Thehomer's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 (of 210 pages)
Enigma: I even give you an example of a thread on Christianity as being, as you say, "reasonable and "justified" and, for that matter, even more.Wasn't that the thread where I had to teach you what it means for a view to be reasonable and justified? ![]() |
davidylan: That is just trying to skirt around the fact that you are clueless here. Theories are just theories BECAUSE we have no empirical evidence for it and that is FACT. The minute you can provide evidence for a scientific problem then you can start to draw conclusions... At this point, the big b[i]a[/i]ng THEORY is simply a set of conjectures based on very limited REAL DATA that is used to explain the origin of the earth. Much of these conjectures are themselves biased in the sense that they are mostly forced to fit potential changes in natural phenomena...How can you make that statement emphasized in bold? You do realize that there is a difference between a scientific theory and the regular usage of the word theory. I once presented you with an outline of the evidence behind the big bang theory but it seems you've forgotten already. |
davidylan: and that was my point! The definition of the term "empirical" CLEARLY excludes scientific theory which was why it should have been the most relevant definition to this discussion (Kay17 omits this because it destroys his ignorant position)... this has been mentioned severally in my posts which you either dont read, dont understand or too dishonest to admit. See my response to Kay17 below.Your response doesn't do you any favours. Kay 17 picked the definition he was using you instead decided that the others were better. You need to understand how to actually carry out a discussion. I read your post but it seems as if you actually don't know what you're supposed to do. If someone says that the theory of gravity is based on empirical evidence, does this somehow mean that there is no evidence for it? It is amazing to read what you're writing here and claim that you actually have some understanding of how science is done. |
davidylan: Bro, i got you. He gets no more responses from me.Excellent run away when the fire gets too hot. ![]() |
Enigma: thehomer himself has form when it comes to manipulating "definitions"Aww. |
davidylan: More deliberate dishonesty... actually while all 3 definitions are almost identical, point 2 is the MOST relevant to this discussion since it SPECIFICALLY mentions scientific theory! Why did Kay17 deliberately leave that out?Read the definition in full. It mentions scientific theory in order to actually [b]exclude [/b]it. |
davidylan: i'm sure you saw my lengthy riposte to area boy? Believe me, i dont hide behind sheets... i boldly lay out my arguments. I however do not waste time with those who are not here to learn but to pick holes.I'm not Area_boy. You're welcome to repost relevant parts of your response to him but I generally dislike lengthy posts on forum discussions because in an actual conversation, people don't make article length speeches. I'm picking holes because there are holes to be picked. The Bible is not a good source from which to learn the things I'm interested in. davidylan: Like i said in my response to you... you obviously did not read Romans 2 to truly understand the important it was making. It was addressing a key question - how will gentiles (who did not have the benefit of being handed down a physical law) judged relative to the jews?You obviously haven't read Romans 2 recently. If you had, how can you say it isn't about salvation when verses 6 through 8 talk about rewards and punishment? What is the point of judgement? davidylan: Nothing to do with salvation through grace in this case.That is the point. Is salvation through grace by faith or through works? davidylan: I also hope you are aware that Romans 2:13 uses the word "justified" which can apply both under the laws of Moses and under the law of grace by which we are saved today.Come on now. Don't start trying to play this game that poor Nigerian preachers play by hanging on a word that was used in a particular English translation and using that word to explain away the entire 45 minute sermon. That word doesn't appear in the NIV so how does that affect what you're saying here? |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]I asked, and you answered, thehomer, I perceive that your contention over "authority" as used in this thread is because our physical senses and perceptions are geared towards survival and not towards philosophy. If this is the case then, it would be inappropriate to demand that existential truth be subject to man's physical senses. Now, that being said, I asked Pastor AIO how we can know truth for sure but then he gave me an answer that that in a sense questions the notion of 'sureness' itself (I agree with his answer by the way or at least what I think he is saying) To simplify things a bit I'll state that what is truth to us is the best logical explanation available to us for any given phenomenon. As logic itself is the method by which we classify whether a thing is true or it is false.[/quote]Okay. One thing you need to consider too is that when it comes to functioning in the universe, logic doesn't work alone but works with some external input from the universe. [quote author=Mr_Anony]For instance, the existential question "Why am I?" is a question theology attempts to answer and the best explanation I have come across so far is God.[/quote]You would first need to expand on the question because as it stands, it is too vague for someone to answer unless they can read your mind. Also, how does your particular God answer the question? [quote author=Mr_Anony]Now to require that God must satisfy the dictates of physical senses i.e. must be seen, felt, heard etc is irrelevant since the existential truth is not within the jurisdiction of physical senses.[/quote]Even if he isn't directly detectable by our senses, surely a God that wants something from us should be willing to manifest himself in some way. [quote author=Mr_Anony]In the same way, to require an explanation for God by asking questions like "who created the creator?" is also irrelevant as one need not ask for the explanation of an explanation (as this leads to infinite regress) but rather if the explanation sufficiently answers the question.[/quote]That's just it. God isn't an explanation. People used to say God caused the lightning. Would you consider that an explanation for lightning? [quote author=Mr_Anony]When a question has been answered sufficiently for us, then we trust that answer as truth and accept this truth as an authority when judging matters of that nature. To properly refute a said 'truth', one must provide another explanation that better explains the phenomenon. Until such a falsification occurs, the said 'truth' retains it's authority.[/quote]What you're saying there sounds like a certain conception of what a scientific theory is. [quote author=Mr_Anony]This is my understanding for the interplay of faith and reason. Coming to the topic: Religion and Authority, I'll say this: The reason for religion, science and philosophy is because people want the answer to the question What is the meaning of my existence? The answer to that question lies in a perfect and eternal God. That's the Truth I know.[/quote]I don't think that is what science is for. How did you come to know this truth? [quote author=Mr_Anony]To deny this would require that a better explanation for the meaning of existence be proffered.[/quote]I think there are multiple reasons for denying your answer. e.g the multitude of Gods, an ignorance of what this God wants, even an absence of this God. |
davidylan: Why did you DISHONESTLY avoid the FIRST TWO definitions? Is it because definition 2 exposes the idiocy of your own claims? Is the big b[i]a[/i]ng THEORY dependent on EXPERIENCE or direct OBSERVATION ALONE?Why do you people do this? Is it news to you that a word can have multiple meanings? Sometimes even contradictory meanings? He picked the definition that best suited his use. If you're serious about a conversation, you can either propose your definition or work with his. |
noetic16: why answer a question with another? Can you just answer the OP, and for once show us your intellectual weight? what evidence will change or cause a rethink of your atheistic postulations?How could you have forgotten my response so soon? I already answered and you were whining as if the world had come to an end. Why don't you go back and re-read my answer? And note that the statement to which I was responding wasn't a question. Read your own statement carefully. |
noetic16: This is getting boring. Your response is quite DUMB. I finished the book, Darwin (your god) messed up. He is an intellectual light weight, look at how he bundled up the whole arguments especially the Boeing argument. did that make sense to you? idiot.Your stupidity is beyond belief. Was it Darwin that wrote the book? Are you sure you even read the right book? Obviously, you're unable to refute it because if you could, you would have actually presented a refutation rather than just glorifying your brainlessness. noetic16: What a big FOOL. The universe and the devices in question are products of intelligence that is greater than them. None of these human devices was made by a baby, simply because babies do not have such intelligence. is this rocket science?You must be a total numbskull to think that the universe is like an ipad or a laptop. noetic16: yawns loudlyOf course you will. That is the expected response from an ignorant buffoon. noetic16: Get this once and for all. The universe is a complex intelligent entity. It is absolutely STUPID, inconceivable and intellectually awkward to assert that it sprung into existence by chance. It is either you lack basic education or you are intentionally DUMB.The universe is intelligent? Wow. noetic16:You are well and truly unteachable. There is no more hope in educating you. |
davidylan: Did you read the entire chapter to understand what it is talking about? Nah.... just quote one verse and make urself look dumb trying to build a mountain of ignorance on it.Is this the best you can do? You're now trying to hide behind a sheet of paper? Why don't you simply say what is wrong with the conclusion I've drawn rather than attempting to obfuscate? |
davidylan: No they are not and you really should stop bleating when you are ignorant of a subject. Please read my riposte to areaboy... we clearly defined two clearly distinct types of "works". One that is based on the law and the other based on faith in the saving grace of Jesus.You should really stop neighing when you're ignorant and actually read the quoted passages. Romans 2:13 clearly says that it is those who obey the law that will be considered righteous. Please read your Bible. |
davidylan: BEFORE i proceed to show you where you're wrong in your response to my post, i'll like to know for the sake of clarity why you think the says two different things about salvation. Thank you.That is because faith and works are independent of each other. One can have faith without works and another can have works without faith. Just take a look at Ephesians 2: 8-9. Bible NIV: 8 For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith —and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God—Contrast that with Romans 2: 13. Bible NIV: 13 For it is not those who hear the law who are righteous in God’s sight, but it is those who obey the law who will be declared righteous. |
frosbel: What do you think, your gut feeling ?There is no afterlife. |
snthesis: yea i did! do you consider cause and effectGod is the ultimate cause and he guides the ultimate effect doesn't he? Since you consider those pictures to be the images of people created by this God of yours, what makes you think he is an intelligent designer? A more perfect designer would get the designs right all the time. |
InesQor: Sorry to be the party-p[i]o[/i]oper in this Kumbaya, but Authoritativeness and Reliability equally defer to the same connotative meaning i.e. that which we depend upon for assessment.The difference is that reliability can be better generalized than authority. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Do you agree that the truth can be independent of your perceptions?[/quote]Yes I do. |
Pastor AIO: And for good reason too. dropping a ball by releasing it is not the entirety of Induction.I never said it was the entirety of induction. |
noetic16: This is quite LAZY. it explains the fact that you are an emotional atheist, without any concrete, logical reason for disbelieving the existence of God. QED.Actually, what you show is that you're too ignorant about your God to make any reasonable deductions. What concrete, logical reasons do you have for disbelieving in the existence of Brahman? |
noetic16: Quite idiotic.What a demented response. Who wrote The God Delusion? Darwin? Have you been drinking again? If you think you can debunk them, why don't you actually do that after reading the book rather than just shouting? Is your laziness so much that you cannot finish reading the book and you cannot think up rebuttals to the parts you've read? noetic16: Very silly. Do electronic items have a manufacturer? how many gadgets (ipads, laptops, fridges) do not have a designer?What a dullard. The universe isn't man-made unlike the devices you're talking about. noetic16: The issue here is your living in denial and lack of imagination.Why don't you actually address your fallacious statement? noetic16:Do you think you're intelligent with your childish attempts at a rebuttal? The universe wasn't made by humans while those items were? You're supposed to show that the universe was actually created. Instead, you're just making poor analogies. noetic16: You come across as not-educatedYou come across as deeply ignorant and at the same time, full of hubris. |
snthesis: i think the problem lies in appreciating what makes u. if you think you arent a work of art, carefully and fearfully made, then that's ur cup of tea.Did you see the works of art posted by Martian? Was it the same maker who made you that made them? |
I really don't see a problem here. Pastor AIO: When someone tells you that pigs fly in mongolia that probably isn't true but that doesn't mean that they aren't telling you, it's just that it isn't true.Pigs fly in Mongolia. False Someone else tells you that they do. True You heard the person say this. True Pastor AIO: And when you friends tell you that there's a dirty pig there, it doesn't match your perception of the white horse, but you are still hearing what they are telling you.There is a dirty pig in front of you. True What you see is a white horse. True You heard your friends say that there is a dirty pig in front of you. True My point is that regardless of what they say, you still see what you see. Now, if the question is how reliable is what you're seeing or how reliable is what your friends are telling you, that will be a different question. |
Pastor AIO: What would be a problem would be if you were to confer absolute reliability on Induction. For the most part it works. That is fortuitous.No one is doing that. It is simply accepted with good practical reasons. Induction is fortuitous? Would you describe releasing a ball in your hand and it drops to the ground 100 out of a 100 times as being fortuitous? |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Now this is where I am sure that you missed his premise. What I believe he is on about isn't about your perception as much as it is about the trust and reliance on your perceptions and whether they are accurate enough to be deserving of that reliance and trust. So to properly prove him wrong, you have to show that the trust in your perceptions differ from other kinds of trust by proving that either your perceptions are absolute and infallible hence total trust in them or that you do not trust and rely your perceptions at all. Other than these, if you in any way rely on your perceptions, then it falls into the category of authorities that Pastor AIO is proposing. Saying you trust them in a different personal way is totally besides the point[/quote]And that is why I said reliance would be a better concept to use than authority in that context when he suggested it. |
InesQor: If extraterrestrial zoologists (assuming they can understand social patterns and make inferences) spent centuries observing humans & comparing with animals, would they notice any significant "meaning" in a human life?Sure. They would see that humans are significantly different from other animals. They would recognize the relative advancement of human technology with respect to other animals. InesQor: Whatever your thoughts, does life hold any meaning, generally speaking?Not at a cosmic scale but at a personal scale, it does. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]but then, this definition leaves a problem because various sentient creatures have experienced diverse effects for similar actions some even direct opposite effects to others hence right and wrong varies largely across the board. This leads to the question: If right and wrong vary so much, can they be justly defined as right and wrong??[/quote]I don't really understand what you're driving at. Can you elucidate with an example? |
Pastor AIO: If the likes of Russell and Frege are too mathematical for you you might like to check out instead the works of Hume and Locke. Hume laid out the Problem of Induction.I know about the problem of induction and I can see the problem with in philosophical thought but I don't see it as a practical problem. What would be a practical problem is for someone to consistently act as though induction was unreasonable. |
Pastor AIO: I said: Such as? A few examples would be nice here.While all that is interesting, I really don't see how it affects what I'm saying because what I'm saying is that I don't consider numbers as being authorities. |
Pastor AIO: How about if, rather than use the word Authoritativeness, I used the word Reliability. Various people therefore Rely on different sources of information seemingly arbitrarily. Some rely more on the information provided by their senses to determine 'truth'.Reliability would be a better word to use though as I've said, the senses are inherently different but one can decide on whether or how much to rely upon them. Reliability takes into consideration more than just the senses or other people. It also considers mental processes, logical processes, memory among other things so one is able to apportion how reliable they consider the various sources of information to be. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Apparently, I am not confused by it.[/quote]I think you are. Let me see if I can make this more explicit by using my previous example of pain. thehomer: . . . .My point is that your senses are personal to you in a way that people aren't. Thus, you can be having a pain without an external reference e.g phantom limb. This doesn't mean that the pain isn't there just that the reference isn't there. Here's another example from Pastor AIO Pastor AIO: . . . .Here, you're perceiving a white horse. While your perception doesn't match the reference of the pig, you're still perceiving what you're perceiving due to how direct it is to you. |
davidylan: Yawn... just another in the long line of intellectually lazy fellows bleating about "confusion" in the bible when the problem is their own confusion.So you're saying that salvation is through faith and works. Now if someone say on death row had a conversion to Christianity and was executed a week later, will this person be saved? |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 (of 210 pages)





are you so dumb? If as humans we can make intelligent devices, does your common sense not preach that we as intelligent beings (including our universe) is a product of a more intelligent being? do you have a brain at all? 