the various parts of the organism's being and between it and the world around it. That is a negation of the right order of things. The spiritual type ruptures the relationship between a man and God. The eternal type is a total separation from the Source of Life.

Thus, Death is evil.

Edit: so sorry, twin bro. I began editing after your op but got otherwise engaged so I didn't see your following post until I posted. Will see about addressing your argument sha, but later grin
Eating is a rupture of relationships between the atoms of complex molecules of the organism that initially contained them. Is eating evil?
Christianity Etc › Re: About Death: Inviting: DeepSight, Thehomer, Ihedinobi, Reyginus, Kay 17 etc. by thehomer: 4:07pm On May 14, 2013
Finally something worthwhile to engage with. I've had to toy with OLAADEGBU during your absence. I'll be moving on from him then.

Mr anony: First of all, I will start with the following presuppositions for the sake of this discussion.

1. I'll assume that souls do not exist and even if they do, they do not live on after or before death
2. I'll also assume that there is no God or gods (yeah you heard that right) but somehow miraculously there is objective good and evil
3. I will suggest we keep the definition of good and evil simple as what a common man may regard as good and bad without having to go into unnecessary lengthy definitions.
This third point is probably going to be where the meat of the problem with your post will lie.

Mr anony: If we accept the above as basic then I will make my argument thus.

Premise 1: A person's existence begins at birth and ends at death
Premise 2: For a thing to be either good or bad, a subject person must exist to experience it
Premise 3: There is no reason to believe that existence is better non-existence
Conclusion: Therefore if to die means to cease to exist, there is nothing wrong with the state death since the dead experience nothing. Furthermore following from this, killing a person is not intrinsically wrong.


Disclaimer for the over excited ones: I am not personally convicted by the above argument but I have presented it to see how you will tackle it. I am also willing to defend it

Let the fun begin!
Let's examine these premises and see if the conclusion follows.

Premise 1 is acceptable.

I guess that for premise 2, you mean for an action to be good or bad rather than a thing since I don't think things like tools are inherently good or bad.

Premise 3 is faulty because existence is a property that an object may or may not have so what object are you referring to that would be better or not if it existed? Do you mean a person?

From your conclusion, it looks like you mean for people. And I agree that there is nothing wrong with the state of death. I also agree that killing a person isn't intrinsically wrong. One can kill someone else in self-defense or in defense of a loved one.

I wonder if this is the argument you actually wanted to make.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 (of 210 pages)