Thehomer's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 (of 210 pages)
[quote author=Mr_Anony]You see this is the problem with butting into a conversation halfway. I and mkmyers had already agreed on the necessity of a moral judge and moved on to describe what its attributes must then be. For you, I can't proceed with this debate from here since you don't acknowledge a moral lawgiver in the first place. We'll backtrack a little. How do you define morality absent an objective moral standard?[/quote]I'd say that morality is the basis by which we determine that an action is right or wrong. I posit that this basis is arrived at due to the effects of actions on sentient creatures. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Dude, you have failed to demonstrate anything. As far as I can see, you are only arguing against the use of a particular word "authority" and not the idea he is trying to convey. This i feel is unnecessary and doesn't help the debate in any way. It only drags it round in circles. . . . .[/quote]I'm not arguing against the use of the word authority. I'm arguing against the use of that word in a certain way because it will easily lead to confusion. |
Pastor AIO: Such as? A few examples would be nice here.Like numbers, mathematical processes etc. They're very different from someone simply telling you something. Pastor AIO:(Emphasis mine) Is it possible for you not to accept the laws of thought? Pastor AIO: The green part is fruitless speculation. How does that affect the argument in anyway?If an authority is self contradictory, how can its will be done? |
Pastor AIO: From what I seem to understand you saying, you insist that an Authority must be a Person, a personality, or a Book. But it cannot be any other source of information. Why?Because some of those other sources of information are inherently different. |
Anyway, it looks like my contribution to this conversation is already doomed due to the non-standard way the word authority is being used. Which is one of the earliest things I pointed out in the thread. |
@ Pastor AIO I'm sorry but your post doesn't really help me because it seemed so all over the place. It is quite distinct from the clear thoughts you usually express. Pastor AIO: What exactly is an Authority? It is something that cannot be questioned. What Authority says, goes. It's will is done. If it says green is Good then no one can argue that Green is Good. If it says brown is bad then similarly no one can argue that Brown is bad. The buck stops with the authority. It's pronouncements are axiomatic.Saying an authority is something that cannot be questioned doesn't really help because there are so many things that cannot be questioned which wouldn't qualify especially because they don't make pronouncements. Is there any authority that can say green (the colour) is Good and it will be accepted? What if the pronouncements of this authority though axiomatic are contradictory? Will its will still be done? |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]You know what, i don't think I need to show you anything, If you fail to understand what he's getting at then that's just too bad. The rest of us seem to understand his premise quite well enough.[/quote]Why do people find it so difficult to back up their claims? I've just demonstrated to you the problems with the concept of authority he wanted to use. If you did understand it, you would be able to show me exactly where I went wrong. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]The question isn't as much if there is a judge but the qualities such a judge must have to qualify.[/quote]Actually, the topic is wondering whether or not morality is possible without the sort of judge you're proposing. I'm saying it is possible you're saying it isn't. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Thats simple, the fact that there is a moral law necessitates a moral lawgiver.[/quote]What is this moral law? And is it prescriptive (i.e does it tell you what to do) or is it descriptive (or does it tell you how things should be). [quote author=Mr_Anony]I think you've read it wrong. It is only right that someone who can judge you must have authority over you.[/quote]Well a dictator has authority over his subjects. Does this mean that his word should be law? [quote author=Mr_Anony]You don't see the need for such a judge to be impartial, firm and of one character? How so?[/quote]I meant that I don't see how a judge being impartial, firm and of one character would affect what it means to perform a moral action. And the biblical God is partial, he has been known to change his mind and how can he be of one character when he is actually three people? I mean, what is his single purpose? [quote author=Mr_Anony]well this I'll concede to since we haven't yet defined "good" and the moral law-giver has to define good.[/quote]If the moral law giver has to define good, does this then mean that whatever he says is good becomes good or is it that he decides that something is good because it is actually good? [quote author=Mr_Anony]Actually 3 wasn't meant to read as diverse viewpoints but all possible viewpoints.[/quote]Okay. So he understands the reasons why people may not accept him and the reasons why people may not accept his morality. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]At thehomer, I would very much like to continue with you but it is beginning to occur to me (and especially reading your argument with InesQor) that you are purposely trying to misunderstand Pastor AIO premise. For this reason, I won't continue with you. I don't want to dance around in circles today. I'll continue with Pastor AIO who by the way is yet to answer my questions though.[/quote]You'll need to show me how you think I misunderstood his premise because it seems to accept pretty much anything as being an authority which doesn't make sense based on the definition of the word in English. I clearly demonstrated the problems with his approach. |
davidylan: you should read it again... this time with some understanding.If you disagree with what I'm saying, what you're supposed to do is to tell me how I was wrong. |
InesQor: @thehomer:Why not? What was the source of your definition? InesQor: I think my points have been made here. I'm tired of going round in circles.My entire point was to show you that certain things fit the idea that you're presenting better than what you're postulating. |
InesQor: What does existence mean to you?It means all that there is. They're roughly divided into abstract and concrete objects. InesQor: When you're hallucinating, you may be deciding to confer the abstract number three to two keys.Hallucinations aren't under your control. If you're perceiving three keys when there are two, then you're not deciding to confer three to two keys, you're just doing it. InesQor: This makes me feel you're just wasting my time. How does this make sense of my earlier submission? I said numbers can be an authority, and not that I am an authority to numbers. Number PI acts as an authority (a reference point) as the ratio of a perfect circle's circumference to its diameter.It makes sense in that you're pretty much implying that anything can be an authority to anything else which doesn't make sense. And that is why the concept should be limited to certain objects like people, books etc. If you cannot be an authority to two, then can someone else be an authority to two? InesQor: Two [/i]defines your use indirectly. In order for you to TELL that it matches the concept, it means you have subjected yourself to comparing the subject with the abstraction in your head for what "[i]two" means. You have accepted and believed what [i]two [/i]represents.You're basically saying that the number two is somehow making you use it correctly. But it isn't so. You use it correctly otherwise you just end up being incoherent. What you're saying is no better than saying that words somehow make you use them correctly when the point is that if you don't use them correctly, you will simply be failing to communicate. |
InesQor: I already mentioned neurological disorders and mental conditions in which one cannot trust the operation of their mind. e.g. Derealization, and delirium. So, if you think you are mentally and neurologically healthy, then you may confer the authority of trust to your (assumed) healthy mind.Yes you did but as I pointed out, you don't grant them authority, you simply perceive what you perceive. InesQor: Anything can be said to have a right of authority if you have [b]allowed [/b]it to [i]influence [/i]your experience.Lol wut? Numbers have rights because you've allowed them to influence your experience? Gravity has rights because you've allowed it to pull you towards the earth? InesQor: Yes, an axiom defines the scope of logic. You can't logically relate to a "largest possible number" because there is an accepted axiom that the set of integers is infinite.How exactly does an axiom define the scope of logic? InesQor: This is why they are called axioms, d'uh. They are already [b]accepted [/b]as [i]unquestionably [/i]correct. Thus are accepted as an authority.So you're basically saying that there are certain authorities that have no support themselves? InesQor: I think the problem you're having is that you're limiting the definition of "authority" to one's sensory perceptions. This is not true. Whatever you accept as authority is authority for you.Actually, I don't think that one's sensory perceptions are an authority. I think it is a misuse of the word to apply it to the senses. |
InesQor: They are abstractions. Ideas not associated with any specific instance, and so they do not "exist" on their own. Yet they can be used as frames of reference.In other words, they do exist. InesQor: Yes, if you are experiencing a sensory illusion your abstraction will differ from mine.If you're hallucinating, then you're not deciding not to confer the abstract number two to two keys. InesQor: The word "another" in bold refers to any instance, object or idea outside that which is being considered as an authority. It can be a person or whatever.Can you be an authority to the number two? InesQor: Scope has its normal meaning in English. The extent of operation, or value, or ambit of definition, if you may.Okay. So with your example of two, is it the number two that is defining your use of it to two keys or are you using the number two for the two keys because of the way it matches the concept? |
InesQor: Yes, senses aren't like books or other people, but you still [i]need [/i]to accept or believe the information they provide.(Emphasis mine) The highlighted portion of your post is what I've been saying all along. InesQor: Every source of information can be considered an authority, as long as you accept it as one. This is why I said conferred [/b]or [b]consented.So you [/b]conferred authority to [b]your [/b]mind? ![]() Who is this you conferring this authority to your mind? InesQor: I am not slipping in my use. My use still stands as [b]An authority defines scope, and augments the position of another. It is a conferred or consented right. An axiom defines the scope within which logic operates, and augments the position of the premises built upon that axiom. This is because we have accepted these axioms as TRUE (i.e. conferred or consented). Surely my position is entirely consistent.Do numbers and your senses have rights? Does an axiom have rights? An axiom defines the scope of logic? Are you sure you don't have it the wrong way around? You're saying that a statement like the set of integers is infinite defines the scope of logic. You're also forgetting that axioms are premises themselves so how is their own position augmented? |
InesQor: No they don't. Can you show me a seven? Or allow me experience a million?You're being self contradictory. You've already said they exist albeit abstractly. InesQor: I confer the abstraction/idea of two upon a set of objects based on mentally associating that set with another group of similar objects with some shared characteristics i.e. size, also a count of two. "Two" in itself means absolutely nothing, and does not exist.Could you decide not to confer the abstract number two to two keys? InesQor: "Two" then defines the scope (i.e. size of the set of objects) and it augments my position because I am informed of the size / limitation of the set of objects.I just noticed that your definition is a bit ambiguous and I'm wondering if that is one of the problems here. Take another look at it. InesQor: An authority defines scope, and augments the position of another. It is a conferred or consented right.Does the word in bold only refer to people? And what is scope there referring to? i.e scope of what? |
InesQor: @thehomer:(Emphasis mine) Come on. You know I'm not splitting hairs. You've effectively shown why your senses aren't like books or other people. Otherwise, what follows is whether you consider your mind to be an authority. How on earth can someone confer the right of authority to an axiom? You see, you're already slipping in your use of the word authority. I simply wonder if you're ready to progress further with the discussion. |
InesQor: Numbers are an abstraction of size, so they can serve as an authority in establishing a relative frame of reference, even though they don't exist as objects. There is no madness in there.In other words, numbers exist. Using your definition, did you confer anything upon numbers or did you consent? How do these abstract numbers define your scope and augment your position? |
InesQor: I hope you READ that I typed [b]conferred [/b]or consented, and not only consented? In the case of senses, they are conferred. In the cas3 of a third party, it is consented. Surely you couldn't have missed that.How is this better? You're saying that you conferred authority to your senses? Can your senses decide to do something else like deceive you the way books or people can? Do you confer authority to your stomach to digest food? Or does it just digest food whether you like it or not? InesQor: So I can't believe you're saying one requires no conferring from their brains to believe or accept their senses! How does sensory perception work then? Why are there neurologically-based conditions like synaesthesia, derealization and delirium?Sensory perception works directly. There are no permissions asked or granted. InesQor: Your senses do not augment the position or define the scope of someone else, but then your senses are not you, so they still augment the position of another (i.e. you, as opposed to the senses themselves).Your senses aren't a person. They're a part of you unlike books or other people. Again, you're butting up against the problems but you're refusing to see it. Is it possible for your senses to augment the position of someone else other than you who they're a part of? InesQor: The point here is that either way, an authority defines scope. It is that which you accept or depend upon or believe in to establish a reference point or axiom.You do realize that axioms are what you accept or depend upon to believe in to establish a reference point. Are they also authorities? |
InesQor: How? Numbers don't even exist. They are abstractions of size, and only have value because we associate them with a group of similar objects with some shared characteristics (all called numbers).Keep in mind the definition that Pastor AIO was using which is what I was responding to. Which was: Pastor AIO: Let's put it this way. An Authority is what you rely on to determine the TRUTH.We use numbers to arrive at some truths don't we? Saying they don't exist means that you're able to grant "authority" to something that doesn't exist. That way lies madness. |
Pastor AIO: Since we know that the senses deceive us all the time how can you confer such a high authority on the senses.That's just it. I don't confer "authority" to my senses. Pastor AIO: People have been hypnotised to feel pain. Pain has been hypnotised away. There are so many effects that can be created by messing with the senses. It is ridiculous to place such a high stock on sensory information.This doesn't counter what I've said. There are various theories behind the idea of hypnosis and none of them really leads to the conclusion that the person is or isn't in pain. Pastor AIO: Imagine a scenario. You are with four friends and you see a white horse and you point at it and say to them, 'look at that beautiful white horse'.If one is hallucinating, then that's all there is to it. All I can say here is that my senses aren't an "authority" in the way that the consensus would be considered to be an authority. |
InesQor: You're splitting hairs.Are you basically saying that you're consenting to use your senses? How is that even possible? Are your senses someone else that you're granting it consent? Do your senses augment the position of someone else other than yourself? Do your senses define the scope of someone other than yourself? I seriously find it difficult to believe that you're trying to defend the idea that your senses are like the Bible or another person. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]You asked whether someone can tell me I don't have a headache, you didn't ask me to name the higher authority[/quote]Okay. So who or what is it? [quote author=Mr_Anony]Please, I'll like to see how you describe pain absent the feeling of pain.[/quote]Why should I? I didn't say anything along those lines. You're the one who was talking of pain in the absence of a stimulus not me. [quote author=Mr_Anony]I think it is quite appropriate, so far you have failed to convince me otherwise[/quote]If you cannot see that one's senses are in a different class from books or other people, then I really cannot help you. [quote author=Mr_Anony]You missed the point. If we relied solely on our senses, we would never be convinced the earth was round unless we saw it for ourselves i.e we would never take anyone else's word for it and since for most of us, our vantage point is based on a seemingly flat landscape, the earth is round theory will never have progressed and consequently most scientific breakthroughs will never have happened. At a point, we just had to accept the authority of someone else even though it disagreed with our senses.[/quote]I didn't miss the point because you're committing another error. Taking another person's word for something doesn't automatically make that person an authority when the person actually has some good reasons for what they're saying. It simply means that the person is right with good reason. The whole point is for you to avoid simply taking people at their word and examining how they arrived at their conclusion. |
Pastor AIO: Let's put it this way. An Authority is what you rely on to determine the TRUTH.Would you say that numbers are an authority just as the Bible and the church are authorities? Note that I didn't say my senses were my authority because the way the word is used makes it open to various degrees of misunderstanding which is what is happening already. |
Thanks. Basically, I disagree that there is any judge that decides on morality and I don't think that the Biblical God even meets the criteria you laid out. [quote author=Mr_Anony]In a nutshell, the following were the criteria mkmyers45 and I agreed to (I think you'll find it on pages 2 and 3 of this thread) the validity of any judge may be based on:- 1. How much power it has, 2. How much it knows about the case 3. If it can see the case from diverse veiwpoints, 4. If it has a good conscience and yet discernible 5. If it is impartial 6. If it is firm and unwavering 7. If it is singular in essense and purpose The better a judge is at satisfying these criteria, the more he/she/it is qualified to judge or be a moral standard.[/quote]What you need to do is to demonstrate that this authority is necessary for morality in the first place. The first one there implies that might makes right and I'm sure you don't think that might is a necessary criterion for moral decisions. I also don't see the need for 5,6 and 7 besides, the biblical God fails on them. What makes for a good conscience? I think 2 and 3 are contradictory. How can it both be omniscient and at the same time be limiting its views to certain viewpoints? |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]I believe I answered the question in the best way that fits this argument unless perhaps you are asking for a specific personal opinion which I don't think holds much worth here.[/quote]No you didn't. You didn't say who or what the higher authority was that would tell you whether or not you were in pain. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Pain is simply because your nervous system is working. Pain is information but this information isn't necessarily always true. You can have the illusion of pain even though there is nothing stimulating it, also you can feel no pain even though something is harming you depending on how well your nervous system is working.[/quote]I don't think you can have the illusion of pain. You're probably confusing the referral of the pain with the sensation and feeling of being in pain itself. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Most of the time, you trust your senses and read meaning into evidence based on your senses but sometimes you can't rely on your senses alone to read evidence, you need to defer to another authority.[/quote]Once again, you're failing to see that using the word "authority" when speaking about the senses is not quite appropriate. [quote author=Mr_Anony]For instance, based solely on the judgment of our senses, the earth would be flat but now we know this not to be true because we were able to doubt our senses and believe another authority.[/quote]No, based on our senses, the earth is round. Deciding on whether or not the earth is flat or round depends on your vantage point and your abilities of inference. Today, it is easily determined by satellite images. In the past, it was done by inference to other objects in space, the solar and lunar eclipse and the fact that the tops of sailing ships appear first and disappear last into the distance among other means. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Please give these reasons: but bear in mind there is a set criteria that I and mkmyers45 have already agreed to which every moral judge must meet. You can see it in previous posts on this thread.[/quote]Please is there a main post that I'm to pay particular attention to? |
davidylan: Na, i chose to get a life... my existence does not consist of responding to illogicality, lies and half-truths.Now you're just being ridiculous. You're simply making an appeal to popularity which doesn't help you. As I told you before, your presentation of evidence to show your integrity. When you make make claims without supporting them, then you're opening yourself up to being a liar since it is liars that generally make claims that they cannot support. Making a fallacious appeal to popularity makes you come across as either ignorant or deliberately misleading (which is another thing that liars do). |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]actually yes, it depends on which authority you hold higher than the other. How do you know for sure that your headache is not an illusion?[/quote]You didn't actually answer my question. I also don't understand what you're saying here. How can someone be having pains and not be in pain? |
davidylan: If that one so much as read the bible, he/she may have seen that the above is completely untrue.I've read the Bible and have come to similar conclusions. e.g is salvation by faith and grace or by performing good acts? |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Oh for starters, God is specific. When I say God as defined by the bible, you know exactly who I am talking about. When I say all mankind, you know that I mean every single person including you and I. One thing is clear, I am not making an analogy. On the other hand, when you say a parent and a child, it is obvious that you are using an analogy, it is not specific at all. You don't name which parent and which child in particular. Besides we are seeking a standard for the morality of man in general and not hypothetical parents and children. So, are we going to make progress or shall we continue to dance around words?[/quote]Are you seriously saying that the God of the Bible is an authoritative source of morality? I ask because there are good reasons why he isn't worthy of being a source of morality. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]My argument would be yes they can. especially since they are not absolute and you are going to make decisions based on them[/quote]And this is why I said that problems can easily creep in with the way the word "authority" was being used. You're already demonstrating the problem since your senses aren't an object or a person. Let me see if I can help you with another question. If you're having a headache is there any person or object which you consider an authority that can tell you that you're not having a headache? |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 (of 210 pages)
