Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,156,424 members, 7,830,123 topics. Date: Thursday, 16 May 2024 at 04:34 PM

Excess Crude Account Fiasco: Vindicating Jonathan's Administration - Politics - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Politics / Excess Crude Account Fiasco: Vindicating Jonathan's Administration (1273 Views)

$1 Billion: 'Excess Crude account is Illegal' - House Leader, Femi Gbajabiamila / ‘Where Is The $65bn Obasanjo Left In Excess Crude Account?’ Amaechi Fires At GEJ / Excess Crude Account Now $2.26bn – FG (2) (3) (4)

(1) (Reply) (Go Down)

Excess Crude Account Fiasco: Vindicating Jonathan's Administration by Nobody: 10:59am On Oct 05, 2016
Questions have been raised concerning how and why the administration of ex-president Goodluck Jonathan failed to copiously save for the rainy day, and in my fugacious quest to ascertain the genuine reason for such, I descried a news article that indicated how Okonjo Iweala the ex-minister of finance disclosed how FG's share of the funds that was sourced from the Excess Crude Account was spent and further provided an explicit detail of the funds that were disbursed to the state Governors at that time, after they pressured the quondam Goodluck Jonathan's administration into sharing the savings in the Excess Crude Account.

Communiqué by the ex-minister revealed that the funds were spent on Subsidy and Sure-P payments and a total of 2.92trn was remitted to states in four years.

Nigeria earned N12.3 trillion as excess crude oil money in 4 years – Okonjo-Iweala

The federal government spent about $10.85 billion (about N2.14 trillion) from the foreign excess crude revenue account savings on fuel subsidy payments to petroleum products marketers between 2011 and 2014, Mrs. Okonjo-Iweala, said.
http://www.premiumtimesng.com/business/183667-nigeria-earned-n12-3-trillion-as-excess-crude-oil-money-in-4-years-okonjo-iweala.html

Okonjo Iweala Exposes What States Got From Excess Crude Account

Keeping to her promise to disclose what the states got from the Excess Crude Account, the Minister of Finance Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala-Iweala Sunday said the 36 states of the federation, received a total of N2.92 trillion from the account between 2011and 2014.

A statement from the Federal Ministry of Finance released Sunday night said the it had become necessary to make the figures public following recent accusations by the Rivers state governor on behalf of state governors.

The statement from the federal ministry of Finance noted that the “figures show that they (states) received N966.6 billion in 2011, N816.3billion in 2012, N859.4 billion in 2013 and N282.8 in 2014.

The low figure for 2014 reflects the steep decline in revenues due to the impact of the crash in global oil prices which began in the middle of the year.


Akwa Ibom got the highest with (N265billion), Rivers (N230.4 billion), Delta (N216.7 billion), Bayelsa (N176.3 billion), Kano (N106.5 billion) and Lagos (N82.9 billion) respectively got these amounts from the ECA.

Kwara (N52.8 billion), Enugu (N51.6 billion), Gombe (N47.7 billion), Nassarawa (N46.9 billion), Ekiti (N46.8 billion) and Ebonyi (N44.3 billion) received the least amounts in that order.


The statement added that “the summary of the inflows and outflows from the Account shows that the opening balance was $4.56 billion in 2011 and reached a peak the following year at $8.7 billion before declining to $2.3 billion in 2013. The balance as at May 2015 is $2.07 billion.”

The fluctuation in the ECA the statement explained “reflects the sharing of the proceeds usually requested by state governors as well as the practice of Augmentation which involves additional sharing from the ECA when available funds are not adequate to meet revenue projections.”

The ministry noted that Subsidy and SURE-P payments are also made from the Excess Crude Account while the Federal Government’s share from the ECA during the period was N3.29 trillion.
http://thenationonlineng.net/new/what-states-got-from-excess-crude-account-okonjo-iweala/

And despite all these, Jonathan tried to make it Sovereign Wealth Fund, “so that it would not be easy for one to take from there,” and he was still able to save $2.5billion in the SWF of which was bequeathed to Buhari's administration alongside the $2.07billion in the ECA.

I believe this accentuation have provided answers on how the excess crude oil revenue account, which stood at over $20 billion at the inception of Jonathan's administration, was depleted to about $2 billion when he left office on May 29, 2015, and what his administration did with the “lion share” that it received after the court adjured FG to share the funds in the ECA.

Now the germane and rational questions should be, what did those governors(especially those plaintiffs that moved the motion and compelled FG to share the funds like Amaechi, Oshiomhole, Fashola) do with the astronomical funds that were disbursed to them?

How much is currently in our Excess Crude Account considering that oil price has been undulating between $45 to $50 per barrel and the benchmark at $38?

4 Likes 2 Shares

Re: Excess Crude Account Fiasco: Vindicating Jonathan's Administration by Nobody: 10:59am On Oct 05, 2016
ok
Re: Excess Crude Account Fiasco: Vindicating Jonathan's Administration by Nobody: 11:11am On Oct 05, 2016
Lalasticlala, this should abate the false impression being circulated by some people that GEJ squandered FG's share of the ECA, And also enlighten the masses.

2 Likes

Re: Excess Crude Account Fiasco: Vindicating Jonathan's Administration by wirinet(m): 11:46am On Oct 05, 2016
This is the koko of the whole article;
The statement from the federal ministry of Finance noted that the “figures show that they (states) received N966.6 billion in 2011, N816.3billion in 2012, N859.4 billion in 2013 and N282.8 in 2014. Total = N2,925 trillion

The ministry noted that Subsidy and SURE-P payments are also made from the Excess Crude Account while the Federal Government’s share from the ECA during the period was N3.29 trillion .

The question is what did the Okonjo Iweala do with the N3.29 trillion that was shared to the FG, and why did Okonjo Iweala not save the FG share of the Excess Crude Accounts, Why was she so obsessed with sharing the Governor's share? Afterall her own share is more than the Governor's share.

1 Like

Re: Excess Crude Account Fiasco: Vindicating Jonathan's Administration by Nobody: 12:02pm On Oct 05, 2016
wirinet:
This is the koko of the whole article;


The question is what did the Okonjo Iweala do with the N3.29 trillion that was shared to the FG, and why did Okonjo Iweala not save the FG share of the Excess Crude Accounts, Why was she so obsessed with sharing the Governor's share? Afterall her own share is more than the Governor's share.
Stop feigning ignorance by repeating the same questions that have already been answered. The FG share was spent on financing fuel subsidy and sure-p
The federal government spent about $10.85 billion (about N2.14 trillion) from the foreign excess crude revenue account savings on fuel subsidy payments to petroleum products marketers between 2011 and 2014, Mrs. Okonjo-Iweala, said.

The Excess Crude Account is one of the two accounts (dollar and Naira) where the Nigerian government saves revenue earnings from the difference between budgeted benchmark crude oil price and the actual price at the international market in a given year.

A breakdown of the expenditure for fuel subsidy payments showed$1.818 billion was spent in 2011;$2.63 billion for 2012; $3.26 billion for 2013 and $3.14 billion for 2014. The subsidy expenditure for 2015 is not yet available.

The records released by the government showed that in 2011 about $3 billion was disbursed for distribution to the three tiers of government; $8.76 billion as augmentation for the shortfall in the year’s budgetary allocations; $1.82 billion transferred to domestic excess crude account for subsidy payment, while $901,627 accrued as interest on Sovereign Wealth Fund (SWF).

In 2012, about $2.5 billion was disbursed for distribution to the three tiers of government, while $3.37 billion was released for augmentation; $82.57 million for the National Integrated Power Programme (NIPP) power projects;$2.63 billion transferred to domestic excess crude account for fuel subsidy payments and $918.7 million for the Subsidy Re-Investment and Empowerment Programme (SURE-P).Similarly, in 2013, about $3 billion was disbursed for the three tiers of government; $4.02 billion for budget augmentation; $94.22 million for NIPP projects; $3.26 billion for fuel subsidy payment and $2.53 billion forSURE-P funds.

Besides, in 2014, $54.9 million was released for NIPP projects; $3.14 billion for subsidy payments; $459.52million for SURE-P and another $1.84 billion for SURE-P as well as $455.40 million was released as special distribution to the three tiers of government, in addition to $8,275 as loss on early breaking o investment.

Since the beginning of 2015, only$93.6 million was released as special distribution to the three tiers of government, with the balance of the excess crude account currently at $2.08 billion.
http://www.premiumtimesng.com/business/183667-nigeria-earned-n12-3-trillion-as-excess-crude-oil-money-in-4-years-okonjo-iweala.html

2 Likes

Re: Excess Crude Account Fiasco: Vindicating Jonathan's Administration by Nobody: 12:07pm On Oct 05, 2016
khSteel, Whynotthetruth, cyrilamx, Sheggy13
Re: Excess Crude Account Fiasco: Vindicating Jonathan's Administration by wirinet(m): 1:19pm On Oct 05, 2016
blueto:
Stop feigning ignorance by repeating the same questions that have already been answered. The FG share was spent on financing fuel subsidy and sure-p http://www.premiumtimesng.com/business/183667-nigeria-earned-n12-3-trillion-as-excess-crude-oil-money-in-4-years-okonjo-iweala.html

Stop lying or pretending you cannot read English. Re-read what you posted and comprehend what it says. No where in the report did it insinuate that subsidy payments were from the FG's share of the revenue allocations. The money for subsidy, sure-P, IPP projects, Extra budgetary allocations and the excess crude account/Sovereign wealth fund were deducted at source, before the money was distributed to the 3 tiers of government.

And people like you have the audacity to call Lai Mohammed a liar.

2 Likes

Re: Excess Crude Account Fiasco: Vindicating Jonathan's Administration by Nobody: 1:39pm On Oct 05, 2016
wirinet:


Stop lying or pretending you cannot read English. Re-read what you posted and comprehend what it says. No where in the report did it insinuate that subsidy payments were from the FG's share of the revenue allocations. The money for subsidy, sure-P, IPP projects, Extra budgetary allocations and the excess crude account/Sovereign wealth fund were deducted at source, before the money was distributed to the 3 tiers of government.

And people like you have the audacity to call Lai Mohammed a liar.
It seems that your cognitive faculty needs overhauling
The federal government spent about $10.85 billion (about N2.14 trillion) from the foreign excess crude revenue account savings on fuel subsidy payments to petroleum products marketers between 2011 and 2014, Mrs. Okonjo-Iweala, said.
So you expected that FG would specifically state how it used its share after stating how the funds were spent? It was stated that $10.85 billion was spent(FG's share) on financing fuel subsidy and others, and a sum of N2.92 trillion was disbursed to states while $2.07billion was left for the incumbent administration.

Enough of these distorted comments. The questions that ought to be trending now are what I asked before and I will like to iterate them again.

Now the germane and rational questions should be, what did those governors(especially those plaintiffs that moved the motion and compelled FG to share the funds like Amaechi, Oshiomhole, Fashola) do with the astronomical funds that were disbursed to them?

How much is currently in our Excess Crude Account considering that oil pricehas been undulating between $45 to $50per barrel and the benchmark at $38?

3 Likes

Re: Excess Crude Account Fiasco: Vindicating Jonathan's Administration by Whynotthetruth(m): 1:40pm On Oct 05, 2016
wirinet:
This is the koko of the whole article;


The question is what did the Okonjo Iweala do with the N3.29 trillion that was shared to the FG, and why did Okonjo Iweala not save the FG share of the Excess Crude Accounts, Why was she so obsessed with sharing the Governor's share? Afterall her own share is more than the Governor's share.

1) Buhari, Tinubu and all APC fellas has NO MORAL justification if not for the sake of myopic nature of citizenry mentality, to complain about any government not saving. Why? ... Because today, Osibanjo is mischievously celebrating how much they have saved from subsidy without apologising to Nigeria & Nigerians how they for the sake of hatred and political convenience fought and frustrated Jonathan's government from removing same subsidy which would have saved us millions of dollars. Who's fooling who in Nigeria? Can we eat our cake and have it? Has Buhari told us how and why he suddenly accepted and paid for same subsidy which he denied it's existence while Jonathan was leading? Same tactics was used to propagate boko Haram by him and APC hierarchy.

2)It should be noted that Jonathan administration paid MORE salaries than Obasanjo's administration; hence is bound to have less savings than Obj. Yes, Jonathan paid #18000 for civil servants while Obj paid 7500(over 150% difference). Jonathan paid NYSC 19800, over 200% rise from what Obj paid. It will simply metamorphose into more expenses on recurrent expenditure for Jonathan administration. Compare this and see if we had same amount of rise in our income to cushion our expenditure.

3) Jonathan had so many laudable initiatives and training programs which means INCREASED expenditure for his administration...most of which Buhari has stopped. Eg; PRESSID, YOUWIN, etc We have seen so many threads of graduating students of Nigeria sponsored by Jonathan administration returning or still there. That was money turning to extra expenditure. He ingested in education big time.

4)The innovative almajiri school education which he instituted...which seems to be rotting away now...would have forestalled future boko Haram but we can never have it. We rather treat symptoms and wait again for reoccurrence again. Great country indeed!!! Almajiri education was real money... including his twelve universities at a time.

5)Nigeria is a funny country...which weighs EVERY opinion & initiative on the altar of religion, tribe & political party. A malaise championed by no less a person than our president; Muhammad Buhari. We are heading nowhere yet. Truth is subjective in Nigeria.

Hypocrisy kills a nation...Nigeria seems not to have a soul anymore...good pm!!!

12 Likes 2 Shares

Re: Excess Crude Account Fiasco: Vindicating Jonathan's Administration by oduastates: 3:11pm On Oct 05, 2016
The federal government's share of the money was $12 billion.
That is 12 with a B out of $22 billion.
Why did Jonathan not save that?
The ECA was depleted within 6 months of Jonathan becoming president.

1 Like

Re: Excess Crude Account Fiasco: Vindicating Jonathan's Administration by oduastates: 3:11pm On Oct 05, 2016
oduastates:
The federal government's share of the money was $12 billion.
That is 12 with a B out of $22 billion.
Why Jonathan not save that?
Re: Excess Crude Account Fiasco: Vindicating Jonathan's Administration by 400billionman: 3:36am On Oct 07, 2016
Looking at these figures, the previous govt was wasteful but at least money went round in the ecomomy and people didnt suffer like we are doing under booharry.

Why cant FG release the $2bn currently in the ECA to stabilize the naira and curb inflation now Nigerians are suffering ?
Re: Excess Crude Account Fiasco: Vindicating Jonathan's Administration by Sibrah: 3:44am On Oct 07, 2016
Blueto blueto . . . The GEJ boy.

1 Like

Re: Excess Crude Account Fiasco: Vindicating Jonathan's Administration by Sibrah: 3:47am On Oct 07, 2016
blueto:
Questions have been raised concerning how and why the administration of ex-president Goodluck Jonathan failed to copiously save for the rainy day, and in my fugacious quest to ascertain the genuine reason for such, I descried a news article that indicated how Okonjo Iweala the ex-minister of finance disclosed how FG's share of the funds that was sourced from the Excess Crude Account was spent and further provided an explicit detail of the funds that were disbursed to the state Governors at that time, after they pressured the quondam Goodluck Jonathan's administration into sharing the savings in the Excess Crude Account.

Communiqué by the ex-minister revealed that the funds were spent on Subsidy and Sure-P payments and a total of 2.92trn was remitted to states in four years.


http://www.premiumtimesng.com/business/183667-nigeria-earned-n12-3-trillion-as-excess-crude-oil-money-in-4-years-okonjo-iweala.html


http://thenationonlineng.net/new/what-states-got-from-excess-crude-account-okonjo-iweala/

And despite all these, Jonathan tried to make it Sovereign Wealth Fund, “so that it would not be easy for one to take from there,” and he was still able to save $2.5billion in the SWF of which was bequeathed to Buhari's administration alongside the $2.07billion in the ECA.

I believe this accentuation have provided answers on how the excess crude oil revenue account, which stood at over $20 billion at the inception of Jonathan's administration, was depleted to about $2 billion when he left office on May 29, 2015, and what his administration did with the “lion share” that it received after the court adjured FG to share the funds in the ECA.

Now the germane and rational questions should be, what did those governors(especially those plaintiffs that moved the motion and compelled FG to share the funds like Amaechi, Oshiomhole, Fashola) do with the astronomical funds that were disbursed to them?

How much is currently in our Excess Crude Account considering that oil price has been undulating between $45 to $50 per barrel and the benchmark at $38?
You have some points but GEJ is still a big mess.
Re: Excess Crude Account Fiasco: Vindicating Jonathan's Administration by Sibrah: 3:50am On Oct 07, 2016
Whynotthetruth:


1) Buhari, Tinubu and all APC fellas has NO MORAL justification if not for the sake of myopic nature of citizenry mentality, to complain about any government not saving. Why? ... Because today, Osibanjo is mischievously celebrating how much they have saved from subsidy without apologising to Nigeria & Nigerians how they for the sake of hatred and political convenience fought and frustrated Jonathan's government from removing same subsidy which would have saved us millions of dollars. Who's fooling who in Nigeria? Can we eat our cake and have it? Has Buhari told us how and why he suddenly accepted and paid for same subsidy which he denied it's existence while Jonathan was leading? Same tactics was used to propagate boko Haram by him and APC hierarchy.

2)It should be noted that Jonathan administration paid MORE salaries than Obasanjo's administration; hence is bound to have less savings than Obj. Yes, Jonathan paid #18000 for civil servants while Obj paid 7500(over 150% difference). Jonathan paid NYSC 19800, over 200% rise from what Obj paid. It will simply metamorphose into more expenses on recurrent expenditure for Jonathan administration. Compare this and see if we had same amount of rise in our income to cushion our expenditure.

3) Jonathan had so many laudable initiatives and training programs which means INCREASED expenditure for his administration...most of which Buhari has stopped. Eg; PRESSID, YOUWIN, etc We have seen so many threads of graduating students of Nigeria sponsored by Jonathan administration returning or still there. That was money turning to extra expenditure. He ingested in education big time.

4)The innovative almajiri school education which he instituted...which seems to be rotting away now...would have forestalled future boko Haram but we can never have it. We rather treat symptoms and wait again for reoccurrence again. Great country indeed!!! Almajiri education was real money... including his twelve universities at a time.

5)Nigeria is a funny country...which weighs EVERY opinion & initiative on the altar of religion, tribe & political party. A malaise championed by no less a person than our president; Muhammad Buhari. We are heading nowhere yet. Truth is subjective in Nigeria.

Hypocrisy kills a nation...Nigeria seems not to have a soul anymore...good pm!!!
Mushroom projects.

1 Like

Re: Excess Crude Account Fiasco: Vindicating Jonathan's Administration by genearts(m): 4:12am On Oct 07, 2016
3.29 trillion naira for subsidy and sure-p without budgetary allocation? Lol... If buhari tells you this hope you will believe

1 Like

Re: Excess Crude Account Fiasco: Vindicating Jonathan's Administration by obailala(m): 7:56am On Oct 07, 2016
blueto:
Questions have been raised concerning how and why the administration of ex-president Goodluck Jonathan failed to copiously save for the rainy day, and in my fugacious quest to ascertain the genuine reason for such, I descried a news article that indicated how Okonjo Iweala the ex-minister of finance disclosed how FG's share of the funds that was sourced from the Excess Crude Account was spent and further provided an explicit detail of the funds that were disbursed to the state Governors at that time, after they pressured the quondam Goodluck Jonathan's administration into sharing the savings in the Excess Crude Account.

Communiqué by the ex-minister revealed that the funds were spent on Subsidy and Sure-P payments and a total of 2.92trn was remitted to states in four years.


http://www.premiumtimesng.com/business/183667-nigeria-earned-n12-3-trillion-as-excess-crude-oil-money-in-4-years-okonjo-iweala.html


http://thenationonlineng.net/new/what-states-got-from-excess-crude-account-okonjo-iweala/

And despite all these, Jonathan tried to make it Sovereign Wealth Fund, “so that it would not be easy for one to take from there,” and he was still able to save $2.5billion in the SWF of which was bequeathed to Buhari's administration alongside the $2.07billion in the ECA.

I believe this accentuation have provided answers on how the excess crude oil revenue account, which stood at over $20 billion at the inception of Jonathan's administration, was depleted to about $2 billion when he left office on May 29, 2015, and what his administration did with the “lion share” that it received after the court adjured FG to share the funds in the ECA.

Now the germane and rational questions should be, what did those governors(especially those plaintiffs that moved the motion and compelled FG to share the funds like Amaechi, Oshiomhole, Fashola) do with the astronomical funds that were disbursed to them?

How much is currently in our Excess Crude Account considering that oil price has been undulating between $45 to $50 per barrel and the benchmark at $38?

Enough of all these recurring talks and threads on ECA, jonathanians keep digging up the dead topic and when jonathan bashing starts, the argument always ends with "APC likes blaming GEJ," it's time to move on people..

The fact remains that over $11billion was the FG's share of the ECA. The FG at the time says it used the money for fuel subsidy, SURE-P, payments for NIPPs, etc. Of course no one expected them to say they pocketed the money, but the fact remains that we can hardly see the benefits of those expenses today (oh I forgot, buhari's badluck may be blamed for the dissappearance of the benefits of those spendings).

Meanwhile OBJ also spent $16billion out of ECA for the NIPPS but was able to still leave $20bn in the account, but because we could not see the benefits afterwards, we all (including you @blueto) still blame OBJ for 'squandering' that money. Lest I forget, OBJ and Yaradua also paid for fuel subsidy but were able to save massively. May we also not forget that ECA cash isnt the only money in the hands of the govt, what did GEJ's govt do with all the other money made?

Now all I remember was that while those moneys were shared/disbursed/spent by GEJ, private jet owners and users club in Nigeria soared in membership, even state governors like amaechi and akpabio refused to be left out of the party. Politically exposed pastors even got double portions and even militants keyed into the jet age. At a point even GEJ bragged that Nigerias economy was booming as evidenced by the number of private jets in our skies. Of course the GDP of the nation boomed at the time because when money is spent (whether wisely or foolishly), the economy is affected positively, gdp rate increases, foreign investors rushed in to scratch their own share etc. But the difference between spending wisely or foolishly is only evident when the cash stops flowing.

As soon as the oil price crashed everything began to crumble instantly, if the money was spent wisely on proper infrastructure, the economy would have had something to fall back to. GEJ is however a very lucky man indeed cos he just bowed out at the very moment the consequences of his indiscretions were about to starts showing up. So today, as long as posterity is concerned, when GEJ ruled, the economy boomed, but as soon as he left, a famine set in.



You asked what the governors did with their own share, but that is not the matter here, the real matter is what the FG which was meant to save to balance the nation's economy did with its lion share. Isnt it also funny how they keep singling 3 opposition governors (amaechi, oshiomole and fashola) out of 36 majorly PDP governors?... Fo you mean to tell me governors like Akpabio and Uduagan or Mimiko were fighting against the FG releasing the money to states?.... Anyway, the last time I checked, the 3 names of opposition governors which you jonathanians like to 'blame' for GEJ's indiscretions, those 3 governor did not owe salaries and their states till date arent owing salaries so that answers your question.

Finally you asked how much is in the ECA seeing that crude has been selling above benchmark for months. While I can say the ECA has grown a bit to $3.9bn, I also have a question; as we all know the benchmark price for 2016 budget is $38, did you try to find out what the benchmark daily production target for the year 2016 is?.... At 2.2million barrels per day target, kindly remind us how many barrels Nigeria has been producing on the average since NDA came on board since February?

1 Like 1 Share

(1) (Reply)

I Was Shocked When An INEC Official Demanded $1m Bribe From Me – Jimoh Ibrahim / Victor Umeh Justified, As Dozie Nwankwo Empowered Over Six Hundred Persons / Where Is Sullivan Chime, Former Governor Of Enugu State?

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 83
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.