Thehomer's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 (of 210 pages)
[quote author=Mr_Anony]The authority of your senses[/quote]As I said before, your senses cannot be compared to a person, a group of people e.g church or an object e.g the Bible. |
davidylan: Either he is blind, deliberately being dishonest or both... thehomer is an exercise in obfuscation and cheap pettifogging.Woah davidylan. Why do you continue with such lies and insults? I've asked you twice recently to show me where you asked for evidence and I didn't provide it. You chose to run away those two times yet you have the guts to come here and tell such lies? I thought you were changing for the better. Or has the delirium worn off? |
FXKing2012: I've taken time to go thru the links u posted and they are threads started by ghostofspata, and they tell us absolutely nothing about the evidence u so claim. All what he listed a regards the big ba.ng theory do not give us any proof of the theory. And his attempt to debunk my 5 arguments that killed atheism was a total flop and even a disservice to atheism.Hold on for a moment. What do you think evidence for the big bang would look like? |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]That's not exactly true especially as concerns the way Pastor AIO uses "authority": Evidence is always read based on one's pre-existing bias (in other words, the authority one already defers to)[/quote]Let's take a look at this shall we? You place your finger on a hot stove. You feel pain. If tomorrow you're asked by someone to place your finger on a hot stove and you refuse because of the pain you received from your senses the day before, who is the authority you're deferring to when refusing? |
snthesis: the "theories/processes" u listed are an end to a means- basically they disprove the very existence of a God/intelligent designer, and this pic aims to disprove those theories.Actually, scientific theories aren't simply to disprove the existence of your God, they're there to help explain the world we find ourselves in. You've simply confused the purpose of these theories. It will be pointless for me to answer those questions because the answers are irrelevant to what you're trying to say. |
InesQor: What kind of problems?Please see my response to Pastor AIO. InesQor: How so?That is exactly what I'm saying. The definition of authority I'm using here is the third one here. Wiktionary: (countable) A person accepted as a source of reliable information on a subject.This concept is easily extended to the Bible and the church because they were ultimately made or written by some person. But one's senses aren't those sorts of tools neither are logical axioms tools of a similar nature. |
Pastor AIO: By what authority is evidence considered valid?Evidence itself isn't validated by some authority. It is the basis upon which a certain claim is accepted or a belief is formed. |
Pastor AIO: What is wrong with the 'manner' in which I use the term Authority? Is it grammatically wrong? Or am I twisting the meaning of the word? Please explain your beef. What you consider 'problems' can, you're right, easily creep in. In fact they don't creep in, they storm in, bashing down the fragile doors that keep 'Logic' intact.The so "authority" of the senses is quite different from that of pastors, other people, the church or the Bible in that one's senses are very personal to them. You cannot help but perceive what you perceive unless you've received adequate training so calling it an authority similar to the others can easily be misleading. I don't think such "authorities" don't actually damage logic. If the conclusions made by those "authorities" are logically unsound, then they're unsound. Pastor AIO: Please read what I wrote again and tell me what you understand by it. I'll quote the most relevant portions again:It is basically what I addressed which is equating the senses to other people and artifacts. |
InesQor: Every ounce of logic is based on an axiom or set of axioms. These axioms in themselves represent [/i]an [i]authority in that domain.Problems can easily creep in when one uses "authority" in this manner. It is easy to see that the "authority" that logical axioms represent is very different from the sort of "authority" that the Bible, the church or pastors and other people represent. |
Pastor AIO: @thehomer, so what are your beliefs based on?They're broadly based on evidence and are generally open to revision with the availability of better evidence. |
snthesis: what makes it a bad analogy?Basically, evolution is a process not a physical object, the big bang theory is a theory i.e a conceptual framework and not a physical object, atheism is the non-belief in a God and not a physical object. Maybe I should have said you were making a category error in trying to compare things that aren't comparable. |
mkmyers45: How does an individual develop morality according to you? Is it an innate trait? or something developed over time?It is a combination of both. A certain aspect is innate which people like psychopaths lack and a part of it is acquired from the environment by virtue of being a member of a group and developing a theory of causation. |
svelte8: That's why the test for sex determination is important. Though most times people with turner syndrome are visibly females since they possess XO chromosomes i.e just an X chromosome. There's no Y chromosome to bring about male sexual organs.It is possible for someone to appear female with a uterus but have the XY chromosome. They're also sterile. What happens in this case? |
mkmyers45: I realize that atheists say that morality is some form of social conditioning or contract, but i think the most admired virtues: heroism, self-sacrifice, unselfishness, could not have evolved from a social contract because they do not prolong longevity or serve any self interest. so it leads me to ask if morality is truly possible without an authoritative force?If by authoritative force you mean someone issuing decrees to be taken as moral pronouncements, then it is possible without such an entity. What we need to understand at the core is that humans decide whether or not an act is moral based on the sorts of effects it has on sentient organisms. With this idea at the back of one's mind, one can arrive at various moral precepts without the need for such an authority and another effect of this is that it grants humans the ability to morally improve based on the degree of their understanding of where they find themselves. |
Pastor AIO: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/authorityI for one don't think that morality is based on an authority. Pastor AIO: People in this world are ruled by so many different authorities.I also disagree with this idea that every belief system is based on some unquestioned authority that is taken as axiomatic because at the very least, my belief system isn't based on such an authority. If Augustine didn't question the church or the Bible, that is his loss. The basic aim of critical thinking is to avoid such cognitive ruts that lead to one basing their thoughts on authorities. |
snthesis: Please i need your honest answers related to the picture below:Comparing the Mount Rushmore carvings to evolution or the big bang is simply a bad analogy. You need to look for a much better argument. |
svelte8: Sure a religious point of view wont solve this. And if he decides to be a female no problem. But i think the poster is concerned because he believes in God. If the hermaphrodite decide to be a female, he has to consider certain things; does 'he' menstruate? Does he have ovaries? In case , he is later interested in conceiving. You see that's why the laboratory test are important. Even if he finally finds out he is a male and still wants to live as a female no problem, it's his choice. But if he lives under the dictates of a supreme being, then i think he should go for a test.There are certain people like those with Turner's syndrome with only one X chromosome who do not menstruate and have what is called "streak ovaries". They cannot conceive naturally so what do you think should happen to them? |
gendebs: In church today we taught about HOMOSEXUALISM in the Sunday school class. i asked a question in the class and also in the general class but the response and the answers was not satisfactory. i want my fellow christian brothers and sisters and those that think they knows it to please answer with good reason. The question goes thus:Well you see, some of us don't think homosexuality is bad so such a person would have to decide for themselves, when they're able, which sex they prefer to be if any. |
I'm sure Boko Haram stopped some people. |
FXKing2012: But these atheists never give u any evidence of whatever it is they believe, so shld they keep demanding evidence?Come now this is plainly false as there are links right on this thread demonstrating otherwise. Just follow the links in this quote to see the error of your statement. ghostofsparta: Well... |
davidylan: Really?What was fallacious about that statement? Have you ever asked for evidence from me and I refused to present it? |
Deep Sight: And it is perfectly logical so to do.See my post above. |
caezar: There might be a technical error in comparing different values of different units but the meaning of the post is quite clear. The statistical improbability of complex designs means that, given the age of the earth, it cannot be realistically expected that complex organisms evolved via micro-evolution in such a relatively short period.Since there is such an error, then that comparison cannot be done. Consider this, what is the statistical improbability that you came to exist given the age of the earth? Another thing you're failing to consider is that geometrical changes can have very significant effects with just a tiny change. Consider the difference between 263 and 264. Or the difference between 106 and 107. |
Deep Sight: There's no error there: I think I have explained it better by slighty editting the text in red. Read again.Nope. The same error is there. The key is for you to note what you're comparing which are a probability/improbability figure and the age of the earth. |
Deep Sight: Answer inserted in red above.The answer you gave there is erroneous because you're comparing two things that shouldn't be compared. You're comparing the age of the earth which is a measurement of time to probability which is a ratio. And that is a category error. |
davidylan: I supported my claims. Its ok if you disagree. I dont have to satisfy you.Where did you support them? |
davidylan: My dear... you're not that important.If you actually had evidence for your claims, then why will it wear you out? Or do you actually think that asking for evidence is something that people shouldn't do? Again, this isn't about me but about your own integrity. You're simply showing yourself once again to have been bearing false witness. |
davidylan: my integrity is not tied to thehomer's approval.Again, this isn't about me, but about you supporting your own claims. I didn't put the claims in your mouth I'm only asking you to support them. |
davidylan: All the claims i made here were supported by the facts. You may disagree with them but you are not permitted to lie. thanks.I hope you realize that if you were able to present these "facts" or evidence, then you would have had support but so far, you've only made claims and assertions with no facts or evidence. If you think you've presented a fact, can you show me where you did this? |
davidylan: Biko pls, you are not that important.Again, this isn't about me but it is about your own integrity. You keep making unsupported claims. And when asked for some supporting evidence, you don't present any support because they're simply false. You really should learn to stick to making claims you can support. |
davidylan: I have zero problems and i'm actually proud to be tied to my faith and its "unsupported claims". Any problem?I wasn't just talking about the unsupported claims of your religion, but of the unsupported claims you've made in your last few posts on this thread. |
davidylan: Actually the atheists here dont cite references, infact i have just had to question a thread from ghostofsparta on the same issue.You're talking to me not some other random atheists so I see no reason to drag in anyone else here who may not be free to defend themselves. Can you show me where I presented a theory that I attempted to support by naming a "big name scientist"? I would like to see the top five posts where you think I did this and attacked you on this issue. Will you be able to present these posts? |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 (of 210 pages)
I think it's the same thing.
There is just no point debating this clear fallacy. The evidence is clear that majority of the atheists here have no clue what "evidence" they claim to defend.
So i'm going to wear myself out seeking to show proof to thehomer? I can find 1000 things to do that are worth more of my time.