motymop: ➜I always like black people like you Who are not self aware There are only 70 black staffs in Cambridge out of 6300 employees that means blacks are minority If you think this has nothing to do with race then I have nothing to say to you. ➜ I hope you know you will have children, and this issue will affect them even if you feel they are genius, the system will tell them they don't deserve the role they get by merit and they only got it because they are black
People like you disgust me! Self-aware about what exactly? So, what if blacks are a minority in Cambridge? Are whites the majority in Universities in black countries around the world? I don't follow. 😒😒
2. Issue? The system? Na oyinbo wey dey allow black/brown low-lives bastardize their system of meritocracy, I go blame. 😒😒
seuncyrus: British media has got to be the villest media in the world. The spectator alone had more than 14 articles from different "columnists" on this guy within a few days. It's crazy. At least now that he is dead , they'll be happy and rest
The man told many lies. Here's a video of him teaching his students. Watch it yourself and tell us how that sounds like a Cambridge professor teaching that. 🙄🙄
motymop: ➜ you are actually ignorant for a reason The allegation against him has nothing to do with stealing people's work, it more about text overlap and citation errors
sulaak: ➜ RIP Jason Arday This is where the problem started! Jason Arday and other black intellectuals protested and forced Cambridge to sack the racist Nathan Cofnas.
Sack Nathan Cofnas over fraud that Cambridge allowed? And then you lot keep wondering why black nations and people all over the world still can't seem to figure their sheet out! 🙄🙄
honesttalk21: A little too preoccupied with other things to thoroughly engage? 1. That's deflection, not a rebuttal. The existence of similar material elsewhere in Islamic literature doesn't establish this particular report as sound. The real question is whether this report has actually been authenticated, not whether comparable narratives exist. 2. Ibn Kathir's status doesn't settle that question either. Being an esteemed scholar doesn't make every report he transmits infallible. Ahmad Shakir respected him while still noting weak Isra'iliyyat in his tafsir. Scholarly prestige is not authentication.
1. Your previous comment was a deflection. Both the Quran and Hadiths are literally littered with Isra'iliyyat, so to expect none of that to find their way into tafsir is ludicrous. 🙄🙄
2. That is according to you! However, according to what I have heard from so many other Islamic scholars, Ibn Kathir has been the gold standard for commentaries for the longest time in Islam. I will stick to his words, as they do. 😒😒
SIRTee15: The part I don't agree with is he's not worth being a proff in Cambridge. The guy was already a professor in uni of Glasgow b4 moving to Cambridge. All those talk of incompetence is racist talk. My biggest problem will all this is that term called neurodivergence. Most would be shocked that neurodivergence is a social terminology that forced its way into the medical world. It was coined by sociologist to explain how some people behaved atypical outside of social norm. And boom this concept was embraced by all and the medical world was forced to beleive on it. Arday was an expert in neurodivergence. He helped developed the concept in UK and seems like he forced his life into to concept to make it look real as much as possible. He couldn't talk until 11, he couldn't read until 18, he achieved feat impossible for normal people to do despite being autistic like running marathon within record time. All these helps solidify the opinion that people autism, dyslexia, ADHD, bipolar, OCD, speech delay, dyspraxia, Tourette's syndrome etc do not have a medical problem at all rather it's their brain responding to external stimuli differently , thus it's the society that should adapt and change so people with these conditions can function within their own atypical world. To be sincere it all sounds wokeism. But in a world that's fast losing grip with reality and DEI is prioritized over competence, neurodivergence has come to stay without serious scrutiny done on its validity as a scientific concept. Arday was the poster boy of neurodivergence in the UK for a long time. He was the celebrity guy of neurodivergence and he got the positive publicity which he thoroughly enjoyed. He gave hope to parents with neurodivergence kids and helped shut up critics of the concept. However, when his fall came, I wonder why people expected it wouldn't be hard. If u don't want to fall hard, then don't aim high. Simple. Finally, institutions like Cambridge benefitted having people like Arday on their board. The showmanship he brought definitely put Cambridge in the limelight and they definitely loved it- of course they wouldn't want to end it. Above is the reason the allegations of plagiarism and false claims that started as far back in 2023 went unchecked and not investigated. His case is just the outcome of a world who has driven itself too far into deception that it no longer know when to stop.
Storyland!
Act like you belong Arday has claimed that he was a visiting professor for Nelson Mandela University in South Africa, the University of Glasgow and Ohio State University, all of which have denied that he held such a position. According to the Daily Mail, Arday has also wrongly claimed to have a position as honorary professor at Durham University.
The man likely killed himself after realizing his many lies had finally caught up with him! He is not the first to try this and will not be last! He was far from a victim in all of this. 🙄🙄🙄
goody234: ➜I was arguing this with someone on twitter he kept shouting plagiarism which i accused the person of hiding his racism behind the accusation, i said they all do it And he should stop being naive if he thinks white professors are not doing it ....Its just that black academia are scrutinised more with a racist agenda trying to undermine their ability
Storyland! The man likely killed himself after realizing his many lies had finally caught up with him! He is not the first to try this and will not be last! 🙄🙄🙄
Anaya4life: ➜The university had already investigated and didn't find evidence of plagiarism....it was the whole media barrage that caused this.And you trust that the issue of race will always be brought up. I feel so sad.......its bo small feat to be a professor in Cambridge at 41 years for that matter....God rest his soul.
Storyland! The man likely killed himself after realizing his many lies had finally caught up with him! He is not the first to try this and will not be last! 🙄🙄🙄
LabStores: ➜I feel drained reply you honestly. Okay, let me ask you too: Please prove that there are no evidences of the claim of the Qur'an Have you read the Quran in its entirety to solidly come to a conclusion that it cannot be taken as an authority?
Yes, I have! And I have read me enough of the Hadiths, too, to be certain. Now, don't get me wrong here! Unlike the other, I am not asking you to accept the Bible books as an authority except where it concerns the bloodline of israel. What I am insisting is that the Quran, which you attempt to compare to it, does not offer similar historicity along with references and cannot be considered an authority over anything other than the life, times, and musings that led to the invention of the religion.😒😒
honesttalk21: ➜As you are oblivious and weren't looking so can't see that Ahmad Shakir, while reviewing Ibn Kathir, noted that his tafsir contains isra’iliyyat despite his caution concerning them. ➜ And the material here is traced through Wahb ibn Munabbih, whose transmissions are themselves subject to scrutiny. So if no scholar has established this particular report as sound, why treat Ibn Kathir’s inclusion of it as proof? It appears in his tafsir is not the same as Ibn Kathir proved it Sahih.
1. The Quran and Hadiths are literally riddled with lots of excerpts of that kind and more. 😒😒
2. We are discussing the text that was elevated by Ibn Kathir, Islam's most esteemed tafsir scholar. 😒😒
honesttalk21: ➜Islamist refers to a political ideology, not Muslims generally. Don't know if such moniker exists on this platform but it doesn't refer to me. ➜ More importantly though, tafsir is a defined Islamic discipline with its own methods and internal criticism. Scholars distinguish stronger reports from weaker ones. So while the comparison with Rashi isn't perfectly parallel, the basic point still stands that being classified as scholarly commentary doesn't make everything in it scripture or automatically true. Tafsir itself provides a basis for distinguishing what is certain from what is merely transmitted.
Islam isn't a religion but a political system masquerading as a religion. And Pew reports show that the vast majority of adherents of Islam across the world, including those living in the West, embrace the political aspects of Islam. So, what is this really about again? Taqiyya?😒😒
2. Well, until those scholars come out to attack the claim made by Ibn Kathir, I think I will continue to stick with his claims as Sahih on this, too. 😁
motymop: so many silly people in the comment section. This guy was targeted because of his Race and the originator was Nathan Cofnas a very controversial white professor that was sacked by Cambridge and who have been writing articles to smear black people, he alerted a Cambridge faculty member and ran Arday's 2015 PhD thesis through a plagiarism-detection software. He publicly posted side-by-side text comparisons showing over 100 passages matching an earlier 2009 doctoral thesis. Cofnas framed the discovery as a direct attack on diversity hiring, arguing that elite universities lower academic standards for minority candidates and then the main stream media pick up the story and started their own agenda see...the Liverpool John Moores University, the school that awarded the black guy PhD had previously investigated and cleared him of wrongdoing regarding his thesis. However, following mounting media pressure and calls from some Cambridge academics for an independent inquiry into his hiring, Cambridge announced a review of its processes, leading to Arday's resignation you know what, as a black guy, never be the poster boy for any agenda of white people cultural war ( immigration or any stuff) it is always a setup, white institutions wont protect you when things goes south If a white professional makes a mistake or falls short, it's treated as an individual failure. If a Black professional placed on a pedestal makes a mistake, the culture war turns it into a verdict on all Black people
Because he is the only black/brown professional at Cambridge, abi? You everlasting victims...ehn!! Una matter dey always tire person! 😒😒
motymop: ➜You don't have to contribute original words PhD is purely research and you can use other people work but you have to put citations. There is no official or completed investigation that concluded that Jason Arday committed plagiarism before his death
in Cambridge? I mean if you said this about the local University, I go let am slide. But we are talking here of Cambridge. 😶😶😶
Anaya4life: ➜The university had already investigated and didn't find evidence of plagiarism....it was the whole media barrage that caused this. And you trust that the issue of race will always be brought up. I feel so sad.......its bo small feat to be a professor in Cambridge at 41 years for that matter....God rest his soul.
I am sorry, what? Stop playing the victim card already and come back at me with facts. 🙄🙄
ceeceeuwa: ➜I learnt a Facebook page was created where he was cyber bullied with people making derogatory comments about him. Same Facebook page locked their comments section when they learnt he passed away. Not everyone can withstand emotional torture. Just as our physical strength differs,so is our emotional strength. RIP to him!
Storyland! Based on all that was revealed, the man was supposedly a 419-er!!🙄🙄
What he did amounts to fraudulently robbing people out of their chance at a better life, only that he was backed by Cambridge of all places in doing exactly that. 🙄
honesttalk21: ➜Consulting tafsir for context doesn't mean everything in it is automatically true. Ibn Kathir is reporting transmitted material, including differing narrations;he isn't saying, this is certain Qur'anic fact. That's the distinction you're overlooking. And yes, silence isn't consensus. The fact that later tafsir doesn't explicitly reject Ibn Kathir's report doesn't turn an ahad (single) narration into tawatur or make it Qur'anic. Consensus requires actual agreement, not merely the absence of disagreement. As for the Quran literally says nothing on the subject, exactly. That's why tafsir is consulted. To provide context and transmitted reports surrounding the text, not to turn those reports into revelation. Ibn Kathir is transmitting such material; transmission alone doesn't make it certain.
This is all funny coming from an Islamist. I recall Islamists do this very same thing to biblical texts. For example, I read in the Islamic section on Reddit that the major evidence used by Islamists literally to back their fallacious claim that Rebekkah must have been 3 years of age at the time of her marriage comes from a commentary made by a fool called Rashi, who lived more than 2000 years after the writing of the Pentateuch. Rashi, without any evidence, claimed that Rebekkah was born when Abraham was on the mount, when absolutely nothing in the Book of Genesis, which he pretends to quote, states or suggests(directly or indirectly) any of this. So, if we are to go with the stewpid practice of the Islamists, then we should take even this entry and every other found in the tafsir as Quranic truth. 🥱🥱
** For those not in the know about what the Bible actually records, the text below from Genesis 22:19-24 details all those who had been born to the family of Abraham's brother. Nothing in the text says they were all born at the same time or at the time the message was delivered to Abraham. 🥱
CaseSensitive: ➜Who's this genius again? lecturing me on Jesus's religion this time while getting basic history wrong. Theologians and even secular historians know he was a practicing Jew his whole life, that's not even a theological opinion, ➜ it's a fact you'd know if you read anything outside your own little echo chamber. ➜ Jesus recognized the divine authority of the Torah and aligned his life and ministry with it, he only redefined how people should understand and practice it. Jesus himself supposedly said in Matthew 5:17 that "Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfil them" ➜ And pivoting to blaming an entire religion and way of life for Nigeria's crime rate only proved the level of ignorance. Just a few levels short of Dunning Kruger, you're not there yet but you surely will if you continue on this trajectory. Keep it up.
1. Well, your major problem there is that you got your version on the man named Jesus Christ from the mouth of theologians and not from actual historical accounts recorded by His own people--- Israelites--- in what is a book of Israelite Scriptures. 🥱
2. Unfortunately, absolutely none of what you posted is factual or recorded in the particular book. 🥱
3. The Torah is or was the Constitutional Law of the ancient nation of Israel in the land of Canaan over the Israelites. Every Israelite in the land was mandated by virtue of their blood to abide by and fulfill the Law and only that Law. Jesus Christ of Israel, hence, had every reason to recognize the authority of that Law. He was, after all, born a subject to the Law. 🥱
Also, Jesus Christ of Israel never redefined how people followed that Law... He had no such power over the Law, and He made this clear. 🥱🥱
4. I am not blaming an entire religion for anything. Ritual killings are not merely crimes in Nigeria. They are crimes related to ritual killings that connect back to traditional religions in Nigeria. 🥱🥱
How any of the above is related to Dunning-Kruger's effect is beyond me. 🥱
jaxxy: ➜Greeks, roman or egyptians dont worship and zeus or any mythical gods. That should tell u they dont believe they are real.. ➜ Readn the bible and see where The hebrew God started creation there was nothing like israel or hebrew untill much later and also same bible state jesus coming not just for jews or israel but for All Mankind. ➜ And yes God said most of my claims cos i defintely didnt manufacture it from my head along with millions of other christian.
1. The ancient Greeks, Romans, Egyptians, etc. worshipped their gods, and I explained the gods themselves were not considered mythical; rather, it was and still is the stories that were considered mythical.
2. I have read that book over and over. Again, the book shows that He selected His people from the very beginning. He was of Adam and eventually of Noah, and then of Abraham(the Hebrew), and then moved on to handing His Covenant to the descendants of Jacob the Hebrew, whom He also gave His name to -- YHWH, God of Israel --- to. He may not have started from the beginning with a chosen ethnic group(no law stipulated He had to) to be considered an ethnic God. 🥱🥱
Most of the other tribal deities had similar stories. They had a more general beginning story and then later chose for themselves a people from among the peoples to call their own. 🥱
3. Wrong! He said absolutely nothing of what you claim, which was instead manufactured by way of your religious doctrines, which have nothing to do with what is in fact stated directly in Israelite Scripture. 🥱🥱
safarifarms: ➜1. Jesus Died for the "Whole World" (Not Just Israel) The New Testament explicitly states that Jesus’s sacrifice was global, distinct from and reaching far beyond ethnic Israel. • 1 John 2:2 – "He is the atoning sacrifice for our sins, and not only for ours but also for the sins of the whole world." (This directly separates the immediate Jewish audience from the rest of the world). • John 1:29 – John the Baptist announces Jesus as "the Lamb of God, who takes away the sin of the world!" • John 3:16 – "For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son..." 2. The Purpose of Gathering Israel Was to Bless the Gentiles The Old Testament covenant itself was never meant to stop at Israel. Israel was chosen to be a conduit of salvation to the rest of the world. • Genesis 22:18 – God tells Abraham, "and through your offspring all nations on earth will be blessed..." • Isaiah 49:6 – God tells the Messiah that saving Israel is too small a task: "It is too small a thing for you to be my servant to restore the tribes of Jacob... I will also make you a light for the Gentiles, that my salvation may reach to the ends of the earth."...
1. The context of the 3rd reference there of John 3 makes clear that the world referenced by John the Baptist, as well as Jesus Christ of Israel in John 3: 16, is the world that is comprised of the Israelites, as explained in the verses prior.
14“Moses lifted up the snake in the desert. It is the same with the Son of Man. He must be lifted up too. 15Then everyone who believes in him can have eternal life.” 16 Yes, God loved the world so much that he gave his only Son, so that everyone who believes in him would not be lost but have eternal life. 17 God sent his Son into the world. He did not send him to judge the world guilty, but to save the world through him. - John 3 vs 14 - 17
The World that was loved in the Wilderness with Moses by YHWH of Israel was the World that comprised the Israelites in the desert --Numbers 21. It is the same with Jesus Christ of Israel, meaning the World Jesus Christ of Israel loves is the same World His Father loved in the Wilderness and lifted a snake for love. John 3: 16 is simply using a metonymy to describe the Israelites as the World that was loved and the same that was given by YHWH of Israel to His Son so that it may be redeemed from the curse of sin, similar to how he redeemed them using the snake in the Wilderness.🥱
2. The term Gentile is a term that is used to refer to members of the same family living in the diaspora; i.e. is used to refer to people who are all members of the same bloodline, aka family.
2Japheth’s sons were Gomer, Magog, Madai, Javan, Tubal, Meshech, and Tiras. 3 Gomer’s sons were Ashkenaz, Riphath, and Togarmah. 4 Javan’s sons were Elishah, Tarshish, Kittim, and Dodanim.[a] 5All the people who lived in the area around the Mediterranean Sea came from these sons of Japheth. The people separated and went to different countries according to languages, families, and nations. -Genesis 10 vs 2 - 5
IT was first used about the family of Japheth; I believe he was the father of the Arabs. And it was later on used about the family of Jacob — meaning those who are of the bloodline of Jacob, just as YHWH made clear through His Prophets.
Also, the covenant explains that every nation on the earth would be blessed through Abraham's descendants. It does not say anything of our particular religious interpretation that somehow makes you convinced you can plug yourselves into a covenant made only for Abraham's descendants. 🥱🥱
jaxxy: ➜yes for greek, romans, egyptians and other small g gods and im happy none of them ever claimed to have a univeral origin or scope. Infact the greeks call their mythology cos they know for certian they are not real so atleast they are honest and nobody worships any greek gods in greece. ➜ However some delusional traditionalist worship their myth gods. ➜ But to clarify the biblical God had not ethinic origins from Adam the 1st man and its modern era and beliefs are still not ethnic but about All people becoming Gods people. Inbetween these periods there might be a claim to ties to an ethnic group but it also makes it clear that is not the original or final plan. There is a complete and conciese but detailed history of events and plans for "All humanity" in both past, present and future. ➜ Infact the ethnic group ties is almost left behind or discarded for the new and original order.
1. The ancient Greeks did not regard their gods are myths. They believed their gods were real and wrote of them as such. Mythology instead refers to the traditions and stories told about the legends and poems told of their gods.
2. The myths would be, as explained, the many legends and stories. And this is on the side. 🥱🥱
3. The particular God you refer to said He gave His name to the people He chose as His own. And to that bloodline alone he made his name and His covenants. That makes him a tribal God like the others. 🥱🥱
4. That only happened within your religious delusions, as not a single word from that God --- YHWH of Israel --- affirms any of what you claim. 🥱
Elliotwaveforec: ➜Way to go! Isese is our culture and tradition, not a religion. ➜ Judaism is the culture and tradition of the Jews; ➜ Islam is the culture and tradition of the Arabs. ... good job.
It is definitely a religion, given that it is not a constitutional law or a political system. 🥱
2. Judaism is a religion, not a culture. If by Judaism you instead mean Jewishness, then that is an ethnicity like Yoruba or Hausa. 🥱
3. Islam is a political system that hides itself as a religion. It is not Arab culture, which existed long before Islam was invented and used to colonize and enslave a significant portion of Africa to this day. 🥱
jaxxy: ➜All these ones have reduced their god to an ethnic deity or identity from and for a local cultural group with no world/universal scope or identity. ➜ The concept of that belief already makes it just one of the many man made traditional beliefs with no long or truly tested historical footprint or relevance.
But that is what most of those deities were. Most deities had no world/universal scope or identity. It is the same with the Greek gods, the Egyptian gods, the Danish gods, the God of Israel, the Hindu Gods, etc. All of them were limited to a certain people or ethnic group. 🥱
CaseSensitive: ➜Straight fact. Jesus himself practiced Judaism till his death. ➜ It was his 'disciples' that deitified him. They viewed and worshipped him as divine thus identified him with God. ➜ Wetin concern an African man with Jewish religion/culture. We've truly missed our ways.
Jesus Christ of Israel in the Bible NEVER practiced Judaism in His life. He is famously recorded to have railed against the priests and Rabbis of his time, hurling curses their way.
2. Jesus Christ of Israel, at least 3 times, said He would die and rise from the grave to rule over death for eternity. And he did not; after he rose and then ascended, something no man before him has ever been able to do of their own power. Yeah, according to the report, it was not his disciples who did that. 🥱
3. You are right that a true-blooded Nigerian shouldn't concern himself with an Israelite whose God sent Him only to Israelites. But I think such a Nigerian should be concerned with the spate of ritual killings and kidnappings that have become a regular occurrence in Nigeria, with the rise in those embracing traditional religions. It reflects something about the religion that has yet to be broadly addressed. 🥱
FreeStuffsNG: ➜It is much deeper. His scandal has started destroying a lot of careers. Even the university that awarded him his PhD is in the eye of the storm too. He lived on the fast lane and really would have ended up in jail or probably some day assasinated by those involved in the cover ups.
The University was complicit and should definitely be scrutinized for allowing it. It's the students that are ultimately the victims in all of this. 🥱
ahmedio2017: ➜Can you explain why God created hell fire and Satan? ➜ There is a purpose for everything, jesus wasn't killed he was taken up. So why are you twisting the Qur'an.
If by God, you specifically mean the YHWH of Israel, I can explain why He did what He did.
2. Nah! Jesus Christ of Israel was killed and, by defeating death, as He promised He would on the third day, He proved Himself worthy as the lamb of YHWH and also the Messiah that was prophesied of through the Prophet, the King to reign over Israel forever. He had to die in order to fulfill His promise and take His place at the right hand side of His Father, YHWH of Israel, from where He began reigning almost 2000 years ago. 🥱
Isa of Islam is instead the one who was not killed but was raised to be with his Allah of Islam in the Quran. The two beings have nothing in common. 🥱
honesttalk21: ➜ Ibn Kathir listing multiple versions doesn't make them Qur'anic, nor does it establish one as settled doctrine. He never calls the substitution story Qur'anic fact; that's being inferred from his inclusion of it. ➜ Saying it adds context actually proves the point that it's outside the Qur'anic text. And the absence of another tafsir calling him wrong doesn't create consensus. Silence isn't consensus.
1. Again, the Quran literally says nothing on the subject. Recall again why we are told we should consult the Tafsir when reading the Quran. 🥱
Thus, tafsir al Qur’an is the scholarly discipline dedicated to explaining the meanings of the Qur’an, clarifying its intended messages, understanding the circumstances of its revelation (asbab al-nuzul), and deriving its practical rulings and moral lessons.
And here, we have Ibn Kathir coming in with transmitted information that does not invalidate the particular Qur'anic texts while providing us, via transmitted information, the circumstances of the text's revelation. 🥱
2. Did you really say that? "Silence isn't consensus," that is?😶😶
honesttalk21: ➜Don't mix it up. The distinction is not "transmitted vs transmitted." The Qur'an is transmitted through tawatur, with mass, independent chains across generations. A tafsir report like this is a separate transmitted narration, generally assessed through its isnad and content. ➜ Then this isn't modern scholarship versus Ibn Kathir. Ibn Kathir himself records differing reports about the substitution rather than presenting one version as Qur'anic text. So I'm not overruling Ibn Kathir; I'm applying the distinction his own tafsir demonstrates. Respecting a classical scholar doesn't turn his transmitted reports or interpretations into revelation.
1. I am not the one mixing anything up here. Ibn Kathir literally did that for us from about 800 years ago. And as before, nothing wrong with following precedent here. 🥱
2. I wouldn't really say it differs. I would instead say it adds a different context or detail to events. And again, it is Ibn Kathir, so why shouldn't I say that OP is right to assert that it is the Islamic view? I have not so far been able to find any other tafsirs or comments that claim Ibn Kathir was wrong in his assertions. So, why not? 🥱
honesttalk21: ➜It's actually not really strange. Ibn Kathir's tafsir is a compilation of transmitted material, not a Sahih collection.Reports found there include material outside the rigorously authenticated hadith corpus, including differing or weaker traditions. ➜ So its absence from Bukhari or Muslim doesn't make the report mysterious or Qur'anic; if anything, it is another reason to assess the report on its own chain and content rather than elevate it to Qur'anic fact.
Well, what is strange is that you do not want me to consider them Qur'anic, yet the Qur'anic traditions are also transmitted material nonetheless and certified. I am sorry; we are talking here of a tafsir by Ibn Kathir, if not the most respected Qur'anic commentator there is. 😒
2. Assess it how? Let me guess: you expect me to take the words of a modern Qur'anic scholar over the classic, famous Ibn Kathir of Islam?😒😒