RestructureNig3: You're an ignoramus, Fulani are minority in Nigeria. Igboland is divided into South East and South South Regions, here is the map of Igboland.
Igbo have more population than the Yoruba,
Where is the population living? The entire population of the SE which contains majority of Igbos is around the same population as Oyo and Ogun. Nigeria has really messed up the Yoruba so bad. The entire SE is just eighty percent of Lagos. The SE is less than Kano in population
EmekaA125: Remove Igbo population in Lagos, Ibadan and Ogun let's continue the conversation. Even at that, SE is not small in population. Onitsha alone is bigger than the whole of Ekiti State. So be sure before saying what you have no knowledge of.
Return all Yoruba to Yoruba land before we continue the conversation. You people talk as if it is only Igbos that reside outside their enclave. There is no Nigerian ethnic group that is not scattered across Nigeria. There are probably more Yoruba outside Yoruba land than non Yorubas on Yoruba land so it cancels out. I can post links of university departments in the North where a large percentage of staff are Yoruba. When Christians were killed during the last Jos riots there were more Yoruba killed than Igbos. When there was a census of language spoken at home in US Yoruba was like double Igbo. In Ireland it was like triple. Why do you think it's not like that in Jos, Maiduguri or Kano? Everybody is everywhere. Migration cancels out
According to NIN data, Anambra is like double the population of Ekiti
AntiChristian: Which Torah stories are inside the Qur'an? Do provide clear proofs!
And if Jesus quoted a verse from the Old testament do you say he copied it too?
Jesus did not say he received those verses from God directly. Muslims insist the Quran was divinely revealed to Mohammed when it is obviously a new edition Torah or a new edition of the Bible
Edusouls: china now controls world manufacturing bro do you know what it means? Before it was USA but due to their liberal ways China penetrated their society and started exporting jobs to their place luring away top companies to their country with offer of cheap labor and tax, how did u think they got big cos they stole from USA, one of the reason USA is mad at them, USA helped build the China we see today one reason China keeps mum when USA is throwing accusations,
Labor costs across the world can be evened out then some manufacturing will return to the US. The west too used many Chinese inventions to kick off. So the Chinese using the US to get ahead is normal. We all need each other. What the Chinese did in the 20th century the Japanese did in the 19th and achieved parity with the west
If believing in the virgin birth of Jesus and viewing him as a prophet qualifies someone as Christian then you make an unreasonable argument. By that reasoning, Muslims who honor Jesus would also be considered Christians, even though they reject key Christian beliefs like the Trinity, the divinity of Christ, his sacrificial death, and resurrection which are core tenets of Christianity.
Muhammad pbuh did not support these beliefs or engage in Christian practices. You can't separate from something you were never a part of. Your claim that Sumerians are ancestors of Arabs is historically inaccurate. The Sumerians, who lived in what is now Iraq from 3500 to 1900 BCE, spoke a unique language and were ethnically different from Arabs, who are Semitic people from the Arabian Peninsula. Your comparison to Mormons reinforces my argument. Joseph Smith was a Christian before he established Mormonism, representing a true breakaway. In contrast, Muhammad pbuh was never a Christian; he had a different origin.
There is no historical evidence that Muhammad pbuh practiced or converted from Christianity. Save yourself this pointless banter and bring proof he was. Influence does not equate to identity.
Muslims Revere Jesus because their founder was a Christian at one point. That is where they got it from. You can only get reports about Jesus from Jews or Christians when Mohammed was born. Going by his beliefs, Mohammed listened to Christians and was convinced by them.
Then the ancestors of Arabs did not speak Arabic which is a new language. The ancestors of Jews did not speak Hebrew. The first prominent Semitic language came after the rise of Assyria. As at only 1000 years ago, Sumerian was still in use in Iraq. It later was used only by priests and then it passed out of use. Someone like Moses spoke Kemitic Egyptian and not Hebrew. The difference in language therefore does not mean Sumerians are not Arab ancestors. Arabic is a new language
honesttalk21: Your assertion that Muhammad pbuh was converted by Christians or just a Christian is totally untrue and doesn't hold water historically. There's no real evidence suggesting he ever practiced Christianity or went through any kind of conversion from it. Islamic texts portray him as a monotheist in a society full of polytheism, not as someone who used to be Christian and then started a new religion. Saying that accepting the virgin birth and Jesus as a prophet makes him a Christian is a huge stretch. By that logic, anyone who respects Jesus would automatically be a Christian which makes the definition so broad it loses all meaning. Christianity has some core, non-negotiable beliefs which are Christ's divinity, his sacrifice for sins, and his resurrection. Islam has rejected all three of these from the very beginning. Muhammad pbuh didn't break away from Christianity because he was never part of it to begin with. If just sharing a few beliefs makes religions the same, then Jehovah's Witnesses and Catholics would be the same religion.
Your claim about pre-Islamic Arabian writings mentioning Abraham falls apart when you bring up the Epic of Gilgamesh, which is from Mesopotamia, not Arabia, and existed centuries before Abraham. This shows a basic misunderstanding between Sumerian (Iraqi) and Arabian cultures. If you have tons"of pre-Islamic Arabian texts, you should name them specifically instead of vaguely pointing to stuff from completely different civilizations.
The idea that Muhammad wasn't persecuted by Christians is irrelevant when it comes to classifying religions. Mormons weren't universally persecuted by Christians either, but they're still considered a distinct religion. Persecution doesn't define theological boundaries doctrine does. Islam's clear rejection of Christianity's core beliefs makes it a separate religion, regardless of whether Christians helped early Muslims or whether Muhammad pbuh ever encountered Christian teachings.
You don't understand. Jesus was a Jew. Jews believed he was a nonentity, a vagabond. Anybody in the seventh century of Mohammed that believed Jesus was born of a virgin and was God's prophet was a Christian at one point. I hope you get it now. If you believe Mohammed is the last Prophet, how were you not a Muslim at one point? How were you not converted by Muslims? Mesopotamia is Iraq and those are the ancestors of Arabs. Sumerians are Arab ancestors. There are other Arab ancestors and there are no Arab ancestors that have tradition of Abraham.
Mormons will not argue like you are doing now that their founder was not a Christian
Yoruba customary law is vastly superior to Islam in all respect. Since Yoruba Muslims like Sharia, why are they not marrying their cousins since it is allowed by Sharia?
pek: I agree with you to an extent. But Moslems in Yoruba land can't be said to be insignificant! They are even more in some parts and in some states like Oyo, they determine the status quo
They are balanced out by their rivals the Christians. As they say 'Were la fi nwo were' Madness can only be cured with madness
If a state governor refuses to conduct local government elections then it will be wrong for the Presidency to release local government funds to such a government since it is undermining democracy. Osun however has conducted a local government election though it was boycotted by the APC. I think the election was conducted after the governor got a court injunction that purportedly invalidated the election conducted by the outgone Governor Oyetola.
The fault presently is with the judiciary and not the Osun state government. Let the judiciary say in clear words which of the two local government elections held already is valid. Why is it difficult for the court to do this?
My own opinion is that the PDP and others are not justified to boycott the Gov Oyetola election just because he was on his way out. The Nigerian constitution does not say a Governor that lost election can not conduct local government election. It can however be possible to sue him and claim damages because he did not conduct the elections earlier.
In my opinion the so called Yes or No chairmen are the legitimate chairmen. However it is the courts that have the final say.
Since the present Governor Adeleke has conducted elections then the funds seized by the Presidency should be released to his government while the other party goes to court.
Edusouls: USA is owing 34trillion dollars in debts, mind you they can't pay it off, they spend almost 1trillon a year in military budgets yearly alone, don't mind all these hyped company values, the real economy is jobs and manufacturing which has left the USA to China, when you owe you don't have money folks, no wonder they now go on Broaday light robbery of oil in Venezuela, all these gen z here shouting and praising USA you people we're not born yet when they were at their peak , their glorious days are gone forever
The USA is owing over seventy percent of it's debts to US citizens and institutions not foreign entities. The US is still leading in innovation and the source of new wealth is innovation and new markets. When everything is evened up, the only two countries that will be ahead of the US is India and China because of their local market. The US will still continue to be the most competitive big country
gidgiddy: You are not ashamed of your self? You are here talking about population when small countries like Singapore with a population of just 6 million people, has a bigger GDP than all of Nigeria
Igbos and Yorubas have no business being together in the same country
What are the Igbos basing their arguments on if not population?
No You can't. The worst that can happen is people going voluntarily to Sharia panels. What is happening in Northern Nigeria can't happen in Yoruba land because of insufficient number of Muslims
AntiChristian: Give us your proofs? These rants are just all barks and no bites!
Torah stories inside the Koran is not proof enough for you? If you see Oduduwa stories inside the Koran, will you need proof of where Mohammed got it from?
Kobojunkie: . I get your argument. There remain over 46,000 different Christian sects even to this day. 🥱🥱
Also, Mohammed did set himself as a replacement for Jesus Christ in his Quran, though. ➜Mohammedians literally pray to Mohammed 5 times every day during their Salats(Shahadas) — he is dead, but they still call on him to provide for them intercession so Allah will hear their prayers. He literally presented himself as a go-between for all muslims to reach Allah. (Muslims cannot be heard by Allah unless they first pray to Mohammed.) ➜ Mohammed is expected to sit on a throne next to Allah, in some way taking the place of Jesus in the Christian myths.
honesttalk21: Demanding Arab scriptures is a bit of a misstep. Pre-Islamic Arabia relied on spoken word, not written texts. You really don't know? Just because there aren't written records doesn't mean there were no traditions. If that were the case, we'd have to say most ancient peoples had no history, which isn't true.
We actually have accounts from outside sources. Christian, Jewish, and Byzantine writers before Islam mention Arabs identifying as Ishmaelites, practicing circumcision, and claiming descent from Abraham. Even Jewish scripture mentions Ishmael's twelve princes and recognizes his descendants as distinct groups (Genesis 25; Psalm 83). To say there are no known descendants goes against both your own Bible and historical records.
Regarding Jesus; believing he was a prophet and born of a virgin doesn't automatically make someone a Christian. Christianity hinges on the concepts of divinity, crucifixion, resurrection, and atonement. Islam clearly rejects all of those. Agreeing on a couple of points while disagreeing on the core beliefs doesn't mean you belong to the same religion.
Christianity separated from Judaism despite sharing prophets, and Islam breaks away from Christianity in a similar way. Just because they share some figures doesn't mean they're the same religion.
Your argument doesn't hold up because it asks for written proof from a culture that prioritized oral tradition,overlooks historical accounts from external sources,and confuses surface-level agreement with true theological alignment.
That's not really evidence, it's more like trying to bend the rules. It's special pleading.
So you now agree that Islam broke away from Christianity? Just the same way the Mormon church and the JW broke away. I want you to realize that Mohammed accepted the doctrine of the virgin birth and Jesus' prophethood from Christians. He was converted by Christians!
We can say the first Christians were dissident Jews because they were actually hunted down and persecuted by Jews but Mohammed was just a Christian. His acceptance of Jesus as a prophet and belief in the virgin birth makes him so and there was no time he was persecuted by Christians. He was infact helped and supported by Christians
There are many pre Islamic writing from Arabia. Tonnes of it. The epic of Sumer is one. None mentions Abraham or Ishmael. There is no Torah story in any
honesttalk21: Simple application of basic understanding of history and logical consistency has your arguments crumbled.
Abraham was never exclusively owned by the Jews. Jewish scripture itself states that Ishmael, Abraham's own son, was blessed, destined to multiply, and become a great nation (Genesis 16-17). Pre-Islamic Arabs traced their ancestry back to Ishmael, and Byzantine and Syriac Christian writers recorded Arabs identifying themselves as Ishmaelites, centuries before Islam even emerged. Abraham was a patriarch figure shared across Semitic traditions, not the sole property of one ethnic group.
Yes, Christianity did originate as a Jewish sect and that fact completely undermines your point. Christianity separated from Judaism by discarding Jewish law and fundamentally redefining the nature of God. Islam does something similar with Christianity but didn't separate from it. It acknowledges Jesus, but pointedly rejects core tenets like the Trinity, the Incarnation, the Crucifixion, the Resurrection, and the concept of Atonement. These aren't minor quibbles; they are fundamental contradictions. A belief system that denies the very foundations of Christianity cannot logically be Christianity itself.
Simply believing in Jesus's status as a prophet and his virgin birth doesn't make someone a Christian otherwise, Jews would also be Christians. Christianity is fundamentally defined by the divinity of Jesus, his crucifixion, and his resurrection. Islam explicitly denies all three.
The assertion that Muhammad pbuh was somehow converted by Christians is pure speculation, lacking any real evidence. The Qur'an contains criticisms of both Jews and Christians and outright rejects the central doctrines of Christianity. If Islam were simply a Christian sect, it wouldn't dismantle the core of Christian theology.
Your argument relies on a blatant double standard. Christianity is granted the right to diverge from Judaism and still be considered distinct but Islam is denied the same right to diverge from Christianity. That's not history; it's simply biased reasoning.
Shared prophets do not equal a shared religion. Abraham existed long before Judaism. Islam rejects the defining beliefs of Christianity.
Islam is a distinct Abrahamic faith just as Christianity is distinct from Judaism.
You say Jewish scriptures, show me Arab scriptures mentioning Abraham or Ishmael. Ishmael is a man mentioned in the Torah who according to the Torah lived and died among millions of unknowns in the Egypt Palestine area thousands of years ago. No known descendants
Yes if Jews believed in Jesus' virgin birth and prophethood, they would be effectively Christians but they don't. I am surprised you don't know
honesttalk21: Lawani a derivation from moonlight or is it chief. The foundation of your argument crumbles with even a basic understanding of history.
Recognizing shared prophets doesn't make something a sect. Islam views earlier prophets as part of a continuous Abrahamic tradition, not as something derived from Christianity. Following your reasoning, Christianity would be a sect of Judaism knowing Jesus was Jewish, taught from the Hebrew scriptures, and the first Christians were Jews themselves. Either apply your standard consistently or discard it.
The claim that only Jews and Christians had these stories is simply untrue. Arabia maintained its own Abrahamic oral traditions (Abraham, Ishmael, the Kaaba). Moreover, Arabia was home to Jewish tribes, Syriac Christians, Hanifs, had contact with Ethiopia, and a widespread system of oral storytelling. Similar narratives don't automatically mean direct borrowing of texts.
The concepts of virgin birth and prophethood are not unique to Christianity. Miraculous births appear well before Christianity (Isaac, Samuel, John - the Baptist). Accepting Jesus as a prophet while simultaneously rejecting his divinity, crucifixion, the Trinity, and the atonement is an anti-Christian theological stance, not that of a Christian sect.
Saying there's no other way is just arguing from a place of ignorance. Other possibilities exist.
An independent Arabian monotheism (the Hanifs) Cultural contact from multiple sources Religious synthesis Or the Islamic claim of direct revelation (which you can reject, but you can't historically disprove).
The comparison to Mormons or Jehovah's Witnesses is a false analogy. These groups are centered on Christ and build upon Christian doctrine. Islam directly refutes Christianity's central tenets (the Trinity, Incarnation, Crucifixion). That's not building upon Christianity; it's contradicting it.
Shared cultural practices don't demonstrate derivation. Islam asserts it's restoring Abrahamic rites, and Christianity itself adopted pagan calendars and customs. By this logic, Christianity would also be invalidated.
So shared roots doesn't mean a sect. Neither does shared stories translate to conversion. Nor rejecting core doctrines equal perfect continuation. Saying no other way is not evidence.
Islam is not a sect of Christianity. It is a distinct Abrahamic religion that competes with, corrects, and contradicts Christian theology. You're free to reject Islam theologically, but calling it a Christian sect is historically and logically indefensible.
Abraham is the property of Jews and your notion that anybody apart from Jews originally knew about Abraham is wrong. It is like saying some other people knew about Oduduwa without hearing the story from the Yoruba or some people knew about King Arthur without hearing of him from the British. Abraham is the property of Jews. Always remember that. No tradition of Abraham among Arabs originally. The first Christians were all Jews. So Christianity was infact a dissident Jewish sect at the beginning before they started admitting Gentiles. Emphasis on dissident. Islam on its part is not dissident Christianity but Christianity itself. You can't believe in Jesus' prophethood and his virgin birth in the first century and say you are not a Jesus follower. Mohammed was converted by a Christian sect after which he added his own tribal practices to it to form Islam.
Note Mohammed wasn't converted by Jews but by Christians
Kobojunkie: 1. Mohammed's tales are fables he cobbled together about the Jewish and Injeel traditions that existed around his time. 🥱🥱
2. Mohammed believed in someone whose teachings he never once attempted to emulate. Mohammed believed so much that he confused the mother of Jesus with the sister of Aaron? Well, yeah, Mohammed could indeed have been part of a Christian sect. 😏11
3. Glad you didn't say he accepted Jesus Christ of Israel, as the Christians love to mouth on about doing. 🤔
Yeah, Mohammed is indeed no different from those you listed there. Sadly, he was able to capture the Arabs in the way he did with his many co-opted tales that prove nothing about him other than that he was good at the fraud that is religion.
He in a way accepted Christ because he acknowledged him as a prophet. He however did not acknowledge him as God. It was in the convention at Nice that early Christian leaders decided to accept the divinity of Christ. In the beginning there were many Christian sects that did not accept Jesus Christ as God. It must have been a sect that did not accept Christ as God that preached to him in Arabia
AntiChristian: Do you have proof he heard the details about them elsewhere?
If you present someone's work as your original work in academic circles then you are courting jail. The court will not accept your argument that you got it from God
AntiChristian: 1. Distinct Origins and Revelation A. Islam presents itself as a distinct and final revelation from God (Allah) through the Prophet Muhammad, not as a sect or offshoot of Christianity or Judaism. The Quran explicitly states that it confirms and corrects previous scriptures but is a new, independent revelation (Quran 5:48). B. The Quran challenges Christian doctrines such as the divinity of Jesus and the Trinity (Quran 4:171; 5:73), which shows a clear theological divergence rather than mere adoption. C. The Quran also rejects the idea of Jesus as the Son of God and emphasizes strict monotheism (Tawhid), which is fundamentally different from Christian beliefs.
2. Historical and Theological Differences A. While Islam acknowledges Jesus as a prophet and accepts the virgin birth (Quran 3:45-47), it rejects his divinity and crucifixion, which are central to Christian faith. B. The Quran’s narratives about biblical figures often differ in details and emphasis, indicating independent sources or oral traditions rather than direct borrowing. C. The presence of Jewish and Christian communities in Arabia at the time of Muhammad does not imply that Islam originated as a sect of Christianity. Rather, Islam arose in a religiously pluralistic environment and engaged with these traditions critically.
3. Prophet Muhammad’s Unique Role A. Muhammad is regarded in Islam as the "Seal of the Prophets" (Quran 33:40), meaning the final messenger who brought the ultimate and complete guidance. B. His teachings include practices and laws that are distinct from Christianity and Judaism, such as the five daily prayers, fasting in Ramadan, and specific legal rulings. C. The claim that Muhammad simply added his own cultural practices to Christianity ignores the comprehensive nature of Islamic law (Sharia) and theology, which is rooted in the Quran and Hadith.
4. Academic and Historical Perspectives A. Scholars recognize that Islam emerged in a context influenced by Jewish, Christian, and Arabian traditions, but it is not accurate to say it was "converted" from Christianity. B. Islam’s theological framework and worldview are distinct and represent a new religious system rather than a sect or derivative. C. The comparison to modern religious movements like Mormonism or Jehovah’s Witnesses is anachronistic and overlooks the historical and theological context of 7th-century Arabia.
5. Verses Emphasizing Islam’s Distinct Identity A. Quran 3:19: "Indeed, the religion in the sight of Allah is Islam." B. Quran 5:3: "This day I have perfected for you your religion and completed My favor upon you and have approved for you Islam as religion." C. Quran 6:162: "Say, 'Indeed, my prayer, my rites of sacrifice, my living and my dying are for Allah, Lord of the worlds.'"
Islam is not a sect of Christianity but a distinct Abrahamic faith with its own unique revelation, theology, and practices. While it acknowledges and respects previous prophets and scriptures, it offers a new and final message. The claim that Muhammad was converted by Christians or simply adapted Christianity does not hold up against theological, historical, and scriptural evidence.
So it was from Allah that he first heard the name of Jesus Christ, Mary, Abraham and etc?
EasternActivist: That era is gone for good... That you're alive today is thanks to Christianity if not, you would have been a slave for the Arabs... Christianity brought civilization you're enjoying today. What has islam brought to humanity if not jihad terrorism ?? If China ancestors can stop Islam their progenitor won't be any different, I can be here in Enugu and trade my wares around the globe with no mix of culture or Islam. Even today Islam is being rejected in Iran, China has put restrictions in place to checkmate islam. Islam can never be an Igbo religion. You can wait like saraduna and danfodio then you can join them in grave waiting for igbo people to be Muslim.
How would the Arabs have enslaved me? The Yoruba have known the Arabs for centuries and there was no time they were in a position to enslave us. They know their territory and we know ours. You seem like a cry baby who thinks Africans were enslaved by anyone they come across. People are waking up against religion now across the world and religion will be eradicated. If however they don't act, then it can grow gradually and eat up any society. That is common sense. No society is immune. It applies to both Christianity and Islam. They are both scourges. You thank Christianity for being alive not me. That is the level of your understanding. Christianity is more ridiculous than Islam, has caused more violence than Islam and etc. A Christian is not by any means justified to say he or she is thinking deeper or better than a Muslim. Some Igbos are already Muslims. So there is nobody waiting for Igbos to be Muslims.