Thehomer's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 (of 210 pages)
Mr anony: Interesting. How does a new-born baby meet that definition in a way that the fetus I showed you does not?You're the harping on what a human being is. Mr anony: That's exactly the implication of "whether it is human or not is irrelevant"No it isn't. Once again, you need to realize that you're the one wondering whether or not it is human not me. Keep in mind the fact that your entire argument still rests on an unresolved logical fallacy. |
striktlymi: You are free to take it the way you want man...the point is only glaring...If it is so glaring, why do you seem to find it difficult to show? Good luck then. |
Mr anony: Hahahaha nice try. Your evasion tactics have failed yet again.That wasn't my claim. Maybe you should take another look at it. Do you understand what naturalism is? From that link I asked you: thehomer: Have you seen matter coming into existence from non-natural incidents?You never answered. |
striktlymi: If you termed that my assertion then it implies that you either did not read Kay's argument or you did not understand the implication of some of its premises...I understood it alright. Its implication was that a natural cause trumps a supernatural one. |
striktlymi: I made no assertions of my own...only built on the argument of Kay.That statement in bold is the assertion. A natural cause trumps a supernatural one. |
Image123: what dead girl and what blind man? Were the dead girl and blind man standing in brazen unbelief of God or proudly mocking God and getting miracles? i have no time for squabbles abeg, you can open another thread to share your disappointments and frustrations. i have shown you plainly from scriptures that the gospel of Christ can be hindered. The gospel of Christ is the good news of salvation, deliverance and healing. i have nothing more to say to you on this thread except on the OP.Okay. I just hope you're not surprised at yet another failure of your God. |
Mr anony: Lol, ridiculous because you say so? Tell me, how do you define a human being?No because once again, I showed you how you committed the fallacy with a reference. Human being has been defined already. See the first definition here. Mr anony: Interesting, so a human being's right to life can be denied based solely on another person's "right" to choose to end it?That isn't what I said. |
Mr anony: it tells me nothing of what you mean by "natural".Look at it this way. Christian is the adjectival form of Christianity. Natural is the adjectival form of Naturalism. If you understand one, you should understand the other. If you cannot, then you just need more instruction on the language. |
Mr anony: Yawn...how does this even relate to what I'm talking aboutYou were asking for something weren't you? Mr anony: Yawn.Keep yawning. Mr anony: The fact that you rejected my answer does not mean I didn't answer your questionYou didn't answer my question. Here it is again in case you've forgotten. thehomer: Secondly, is "that which is in accordance with the will of your Designer" contrary to what I presented as well-being?eWhat exactly are you trying to explain with your analogy? What does it relate to? We are discussing the relationship between a creator and his creation. In your analogy; 1. Who is the creator? 2. Who is the creation? 3. Is the person asking the question a creator or a creation?[/quote]At that point, we were trying to determine whether or not one can discover purpose without being informed. Mr anony: You are the one who is dancing around. You are the one who thinks people ought to act a certain way yet you also think there is no purpose why they ought to act that certain way. If you cannot see the glaring contradiction in your stance, then I really can't help you.Wow. You've started mind reading again. This is just amazing. Mr anony: You must really like your circles.Let's see where we are. So far, I've asked you direct questions but you just wriggle like a fish that has been caught on a hook. I wonder just how far you can go without saying anything while the atrocities of your God are so glaring. This is why I said you were just a bad apologist. Avoiding direct questions is just one of the signs. |
Mr anony: I have answered you clearly that a human being is a human being because of the nature of what he is and not what his body looks like i.e. a person does not grow into becoming a human being. A person is a human being from conception until death.But you did commit the logical fallacy and so far, you've done nothing to rectify it. Saying that a single celled organism or a two celled organism is a human being is just ridiculous. Mr anony: You still haven't said whether it is human or not. Does the age of viability determine whether a one is human or not? If the age of viability doesn't determine if one is human or not then bringing it up has no relevance to the question you were asked.As far as I'm concerned, the question of whether or not it is human is irrelevant since as I'm sure you know, rights can be denied with good reason. So, saying that it is human and therefore deserving to be imposed on the mother isn't enough. |
Mr anony: Lol, in all your dancing around, you have not told me what you mean by "natural" yet you claim everything must be natural.What doesn't it tell you? |
Image123: You didn't add that He could not help unbelievers like the pharisees but only helped those who had faith in Him and were humble to see Him as their Help.Sure like the dead girl that got resurrected? Or the blind man? |
Mr anony: I didn't ask you what naturalism is, I asked you what you mean when you use the word "natural". You have not answered my question.If you know what naturalism is, you'll know what I mean by natural. Natural is the adjectival form of what I mean by naturalism. I notice that as usual, you're unable to actually present your own view and defend it. You just prefer to chuck out pointless diversion. A tactic that you and others in your shoes have accused me of without showing evidence for your accusations. Your attempts are just so obvious its embarrassing. |
Mr anony: The bolded is a non-answer. All you've said is "I know what is bad because I know what is good" You have told us absolutely nothing about what exactly it is that you know.What? This is just ridiculous. Please just look up the definition in a dictionary. Mr anony: You have not provided anything that vaguely looks like an objective well beingYou have actually provided nothing at all. Mr anony: no it shows your failures at comprehensionSince you're so comprehending, why have you avoided answering any direct questions? Mr anony: Not to me. Remind me again what exactly was "clear and obvious". thehomer: Look at it this way. If you intended to draw a car but what you drew looks more like a duck than a car, without asking you, how can I tell that you intended to draw a car?What word or phrase was so confusing to you? Mr anony: Can you differentiate between what ought to be done and what ought not to be done? If you can, then you have some knowledge of how people ought to exist (a.k.a. purpose of people's existence)You do realize that you're asking me to tell you what the purpose of your creator is. Why don't you do it as I've asked repeatedly? If I say what it is, you'll disagree and start dancing around again. Just come out and say what you think it is. Mr anony: Similarly, if you do not know what is objectively right or wrong, you have no grounds to discuss moralityYou haven't even shown that you know what is right or wrong before introducing objectivity. Mr anony: You haven't shown that you have any understanding of the question you set out to ask.Really? Since you understand the questions, just go ahead and answer them using your own idea of right and wrong. It shouldn't be so difficult for you. |
Mr anony: Is it human? Yes or no.If you recall, that was one of my questions to you that you never answered non-fallaciously. Though whatever it is, if it isn't yet at the age of viability, I don't think that it has rights equal to or superior to that of the mother. |
Mr anony: And by "natural" you mean.....?I mean [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalism_%28philosophy%29]this[/url]. |
Image123: i didn't plead for your deliverance. i gave you simple instructions which you did not follow.But Jesus was able to help people in their iniquities. Just face it. Your prayers failed. As usual. |
striktlymi: Nah mehn...you haven't said anything...I just showed you the bare assertion you made that had already been addressed. In the absence of your own response properly countering Kay 17's response, it is taken that you have nothing more to add. |
Mr anony: How can you have a concept of malicious without granting that the creation has a purpose which is being thwarted?Come on. I asked you another direct question and you try to cause another diversion. I have a concept of malicious because I have a concept of the sorts of actions that would promote well-being. Now please answer my direct question. Mr anony: As I said, happiness, health and prosperity mean different things to different people. It is only by granting a designer that you can talk about what ought to be seen as true happiness, prosperity and healthAnother direct question that you're trying to obfuscate. You alone know what you mean by the will of your designer. You and I know what I mean by well-being. Why don't you tell me if what you mean by the will of your designer corresponds to what I mean by well-being? Mr anony: too bad for youIt shows the failures of your attempts at obfuscation. Mr anony: If that was not an analogy, then I don't know what you were trying to say there. As I have said many times over. The moment you start saying that people ought to behave a certain way or that a certain manner of behaviour is objectively better than another, in that very moment, you have assumed that people exist for a purpose and hence they must have a designer.Seriously? You didn't understand something that was so clear and obvious? Do you know the purpose for which people exist? Mr anony: What is the purpose of the designer? we may not know it in it's entirety but whenever we say that a person is acting in an objectively wrong manner, we are indeed saying that the person's actions are not part of the designer's purpose.If you do not know the designer's purpose, then it is actually you who has no say in what is actually right or wrong objectively or subjectively. You have just successfully recused yourself from the discussion of morality. If you feel able, you can go ahead and attempt the questions in the OP with whatever degree of knowledge you have of this designer's purpose. |
Mr anony: https://www.priestsforlife.org/images/baby-phillip-01.jpgThat doesn't look like a zygote to me. Neither does it look like anyone I know so can you tell me how it is human since you think it is? |
Mr anony: If you have an explanation for how nature that wasn't existing caused itself to begin to exist, I'd like to hear itThat's just it. If nothing cannot exist, then there must always have been something natural not necessarily the universe. Mr anony: This assumes that matter is all there is.No, just that the natural is all there is. Mr anony: Nairaland is purely non-material data yet all the things that cause nairaland to exist and sustain it's existence are physical matter.We see matter coming into existence from natural occurrences. Have you seen matter coming into existence from non-natural incidents? |
striktlymi: You forgot to state why you don't think I have.That's just it. You haven't actually done anything other than present assertions. The last clear one was striktlymi: One small detail you left out...the Supernatural cause is also the first cause...without it there will be no natural cause.Your statement about the supernatural cause was just an assertion addressed by Kay 17. |
striktlymi: My goal here is to show the flaw in Kay's argument...I believe I have achieved that...hence I leave as I came...I don't think you have but good luck. |
Image123: Excuse, how?Excuse for your God not responding to your pleas for my deliverance. |
Deep Sight: @ thehomer: your responses in this thread sir, with respect, are utterly cowardly and disgraceful.Since you're so brave, why don't you show me what the problem with my responses are. |
mkmyers45: So are you agreeing that evidence is based on the views and scope of the judge?No, the sort of evidence to be accepted depends on what is being considered. |
edoreedore: Tnx for this research on obama, nice work, additionally, why are you wasting your time arguing with someone that. Wants to deny the truth. You have played your path, let those that are smart see and learn for we wrestle not against flesh and blood but against wicked spirits. Even from. Their utterrances you will know.You think this is research? What a shame. Just run along now since you don't seem to have anything to contribute. |
Image123: yep. We are derailing the thread i think.Is that the best excuse you can give for your God? |
striktlymi: Nope...his conclusion is thay "A" does not exist because "A" is not necessary.Right. And if "A" is not necessary, it would contradict the idea that "A" was necessary. Thus, how can one tell that "A" is out there if all we have is "C" and maybe "B"? |
Image123: does or did?Does. Or can you stop God from doing whatever he wants? |
striktlymi: I have my answer handy but considering that Kay was the one who set up the argument in the first place, he should be the one to tell us why...The conclusion of his argument appears to be that "A" isn't supernatural while you think it is. So, what is your answer? |
Image123: i like the word 'except' that you use. You need to revise the meaning.You really don't understand what I mean do you? What I mean is that God does what he wants to do in spite of the claims you raised that would have stopped him. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 (of 210 pages)