Thehomer's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 (of 210 pages)
Uyi Iredia: [url=en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Issei_Sagawa]This comes close[/url]. [url=en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spider_cannibalism]An example of this behaviour in spiders[/url]. This comes very closeAnd you proceed to miss my points entirely. Do you know what my position on this is? Do you know what deep sight's position is? |
Mr anony: Please tell me how as an alien researcher, you would go about knowing this solely from empirical observation and without the ability to read the minds and intents of your subject animals.I don't care about how it discovers that knowledge, I said if it had that knowledge, then it would be able to understand that for a human, certain actions would be wrong. You're about to hitch your argument to something irrelevant. |
Mr anony: Yawn. I have only described your methods. Funny enough, I like to engage with you, I only usually stop when I see that we are now moving round in circles and getting nowhere. It makes no sense beating dead horses you know. I learnt that lesson from arguing with guys like logicboyNo you didn't. You're yet to actually show me contradicting myself. It looks like you've forgotten how long you dragged previous threads we engaged in simply because you refused to answer basic questions. |
Mr anony: Actually it doesn't because if God did create humans and animals, He can very easily have different purposes and demands for them.If his purpose for them was that they should act morally, then he cannot be giving them immoral commands. Mr anony: For you it becomes a problem because you claim that there objective moral principles are not based on any designer, you also claim that humans are animals, you also claim that we should only accept what we can observe and test.Yes objective moral principles don't need a designer since the presence of the designer doesn't make them objective, it just makes it subjective from the point of the designer. Yes humans are animals do you disagree with that fact? If you do, then you're saying humans are not animals. If they aren't, then I'd like to know where they belong in biological taxonomy. Where did I make the third claim you've attributed to me? Mr anony: You must now explain why different animals are observed engaging in the same activities and yet one is specially picked out as moral while the others are considered amoral.I've answered this several times already. I think you should now explain how God's views are can be considered objective but not this alien's views. |
Mr anony: Avoiding my question again are we?You were asking a question based on something I didn't say. Mr anony: Man has freedom to choose his actions that plays a big part. A perfectly straight line that has choices can choose to become crooked.If man were perfect, won't his choices have been perfect? Mr anony: Upon what basis do you judge any of his commands immoral?Let's take his commands one at a time. I'm judging this command immoral because it commanded the killing of children for land. Mr anony: The question you must first answer is upon what basis you consider them wrong?Here, I'm asking you if commanding a genocide for the purpose of taking other people's land is right or wrong. Why don't you answer that? |
Mr anony: Lol, his tatics usually ends up in last man standing wins no matter how absurd and contradictory the position is. He'll probably try to drag this thread on until someone gets tired of dancing with him. This is just your transference in action. You're used just mumbling about the Bible and having what you say accepted. Once a little challenge pops up, you start complaining about the challenge. |
Deep Sight: Going further. As an extra terrestrial researcher you come upon the earth and its basket of living creatures. You observe that humans kill one another for mates, resources, land, wealth, survival and other desires. You observe that ALL creatures on same planet do this. Why on earth (no pun intended) would you say that the human is doing something wrong, unnatural or perverse?What sort of information does this researcher have? If it has knowledge about social animals, intelligence, culture and other such characteristics, it would be able to understand why it can be said that for a human, those acts would be wrong. You're just ignoring what I've already said. |
Mr anony: If thehomer can really pay attention, he'll see that this illustration exposes the fatal flaw in his arguments. There is really no reason why the alien should decide to hold humans to a different moral standard apart from the other animals.Actually, that is the argument that totally destroys your claim about God having anything to do with morality not to talk about objectivity. |
Deep Sight: And is this wrong, or morally reprehensible?Yes. |
Mr anony: Perhaps you missed the point of my question. What do you mean when you say that a mind is complex? To use your example, how is a mind that can think about blackholes more complex than one that cannot?I said we're capable of having complex thoughts. Mr anony: Man has chosen to do evil and hence made himself imperfect.But then, something perfect made by a perfect being shouldn't be able to become imperfect otherwise we can expect Heaven to go the same way. Mr anony: The question really doesn't bug me. Asking you a question in reply is just my way of getting you to really examine your question. Well since you've pushed on and on, let me answer you in the way you want to be answered.Finally. A response. Now if that were God's purpose, why would he give immoral commands like commanding a genocide? Mr anony: Hmm,You're just expatiating on my point without actually saying the role your God has to play. Remember the sorts of instructions your God has given in the past. Were those instructions morally right or wrong? Was commanding a genocide morally right or wrong? |
Deep Sight: ^^^ Aite, answer them now, thanks. Particularly Q 3.Humans have been known to kill others for mates. |
Deep Sight: Lol. Are you telling me that Lions do not make informed decisions about staying away from another Lion's female pride members? Decisions based on the strength and territory of that other Lion and his pride, which strength and territory are clearly discerned by the Lion so deciding?I'm telling you that lions aren't introspective. |
Deep Sight: @ thehomer. Do you accept my deal for you to closely reflect on these questions for 24 hours and revert to me tomorrow. Please the questions are all very important, but I request that you pay special attention to Question No 3: it is the most important.The best you can do with any answer I give to these questions is to go for a naturalistic fallacy. I don't need 24 hours to show you why any answer I give to these won't help you. |
Deep Sight: Yes of course they do, and this shows your ignorance about animals.This shows your ignorance about the requirements for decision making. |
Mr anony: "complex" another vague word. In what ways are your thoughts more complex than those of a dog or a lion?I can think about a black hole, they cannot. Mr anony: The question is not whether man is perfect or not. The question is whether God made man imperfect? Here's what the bible says about thatStill boils down to the same thing. If God made man perfect and placed him in a perfect world, how come he is now imperfect? Or if God didn't make man perfect or placed him in an imperfect world, why would he do that? Mr anony: What is objectively morally good?And here we see the question that just halts you in your tracks. Rather than answering a direct question, you try to sidestep it by presenting something else. Just answer my question. What is God's purpose? Mr anony: We are here talking about morality. You have claimed that other animals are "significantly different" from humans.And I've said again that lions and dogs aren't the sorts of animals that can make moral decisions. Making moral decisions require certain features that dogs and lions don't have or that they have to limited degrees. e.g can a lion stop itself from copulating based on introspection? Humans can and that is a significant difference. As you can see, I've answered your direct questions but that one question of God's purpose just prompts you to throw out irrelevant questions. As I've said before, just decide on what you want think it means to be objectively morally good and answer your question. We'll explore whether or not it is really objective or morally good when we see your response to that question. |
Mr anony: The question you have not yet answered is in what way are they "significantly different" and how that ought to play out in the context of morality. All you keep doing is repeating that they are significantly different.Maybe I don't understand what you're asking for. What sort of answer do you want? Again, do you think there are no significant differences between humans and other animals? If you do, then surely you realize that this entire line of questioning is moot. So why don't you tell me whether or not you think there are significant differences before I bother with looking at the sort of answer you want. |
Mr anony: But their biology allows them both to force other members of their species to have sex against their will, it also allows man and animals to kill other members of their species. These are similarities their biology allows. Why subject the exact same actions to different moral scalesTheir biology also prevents them from having complex thoughts and cultures. Mr anony: He didn'tSo is man a perfect being or not? Mr anony: That is an answer. You have admitted that there is such a thing as the way man ought to behave. A purpose of a thing is exactly that: The way the thing ought to behave. Or what do yo think "purpose" means?What is God's purpose? That is my question. |
Deep Sight: Lol @ the bold.Of course they're apes. Or do you think they're fish or hoofed animals or what? Deep Sight: So, you are arguing that humans are different from animals. At the same time you say humans are animals.I seriously don't see the confusion here at all but you're obviously still confused. |
Mr anony: Again, "what are these "significant differences"?I've answered this in so many ways but you just keep on repeating the question. There are significant differences in judgement, science, empathy, biology and other such features. Do you think there are no significant differences? Mr anony: Ok then let's try the equally animal example of the dogYou use that and make your point. I've chosen the animal I would rather use for mine. Mr anony: ok joke it wasFor some reason you started hopping all over it. |
Deep Sight: This kind of statement is very offensive to a dog lover, such as myself. I have not lived a day in my life since I was born without dogs as part of my family and as such I know dogs very well. Dogs have a VERY keen sense of society. They know their place within a home. The ALWAYS recognize who the head of the house is. They will protect you with their lives from ANY attacker or violence. They show uncommon loyalty FAR exceeding that of human beings.This still doesn't negate what I've said. If your dog defaecates on your sofa, do you hold it morally responsible in the same way that you would hold a 25 year old friend of yours responsible for doing the same thing? |
Deep Sight: Don't be silly. Do you have any reports on Lions committing genocide or blasphemy. Each predatory territorial animal has its ways. You simply cannot accuse an animal (man) of being bad or evil for being predatory and territorial.Now you persist in your buffoonery. Need I remind you that you're the one making the argument that they're no different from humans. I'm arguing the contrary. |
Mr anony: This does not answer anything at all and you know itIt answers everything as far as I can see. It also explains why they don't speak. Mr anony: perfectThen how could he have made anything imperfect? Mr anony: What is objectively morally right? (I'm assuming you are referring to how he want humans to act morally.)That is a question not an answer. Try to answer the question or have you suddenly forgotten how to answer a question using your own terms? You did that before using the word "sacred". Answer my own question using your own terms. We can explore the terms after we have a general sense of the implications. |
Deep Sight: It is amazing that you do not see that for 99 per cent of human history, most human societies have been run based on dominance and subjugation by violence exactly as happens with other social predatory territorial animals. . . . . .Exactly? Really? Do you have any reports on humans killing and eating their spouses after intercourse? |
Mr anony: again he switchesSarcasm from me. |
Mr anony: Pardon me but from an evolutionary perpective, this is no different from sayingI was making a joke but you're welcome to explain what you mean. |
Mr anony: a praying mantis is as much an animal as all of my examples. If you think it isn't, you are welcome to show that it isn't.I didn't say it wasn't an animal. It was the one I chose to make my point using that as an example. You on the other hand just seem to be confused about the point. |
Deep Sight: I will. So do we have a deal?Here is is again. thehomer: Do you think that the fact that humans are "smarter" and can exercise judgement is something significantly different? |
Mr anony: Thehomer's arguments sound to me like specieism.You say this as if there are no significant differences between the species. |
Mr anony: Why not?You know, I've answered more than my share of questions here. I'll answer this and you'll have to answer questions that I already posed before that you ignored. It is a fact of their biology. What is God's nature? What is his purpose? |
Deep Sight: EMPATHY! THE BIG WORD! THE VERY BASIS OF MORALITY!Sure massive empathy is all that is needed. That is why they would kill off other cubs and take over kills they didn't make. They've even started running a system of determining who would lead the pack by voting. |
Deep Sight: I wonder if thehomer is acquainted with the order and sense of society within a pack of wolves.Yes. Just the other day, a wolf was talking about changing from the social group of a pack to one based on capitalism. |
Deep Sight: Dont even be having a laugh. The Pythagoras theory has nothing to do with morality. On the other hand, a sense of society, has everything to do with morality and these animals have very advanced senses of society.I didn't say Pythagoras' theorem had something to do with morality, I was just pointing out a significant difference between humans and the praying mantis. Yes. Their sense of society is so advanced that they can practice a feudal system of government or a capitalist one. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 (of 210 pages)
This is just your transference in action. You're used just mumbling about the Bible and having what you say accepted. Once a little challenge pops up, you start complaining about the challenge.