Thehomer's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 (of 210 pages)
truthislight: I was thinking that with the arrival of therhomer the essence of this thread will be address, "the life span issue"If you can explain the conflict between evolution and the human lifespan, then you'll be able to get a better answer. |
manmustwac: It had been marked as spam but i've sorted it nowRight thanks a lot. ![]() |
Hi there mods. Please I was wondering why the last two responses I posted on the thread Evolutionist: How Do You Explain Human Lifespan? (https://www.nairaland.com/1016350/evolutionist-how-explain-human-lifespan/5) keep getting hidden. Thanks. |
davidylan: Hmmm really they do. Dont be embarrassed to admit the truth.Once again, I'll direct you to take a look at the evidence for evolution. It is more than missing links. Simply look it up on Wikipedia. I've shown you these things before so there is no need for you to lie. davidylan: Yawn. Not true. We only study populations because we need a lot of samples. If we could get enough sample from one cell we would not need the entire population. We sometimes study mutations in as little as 4 mice.This is why I've been saying over and over again that you really didn't understand what you were doing in the lab. The reason why you study populations is because a single individual isn't enough to assess that evolution is occurring. Another thing you should know is that evolution isn't just studying mutations. If the mutations are harmful and prevent reproduction, would you still say that evolution is occurring? What lie? Don't blame me for not knowing what you were doing in a lab. davidylan: Daft. You should have read this portion of my post - The genomic mutations that are required for clear phenotypic changes occurs FIRST at the level of the individual organism no? It takes one individual to change and then pass on that change to his/her offspring no? As long as the change in that individual is beneficial then the mutation is sustained over a larger proportion of the population no?You see? This is why I keep saying that your idiocy knows no bounds. Again I have to ask you what you think evolution is because just a short while ago, you were talking about assessing evolution in a single individual by looking at its mutation yet you're saying that if the organism that mutated died, then evolution isn't happening. This is stupidly contradictory. Have you seen it yet? Keep in mind that evolution isn't just mutation. I've said this too before. davidylan: My question is DID YOU read the article yourself because if you did you should be able to point precisely to what portion supports your nonsensical statement. It obviously did not provide supporting evidence for you. I read that article, that was why i was able to address the SNP and haplotype questions... again DID YOU? Or have you, as is usual with you ignorant blowhards, merely posted a link you know nothing about?Yep I read the article. Did you read the paragraph and what was in bold? That directly contradicts what you've been saying you halfwit. The paragraph was from the article. The article wasn't asking you a question, it was passing across to you information. The question headings weren't for you to fill in with your fantasy, they were there to draw the reader to read the following paragraph and understand the answer. Do you actually know how to read or is it just scientific papers that bother you? davidylan: Most of the papers that first described gene knockouts were done in mouse populations of sometimes less than 3 id[i]i[/i]ot. Again just hiding your lack of knowledge behind a lot of insulting bluster.[size=14pt]Oh your God[/size] Gene knockouts experiments aren't demonstration of evolution, they're used to study the expressions of various genes you daft camel. Read up on it here and what it is for. And note what it isn't for. Wow you really have no idea of what you're doing. davidylan: Already read it and i certainly do not agree with that claim. Again read my response to that exact portion here - the initial SNP is a V-E substitution at position 6 in the beta-globin gene. How is it that every single variant of the disease has this SNP as the fundamental defect? Why didnt other variants have several different SNPs that could just as easily caused the same disease? The only explanation is that this SNP would have probably occurred in one individual and then passed down through cross breeding. It is highly likely that environmental and other genetic factors may have influenced the differing haplotypes that we see today that mainly manifests in varying intensity of disease symptoms.Did you see these parts in bold in the paper? Nature: In 1978, Y. W. Kan and Andreé Dozy used the new tools of recombinant DNA and restriction enzymes to observe sequence differences (polymorphisms) in the DNA around the ß-globin genes of different individuals. They went on to use these polymorphisms, reflected in the loss or gain of specific restriction enzyme cleavage sites, to trace the sickle ß-globin allele within family pedigrees (Kan & Dozy, 1978a; 1978b; 1980). These studies were the first application of restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs) to follow disease genes, and they represented a milestone in human genetics. For SCA in particular, this effort paved the way for prenatal diagnosis and improved genetic counseling. In addition, it provided the tools used by other investigators to show that the mutation causing SCA arose multiple times during human history. Nature: In contrast to these non-African cases of SCA due to breeding between nations, investigators examining SCA patients in the eastern oases of Saudi Arabia and portions of central India discovered another distinct haplotype, indicating a fifth independent occurrence of the sickle-cell mutation in a region historically hyperendemic for malaria (Kulozik et al., 1986). Whether the geographic distribution of this mutation resulted from eastern migration to India or western migration to the Arabian peninsula is still unknown.Is that evidence enough for you? Or do you now want to write a letter to Nature telling them to retract this paper? Daft buffoon. davidylan: Did you even read what i wrote at all? The authors have based their SPECULATIVE conclusions on differing HAPLOTYPES (perhaps you should find out what that means first). The SCA anomaly still remains the result of only one single specific SNP (again find out what that means too).I read what you wrote but it was rubbish. Now read the heading of the paper and tell me why you think they shouldn't have used the haplotypes in assessing the distribution of sickle cell anemia and the sickle cell trait. Assume I don't know what those words mean in your explanation. davidylan: good point. Wrong on that score.What was wrong? Are you confused about the independent mutations? Now you're trying but failing to criticize a Nature article because it doesn't agree with you? |
davidylan: Hmmm really they do. Dont be embarrassed to admit the truth.Once again, I'll direct you to take a look at the evidence for evolution. It is more than missing links. Simply look it up on Wikipedia. I've shown you these things before so there is no need for you to lie. davidylan: Yawn. Not true. We only study populations because we need a lot of samples. If we could get enough sample from one cell we would not need the entire population. We sometimes study mutations in as little as 4 mice.This is why I've been saying over and over again that you really didn't understand what you were doing in the lab. The reason why you study populations is because a single individual isn't enough to assess that evolution is occurring. Another thing you should know is that evolution isn't just studying mutations. If the mutations are harmful and prevent reproduction, would you still say that evolution is occurring? What lie? Don't blame me for not knowing what you were doing in a lab. davidylan: Daft. You should have read this portion of my post - The genomic mutations that are required for clear phenotypic changes occurs FIRST at the level of the individual organism no? It takes one individual to change and then pass on that change to his/her offspring no? As long as the change in that individual is beneficial then the mutation is sustained over a larger proportion of the population no?You see? This is why I keep saying that your idiocy knows no bounds. Again I have to ask you what you think evolution is because just a short while ago, you were talking about assessing evolution in a single individual by looking at its mutation yet you're saying that if the organism that mutated died, then evolution isn't happening. This is stupidly contradictory. Have you seen it yet? Keep in mind that evolution isn't just mutation. I've said this too before. davidylan: My question is DID YOU read the article yourself because if you did you should be able to point precisely to what portion supports your nonsensical statement. It obviously did not provide supporting evidence for you. I read that article, that was why i was able to address the SNP and haplotype questions... again DID YOU? Or have you, as is usual with you ignorant blowhards, merely posted a link you know nothing about?Yep I read the article. Did you read the paragraph and what was in bold? That directly contradicts what you've been saying you halfwit. The paragraph was from the article. The article wasn't asking you a question, it was passing across to you information. The question headings weren't for you to fill in with your fantasy, they were there to draw the reader to read the following paragraph and understand the answer. Do you actually know how to read or is it just scientific papers that bother you? davidylan: Most of the papers that first described gene knockouts were done in mouse populations of sometimes less than 3 id[i]i[/i]ot. Again just hiding your lack of knowledge behind a lot of insulting bluster.[size=16pt] Oh your God[/size] Gene knockouts experiments aren't demonstration of evolution, they're used to study the expressions of various genes you daft camel. Read up on it here and what it is for. And note what it isn't for. Wow you really have no idea of what you're doing. davidylan: Already read it and i certainly do not agree with that claim. Again read my response to that exact portion here - the initial SNP is a V-E substitution at position 6 in the beta-globin gene. How is it that every single variant of the disease has this SNP as the fundamental defect? Why didnt other variants have several different SNPs that could just as easily caused the same disease? The only explanation is that this SNP would have probably occurred in one individual and then passed down through cross breeding. It is highly likely that environmental and other genetic factors may have influenced the differing haplotypes that we see today that mainly manifests in varying intensity of disease symptoms.I hope you've registered your objection with the magazine so they can consider your esteemed opinion against that of the experts who peer reviewed the paper. Did you see these parts in bold in the paper? Nature: In 1978, Y. W. Kan and Andreé Dozy used the new tools of recombinant DNA and restriction enzymes to observe sequence differences (polymorphisms) in the DNA around the β-globin genes of different individuals. They went on to use these polymorphisms, reflected in the loss or gain of specific restriction enzyme cleavage sites, to trace the sickle β-globin allele within family pedigrees (Kan & Dozy, 1978a; 1978b; 1980). These studies were the first application of restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs) to follow disease genes, and they represented a milestone in human genetics. For SCA in particular, this effort paved the way for prenatal diagnosis and improved genetic counseling. In addition, it provided the tools used by other investigators to show that the mutation causing SCA arose multiple times during human history. Nature: In contrast to these non-African cases of SCA due to breeding between nations, investigators examining SCA patients in the eastern oases of Saudi Arabia and portions of central India discovered another distinct haplotype, indicating a fifth independent occurrence of the sickle-cell mutation in a region historically hyperendemic for malaria (Kulozik et al., 1986). Whether the geographic distribution of this mutation resulted from eastern migration to India or western migration to the Arabian peninsula is still unknown.Is that evidence enough for you? Or do you now want to write a letter to Nature telling them to retract this paper? Daft buffoon. davidylan: Did you even read what i wrote at all? The authors have based their SPECULATIVE conclusions on differing HAPLOTYPES (perhaps you should find out what that means first). The SCA anomaly still remains the result of only one single specific SNP (again find out what that means too).I read what you wrote but it was rubbish. Now read the heading of the paper and tell me why you think they shouldn't have used the haplotypes in assessing the distribution of sickle cell anemia and the sickle cell trait. Assume I don't know what those words mean in your explanation. davidylan: good point. Wrong on that score.What was wrong? Are you confused about the independent mutations? |
davidylan: another dumb id[i]i[/i]ot. There is a difference between SCIENCE (as a whole body of knowledge)and SCIENTIFIC THEORY (used in the context of discussing evolutionary theory).Actually, the theory of evolution is a scientific theory just as the theory of gravitation and the theory of plate tectonics. It is just you and your fellow creationists that claim there is a difference. |
davidylan: Yawn. Most incredibly inane piffle.Actually, they do not. The missing link is a part of the whole picture. davidylan: Saying that "evolution is assessed at the level of the population" is a meaningless statement that conveys nothing beyond an ego-driven attachment to incredulous illogic.What exactly is meaningless about it? What do you think evolution is? Were you taught in school that evolution was assessed using only an individual? davidylan: Secondly, if you read the detailed experiment i described earlier on... i did use that to drive home the point that I had made earlier (which you arrogantly and ignorantly bleat is wrong) that mutations start at the individual organism level and is then passed on to the population as long as it is a beneficial mutation. It was EXACTLY the same point Mr_Anony was making as well hereThe experiment you described showed you that you need to compare populations. davidylan: Now that answer is senseless and wrong. For more info pls read up on transfections.Seriously, your ignorant rambling knows no bounds. If the organism that mutated died before producing any offspring, is that evolution at the level of the individual? You're well and truly lost. davidylan: The EXACT SAME random mutations DO NOT occur spontaneously in a population. They start with one individual and then get passed down that specific lineage. That is why your claim (of course with no supporting evidence) is daft.Did you read the Nature article? If that isn't supporting evidence, then what will be supporting evidence to you? Sometimes I simply have to exclaim that your idiocy knows no bounds. The theory of evolution has two major mechanisms, random mutations (within individuals in the population) and natural selection (of those individuals). Those points aren't in question. What you're questioning here is whether you assess this by looking at a single individual or at a population of these individuals. What actually did you learn in school? davidylan: Stup[i]i[/i]d. Again you try to dodge the facts by hiding behind that amorphous "evolutionary time scale". Again your point is that somehow a mutation slowly occurred across multiple species over time? The only explanation again is one anony and I have given... it begins in one individual and then as it stabilizes within the genome, it gets passed down that particular lineage and spreads through cross-breeding. Exactly the point my experiment was meant to pass across to thick-headed morons like you.You daft deluded numbskull, please go back and ask who ever taught you how one determines whether or not evolution is occurring. Ask them whether they do that by examining only one individual or a population. Your so-called experiment points out to you that you need to assess populations. davidylan: why not?Obviously, you either didn't read the nature article properly or you're suffering from reading comprehension disorder. Take a look at this paragraph and pay attention to the parts in bold. Nature: Using RFLP analysis, geneticists found many distinct haplotypes in and around the tens of kilobases that make up the β-globin gene cluster. For instance, in 1984, Pagnier et al. reported that within four African populations with significant frequencies of sickle-cell trait, three distinct haplotypes were present among SCA patients that corresponded almost entirely to geographic origin. Patients from Benin and Algeria were homozygous for one haplotype (the Benin type), whereas more than 80% of patients from the Central African Republic (CAR) and from Senegal were homozygous for two other haplotypes (the Bantu and Senegal types, respectively). Although a few patients had two haplotypes resulting from population mixing, this study strongly suggested that the sickle-cell mutation arose independently at least three times in Africa and was selected for among geographically and reproductively isolated populations. A later study expanded the number of independent African initiating mutations to four, when Lapoumeroulie and colleagues identified a distinct haplotype among sickle-cell patients of the Eton ethnic group of eastern Cameroon (the Cameroon type, Figure 2) (Lapoumeroulie et al., 1992).Once again davidylan, please read and stop embarrassing yourself with your ignorance and bluster. davidylan: Another SNP example would be the hemophilia gene (popularly known as the "royal disease". read up on it. ![]() Here are two articles (one, two) on haemophilia also saying the same thing about independent mutations. There's more where these came from. Please please read these abstracts. Did you think that anyone with it must be or have been a royal? There are Africans with haemophilia too. Maybe you need another bout of delirium. ![]() |
Ishilove: Au contraire; it shows he is very very smartI wouldn't consider slipperiness in a debate to be a sign of being smart though. Neither is dishonesty. |
Uyi Iredia: This should be the second time I'm telling you that Nature can't select. Nature is a classification of things, saying it (Nature) can select is a reification fallacy.And you're back with the same error. "Natural selection" is a phrase with a specific meaning. As I've told people before, words and phrases can mean different things. Splitting it up into its constituent words won't really help you that much. I've advised you in the past to actually read up on it. |
davidylan: interesting that both you and ihedinobi made the same observation on this same thread. I ran into another thread earlier where debosky made the same exact comment.Yet for some reason, you couldn't use that thread to actually demonstrate what you were accusing me of? The thread is still up along with my posts so you're still welcome to try. |
Enigma: ^^^ He is unquestionably the most sly and dishonest of the evangelical atheists. Quit whining and address the arguments. |
davidylan: pah.Boo hoo. Here you're simply going with the bandwagon fallacy combining it with a poisoning the well fallacy. Merely saying that I'm a bad person or that many other people think that I'm a bad person doesn't actually address any single argument I've made. Why don't you actually stick to the argument? If you're going to accuse me of any misdeeds, then you need to clearly spell it out using my posts. They're still up there for you to use. Sheesh. Don't you ever learn? |
I see that your delirium has worn off. davidylan: you keep saying the same nonsense and then covering it with insulting bluster. The genomic mutations that are required for clear phenotypic changes occurs FIRST at the level of the individual organism no? It takes one individual to change and then pass on that change to his/her offspring no? As long as the change in that individual is beneficial then the mutation is sustained over a larger proportion of the population no?Now take a careful look at your own example and note your usage of the words in bold. You would have done better to have actually read some of my follow up posts. Like the one here thehomer: My point is that evolution isn't assessed at the level of the individual. I've already said this before.which conceptually better presents what I meant to say. Once again, you demonstrate that you had no idea of what you were doing. You were merely following the rules rather than conceptually internalizing what you were being taught. davidylan: We already know that. your point being?How is it daft to understand that these random mutations can and do occur randomly in the population? What do you understand by "at once" when one is talking about an evolutionary time scale? Seriously your stupidity is astounding. Whether or not you've performed a simple mutation experiment doesn't actually make you an expert on the concepts as you keep demonstrating from time to time. The sort of ignorance you keep displaying in your claimed field is simply embarrassing. Take something common in the tropics like sickle cell anaemia. Do you think it was one individual who had the mutation that spread it to all the other places it currently occurs? Reading this article will inform you otherwise. Please read it and understand that reconsider what you've said above. |
truthislight: dudeDon't blame me for your failure of understanding. To back up your statement, why don't you post three of my quotes and explain to me why you don't think they're logical. |
Ihedinobi: @thehomer, as far as I can see, you're incredibly slippery in debate. A distinctive mark of dishonesty.Like other Nairaland Christians, you seem to enjoy making accusations without evidence. When asked to present your evidence, you'll shy away from it. To demonstrate, why don't you present your evidence of my slipperiness using quotes I've made on this thread? |
davidylan: this is as absurd as a non-answer can get. Mr_Anony asked a very simple ques - If genes are passed on from one individual to another, how come "Random mutation and natural selection act at the level of the population." when the genes themselves are passed at an individual level?I should probably have said they're assessed at the level of the population. davidylan: Your response was - it is because population evolves not the individual? What did that even mean?It means what I said. The population evolves not the individual. I would recommend that you read but you'll just start whining and continue your ignorant blather. But really, for someone who claims to have studied these things, the depths of your ignorance and braggadocio is simply amazing. davidylan: Random mutations dont occur at the population level but at the level of the individual genome... how does this then get passed unto the general population so as to affect their phenotype... and your answer is the above? Puerile.Think of it as being that random mutations are assessed at the level of the population. I hope you know that a random mutation doesn't necessarily affect the phenotype of an organism. But before you go too far along Mr_Anony's questions, what is your response to this post? |
davidylan: 1. Many organisms arent unicellular but the VAST bulk of biomass on earth is unicellular so what was your point? Infact we can conclude that the most adaptable and most successful species on earth are unicellular organisms.My point is that evolution isn't assessed at the level of the individual. I've already said this before. davidylan: 2. To say we cannot tell that a single organism is evolving is just plain mad. The bulk of research showing how mutations markedly change phenotype has been done in single-celled organisms. For example, a lot of my mutation studies back in grad school was done in E. coli.This is just naive and shows that you didn't understand the core concepts behind what you were doing. Now, was it a single E. coli cell that you were using? A single sample or a comparison among many different samples? Frankly you're just embarrassing whatever institution it was that you claim your grad school education was in. |
davidylan: worry not, every single individual who has had the opportunity to cross paths with thehomer has left with the exact same feeling. A slimy snake who really doesnt know but covers his own ignorance with hubris.Really davidylan? Are you sure about that? Don't blame me for your ignorance and hubris. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]but evolution is not a decision...anyway, that's by the way.[/quote]I know it isn't but reacting to stimuli can in a sense be considered as one. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Would you agree that each individual cell is evolving however, we observe it by looking at the population?[/quote]No for various reasons. 1. Many organisms aren't unicellular. 2. You cannot tell that a single organism is evolving because that will be too little information. You're still yet to actually present what you thought was a contradiction. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Dude, I am not thinking anything. I am asking a question that truly puzzles me as regards evolution and you are linking me to a psychology article. What has that article got to do with anything I am asking?[/quote]That article tells you that it is possible for the decision of an individual to be different from that of the group. [quote author=Mr_Anony]If genes are passed on from one individual to another, how come "Random mutation and natural selection act at the level of the population." when the genes themselves are passed at an individual level?[/quote]It is because a population evolves not just the individual. In order to determine that evolution is occurring, you compare the frequency of certain alleles between different populations. |
Ihedinobi: I'm going to bed, thehomer, I think your wiliness is showing.What wiliness? Your inability to answer my questions or your committing logical fallacies aren't my fault. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]How can you say that something acts in a particular way as a single entity but then suddenly acts in many unpredictable ways once it is a multiple? How come this happens?[/quote]I've not actually said what you're attributing to me in your post above. I simply pointed out to you that what you think are contradictions aren't actually contradictions. There is no contradiction between reacting to stimuli and random mutation plus natural selection. If you think they are contradictory, then I need you to demonstrate this. Also, it is possible for an individual to act a certain way and a group which it belongs to act in another. It is a well known phenomenon in social psychology. Consider the introduction on this article. |
Ihedinobi: Thehomer and Kay 17, you guys must really be feeling like intellectuals right now, aren't you?You're working with the assumption that the sun and plants were put in place for you. Isn't that just hubris? There are billions of galaxies with billions of stars and you think this one was put in place just for you? Ihedinobi: Kay 17, tell us the functional difference between the word, "function" and the word, "purpose".You're reifying nature and that is a fallacy. You can use the third definition here. Wiktionary: The summary of everything that has to do with biological, chemical and physical states and events in the physical universe. Ihedinobi: Again, thehomer, why complexity at all? And why diversities of species and organisms? If this is all nonsense, why so much and so many varieties of it?Who says it is all nonsense? Definitely not I. Why shouldn't there be a diversity? Besides, this diversity is explained by the theory of evolution. Ihedinobi: Yeah, while you're mulling that, thehomer, I'd like to know too, how did cells and atoms figure to come together in certain ways and not others? I mean, this whole thing is purposeless, so why must it be one way and not any other random way? The luck here looks a bit too lucky, if you get my meaning.What do you mean? Atoms assume all sorts of structures e.g Carbon exists as graphene, buckminsterfullerene and diamonds. So what on earth do you mean by "other random way"? |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]There is something missing from your answer, It is how exactly does random mutation and natural selection not contradict response to stimuli? Please explain in some detail.[/quote]I've already given you an answer. Let me repeat it. Random mutation and natural selection act at the level of the population. Response to stimuli acts at the level of the individual. You'll need to actually show me the contradiction you have in mind because I don't see it. |
davidylan: My answer - God made it so.That is a meaningless answer. It is no better than saying Santa Claus made it so. davidylan: your answer?My answer depends on "who"/"what" you think defines what the "purpose" is. |
davidylan: the sun appeared by random chance and those seeds just appeared out of nowhere? So sand exists because that is what it always does? Somehow this chance has ONLY found expression on this tiny portion of the universe?You seem to be answering another question. The questions again are as follows. Why does the sun shine and why do seeds germinate? |
davidylan: Why? what was the purpose for them doing that? What defined that purpose if at all?Purpose according to who are you looking for? The sun shines because it is what it does. Seeds germinate because it is what they do. What is the purpose for these processes? Answer those questions and you'll be closer to finding the answer to the question you're asking. |
davidylan: But why? what was the purpose?That is simply what they do. Or what sort or purposes do you have in mind? Your question is no better than asking why the stomach digests food. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]First of all, you are very welcome to interrupt. I am trying to learn something here. I am of the understanding that evolution is guided by completely random mutations of which the best surviving ones are propagated. My question now is does this not contradict the basic characteristic of living things which is to respond to stimuli?[/quote]You're confusing a number of things here. Evolution occurs mainly by two processes, random mutation and natural selection. It acts on populations. It isn't contradictory to an individual responding to stimuli. [quote author=Mr_Anony]I see evolution as a way organisms adapt to their environment by responding to it. Evolution by natural selection seems to hold that living things are not really responding to their environment but are throwing out different responses of which nature now allows the best response to win. Is this true? If not explain.[/quote]Nature selecting certain individuals is a response to the environment. |
Sorry to interrupt. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Ok wiegraf, let's work through this... First of all human beings are a very complex organism. Basically, a human being is a whole universe of individual cells living together and these cell all have to work in near perfect uniformity for a human being to function. A human being who doesn't feel pain will be seen as diseased. It won't be attributed to genetics. Perhaps we should make it a bit simpler by focusing more on unicellular organisms.[/quote]Other organisms made up of organ systems are very complex too. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Now you talked about probabilities, let us put a number to it shall we? The number of atoms present in a single cell organism is estimated at 100 trillion. Now, the chance of life starting from a primordial soup means that these 100,000,000,000,000 atoms need to come together in a specific way. This puts the chance of life forming on earth at one in 100 trillion factorial (100,000,000,000,000 x 99,999,999,999,999 x 99,999,999,999,998......3 x 2 x 1). Please take a minute to consider the magnitude of that number. Just for comparism, 50 factorial is approximately 3 x 10^64 (3 with 64 zeroes following). Now even if this "probability" happened (and mind you it would have to repeat itself quite a number of times), it wouldn't still explain life.[/quote]So you have a large number. What is its significance? Another thing you're failing to consider is the fact that atoms and molecules assemble in certain ways. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Let us leave the above aside for now, let us assume that the conditions were just right (which by the way is another "probability" of it's own) so that life "miraculously" happened and we have the first living cell or groups of cells, let us also agree that these cells don't have any consciousness whatsoever and the basic characteristics of living things (movement, growth, respiration, feeding, excretion, reproduction and response to stimuli) are just chemical reactions for this cell since it doesn't have a conscious life. The question now becomes why would the cell reproduce at all in the first place enabling it to pass it's genes on? Why would the gene want to be propagated?[/quote]Cells reproduce because it is what they do. It is what living things do. Your stomach digests food, your heart pumps blood, cells divide. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Let us also ignore this question and assume that reproduction is just a random chemical reaction such that the cells that don't reproduce simply die. same thing for feeding respiration e.t.c. Another question pops up: How can an organism die if all the characteristics of it being a living thing are more or less, chemical reactions? This should point to the fact that as long as natural conditions remains the same, these chemical reactions should continue and the organism should stay 'alive' and never die or decay.[/quote]Organisms die and decay due to entropy. The universe tends towards an increase in entropy. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Let us not even talk about the probability of these 'mindless' organisms eventually evolving into complex animals like we have today (A human being that weighs 70kg is roughly 7 quadrillion synchronized cells).[/quote]So what? Larger animals can easily have a larger number of cells. [quote author=Mr_Anony]The above are some of the logical steps we have to jump across before coming to complex organisms. Now most animals are in such a way that they are adapted to their environment, this evolution explains is as a result of natural selection i.e. these are the animals that survived and the traits are not developed in response to the environment rather, they are developed in spite of the environment. the environment only lets some traits survive. This sounds like a good explanation until we look at it a bit more closely.[/quote]This is simply false. Certain traits are developed due to environmental pressure. Maybe you need to take a primer course on the theory of evolution. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Take for instance the presence of melanin in the human skin, or the absence of tails in human beings. If evolution is really by purposeless natural selection, shouldn't a surviving trait simply continue to exist even though it we have no more use for it? After all it is not threatening our survival.[/quote]Not really. If a trait or organ is no longer used, then it may be adapted for another purpose or it may become vestigial accumulating mutations that won't significantly affect the organism's ability to survive to the age of reproduction. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Doesn't this suggest that rather than mindless natural selection, there is a purpose that allows the animal to adapt to it's environment.[/quote]No it doesn't. What do you think the purpose of a whale is? And who gave it this purpose? [quote author=Mr_Anony]As for dawkins and his selfish gene theory, well that's another pot of soup on it's own.[/quote]The selfish gene was simply a metaphor not a scientific theory. |
Ihedinobi: Like, are you serious about that bolded statement? Because it's hilarious coming from a proponent of the theory.Yes I am. Scientific theories aren't developed because there are religious ideas which are more often wrong than not. |
What do you expect? Jesus was said to have commandeered some animal for his triumphant entry. Maybe these days, due to regulations and proper checking, it isn't so easy to commandeer transports so the pastors have to buy theirs which must be the most expensive unused one available. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 (of 210 pages)




