₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,381 members, 8,522,747 topics. Date: Saturday, 21 November 2026 at 10:04 PM

Toggle theme

Thehomer's Posts

Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 (of 210 pages)

Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 10:45am On May 29, 2013
Ihedinobi: What articles?
thehomer: I gave that short response for the discussion to have a starting point but since you want an explanation, then you're welcome to read these articles.

I hope you're also ready to have your views questioned as this discussion proceeds.

Happy reading.
Sorry that was to Mr anony but see them for clarification.

Again, how would you address your questions?
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 8:29am On May 29, 2013
Ihedinobi: Oga, "physical" has a very specific meaning, I think. Can these phenomena be fit into that meaning?
Did you read the articles I referred you to?
How would you like to explain those phenomena?
Christianity Etc › Re: In What Way Is God Good? Inviting Mr Anony And Any Intersted Party by thehomer(op): 11:19pm On May 28, 2013
Image123: do not take it as a call of duty to do the pointless. God loves you.
Well one must try when the stakes are high. Looks like God doesn't love you.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 10:55pm On May 28, 2013
Ihedinobi: So then, you mean that I am right about the phenomena being non- or meta-physical. How does it not negate your position that "everything that exists is physical"? Consider that you have just conceded the existence of things or phenomena that are not strictly physical.
They're not physical in the way that a ball is physical, they're physical in the sense that they're brought about by the interactions of physical structures.

Now how would you like to explain the presence of those phenomena?
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 10:53pm On May 28, 2013
Mr anony: Interesting. So you conveniently ignored it in order to help your quote-mining exercise along. Very interesting indeed
As I said, what you tacked on was irrelevant.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 10:52pm On May 28, 2013
Mr anony: This is just you yanking things right out of context. Carefully omitting that the person you are accusing not only owns the land but actually owns the very lives of his "victims". He created them and kept them alive and could decide to withdraw his gift of life whenever he wanted, besides he didn't have them wiped out rather he had them driven out.
All you're doing here is trying to justify genocide by saying "because God". What do you think happens to your ideas of objective moral values? If you're willing to accept that, then you're willing to accept that torturing babies for land isn't objectively wrong because if God commanded it, then it would be right since he owns the child and the land.

Mr anony: But we are arguing human morality not so? If moral principles are objective to humans but not necessary principles, wouldn't that be strong evidence that humans have a designer?
No it isn't evidence of a designer. Does the presence of the designer mean that there are objective moral values or does the presence of objective moral values mean that there is a designer?

Mr anony: Lol, I'll let this pass because I'm too lazy right now to scroll through all your posts on this forum.
And this is what you do when you know you don't have the evidence to support your claim.

Mr anony: You mean another vague answer without carefully explaining how any of them leads us to objective morals for humans instead of that of other animals
judgement - How so? if by this you mean moral judgment, then you are merely begging the question because moral judgment already presupposes morality.
science - how so?
empathy - how so? Other animals have empathy too, besides the fact that I know it will hurt a dog if I kill it does not place a moral obligation upon me to spare it
biology - how so?
Take them together. The fact that humans can judge whether or not certain actions have certain effects on others, the fact that using the tools available from science to inform human values, the fact that with empathy, we can mentally put ourselves in other people's shoes and the fact that our biology supports complex thinking these all mean that we can reasonably tell whether or not certain actions help or hinder our well-being.


Now can you tell me how the presence of your God says anything about how humans ought to behave? Recall that God's mere existence has no bearing on how humans ought to behave neither does the claim that he created humans mean that humans ought to behave in a certain way. All that would mean is that he wants humans to act in a certain way.

Mr anony: I didn't realize we were talking about the morality of the alien. We were talking about an alien observing animals on planet earth and seeing them all at every level killing each other, would it come to the conclusion that human morality was any different from dog and lion morality or that humans had any special value as moral beings?

How does your question relate to what we've been talking about?
My question is related to your idea that a God is required for objective morality. If the alien armed with its knowledge determines that it is objectively immoral for humans to commit genocide, then why do we need your God when talking about objective morality?
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 10:35pm On May 28, 2013
double post.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 10:30pm On May 28, 2013
Deep Sight: What you fail to understand is that a fallacious notion of things will deny the person being fallacious or absurd from using the legitimate logical fallacy as his defense.

In this regard alleging the fallacy of natural appeal [b]cannot avail some one who says that only physical nature exists: this is because that would mean there is nothing else for him to appeal to. Must explaining this to you be so painful?[/b]

Now because you are being so dull on this matter I will spell it out for you with a few examples. Let me randomly pick some logical fallacies and show you how they cannot avail the person adopting an absurd stance against them.

Your statement alleging an appeal to nature, must be redundant against one (a strict materialist) who insists nature is all that exists, just as surely as -

This is an example of a propositional fallacy:

Affirming the consequent
– the antecedent in an indicative conditional is claimed to be true because the consequent is true; if A, then B; B, therefore A.

If a person tells me that I am committing this fallacy, he cannot also be a person who believes that if A, then B; B, therefore A in his own argument. Such a person will not be entitled to say that I am committing a fallacy by accusing him of same, if his argument itself holds such. In the same way, the strict materialist cannot shout "wrong! appeal to nature!" when his very strict materialism stands squarely on nature and nature alone and admits nothing else to exist.

The queer illogicallity of this is further shown by the fact that an appeal to nature must be correct and acceptable, if indeed, as the strict materialist says, physical nature is all that exists.

This is why the strict materialist cannot allege an appeal to nature as a logical fallacy! His worldview MUST endorse appeals to nature as he says that physical nature IS ALL THAT EXISTS!

In fact, this is so hair-raisingly obvious that I feel like a dumb ass eediot having to explain it this many times. But that is what talking to you does to one.

Therefore I am not going to repeat myself one more time on this one: it makes me nauseous and feel like puking.
So you're seriously saying that a materialist cannot point out that someone else is making or wants them to make a fallacious appeal to nature? This has to be one of the most absurd and ridiculous ideas I've heard in a while.

Deep Sight: Oh no, this is not true, I have interacted with you for years on this forum and have abundantly expressed my views, take and reasons for the spirit. Going back to such will be like going back to argue trinity with davidylan, which I have done a zillion times. It would be st.upid, infantile, even. Nevertheless if you want my views again I am labouring over a short epistle in a thread Plaetton opened on Consciousness and I will say my all on Spirituality there, you can always read it if interested.
Well if you want us to have a discussion of morality, it has to be a two way street so I'd rather you be ready to defend the ideas you present as you question mine.

Deep Sight: You still dont get it. I am not the one willing to accept a logical fallacy. I say that the strict materialist atheist MUST accept that fallacy because he says nothing else exists. Simple.
And I've told you over and over again that they do not have to accept a logical fallacy because of your own misunderstanding.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 10:04pm On May 28, 2013
Mr anony: What other context have we been talking about? Keep dodging
You should go back and find out why you asked that question. Don't push your own misconceptions on me.

Mr anony: Out of the moral context again. Besides I never said that a perfect being has perfect choices, in fact I was arguing that because man could choose between good and evil, he could become imperfect even though he was perfectly good at the beginning. It was you who tried to suggest that a perfect being would have perfect choices. Please stop shifting your burden to me. It is either you have forgotten what you were arguing or you are just being dishonest.
I am telling you that a perfect being would only make perfect choices. Trying to argue otherwise simply means that you're implicitly saying that your perfect God could also become imperfect. So, once again, without trying to shift your burden to me, can you tell me why a perfect being would make imperfect decisions?

Mr anony: Please show how X is different from Y. Please show how God's command to kill the children of the land is different from God's command to kill the children of the land. And please don't try to shift your burden again. You are the one claiming that it is immoral and I am the one asking you on what basis it is immoral.
Once more, you're trying to run from direct questions. X is God's command, Y is what carrying out what that command entails. Do you think that it is moral or not? That is my question. You've started dancing away from answering a direct question once again.

Mr anony: We've been over this before. It is irrelevant what my opinions are, what is relevant here is what is objectively right vs what is objectively wrong and how we know this. If that is not what you are interested in, I can't help you.
Again, your double standard reveals itself. I'll just ask you the same question again. Do you think commanding a genocide for the purpose of taking people's land is moral or immoral? This appears to be the question that you cannot answer.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 9:50pm On May 28, 2013
Mr anony: Interesting.....as they say, the madman never knows that he is mad, he thinks everyone else is crazy.
Yes. It is why I find it amazing that you find clear distinctions problematic.

Mr anony: Good, now following from your materialist worldview. Here are a few questions
I hope you're also going to answer these same questions.

Mr anony: 1. Do objective moral principles exist, If yes can you describe some of them and what the laws are based on?
Yes I think they do. e.g Commanding genocide in order to take away some people's land is immoral. This is based on facts like there are ways of obtaining the use of land without committing genocide. Now, you answer this same question.

Mr anony: 2. Why should people act a certain way and not another? for instance, do you think child po[color=#000000]rnogra[/color]phy is objectively morally wrong? Mind you, there is no physical contact between the child and the watcher, also the child need not know he/she is being filmed.
Sure child pornography is immoral for various reasons like the fact that child cannot consent to being used in that way. After all, the person viewing this pornography has other options like choosing adults who have consented. Now, you answer that same question.

Mr anony: 3. If child por[color=#000000]nogr[/color]aphy is morally wrong, on what basis is it morally wrong? If it is right, on what basis is it right?
It is wrong on the bases I've written above. Now you answer the same question.

Mr anony: 4. Do humans have an intrinsic value or is it merely the opinion of humans that they are valuable.
Both.

Mr anony: 5. From a materialist point of view, does life have a meaning/purpose? if yes, what is it and how do you know? If no, why should one live objectively according to any particular manner if life has no purpose
What do you mean by "life" and "meaning" here? Maybe after you've answered this question including what you mean by those words, I'll be able to better answer your question.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 9:34pm On May 28, 2013
Ihedinobi: @bolded: I presume you mean non-physical phenomena, am I right? If I am, would that not negate the position that "everything that exists is physical? If I am not, what kind of phenomena did you feel the need to alert me to?
No it won't. I'm referring to phenomena like consciousness, intelligence and their likes.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 9:20pm On May 28, 2013
Mr anony: And you very conveniently missed this:
I didn't miss it, what you tacked on was simply irrelevant to the idea of well-being. Or do you once again wish to use some mystical notion of well-being?
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 7:21pm On May 28, 2013
Mr anony: If morality is based on his purpose, then he cannot be giving them immoral commands.
Then you have implicitly accepted that genocide for the purpose of taking people's lands is not immoral.

Mr anony: You are confusing objective with necessary. For instance, the way your PC works is the objective way for the PC to compute but it is not necessarily how it should work. The designer has given them objective principles which they should work by and when they don't, we can say the computer is malfunctioning even if it is still computing. Compare this to humans; For instance r[color=#000000]api[/color]ng women for fun is objectively worse (in a moral sense) than not r[color=#000000]api[/color]ng for fun but is not necessarily worse. We could have easily been designed to rape for fun and pursue it as what we ought to do.
This is you just getting confused on the use of objectivity. The point of view of the "designer" isn't objective, it is his point of view. Necessity is something else entirely. Necessity implies that it cannot be any other way.

Mr anony: 2. Good so if humans are animals according to you. why ought they behave differently. For instance why should men not rape women for fun? dogs do this all the time.
See the end of my response yet again.

Mr anony: 3. Are you saying we can accept things on blind faith?
No, I'm asking you for a link to where I made the claim you're attributing to me.

Mr anony: Urhm no you haven't answered. link me to where you clearly answered it
Asked and answered.

thehomer: As I said before, judgement, science, empathy, biology and other such features.
Now can you tell me why God's views are objective but not the alien's?
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 7:11pm On May 28, 2013
Mr anony: How so? You said we're are capable of complex thoughts and I asked you what you meant by complex in the context of morality. . . .where did I get you wrong?
What you're getting wrong right now is that you didn't ask the question you've asked now. Go and look through your posts. Secondly, when I was talking about complex thoughts, I didn't say "in the context of morality".

Mr anony: Interesting. Please give me an example of a situation where one has multiple choices concerning a matter that are all different and yet all equally perfect.
By your reasoning, your God had the choices of creating the universe and not creating the universe. Both of them should have either been equally perfect. Try not to shift your own burden to me.

Mr anony: This tells me nothing about the basis by which you condemn the action. "I am judging X immoral because it is X" tells us nothing about the laws by which you judged it
That isn't what I've said either. I said I'm judging X immoral because it requires Y. If you think Y isn't actually immoral, you're welcome to say so.

Mr anony: And I have asked you to tell me the basis by which you define right and wrong. Until you can do that, we can't know what is truly right and what is truly wrong. My answer therefore will be irrelevant to you.
And your evasions begin once more. I've asked you to tell me by your own standards whatever they may be whether or not commanding a genocide for the purpose of taking other people's land is right or wrong. It doesn't even require me to say anything despite the fact of what I've told you about the relevance of human well-being at the very least. Just say whether or not commanding genocide for the purpose of taking other people's land is right or wrong.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 6:56pm On May 28, 2013
Mr anony: @bold. I didn't know you believed human well-being was dependent on living to the glory of God. . .or were you just misrepresenting me again?
I'm sorry but this is just dishonest. This is what you said on that thread.

Mr anony: Objective good is dependent on an objective human well-being (i.e. the way a human ought to be). We can only legitimately say that there is way humans are supposed to be if there is a designer who has purposely designed humans to be a certain way.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 6:47pm On May 28, 2013
Mr anony: It is these sorts of vacuous statements I don't like. You really have told us nothing about what you mean when you say something is physical and how we can differentiate it from non-physical things.

You might as well have said: "To put it simply, it is that everything that exists is spiritual. Note that this doesn't mean that certain phenomena don't emerge out of the spiritual"

All you have done is put everything under your "physical" umbrella while being careful to leave the door open for yourself in case there are "certain phenomena" that may not be considered physical. So please explain your worldview properly and stop hiding behind shadows

to quote one of your comments again (ironically this was you accusing me of your crimes):
That accusation was apt because as I'm sure you saw, you weren't answering the simple question I was asking. In fact on another thread, your inability to respond dragged on for multiple pages.

There's no irony there because unlike yourself, I didn't refrain from presenting my view, neither did I present something irrelevant.

Mr anony: So once again;

[size=17pt]@thehomer, why don't you explain what your own brand of materialism is so that we'll understand what it is you're trying to say?[/size]
I gave that short response for the discussion to have a starting point but since you want an explanation, then you're welcome to read these articles.

I hope you're also ready to have your views questioned as this discussion proceeds.

Happy reading.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 5:47pm On May 28, 2013
Deep Sight: And I have said that that fallacy does not apply to the view point of a strict materialist. It cannot, because a strict materialist by definition hold material nature to be all that exists. I dont know whether you dont know what a strict materialist is, or you are just looking the other way when cornered.
Fallacies apply to anyone trying to use reason. If the reasoning is erroneous, then there's some problem with it. Fallacies are generally the ways that reasoning have been known to go wrong.

Deep Sight: Son, you're really being lazy in this thread. I never even used the idea of Karma for any of my arguments in this thread. You asked my opinion on morality and in explaining it I also mentioned Karmaic laws, which work at the level of the spirit. I specifically recall saying I cannot discuss this with you since you reject the existence of the spirit. I however, can discuss nature and matter with you because we both accept the existence of nature and matter.
Punk you're definitely being lazy on this thread. Even worse, you're denying your own words that are still available on this thread. What was the point of your mentioning these "karmic laws" if not as some reason for morality? The worst thing here is that you now try to insulate these preposterous ideas from scrutiny by saying you cannot discuss them because I haven't swallowed your unexplained notion of the spirit. You see, if we can discuss nature and matter because we both accept their existence, then surely you should be ready to discuss this new field you're introducing. If your arguments are good, who knows? You may be able to convince me or someone else.

The claim that someone else won't accept something so you won't bother explaining it is based on either your hubris or your fear that there really is nothing to that idea. The lay person would find it difficult to understand black-holes, quantum mechanics and cosmic evolution. Yet the experts take the time to explain these things but Mr Deep Sight can't be bothered to explain to us his notions of karma and the spirit because we don't accept them already. Ignoring the fact that the features I mentioned weren't accepted some time ago but became accepted with evidence and explanation.

Deep Sight: I have more than abundantly canvassed and expatiated on my view that the strict materialist cannot have a quarrel with that which is standard fare in material nature as it also demonstrably occurs to humans - who are part of material nature. Your views, on the other hand, have been wild contradictions of these basic facts.
No, all you have done is to say that with your sloppy thinking, you're willing to accept a logical fallacy therefore I should make one for you to say you accept. I've tried hard to avoid such poor thinking and your encouragement for me to start thinking poorly won't make me start now.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 5:31pm On May 28, 2013
Ihedinobi: It's amusing how someone confuses himself so deliberately in the hopes of spreading his confusion on everyone else.

@thehomer, why don't you explain what your own brand of materialism is so that we'll understand what it is you're trying to say? Because I'm curious to see how it allows you to be more than physical, ie, meta-physical.
To put it simply, it is that everything that exists is physical. Note that this doesn't mean that certain phenomena don't emerge out of the physical.

Now, what are you trying to say? I hope that you'll also be willing to let us examine your views.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 5:08pm On May 28, 2013
Deep Sight: ^^^ Obviously its too hard for you to take on the specific points made and deconstruct them. I will not respond to side jibes and non-starters. The points are there, if you are able, look them squarely in the eye and explain why they are wrong. Simple. All these one line escapist remarks that have nothing to do with how to bed a unicorn style chic are just boring.
I've already done that. What specific point of yours do you think I didn't address?

Sure don't respond to the side jabs, only make them to please yourself.

When pithy responses knock you down, just claim they're boring. That appears to be your preferred tactic.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 4:53pm On May 28, 2013
Deep Sight: Your issues on consciousness will be better addressed on that thread. I am writing an epistle for it, and it would not be efficient to repeat myself.

But just as a little teaser, do your body parts form voltron or do they work for voltron?
Hmm. I wonder what answer you want to give to this.

Deep Sight: O dear, o dear. I am really surprised that you fellows do not see the dilemma of someone who says that only physical nature exists and yet seeks to locate his morality on something else?
It now appears that you're getting confused of what my position as a materialist is.

Deep Sight: Don't make me laugh, lol, none of you have shown a single thing whatsoever on this thread.

If physical nature is all that exists, it must perforce be the reference point for morality, simple. How anyone can ask for an explanation of that, just beats me.
Deep Sight has shown it all it seems. This looks like more of your confusion. Let me help you with a question.

Do you think materialists accept that consciousness, justice and judgement are available?

Deep Sight: It is like agreeing that every cake in the world is made of flour and yet insisting that you have a cake that's made of something else.

Thus, saying that everything that exists is physical nature, but then saying that you have something that is NOT physical nature!

How is this a logical fallacy, as thehomer lazily claims? Res ipsa loquitor! The thing speaks for itself!
It is nothing like your poor analogies above. In fact, the analogies you've given above are more consonant with theists who believe in some God with a mind or a personal God.

The fact that e.g animals kill and eat their mates after copulating therefore someone who is a materialist should think that humans doing the same is just fine, commits the fallacious appeal to nature because there is no reason to think that just because something occurs in nature, therefore it is good.

Deep Sight: That is the meaning of strict materialism. That everything is physical matter, and we and all living things are, and derive from the interplay of physical matter alone. In the first place one wonders why things that derive from mindless interactions of matter need to have any moral compunctions at all. In the second, and more relevant case, one wonders why the strict materialist would then seek to dissociate himself from the territorial and predatory inter working evident in ALL of nature?
Now you're wondering why humans have moral compunctions? I've still not seen you explain why humans cannot dissociate themselves from the rest of nature with respect to issues like morality. They've already done that with respect to issues like sex and reproduction, nutrition, motion, intelligence and many other features. Why not morality?

Deep Sight: In other words, he is trying to stand aside from and dissociate himself from something that he says is the only thing that exists and is ALL that exists!

Beat that man!

Its an absurd, absurd absurd stance.

In fact, I will go so far as to say that there is NOBODY on this planet that lives his life with this stance in mind. Nobody whatsoever. There are only baby atheists with poorly thought out views who claim that they are strict materialists. No human being can actually be one - for that would entail denying his very thoughts, which are not physical things. His very emotions, which are not physical things. His very ideas and conceptions, which are not physical things. His imaginations and fantasies, which aren't physical things.
Ooh. Obviously we have adult theists with well thought out views who claim that karma and spirits are their guiding concepts in morality. But when they're probed, they start running and dodging.

You, my friend, are just confused and seem unable to make your way out of that confusion.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 4:31pm On May 28, 2013
Deep Sight: Logical fallacy? Are you kidding me? This can never be a logical fallacy for a strict materialist who beleives that everything that exists is physical and all things derive from nature. He has nowhere else to derive his morality from bur from said nature. So the strict materialist cannot do a double-flip on this. I will not let you play word games on this one: this point is cast in iron and adamantine.
If something is a logical fallacy, then whether one is a materialist or anything else, it simply is a fallacy. You are just asserting that I must agree to commit this logical fallacy maybe because you'll look the other way but I don't work that way. I think you really need to take a look at the fallacy of making an appeal to nature when it comes to morality.

Deep Sight: And I did not discuss anything to do with Karma with you by the way. You asked a question, I gave my reason, and specifically said I was aware it means nothing to you.
I demonstrated two things to you.

1, Your reason wasn't a reason at all and
2, you were misusing the idea of karma with regards to morality.

It appears that due to your discomfort in trying to defend your view, you're trying to simply ignore my requests for you to provide your explanations.
Christianity Etc › Re: Ghanaian Pastor Want A Contest With Nigeria Pastor by thehomer: 11:06am On May 28, 2013
Hmm sub-Saharan Africans.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 8:33am On May 28, 2013
Deep Sight: ^^^ Stop making hopeless one-liners that are utterly illogical, side-stepping the points made: a strict materialist can never be seen to argue that something is a fallacy from nature. That is an inescapable contradiction. Period.
This is quite illogical and laughable. You're asking me to accept a logical fallacy simply because you think I should?

Is this your attempt at escaping the fact that karma doesn't help you?
Christianity Etc › Re: In What Way Is God Good? Inviting Mr Anony And Any Intersted Party by thehomer(op): 8:30am On May 28, 2013
Image123: hahaha, good of you. You made me laugh, that's new. One, God is not a man.Two, you are not His judge, but rather He is yours. You are the criminal while He is your Judge and Owner as it were. Three, God is kind and good to those who believe like your person is kind to his wife. Therefore it is fruitless and shallow of you to try to show those who believe anything.
Sure God is not a man, he is made up. I am perfectly able to judge him. He is a criminal entity. He is not kind and good even to those who believe in him. Otherwise they won't suffer at all. Besides if he only likes those who believe in him, then why should anyone bother with him? In what way is he worthy of being God? It is pointless to show you the evils of your God.
Christianity Etc › Re: In What Way Is God Good? Inviting Mr Anony And Any Intersted Party by thehomer(op): 11:03pm On May 27, 2013
Image123: Thanks for your great concern, though it always seems youbelieve the "evil" more than the good. We who believe in God are more sensible to observe the overwhelming good and make reasonable conclusion that God is good and His mercies endure forever.
I judge his character by the evil that he has been capable of. Just as I would point out that a person who kills children to take their parent's lands even if that person is kind to his wife, I would still say that such a person has an evil character.
Christianity Etc › Re: In What Way Is God Good? Inviting Mr Anony And Any Intersted Party by thehomer(op): 9:14pm On May 27, 2013
Image123: Oh, but you take His recorded 'evil' as factual?
I'm just showing those who believe in that God based on information from that book that their ideas about that God being good is misinformed. So, if they take the information recorded in that book as factual, I'll just use it to show them the problems with that line of thought.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 7:25pm On May 27, 2013
Deep Sight: Please do not venture into absurdity if you intend to keep the conversation a serious one. Being humans ourselves we know the perceptions, desires and needs of humans. You are not a Lion and thus do not necessarily know what a lion's notions are. You may observe him, but you are not inside his mind.
You're there already. Despite the fact that you're human, you don't assign moral responsibility to children who are also human but you start to assign one to them as they grow older. What I've been pointing out to you is that lions don't have notions of morality.

Deep Sight: I brought this up because you brought up an answer saying that if an alien knew what was within the minds of humans, he would know that for humans, this or that is wrong. This is the same way that if humans knew what was in the mind of Lions, we would know that for lions, this or that is wrong - and that they therefore have their own moral compass.

Please let us not be distracted by this, it is a side-point anyway.
Not if it knew what was within the minds of humans, but if it had certain information about humans in contrast to having that information about other animals.

Deep Sight: Why should he have known? It is in order surely, for him to give them commands suited to their stage of evolution, no? Would you hold homo erectus to the same moral standards of homo sapiens? If you insist that morality evolves with creatures, and man evolved from lower creatures, then it would make perfect sense to expect that there would be an appropriate state of nature he dwells in at every stage of his evolution. It would thus make sense to say that ancient men were at that stage of their evolution and as such everything they did was only natural. In this context it cannot be deemed wrong. Furthermore, their God would know that it was appropriate for them at that stage.

This is the right and proper reasoning and logic that should follow from your contentions.
He should have known because he is a good and omniscient being who cares about humans. Just so you know, the humans who wrote the Bible were the same species as you.

Deep Sight: A strict materialist CANNOT say this! For a strict materialist, everything springs from nature and the physical environment! As such, it should be perfectly sensible to look to nature and appeal to nature in all things, for the strict materialist.

If all things spring from nature, and you say that a given thing is perfectly natural, you would be contradicting yourself to say that such a thing is wrong or evil.
And this is why what you're saying is a fallacy. For some reason, you seem to thin that if you cannot see it as a fallacy, others shouldn't be able to see it as such.

Deep Sight: Because I see man as a spiritual being living in a spiritual environment with attendant spiritual laws such as Karma. However I will not go into this with you as you do not believe any of that. As such, all I can do is show you that your own perspective on the matter is contradictory.
Actually, you have to go into it to fully explain your point of view because it is looking pretty incoherent. Whether or not I believe it shouldn't stop you from showing if what you're saying is coherent. If the best you can do is just sticking to criticizing what I'm saying based on your fallacious notions, then you have to realize that you've not made your argument for your point of view.

Besides, karma is the magical idea that people get what they deserve not that people committing evil acts is wrong. Secondly, you'll have to say what you think spirituality is. Is it something that humans have like sight? Or is it something that is out there in the environment like a molecule?

Deep Sight: You cannot tell that it is not good for humans: a simple argument for example may be made that wars and such other fatal competitions must have been necessary to hone the skills of early men into being fit, ruthless and brutal enough to rule the earth as against its many other living dangers and predators. It would fit perfectly into the development of man as seen from a historical perspective and therefore would not be wrong.
Actually, I can tell that it is not good for humans and you can too. Unless you think that commanding a certain man to go out and kill 20 children is somehow good for those children, then frankly you don't know what you're talking about and I don't know what you're trying to get at.

Deep Sight: Just as surely as the Greeks would never have had the rigor and discipline to defeat Persia if they had not fought a lot among themselves already and mastered a military culture therefore.
The Greeks weren't being lead by an omniscient deity were they?
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 12:43pm On May 27, 2013
Deep Sight: Children are the same creatures that we are: being of our species and as such we can communicate with them. A lion has never explained to you why he does what he does and just how it feels, he?
So a 6 month old child has communicated to you why it peed in your face while you were trying to help?

Deep Sight: It would seem so from your very contradictory point of view.
Then show me the contradiction.

Deep Sight: And morality with it?

With this you have hammered yourself.

If indeed these "forms of expression" take "different turns" then you have no place condemning the genocides of the bible: these would simply be predatory territorial animals doing what comes naturally to them, at a time in history when further common grounds of morality had yet to evolve.
Is that your main confusion? My response is that it was still immoral and generally Christians would agree but they're often blinded with their God glasses. Those people just didn't know it. Now the problem Christians face is that their God should have known and have given better commands.

Deep Sight: It is false to say that you have answered any of my questions. You have answered almost none.



Going by your definition of man as merely a smarter animal, it is very very right and natural and proper to be engaged in genocides against groups whose resources you seek to control.
And this is just your own misunderstanding. In fact, what you're doing above is an appeal to nature which is fallacious. The fact that those actions are natural doesn't make them moral.

Deep Sight: Going by my definition of man as a spirit being, it is very wrong and immoral.
Now why is it very wrong and immoral?

Deep Sight: And as for the issuer of the command, you do not know what his moral compass is, do you - just as animals do not know ours, do they?
Whatever his moral compass is, it isn't good for humans at the very least. And that is the other arm of my argument against religious folks reading this.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 12:13pm On May 27, 2013
Deep Sight: And yet curiously without being in the heads of other predatory territorial animals, you are able to pronounce conclusively that they do not have the properties to make moral choice or judgments, notwithstanding that you see them carrying out the same acts of predatory aggression that humans have always carried out, and protecting their families as humans do.
Without being in the heads of children, we're able to pronounce conclusively that they do not have the properties to make moral judgements. Have you ever wondered why?

Deep Sight: You sir, have been a wild maze of preposterous contradictions in this thread.
But you have just been a wild maze of astounding confusion in this thread.

Deep Sight: Most cardinally, you have failed to show, and of course you cannot show just why greater intelligence should stop a predatory territorial animal from being predatory and territorial in greater and better ways.
You do realize that the form of expression of territorial and behaviour has taken a different turn.

I've answered so many of your questions that I think it is time for you to try some of mine.

Is it right to command a genocide for the purpose of taking other people's land? If yes, why? If no, why not?
Christianity Etc › Re: The Basis Of Human Morality by thehomer: 12:04pm On May 27, 2013
Kay 17: Mr anony's arguments for objective based morality amazes me more and more. He claims there is objective morality, he claims such objective morality is impossible without God. No God No morality, yet morality is objective.
You ain't seen nothin' yet.

He actually agrees with me that good is dependent on human well-being. But for some reason, we still need some God to tell us what is beneficial to humans given what we've managed to find out about ourselves.

A philosopher said that the ideas of objectivity and subjectivity can be confusing to people. It looks like Mr anony has been confused by these ideas.
Christianity Etc › Re: In What Way Is God Good? Inviting Mr Anony And Any Intersted Party by thehomer(op): 10:09am On May 27, 2013
Image123: Do you take God's recorded goodness as factual?
I don't take God as factual.
Christianity Etc › Re: In What Way Is God Good? Inviting Mr Anony And Any Intersted Party by thehomer(op): 10:09am On May 27, 2013
dexmond: Being the creator and owner of the world, he he reserves the right to send them wherever it pleases Him.

Are you judging the Almighty God? The innocent children will surely be accepted into heaven because they know no sin.
Then you should take a look at this thread and let me know what you think about the argument.

dexmond: He God is still good seeing that he saved the innocent children. It should come as a surprise to you that Israel was punished when they did the very same thing that led God to take those land and give them to Israel. At a time they began worshipping Idols and engaging in the same practise of the people of that Land which led God to punish them by other Nations too. Is God not Just? You, thehomer will also account for all your actions after you die, in fighting the Lord Jesus and his Church. I pray that the Lord opens your eyes.
He didn't save them, he killed them. My question is simply this. Based on what we've seen God command, how do we know that he is good?

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 (of 210 pages)