₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,380 members, 8,522,744 topics. Date: Saturday, 21 November 2026 at 09:55 PM

Toggle theme

Thehomer's Posts

Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 (of 210 pages)

Islam › Re: Dr. Zakir Naik In Nigeria From 8th June by thehomer: 12:18am On Jun 08, 2013
tbaba1234: It is intellectual laziness to even suggest that he supports terrorism given the fact that he has a whole video on terrorism on youtube. Within a few minutes, you would have educated yourself on his true position. I have watched the video and there is nothing that supports acts of terror against civilians.
It is intellectual dishonesty to suggest that he doesn't support terrorism given the fact that his very own words on terrorism say otherwise. You should have taken a few minutes to educate yourself on his true position. Maybe you should then try to watch this video.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bxk5AAA5FbI

tbaba1234: Unfortunately, many people are too lazy to actually investigate. It is disgusting the way people take quotes just to fulfill an agenda. I do not always agree with Dr zakir naik but i know his position on issues are far from extreme.
Unfortunately, many people are too lazy to actually investigate but simply support blindly because they happen to be of similar religious views. The only way his position is far from the extreme is that he doesn't go out and kill or oppress people, he simply gives others the justification to do so.
Islam › Re: Dr. Zakir Naik In Nigeria From 8th June by thehomer: 12:04am On Jun 08, 2013
lanrexlan: You are just misquoting the man.

He said ''I haven't meet osama bin laden in person,so I don't know much about him.If he's terrorizing the terrorists,I am with him but If he's terrorizing innocent human,that's against islam.Making allegations without proofs is wrong''.What's wrong with his statementhuh?
What is wrong with it is that it is dishonest. You don't have to meet someone to know what they've said. You can listen to the interviews they've given, their speeches and what they themselves have said were their aims, methods and goals.

lanrexlan: You are free to leave Islam but If you leave Islam and then propagate false and bad allegations against Islam,then the sharia law comes in.
Why should sharia law come in when one is no longer a Muslim? In fact why should sharia law be a law that reasonable and free people should subscribe to? An unjust law should be discarded.

lanrexlan: Liar,in his hometown there are over 600,000 hindus and they are propagating their religion,there's no compulsion in religion.Forcing people to Islam is forbidden in Islam.He will benefit Nigeria.....Peace
You forgot to mention that his hometown is in India. If his hometown were in Saudi Arabia, do you think he would be in support of those same Hindus propagating their religion? I didn't say he was forcing people into Islam, I said he was in support of killing people for being homosexual and against the free expression of religions except his own. Those two statements are true.
Islam › Re: Dr. Zakir Naik In Nigeria From 8th June by thehomer: 8:10pm On Jun 07, 2013
mazaje: The man also supports that ONLY islam be propagated he also says that Non-Muslims should not have equal Human rights to propagate their religions in islamic societies. . .He says islm is the only true religion and he does not allow the propagation of any other religion. . .He is against other reigions building their temples in muslim lands but supports the building of mumslim temples in the lands of the infidels. . .The guy is a bigot. . .


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6jYUL7eBdHg
Oh yeah even worse, he's said he supports terrorism as a method of getting one's political views across. These are the worst types of religious people. The ones who are so sure that they're right that they think their ideologies are more equal than others. And he is being let into Nigeria. A country being wracked with terrorism from people who believe as he does. He'll simply help those murderers justify their actions using their holy books and magic prophets.
Christianity Etc › Re: Dear Atheist, Do You Feel The Need To Be Thankful? by thehomer: 8:04pm On Jun 07, 2013
Mr anony: I wouldn't call that sin. It is an unconscious thought in the same way it is not a sin at all if someone shot me in the head while sleepwalking because it is an unconscious action.
Sure you won't call it a sin but then, you're not the judge.

Mr anony: True but the point is that we sin in order to gratify the flesh. Without the flesh, it is impossible to sin. For instance a person steals, fornicates, is greedy, is selfish, is a drunkard e.t.c. because he wants to gratify the flesh.
Yes that is the idea you're operating under but for what reason does the devil sin? For what reason do the demons sin? They don't have any flesh to satisfy either.

Mr anony: When the rapture happens, the flesh will be discarded and replaced with a new Spiritual body which the Lord will give to us. Now not only will our desire be to serve God, we will also no longer have any flesh to gratify. For instance:
How can one be greedy or steal or cheat in heaven when not only does he not have the desire, God's resources are truly limitless?
How can one kill or maim anyone when we have life eternal and there is no desire to do so?
How can one lust carnally in heaven when not only do we not have the desire, the body that would have derived pleasure from such has been discarded?

Sorry thehomer, I can't see whatever it is you are seeing.
You're still missing the point. Can Mr. Dahmer who remembers how he lived on earth say you know what God, I'm here in heaven now and although I feel like worshiping you (I'm granting your idea that his desires themselves have been magically transformed not that I actually accept it), I will not be worshiping you. I would be out on the banks of the river looking at unicorns and beautiful women.
Christianity Etc › Re: Dear Atheist, Do You Feel The Need To Be Thankful? by thehomer: 7:19pm On Jun 07, 2013
Mr anony: Lol, nice try. You and I know that there is an obvious difference between a thought flashing into a person's mind and a person consciously engaging in a thought. You cannot be punished for a sin that was not consciously commited. That's the point of having free-will and being accountable for it.
So the lustful thought just flashing through one's mind or the covetous thought just flashing through one's mind is okay.

Mr anony: How did you arrive a this conclusion? Remember that not only is the desire changed, the object of the desire as well as the cause of the desire (i.e. the flesh) also don't exist anymore.
I arrived at it on the basis that the person remembers how they were on earth. Even if the desire has changed, if the person has free-will, then the person can still choose to do something that isn't consonant with their desire. They may not like it but they can still choose to do it.
Christianity Etc › Re: About Abortion. by thehomer: 6:59pm On Jun 07, 2013
OLAADEGBU: Adoption is a viable option then.
Of course. But then it requires a certain type of social support and of course as I've said, before the age of viability, the mother is free to do whatever she wants.
Christianity Etc › Re: Thehomer Please Say by thehomer: 6:57pm On Jun 07, 2013
Deep Sight: Can you please let us know of any right or good arguments (in favour of the existence of God) that theists (on this forum and elsewhere) have ever made to you?

If there are none, please say so.

Thank you.

Oya.
Looks like you have a real hard-on for me and I don't know why.

I haven't encountered any right or good arguments in favour of the existence of their Gods. Do you have any? I'm willing to hear your best three.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 6:51pm On Jun 07, 2013
Deep Sight: No one has to demonstrate this. It is like asking people to demonstrate that the sun exists. It is self evident. In Latin -Res ipsa loquitor. The thing speaks for itself.
So much ignorance. So people shouldn't demonstrate their claims? People shouldn't show when questioned whether or not they've been lying? What is wrong with you? Do you practice jungle law or is it law as the inquisitors used to practice?

Deep Sight: EVERYONE, sees how dumbfoundingly THICK you are.

By the by, I opened thread to ask if u have ever heard a good theistic argument. Did you see it or just ignore it? Your choice.
Still with the childish insults I see. I'm sending you to bed. No supper for you tonight. Tomorrow, I'll wash your mouth out with soap.
Christianity Etc › Re: About Abortion. by thehomer: 6:46pm On Jun 07, 2013
OLAADEGBU: I only responded to Kay 17 who asked why the woman is not obliged to carry the pregnancy.
Yes you did. But as I pointed out, the options you gave other than adoption aren't possible at least for now.
Christianity Etc › Re: About Abortion. by thehomer: 6:44pm On Jun 07, 2013
OLAADEGBU: Those who kill babies at will should face the music as the doctor in the OP will.
How about the doctors in the article I posted?
Christianity Etc › Re: Does This Man Have Supernatural Powers? by thehomer: 6:40pm On Jun 07, 2013
An interesting documentary and an interesting way of promoting skepticism but I wonder if it will be enough to counter what the charlatans are out there doing. Without more background knowledge and education, the charlatan would simply have to use tricks different from what they were shown but hopefully, the mindset of initial skepticism towards such claims will blossom.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 11:57pm On Jun 06, 2013
Image123: Going by experience on this thread and others, you have the defect of not being able to recognize one when shown.
This is another slanderous claim that you'll have to demonstrate. Do you have evidence for this claim and the previous one? If you do, please present it.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 11:37pm On Jun 06, 2013
Image123: i did not lie against you. i also thank God that there are other readers that see your fallacies oh king. You may keep living in denial as an unbelievaber.
If you weren't lying against me, then surely you should be able to show me these fallacies. So, where are they?
Christianity Etc › Re: About Abortion. by thehomer: 9:19pm On Jun 06, 2013
OLAADEGBU: As soon as she realises that she is carrying another human being. The option of surrogacy, test tube and adoption is also available.
This is ridiculous. A pregnant woman has the option of surrogacy for the child she's already carrying? The can chuck that baby into a test tube? You're one strange guy I must say.
Christianity Etc › Re: About Abortion. by thehomer: 9:18pm On Jun 06, 2013
OLAADEGBU: What did you think they were saying?
Oh I know what they were saying. I'm wondering whether or not you agree that a doctor can perform abortions at will because that is what your acceptance would amount to.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 9:11pm On Jun 06, 2013
Image123: Bros, there are more gainful things that can be done, sorry.
Maybe there are but don't you think that as a Christian, you shouldn't be bearing false witness? What you've said amounts to lying against me. The way for you to show that you're not lying is for you to back up your slander with evidence.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 9:06pm On Jun 06, 2013
Mr anony: Read this 4 times. It still doesn't make sense.
Let me make things more explicit then. The speed of light in a vacuum is a constant approximately 3E6 m/s. This doesn't change even when the speed of a photon changes to 6 m/s. Basically, a constant doesn't change. You on the other hand, seem to think it can so, is your own idea of chaos physically possible?

Mr anony: Good then we are both agreed that none of your chaos examples violates the physical laws by which the universe is defined. The only problem is our inability to measure them precisely.
I never said it did. What I said was that the universe had chaos (the conception I presented) inbuilt into it.

Mr anony: You have expressly claimed ignorance of whether or not the universe exists necessarily hence there is no need to show you previous places where you conceded it didn't exist necessarily.
You do because you claimed that I made a concession. If I made this concession, you should show it otherwise one can conclude that you were lying against me.

Mr anony: Asked and answered here
And you have once again shown that you don't understand the difference between a logical possibility and a physical possibility. Saying that since it is logically possible therefore it is physically possible means you have no idea of what you're talking about. Please examine those concepts again.

Mr anony: ....uhm no you miss the point. Nairaland represents the universe in the analogy and the submit button represents the moon. Now please go and read it again
Nairaland cannot represent the universe because it relies on other tools itself. That is why your analogy is not accurate.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 5:21pm On Jun 06, 2013
Image123: 1 Timothy 6:16 Who only hath immortality, dwelling in the light which no man can approach unto; whom no man hath seen, nor can see: to whom be honour and power everlasting. Amen.

BTW, never have i read or met a more fallacious fellow than thehomer. Its like an infection.
But for some reason, you find it difficult to actually show me the fallacious error I made. Try to back up your assertion and show me the fallacy.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 5:18pm On Jun 06, 2013
Deep Sight: You of course must be very very slow not to have realized a long time ago that it is nothing but ediocy not to agree with me. Agreeing with me is very smart: disagreeing is ediocy, becuase I am always right. Now, I am not being sarcastic: I mean it: I am always right. Disagree at peril of your own ediocy.

Thehomer and anyone else, including yourself sire, who believes that mindless matter purposelessly assembled human beings over time, is a prize winning eddiot and certainly no better than a goat or rooster in terms of brains or perception.
Tut tut tut.
Still with the tantrums I see. Why don't you ragequit like you normally do?
Well, no cake for you. You're excused from the adult table.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 5:12pm On Jun 06, 2013
Mr anony: interesting, I can also say that however unlikely a DNA code is, it is still less likely without the initial presence of an intelligent being and therefore the presence of an intelligent being is more likely than the presences of the DNA code.
Huh? What do you mean?

Mr anony: Notice that you have not told us anything about why one code is more likely or less likely than the other
Remember that I said DNA was a molecule that can be represented as a code. From that and the chain rule in probability theory, if computer code needs to be created by sapient creatures, then the probability that we have computer code must be less than the probability that those sapient creatures exist.

Mr anony: Constituent parts all assembled and working according to a set of specific pattern such that we can accurately predict exactly how it ought to function.

Or to use your criteria: parts assembled so that it works in such a way that it achieves a certain end

btw: I can also say tweaking a computer code is merely changing a bunch of alphabets and numbers it doesn't change anything about the software being designed
How on earth can you not see this? Computer code is actually code. DNA is actually a molecule that can be represented as code.

Mr anony: The question to you is do you think it was designed? You are not under any obligation to say who
This is a separate question but no I don't think it was designed. My point is that with your very first response, you indicated that it was God that you had in mind. If this line of inquiry isn't supposed to lead to your God, then please say so.

Mr anony: Read again exactly what I highlighted and what I said about what it
I did that before and pointed out that you highlighted the tail end of my response and the beginning part of your own conception. You were quote-mining yourself and didn't realize it.

Mr anony: I remember specifically saying that I didn't know enough about them to say if they were designed or not i.e. I don't know their constituent parts and how they work properly enough to make the call. If you gave me more information about them, then I'll be in a better position to tell you if they are designed or not. There is no contradiction there
I know you specifically said that and with your answers to those questions. What you said amounts to saying you didn't know what a neutron star was but that (your own conception again): it's constituent parts all work according to a set of specific instructions such that we can accurately predict exactly how it ought to function therefore it is designed.

My point is that if you do not know enough about it, then you cannot make that conclusion.

The contradiction is that you claimed that since God specified the laws and what not and the moon was designed, then God designed the moon. But you turn around and say that other objects like water and the electron weren't designed yet they too came about by those same laws. That my friend is a contradiction. If you say God through the laws designed some things, it follows that he designed it all.

Mr anony: ....and yes a vacuum is not designed neither is it an object. It is nothing.
Hmm. This is interesting. A vacuum is nothing? Yet it came about by the very same laws you attributed to God and credited with making the moon.

But hey, since you say a vacuum is actually nothing, that's all well and good. Just remember that you said it here.

Mr anony: Go back and read it again. Pay close attention to the part I highlighted in red
The part you highlighted in red was a part of my own statement and a quote you mined from your own conception. And I've read it now please actually show that I have committed any of the fallacies you've accused me of. Notice that each time is point out that you committed a logical fallacy, I actually show you the error in your line of reasoning.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 4:44pm On Jun 06, 2013
Mr anony: I remember pointing out to you that particles change speed all the time and asking you why you seem to be convinced that a photon can't.
The fact that a photon's speed can change doesn't mean that the constant known as the speed of light can. In fact, the speed of light changes within various media this still doesn't mean the speed of light isn't a constant.

Mr anony: This is also from the article:

This tells me that the key issue here is precision which is basically what I said.
What you just pointed out isn't contradictory to what I showed you from the same article. In fact, what I showed you from that article was much clearer.

Mr anony: i don't see the need since you have now claimed ignorance.
What did I claim ignorance of? And how would that prevent you from demonstrating my concession?

Mr anony: Lol, no that is not what I am arguing at all. What I'm arguing is that
If (1) the universe necessarily exists the way it does then there is no need to say that God did it that way.
If (2) the universe does not necessarily exist the way it does, then it can be said that God did it that way.
Okay. Now that the confusion has been clarified, how do you know the universe doesn't necessarily exist the way it does? Do you know of any other universe?

Mr anony: I'll give you rough analogy. Let us say that Seun wrote the entire code that defines Nairaland. The constituent parts of Nairaland you see result from that code. The comments we type can be seen as our own creations made by re-assembling parts of an already created Nairaland.
Your argument against the moon is like saying Seun created Nairaland but didn't create the "Submit" icon. To make this argument you must show that another mind created the submit button and that it doesn't follow from the code.

The same can be applied to the universe and it's physical laws resulting in all of it's space, time and matter.
This rough analogy isn't accurate because based on what you're saying, he didn't write the entire code that defines Nairaland because he used a programming language that he didn't define himself. On the other hand, you're saying God did it all. You're saying God created the "tools" themselves the constants that eventually arrived at the moon in the same way that Seun would need to have created HTML and the Python Language (I think is one of the tools that powers Nairaland). He would also need to have created the server software and all that for your analogy to be accurate. Then these programs would have written Nairaland spontaneously.
Christianity Etc › Re: Dear Atheist, Do You Feel The Need To Be Thankful? by thehomer: 4:28pm On Jun 06, 2013
Mr anony: But of course you can choose not to lust and not to covet, you can resist the urge and not indulge in it. People do it all the time. You can choose to think or not to think about a thing.
Really? Okay. Don't think about an elephant.
Did you think about an elephant?

Mr anony: ...and if after choosing A, B is not available, have you lost your freewill?

Freewill is the ability to make choices it is not the ability to decide which choices will be available.
How will it not be available? As long as the person remembers how he was, then it will always be available.
Christianity Etc › Re: About Abortion. by thehomer: 12:23pm On Jun 06, 2013
OLAADEGBU: Referring to the medical institution in your scenario, the doctors concluded that the case was under control only for the lawyers and politicians to say otherwise. The medical profession has a duty of care and respect for human sanctity.
So doctors can perform an abortion once they conclude the case is under control.
Christianity Etc › Re: Dear Atheist, Do You Feel The Need To Be Thankful? by thehomer: 12:22pm On Jun 06, 2013
Mr anony: Temptation is not sin, commission is.
Not according to Jesus with his talk about adultery in the heart and not according to God with his command that people not covet.

Mr anony: Not all choices are reversible surely you know that.
Once a choice is made, it isn't reversible. The person can then make another choice further down the decision tree. But the thing though is that if you know you can choose between A and B, then with your freewill, you can choose either A or B. If after choosing A, B is still available, then further down the path if you still have freewill, you can still choose B thereby making yet another choice.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 12:11pm On Jun 06, 2013
Mr anony: Lol, interesting, first of all I'd like to know where you draw the line for things likely resulting from chance and things that are unlikely to result from chance otherwise what you've just said is pretty vague I can as well say that a computer software is not unlikely to occur by chance. You have really said nothing here.
The line is a statistical one but what you need to realize of course is that however unlikely computer software might be, it is still less likely without the initial presence of sapient beings therefore, the presence of sapient beings is more likely than the presence of computer software.

Mr anony: Secondly, a computer program is a software that can be represented by code. and by the way, we can engineer genes by tweaking the DNA code same as software.
Wrong. A computer program is code. Tweaking the DNA code is a short way of saying you're moving around specific molecules.

Mr anony: Thirdly, the question is not who designed DNA but whether DNA is designed according to your criteria. If you think there are extraterrestrial design teams floating about, feel free to give evidence for them later. For now tell us whether you think the DNA code is designed.
Actually, the question of who is very much in play because your aim with this line of inquiry is to present DNA as being evidence for God.

Mr anony: The part I highlighted there is your strawman. I said "the universe has constituent parts....." not "everything in the universe has....". I am focussing on the universe as a specific entity and applying my criteria for inferring design to it.
This is why you should have read the entire sentence before randomly picking out something and calling it a strawman. What you did was to edit out the rest of your own quote and you called it a strawman. Really. The words following the semicolon that are in bold are in fact your very own words.

Mr anony: This is the problem with your strawman not my argument
I quoted your own argument and you're calling part of it a strawman?

Mr anony: I have a feeling that this is a red herring but I'll answer you either way. I will only use this response to explain what I mean. I will not be drawn on a tangent following from this

viruses - i don't know enough about them to make a call
neutron stars - i don't know enough about them to make a call
crickets (by which I suppose you mean the insect) - yes, they consist of constituent parts arranged in such a way that they work according to a specific pattern that can be recognized analyzed and predicted.
sand - i don't know enough about them to make a call
melon - yes for the same reasons given for crickets
water - not necessarily designed
electron - not necessarily designed
vacuum (if by vaccum you mean nothing)- not designed
amoeba - yes
It is not a red-herring and what you've just demonstrated is that you're partly making an argument from ignorance and contradicting yourself. Let me explain as usual.

You don't know whether or not some of those objects were designed. If you don't know that, then you cannot actually say (what follows is a direct quote from you on own method of inferring design not a strawman): it's constituent parts all work according to a set of specific instructions such that we can accurately predict exactly how it ought to function therefore it is designed.

You also said some of those objects weren't designed. If they weren't designed, but you're willing to attribute the moon to your God's design, how did they come about?

Mr anony: I accused you of that fallacy because I thought you actually got my argument. I am now convinced you did not. You were arguing a strawman all along
I really find it difficult to understand why you guys just chuck out the name of a fallacy and think it settles everything. That isn't how to have a serious discussion. Please can you actually show me how I committed this fallacy? If you had tried to do that and read my post in its entirety, you'll have realized that it wasn't a strawman. Unless of course you failed to recognize your own ideas being quoted back to you verbatim.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 11:49am On Jun 06, 2013
Mr anony: Of course it is possible. Do other particles not change speed? What is so special about a photon? Once again this proves that the speed of light does not exist by necessity. A universe where the speed of light varies is very logically possible.
Once again, you're answering a question I did not ask. I asked if it was physically possible.

Mr anony: But I have also shown you that what you mean by chaos is not truly chaos but can be predicted accurately as long as it is measured accurately.
That is directly contradictory to what is in the article.

Wikipedia: Small differences in initial conditions (such as those due to rounding errors in numerical computation) yield widely diverging outcomes for such dynamical systems, rendering long-term prediction impossible in general. This happens even though these systems are deterministic, meaning that their future behavior is fully determined by their initial conditions, with no random elements involved. In other words, the deterministic nature of these systems does not make them predictable.
Mr anony: Lol, never mind, you have already said that you don't know. Just don't get any bursts of memory soon.
Once again, you run from demonstrating your own claim that should be easy.

Mr anony: Lol, this is just too funny. Let me remind you what I asked you:

I asked you if the universe exists necessarily and I gave you this warning

"Be very careful how you answer this question. Let me tell you the implications: If you say yes, then you would be saying that the idea of a multiverse is a logically incoherent idea. If you say no, then you would be saying that the universe must ultimately be contingent on something that exists necessarily. Your call"

You read it all and then replied that you didn't know if the universe existed necessarily.

At that point, you knew fully well what it means to exist necessarily you knew that to say a thing exists necessarily is to say that it is logically impossible to exist any way else.
By claiming that you don't know, you have excused yourself from making the contention "if the universe were different" because that will mean that you KNOW that the universe does not exist and function necessarily. I pointed that out to you. Claiming ignorance is not a shield here sir. If you don't know, then you can't contend because contention requires that you know.
This still stems from your failure to understand the entire realms of the possibilities.

Let me make it even more explicit.

Here are the only two possibilities.

1. The universe necessarily exists the way it does.
2. The universe does not necessarily exist the way it does.

My point is if (1) your response is: God did it that way. If (2) your response is: God did it that way. So in your attempt to explain it all, you explain nothing at all.

Mr anony: no it is not.
Then show that it doesn't follow.
Christianity Etc › Re: Dear Atheist, Do You Feel The Need To Be Thankful? by thehomer: 11:35am On Jun 06, 2013
Mr anony: No I find it boring that you keep harping on the same thing over and over without showing which goals it is that you'll like me to meet

That is not true. We say a person who is tempted by homos[color=#000000]ex[/color]uality has the freewill to resist the desire.
So you're denying that people actually are homosexual. You're saying they only have the desire but are wrong to have it.

Mr anony: No it doesn't transform the person into a robot it gives him new desires. He still makes his own choices. Unless you want to argue that a person doesn't have free-will in the first place because his preferences influence his choices.
Of course a people's preferences influence their choices. That is what you've just said. The thing is that if someone can choose to have the desires removed, they have to be able to choose to get those desires back with that same free will. If it doesn't turn the person into a robot, then whatever the new desires may be, they would be able to choose to get the old desires back.
Christianity Etc › Re: Dear Atheist, Do You Feel The Need To Be Thankful? by thehomer: 10:15am On Jun 06, 2013
Mr anony: The person should be immersed completely. The Greek word for it is baptizo which means to make fully wet.
In Colosians 2:12 Paul shows us that the batism involves fully submerging in water when he says

"....and you were buried with him in baptism, in which you were also raised with him through faith in the working of God, who raised him from the dead....."



Ok


Nah, I only yawn when you bore me
You find it boring that you're unable to meet your own goals? I find that interesting.

Mr anony: Lol, on the contrary, I think it is you who doesn't fully understand the meaning of freewill. Let me see if I can help you by explaining it thus.
If you are heterosexual i.e. you prefer s[color=#000000]exu[/color]al intercourse with women than men, and as a result only have s[color=#000000]exu[/color]al relations with women and never with men, does this mean you don't have freewill? No it doesn't. You simply don't have any homos[color=#000000]e[/color]xual desires. Now what if all men who would have been a source of temptation were removed and you now lived in a land full of women. Now you neither have the desire nor the object. How can you possibly engage in homos[color=#000000]exu[/color]al s[color=#000000]e[/color]x? Does this mean your free-will disappeared? Absolutely not.
Actually, according to the idea of free-will Christians generally use, a homosexual does have the freewill to become heterosexual.

Mr anony: Now similarly sin is as a result of seeking to gratify the flesh. It is because we live in the flesh that we can be tempted. When we are not born again, our desires are to satisfy our lusts but when we get born again, our spirit man is transformed and the desire to sin disappears that's why you hear Paul saying:
"I can will what is right, but I cannot do it. For I do not do the good I want, but the evil I do not want is what I do....Wretched man that I am! Who will deliver me from this body of death?" This clearly shows that the desire is totally changed but the flesh seems to be prevailing against his will. Sometimes you'll hear christians say "the spirit is willing but the flesh is weak"
But when we rapture, we will take upon us a spirit body while our sinful body will be discarded (1Corinthians 15). At this point both the desire to sin and the source of temptation have been removed and hence it will be impossible to sin.

For Mr Dahmer or anyone else, the very same applies.
What you're saying here means that this process of transformation actually changes the person's will thus turning the person into a robot. Recall that according to you, the person first "freely" made the choice to become born-again. What you're later implying is that such a person cannot unmake that choice. If someone can "freely" choose something and while having an alternative cannot choose otherwise, then in what sense is such a person actually free?
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op):
Mr anony: Good. So according to you we can tell that something is the work of an intelligent agent when

1. the thing is assembled in such a way that is very unlikely to occur by chance
2. this assembly works in such a way that it achieves a certain end
3. we don't have to know what the particular end is all we need to see is that it is functioning according to a specific pattern.

For instance a computer program is designed because
1. it is assembled in such a way that is unlikely to occur by chance
2. it works in such a way that it achieves a certain end
3. We don't have to know the particular end all we need to see is that it is functioning according to a specific pattern

Compare with

1. The DNA code is assembled in such a way that is unlikely to occur by chance
2. it works in such a way that it achieves a certain end
3. We don't have to know the particular end all we need to see is that it is functioning according to a specific pattern

According to your criteria, the DNA code is designed. Wouldn't you agree?
No I don't agree because I DNA is not unlikely to occur by chance. Note that DNA is a molecule that can be represented as a code.

Secondly, even if I agreed that DNA was designed, it still doesn't get you to God since there could be other designers like extra terrestrials and fairies.

Mr anony: I have argued something specific which is that the universe is designed because it's constituent parts all work according to a set of specific instructions such that we can accurately predict exactly how it ought to function
In much the same way that I can say that a car was designed because it's constituent parts all work according to a set of specific instructions such that we can accurately predict and analyze how it ought to function.

All you have done here is ignore the reason why I inferred design (in bold) and thrown in silly questions like "who created the trafficator bulb filament?" "who created the car door handle?" You are reducing the design to it's components and trying to say if the components don't meet the requirements of the whole then the whole fails. What you have committed is the fallacy of composition.
If you are not interested in seriously tackling my argument then please say so.
Pay attention to what you're doing. You're saying everything in the universe has: it's constituent parts all work according to a set of specific instructions such that we can accurately predict exactly how it ought to function therefore it is designed.

But what you're hiding is the fact that the entire phrase in bold is what you mean by design so you've successfully begged the question of design. Unless of course you think that that phrase in bold could be true but it still won't be designed.

What I'm pointing out to you is that you're saying everything in the universe was designed by God and with that, you've explained nothing by explaining everything.

What I'm trying to do is to understand using examples, what you mean by inferring design. You can still help if you could tell me whether or not the following objects are designed.

Viruses, neutron stars, crickets, sand, melon, water, electron, vacuum, amoeba.

Note that you've not actually demonstrated your claim that I made the fallacy of composition but you on the other hand are saying that God did it all except when I point out to you what humans actually did.

Edited for clarity.
Christianity Etc › Re: An Argument Against Any Reasonable Knowledge Of God. by thehomer(op): 9:42am On Jun 06, 2013
Mr anony: Lol, "corrected" indeed. Anyway, no need beating this dead horse
You just keep resurrecting it.

Mr anony: How exactly this question relates to my comment, I know not.
Then let me show you again. What you're describing is for instance a universe where the speed of light rather than being a constant at say 3E6m/s, you're thinking of one where it may be 1 m/s then becomes 200m/s then becomes 0.2m/s then 7E9m/s. My question to you is whether or not such a phenomenon is actually possible.

Mr anony: That is what you'll have to show in order to demonstrate chaos. You wouldn't have to show this if the physical laws exist necessarily. But if the physical laws do not exist necessarily, then it is logically possible but since we don't observe chaos, we can comfortably say that the universe follows a design.
No I don't because I presented you with what I meant by chaos. You on the other hand were talking about something else. You're saying we don't observe chaos but the article I showed you to said otherwise. Note once more that I'm talking about physical possibilities not logical possibilities.

Mr anony: Seriously this is just you being dishonest. You know full well that to say that a thing exists necessarily is to say that it is not logically possible for such a thing to exist otherwise. In fact you employ this when questioning God's necessary attributes.
What on earth are you talking about? You're the one talking about some necessary existence and claiming that I made some concession but for some reason, you've been unable to show me making these mysterious concessions.

Mr anony: Now you have been caught like a fly in a web you have suddenly developed amnesia of what it means to be necessary and started "correcting" me into what you know full well is wrong. Don't be a coward now. You can't make an argument if you won't stick your neck out. You can't fire arrows while hiding behind a claim of ignorance
If what I'm saying is wrong, then you have to actually show me that I'm wrong.

Mr anony: Lol, I know what I said. Misrepresenting it like this doesn't help you
That is not a misrepresentation. That is the implication of what you said.
Christianity Etc › Re: Dear Atheist, Do You Feel The Need To Be Thankful? by thehomer: 12:12am On Jun 06, 2013
Mr anony: He did not ask me a question.
Maybe you should have looked a bit closer.

Mr anony: No the devil wasn't born again and neither are the angels but for God (Father, Son and Holy Spirit) it doesn't apply since being born again entails being led by God. and the thing that stops us from following God is the flesh because our desires are for God. and the flesh will be discarded so that nothing will oppose our Godly nature anymore. So basically what you are trying to argue by using the case of Jeff Dahmer is that it is possible in Heaven for God's holy nature to act against His holiness. That is why I asked you whether you know what it means to be born again.
That's just it. If Mr. Dahmer has his own free-will, then he can act against God's nature. To say otherwise means to say that he actually has no free will.

Mr anony: What has bathing with soap or without soap got to do with anything. What precisely do you want to know about salvation and reward that you don't think I have covered?
It has everything to do with it. Basically, how immersed should the person be in the water for baptism?

Mr anony: Really? please quote bits of the article that explained what I explained better. If you can't point to anything specific you want me to explain, then you are only blowing hot air
You should really have read that article.

Wikipedia: The traditional Jewish understanding of the promise of salvation is interpreted as being rooted in "the seed of Abraham"; that is in the physical lineage from Abraham. Jesus explained to Nicodemus that this doctrine was in error—that every person must have two births—the natural birth of the physical body, the other of the water and the spirit. This discourse with Nicodemus established the Christian belief that all human beings—whether Jew or Gentile—must be "born again" of the spiritual seed of Christ. The Apostle Peter further reinforced this understanding in 1 Peter 1:23. The Catholic Encyclopedia states that "[a] controversy existed in the primitive church over the interpretation of the expression the seed of Abraham. It is [the Apostle Paul's] teaching in one instance that all who are Christ's by faith are Abraham's seed, and heirs according to promise. He is concerned, however, with the fact that the promise is not being fulfilled to the seed of Abraham (referring to the Jews)."

Charles Hodge writes that "The subjective change wrought in the soul by the grace of God, is variously designated in Scripture" with terms such as new birth, resurrection, new life, new creation, renewing of the mind, dying to sin and living to righteousness, and translation from darkness to light.

. . . .

Evangelical Protestants employ the KJV translation of John 3:3 as "born again" rather than "born from above". "Although many evangelicals allow that conversion can be a process, generally they see it as a specific, identifiable moment of time when a person simply and sincerely trusts in Jesus Christ as savior."[14] They understand Romans 10:9 to indicate a requirement of salvation: "That if you confess with your mouth, 'Jesus is Lord', and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved." So, "to be born again" means "to be saved" because to be saved, one must confess Jesus is Lord with one's mouth and believe it in one's heart. Also, to be born again means to follow Romans 10:10 that "with your heart that you believe and are justified, and it is with your mouth that you profess your faith and are saved".
Mr anony: yawn.
It is funny how you keep yawning when you realize that you're unable to scale past your own goalposts.

Mr anony: It is logically impossible because when one gets born again, he acquires God's nature; note this doesn't mean that he becomes a robot controlled by God rather he gains the character of God, he likes what God likes, hates the things God hates and does the kind of things God does. He still makes his own choices but his preferences have changed. The reason why a christian sins sometimes is because he/she is still hampered by the flesh and the trappings of a physical world (Romans 6-8 ). However at the rapture, he discards the flesh and with it every source of temptation (1Cor 15). In heaven, He will now be free to act according to his God nature without the temptations of the flesh. To say that the renewed man will sin in heaven is to say that God's nature will act against God's nature and that's a logical impossibility
This further demonstrates that you have no idea of what lies in the realm of logical possibilities. If he actually had free-will, then he will be able to go against God's character unless you wish to say that God's character has suppressed his free-will because his character is separate from God's character. For you to say otherwise would mean that his character and God's character are identical and if they were identical, then he actually has no free-will.

Being free to act according to his God nature also has the corollary of being free not to act according to his God nature since even then, there will be people who won't be acting according to this God nature. If he can freely choose to act according to this God nature, then he can freely choose to reject it. Saying otherwise means contradicting yourself on your notion of free-will.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 (of 210 pages)