₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,381 members, 8,522,747 topics. Date: Saturday, 21 November 2026 at 10:04 PM

Toggle theme

Thehomer's Posts

Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 (of 210 pages)

Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 11:48pm On Jun 05, 2013
Uyi Iredia: What makes you think I didn't do that ? I answered your question so what's to be demonstrated is not my point but a possible refutation. Now quit being a lazy bum.



This is the mental sloppiness expected from someone who intellectually ma$turbäte$ by evading simple, articulated points. Read the article on taste. Licking will suffice, though it could be eaten.
This has to be one of the most asinine things I've come across on this forum. You declare that I've committed a logical fallacy, I ask you to demonstrate it and you just go bonkers. You then hop on to making the sorts of comparisons that even children will notice as being a demonstration of either idiocy or insanity.

I'm done with you. Your petulant cry for attention has been noted.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 11:45pm On Jun 05, 2013
Uyi Iredia: Did I say you said it was ?



Neither did I say you said time is an object, your definition of time makes it an object. I think your definition is flawed. First 'temporally preceded' is a tautology, both refer to time. Second, an event can be preceded by one which isn't the cause e.g. thunder before rain, having $ex before dying.



Just Google 'massive evidence for evolution'. But of course, you would be too lazy to do that.
This is why trying to have a discussion with you is just a waste of time. You often find it difficult or are just too dumb to back up your own claims.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 11:42pm On Jun 05, 2013
Mr anony: I think I can almost get what you are saying but seeing as you have the remarkable ability of being deliberately vague, I'll push you to clarify further. As per the bold. Must you know precisely what the end to be achieved is in order to know if it is a design or not?

I have already answered the same question here (fourth paragraph).
Push all you want. No you don't have to know precisely what the end is but that isn't all I said about it.

But, based on what you said, the sun is designed even the electron is designed and once again, in your attempt to explain it all, you've explained nothing.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 11:40pm On Jun 05, 2013
Mr anony: You made it when you argued "if the universe turned out any other way". Well, it doesn't matter now as you have said "you don't know?"
It does because you're still making the same mistake that has been corrected.

Mr anony: Lolol, you have not said whether you agree or not, well, no matter instead of beating about the bush, let me address your question of chaos:
The problem is that you have not used chaos in the sense that I was using it i.e. I argued that the universe follows a set of specific physical laws such that we can accurately predict what should happen next given the initial conditions. Chaos in the sense I meant would be a situation where the universe will not function according to any laws such that we can predict what will happen next.
Is that something physically possible?

Mr anony: The article you linked didn't provide such a situation. In fact it agrees that if we knew the precise initial conditions that lead to an action, we would be able to predict that action accurately however where we can't precisely measure the initial conditions leading to the action, we would miss it by a very wide mark. Your double pendulum example for instance follows the physical laws of the universe to the letter and hence is not chaotic in that sense. If we could freeze each moment and measure precisely the exact energy and force at that moment, we would accurately predict exactly where the pendulum will swing next. The only reason it looks random is because we cannot adequately measure it's movement.
You have failed to present any example of chaos that violates physical laws of the universe
Is it possible for anything in the universe to violate the physical laws of the universe?

Mr anony: Lololol, To say that a thing exists necessarily is to say that there is no logical possibility that such a thing would be other than it is i.e. if such a thing were any different, it would be logically incoherent.
It is either you know or you don't know. You can't make this argument you are trying to make by claiming ignorance.
It looks like you're still confused about the difference between logical possibilities and physical possibilities. I don't have to know whether or not something is physically possible in order to make a conditional statement about a logical possibility.

Mr anony: Lol, let's see: so God creates a universe and sets certain physical laws in place such that space time and matter can form and behave in a certain specific way. The moon is one of such matter and behaves according to the physical laws set by God. The creation of a gun involved another mind entirely called man. So if you know of another mind other than God that specifically created the moon, feel free to bring such a mind forward.
Based on what you've just said, God didn't create the moon while some man created a gun. The moon came about maybe while God was asleep.

Mr anony: By the way, don't forget to respond to this post
I'll do that next.
Christianity Etc › Re: Dear Atheist, Do You Feel The Need To Be Thankful? by thehomer: 1:50pm On Jun 05, 2013
Mr anony: answered here
You seem to have forgotten when you were talking about striving against the flesh. And the point about whether or not you sin is something that you can answer yourself with a yes or no. It wasn't an ad hominem.

Mr anony: This shows you have not been paying attention.
Now that you know a bit more about what being born again is, kindly answer from scripture: Was the devil ever born again?
About Jeffrey Dahmer I answered here
No the devil wasn't born again but neither are the angels, Jesus, God or the holy spirit. And based on that response about Jeffrey Dahmer, since he'll be having free will in heaven, what would stop him from acting like the devil? Note that being born-again is to get you into heaven. It doesn't mean you'll remain there. And that he has his free-will.

Mr anony: What information specifically were you looking for about being born again that you feel I have "massaged out"?
You didn't say whether or not a bathing in water without soap was required, accepting that Jesus died for your sins you didn't even talk about salvation and reward.

Mr anony: Are you blind? Read my post again, I explained what it means to be born again,
About whether I agreed with you or not; I told you that wikipedia was too basic for me to give my full agreement however I didn't disagree. You don't ask questions then try to force the answer you want you know.
About adding depth to what it means to be born again, I think I Muskeeto and I have done precisely that. If there is anything more you want to know about being born-again, you'll have to ask for it specifically.
The extra questions I tacked on was my way of testing if you actually knew what you were talking about. Apparently you didn't
Obviously you're lazy and ignorant because you haven't even met your own standards of explanation for what it means to be born-again.
Your so-called explanation and more were given in the article I posted but you suddenly started wailing and throwing up roadblocks.

Mr anony: Lol. I laugh in Aramaic
Keep laughing. But they're still here see them below.

Mr anony: Explain using bible references:
what one is born from and what he/she is born into.
what salvation is and why it is necessary
why those who are born again will make heaven while those who reject Christ will go to hell,
whether or not a person who is born again can lose the status of being born again
what exactly does a relationship with Christ entail.
If you think the goalposts you've moved are too wide for you that's all well and good so we can now get back to where we were before you derailed my point.

Here's a simple question for you. Is it logically possible for Jeffrey Dahmer to go against God's will in heaven while he has free will? Be careful with your answer because it has profound implications.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 1:26pm On Jun 05, 2013
Mr anony: Lol. of course you don't
So will you show me where I made this concession?

Mr anony: I got all that. What I am asking is whether that diagram is an example of what you meant when you were talking about chaos because it was one of the examples given in the article you presented.

by the way this is a summary of chaos as per your article:
Chaos: When the present determines the future, but the approximate present does not approximately determine the future. - Edward Lorenz

Do you agree with it?
I agree with the fact that chaos is an integral part of the universe if you do not agree with that fact after reading that article, then simply say so rather than rambling on about definitions. The article is more informative than a definition. And that is the point I was making.

Mr anony: You can't make this counterargument because it presupposes that the universe does not exist necessarily and you just said you don't know. Do you know now?
I don't have to know in order to make that argument. It does not presuppose that about the universe, it demonstrates the fact that your so-called answer tries to explain everything.

You're basically making the same mistake you made when you were confusing logical possibilities with physical possibilities. I don't know that it is physically possible for the universe to be any other way but it is logically possible. Try not to keep confusing these two issues.

Mr anony: I've told you who created the universe. Go figure
This makes no sense. Even if your God created the universe, it doesn't mean he also created the moon otherwise, one can also say he created a gun.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 10:12am On Jun 05, 2013
Mr anony: This is just you beating about the bush and you know it. You have already conceded that the laws defining how the universe behaves do not exist necessarily. You wouldn't have made the contention "if the universe had been any other way" if you thought the universe existed necessarily. Not only that, you have also conceded that the universe began to exist at some point.
Where exactly did I make these concessions?

Mr anony: Now let me ask you again and this time pointblank. [size=13pt]Does the universe exist necessarily in it's current form and function? Yes or no.[/size]

And just so you don't misunderstand me, by "form" I mean - the way it appears, and by "function" I mean - the way it behaves

Be very careful how you answer this question. Let me tell you the implications: If you say yes, then you would be saying that the idea of a multiverse is a logically incoherent idea. If you say no, then you would be saying that the universe must ultimately be contingent on something that exists necessarily. Your call
I don't know.

Mr anony: I have read it and I think you have missed my point but just to be sure I got what you were talking about, by "chaos" you mean something like this?
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/45/Double-compound-pendulum.gif
The movement of a double pendulum.
I was making the point which you missed. I said the universe had chaos inbuilt. You asked for a reason for this conclusion and I presented it. What I showed you was that however the universe turned out, you would still have given the same answer to these very different questions and that means your answer which tries to explain it all actually explains nothing.

Now can you tell me who created the moon?
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 10:07am On Jun 05, 2013
Uyi Iredia: In the OP I replied. I coukd be wrong, of course, but you'll have to show how.
If you could be wrong, why didn't you take the time to find out whether or not you were wrong before speaking? You're now asking me to demonstrate your own point to you? This is ridiculous. If you cannot, simply say so.

Uyi Iredia: What is clear is that you are dull and need to nderstand the concept of taste (see Wikipedia) to see that my point was valid.
This is why I say you don't know how to have a reasonable conversation. The unintelligent laziness demonstrated by this response clearly shows your poor reasoning skills. If you usually go around comparing taste by eating the Eiffel Tower, then the problems you face are deep indeed.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 10:04am On Jun 05, 2013
Uyi Iredia: I know. Just don't say the term God is ambiguous. It isn't in this context.
Did I say it was?

Uyi Iredia: And what else can 'begins to exist' mean ? Cause is a condition necessary for another to take place. Your definition is flawed because time isn't an object and can't precede itself.
In that case, the reason my rejection of the definition is pretty clear. I didn't say time was an object. What I meant was something being temporally preceded by another in time.

Uyi Iredia: That is strongly suggested. I believe the phrase 'massive evidence for evolution' is known to you.
If someone said that, please show this otherwise be silent on it.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 8:15am On Jun 05, 2013
Uyi Iredia: The way you threw out a name. Now are you open to correction. I know you for being stubborn.
Can you show me where I pointed out a named fallacy without explaining why it was fallacious?

Uyi Iredia: And that comparison can be made. Take a part of the Eiffel tower, stick it in your mouth and report back to me.
And with this, it is clear that you're either unserious or you don't know how to have a reasonable conversation.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 8:13am On Jun 05, 2013
Uyi Iredia: Okay.



Then don't advance the notion that God is an ambiguous concept. Here's a clear definition which you reject.
I know. I rejected it.

Uyi Iredia: I wonder what else he meant.
"Begins to exist" can mean beginning to exist from pre-existing "stuff". Cause can mean being preceded by time.

Uyi Iredia: Just like 'everything proves evolution' says nothing about evolution.
But no one actually says that.
Christianity Etc › Re: What They Don't Tell You About Atheism by thehomer: 8:02am On Jun 05, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony]1. Atheism is supposed to be the lack of a belief in deity (God) rather it is the convenient denial of God so as to go against conscience commit as many crimes one can get away with.

2. Atheism has no moral code or guidelines i.e. does not define good and evil hence serial rapists, serial killers, pedophiles, fraudsters are all justified as atheists.

3. The world's most hideous mass murderers were atheists namely Hitler and Stalin

4. For a group of people who don't believe in God, they go a long way to try and force this non-belief on others who don't share it and will even resort to name-calling and violence in some cases. It seems to me that they do this so as to constantly convince themselves that there is no God even though their consciences and their souls protest (heck they even deny the soul)

5. Atheists will always misuse science by quoting so called "scientific facts" as if they were some infallible creed (deliberately forgetting that fallibility is in fact the nature of science)

6. Atheists simply do not have any morals and they are quite comfortable attacking those with morals by calling them intolerant brainwashed fanatic bigots because it gives them some sort of a superiority complex.

7. Though they often claim to be logical, they mostly fail to provide logical arguments rather they resort to over-simplistic lines, quoting theists out of context and plain old mockery.



8. My question to Atheists; Justify your belief. Can you prove to me with 100% certainty that there is no God?





This is in response to similar posts by logicboy and other militant evangelist atheists on Nairaland.[/quote]Well I'm a humanist too.

Your final question shows that you either don't understand your first point or you were just committing the tactics you're accusing atheists of. I've placed the emphasis on what you need to first understand in order for you to address your last question.
Christianity Etc › Re: Dear Atheist, Do You Feel The Need To Be Thankful? by thehomer: 7:56am On Jun 05, 2013
@Mr anony

So was that why you didn't answer these questions raised by mazaje?

If the devil himself who was in heaven could sin along with a lot of angels, what makes you think that a murderer who went to heaven won't be able to sin? When you say a murderer in heaven is an impossibility, then it tells me that you've not been reading my responses because unless you can definitively tell me that Jeffrey Dahmer is not and will never be in heaven, then you're simply wrong. You see, all you've done is to ignore other parts of your Bible in order to massage out information that you didn't even provide with your highlighting.

I notice that for some reason, you never actually said what it means to be born-again and you never said whether or not you agreed with what I posted. You never added the depth of this idea of yours to be born-again finally, you've just shown that the extra questions you tacked on which you also never answered here were just you way of shifting the goalposts.

Your questions still await you whenever you're ready.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 7:38am On Jun 05, 2013
Uyi Iredia: Precisely the kind of bandwagon fallacy used by evolutionists.
And he's back just hurling fallacies left and right. I've told you time and again to actually demonstrate the fallacy rather than throwing out a name.

Uyi Iredia: The similarities are what is his focus. That they can be decribed using physical laws. That they contain interacting parts. That they are made up of matter and can exhibit energy.
It looks like you don't know how to carry out relevant comparisons. By that reasoning, an apple like the Eiffel Tower can be described using physical laws, contain interacting parts and are made up of matter. Therefore we're being reasonable when comparing them in a discussion of which one of them is sweeter.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 7:34am On Jun 05, 2013
Mr anony: @thehomer:

To make it easier for me to understand you: Can you tell the difference between the work of an intelligent agent and the effect of a non-intelligent agent? i.e can you tell the difference between something that is designed and something that is not designed? If you can, then please tell me how you differentiate between design and non-design by observation.
Generally, how we tell the difference is that works of intelligent agents are tools that are used to achieve a certain end while works of unintelligent agents don't have such ends. And these tools are often assembled in a way that is unlikely to occur by chance.

Now can you answer your own questions?
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 7:28am On Jun 05, 2013
Mr anony: Lol, monotheistic religions define God as the creator of the cosmos.
No they don't "define" it that way, they say he did it.

Mr anony: Lol, listen to yourself. Then why bring up the "if" when you don't think the universe can possibly be any other way?
To show you that you would say the very same thing.

Mr anony: But it means that you have invoked a possible world where you can fly in other to make your argument. Basically you have said that your lack of ability to fly is not an impossibility only that in your current form of existence you cannot fly.
Is there any other form of existence?

Mr anony: Lol, my point has already been made. By conceding that "everything" could possibly exist in a different form, you have granted that "everything" does not exist by necessity and hence is contingent on a necessary something
But I never made such a concession.

Mr anony: Yeah it began to exist and orbits around the earth because of initial conditions and physical laws that allow it to do so. In fact we can accurately mathematically predict it's birth existence and death by imputing a set of specific mathematical constants in our equations. These set of specific constants ensure that the moon fits into the order of the universe. We could just as easily have a universe where this numbers could be different and then we'll have a different particle behaving very diferently or even no particle at all. Not only the moon but the whole universe follows this same mathematical order.
Now tell me exactly how you know that the moon wasn't created and why it has to follow this specific order and not another?
You never said who created the moon. The moon wasn't created by anyone because there was no one here to create it. It has to follow the physical laws of the universe because it is the type of thing that does.

Mr anony: Yeah let's have it.
Here you go. Pay attention to the applications.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 6:43pm On Jun 04, 2013
Deep Sight: Maybe you consist of matter, I do not. I am a spirit being within a material cloak.
You don't consist of matter? That's interesting.

Deep Sight: STOP RUNNING. DONT BE A COWARD. IT IS IN FACT YOUR RPOSITION, IS IT NOT, THAT DEAD MATTER, GIVEN ENOUGH TIME, CONTRIVED TO FORM HUMAN BEINGS, NO?
Not just time.

Deep Sight: You'll be surprised.
Hmm I would be indeed. Maybe you can get the corpse a bit part in a movie.

Deep Sight: O, infinitely greater and more magnificent, yes of course.
Then your comparison is inappropriate.
Christianity Etc › Re: About Abortion. by thehomer: 6:41pm On Jun 04, 2013
OLAADEGBU: Then leave the medical doctors to make the ethical decision in preventing both deaths instead of using lawyers to promote your pro-choice campaign.
Some doctors are also in support of abortions. So take your advice and leave them to make the ethical decision.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 6:38pm On Jun 04, 2013
striktlymi: Enjoy your thread o! I don comot! This ya plan to take this thread to the 15th page shall not work.
Thanks. Can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 6:37pm On Jun 04, 2013
Deep Sight: Don't worry, with time, this could become a human being - Thehomer

By Spontaneous generation in a primordial soup, and subsequently by natural selection, no help needed.
Excellent. I know sticking to attacking strawmen is easier but it still doesn't mean you've actually addressed my argument.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 6:35pm On Jun 04, 2013
Deep Sight: O yes, delusions such as the intricacy required for the existence of a human, or any brain, for that matter. No doubt that is nothing but our imagination, a delusion - which of course was put together by mindless matter and gases which simply had enough time to arrive at that!
Huh? How you make these leaps, I will never know.

Deep Sight: O, we do not speak of their work, which they may get right or wrong at any time. We speak of the necessity of God: which necessity, has nothing to do with their work, whatever they may propound or not propound.
If they can do their work without introducing your God, then your God is not necessary for them to do their work.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 6:33pm On Jun 04, 2013
Mr anony: the question was how do you define God? not whether you believed in God.
The single deity of various monotheistic religions.

Mr anony: good

Sorry your argument here is moot because you have already conceded that it is possible for the universe to work in a way totally different to how it currently works
No I did not concede that. What I said was that if the universe had been any other way, you would have made the same statement. It does not mean that the universe actually could have been any other way.

Mr anony: and this shows that you believe it is possible for physical laws to be different than how they are now. You agree that physical laws are not the way they are by necessity
No I do not agree with that claim either.
e.g If I could fly, I would fly to the top of the Leaning Tower of Pisa. Does this mean that I believe I can fly?

Mr anony: But you have just conceded that the physical laws defining the universe do not exist necessarily but arbitrarily. this allows for an agent. Secondly the universe has a beginning. If something begins to exist and works according to a specific pattern such that it's behavior can be accurately predicted and not many other possible ways, It can be said to be created. Secondly, water is wet by definition does not tell us that it is or isn't created. A computer computes by definition equally does not tell us whether or not it is created. I am making an argument of function (how a thing works) and you are attacking a strawman of form (how a thing is)
No I made no such concession. So the sun was created? So were hydrogen and the ocean? Again, explains everything, explains nothing. Water is not wet by definition. Water can be H2O by definition, a chemical by definition but not wet by definition. Wetness is one of its properties. Just as it is also a property of kerosene. I don't see how you can talk about a computer computing without having some notion of how it actually is.

Mr anony: As I said, if you think the universe didn't have a creator, then you are welcome to explain how something can begin to exist and work according to a specific pattern and yet be uncreated.
The moon began to exist and it orbits round the earth but it wasn't created by anyone.

Mr anony: I remember asking for specifics
Would you like an article? Because that is specific enough to make my point.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 6:23pm On Jun 04, 2013
Deep Sight: Of course, because they are living beings, who recognize that they use material tools to perceive a material world; it being more than evident to any thinking being, that he does not consist of matter. These people can then locate the glaring fact of their intangible existence as beings, and as such recognize the fount of life itself as non material and intangible.
But you do consist of matter unless of course you're not human.

Deep Sight: [size=16pt]DO NOT BE A COWARD NOW. EVERYTHING YOU HAVE SAID INESCAPABLY MEANS THAT YOU SAY THAT DEAD MATTER AND GASES, GIVEN ENOUGH TIME, WILL IN FACT AND DID IN FACT PRODUCE CONSCIOUS INTELLIGENT, KNOWING SAPIENT BEINGS.[/size]
Dead matter? Is the moon alive or dead? Last time I checked, it consisted of matter. No I don't say that because there are certain conditions required.

Deep Sight: About as many things as a corpse appreciates, I guess.
Can a corpse appreciate great wine?

Deep Sight: A self existent universe should surprise you just about as much as a self existent house should, if not more: for a self existent universe contains many more vastly amazing and intricate things than any house does.

You, of course, being one such amazing thing. cheesy
Meh. A universe is still very different from a house.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 5:06pm On Jun 04, 2013
Deep Sight: O, one line containing two sentences in perfect contradiction.

Second sentence defeats your argument, since not just one, but millions, profess to detect God and even hear God. And oh, you cannot deny their statements since you are not within their mind or perceptions, you can never know, can you?
This is of course a text book case of the bandwagon fallacy. Millions claiming to detect God or to hear him doesn't make it true. For all we know, those claiming to hear him may have some psychological problems while others claim to detect him because he got them a parking space near the supermarket entrance. If they can actually hear God, then God is interacting with the universe in some way.

Deep Sight: Dont worry, dead matter, rock and gases did it all by their very intelligent selves.

And ignorant about what? Ignorant about the capacity of dead rocks and gases to, given sufficient time, form intelligent beings of culture and knowledge such as us?

You are hilarious.
I am sometimes hilarious when I want to be but you're just making a strawman argument here because nothing I said actually leads to that conclusion.

Deep Sight: Answering this question to you, would amount to throwing cheap jewelry (not pearls) before swine. No offence intended mate, just meant proverbially about he who will not appreciate anything, no matter how simple or valuable.
Oh I appreciate a lot of things. It is just you people with your hubris and desire to be special that crack me up. Throw cheap jewelry or broken glass. It is up to you.

Deep Sight: Just as surely as when we see houses, we cannot tell who built them, or that they must have have a mind, or hands.
The universe is a very different beast from a house. It is like comparing an apple to a pod of whales.
Christianity Etc › Re: About Abortion. by thehomer: 4:59pm On Jun 04, 2013
OLAADEGBU: And so is the life of the baby.
The baby was born without a brain and would have died shortly after birth if carried to term while the mother didn't look like she would have made it to term.
Christianity Etc › Re: Dear Atheist, Do You Feel The Need To Be Thankful? by thehomer: 4:57pm On Jun 04, 2013
@ musKeeto.

I am thehomer and I endorse your response. grin
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 4:55pm On Jun 04, 2013
Deep Sight: Well this nullifies your whole argument. Millions detect him and profess so everyday. They detect God in all the wonder that they see: particularly with reference to seeing living, thinking, conscious, sentient, knowing, sapient beings, the technology for which remains beyond the highest human intelligence but which you seek to claim was performed by dead matter. Bro, you are funny indeed.
No it doesn't. Millions of people can be and have been wrong about what they thought they detected. People have had wishful thinking, delusions, hallucinations, illusions, faulty memory and many other issues.

Deep Sight: If you laugh at or reject religious notions of God, I can understand that. I cannot understand however, laughing at or rejecting the philosophical and indeed, scientific necessity of God.
Yet philosophers and scientists have been doing their work without the need for introducing God. I wonder why.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 4:52pm On Jun 04, 2013
Mr anony: Yes I believe He does
Hmm. So you had a more specific idea of God in mind. For some reason, you didn't try to be more specific in your first attempt.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 4:49pm On Jun 04, 2013
Mr anony: What then do you define God as? Since you have rejected the very definition of God which Christians believe in. perhaps you may want to define the God you had in mind.
I don't believe in one. It is up to you to actually justify your own definitions.

Mr anony: I'm sure you have access to a dictionary
Sure I do. And I know how easy it is to confuse those terms.

Mr anony: The fact that there are possible worlds where things such as the speed of light, gravity, the strong and weak nuclear forces can be different from what they are here tells me that the laws of this universe are not necessary laws.
Err. You don't know that there are possible worlds with different constants.

Mr anony: Interestingly this proves my point. The fact that the universe works according to a specific pattern tells us that there is an intelligence behind it. If you disagree, you are welcome to tell me how you would have gone about detecting an intelligence from utter chaos.
In a funny way, you have conceded that the universe is not necessarily ordered but could just as easily have been utterly chaotic and therefore the physical laws that define it cannot be necessary laws
No I haven't I'm simply pointing out to you that if the universe had been that way or if we had observed a universe that way, you would have said the same thing thus explaining nothing.

Mr anony: I don't know what you are on about here. God by definition is the creator of the universe. You demanded for things we can detect that will tell us that the universe had a creator, I have shown you. If you think the universe didn't have a creator, then you are welcome to explain how something can begin to exist and work according to a specific pattern and yet be uncreated.
Well, you'll have to do some work justifying your definition. Again, water would still be wet with or without your God. The universe already does that so for your explanation, look to the universe.

Mr anony: And this shows you haven't understood my argument. I didn't merely say "everything proves God". I have given you the characteristics of the universe by which we know it has a creator. Once again, if you think the universe didn't have a creator, then you are welcome to explain how something can begin to exist and work according to a specific pattern and yet be uncreated.
You haven't because the features you gave would still hold without your God so you haven't explained anything at all.

Mr anony: .....and by "chaos inbuilt the universe" you mean? Specifics please.
I mean that there are chaotic elements within the universe.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 4:40pm On Jun 04, 2013
Deep Sight: .

It does, when you say this:



It is possible that you might not be able to detect it. That is logically possible.
By we, I meant people in general. One human person would be enough to satisfy this requirement.

Deep Sight: Of course, man has logically and intuitively detected the existence of God from the dawn of time. This is why you have all the concepts of God all over the world. No body, save mad men, see the sort of extensive design of the human brain, and its functions far in excess of that which is warranted by evolution, and concludes that it is the product of un-directed mindless matter. It takes madness, to believe that.
Since we're just stamping our feet and making assertions, then I too say that it is only a mad or ignorant man in these modern times would take a look at the world and believe that it had a God behind it.

Deep Sight: The argument does not say that God is all good. It does not even say that God is benevolent. It says that God is necessary.

At all events, for anything to exist, something or the other must be self existent. I have already told you severally why matter cannot be the self existent, but you never just get the very simple reason why. Self existent things are not mutable.

That it is necessary, self-existent and living.
By necessary, I take it that you mean logically necessary. You'll need an argument for that. The rest are just assertions and misuse of words. How can God be living when it isn't at the very least made of cells? Or are you using a hidden definition of "living"?

To be clear, the conclusion of the argument was:

5. If we cannot tell that he does exist, then we cannot know about any other properties it could have.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 4:34pm On Jun 04, 2013
striktlymi: Are you sure you know what the fallacy of false dichotomy is about? If you do then you should realise that all that is needed to show this fallacy in your argument is present just one more option to the ones you already presented.
I already told you this several times and posted a reference link for you to realize this.

striktlymi: Being detectable and being not detectable? To whom?...You, me, the whole of mankind?

It can be implied from your argument that you mean the whole of creation or better still mankind.
Now why will will you make such a statement? I used your own example of it being detectable to one person as satisfying the criterion for being detectable.

striktlymi: Note that there is a huge difference between: 'being detectable' and 'being detectable to at least one person'.
No there isn't. Being detectable to at least one person is a subset of being detectable. If he is detectable to two people, he is still detectable.

striktlymi: Your second premise: 2. If he does exist, then either he interacts with the universe in a detectable manner or he doesn't.

talks about God interacting with the Universe in a detectable manner which can be interpreted that God needs to interact with the whole of creation which includes the whole human race.
As I said, it doesn't.

striktlymi: That premise does not give room for partial interaction though you have denied this despite it being obvious from your premise.
I'm not denying that, I'm saying that the idea of being half detectable and half undetectable is incoherent. If it is detectable, then it is detectable and not partially detectable.

striktlymi: The options from the premise are (a) God interacts in a detectable manner to everyone or he does not....but there are further options as I have stated before which I now have reasons to believe that you deliberately decide not to see.
I'm sorry but this is a strawman. I didn't say it had to be detectable to everyone.

striktlymi: God can decide to be detectable to just one person and not the whole of mankind.

He can decide to be detectable to more than one person but not the whole of mankind till the (n-1)th number of people on Earth.

Whether you accept or not the fallacy of false dichotomy is on you.
If he decides to be detectable to even one person only, then he is detectable and thus interacts with the universe. Frankly it looks like you don't know what you're to do to show that I've committed this fallacy. The reference link would have helped you with this hopefully better than I have.
Christianity Etc › Re: Dear Atheist, Do You Feel The Need To Be Thankful? by thehomer: 4:26pm On Jun 04, 2013
striktlymi: Question: What do you understand by being born again? Please support your answer with relevant scriptural backing.

Answer: Being born again is simply...the scriptural backings are...
Here you go.

To be born again is to undergo a "spiritual rebirth" (regeneration) of the human soul or spirit, contrasted with the physical birth everyone experiences. The origin of the term "born again" is the New Testament: "Jesus replied, 'Very truly I tell you, no one can see the kingdom of God without being born again.' It is a term associated with salvation in Christianity. Individuals who profess to be born again often state that they have a personal relationship with Jesus Christ.

Scriptural backing: [Jn 3:3 NIV]

NIV: 3 Jesus replied, “Very truly I tell you, no one can see the kingdom of God unless they are born again.[a]”

4 “How can someone be born when they are old?” Nicodemus asked. “Surely they cannot enter a second time into their mother’s womb to be born!”

5 Jesus answered, “Very truly I tell you, no one can enter the kingdom of God unless they are born of water and the Spirit. 6 Flesh gives birth to flesh, but the Spirit[b] gives birth to spirit. 7 You should not be surprised at my saying, ‘You[c] must be born again.’ 8 The wind blows wherever it pleases. You hear its sound, but you cannot tell where it comes from or where it is going. So it is with everyone born of the Spirit.”[d]

9 “How can this be?” Nicodemus asked.

. . .

16 For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life. 17 For God did not send his Son into the world to condemn the world, but to save the world through him. 18 Whoever believes in him is not condemned, but whoever does not believe stands condemned already because they have not believed in the name of God’s one and only Son. 19 This is the verdict: Light has come into the world, but people loved darkness instead of light because their deeds were evil. 20 Everyone who does evil hates the light, and will not come into the light for fear that their deeds will be exposed. 21 But whoever lives by the truth comes into the light, so that it may be seen plainly that what they have done has been done in the sight of God.
Now can you ask him to answer this same question?

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 (of 210 pages)