Politics › Re: Low VAT Doesn’t Mean Low Economic Contribution: The South East Nigeria Case by lawani(m): 9:07pm On Jan 31 |
timbabng: VAT is a consumption tax, so the final consumer bears the cost. Companies act as VAT agents for FIRS.
When a company sells goods or services, charges 7.5% VAT on its invoice, Customer pays price + VAT, Company remits the VAT to FIRS.
The company pays their own VAT only when they purchase things too. I know the consumer pays but how can the producer be sure of the location of consumption?. Then VAT measures value added production and you have to credit that one to the location of the producer. If you turn ten naira to one million by value addition it will mean you pay high VAT. Who do you credit that to if not the producer? |
Politics › Re: Low VAT Doesn’t Mean Low Economic Contribution: The South East Nigeria Case by lawani(m): 9:01pm On Jan 31 |
givedemwotowoto: The disagreement here is not whether consumption matters. Nobody said that. Of course it does.
The problem here is the idea that low VAT equals low economic contribution - which necessitated this thread, or that production that doesn’t immediately show up as consumption “is not creating wealth.”
South Easterners live all over the country and operate production, importation, distribution, and retail channels from Aba and Onitsha to Kano and Lagos.
Also, your claim that production stalls unless it is locally consumed is false. Production can be sustained through exports, inter-regional trade, or subsistence consumption - all of which reduce unemployment and create value without necessarily increasing local VAT. I don't know what all the debate is about. The SE is less than ten percent of the population and the GDP expected from there should be around that percentage. If it is more, it means they are pulling more than their weight |
Politics › Re: Low VAT Doesn’t Mean Low Economic Contribution: The South East Nigeria Case by lawani(m): 8:55pm On Jan 31 |
timbabng: Correction. VAT contribution by state is calculated based on place of consumption/economic activity, not origin of production. It is not calculated by where the company’s head office is, but mainly by where the transaction happens.
For example: A bank headquartered in Lagos. - Customer uses the service in Kano - VAT is credited to Kano, not Lagos
Your statement on Igbo population in Lagos adding to Lagos VAT is correct, but a huge percentage of the VAT generated goes to the states that did not contribute as much. e.g. South East States and the other regions.
Which means, Igbo people in Lagos are indirectly contributing to their region.
So, it's a win win for everyone. There's no need to be emotional about it.
That's why Nigeria is better together if properly managed. VAT is paid by companies. So how do the companies determine location of consumption? |
Politics › Re: Low VAT Doesn’t Mean Low Economic Contribution: The South East Nigeria Case by lawani(m): 8:48pm On Jan 31 |
inoki247: Lol with how you guys always attribute ehn Economic hub, the biggest market in West Africa...
So in one word all the big this and that are just big for nothing without adding anything to the purse...
If truly you guys are the economic hub and the biggest market in West Africa it will show on your Vat cause you can't be the biggest and be selling and Govt won't take out of it.... Actually VAT is only paid by companies that add value. It is not paid by traders |
Politics › Re: Low VAT Doesn’t Mean Low Economic Contribution: The South East Nigeria Case by lawani(m): 8:40pm On Jan 31 |
How many people are living in the SE for the zone to have high figures? NIN data says they are 80 percent of Lagos state. This means they are less than twenty million if Lagos is 23 million. Revenue can only be high if population is high. |
Politics › Re: What Six Geo-political Zones Contributed To The VAT Pool And Received In 2025 by lawani(m): 8:34pm On Jan 31*. Modified: 8:51pm On Jan 31 |
Eriokanmi: What a wise submission. I'm also from same region. Those posting the news repeatedly know what they're doing. They're the same sycophantic beings we've been talking about . Our region houses the corporates HQs of many establishments. That's not all, those contributors aren't all from our region. You can imagine the ibos who are leading in pharmaceuticals,hospitality,banking, transportation, aviation, etc all move their corporate hqs to the south east, what would you think would have happened? Unfortunately,they dont know how much they're harming their region economically by citing industries outside their domain. We won't do that as a people. They could have come 2nd after the south west but the entire SW revenue would be reduced to half. With this move, their region would have received much more allocation than what's seen on the newspost If 3 million Igbos are in the SW, there will be over one million Yorubas in the SE. SE can't come second after the SW. It is to do with population. There is no zone that is not significantly higher than the SE in population. Even in the 19th century it would have been so |
Politics › Re: Why Lagos Does Not Belong To Yorubas – Oba Akiolu by lawani(m): 7:10pm On Jan 31 |
Islander23: The population under the kingship of Lagos should be in hundreds of thousand because we have various clans that dominated the settlement &as a matter of facts some present day kings were bales before been upgraded to kings & their domain was under the tutelage of Eleko as you rightly called it Lagos state was created after independence. The other Obas in Lagos whose lands were added to Lagos state don't owe traditional allegiance to the Eleko just because the military government added their lands to Lagos state. The Ijebu in Lagos owe their allegiance to the Awujale. Anything the Eleko is heading in Lagos state is just ceremonial. His domain does not extend outside Lagos island |
Politics › Re: Abia Unaffected By National Grid Collapse - Governor Otti by lawani(m): 6:50pm On Jan 31 |
What is happening in Aba is proof that the claim that prospective investors in the power sector will not be able to recover their investment if they invest is false |
Politics › Re: What Six Geo-political Zones Contributed To The VAT Pool And Received In 2025 by lawani(m): 6:46pm On Jan 31 |
Putinofrussia: Says a parasite. Anambra,Ogun,Ondo etc all have GDP in the range of 5 trillion,moreover gdp is dynamic,. Without SW giving SE billions out of its VAT,SE is dead. They can't have the same GDP. Ogun and Oyo together have almost the same population as the entire SE according to NIN data. Individually Ogun or Oyo is more than double the average SE state in population |
Politics › Re: Why Lagos Does Not Belong To Yorubas – Oba Akiolu by lawani(m): 6:24pm On Jan 31 |
Islander23: I never said that Bro but Lagos island as the major seat of power dominated other sub towns...you should know that in any major invasion what comes to the mind of the invaders is to capture the seat of power...No doubt ikoyi was founded by the Oyos admittedly but yet to confirm it...My family also gained not by conquest but by being the first settlers of a high end part of Lagos The Oba of Lagos or Eleko of Eko is the most popular Lagos King but I don't think his land contains up to one million people. It can't be up to five percent of Lagos land mass |
Islam › Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by lawani(op): 6:17pm On Jan 31 |
honesttalk21: Use same for your personal and professional development. Accepting Jesus as a messenger of God as he accepted all others is not in dispute but he was never a Christian and more likely neither are you. Jews did not accept Jesus at all. They didn't reckon with him. They also do not believe in the virgin birth. This means they are not Christians. I am not a Christian of course. If I believe Jesus is a prophet, that he was born of a virgin, he resurrected and etc. It will mean I am a member of a Christian sect because there is nowhere else I could have gotten those beliefs |
Politics › Re: Why Lagos Does Not Belong To Yorubas – Oba Akiolu by lawani(m): 2:46pm On Jan 31 |
Islander23: ...oh my dear brother,I find this hard to believe...we have major sub tribes like the Aworis,Ijebus,Egbas,Igbominas.... Okie,lemme make understand those that discovered the island are the Ilajes due to their fishing activities but they did not settle down as residents,A former Lagos state governor"s ancestry is rooted in Ilaje Are you now saying Lagos island owns the whole Lagos state? Ikoyi for example was established by Oyo. |
Politics › Re: Why Lagos Does Not Belong To Yorubas – Oba Akiolu by lawani(m): 2:44pm On Jan 31 |
Hankim: Do you even know some parts of Lagos belong to Ewe people? The post is about Lagos island not Lagos state |
Politics › Re: Why Lagos Does Not Belong To Yorubas – Oba Akiolu by lawani(m): 2:35pm On Jan 31 |
Islander23: To be candid I don't know how about an Ijesha man being the founder of the town but Benin did invaded Lagos using the Uromi warriors...I think Wikipedia can be of help here. The whole population of Lagos island when it was founded would be a few hundreds or much less. Nobody knew it would become big except maybe the priests who insisted it would become big. There was nothing to invade. The population of Lagos island in the 1890s after centuries of expansion was around 20k. Not everything on Wikipedia should be taken seriously |
Politics › Re: Why Lagos Does Not Belong To Yorubas – Oba Akiolu by lawani(m): 2:29pm On Jan 31 |
Christistruth00: The Ilaje even drowned Oba Ehengbuda of Benin and his War entourage in Lagos It was a very big disaster for Benin It should be remembered they didn't see the Benin as aliens. They spoke the same language. I used ifa to determine what happened in the past and I got that the Ijesa went to Benin to secure palm oil contract with the Portuguese and they sealed it. The Owa who was a woman and the Oba of Benin secured land from the Awori and isale Eko was founded. IFA said the odu IFA they got at Benin for the new town was Ose Irosun and that the second one which is Ogunda Irete that Lagos island is now known for was gotten when they got there and it is less potent. That is my finding using ifa. The Ijesa priest that led them there is the progenitor of the current line of Kings. He wanted to return to Ijesa but they begged him to stay and built him a palace |
Politics › Re: Abia Unaffected By National Grid Collapse - Governor Otti by lawani(m): 2:11pm On Jan 31 |
There are over 3000 power plants in the USA. In Nigeria there are less than thirty. To develop as a Nigerian city you need your own power plant like Aba |
Politics › Re: Why Lagos Does Not Belong To Yorubas – Oba Akiolu by lawani(m): 2:07pm On Jan 31 |
Islander23: .....are you saying the Benin invaded Lagos and they moved the palace because of that....Yeah If that happened it will be recorded in history and the name of the war will be well known. Lagos island is very small and far from Benin and it can't be held by force by Benin. I doubt they had the logistics to invade the place since it would have had to be by the sea. Then how do you explain the fact that the Awo that established the town was an Ijesa man?. |
Politics › Re: Why Lagos Does Not Belong To Yorubas – Oba Akiolu by lawani(m): 2:00pm On Jan 31 |
Islander23: first& foremost,I am a pure Yoruba man&I can't distort historical facts so back to the discussion, it has a whole lot to do with it because the main Oba of Lagos"s palace was situated at present day Ido...it was due to the war that it was moved to its present location... You are saying it was because of the British expedition against Benin that they moved the palace in Lagos island?. Or are you saying the Benin invaded Lagos and they moved the palace because of that? I don't really understand you |
Politics › Re: Why Lagos Does Not Belong To Yorubas – Oba Akiolu by lawani(m): 1:50pm On Jan 31 |
Christistruth00: What I read was that Ogedengbe was angry at Benin supplying Firearms to Ibadan that he and the EkitiParapo were fighting against and so he turned on Benin for doing so Are you sure that the Ijesa were not under the Ibadan at that time? I know that at one point Ibadan gave Ogedengbe the go ahead to go on expeditions. Ibadan already took territory from Benin by way of Akure and etc and they were not likely to be allies. The year I think was in the 1870s. It was a few years before Kiriji war broke out that Ogedengbe was in Benin territory |
Politics › Re: What Six Geo-political Zones Contributed To The VAT Pool And Received In 2025 by lawani(m): 1:46pm On Jan 31 |
If they were separate countries they would collect VAT on their telcos and banking services by themselves |
Politics › Re: Why Lagos Does Not Belong To Yorubas – Oba Akiolu by lawani(m): 1:40pm On Jan 31 |
Christistruth00: Thank you!!!! It was Oba of Benin’s begging and pleading that pacified Ogedengbe and the EkitiParapo Army from taking over Benin. They went back to fighting Ibadan instead Ogedengbe invaded parts of Benin but not Benin City itself Accounts say an alliance was negotiated. Ogedengbe could not have acted without the go ahead of Ibadan because as at then the civil war had not yet broken out. The expedition was on behalf of Ibadan obviously.
|
Islam › Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by lawani(op): 1:24pm On Jan 31 |
honesttalk21: You've given no proof that Muhammad pbuh followed Christianity. Saying that knowing about Jesus makes someone a Christian doesn't work and that would mean every historian who studies Jesus is automatically Christian. You also shared a vague memory without any source, a Quora link about where a name comes from, and a made-up claim about what academics agree on, which doesn’t exist. All this shows you don’t have any real evidence.
Get proper reference and suspend further claims until you actually have. Mohammed did not just know about Jesus. He accepted Jesus. A historian studying history is not the same as believers. |
Politics › Re: Why Lagos Does Not Belong To Yorubas – Oba Akiolu by lawani(m): 1:17pm On Jan 31 |
Islander23: at least you &I weren't born as that time...but we solely rely on research... that's why I gave a snippet of what you should research about...Benin punitive expedition of February 1897 But the Benin punitive expedition have nothing to do with Lagos island being discussed. Benin had no influence in Lagos to be diminished as at 1897. |
Politics › Re: Why Lagos Does Not Belong To Yorubas – Oba Akiolu by lawani(m): 12:32pm On Jan 31*. Modified: 1:12pm On Jan 31 |
Islander23: you are right about this but the British were not fully grounded,this main expedition caused the fall of Benin empire...the British had to invade Benin to diminish their influence &power No the British did not cause the fall of the Benin empire. There was no Benin empire in 1897. The last person that collected tribute in Benin was Balogun Ogedengbe of Ijesa who did so on behalf of Ibadan before the Yoruba civil war broke out. Ogedengbe is well known throughout the Delta, Edo states. Which city was tributary to Benin in 1897? It is wrong history to say the British truncated the Benin empire with one so called punitive expedition. The British were not able to suppress the Anioma for over thirty years |
Politics › Re: Why Lagos Does Not Belong To Yorubas – Oba Akiolu by lawani(m): 12:25pm On Jan 31 |
Islander23: ..Answer to the name of the war-British punitive expedition,year-1897...cause-Succession claims to the throne by the different factions of the locals You said Benin invaded Lagos. I asked for the details of that particular war. The war you are talking about must have happened more than a century before 1897 |
Politics › Re: Why Lagos Does Not Belong To Yorubas – Oba Akiolu by lawani(m): 10:10am On Jan 31 |
Islander23: it was simply because of Benin empire invasion albeit did you know the present day "Eyin Igbeti"? What is the name of the war? During the reign of which King? Remember also that invading Lagos island from Benin would not have been a small undertaking. They will need to come through the sea. If there was war, the locals would have had it in their history. Any confrontation with the local Aworis would have seen Lagos island swept into the sea |
Politics › Re: Why Lagos Does Not Belong To Yorubas – Oba Akiolu by lawani(m): 9:36am On Jan 31 |
Sheuns: The word “Yoruba” originated from the Fulani word Yoruba in the 16th century. Yoruba was used to refer to the people of Oyo by the Fulanis.
Oduduwa myth was before 16th century and Oduduwa was father to the very first Alaafin who lords over Oyo town. There were literally no settled Fulani in the sixteenth century at least in the Nigerian area. Yoruba as a word came from the Songhai empire who learnt the word from Muslims and the word was originally Europa before it was corrupted to Yoruba. It used to mean people who were civilized without submitting to Islam. Europe was Christian yet civilized. The word originally meant west in the original Phoenician to refer to Europe. The Muslims got the word from Phoenicia originally. In west Africa, it meant people to the South who wouldn't submit to islam |
Islam › Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by lawani(op): 9:10am On Jan 31 |
honesttalk21: I should respond fully to you but will hold because you fail to do what wouldn't necessitate all this talk. Where is the proof Muhammad pbuh was once a Christian then broke or branched off?
Saying Muhammad was a Christian name is a spectacular leap from zero evidence but saying you once read about a Byzantine Christian of same name without a reference is not proof. Muhammad praiseworthy in Arabic and is not a baptism name. What will it have meant in any of the Byzantine languages?
Your Quora link discusses name etymology, not proof Muhammad practiced Christianity. The proof that Mohammed was a Christian is that he believed in Jesus prophethood, virgin birth and etc. When Mohammed was born, that was only possible if you are a Christian. I can't find what I read about the Byzantine Christian again but in the Quora link I provided, someone talked about an Arab Christian named Mohammed that was martyred over 100 years before Mohammed was born. That maybe the same man whose quote I read. Read the link again. What evidence again do you need? Any academic observer will come to the conclusion that Mohammed was converted by Christians. It is only difficult for indoctrinated and ardent Muslims. |
Politics › Re: Why Lagos Does Not Belong To Yorubas – Oba Akiolu by lawani(m): 8:58am On Jan 31 |
Islander23: Why was the palace moved to the present location from Ido I have no idea |
Politics › Re: Why Lagos Does Not Belong To Yorubas – Oba Akiolu by lawani(m): 8:56am On Jan 31 |
|
Islam › Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by lawani(op): 7:59pm On Jan 30*. Modified: 8:36pm On Jan 30 |
honesttalk21: Holding extremely strong to your fallacy despite it faulted repeatedly? It is an unquestionable fact that Christians have committed violence in the name of Jesus which demonstrates that worship can lead to violence, and political murders indicate that people can also kill for secular reasons thus, violence does not uniquely apply to Islam or prove its distinctiveness. Asserting that Muhammad pbuh is the most idolized ever is factually incorrect, as figures like Jesus, Buddha, and Krishna have been revered for centuries; personal bias does not constitute evidence.
The miracles attributed to Muhammad pbuh are granted by God's permission, similar to those of Moses or Elijah. Miracles alone do not imply divinity or worship. In the seventh century, Christianity was not a level playing field. By the 2nd to 4th centuries, the divinity of Christ and his sacrificial death were already central beliefs, and those who denied them were marginalized. Islam did not reform Christianity but rather rejected its foundational beliefs. The notion of a peaceful world before conversion is historically inaccurate as civilizations like Assyria, Egypt, Babylon, Greece, Rome, and Israel engaged in violent expansion long before the advent of Christianity or Islam. You are not correcting historical facts; you are altering them to support a thesis that the evidence does not back up. I have long asked you for direct not speculative proof that Muhammad pbuh was first a Christian or such convert before branching off to form Islam. Just do that and end this back and forth over your illusive fantasy. Today there is no set of central beliefs that is common to all Christian sects despite that the world is a global village. How much more in the world of the seventh century?.Despite the agreement at Nice, there would still have been groups that continued to do their thing just as it is today. A proof that Mohammed was a Christian is that there was a Mohammed a Christian in the Byzantine empire who I have once read about. What this means is that Mohammed is probably a Christian baptismal name that was adopted by the Prophet of Islam. I hope you know that Mohammed was not his original name? The only other Mohammed I have heard of was a Byzantine Christian. I read a quote from him that I can not remember now If you say Mohammed is not the most idolized person ever, he would still be among the first three but I think considering all the daily rituals involving billions of people that he is associated with, he should be number one This is a thread I found discussing the origin of the name Mohammed on Quora https://www.quora.com/Was-there-anyone-named-Mohammed-before-the-prophet-of-IslamBefore conversions started, the only reasons nations fought wars was for territory. We had no reasons to fight or hate each other over God. There was therefore peace in that respect unlike now |
Christianity Etc › Re: Religion Should Be Banned. It Has Not Always Existed by lawani(op): 7:23pm On Jan 30 |
MaxInDHouse: If your ifá had foresight it should have known that failure to address necessary issues will later render it useless before the coming generation. Today you keep complaining about religion as if that's the only problem of mankind whereas spirituality that's useless is the real problem! A body of knowledge can not have foresight. Ifa is getting larger and stronger all over the world. You can't know it and abandon it. It can never be rendered useless. I write about religion and I also write about other challenges I believe the world is facing. Have you gone through my posts? If you have done that you will not say I think religion is the only problem of mankind |